>
n libraries Smithsonian-" institution noixiuixsni NviNOSHXiws^sBidVii
= w 5 . « , — , 5 ,v «>
CO
4 CO
O xg>. pcy “ O
Z -J " Z -j 2 a
ON NOIinillSNI NVIN0SH1IINS S3ldVdail LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUb
2: f , 2 r* 2 r- ■
„ m m X^osv^X ^ m Xl^oswj
~ CO " — CO E CO
n LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION N0I1D1I1SNI NVINOSH1HMS S3I8VH
z > co . — -- — ^
< ^
2 ^ 2 > ' 2
3N NOlinXUSNI NVINOSHIIHS^SB I BVH a I I BRAR I ES^SMITHSONIAN^INSTITUI
CO — V CO ~ tn
1 <yg*
§ z _
I^LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN^INSTITUTION^NOIXnXIXSNI^NVINOSHXIWS ^SBIdVd
E ^ — - z r- 2
m
00 - co = HR. co
DN NOIinillSNI NVINOSHlilMS S3iaVH8ll LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUT
CO 2 _ _ CO 2 . CO -?>
< S , „ ,3 I
> V'’ 2 'w. > X^oxijl ^
Z CO 2 CO V Z ^
IT LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOIXOXIXSNI NVINOSHXIWS S3ldVB
CO = CO — CO
O Ncwoc^x ~ O
DN NOIinillSNI ""WlNOSHll IMS ^S 3 IdVdSH^LIBRARI ES^ SMITHSON IAN”* IN STITUT
Z r* 2 r- 2 r-
m m ^ m xZ'vosv's
— co ' — co E co
11 LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOIinillSNI NVINOSHlilMS S3IHV8
E > ^ ^ z *. co z
2 m .x -i A?AWh&\ ^ . — . JMz.z. ^
X
CO
•/
m
'fm? s ± "■fm? = " ^ ±
^ oo __ ^oxixs^y 2 >
RAR I ES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOIXriXIXSNI NVINOSHXIIAIS^SS I a VH 8 11 LIB
2 " ^r~~. 5 xx.- « 5
CO
CO
O ^
L01I1SNI "'nVINOSHIIIAJS S3 ! U Vd a II LI B RAR I ES^SMITHSONIAN^INSTITUTION ~N0I.
f“ , 2 r~ 2 r* 2
m ' \^r ^ \!vasi^ m x^vosv^ x; m
co — co iE co t:
RARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOliniliSNI NVIN0SH1IINS S31dVd3l1 LIB
2 * CO 2 CO 2
< a 2 <
2 >
LflXIXSN 1 _ NVINOSHil WS01 S 3 I U VH 8 I T^LI B RAR I ES^SMITHSONIAN^INSTITUTION ^NOI
rn , — . 5 co ~ co
c
o
2 _J 2 -J
RARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOliniliSNI NVIN0SH1UNS S3ldVdan UB
2 r~ 7 r- -*• r~
^vaso/vTx O
m X! m X C° m
co z co \ 2 co
inilXSNI NVINOSHXIWS S3iava8ll LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN "INSTITUTION NOI
" 2 v, V>
2 > 'W* 2 v\ > NiSiujyx s
RAR I ES^ SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTlON^NOIXflXIXSNI NVINOSHXIWS^SS I ava a 11
co z= co
LIB
iX
“ 5
.nXIXSNI^NVINOSHXmS S3 I ava a 11 ""li b RAR i eszsmithsonian",institutionznoi.
f“ 2 r- 2 r- 2
m ' .V^ rr m X^OSV^X X^ HI
CO — co fE CO 2
RAR I ES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOliniliSNI NVINOSHiltMS S3ldVdai1 LIB
2 v CO 2 CO 2
% E < xr^ox S ^ <
2 ^ H «4. 2
O
CO
Journal of the
Bombay Natural History Society
Vol. 71, No. 1
Editors
J. C. DANIEL, P. V. BOLE &
A. N. D. NANAY ATI
svc.^ V
& 7J.
Rse 18 (Inland), £1*50 (Foreign)
NOTICE TO CONTRIBUTORS
Contributors of scientific articles are requested to assist the editors
by observing the following instructions:
1. Papers which have at the same time been offered for publica-
tion to other journals or periodicals, or have already been published
elsewhere, should not be submitted.
2. The MS. should be typed (double spacing) on one side of a
sheet only, and the sheets properly numbered.
3. All scientific names to be printed in italics should be under-
lined. Both in zoological and in botanical references only the initial
letter of the genus is capitalized. The specific and subspecific names
always begin with a small letter even if they refer to a person or a
place, e.g. Anthus hodgsoni hodgsoni or Streptopelia chinensis surat ensis
or Dimeria blatteri.
4. Trinomials referring to subspecies should only be used where
identification has been authentically established by comparison of
specimens actually collected. In all other cases, or where identification
is based merely on sight, binomials should be used.
5. Photographs for reproduction must be clear and show good
contrast. Prints must be of a size not smaller than 8*20 x 5*60 cm
(No. 2 Brownie) and on glossy glazed paper.
6. Text-figures, line drawings, and maps should be in Indian ink,
preferably on Bristol board.
7. References to literature should be placed at the end of the
paper, alphabetically arranged under author’s name, with the abridged
titles of journals or periodicals underlined (italics) and titles of books
not underlined (roman type), thus:
Banerji, M. L. (1958): Botanical Exploration in East Nepal.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 55(2): 243-268.
Prater, S. H. (1948): The Book of Indian Animals. Bombay.
Titles of papers should not be underlined.
8. Reference to literature in the text should be made by quoting
the author’s name and year of publication, thus: (Banerji 1958).
9. Synopsis : Each scientific paper should be accompanied by
a concise, clearly written synopsis, normally not exceeding 200 words.
10. Reprints: Authors are supplied 25 reprints of their articles
free of charge. In the case of joint authorship, 50 copies will be given
gratis to be distributed among the two or more authors. Orders for
additional reprints should be in multiples of 25 and should be received
within two weeks after the author is informed of the acceptance of the
manuscript. They will be charged for at cost plus postage and packing.
Hornbill House,
Shahid Bhagat
Singh Road,
Bombay 400 023
Editors,
Journal of the Bombay Natural
History Society.
BOMBAY NATURAL HISTORY SOCIETY
Hornbill House, Shahid Bhagat Singh Road, BOMBAY 400 023
Telephone: 2 5 7 27 7
Dear Member,
The Executive Committee, taking into consideration the increasing
cost of operation of the Society’s activities, has been reluctantly compelled to
increase the membership and entrance fees, and subscription rates for the journal.
The new rates are given below, and will come into effect from
1st January 1975.
(a) Entrance Fees (for new members) To be
Yours faithfully,
A. N. D. Nanavati, M. D.
Honorary Secretary
VOLUME 71 NO. 1 : APRIL 1974
Date of Publication: 21-10-1974
CONTENTS
Bonelli’s Hawk-Eagle, Hieraaetus fasciatus (Vieillot). By S. M. Osman 1
Indian Mammals on Texas Rangelands. By Ernest D. Abies and
Charles W. Ramsey. ( With two text- figures ) . . . . . . 18
Common edible Mushrooms of Jammu and Kashmir. By T. N. Kaul
and J. L. Kachroo. ( With five figures in two plates ) . . . . 26
Preliminary observations on the breeding of pearl oysters, Pinctada
fucata (Gould) of the Gulf of Kutch. By K. R. Narayanan. ( With
two text-figures ) . . . . . . . . . . 32
Taxonomy and distribution of Sardinella leiogaster Valenciennes,
1847 (Pisces: Clupeidae) from the Indian Seas. By A. G. K.
Menon and P. K. Talvvar. (With a text- figure ) . . . . 41
A new Copepod from Ratnagiri. By M. R. Ranade. (With three plates ) 46
Records and observations on Bats of Himalayan region of Uttar
Pradesh and West Bengal, India. By H. R. Bhat .. .. 51
Additions to the Flora of North Gujarat (Ahmedabad-Mehsana-
Sabarkantha District). By G. L. Shah and D. V. Yogi .. 58
Three new species of Aphelinidae (Hymenoptera : Chalcidoidea)
parasitic on Aonidiella orientalis (Newst.) from India.
By Mohammad Hayat . . . . . . . . . . 64
Smithsonia (Orchidacfa), a new Genus from Western India. By Cecil
J. Saldanha .. .. .. .. .. ..72
The Avifauna of introduced Eucalyptus plantations in Maha-
rashtra. By Lincoln Gray . . . . . . . . 76
Fishery resources of Ullal (Mangalore) in relation to certain
environmental factors during 1963-67. By M. S. Prabhu, S.
Ramamurthy, M. H. Dhulkhed, N. S. Radhakrishnan and G. P.
Kumaraswamy Achari . . . . . . . . . . 85
Observations on the breeding mechanism of Biophytum candolleanum
Wt. By R. Vasu devan Nair . . . . . . 99
Observations on systematics of Sessile Barnacles from West
Coast of India — 1. By Arun B. Wagh and D. V. Bal. (With ten
text-figures ) . . . . . . . . . . . . 109
The copulatory complex of Neurobasis chinensis chinensis (Linn.)
(Agriidae: Zygoptera) 1. By Basit Ali Khan. (With three text-
figures) .124
Reviews :
1. Ecological principles for economic development. (Z.F.) 131
2. A first guide to the Indian Ocean seashore. (B.F.C) . . 132
3. A revised handbook to the flora of Ceylon. (D.H.N. & C.J.S.) 133
4. Tropical Aquaria. (B.F.C.) .. .. .. ..135
5. Classification of the Animal Kingdom. (N.D.) 136
Miscellaneous Notes:
Mammals: 1. Status of the Tiger in Burma. By Tun Yin (p. 137); 2. Weight
and size at birth of two species of wild mammals in captivity. By L. N. Ach-
arjyo and R. Misra (p. 137); 3. Burrowing habits of the greater Bandicoot
Rat ( Bandicota indica). { With a text-figure ). By A. V. Arjunwadkar and
Madhav Gadgil (p. 138).
Birds: 4. Storks preying on live birds. By Jamshed D. Panday (p. 141); 5.
Breeding of the Lesser Flamingo, Phoeniconaias minor (Geoffroy) in Kutch.
( With two photographs ). By Salim Ali (p. 141); 6. Notes on a Sooty Tern
( Sterna fuscata nubilosa Sparrman) collected near Calicut. By D. N. Mathew
and E. A. A. Shukkur (p. 144); 7. More Cuckoo problems. By Michael Des-
fayes (p. 154); 8. On the occurrence of the Common Grey Hornbill Tockus
birostris (Scopoli) near Bombay. By Humayun Abdulali (p. 147).
Reptiles : 9. Feeding habits of the Star Tortoise, Geochelone elegans. { With
a photograph) . By R. Whitaker (p. 147); 10. Behaviour of the Agamid Garden
Lizard, Calotes versicolor. By M. V. Subba Rao (p. 148); 11. Cobra with king-
fisher caught in throat. By R. Whitaker (p. 150).
Fishes: 12.- Algal food of Aplocheilus blochii (Arnold). By N. D. Kama!
(p. 151); 13. On a new record of a Murrel, Channa leucopunctatus (Sykes)
from Rajasthan. By R. N. Bhargava (p. 152); 14. A special method of fish
trapping in River Ganga at Varanasi. {With a text-figure). By S. P. Singh
(p. 153).
Arachnida : 15. Cannibalism among Scorpions. By Thomas Gay (p. 156).
Insects : 16. Aleurodothrips fasciapennis (Franklin) predatory on Coccids and
Aleyrodids. {With a text-figure) . By T. N. Ananthakrishnan (p. 157); 17. Note on
the peculiar behaviour of Dragonflies. By Tridib Ranjan Mitra (p. 160); 18. Food
preferences in the larvae of two moths: Spodoptera litura F. (Fam. Noctuidae)
and Diacrisia obliqua Walk. (Fam. Arctiidae). {With a text-figure) . By Asha
Bassi (p. 161); 19. Orthetrum glaucum (Brauer) preying upon Palpopleura
sexmaculata sexmaculata (Fabr.) (Odonata: Libellulidae) . By R. N. Bhargava
and Mahabir Prasad (p. 164). a
Botany: 20. Archidiaceae from Western India. {With fifteen text- figures) . By
G. T. Dabhade (p. 164); 21. Hedyotis tavoyensis Balakr. (Rubiaceae) — a5 new
species from Burma. {With a plate). By N. P. Balakrishnan (p. 168)'; 22.
A noteworthy Sarcopyramis from Eastern Himalayas. {With a text-figure) '0 :B*y
M. P. Nayar (p. 170); 23. A synopsis of the genus {Perilimnastes Ridley
(Melastomataceae). {With a text-figure). By M. P. Nayar (p. 172); 24. On
the citation of Palaquium ellipticum (Dalz.) Baillon. By G. M. Oza (p. 175);
25. On the occurrence of Sympagis petiolares (Nees) Brerrf. and Canscora- per i-
foliata Lamk. on the eastern ghats. By B. Suryanarayana and D. Radhakrishna
Murthy (p. 176); 26. Chenopodium ambrosioides Linn. (Chenopodaceae) —
A new record for Chamoli District in western Himalayas. By K. N. Nautiyal
(p. 178); 27. Botanical identity of ‘Century Plant’ in western India. {With a
photograph). By G. M. Oza (p. 178); 28. On the occurrence of vegetative
shoots at the crown area in Cocos nucifera L. By T. Ananda Rao and G. C.
Das (p. 181).
JOURNAL
OF THE
BOMBAY NATURAL
HISTORY SOCIETY
1974 APRIL Vol. 71 No. 1
Bonelli’s Hawk-Eagle,
Hieraaetus fasciatus (Vieillot)
BY
S. M. Osman
ll-D/10, Circular Road, Dehra Dun, U.P.
One evening as I was cycling along, thinking of the hot tea and
thick slices of cake I would be enjoying once I got home to Dehra Dun,
an eagle crossed the unfrequented track I had taken. A few short wing-
beats very smoothly propelled it to a tree not more than a hundred
yards from the place where I had abruptly come to a halt. A quick
look through binoculars confirmed my suspicion. It was an eagle worthy
of any falconer’s mew.
The eagle had perched on the dead limb of an old mango tree. The
way it looked around, its alert posture, and its choice of a commanding
perch all indicated that it was hunting. At such a time, delay would
be disastrous and the sooner I got my trap into position, I thought,
the better would be my chances of capturing the eagle. I dropped the
cycle where I stood, chose a spot to set the trap, and quickly went to-
wards it with the trap in one hand and the live pigeon, used for luring
hawks to captivity, in the other. Let me describe the trap. It is a strong
Accepted February 2, 1973.
2 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (1)
net made from thin silk or nylon line. When properly fixed it stands
about six feet wide, and about five feet high. On each side it is bracket-
ed by wooden rods driven into the ground, and easy to erect since an
iron spike is fixed to the bottom of each rod. The live pigeon is an-
chored to a peg also driven into the ground, in such a position that the
net lies between the pigeon and the line of approach the hawk or
eagle is likely to take.
The moment any bird of prey that flies to the bait hits the net, which
falconers call the dogaza, the supporting wooden rods are dislodged
and fall to the ground. There is not enough time for the hawk to back
out of the collapsing net, and it finds itself shrouded in the folds of
the dogaza. On very rare occasions, the hawk flies over the net and
grabs the bait, but in all the years that I have been using the dogaza,
this has happened only three or four times.
The feeling of anticipation a falconer experiences when about to
catch a hawk is indescribable. It is a mixture of ineffable joy and
tingling fear. It was with such anticipation that, after preparing the
trap, I withdrew to the cover of some bushes to watch further develop-
ments. With bated breath, I watched the eagle’s every move. It had
spotted the pigeon behind the trap and was showing its interest in the
bait by bobbing its head up and down, a sure sign that a bird of prey
is about to home in on its target. In falcons, the lifting and lowering
of the head preceding an attack is almost a continuous movement. The
eagle had by now assumed a crouching posture, dwarfing it to almost
half its normal size. It suddenly launched itself from the branch and
flew fast towards the trap.
The painful suspense of such moments for a falconer cannot be
exaggerated. He knows how keen is the eagle’s sight, how likely it is to
spot the net, or how a chance movement or sound may deflect its flight.
He cannot relax until he has his prize in hand. Fortunately I was not
to be disappointed this particular evening. The eagle crashed into the
net that had been prepared to receive it, and when I had sprinted across
I found it struggling in the shrouds of the fallen dogaza. It is one thing
to examine some object from a distance through binoculars, and quite
another to look at it at point-blank range. This was the first time I had
seen such an eagle, and I was unable to label it correctly. All I could
be sure of just then was that it was no ordinary hawk-eagle. My instinct
told me that it was a rare bird and a great killer.
Instead of cycling home directly, I went first to a friend who was
also a falconer. His name was Robin Lhockner. He had a lot of books
about hawks, eagles and falcons, and I hoped to get my capture pro-
perly identified.
The first thing Robin said, when he saw me, was, ‘Where are my
binoculars?’, and I then realized with horror that I had forgotten them
BONELLTS HAWK-EAGLE
3
when I sprinted across to the trapped eagle. I was so flabbergasted at
my carelessness that I decided to change the topic at all costs and offer-
ed to give Robin the eagle. He promptly accepted the gift but reminded
me that he needed the binoculars soon. I then hurried away, not home
to tea and cake, but all the way I had just come, and found the blessed
binoculars lying just where I had left them a couple of hours before.
Next day I triumphantly returned them to Robin.
After comparing pictures of the various eagles in Robin’s books,
we came to the conclusion that this must be the famous Bonelli’s eagle.
We had read somewhere that hawks could be trained quickly if given
camphor. It was said to be a widespread Indian method of subduing
and training hawks because camphor, given in specific doses, would
cause such a violent reaction that even the most headstrong bird would
be shocked into obedience. The article went on to say that any hawk
treated in this manner would forget its past life and freedom, and
quickly learnt to look upon man as a benefactor always ready to help
it with food. We gathered that a teaspoonful of camphor would be a
safe dose for a bird the size of an eagle. I shall never forgive myself
for trying the experiment, but like a fool I let curiosity get the better
of my judgement.
The result was disastrous. Twenty minutes after the dose had been
fed to the eagle, a very violent reaction similar to convulsions became
apparent. Even after the bird had lost consciousness the muscles con-
tinued to twitch spasmodically. To feed the eagle was not possible; we
only succeeded in pouring a small quantity of blood down its throat.
Throughout the day, though kept under close observation, there was
no improvement in its condition. I vainly tried to drain the crop by
introducing a suction tube but all our attempts were unavailing and the
eagle died on the second day.
In spite of this unhappy beginning I later found Bonelli’s eagles
easiest of all to train, soon losing their fear of man. I had many oppor-
tunities of examining them closely and will therefore attempt a fairly
detailed description.
The upperparts are yellowish brown. The base of every feather,
especially of those around the nape of the neck, is light yellow or almost
white. Bonelli’s eagle does not carry a crest like most of the ornate
hawk-eagles throughout the world, but it has a few feathers which when
raised are somewhat like a crest. The feathers of the mantle have dark
brown shafts that contrast with the rest of the plumage, which is much
lighter in colour. The upper portion of the tail is of a dark slate colour,
becoming rather more grey lower down. Running across the tail are
very dark slate-coloured bands, with narrower and less defined bands
in between. The tip of the tail is a dirty livid white. Both primaries and
secondaries are barred black and mottled all over. The wing-coverts
4 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
have a dark brown central quill, and the greater wing-coverts are light
brown. As the eagle gets older, with each successive moult there gradu-
ally appear traces of eyebrows similar to those seen in sparrow-hawks
and goshawks. The eagle’s cheeks are mostly of a cinnamon colour
with dark streaks running through them. These streaks are actually
shafts of feathers.
The feathers on the thigh are of a slightly darker shade than the
rest of the underpart feathers. In immature birds that have been out of
the nest no more than two or three months, the eyes are yellowish green,
but with age the eyes turn to orange, and in some very old birds I have
noticed them to be almost copper-red in colour. Normally a two-year-
old bird will have golden brown eyes.
In immature birds the cere is usually dull yellow, sometimes whitish
yellow. The feet are either dusty yellow or plain yellow but these colour-
differences are not invariable, for the feet and the base of the beak are
bound to be affected by the food the eagle has been getting, and also
on the general health of any particular bird at a given time. In females
the tail is about ten-and-a-half inches long. Each wing when fully spread
measures about twenty inches.
Young birds as a rule have lighter plumage, the feathers along the
nape of the neck being almost yellowish white.
I have come across this eagle in northern Afghanistan, in the Sind
valley, and in parts of Baluchistan. My falconer friends tell me that
these birds are found in many parts of southern Europe. The Booted
Eagle of Europe (Hieraaetus pennatus) is a very close relative of
Bonelli’s ( Hieraaetus fasciatus fasciatus). In his classical book on eagles
Leslie Brown says that the birds of the genus Hieraaetus are quite
plentiful in Africa. There are accounts of these birds by Turkish fal-
coners who have seen them in Chinese Central Asia.
Bonelli’s Eagle is met with in most of the northern provinces of
Afghanistan and in some parts of Iran also. In the Baz Nama a Nasarie
the author tells us how he once caught an eagle which he later trained,
and was able to hunt Chukor Partridge with it. From the description I
am sure it must have been a Bonelli’s Eagle. In the Baz Hama, that
famous treatise on falconry, Bonelli’s Eagle is referred to by the name
ukab-a-sena-baza which roughly means ‘the eagle with a hawk-like
breast’. Here the author is referring to the spots that normally cover
the area mentioned.
In India the eagle is often seen in the Himalayas up to a height of
nine thousand feet. During winter it may be seen all over the Penin-
sula, even as far down as Kerala. Identification in flight is not very
difficult. The salient features to be noticed are (a) elongated wing-tips,
and comparatively narrow secondaries, ( b ) flight much bolder and
faster than that of any other hawk-eagle. There is some resemblance
BON ELLIS HAWK-EAGLE
5
to an osprey, though there are colour differences and Bonelli’s Eagle
has a longer tail.
Nest-building begins as early as December in the Doon valley.
Generally speaking, eggs are hatched in April. The nest is usually big,
and mostly found two-thirds up some lofty tree on the bank of a river.
Once I saw a huge nest built on a cliff. Twigs, lined with leaves, form
the nest. It is bulky, and not very pretty, yet it manages to escape
detection, and a casual observer will only notice a nest when he sees
the eagle enter or leave it. In the western Doon in the hills along the
river Jumna, I came across two nests. In one I found eggs of a dirty
white colour, streaked with dark brown spots. In the other nest I saw
an eaglet that could only have been a few days old, for its whole body
was covered with white down.
Bonehi’s Eagle is bold and energetic. It is extremely active and
feeds much on partridges, grouse, sometimes pigeons but mostly wild-
fowl. Pheasants and peafowl are taken as well. The call is a screechy
cry like that of a goshawk, only many times greater in volume.
My second Bonelli’s Eagle was also acquired near Dehra Dun. I
had gone for a long walk in country now ruined by indiscriminate lime-
stone quarrying, and as I was watching the high peaks ablaze with
glory in the last rays of the sun I became aware that the dark object
on top of a tree a few hundred yards away must be an eagle. Without
bothering to examine it through binoculars, I set about preparing the
dogaza with a live pigeon for bait. As usual, after having pitched the
net and bait, I withdrew to a flank to watch the proceedings. By this
time the sun had sunk behind the Siwalik Hills and any detailed ex-
amination, even with the aid of binoculars, was impossible.
Just then a laughing bark drew my attention. I had often seen this
crafty old fox in the same spot before, usually in the late evening on
his way to raid a hen roost. Now it seemed that he was in great haste.
When I turned again to look at the tree with the eagle on it I found it
empty.
I stared at the net and soon realized that the trap had been sprung.
Probably the fox had seen the pigeon and had begun to stalk it at the
same time that the eagle decided to attack. On seeing the eagle
approaching from the opposite direction the fox had turned and run
for cover while the eagle, oblivious of the future that was in store for
it, had sailed into the net.
It had become pretty dark by now and only a few flashes of white
betrayed the fact that the eagle was struggling in the net. As fast as my
legs could carry me I ran to the trap, but arrived too late to save the
life of the faithful pigeon.
I got home at around eight that evening. My first object was to
find a hood. I rummaged in vain in all the boxes I had, crammed with
6 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
hoods of various sizes, but none would fit and I decided I should have
to seal the eagle’s eyes. This is not as painful an operation as the reader
may imagine, though it does require a certain degree of skill and prac-
tice; also needed are the services of a helper to cast and hold the bird
firmly.
I slipped a woollen sock over the eagle, my servant held it down
gently but firmly, and in a few minutes the sealing operation was per-
formed. Being confident that the eagle would remain quiet, I carefully
slid off the woollen sock and deposited the eagle on a cushion kept on
the ground for this purpose.
For a moment the eagle with sealed eyes stood sizing up the situ-
ation, then it flew straight at the light and the electric bulb exploded with
a hollow bang. In the total darkness which ensued, there was no stopping
the eagle. It kept on flying, blindly and in a rage, into strange objects.
A heavy silver frame containing my great grandfather’s picture was
soon knocked off the wall and in the process of falling started a little
avalanche of other family pictures. As befitted their subordinate status,
the descendants fell with their progenitor. And all fell on to the sofa,
where our cat had decided to take a nap.
With a terrific shriek of protest pussy leapt down, disturbing Dinky,
our fox-terrier. Immediately there began a pitched battle between dog
and cat. While this land engagement was in full swing, the air arm was
not idle. It was again and again crashing into chandeliers, old china,
and other objects that were foolish enough to get in its way. At last
it flew into one of the curtains which mercifully came down, rod and all,
on top of it.
In the meanwhile someone had opened the dining-room door and a
goodish amount of light was coming through. I immediately attacked
the heap of fury that lay helpless in the curtain and without much
difficulty obtained a good hold, though in the process the eagle deeply
scratched my hands.
The eagle was to give me some more anxious moments that night.
At about two in the morning I got out of bed to pay a visit to the
mews where the eagle had been left on a perch to roost for the night.
Shivering with cold I crept to the mews, which in fact was an outhouse
converted into a hawk-house, and was horrified to see that the door,
which I had bolted from the outside before going to bed, was now
gaping wide open.
When I got inside I found the eagle had vanished, but as I was
wondering what could have happened I heard footsteps approaching.
It was my father, who had been out with the eagle on his fist in the
frosty morning air. This is a part of the training, gradually to wear down
the eagle’s resistance by keeping it from rest.
Most of the next day was spent in carrying the eagle about and in
BONELLI’S HAWK-EAGLE
7
preparing a hood for it. When it was ready the eagle’s eyes were unseal-
ed and the hood clamped on. Round about eleven in the morning, feed-
ing was attempted. The eagle showed no interest but by alternately
pressing its claws, and rubbing pigeon meat on its beak, it began to
peck, lowering its head to pull at the meat that was being offered.
Though blindfolded, it managed to stow away almost half a cropful
before we restrained it from having any more.
At about nine o’clock the same evening, we took the eagle to a
dimly lighted room, and there gently slipped off the hood. The only
source of illumination was a lantern, placed in one corner of the room
and burning very low. I sat near the lantern, with my father a little
distance away. In accordance with his signals I gently twisted the thumb-
screw of the lantern, to raise the wick in the lamp very slightly. Gradu-
ally we increased the light in the room till the objects were well defined.
The eagle seemed to accept their presence and showed no signs of
agitation.
Now and again my father very gently stroked the eagle with a
feather. The feather (which was in fact the primary quill of a pigeon)
was drawn across its chest and, though the eagle did not positively
enjoy such treatment, it did not mind it very much either. By now the
lantern wick had been fully raised and the electric light switched on
as well. All our attention was fully concentrated on the eagle and we
watched it with hopeful expectation. For a little while we remained
quite motionless, then very slowly at first, and without any jerky move-
ment, the stroking was resumed. The eagle did not seem to mind much,
for it just sat there looking from one of us to the other. When a piece
of meat was held on the index finger and very slowly offered, to our
surprise the eagle picked it up and swallowed it.
I very slowly got up from my chair and unhurriedly walked over
to another one close by. The eagle watched me and did not attempt
to fly off the fist. We then started speaking in hushed tones, so as to
get the eagle accustomed to the human voice. The eagle did not mind
this cither and we were encouraged to raise our voices till we were
soon speaking to each other as loudly as in ordinary conversation. The
eagle bated a couple of times, but the fact that it climbed back to its
perch on the gloved fist after bating was a clear indication that it was
behaving very well. I began to think that it would soon be in flying
order.
We retired to bed at about one in the morning. I was up again by
five and the first light of the sun found me pacing the garden with the
eagle on my fist. It had responded so well to an almost non-stop train-
ing programme of handling that I did not expect any adverse effect
when I unhooded it again. But daylight, free vision, and an excellent
prospect of trees all round was enough to make the eagle yearn for its
8 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
lost freedom. Without any warning it became a raging lunatic. It bated
again and again, till at last it hung exhausted from my fist. In vain did
I try to help it back to a sitting posture. It simply refused to sit up
properly, even after being hooded. No matter how hard I tried, the
eagle continued to roll off my fist.
I had blundered. I ought not to have unhooded the eagle in broad
daylight at this early training stage. According to the rules I should
have punched two small holes in the hood in front of the eagle’s eyes,
permitting a very restricted field of view. Then every day these holes
would have been enlarged, until the eagle enjoyed about eighty per
cent visibility. Only then could the hood be safely removed. In my
anxiety to accelerate the process of training, I had foolishly thrown
caution to the winds.
Now that the mischief had been done, immediate steps to check any
further bating would have to be taken. Every time a newly-caught
hawk bates, it becomes excited. The excitement grows progressively
with subsequent bates till a stage is reached when it is beyond all help.
Hooding had been tried, and had failed. More drastic action was
needed, so I put the eagle under the shower and doused it with water.
After this it sat on the perch with drooping head, hooded and wet to
the skin. This was better than hanging upside-down by the jesses.
After the eagle had remained on the perch for some time, all damp
and forlorn, I attempted to feed it, but all my efforts having failed. I
resorted to force-feeding in the afternoon of the same day. Under such
circumstances it is imperative to keep the eagle well fed, for on an
empty stomach the shock of handling can prove disastrous to a bird
newly caught and undergoing training. Until late at night it was carried
about on the fist and unhooded for extremely short periods. Next morn-
ing, on the third day of the eagle’s captivity, it was collected from the
perch, hooded and taken out on to the lawn just before sunrise. When
unhooded it did not betray any unusual signs of jumpiness, though
it still remained completely indifferent to the food that was offered it
at feeding time.
Force-feeding is not a satisfactory answer to the problem, for if
continued the hawk or eagle usually starts disgorging the food thus
given. Something else had to be done, and done very quickly. Since
dead meat conveyed no meaning to the eagle, a crow was netted and
tied to a peg near the unhooded eagle, then sitting on a bow perch on
the lawn. The crow immediately attacked, and had I not intervened
would surely have damaged the eagle’s feathers severely. My plan had
failed, and the crow had to be removed. Then I tried a live pigeon,
which was understandably very disturbed to find itself so close to the
eagle, and repeatedly attempted to fly away. But the eagle remained
unmoved throughout the performance.
BON ELLIS HAWK-EAGLE
9
By now I had became absolutely desperate. As a last resort, I got
a live rat from our neighbour, tied a strong bit of twine to one of its
hind legs, and attached it to the same peg which held the crow and
the pigeon. After ignoring Master Rat for about a minute, the eagle
began to watch keenly as the rat settled down to nibbling the cord
that lay between it and freedom. After a few minutes it gathered itself
together and pounced, killing the rodent in a clean strike.
I was triumphant but had no intention of allowing the eagle to take
a meal off the dead rat. Cautiously I offered a piece of meat, and while
the eagle was busy grabbing this, I managed to pull the rat away and
hide it behind me.
The crowning moment came when standing about a foot away, I
displayed a piece of meat on my gloved fist, and the eagle jumped to
the outstretched fist and started to peck at the food. Gradually I moved
away until in a few moments the eagle was jumping to my fist a distance
of more than five feet. My hands were trembling with excitement as I
watched the eagle. Was all this possible, or was it some sort of a dream?
Half an hour earlier the eagle had been a raging, rabid brute, not caring
to eat, and only interested in trying to get away from the company of
man. Now it sat up obediently taking the food offered to it. I need
no longer harbour fears of not being able to complete my training
programme.
That afternoon, on his way out hunting, my uncle dropped in, and
at the same time Robin also arrived, on short leave from Belgaum
where he was undergoing some special military training. So we all set
out together, father with the eagle, my uncle with his goshawk, and
Robin with his peregrine falcon Comet. I took the Irish Setter I had
painstakingly trained. Only the goshawk was in flying condition and
it was decided to try her at partridges. So far as the eagle was concern-
ed, the idea was to keep up the training pressure. It was allowed to
remain unhooded for short periods only, and the moment it showed
signs of uneasiness, or a tendency to bate, the hood would be imme-
diately clamped on again. It would once again be unhooded, when all
signs of nervousness had disappeared. During one of the spells when
the eagle was unhooded, it noticed the goshawk on my uncle’s fist,
and from then onwards, whenever the hood was off and the eagle close
to the goshawk or Robin’s peregrine, it would promptly bate at them.
This was exceedingly good progress. Robin henceforth gave the eagle
a wide berth and my uncle blamed it for his goshawk’s shameful per-
formance that day. Indeed no sensible hawk could be expected to have
much appetite for hunting when it is itself the object of an eagle’s
attention.
To avoid any further disturbance of the hunting I took the eagle
from my father, and set out for home. Robin came with me and was
10 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
obliged to hood his falcon for she was terribly afraid with the eagle
eyeing her the way it did, and excited almost to the point of going into
a fit. I remembered how a short while ago, a crow had attacked this
very eagle with impunity and how the harmless pigeon, so much relish-
ed by all birds of prey, had completely failed to attract its attention.
Now the eagle was ready to tear a goshawk to pieces and eat a pereg-
rine falcon.
When my father got home late that evening he told me how things
had brightened up after the eagle had quit the scene. The goshawk had
bagged a grey partridge and run a junglefowl to earth, though it had
not been possible to flush it out again. It is very annoying to the fal-
coner when heavy cover and a tired dog make flushing out an impos-
sibility. Sometimes the quarry even seeks refuge in a disused rodent
warren.
I tried to digest as much of the news as I could, but was already
thinking of the future. How could I raise the money required to buy
a nice pair of bells for my eagle? I remembered an elaborate pencil-
sharpener given me by some well-meaning relative. It was just as good
as new, and after a great deal of haggling, I managed to sell it for
twelve rupees.
In those days, one could order bells to suit one’s hawk or eagle
from the hawk market at Amritsar. Eagle’s bells were more expensive,
because not many people took to training eagles. I ordered an extra
large pair which cost me Rs. 5, at a time when a pair of peregrine
bells could be picked up for a rupee.
Everything went according to plan during the next two days. At
feeding time, a whistle was blown at regular intervals, and soon the
eagle began to associate this sound with its food. Even when hooded
it would become restless, and search for food when it heard the
whistle. She (for the bird was a female) had also grown quite tame
and could be called to the fist from twenty feet or more.
Up till now the eagle had never been called from a perch higher
than my shoulder. It is always best to call a new hawk from the ground
to the fist for then it will be flying to a higher perch, which normally
birds of prey do not mind. If obliged to fly down, they are less likely
to cooperate. At this stage of training all hawks are held on what is
known as the creance. This is a long line attached to the leash of the
hawk and held by the falconer, to enable him to restrain any straying
from the course. I soon had my eagle flying from any distance and
height without any hesitation, which was a fair indication that the
creance was no longer required. I could throw her up on to the tallest
tree in our compound and when called she would obediently fly down
to my fist.
It was on the eighth day after the eagle had been captured that there
BON ELLIS HAWK-EAGLE
11
occurred an incident, which though it happened more than thirty years
ago, still makes me shiver to remember. I was visiting my uncle’s house
and was sitting with the eagle unhooded and on my fist. My uncle’s
one-year-old son began crawling towards me and I was encouraging
him to try to stand up and take a few steps. As usual I had the eagle
on my right fist. The child approached from the left, and tried to stand
up by supporting himself against my leg. When his head was almost
level with my knee the eagle attacked. I was a fraction of a second
quicker in jerking up and away the fist that held the eagle. I shudder
to think what would have been the result had the eagle been success-
ful in her attack, for a child’s soft bare head can offer little resistance
to the grip of an eagle’s powerful claws.
On the sixteenth day after its capture, the eagle took a live fowl in
great style. It was in yarak, ready to hunt. When this condition has been
attained it is advisable to fly the eagle or hawk at game as soon as
possible. For two successive days we vainly tried to find suitable quarry
in the vicinity. A couple of junglefowl were flushed, but the birds broke
cover at awkward angles and a slip was not made. It has to be remem-
bered that the first flight at game by any new hawk or eagle should
be one hundred per cent successful. If not, a bird of prey may com-
pletely lose confidence in itself.
Therefore we called a council of war, and decided to go to Riawala
by the next train, there to fly the eagle at peafowl. Riawala is in the
Eastern Doon valley, and was then one of the best areas for hunting
and shooting. Unfortunately all the beautiful forests that once stretched
from the station right to the banks of the Ganga have been cut down,
and all the game wiped out long ago.
At 7.30 in the evening we entrained at Dehra Dun and reached
Riawala an hour later. We were a party of three — my father, my-
self and an old friend whom I will call G.
It was bitterly cold and we made for a hut where we saw a fire
burning. It was occupied by a party of bullock-cart-drivers who hauled
timber from the forest to the railway station. They welcomed us, and
since there was lots of room inside the hut we decided to spend the
night there. By a happy accident a pole was slung across the entire
breadth of the hut, which would serve as a perch for the eagle. Beyond
the pole were tethered a number of oxen, wearing sackcloth coats to
protect them from the cold of the night. As I lay well wrapped up in
my blanket on a bed of straw, I was amused to see by the light of the
fire the eagle slice a mute far out which landed on one of the coats and
made a white pattern like an exploding rocket, or some fiery-tailed
comet. The mark of the eagle, I thought. Soon after, she fluffed out her
feathers, pulled one leg up, turned as though to examine the pattern
on the bullock’s coat, then tucked her head beneath her feathers and
12 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
went to sleep.
Before dawn we set off. Father carrying the eagle, I the shot-gun
and our lunch, and G following with a few extras such as cups and a
kettle. The sun had not yet risen and mists were rising from innumer-
able springs and gullies, lying round us and on the road as well like
teased wool. Patches of hoar frost gave evidence of the drop in tem-
perature during the night.
We had marched nearly three miles when the first rays of the sun
bathed the crests of the tallest trees in a flood of orange light. Another
five miles brought us to our hunting ground, the famous Virbather
shooting grounds on the western banks of Gangajee. The country was
one big undulating pampas-covered field, stretching for many miles.
Giant cottonwood trees grew at intervals all over this savannah type of
country, and in the depressions one would find a luxuriant growth of
bramble bushes, with as often as not a tiny spring of crystal-clear
water running in the middle. In these depressions, which looked like
tiny oases, lived peafowl, junglefowl, many a sounder of pig, a rare
tiger and even marsh deer, as well as the dainty little Chausinga ante-
lope. This last antelope has now become extinct throughout the Doon
valley.
We spread out and advanced towards a depression thickly over-
grown with bushes, trees and brambles. I was sure there would be
peafowl, and we had hardly gone twenty yards when with a shrill cry
out flew three hens. My father unhooded the eagle, and cast her after
the peahen closest to him. She made a bee line for the bushes growing
on the rim of the hollow, flying almost over my head, with the eagle
close behind and nearly underneath. This trick of chasing game and
ultimately attacking the quarry from below is adopted by all the
accipiters. As eagle and peahen were silhouetted against the blue of
the sky at the edge of the depression, the eagle turned on her back
and grabbed the quarry by the breast. Both came down in a big flutter
of wings into a monstrous bramble patch.
I reached the top of the rise just in time to see the peahen break
from the far end of the thicket and immediately take to the air. Swiftly
I drew a bead on her and brought her down. We then went to rescus
the eagle, which was hopelessly entangled in the thorny bramble. With
her greater weight the peahen had managed to smash loose from the
eagle’s grip and get away, while the eagle’s jesses had knotted round a
twig. I had to cut a path into that veritable thicket of thorn with my
hunting knife before I was able to free her. The first slip at game had
not been as successful as we wished it to be. It was only a partial
victory. Could we induce the eagle to believe that she had really made
a kill? While Father and G stood with the eagle behind some bushes,
I tied a long line to the dead peahen and hid her in some grass about
BONELLVS HAWK-EAGLE
13
twenty paces away. Then I hid and at a signal from my father, who
stood with the unhooded eagle on his fist, began to pull the peahen
into the open. As soon as the eagle saw her victim she launched her-
self and grabbed it. This sort of subterfuge works very well sometimes
but it is not advisable to repeat it often.
After the eagle had tasted a little blood she was allowed to feather
the quarry for a short while and then hooded. Later that day we hoped
to give her another try.
Any falconer will tell you that the right time for hawks and other
birds of prey to start soaring is the middle of the day. We did not
wish the eagle to do any soaring so she had to remain grounded for
the afternoon. But soon after we headed for a narrow strip of land
bordering the western bank of the river. Opposite this, the Ganga had
split into innumerable channels, most of which could be easily crossed.
There were clumps of khair trees on many of the islands and as we
reached the bank of the main stream a peacock flew out of a little
bush and headed straight for the mosaic of islands beyond.
He was a monster, with a magnificent tail. By the time my father
had managed to slip the hood from the eagle’s head and cast her, the
peacock had gained a considerable distance and was making for one
of the islands. The eagle rose sharply above the khair trees when it
reached the island on which the peacock had taken refuge, and for a
moment I thought she was starting to soar. However, she flew steadily
on till she gained the centre of the island, and then dropped like a
stone and disappeared in the dense jungle. A piercing scream from the
peacock soon followed, and we all rushed towards the spot from which
it had come. G and I were a bit delayed by tumbling one after the
other into a pit which someone had been digging for porcupine.
Father arrived first. When he got there he found the eagle, looking
very small, bothering the already dead peacock.
We allowed her to feather the kill for a while, and then cut out
and gave her the liver. We also added half a pigeon to the eagle’s
menu that evening, for she had started to earn her keep.
This had been very good going. The eagle had registered a kill
within nineteen days of its capture, the shortest time in all my experience.
Normally eagles trapped as passengers, or adult birds obtained from
dealers, require at least two to three months of gruelling work before
they are ready for the hunting field. My falconer friends agree such a
short training period is very rare. Probably my eagle was exceptionally
intelligent.
I was very happy with her, and we used to go out almost every
day after hares and junglefowl. She was always very keen, never show-
ing any lack of interest no matter how much she had been fed the day
before. Soon we found ourselves in the middle of March, the time
14 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL UlST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (i)
some birds get excited with ideas of nest-building and rearing a family.
Under normal conditions, a bird of the hawk tribe always mounts guard
over the spot where it has run game into cover, so that the falconer
can come along and flush the game that has taken refuge in the thicket,
giving the eagle, or hawk, another chance of flying down the quarry.
Falcons immediately start soaring over the spot where they have run
a quarry to earth, but when hawks and eagles soar, it indicates the in-
fluence of the mating instinct. My eagle had now begun soaring on two
consecutive occasions after her quarry had taken refuge in some bush.
For more than a week I was not able to devote more than half an
hour a day to my eagle, being fully occupied with training a Shahin
falcon, a tiercel, that I had captured. Then a friend came along who
wanted to see the eagle in action, and pressed me to fly her at game. In
the area where the eagle had been first netted we soon put up a hare
and cast the eagle after it. It was a thrilling chase but at the last moment
the hare twisted sideways and the eagle struck only the ground. She
rose slowly, much disappointed, and began to soar. Having foolishly
forgotten to bring along the lure, and being without any live bait with
which to coax her back to earth, I could only watch her mount till
she became a mere speck against a silvery patch of clouds in the
background. For the next two or three days I walked mile upon endless
mile, swinging the lure and blowing the whistle, vainly seeking her.
But she must have left for the hills, and I hope that there she met her
match, built a home, and reared a family.
Many years passed before I again came across a Bonelli’s eagle.
I had been marching through the Eastern Doon jungle, and was in
Motichur block where the old Hardwar-Rishikesh cart road climbs
steeply to enter the Government forest. Here there are giant trees of a
kind to be seen nowhere else in the Doon valley, towering to a height
of more than two hundred feet, and through these trees I saw an eagle
fly, heading towards the open grassland beyond.
Snatching up the trap and my binoculars, I immediately followed
in the general direction the eagle had taken. A couple of hundred yards
beyond the rim of the cliff, where the trees grew less densely, I halted
to scan some likely trees, but there being no eagle in sight I proceeded
further and further in the direction I had seen the eagle fly, till I was
standing on the edge of a huge grassy plot. Here I could see an object
looking like an eagle perched on a solitary cottonwood tree some dist-
ance away, and with the binoculars it was easy to identify.
I set the dogaza at a place clearly visible from the eagle’s point of
vantage and fastened a live partridge which I had with me behind the
net for bait. Then I withdrew to take cover and watch developments.
Almost at once the eagle flew down and was caught in the meshes of
the net but before I could reach it it had ripped the net to shreds and
BONELLl’S HAWK-EAGLE
15
was flying away with the dead partridge dangling from its claws. Even
today I do not know how it happened, for I had spun the net with
thin, strong cord. Anyway I had lost my third Bonelli’s eagle.
For me, capturing an eagle, or any other bird of prey, is more than
half the fun. I do not mean taking an eagle from the nest, or trapping
a parent when it is engaged in raising a family, for in such cases
capture is more or less a foregone conclusion. I prefer to go out into
the country at a time when the eagles, or hawks, or whatever I am
after, are not handicapped by nesting activities. I may have to tramp
for miles, day after day, before meeting the object of my desires. Then
to set a trap, and persuade a recalcitrant monarch of the air to fly into
the net requires not only skill and experience but also some element of
luck. It gives me great satisfaction to catch a bird this way.
I will now describe yet another failure. I was raking the country-
side around Danda in quest of birds of prey, in a maze of deep over-
grown ravines, interspersed with groves and a few fields, and with
Nalapani Hill crowned with the once famous Kalanga fortress rising
sharply to the east.
Soon I was attracted by a congregation of crows in a distant mango
grove. They might, I thought, be mobbing an owl, an eagle, a hawk, a
falcon, or even a harmless cuckoo. Their object might also be a stone
marten, a jungle cat or even a dead crow caught in a branch. There
was absolutely no harm in investigating, for inquisitiveness is the fal-
coner’s main attribute, so I cut across and found a whole pack of black
devils concentrating their attack on an object that looked like an eagle,
sitting in the middle of a massive old mango. Though lighting condi-
tions were not very favourable, through binoculars I was soon able to
identify an old acquaintance. It was an immature Bonelli’s eagle. There
was no time to lose, and I looked around for a favourable spot to
pitch the net.
The choice of ground for a trap is very important. The trap and
bait must be in full view of the bird that is intended to be caught,
broadside on. The background should be such that it does not throw
the net and its meshes into contrast with the surroundings, for with
the sky as a backdrop every mesh on the net would be finely etched,
and the hawk would probably take fright. On the other hand, the sharp
outline of the meshes is well camouflaged when the net is spread
against a green and dappled background of bushes, and a hawk in a
hurry to pick up its dinner will hardly notice it.
A live bait must be secured behind the trap, at a suitable distance.
If fastened too close the bait may work its way into the net and bring
down the trap intended for the hawk, but if too far away the hawk may
be able to grab the bait without having to go dangerously near the net.
Also, the line on which the bait is held be long enough to allow it to
i6 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HlST. SOCIETY, Vot. 11 (1)
flutter about, and give the hawk the impression that some easy prey
is available for capture; but if the line is too long the bait may get
caught in the net. Then the falconer must choose bait appropriate for
his purpose: a wild bird of prey is not likely to fly down to something
it has never before seized. It is essential to make a thorough study of
the feeding habits and sex of the bird of prey one is trying to capture.
It is well known that in birds of prey, the female of the species is
bigger than the male, and also stronger. The disparity is not so obvious
where eagles are concerned, and in the wild state, both male and female
birds can be seen pulling down game of the same weight. But for hawks
and falcons the difference in size must always be taken into account.
Similarly, when he has trained his hawk or falcon, the falconer must
know the sort of game to hunt as well as the country in which to look
for it.
For a Bonelli’s eagle the best bait would have been a partridge, for
with partridges it is possible to bag not only eagles, but any bird of
prey, from pretty little sparrow-hawks to powerful goshawks. But
Bonelli’s eagle is also very fond of the blue rock pigeon, which was
the only bait I had to offer that day. Having chosen my site, and set the
trap, I retired to a flank to wait and watch. I had the eagle sharply in
focus as it took off and flew towards the trap, but to my horror it
suddenly swerved out of my field of vision, and when I lowered the
binoculars I was only just in time to see it rising from behind a bush
some distance from the net, with the pigeon I had tied behind my trap
dangling from its claws.
It took me some time to figure out what had happened. It was a
wet, rainy day and I had used an old eight-inch screwdriver as a peg
to anchor the pigeon. The screwdriver was strong, and so was the
bootlace used to tie the pigeon to it. I had pushed the screwdriver deep
enough into the soil to make it firm and steady under normal condi-
tions, but in soft wet soil it should have been hammered in a few
inches more. When it saw the eagle making for it, the pigeon had made
a terrific struggle to smash loose from its mooring and had managed
to dislodge the screwdriver from the soft soil. It had escaped to the
nearest bush, but had once again run into bad luck. The screwdriver
had got entangled in a bramble, so that the pigeon was held dangling
by the bootlace. Then the eagle had struck, carrying off the screw-
driver, a bit of the treacherous branch and the game little blue rock
all together.
Bonelli’s Eagle has been prized by falconers all over the world
for its boldness and bravery. It is comparatively easy to train and when
trained loses all fear of man. Its long primaries and short secondaries
fit it for soaring, and I have on a number of occasions seen it dive from
the sky to capture game on the wing. Normally it thrives on the border
BO NELLI’S HAWK-EAGLE
17
lands where the forests merge into open country, and though it is not
as fast as the crested hawk-eagles over short distances it will follow
game for much greater distances and does not seem to be discouraged
by a long chase.
There is just one more aspect I would like to mention, for the sake
of my falconer friends. When training Bonelli’s Eagle, I noticed that it
was not at all punctual in disgorging its cast very day early in the
morning. A cast is a tight pellet of feathers thrown up each day by
hawks and falcons, the remains of the previous day’s meal. Unlike
meat and bones, feathers cannot be digested and have to be ejected in
this form; it is nature’s way of cleaning up the inside of a bird of prey.
If the cast is not thrown out every day at sunrise it indicates that the
eagle is not keen to hunt.
The language of falconry is often confusing, and while a cast or
casting is something thrown up from the crop the same word ‘casting’
is applied to any purgative dose given to a hawk. The fur and feathers
given to a hawk with his food is called a casting, and it is in these
castings the medicines are administered. Hawks are regularly deworm-
ed, and are sometimes sick or in need of a tonic. If they are not ejecting
their daily pellet regularly, the meat should be soaked in luke-warm
water mixed with isabghul. Other ways to stimulate regular ejection are
to mix crushed bird-bones with the meat or to force-feed two or three
tiny pebbles wrapped in cotton-wool or a chunk of meat. Normally
however hawks thrive on a diet of dead birds and rodents, and if only
mutton is available some feathers or fur should always be given with it.
2
Indian Mammals on Texas
Seven species of Indian ungulates have been introduced onto
rangelands in Texas. At least four of these species are successfully
established with population in excess of 4,000 animals. Similarities
and contrasts between the Texas and Indian habitats are noted
and the role of exotics on Texas rangelands is discussed.
Within the State of Texas at least 26 species of non-native ungulates,
exclusive of domestic livestock, have been introduced by landowners.
Most of these exotics exist as free-ranging herds on private ranches
which vary in size from a few hundred acres to more than 100,000 acres.
In some instances individuals of a species have escaped and spread
over large geographic areas. Most, however, are confined within indi-
vidual ranches by 7-8 foot high game-proof fences.
United States Government health regulations prohibit direct im-
portation and release of wild ruminants and swine from countries
where foot-and-mouth disease or rinderpest is declared to exist. How-
ever, animals with proper health inspections and clearance may be
imported and placed under permanent consignment to specifically
approved zoological gardens where the animals must spend the re-
mainder of their lives (Smith 1968). The progeny of these captive
animals can be purchased and released on private lands in Texas and
in some other states (Craighead & Dasmann 1966). Such releases have
1 Accepted December 27, 1972.
2 Associate Professor, Department of Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences, Texas
Agricultural Experiment Station, Texas A & M University, College Station,
Texas, U.S.A.
3 Wildlife Specialist, Department of Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences, Texas
Agricultural Extension Service, Texas A & M University, College Station, Texas,
BY
Ernest D. Ables1 2 and Charles W. Ramsey3
(With two text -figures )
Introduction
U.S.A.
INDIAN MAMMALS ON TEXAS RANGELANDS
19
been made by landowners since as early as 1924 (Sheffield et al. 1971).
As range herds produced surplus animals and the demand for animals
to stock other ranches grew, the activity of supplying exotics shifted
from zoos to private ranches. Presently the supplying of breeding stock
has become a business for some ranches.
Most early stocking of exotics was motivated by the allure of new
and different game species. However, in recent years the economic
possibilities of game ranching to supply trophy hunting to paying
sportsmen has promoted new releases. As of 1971, more than 300
ranches in Texas had one or more species of non-native big game.
Places of origin for exotics in Texas include Africa, Asia, Europe,
and the Mediterranean region. The most numerous and widespread
species, excluding wild sheep ( Ovis spp.), are native to the Indian
subcontinent. Seven species of Indian origin exist on ranches through-
out the State (Table 1). Estimated numbers are based on a 1963 survey
by Ramsey (1969) and modified by data collected since that time. A
current survey would surely show larger numbers and wider distri-
bution within the state.
Species and numbers of Indian ungui.ates that occur in Texas
The animal nomenclature follows that of Prater (1965). Subspecies
present are generally not known, or have been obscured by interbreed-
ing. Easily recognized morphological differences exist among certain
species, but it is uncertain whether or not these are genotypic or
phenotypic variations. Most chital fit the general description of Axis
axis axis, however, some ranches have a form smaller and stockier in
size, and with shorter antlers. These animals more closely resemble
Axis axis ceylonensis. The red deer or stag and the wild boar are
advertised in hunting brochures as being European in origin. How-
ever, some zoo stock came from India or the Himalayan region, and
Indian species present
Table 1
Chital ( Axis axis )
Blackbuck antelope ( Antilope cervicapra )
Wild Boar ( Sus scrofa)
Nilgai antelope ( Boselaphus tragocamelus )
Red deer ( Cervus elaphus )
Sambar ( Cervus unicolor )
Barasingha ( Cervus duvauceli )
> 10,000
> 4,000
> 10,000
> 4,500
> 300
> 100
> 50
20 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
doubtlessly have supplied some of the animals stocked on Texas
ranches.
Distribution and Habitat in Texas
Areas in the state which contain the greatest numbers of exotics
are the Edwards Plateau, the South Texas Plains, and the Gulf Prairies
and Marshes (Fig. 1). Reasons for this pattern of distribution are
partially cultural and partially ecological. The largest number of species
and the greatest numbers of animals are in the Edwards Plateau. This
region is devoted mainly to ranching enterprises: cattle, sheep, and
goats. It is also the area containing the greatest numbers of white-tailed
deer ( Odocoileus virginiana). In recent years the economic return
from sheep and goats has greatly declined. Landowners have conse-
quently sought means of supplementing ranch income by stocking
exotic game and charging sportsmen for the privilege of hunting.
Ecologically, the regions of Texas with the largest numbers of
exotics are very similar to their native ranges in India. The area of Texas
containing most exotics is between 26° and 31° N. latitude, and lies
Fig. 1
INDIAN MAMMALS ON TEXAS RANGELANDS
21
within the latitudinal ranges of India, approximately 8°-33° N. lati-
tude. Annual patterns of temperature and precipitation are similar in
both regions with extremes in precipitation in India being greater (Fig.
2). Temperatures in the northern Edwards Plateau sometimes drop
below 0° F. during the winter, while in some years temperatures do
not fall below 32° F. in the extreme southern tip of Texas.
The Edwards Plateau is an area of some 24 million acres character-
ized by rough, stony hills dissected by several river systems. Elevations
vary from 1,200 to more than 3,000 feet. Soils are shallow and under-
lain primarily by limestone. The climax vegetation is grassland and
open savanna. Overgrazing by domestic livestock has depleted the
grass cover and has resulted in an increase of woody plants such as
mesquite ( Prosopis juliflora), live oak ( Quercus virginiana) , shinnery
oaks ( Quercus spp.), and junipers (Juniperu s spp.).
lOO
J
NEW DELHI. INDIA
IM
ill
X
<
“■ 70
X 80
Z
M
9©
N
J
50
k
J
2
4
6
O
INCHES OF PRECIPITATION
Fig. 2
8
lO
22 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
The South Texas Plains and the Gulf Prairies and Marshes together
comprise an area of almost 30 million acres. This region of flat to
rolling topography originally supported a climax grassland. Reduced
numbers of fires and overgrazing by livestock have vastly altered the
plant community until now scrub woody vegetation is the predominant
growth form. Invading woody species include mesquite, live oak,
prickly pear cacti ( Opuntia spp.) and several species of Acacia. Land
use practices are similar to those of the Edwards Plateau though farm-
ing is more intensive on the Coastal Plains.
The wild boar is perhaps the most numerous and widespread
species, but because of its secretive behaviour it is difficult to accurately
estimate their population. This cosmopolitan species quickly adapted
and successfully established itself in the wild. In several regions the
animals have mated with feral domestic swine. The resultant wild hog
is not readily accepted by landowners particularly in the Edwards
Plateau where they cause damage to net-wire fencing and occasional
depredation of young sheep and goats. They are also accused of com-
peting for food with native game and destruction of turkey (Meleagris
gallopavo) nests. However, little documented information on their
true role is recorded.
The adaptability of spotted deer is apparent in that it has a wider
distribution of established herds than any other species. There are at
least two populations of chital that number more than 1000 individuals.
In addition, an unknown number have become established as free-
ranging wild animals outside of game-proof fences in the Edwards
Plateau. One large population exists on the Coastal Plains in pre-
dominately low (1-6 feet) live oak interspersed with open grasslands.
However, the majority are in the more rugged, drier Edwards Plateau.
Spillett (1966, 1968) described the habitat of the chital in India as
primarily open deciduous forest that sometimes graded into thorn scrub.
There was an indication in the drier areas that chital were associated
with water supplies (De & Spillett 1966). Chital in Texas are found
in vegetative types closely resembling those described by Spillett, and
in dry regions they are more common along streams.
The largest continuous population of a single species is the nilgai
which occupies a 1000-square mile area including King Ranch, Inc.
and adjoining ranches along the lower Texas coast. This single popu-
lation of 2200-2400 animals is reproducing well and expanding its range
(Sheffield et al. 1971). The vegetative description of the nilgai’s Indian
habitat by Spillett (1968) and Sankhala (1964) is also appropriate
to its Texas habitat — a dry deciduous forest or dry deciduous thorn
forest with nilgai being more common in the drier more open areas.
Blackbuck are found in small numbers in the coastal plains, perhaps
similar to that described by Daniel (1967) for southern India. The
INDIAN MAMMALS ON TEXAS RANGELANDS
23
largest numbers occur in rangelands of the Edwards Plateau, a habitat
consisting of an interspersion of scrub oaks and grassland. Blackbuck
are successful in the open scrub which they utilize readily as escape
cover. They seem more tolerant of overstory canopy than the native
pronghorn ( Antilocapra americana).
Sambar deer are present in smaller numbers with very limited distri-
bution and it is difficult to assess their establishment. One population
of 50 animals occurs in the Gulf Prairies and Marshes vegetative area.
On the ranch where they occur, along with 1200 chital, the sambar
remain almost exclusively in thickets of the larger live oak. They are
frequently seen feeding on submerged aquatic vegetation in 1-3 foot
deep brackish lakes adjacent to the coast. A second small herd in the
Edwards Plateau remains close to a small freshwater lake and have
been observed feeding on aquatic vegetation. It appears that their dis-
tribution is restricted by habitat preference. However, in India they
arc widely distributed through seemingly similar habitats to those in
Texas.
Red deer are more widely distributed than sambar deer, but be-
cause of their close similarity to native elk ( Cervus canadensis ) and
their large size, they are not very popular. They adapt well to semi-
captivity, but when confined together they breed with elk. The off-
spring of this mating is neither as valuable as the elk nor the red deer.
Barasingha exist on only a few ranches, and in such small numbers
that little is known about their habitat in Texas. Other species of Indian
mammals are confined to zoos.
Discussion
Climatic and vegetational similarities between habitats in India and
Texas probably account for the success of most exotics. Also, since
most populations in Texas were produced by zoo stock, they were
already somewhat acclimatized. Supplemental feeding of newly acquired
animals and protection from unwanted hunting further insured their
survival. Throughout the region where exotics have been most success-
ful there are few large predators. Coyote ( Canis latrans ) control is
practiced intensively by ranchers who raise sheep and goats.
The potential natural spread of these exotics into other parts of Texas
and into adjoining states is only speculative at the present. Low winter
temperatures would seemingly limit the northern spread of many Indian
antelope and deer. The blackbuck is sensitive to sub-freezing temper-
atures. Heavy mortality has occurred in some herds during late winter
when food supplies were minimal and either snowstorms or cold rains
produced additional stress. Young nilgai are born during all months,
24 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (1)
but the peak of births is August-September, a season unfavourable
for survival of young throughout much of the northern United States.
The peak of births among chital in Texas is February-March, though
some young are born during all months. In that region of Texas con-
taining most chital late winter weather is not severe enough to hinder
survival, but would likely prove fatal to fawns born further north. The
same is true for all other species that give birth year-round or during
the winter season.
Exotic ungulates seem well established and are becoming an accept-
ed part of ranching and sport hunting enterprises in Texas. Exotics
offer the sportsman unusual and unique opportunities. He can easily
pursue trophy animals that would otherwise require considerable in-
vestments of time and finances if hunted in their native lands. To the
landowner exotics offer some advantages over native species. Native
game species are regulated by state game laws with bag limits and
seasons being restricted. However, exotics are not regulated by game
laws and may be harvested at the landowner’s discretion. A group of
several species can provide year-round hunting since reproductive
patterns of exotics are different from native animals.
The potential of exotic game for meat production has not been an
important consideration in the past, but presently there is an increasing
interest in the potential of exotic animals as meat producers. Some
species are better adapted to arid and semi-arid regions than are
domestic livestock and some range scientists now suggest that selecting
an animal species compatible with the vegetation is a better approach
than altering the habitat to fit the animal. Thus, exotics are likely to
occupy some role in ranching enterprises in Texas for some time to
come.
Acknowledgements
Unfortunately most introduced ungulates in Texas were released
with little or no knowledge of their biology, habitat requirements and
possible consequences to native biota. To increase our understanding
of exotics and their role in ranching enterprises in Texas a series of
investigations were begun in 1967 by the Department of Wildlife and
Fisheries Sciences of Texas A & M University. These studies were
financed by a grant from the Caesar Kleberg Foundation for Wildlife
Conservation. We gratefully acknowledge their support of this research
programme.
INDIAN MAMMALS ON TEXAS RANGELANDS
25
References
Craighead, F. C. & Dasmann,
R. F. (1966): Exotic Big Game on
Public Lands. U. S. Dept, of Int.
Bur. of Land Mgmt. Washington
D. C. 26 pp.
Daniel, J. C. (1967): The point
Calimere Sanctuary, Madras State —
May 1967. J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc.
64(3) : 512-523.
De, R. C. & Spillett, J. J. (1966):
A study of the Chital or Spotted
Deer in Corbett National Park, Uttar
Pradesh, ibid. 65(3): 576-598.
Prater, S. H. (1965): The Book
of Indian Animals, Second Edition.
Bombay.
Ramsey, C. W. (1969): Texotics.
Bull. No. 49. Texas Parks and Wild-
life Dept. Austin, Texas.
Sankhala, K. S. (1964): Wildlife
Sanctuaries of Rajasthan. J. Bombay
nat. Hist. Soc. 61(1) : 27-34.
Sheffield, W. J., Ables, E. D. &
Fall, B. A. (1971): Geographic and
Ecological Distribution of Nilgai
Antelope in Texas. J. Wildl. Mgmt.
35(2): 250-257.
Smith, C. A. (1968): Protecting
the United States Against Diseases of
Foreign Origin. In Symposium: In-
troduction of Exotic Animals. Caesar
Kleberg Research Programme in Wild-
life Ecology. Texas A & M University.
Spillett, J. J. (1966): A Report
on Wild Life Surveys in Northern
India and Southern Nepal. J. Bombay
nat. Hist. Soc. 65(3) : 492-628.
(1968): A Report on
Wild Life Surveys in South and West
India, ibid. 65(1): 1-46; 65(2): 296-
325; 65(3): 633-663.
Common edible Mushrooms
of Jammu and Kashmir
BY
T. N. Kaul and J. L. Kachroo,
Regional Research Laboratory ( Branch T Srinagar-5, Kashmir, India
( With five figures in two plates)
The region, because of its varied climate and topography,
offers a rich field for mushroom collection. Description of
common edible species along with field notes for mushroom
collectors are provided. Four edible mushrooms from Kashmir
valley, Coprinus atramentarius (Bull.). Fr., C. comatus Fr.,
C. micaceus (Bull.). Fr. and Pleurotus salignus Fr. and one from
Jammu Province Pleurotus ostrcatus Fr. white form, are described.
Two Pleurotus species are new records for India, while the other
three have been recorded from Kashmir valley for the first time.
Introduction
The Kashmir valley has a variety of mushrooms, which are collect-
ed regularly by villagers for consumption. A few like Morels (Mor-
chella spp.; Verpa spp.) and to a lesser extent Pleurotus (‘Dhingri’ local
name) are collected in bulk, dried and exported to different parts of
the country. The annual export of dried morels from the State is about
12,000 kg valued at a million rupees.
Mushroom hunting if indiscriminate can lead to fatal accidents due
to eating of poisonous ones. This series of papers is published with a
view to make available to mushroom lovers a field guide for collection
and identification of edible mushrooms and also a description of the
species recorded is given to assist students of mycology.
Genus Coprinus (Pers.) Fr.
This genus is characterised by black spore deposits and conversion
of cap and gills into black inky fluid. They are commonly referred to
as ink caps and are easy to recognize in the field. The plants vary in
1 Accepted October 24, 1970.
EDIBLE MUSHROOMS OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR
27
size and some grow several inches high and more than an inch in
breadth. A number of species grow on dung or recently manured
ground, while some live on humus and others grow on wood. Most of
the larger ones are edible in immature stages. Their only drawback
is that they must be picked before they mature and used almost at
once. The three species described here are said to be the best edible
species in the genus.
Coprinus atramentarius (Bull.) Fr. Syll. Fung. 5:1081, 1887.
Cap: (Pileus) 7 mm to 30 mm wide in button stage and 30-50 mm
x 40-70 mm in adult stage, at first conical to egg shaped, later broadly
conical covered with grayish bloom which is readily rubbed off. Colour
varies from light brown to dark brown, surface mostly smooth, except-
ing small scales near the top or occasionally at the centre with fine
lines or striations marking the entire surface. The marginal half of the
cap is furrowed irregularly, forming an uneven edge.
Gills : 4-6 mm (button) and 10-15 mm (adult) wide, crowded,
creamy white in young specimens, then pinkish grey and finally black,
liquefying from the margin towards the centre.
Stem : 1.5 to 8 cm long, 10 mm to 15 mm thick, hollow, smooth,
white and shiny above the faint annulus and provide with small up-
ward pointing scale below. Annulus forms an irregularly zigzag elevat-
ed lines of thread which extend around the stem near the base.
Spores : 8-14 x 5-7 [x. elliptical, black.
Collected on ground near the base of trees or on pieces of decom-
posing wood at Chundinah willow plantation (5200' a.s.l.) 22.iii.1970,
T.N. Kaul and J.L. Kachroo, RRLS No. 1, Fig. I.
Reported earlier from Allahabad. New record from Kashmir.
Field notes : Coprinus atramentarius is the most common among
the edible species of Coprinus and forms an article of commerce in
the valley. The species fruits during cold wet weather in spring mainly
but some crop also appears during summer and fall. Extensive collec-
tions are made by villagers from Government willow plantation at
Chundinah (Kashmir). Mushrooms grow in dense clumps near the
base of standing trees, cut stumps or on decaying wood. The soil is
sandy, full of peat and submerged during summer.
An irregular zone of squamules (scales) extending from the base of
the stalk for a short distance distinguishes it from other edible species
of the genus.
There is no local record of poisoning from the species. Smith (1958),
however, refers to the controversy regarding the adverse effect of this
species specially in combination with alcoholic beverages.
28 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Coprinus comatus Fr., Syll. Fung,, 5:1079, 1887. Berk, in J. Bot.
3, 8, 1856 Banerjee in Bull. Bot. Soc. Bengal 1; p. 42.
Cap : (Pileus) 4-10 cm long, 2-3 cm wide, at first egg shaped, be-
coming campanulate or barrel shaped as it matures and margin often
splitting into lobes, turning into umbrella shape at dissolution. Surface
shaggy, covered with prominent brown scales, close together on the
buttons and widely separated in the adult stage, sometimes arranged
concentrically, white between the scale.
Gills : 6-10 mm wide, free, crowded, creamy white first, pink later,
finally black and becoming liquid.
Stem\ 4-14 cm long, 10-15 mm thick at the top and 20-25 mm at
the base, tapering slightly upwards, white and mostly smooth; hollow
even at the young stage with delicate cord suspended in the cavity.
Annulus in the form of free movable ring on the stem, generally resting
at the base or vanishing entirely.
Spores : 12-18 x 5-7 a elliptic, black.
Collected on the side of a rivulet in Sanat Nagar, Srinagar (5200'
a.s.l.) 17-iv-1969 T. N. Kaul & J. L. Kachroo RRLS No. 6, Fig. 2.
Reported from Bombay, Darjeeling and Calcutta on lawns and
refuse dumps. New record for Kashmir.
Field notes’. Coprinus comatus commonly referred to as shaggy
mane is easy to identify in the field. Besides the dissolution of the
ripening cap into a black liquid it is characterised by scaly surface
and narrow loose ring round the stem in earlier stages. European
authors have classed it as one of the best among edible fungi.
It has been noticed in the valley growing mainly on the sides of
rivulets in shady places from late April to October, mostly solitary,
rarely in clumps. Villagers collect the closed button stage for con-
sumption.
Coprinus micaceus fBull.) Fr. Syll. Fung; 5:1090, 1887; Banerjee
in Bull. Bot. Soc. Bengal I: 42.
Cap (Pileus) 20-40 mm v/ide, at first ovate then conical to camp-
anulate, tan or yellowish brown in colour with prominent striations
from the margin up almost to the centre. Surface covered with shining
particles.
Gills 3-4 mm wide, crowded, first white then tan, later black, and
liquefying.
Stem 4-8 cm long, 3-6 mm thick, slender, fragile, hollow and white.
Annulus rarely visible.
Spores 10 x 5-* , blackish, sometime brown elliptical.
Collected around stumps of Robinia pseudoacacia, in shady moist
places in Sanat Nagar, Srinagar (5200' a.s.l.) 9-iv-1970. T. N. Kaul &
J. L. Kachroo, RRLS No. 3, Fig. 3.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (1) Plate
Kaul & Kachroo: Mushrooms
Fig. 1. Coprinus atramentarius Fig. 2. Coprinus comatus
Fig. 3. Coprinus micaceus Fig. 5. Pleurotus salignus
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (1) Plate II
Kaul & Kachroo: Mushrooms
Fig. 4. Pleurotus ostreatus white form
EDIBLE MUSHROOMS OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR
29
Reported from Calcutta (West Bengal). New record for Kashmir
valley.
Field notes : This mushroom appears in clumps near the base of
standing trees of Populus spp., Salix spp., Robinia spp. or around
their cut stumps in the valley. Grows in tufts of ten to thirty or more
individuals. It appears in spring, summer and autumn in cool wet
weather. It is commonly referred to in literature as glistening Coprinus
because of the delicate scales covering the surface of the pileus which
glistens in light like particles of mica. Prominent striations on the Cap
and glistening scales distinguish it from other species of Coprinus.
Since this mushroom occurs in clusters it offers a good meal to the
villagers who collect it.
Genus Pleurotus Fr.
The genus is characterized by spore deposits of white colour when
the cap is left for few hours on a clean surface; an eccentric or lateral
stem; fleshy or tough texture of the cap. There is no annulus. Almost
all species of Pleurotus grow on trees or on dead wood.
Pleurotus ostreatus Fr. white form, Syll. Fung., 5:355, 1887.
Cap 1.5-12 cm wide, 2-10 cm long, soft, fleshy, convex or slightly
depressed near the point of attachment. White, light grey or dark grey,
often becoming yellow on drying, spatulate to kidney shaped, margin
inrolled, imbricate in groups of 4-10 or more. Sessile or with a short
stem.
Gills 5-10 mm wide, white, broad, decurrent, anastomosing at the
base.
Stem when present short 1-3.5 cm long, 0.2-1 cm thick, lateral or
eccentric.
Spores 8-11 x 3. 3-4. 3 p. , subcylindric, not amyloid.
Collected on decaying logs of Euphorbia royleana Boiss. from
Katra Forests, Jammu (1000' a.s.l.) 13-ix-1966, T. N. Kaul & K. K.
Janardhanan, Fig. 4.
The specimens were referred to Mr. E. J. H. Corner of Botany
School, Cambridge who considers them close to Pleurotus eugrammus
(Mont.) Dennis but in the absence of thorough study identified it as
“P. ostreatus white form”. P. ostreatus has not earlier been recorded
from India. It is thus a new record. Corner (Personal communication)
records the prevalance of the same white form in North Borneo.
The detailed microscopic characters communicated by Prof. Corner
are also recorded here.
Basidia 30-38 x 6 jx , 4 sterigmata. Cheilocystidia as sterile basidia
or more inflated 5-8 pi wide, some with a short appendage, ill defined
and not forming a sterile edge. Hyphae monomitic, clamped, 4-15
30 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
(-25) p, wide, the cells 40-230 \i long, the walls 0.5 pi thick but strongly
thickened -2 p. at the base of the stem.
Field notes’. Pleurotus ostreatus is known as the oyster agric as
the form of the plant suggests the outline of an oyster shell. It is an
excellent edible mushroom with considerable host range. This mush-
room locally known as “Dhingri” forms an article of commerce in the
plains of Jammu and is even exported outside the State, as it can be
preserved well after drying.
The mushroom is abundant during the rainy season (August-
September) on decaying stumps of Euphorbia royleana (“Thor” local
name) which occurs commonly from Jammu to Udhampur. Extensive
collections for the market are made in Thor plantations in Katra area
of Jammu Province.
Collection and identification in the field is easy because of the
characteristic shape and specific host in the region.
Pleurotus salignus Pers (Fr.) Syll. Fung 5:359, 1887.
Cap (Pileus) 1-8 cm wide, convex to expanded, depressed in the
centre, margin involute, surface white covered with brownish black
scales which give mottled appearance especially in young stages wear-
ing off in mature specimens.
Gills 4-5 mm wide, white becoming yellow with age.
Stem nearly central, 2-10 cm long and 1-2 cm in thickness.
Spores 6-10 x 3-5 p., elliptical, white.
Collected on willow (Salix alba) stumps at Chundinah willow
plantation, Kashmir (5200' a.s.l.) 22-iii- 1970, T. N. Kaul & J. L.
Kachroo, RRLS No. 2, Fig. 5.
New record for India. P. dryinus has been recorded earlier from
Awantipora, Kashmir on undetermined host. However, most of the
authors have designated the Pleurotus on willow as P. salignus.
Field notes’. This species has been found associated throughout
the valley with willow trees, mostly growing round cut stumps in moist
shady places. It appears in abundance during spring but it also avail-
able in summer, and autumn when the weather is cool and wet. Chara-
cteristic mottling of the cap surface and association with willow trees
distinguishes the mushroom in the field.
Ack nowledge m e n ts
We are thankful to Dr. K. Ganapathi, Director for encouragement
in the work and to Prof. E. J. H. Corner, Botany School, Cambridge
(U.K.) for determination of Pleurotus ostreatus.
EDIBLE MUSHROOMS OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR
31
References
Attkinson, G. F. (1961): Mush-
room, Edible, Poisonous etc. Hafner
Publishing Co. New York.
Christensen, C. M. (1943): Com-
mon Edible Mushrooms. The Lund
Press Inc. Minneapolis, University of
Minnesota.
Cooke, M. C. (1870): Kashmir
Morels, Trans. Bot. Soc. Edi. 10:
439-443.
Krieger, L. C. C. (1967): The
Mushroom Hand book. Dover Pub-
lications, Inc. New York.
Smith, A. H. (1958) : Mushroom
Hunters field guide. The University
of Michigan Press, Ann. Arbor, USA.
Preliminary observations,
on the breeding of pearl
oysters, Pinctada fucata
(Gould) of the Gulf of Kutch1
BY
K. R. Narayanan2
Fisheries Research Station, Jamnagar-l
( With two text-figures)
The pearl oysters of the Gulf of Kutch breed twice in a year.
The primary breeding season is during winter, i.e. December to
January, which is followed by a secondary less significant breeding
period in early summer, i.e. April to May.
The stimulus for breeding does not appear to be in relation
to the changes in salinity and temperature, as there is great vari-
ation in the salinity and temperature values during these two
breeding seasons.
Introduction
While the biology of the pearl oysters of the Gulf of Mannar has
been studied in detail by Herdman (1903-06), Hornell (1916 & 1922)
and Malpas (1929 & 1933), those in the Gulf of Kutch have not
received much attention in this regard. Hornell (1909) and Easwaran,
Narayanan & Michael (1969) concentrated mainly on the fishery
aspects and Gokhale, Easwaran & Narasimhan (1954) and Narayanan
& Michael (1968) dealt mainly with the dimensional relationships of
these bivalves. So much so, the biology in general, and the breeding
habits in particular, of the oysters of this locality have not been studied
by previous authors. This paper presents the preliminary observations
made on the breeding habits, with particular reference to the spawning
season of the pearl oysters of the Gulf of Kutch. The present studies
1 Accepted May 5, 1970.
2 Present Address : Marine Biological Research Station, Govt, of Gujarat,
Port Okha (India).
BREEDING OF PEARL OYSTERS
33
form a part of the scheme for research and investigation on the pearl
oysters of the Gulf of Kutch, implemented by the Directorate of
Fisheries, Government of Gujarat, through its Research Station at
Jamnagar.
I have, made a detailed study on the taxonomy of the Gulf of Kutch
pearl oysters and find them to be the typical Indian species referable
to Pinctada fucata (Gould, 1850: Proc. Boston. Soc. Nat. Hist. 3: 309-
312) [Syn. Pinctada vulgaris (Schumacher)], which nomenclature is
used in this paper. No other species of the Genus Pinctada (Bolten) has
been observed in the collections from this locality.
Materials and Methods
About five hundred oysters collected from the pearl oyster Khaddas
of the Gulf of Kutch and reared in a Sea Water Tank at Sikka
(Jamnagar District, Gujarat State) by the Fisheries Research Station,
Government of Gujarat, Jamnagar, constitute the material for the
present studies. Regular samples of living oysters were measured,
weighed and their gonads examined afresh every fortnight. Side by
side, the salinity and temperature of the sea water of the tank were
also recorded regularly.
As adopted by Gokhale et al. (1954) and Narayanan et al. (1968),
the thickness denotes the maximum distance between the external sur-
faces of two valves and hinge-width the maximum distance between
the edges of the two valves at the hinge. The whole-weight indicates
the weight of the animal inclusive of the valves and flesh-weight, the
weight of the body exclusive of the valves. (Special care has been taken
to see that the water particles are blotted out from the flesh to the
maximum possible extent and to obtain the accurate weight of the
flesh). The linear measurements, referred to above, were made with
a pair of Dial Calipers and represented in millimeters. The flesh and
whole weights were measured in a Chemical Balance and represented
in grammes.
For the sake of convenience, the gonads were classified into five
stages, basing on their stage of development, as follows:
Stage 0 : Resting /Immature Gonad
Stage I : Developing Gonad
Stage II : Ripe Gonad
Stage III : Running or Oozing Gonad
Stage IV : Spent Gonad
While classifying the gonads, as above, there were a few oysters
whose gonads could not be catagorised, as the gonad-development was
too obscure. Such gonads are indicated as ‘Un-identified Gonads’.
3
34 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Observations on the gonads and their contents were made from
fresh specimens only, so as to avoid any shrinkage of the tissue. Body
dimensions and stage of development of the gonads were recorded
against each specimen at regular intervals.
Observations
It has been observed, as a general rule, that a male gonad is creamy
white and the female gonad yellowish to dark-yellow in external ap-
pearence, when they are fully ripe. However, at times when the gonad
is infested by a trematode parasite1 — which is a very common pheno-
menon in the Gulf of Kutch oysters — the external coloration of the
gonads of either sex is pinkish-red.
The age at first maturity of these oysters has not been correctly
estimated so far. Tranter (1958a & 1958d) has observed that the
Australian pearl oysters, Pinctada albina (Lamarck) and Pinctada
margaritifera (Linnaeus) attain sexual maturity around the first year
of their life. Gokhale et al. (1954) contended that the Gulf of Kutch
oysters attain sexual maturity towards the third or fourth year. I do
not agree with their view, as on many occasions I have examined the
gonads of oysters of below one year, one year and two years and have
found them to be fully ripe. My observations reveal that, in general,
the Gulf of Kutch pearl oysters attain sexual maturity at a hinge-width
of 2 to 2.5 mm and a thickness of 18 to 22 mm. Narayanan et al.
(1968) have observed that the mean thickness and hinge- width of
these oysters at the end of the first year are 21.9 mm and 2.5 mm res-
pectively. This, therefore, should mean that the age at first maturity
of the pearl oysters of this locality cannot be more than one year.
Unfortunately, no definite conclusion can be arrived at in this regard
and the exact age at which these oysters attain sexual maturity cannot
be pin-pointed, as I have not examined sufficiently large number of
oysters of one year and below.
The percentage of sex of the pearl oysters of the Gulf of Mannar
has been estimated by Hornell (1916) as 55 males to 45 females.
Tranter (1958d) observed the proportion of sex of Pinctada margari-
tifera (Linnaeus) of the Australian waters as five males to every female.
In the Gulf of Kutch, however, the percentage of male and female
has been worked out as 35.5 and 64.5 respectively.
Tranter (1958c) observed that the ratio of sex decreases until in
old oysters the proportion is equal. According to him, such a pro-
nounced variation is the result of a sex-change within the population.
1 The taxonomy of these parasites has not been worked out as yet.
BREEDING OF PEARL OYSTERS
35
Ojima & Maeki (1955) noted bi-sexual nature in the gonads of
Pinctada martensii, but Herdman & Hornell (1903, 1904 & 1906)
though recognizing the possibility of a sex-change in oysters, stated
that their species ( Pinctada fucata) was permanently dioecious. Wada
(1938 & 1953) showed that Pinctada martensii and Pinctada maxima
experienced change of sex.
The possibility of such a change of sex in the Gulf of Kutch oys-
ters cannot altogether be ruled out as on many occasions my samples
consisted only of one sex. But the data in this connection is not suffi-
cient to substantiate this view. Also, it has not been possible for me to
observe the same stock of oysters over a long period.
Breeding Season
The stage of development of the gonads examined afresh was deter-
mined and the percentage of each stage of development was worked
out month-wise, as tabulated in Table 1.
As can be seen from the table, a great majority of the oysters were
found to be in the resting stage during the months of June, July and
August. In October, however, majority of the gonads were ripe and
in November and December, oozing (running) ones formed the major
percentage. In January and February, the spent gonads were more
than those of the other stages. In March, about a third of the oysters
were found to ripen again. In April, these were found to be in the
running (oozing) stage and in May most of them were either spent or
resting. These observations indicate that the actual or the primary
breeding season of the pearl oysters in the Gulf of Kutch is November,
December and January. This primary breeding season is followed, in
some cases, by a secondary one in April-May.
The observations made on the whole weight- flesh weight relation-
ship and other studies made on the seasonal variations in oysters also
support this view.
The mean percentage of the flesh- weight in the whole- weight of
the individual oysters were estimated monthwise and is shown in Fig.
1. As can be seen from the figure, the percentage of flesh-weight in
the whole-weight increases from November onwards and this increase
lasts up to February, after which the percentage falls. Again, from
March onwards up to May there is an increase in the percentage.
The percentage decreases in June, July, August and September. The
whole-weight of the oysters includes the shells also, but the flesh-
weight, on the other hand, indicates only the weight of the body with-
in the shells. Since during sexual development, the gonads extend to
almost all parts of the viscera, there are all possibilities of increase in
36 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
BREEDING OF PEARL OYSTERS
37
the weight of the body. Hence, the increase in the percentage of flesh-
weight in the whole-weight during the months of November- January
and March-May invariably indicates the excessive gonad development
and hence breeding season.
Fig. 1
Similarly, changes in the gonadial elements were also observed
during the breeding season. The average ova count per field and the
mean size of the ova were also found to increase corresponding to the
breeding peaks. These changes have been plotted in Fig. 1.
As observed by Easwaran et al. (1969), there are no heavy spat-
falls observed in the Gulf of Kutch, unlike in the Gulf of Mannar and
Palk Bay. However, I have collected a few three to four month-old
spats from the Pearl Oyster Reefs of Movada, during March-April,
1966. These spats, though scanty, do indicate that the oysters of the
Movada Reef had bred somewhere between November, 1965, and
January 1966.
Temperature and Salinity
Herdman & Hornell (1906), Hornell (1916) and Malpas (1929)
have estimated that the Ceylonese and South Indian pearl oysters breed
38 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
twice in a year, namely during the south-west monsoon and north-
east monsoon seasons. The present observations show that the pearl
oysters of the Gulf of Kutch also breed twice in a year; but the breed-
ing maxima do not tally with those in the Gulf of Mannar and Palk Bay.
This is probably because the hydrological conditions in the Gulf of
Kutch are entirely different from those in the Gulf of Mannar and
Palk Bay. Malpas (1929) believes that the changes in salinity and
temperature induce the pearl oysters to spawn. According to him, high
salinity in July- August and low salinity in December- January in the
southern waters both act as breeding 'stimuli.
The salinity and temperature of the Gulf of Kutch have been re-
corded regularly by the Fisheries Research Station, Jamnagar, and
are shown in Fig. 2. As can be seen from the figure, there is not much
appreciable variation in the salinity of the Gulf of Kutch waters. This
has been observed by Gokhale et at. (1954) also. The maximum
BREEDING OF PEARL OYSTERS
39
salinity observed is 39%0 in December and minimum 32.18%0 in
February-March. During the primary breeding season of the pearl
oysters of this locality, the salinity is the maximum (37 to 39%0) and
during the secondary breeding season, in April-May, the salinity is
minimum (32.18 to 31.8%0). Malpas’ (1929) contention that the
oysters get spawning stimulii from both high and low salinity may
appear to be quite true in regard to the pearl oysters of the Gulf of
Kutch. But, as Dewanesan & Chidambaram (1956) put it, it will not
be justifiable, though it cannot be proved with the information on
hand, to believe that an animal can respond to different stimulii in the
same manner.
Similarly, the contention that temperature variation too stimulates
the pearl oysters to breed cannot be agreed to, as the mean temperature
during the primary breeding season in December- January is 17.5 to
23.5°C and during the secondary breeding season, in April-May, the
temperature ranges between 30 to 31°C (Fig. 2).
Ack n o wledge m e n ts
I am grateful to the Directorate of Fisheries, Government of
Gujarat, Ahmedabad, for permission to publish this paper and to
Messrs. C. R. Easwaran and M. M. Chhaya for their encouragement.
Special thanks are due to Mrs. Sita Narayanan for her help in the
analysis of the data and preparation of this paper, to Shri. J. S. Joshi
for furnishing the hydrological data and to Shri. K. G. Dave for draw-
ing the figures.
References
Devanesan, D. W. & Chidam-
baram, K. (1956): Results obtained
at the Pearl-Oyster Farm, Krusadai
Island, Gulf of Mannar, and their
application to problems relating to
the pearl fisheries in the Gulf of
Mannar, Part-I. Contribution from
the Marine Fisheries Biological Sta-
tion, Krusadai Island, Gulf of Man-
nar, No. 4: 15-23.
Easwaran, C. R., Narayanan K. R.
& Michael, M. S. (1969) : Pearl
Fisheries of the Gulf of Kutch. J.
Bombay fiat. Hist. Soc. 66(2): 338-
344.
Gould, A. A. (1950) : Shells from
the United States Exploring Expedi-
tion. Proc. Boston. Soc. Nat. Hist.,
3: 309-312.
Gokhale, S. V., Easwaran C. R.
& Narasimhan, R. (1954): Growth
rate of the Pearl Oyster, Pinctada
pinctada, in the Gulf of Kutch, with
a note on the Pearl Fishery of 1953.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 52(1) :
124-136.
Herdman, W. A. (1903-06): Re-
port to the Government of Ceylon
on the Pearl Oyster Fisheries of the
Gulf of Mannar. Parts I-V. The
Royal Society, London.
40 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Herdman, W. A. & Hornell, J.
(1903) : Observations and experi-
ments on the life-history and habits
of the pearl oyster. Rep. Pearl Fish.
Mannar, 1 : 25-46.
(1904) : Anatomy
of the Pearl Oyster, ibid. 2: 37-76.
(1906): General
summary and recommendations : Re-
production and life history of the
pearl oyster, ibid. 5: 114-118.
Hornell, J. (1909): The Marine
Resources of Okhamandal. In : Re-
port to the Government of Baroda on
the Marine Zoology of Okhamandal
in Kattiawar, Part 1 : 1-17. Williams
and Norgate, London.
(1916) : An explanation
of the cyclic character of the pearl
fisheries of the Gulf of Mannar. Mad.
Fish. Bui. 8: 17-19.
(1922): The Indian
Pearl Fisheries of the Gulf of Man-
nar and Palk Bay. Mad. Fish. Bui
16: 115-128.
Malpas, A. H. (1929) : Age and
Growth rate of the pearl oyster in
the pearl fishery of 1925. Bull. Cey-
lon J. Sci. (C) 3: 62-74.
(1933) : Further obser-
vations on the age and growth rate
of the Ceylon pearl oyster. Margari-
iifera vulgaris, with special reference
to the oysters of Donnan’s Muthu-
varattu par. ibid. 5: 21-48.
Narayanan, K. R. & Michael,
M. S. (1968) : On the relation bet-
ween age and linear measurements of
the pearl oyster, Pinctada vulgaris
(Schumacher), of the Gulf of Kutch.
/. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 65(2):
444-452.
*Ojima, Y. & Maeki, K. (1955) :
Some cytological account of the ma-
turation of gonad in pearl oyster,
Pinctada martensii Dunker. Bull. Inst.
Sci. Res. Res. Pearls., Japan, No. 2.
Contrib. 41.
Tranter, D. J. (1958a): Repro-
duction in Australian pearl oysters
(Lamellibranchia) . Pinctada albina
(Lamarck) : Primary Gonad Develop-
ment. Aust. J. Mar. Fresh W. Res.
9: 135-143.
(1958b) : idem. II, Pinc-
tala albina (Lamarck) : Gametogen-
esis. ibid. 144-158.
(1958c): idem. Ill,
Pinctada albina (Lamarck) : Breed-
ing Season and Sexuality, ibid. 191-
216.
(1958d) : idem. IV,
Pinctada margaritifera (Linnaeus),
ibid. 509-525.
Wada, S. (1953) : Biology of the
Silver Lip pearl oyster, Pinctada ma-
xima Jameson: Breding Season. Mar-
garita 1: 28.
Not referred to in original.
Taxonomy and distribution of
Sardinella leiogaster
Valenciennes, 1847 [Pisces :
Clupeidae] from the Indian
Seas1
BY
A. G. K. Menon and P. K. Talwar
Zoological Survey of India, Calcutta-13
( With a text-figure)
Introduction
The Indo-Pacific representatives of the genus Sardinella Valen-
ciennes fall into two subgenera, Sardinella Valenciennes and Ambly-
gaster Bleeker distinguished, one from the other, by the degree of
compression in the ventral keel and scutes, and by marked differences
in the arrangement of the scales along the median line anterior to the
dorsal fin. The specific identity of S. ( Amblygaster) leiogaster Valen-
ciennes has been in great confusion, the species having either placed
in the synonymy of Sardinella sirrn (Walbaum) (by Regan 1917;
Fowler 1941; Misra 1947) or confused with Sardinella clupeoides
(Bleeker) (Bertin 1944). Recently Chan (1965), Whitehead, Boeseman
& Wheeler (1966), and Whitehead ( 1967a) revised systematics and
recognised Sardinella sirm (Walbaum), S. clupeoides (Bleeker) and
S. leiogaster Valenciennes as three distinct species under the subgenus
Amblygaster.
During a recent survey of the Andaman and Nicobar group of
Islands, as a part of a comprehensive programme of survey of the
ichthyo-fauna of these islands by the senior author, a specimen 242
mm in total length, of Sardinella leiogaster Valenciennes, hitherto not
recorded from Indian waters, was collected from the Car Nicobar
Accepted March 4, 1972.
42 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Island on 14th March, 1969. This species has so far been known to
occur from the East African coast, the Red Sea, Indian Ocean, Singa-
pore, the East Indies and the Philippines ( vide Whitehead 19676). It
is here recorded for the first time from the Indian waters. The specific
identity of earlier records (Day 1878; Homell 1917; Deraniyagala
1929, 1952; Munro 1955; Kuthalingam 1961) of the three species of
the subgenus Amblygaster from the Indian Seas are discussed.
Systematic Account
Sardinella (Amblygaster) leiogaster Valenciennes
Clupea caeruleo-vittata Richardson.2 1846, Ichth, China Japan, p. 305; White-
head, 1966, Bull. Br. Mas. nat. Hist. ( Zool .) 14(2) : 28.
Sardinella leiogaster Valenciennnes, 1847, Hist. nat. Poiss. 20:210 (Indian
Ocean); Kner, 1865, Reise Novara, Fische: 327; Chan, 1965, Jap. J.
Ichthyol. 72(3-6): 117, fig. 15; Whitehead, Boeseman & Wheeler, 1966,
Zool. Verhandl. Leiden 84:41 (Key); Whitehead, 1967, Bull. Br. Mus.
nat. Hist. (Zool.),: Suppl. 2: 68 (Redescription of type); Whitehead, 1967,
/. mar. biol. Ass. India 9(2) :235, fig. 13.
Clupea leiogaster Klunzinger, 1871, Verh. zool.-bot. Ges. Wien. 27:598.
Clupea (Amblygaster) leiogaster Bleeker. 1872, Atlas Ichthyol. Ind. Neerland.
6: 102; Weber and de Beaufort (partim), 1913, Fishes Indo-Australian
Archipelago 2:61; Deraniyagala, (partim), 1929, Spoilia Zeylanica 75:37.
Sardinella clupeoides Fowler (nee. Bleeker), 1941, Bull. U.S. nat. Mus. (100)
13 : 619.
Sardinella (Amblygaster) sirm Deraniyagala (nee. Walbaum) (partim), 1952,
Coloured Atlas of some Vertebrates from Ceylon 1 : 14.
Amblygaster clupeoides Munro, 1955, Marine and Fresh water fishes from
Ceylon : 26.
Sardinella ( Amblygaster ) leiogaster Val.
material:
1 ex., 210 mm in standard length; Teetop (Car Nicobar Island); 14th
2 putative nomen oblitum vide Whitehead, Bull. zool. Nomencl. 23 (pt. 1) :
62-64, 1966.
SARDINELLA LEIOG ASTER FROM INDIAN SEAS
43
March, 1969; Coll. P. K. Talwar; Zoological Survey of India, Reg. No.
F. 6168/2.
DESCRIPTION :
Br. St. VI, D IV 14, P i 16, V i 7, A iii 13.
Scales in the lateral series 42, 11 transverse.
Predorsal scales 14.
Abdominal scutes 16 + 12.
Gillrakers on first arch 17 + 1 + 35.
In percentages of standard length: body depth 22.8; head length
23.3; snout length 7.6, eye-diameter 6.0, length of upper jaw 8.0,
length of lower jaw 8.8, pectoral length 15.0, pelvic length 8.5, length
of anal fin base 11.9, pre-dorsal distance 51.4, pre-pelvic distance 51.4,
pre-anal distance 76.7.
Body oblong, elongated, sides slightly compressed; weakly keeled
medio-ventrally, with blunt scutes which are not prominent. Maxilla
not reaching to the vertical from anterior edge of eye; two supra-max-
illae, the second (posterior) almond-shaped but profiles of both por-
tions meeting the anterior shaft at about the same point as illustrated
by Whitehead (1967a, fig. la). Pseudobranch present, exposed, about
as long as eye-diameter; filaments long, ventral base crescentric and
without groove below it. Gillrakers rather short, slender, shorter than
the corresponding gill filaments. Cleithral lobe prominent. Fronto-
parietal region with 14 longitudinal striae. Teeth absent except for a
patch of minute, feeble teeth on tongue and palatines. Opercular bones,
postorbitals and suborbitals covered by translucent adipose tissue,
under which minute hollow venules spread downwards in a radiating
pattern.
Dorsal fin origin equidistant between snout tip and caudal base.
Pelvic fin base below first branched dorsal ray.
Scales cycloid, thin; deciduous. Predorsal median ridge before
dorsal fin covered by a single longitudinal series of scales. Scaly sheath
cover the bases of dorsal and anal fins. Elongated axillary scales in
angle of pectoral and pelvic fins. Alar scales present.
Colour in alcohol — Upper one-third slate-grey, flanks pale brownish;
tips of jaws dusky. Caudal slightly dusky.
Discussion
Our specimen agrees very well with the description; keys and
figures given by Chan (op. cit.), Whitehead, Boeseman & Wheeler
(1966), and Whitehead (op. cit.).
Day’s (1878, 1889) record of Clupea leiogaster (Val.) from Sri
44 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Lanka with the maxilla reaching to below front edge of eye and with
13-20 blue spots along the flanks, is evidently based on an erroneous
identity of Sardinella sirm (Walb.); there are no spots along the flanks
and the maxilla does not reach the vertical through the anterior edge
of eye in S. clupeoides and S. leiogaster, ( vide Chan, op. cit.; Whitehead
et al., op. cit.). Hornell (op. cit.) listed Clupea leiogaster (Val.) as one
of the principal food fishes caught off Tuticorin (south-east coast of
India) and based his identity on Day’s (1889) description of the
species which is here considered conspecific with Sardinella sirm.
Munro’s (1955:26) record of Amblygaster clupeoides (Blkr.) from
Sri Lanka with 17-22+32-33 gillrakers, is undoubtedly Sardinella leiogas-
ter Valenciennes as S. clupeoides (Blkr.) has a lower count (26-30 vs.
31-36) ( vide Whitehead et al., op. cit.). Deraniyagala (1929, 1952),
however, correctly reported S. clupeoides from Sri Lanka with 27-29
gillrakers but his S. sirm with 30-40 gillrakers is clearly a mixture of
both S. sirm and S. leiogaster. Kuthalingam’s (op. cit.) record of S.
clupeoides from Madras is erroneous as in no species of the subgenus
Amblygaster does the maxilla reach below the middle of the eye.
Hornell (op. cit. — as Clupea leiogaster ) and later Menon (1961)
recorded Sardinella sirm (Walb.), and Bonnet! (1965) reported Sardi-
nella clupeoides (Blkr.) for the first time from Indian waters. All the
three species of the subgenus Amblygaster, therefore, occur in the
Indian and Sri Lanka waters. A key to the field identification of the
three species of the subgenus Amblygaster is given below:
I. A series of 10-12 dark blue spots along flank; maxilla reaching vertical
from anterior eye border . . . . . . . . sirm (Walb.)
II. No series of spots on flanks; maxilla not reaching vertical from anterior
eye border.
a. Body moderately heavy; dorsal fin origin slightly nearer to tip
of snout than to caudal base; gillrakers 26-30 . .clupeoides (Blkr.)
b. Body slender, elongated; dorsal fin origin approximately equi-
distant between tip of snout and caudal base; gillrakers 31-36
leiogaster Val.
Summary
Sardinella (Amblygaster) leiogaster Valenciennes, belonging to the
family Clupeidae is recorded for the first time from Indian waters,
the earlier record by Hornell (1917) being due to mistaken identity.
The specific status of earlier records of the three species of the sub-
genus Amblygaster, which was in great confusion until Chan (1965),
Whitehead, et al. (1966) and Whitehead (1966) revised the systematics,
from the Indian Seas has been cleared and the distributional limits
discussed.
SARDINELLA LEIOG ASTER FROM INDIAN SEAS
45
Ack n o wledge m e n t
We are grateful to Dr. P. J. P. Whitehead, British Museum (Nat-
ural History), London for kindly confirming the identification of our
specimen.
References
Bennett, P. S. (1965) : On Sardi-
nella clupeoides (Bleeker) from the
coasts of India. J. mar. biol. Ass.
India 7(1): 208-210.
Bertin, L. (1944) : Mise au point
sur quelques especes de clupeides.
Bull. Soc. zool. France 66: 18-25.
Chan, W. L. (1965): A systematic
revision of the Indo-Pacific clupeoid
fishes of the genus Sardinella (family
Clupeidae). Jap. Jour. Ichthyol. 12(3-
6): 104-118; ibid. 73(1-3) : 1-39.
Day, F. (1878): The Fishes of
India. Vol. I. Williams & Norgate,
London, pp. 778.
(1889): The fauna of
British India, including Ceylon and
Burma. Fishes. Vol. I. Taylor &
Francis, London, pp. 548.
Deraniyagala, P. E. P. (1929):
Ceylon Sardines. Spoilia Zeylanica
15: 31-48.
(1952): A colour-
ed atlas of some Vertebrates from
Ceylon. Vol. I. Fishes. Ceylon Na-
tional Museum, Colombo, pp. 149. 34
coloured plates.
Fowler, H. W. (1941): Contribu-
tions to the biology of the Philippine
Archipelago and adjacent regions.
Bull. U. S. nat. Mus. (100) 13: 1-879.
Hornell, J. (1917): A statistical
analysis of the fishing industry of
Tuticorin (South India). Madras Fish.
Bull. 11(2): 67-118.
Kuthalingam, M. D. K. (1961) :
Observations on the feeding habits of
some Sardines together with the key
to the identification of the young
ones of the genus Sardinella. Rec. In-
dian Mus. 59: 455-469.
Menon, A. G. K. (1961): On a
collection of fish from the Coroman-
del Coast of India including Pondi-
cherry and Karaikkal areas. Rec. In-
dian Mus. 59 : 369-404.
Misra, K. S. (1947): A check-list
of the fishes of India, Burma and
Ceylon. II Clupeiformes, Bathyclupei-
formes, Galaxiiformes, Scopeliformes
and Ateleopiformes. Rec. Indian Mus.
45: 377-431.
Munro, I. S. R. (1955): The ma-
rine and fresh water fishes of Ceylon.
Canberra. 350 p. + 56 pis.
Regan, C. T. (1917): A revision
of the clupeoid fishes of the genera
Sardinella, Harengula, etc. Ann. Mag.
nat. Hist. (8) 19: 377-395.
Whitehead, P. J. P. (1967a) : The
clupeoid fishes described by Lacepede,
Cuvier & Valenciennes. Bull. Br. Mus.
nat. Hist. (Zool.) Suppl. 2: 1-178.
(1967b): The clu-
peoid fishes of Malaya. J. mar. biol.
Ass. India 9(2): 223-280.
, Boeseman, M. &
Wheeler, A. (1966): The types of
Bleeker’s Indo-Pacific clupoid and
clupeoid species. Zool. Verhandl.
Leiden 84: 1-152.
A new Copepod from Ratnagiri
BY
M. R. Ranade
Marine Biological Research Station, Ratnagiri
( With twelve figures in three plates )
In the month of January 1962, a number of copepods were
collected from the mantle cavity of Solen kempi Preston, from the sandy
beaches of Purangad, ten miles south of Ratnagiri. On a closer exami-
nation of the material, it was found that the copepods were not des-
cribed previously. This was also confirmed by Dr. J. H. Stock, who
kindly examined the specimens and offered great help in the prepara-
tion of this account.
Leptinogaster stocki sp. nov.
Material and types:
Several ovigerous females and adult males were collected from the
mantle of Solen kempi -from Purangad near Ratnagiri. (Type to be
incorporated later).
The specific name stocki is proposed in honour of Dr. J. H.
Stock of Zoologisch Museum, Amsterdam (Netherlands).
Description of the adult female:
Body cyclopoid ,somewhat flattened (Fig. 1). Length of the body
excluding the caudal seta 3.0 mm, width 1.0 mm. The prosome equals
the length of urosome and is four segmented. The first prosomal seg-
ment is larger and nearly equals the length of the remaining three seg-
ments. It is slightly wider than long and the length-breadth proportion
is 45:55. Rostrum is distinct and triangular in shape. The cephalosome
is ovoid anteriorly whereas the posterior end is almost straight. The
remaining four pedigerous segments become, successively narrower
and are separated by deep incisions. There is a wide gap between the
segments bearing fourth and fifth pairs of legs. The urosome is five
segmented and bears the reduced fifth pair of legs on its first segment,
which is the widest. The genital segment is longer than wide. The re-
maining three segments are shorter than the genital segment. All the
urosome segments become successively narrower. The last three seg-
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (1)
Ranade: Leptinogaster stocki sp. nov.
Leptinogaster stocki sp. nov.
Fig. 1. Adult female (x 75), dorsal view. Fig. 12. Adult male (x 75), dorsal view.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (1) Plate II
Ranade: Leptinogaster stocki sp. nov.
Leptinogaster stocki sp. nov.
Adult female. Fig. 2. First antenna (x 400) ; Fig. 3. Second antenna (x 400) ;
Fig. 4. Mandible (x 400); Fig. 5. Maxillule (x 400); Fig. 6. Moxilla; Fig. 11.
Fifth leg. Adult male. Fig. 13. Maxilliped (x 400).
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (1)
Ranade: Leptinogaster stocki sp. nov.
Plate III
Leptinogaster stocki sp. nov.
Adult female. Fig. 7. First leg (x 400); Fig. 8. Second leg (x 400); Fig. 9.
Third leg (x 400); Fig. 10. Fourth leg (x 240).
A NEW COPEPOD FROM RAT NAG I Rl
47
ments are also longer than wide and the last abdominal segment bears
posteriorly two slender caudal rami. The caudal rami are slightly longer
than the last abdominal segment. The caudal ramus is elongate and
slender and bears a lateral seta, a little less than half way along its outer
edge, a subterminal outer seta and three terminal setae, the middle
one being the longest. There is a slender seta present on the middle
distal position of the ramus. There is a group of spinules on the outer
edge near the base of the ramus.
The first antenna (Fig. 2) is six jointed, the first segment the
smallest and the second the longest. There are several setae on the
segments as shown in the figure.
The second antenna (Fig. 3) is four jointed, the first segment with
a seta at the distal end, the second segment bears a seta and group of
spinules at the inner anterior end. The third segment with a row of
spinules on the inner side and two recurved spines, one short and
another stout, at the distal anterior end. The fourth segment is quadrate
bearing three long setae and one short seta.
The mandible (Fig. 4) consists of a single segment and bears at the
terminal end a spine, a plumose seta and a unilaterally serrated spine.
The maxillule (Fig. 5) is unsegmented, quadrate, bearing four setae,
two distal and one on either side.
The maxilla (Fig. 6) has a broad basal segment with row of spin-
ules at the posterior end and a large recurved stout spine with a small
seta at the base.
The maxillipeds are absent.
Rami of the legs 1-4, three segmented with spines and setal formula
as follows:
Leg 1. (fig. 7):- Coxopodite with a row of spines at the outer angle.
Basipodite with an inner spine and an outer seta. There is a row of
small spines at the base of the inner spine. The terminal segment of
the exopod with four spines and four setae. The last endopodite seg-
ment bears three spines and three setae.
Leg 2 (Fig. 8):- The coxopodite with a group of spines at the outer
angle. The basipodite with a seta on the outer edge and a row of spines
terminally. Last exopodite segment with four spines and five setae
instead of four as in 1st leg.. The last endopod segment with three
spines and three setae.
Leg 3 (Fig. 9):- The basipodite with a seta on the outer edge and a
row of spinules on the inner edge. The second segment of the endopod
48 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
bears two setae and the last has three spines and three setae. The last
exopodite segment bears four spines and five setae.
Leg 4 (Fig. 10):- Leg four is similar to leg three except that the last
segment of the endopod bears three spines and two setae instead of
three as in leg three. The last exopodite segment bears four spines and
four setae instead of five as in leg three.
Leg 5 (Fig. 11):- Consists of two segments the first bearing on its
outer edge a single long and slender seta and a row of spinules at the
base of it. The second segment is more elongated than the first and
bears on the outer edge a seta with a group of spinules at its base and
two terminal seta and a stout slightly curved spine with spinules at
their basis. There are two rows of spinules on the inner edge of the
second segment.
Description of the adult male :
Body form (Fig. 12) as in the female. Length of the body exclud-
ing the caudal setae 2.60 mm greatest with 0.75 mm. The urosome
six segmented. The genital segment slightly wider than long and is
oval in shape. The next two segments are each as long as the genital
segment and the last two slightly smaller in length. The genital seg-
ment bears on either side two elongated setae at the postero-lateral
angles. There is a row of spines at the base of the seta.
The first antenna, second antenna, mandible, maxillule and the
maxilla as in the case of female. The maxilliped (Fig. 13) four jointed,
the first segment without any seta. The second also without a seta but
having rows of spines on the inner side which is considerably elevated,
the third segment very short and the fourth a long terminal claw bear-
ing a single inner seta.
Spine and setal formula of legs 1-4 as in female Leg 5 similar to
that of female except instead of two rows of spinules on the inner
edge of the second segment there are two patches of spinules on the
same side.
Remarks :
The genus Leptinogaster was created by Pelseneer ( 1928) 1 to
accommodate the species pholadis. The number of species so far re-
corded under the genus Leptinogaster Pelseneer is as follows:
1) Leptinogaster pholadis Pelseneer
2) Leptinogaster histrio (Pelseneer)
3) Leptinogaster major (Williams)
4) Leptinogaster inf lata (Allen)
1 Pelseneer, P. (1928): Copepods parasites de Mollusques. Ann. Soc. Rav.
zool. Belg. 59: 33-49.
A NEW COPEPOD FROM RAT NAG I Rl
49
5) Leptinogaster scobina (Humes & Cressy)
6) Leptinogaster dentata (Humes & Cressy)
Leptinogaster stocki differs from L. inflata and L. histrio in not
having an inflated metasome in the adult females. It differs from L.
pholadis in having two spines on the third segment of the second an-
tenna instead of one and in the different shape of the second segment
of the male maxilliped. It differs from L. major in the less elongate
fifth leg in female and different position of the outer edge spine on
the second segment of the fifth leg. It differs from L. scobina and L.
dentata in having spines and setae on the terminal segment of the
exopod of the fourth leg instead of six. Apart from these, the species
differs from all other species in having two setae instead of one on the
second endopod segment of the fourth leg.
The genus Leptinogaster Pelseneer is being recorded in Indian
waters for the first time. After the key given by Bocquet & Stock
( 1958) 1 three more species have been added under the genus Lepti-
nogaster Pelseneer and therefore an up-to-date key for the identifica-
tion of all the species is given below:
Key to the identification of species of Leptinogaster Pelseneer based on
female specimens
1 Metasome in the adult female inflated 3
2 Metasome in the adult female not inflated 5
3 Caudal rami longer than the anal segment L. inflata (Allen)
4 Caudal rami shorter than the anal segment. .L. histrio (Pelseneer)
5 Second endopod segment of the 4th leg with one seta 7
6 Second endopod segment of the 4th leg with two setae
L. stocki sp. nov.
7 Third segment of the second antenna with two spines 9
8 Third segment of the second antenna with one spine
L. pholadis (Pelseneer)
9 Terminal segment of the exopod of the 4th leg with 6 spines and
setae 11
10 Terminal segment of the exopod of the 4th leg with 8 spines and
setae L. major (Williams)
11 Spines on the 3rd segment of the 2nd antenna claw like
L . dentata (Humes & Cressy)
12 Spines on the 3rd segment of the 2nd antenna not claw like
L. scobina (Humes & Cressy)
1 Bocquet, C. & Stock J. H. (1958): Copepodes parasites d’invertebres des
cotes da la Manche. IV Sur lestrois genres synonymes de copepodes cyclopoider,
Leptinogaster Pelseneer, Strongylo pleura Pelseneer, et Myocheres Wilson (Clau-
sidiae). Arch. Zoo]. Exp. Gen. 96:71-79,
4
50 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Acknowledgements
I wish to express my sincere thanks to Dr. J. H. Stock for kindly
confirming the identity of the new species. I am grately indebted to
Dr. C. V. Kulkarni for encouragement and to Dr. H. G. Kewalramani
for going through the manuscript and making helpful suggestions. My
sincere thanks are also due, to Shri. K. A. Narasimham who kindly
placed the copepods collected by him at my disposal.
Records and observations on
bats of Himalayan region of
Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal,
India
BY
H. R. Bhat
Virus Research Centre, Indian Council of Medical Research, Poona,
India
During a survey of haematophagous arthropods in the Hima-
layan region of Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal between November
1966 and August 1970, 362 specimens of bats were collected for
ectoparasitic search. These specimens represent 15 genera and 20
species. Additional geographical and ecological ranges for some
species are recorded. Notes on distribution, reproduction and
general natural history are presented for some of the species.
This paper presents data on bats collected in the Himalayan region
of Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal by me intermittently between Nov-
ember 1966 and August 1970 during a haematophagous arthropod
survey. A total number of 362 specimens representing 15 genera and
20 species was collected. This included 14 of the 26 species recorded
from this area in the Checklist by Ellerman & Morrison-Scott (1951),
two species recorded later on (Bhat, 1967, 1968) and 4 additional
species. Representative specimens of each species are preserved either
as dry skins and skulls or as wet specimens in formalin.
Additional notes on distribution, reproduction and general natural
history are given for some of the species.
Collection Localities
Brief description of the collection localities are given below. The
altitudes in many instances are approximate. The area has diverse
1 Accepted May 15, 1972,
52 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
geographical and ecological features represented by tropical, subtro-
pical temperate and alpine zones.
Uttar Pradesh:
District: naini tal : - 1) Bilaspur near Bhim Tal (1380 m), sub-
tropical zone; 2) Dugada (680 m), Balya valley, tropical zone; 3)
Garjia (460 m), Kosi valley, tropical zone; 4) Haldwani (430 m),
below foot hills in Bhabar, tropical zone; 5) Ramnagar (350 m), be-
low foot hills in Bhabar, Kosi valley, tropical zone; 6) Rani bag (620
m), Balya valley, tropical zone.
District: almora:- 7) Arey (770 m), near Bageshwar, Sarju valley,
tropical zone; 8) Bageshwar (770 m), Sarju valley, tropical zone; 9)
C halt hi (620 m), Ladhiya valley, tropical zone; 10) Dhakuri (2620
m), western slope of the Dhakuri Binayak range, Pindar valley, upper
temperate zone; 11) Dwali (2770 m), Pindar valley, temperate
zone; 12) Kapkot (1140 m), Sarju valley, subtropical zone; 13) Katai-
thbara (770 m), near Bageshwar; 14) Katarmal (1380 m), near
Almora, Kosi valley, lower temperate zone; 15) Khati (2300 m),
Pindar valley, upper temperate zone; 16) Loharkhet (1960 m), Sarju
valley, temperate zone; 17) Phaltaniya (770 m), near Bageshwar; 18)
Sukhidhang (1380 m), lower temperate zone.
District: pithoragarh : - 19) Aat (920 m), near Thai, Ramganga
valley, subtropical zone; 20) Dharchula (920 m). Kali valley, sub-
tropical zone; 21) Dummer (1540 m), Gori valley, temperate zone;
22) Girgaon (2000 m), on southern face of Kalamundi ridge, tem-
perate zone; 23) Khela (1540 m), near Tawaghat, lower temperate
zone; 24) Kotera (920 m), near Dharchula, subtropical zone; 25)
Kuity (1380 m), near Tejam, subtropical zone; 26) Lilam (2000 m),
Gori valley, temperate zone; 27) Martoli (3380 m), Gori valley,
alpine zone; 28) Milam (3540 m), Gori valley, alpine zone; 29) Patet
(920 m), near Thai, Ramganga valley, subtropical zone; 30) Tawaghat
(1140 m), Dhauli valley, subtropical zone; 31) Tejam (1080 m), Ram-
ganga valley, subtropical zone; 32) Thai (920 m), Ramganga valley,
subtropical zone.
District: pauri:- 33) Dalmisain (610 m), Kho valley, tropical
zone; 34) Dungripanth (610 m), Alakananda valley, tropical zone;
35) Narkota (610 m), Alakananda valley, tropical zone; 36) Raitoli
(610 m), Alakananda valley, tropical zone; 37) Srinagar (550 m),
Alakananda valley, tropical zone.
District: chamoli:- 38) Didoli (770 m), near Sonia, Alakananda
valley, subtropical zone; 39) Dogalbita (2370 m), Nagnath hill range,
temperate zone; 40) Guliyo (1230 m), near Gopeshwar, subtropical
zone; 41) Gwaldam (200 m), Pindar valley, temperate zone.
District: tehri:- 42) Ghonti (920 m), Bhillangana valley, sub-
BATS OF HIMALAYAN REGION
53
tropical zone.
District: dehra dun:- 43) Dehra Dun (610 m), tropical zone;
44) Ramgarh (600 m), tropical zone; 45) Sahasradhara (770 m), tro-
pical zone; 46) Sahaspur (600 m), tropical zone; 47) Satyanarayan
(340 m), tropical zone.
West Bengal:
District: Darjeeling:- 48) Tashiding (550 m), Tista river valley,
tropical zone.
District: jalpaiguri:- 49) Chunabhatti (200 m), Lish river basin,
tropical zone.
In addition to these localities attempts had been made to collect
bats at a number of other localities, but with negative results.
Records and notes on Species
i
Rousettus leschenaulfi Desmarest, 1820
(Fulvous Fruit Bat)
Specimens collected : Total 74 (45 21 $9,2 sex unrecorded). 2 SS,
3 $ $ (1 juvenile), Dungripanth, 18 May ’67; 1 s 1 sex unrecorded, Narkota, each
on 20 and 21 May ’67; 2 SS, 1 9, Raitoli, 23 May ’67: 5 SS, Dugada, 8
Sept. ’67; 1 cT, 1 9, Patet, 11 Sept. ’67; 5 SS, Tejam 13 Sept. ’67; 6 S S', 9
9 $, Kapkot, 30 Sept. ’67; 1 $ (juvenile), Srinagar, 24 Oct. ’67; 1 $, Sahasra-
dhara, 31 Oct. ’67; 4 SS, Dalmisain, 12 Nov. ’67; 2 SS, Phaltaniya, 6 May
’68; 2 SS, Kataithbara, 7 May ’68; 2 $ $, Kataithbara, 8 May ’68; 1 S, 2 $ $,
Thai, 5 Aug. ’70; 12 SS, 3 9 9, Thai, 7 Aug. ’70; 2 tfc?, 4 99, 1 baby, Aat
9 Aug. ’70.
Notes'. Specimens were collected in mist nets set between fruit
trees, mainly bananas, near the cultivations in tropical and subtropical
zones. Two juveniles were collected, one each in May and October.
A female collected in August was carrying a baby with eyes not yet
opened. The findings indicate the possibility of two breeding seasons
for the species in the present area, one each in March and August, as
recorded by Brosset (1962) in Western India.
Cynopterus sphinx Vahl, 1797
(Short-nosed Fruit Bat)
Specimens collected : Total 103 (45 SS, 51 99 and 1 sex unrecorded).
2$$, Dugada, 25 Feb. ’67; 1 cT, 2 9. 9, Dugada, 26 Feb. ’67; 1 sex not re-
corded, Chalthi, 6 Mar. ’67; 2 SS, ^ 9, Dharchula, 17 Mar. ’67; 1 3 99,
Dharchula, 18 Mar. ’67; 1 S', Kotera, 19 Mar. ’67; 1 2 99, Kataithbara,
23 Mar. ’67; 2 $ 9, Arey, 24 Mar. ’67; 4 SS, 3 S S, Dugada, 8 Sept. ’67;
1 9, Tejam, 13 Sept. ’67; 1 S, Dehra Dun, 28 Oct. ’67; 1 9, Ramgarh, 29
Oct. ’67; 1 9, Dalmisain, 12 Nov. ’67; 2 SS, 2 9 $, Dalmisain, 13 Nov. ’67; 2
SS, 1 9, Garjia, one each on 16, 18 and 19 Nov. ’67; 1 s, 3 99, Bilaspur
54 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (1)
23 Nov. ’67; 7 c?c?, 3 $ $ and 1 $, Dugada, respectively on 28 and 29 Nov. ’67;
2 Q $, Sahaspur, 2 Apr. ’68; 1 d% 1 9 . Didoli, 24 Apr. ’68; 1 <?, 4 9 9,
Dugada, 3 May ’68; 2 c?c?, 1 9, Bageshwar, 5 Mar. ’68; 5 cf d71 , 7 99,
Tashiding, between 17 and 19 Mar. ’69; 10 c?c?, 13 9 9, Chunabhatti, between 24
and 28 Mar. ’69; 2 c?c?, 1 9, Dugada, 2 May ’69; and 1 c?, Thai, 5 Aug. ’70.
Notes: Collected in mist nets set between fruit trees, mainly bana-
nas, near cultivation in tropical and subtropical zones.
Sphaerias blanfordi Thomas, 1891
(Blandford’s Fruit Bat)
Specimens collected : Total 40 (21 c?c?, 17 9 9,2 babies and 1 sex unre-
corded) in addition to 51 specimens already reported (Bhat 1968). 1 c?, 1 9,
Sukhidhang, 4 Mar. ’67; 1 sex not reeorded, Dharchula, 17 Mar. ’67; 1 baby
born in mist net, mother already recorded (Bhat 1968), Dummer, 25 Sept ’67;
1 9 plus baby and 3 99, Khela, respectively on 14 and 15 May ’68; 1 9,
Tawaghat, 16 May ’68; 8 c?c? and 2 9 9,4 c?c?, and 2 9 9, 2 c?c? and
3 9 9, 4 c?c? and 19,1c? and 1 9,1c? and 1 9, Dogalbita, respectively
on 10 and 11 May ’69, and 8, 9, 11, and 12 July ’70.
Notes: Collected in mist nets set between fruit trees (mainly bana-
nas) near cultivation and forests in subtropical and temperate zones.
The presence of a baby and juveniles in September indicates .the
month being breeding period. Collection of one baby in May and a
number of young males in July at Dogalbita indicates a possibility of
having a second breeding season in May.
Econycferis spelaea (Dobson, 1871)
(Dobson’s Long-tongued Fruit Bat)
Specimens collected : Only one young male was collected from Thai on 5
May ’70, since the species was first recorded in the area on the basis of 7 speci-
mens (Bhat 1967).
Notes'. Collected in mist net set between banana trees near culti-
vation in tropical and subtropical zones.
Megaderma spasma Linnaeus, 1758
(Malay False Vampire)
Specimen collected :1c?, Chunabhatti, 28 Mar. ’69.
Notes: Collected in mist net set near the Bungalow. Recorded from
this part of country for the first time.
Megaderma lyra Geoff roy, 1810
(Indian False Vampire)
Specimens collected : 2 c?c?, 1 9, Ranibag, respectively on 26 and 27
Aug. ’70.
Notes : These specimens were trapped at 19.30 hrs. in mist nets set
at Dak Bungalow.
BATS OF HIMALAYAN REGION
55
Rhinolophus femimequunim Schreber, 1774
(Greater Horseshoe Bat)
Specimen collected : 1 $, Katarmal, 19 Aug. ’70.
Notes: Trapped at 19.15 hrs. in mist net set on the door of an an-
cient sun-temple. The temple dome was used by the species as day
roost along with Hipposideros armiger.
Rhinolophus affinis Horsfield, 1823
Specimen collected'. 1 S, Bilaspur, 21 Apr. ’67.
Notes: Trapped in mist net set between fruit trees.
Rhinolophus rouxi Temminck, 1835
Specimen collected: 1 9, Tashiding, 18 Mar. ’69.
Notes: Trapped in mist net set between banana trees.
Rhinolophus pearsoni Horsfield, 1851
Specimen collected". 1 S, Narkota, 20 May ’67.
Notes: Trapped in mist net set between banana trees.
Hipposideros armiger Hodgson, 1831
(Great Himalayan Leaf-nosed Bat)
Specimens collected : 3 SS, 4 $ 9, Katarmal, 1 9 on 18 and rest on 19
Aug. ’70.
Notes: 1 c? and 2 9 9 specimens were collected in mist nets set
along verandah of Dak Bungalow. The bats got trapped at 19.30 hrs.„
while entering the verandah which was being used as night roost. 2^ c?
and 2 9 9 were trapped in mist nets on the door of the temple. The
temple was being used as day roost along with Rh. ferrumequinum.
Myotis siligorensis Horsfield, 1855
Specimens collected: Total 22 (6 SS and 16 99). 3 d’o1, 6 9 9, Dwali,
2 SS and 5 99, and 1 S' and 1 9 respectively on 4 and 5 Oct. *67; 2 SS,
10 99, Dogalbita, 2 SS and 999, and 1 9 respectively on 10 and 11 May
’69; and 1 & on 12 Jul. ’70.
Notes’. At both the places the species was using roof crevices as
day roost. The specimens were collected by trapping in mist nets while
they were emerging at dusk. They were also seen while returning to
the roost in the morning about 30 minutes before sunrise.
Myotis myotis dobsoni Trouessart, 1878
(Large Mouse-eared Bat)
Specimen collected : 1 S, Katarmal, 18 Oct. ’70.
Notes'. Trapped in mist net while hunting near a Bungalow.
56 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
The specimens perfectly fits with the description of Vesper tilio
murinus of Blanford (1891) which is a synonym of Myotis myotis
Borkhausen, 1797, according to Ellerman & Morrison-Scott (1951).
Tate (1947) considers Vespertilio dobsoni Trouessart, 1878 ( Vespertilio
murinoides Dobson, 1873 and V. blythi of Wroughton) as a subspecies
of Myotis myotis occurring in Himalayas. The identity of the specimen
is based on the above reasons. The species is now recorded for the
first time from Kumaon.
Nyctalus leisleri montamis Barret Hamilton, 1906
(Hairy-armed* Bat)
Specimens collected : Total 2. 1 9 , Dogalbita, 8 Jul. ’70; 1 9 , Katarmal,
18 Aug. *70.
Notes : Trapped in mist nets set in Bungalow premises.
Nyctalus noctula labiatus Hodgson, 1835
(Common Noctule)
Specimen collected : 1 Gwaldam, 13 Apr. ’67.
Notes : Collected in mist net set in forest. The species has been
known to occur in the adjacent areas. Recorded for the first time in the
area.
Pipistrellus niimus minuis Wroughton, 1899
(Indian Pigmy Pipistrelle)
Specimens collected : Toatl 21 (6 and 15 9 9). 3 c? cf, 13 99, Hald-
wani, 1 c? and 9 9 $ and 2 and 4 9 9 respectively on 27 and 28 Nov.
’67; 3 cfc?, 2 99, Satyanarayan, one each on 29 Jun. and 2 to 5 Jul. ’70.
Notes : All the specimens were collected either by pulling them out
with forceps from wall crevices or in mist nets at dusk while emerg-
ing from their day roosts in the roof crevices. Both the collections are
from the tropical zone.
Pipistrellus babu Thomas, 1915
Specimens collected : Total 5 (1 d1 and 4 9 9)- 1 cf, Sukhidhang, 2 Mar.
’67; 1 9, Srinagar, 24 Oct. ’67; 3 9 9, Ghonti, 16 Jan. ’70.
Notes : Collected in mist nets set in Bungalow premises at dusk.
Appears to be distributed in tropical, subtropical and lower temperate
zones.
Barbastella leuconielas darjelingensis Hodgson, 1855
Specimen collected :1c?1, Kapkot, 30 Sept. ’67.
Notes : Trapped in mist net set in wooded bungalow premises. The
species has been known to occur in the neighbouring areas, but is
recorded in the present area for the first time.
BATS OF HIMALAYAN REGION
57
Scotophilus heathi Horsfield, 1831
(Greater Yellow Bat)
Specimens collected : Total 15 (7 cPtf and 8 99). 2 d'd', 3 9 9> Hald-
wani, 2 9 9 and 1 & respectively on 28 and 30 Nov. ’67; 1 cf and 1 9 on
May ’68. 5 d'd', 5 9 9, Ramnagar; 5 tfc? and 2 9 9,2 9 $ and 1 9 respec-
tively on 28, 29 and 30 Aug. ’70.
Notes : Trapped in mist nets set in wooded premises of Bungalows
while the bats were hunting. The species was found actively hunting
within 10 feet from the ground between 19.00 to 20.00 hrs. Never met
with in the hills.
Plecotus auritus homochrous Hodgson, 1847
(Long-eared Bat)
Specimens collected'. Total 3. 1 9, Martoli, 18 Sept. ’67; 2 c?d% Milam,
one each on 29 and 30 May ’68.
Notes : Specimen from Martoli was caught flying inside a deserted
building and those from Milam in mist nets set in the open ground. A
number of specimens were observed emerging from the crevices of
slate-roofs just after dusk. Never encountered in lower elevations.
Ack n o wledge m e n ts
I am grateful to Dr. T. Ramachandra Rao, former Director, Virus
Research Centre, Poona, under whose supervision the work has been
carried out. The material was collected under a scheme for the survey
of haematophagous arthropods in the mountainous regions of India,
financed by the Indian Council of Medical Research. The Assistance
rendered by the Armed Forces Medical Services during the collection
trips is gratefully acknowledged.
References
Bhat, H. R. (1967): Dobson’s
Long-tongued fruit bat, Eonycteris
spelaea (Dobson), from Kumaon hills,
U.P. An addition to the Chiropteran
fauna of India. J. Bombay nat. Hist.
Soc. 64(3) : 550-551.
(1968) : Sphaerias
blanfordi (Thomas, 1891) from Him-
alayan region of Uttar Pradesh: An
addition to the Chiropteran fauna of
India, ibid. 65(2) :471-473.
Blanford, W. T. (1891): The
fauna of British India, including Cey-
lon and Burma, Mammalia, Vol. 2,
Taylor & Francis, London.
Brosset, A. (1962): The bats of
Western and Central India. Part I. J.
Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 59(1): 1-58.
Ellerman, J. R. & Morrison-
Scott, T. C. S. (1951): Checklist of
Palaearctic and Indian Mammals,
1758 to 1946. British Museum (Natu-
ral History), London: 810.
Tate, G. H. H. (1947): Mammals
of Eastern Asia, Macmillan, New
York: 366.
Additions to the Flora of
North Gujarat (Ahmedabad-
Mehsana-Sabarkantha
Districts)1"2
BY
G. L. Shah and D. V. Yogi
Department of Botany, Sardar Patel University, Vallabh Vidyanagar,
Gujarat
Several papers have been published on the flora of some parts of
south and central Gujarat and Saurashtra. However, the information,
available on the flora of north Gujarat through the works of Saxton &
Sedgwick (1918), Saxton (1922) and C. K. Shah (1963), remains in-
complete as many of the areas within the limits of north Gujarat are
not yet botanical explored. Hence it was thought desirable to explore
botanicaljy as many areas of Mehsana and Sabarkantha districts as
possible with a view to fill this lacuna. The present study was confined
to Mansa, Mahudi, Lakroda, Pahada and Keshni in Mehsana district
and Himatnagar, Idar, Khedbrahama, Vireshwar, Sarneshwar and
Vijaynagar in Sabarkantha district. During the course of the intensive
explorations of these areas from 1965 onwards, extensive collections were
made. The total number of species so far reported from north Gujarat
(excluding Lunawada which did not fall within the limits of north
Gujarat even at the time of Saxton and Sedgwick) is 672 to which 8
cyperaceae have been added by C. K. Shah (1963). Almost all the
plants listed by earlier workers have been collected by us. In addition,
there are about 200 species in our collections, which are reported here
for the first time from north Gujarat.3 In the list cultivated plants are
omitted unless they are naturalised or escapes.
Geographically Mahudi, Pahada and Lakroda are on the banks of
river Sabarmati, Keshni on the bank of river Khari, whereas Himat-
nagar and Khedbrahama are situated on the banks of rivers Hathmati
1 Accepted October 24, 1970.
2 Based on the Ph.D. Thesis accepted by Sardar Patel University.
3 Bhatt et al. (Bull. Bot. Surv. Ind. 11: 311-321), published (1972) since
this paper was prepared lists some of the species recorded by us — gls.
ADDITIONS TO THE FLORA OF NORTH GUJARAT
50
and Harnav respectively. All the explored areas are well knit by State
Transport Buses from Ahmedabad, plying at all seasons. Ahmedabad-
Khedbrahama railway line also connects Ahmedabad, Himatnagar,
Idar and Khedbrahama.
Total number of species now known from north Gujarat is nearly
880, indicating that the flora is quite rich. However, the vegetation of
the areas explored is predominantly a scrub forest type but that of
Vireshwar and Sarneshwar is a dry deciduous type with Butea-Alan-
gium community as dominant. The forests in these areas are dense
but Tectona grandis Linn. f. and Terminalia crenulata Roth are rather
occasional.
For the details of nomenclature Santapau & Janardhanan (1967),
Rau (1969) and Shah (1969) may be consulted. The species prefixed
by an asterisk are not given in Cooke’s Flora (1901-08).
Though we have collected plants from Mehsana and Sabarkantha
districts, Ahmedabad district is also included in the title as there are
some plants in the list from Ahmedabad, collected by Saxton and/or
Sedgwick, but not listed by them. Further all the districts are adjacent.
LIST OF PLANTS
FU MARI ACE AE
Fumaria indica Pugsley
Papaveraceae
Papaver somniferum Linn.
Brassicaceae (Cruciferae)
Brassica campestris Linn. var.
sarson Prain
Lepidium sativum Linn.
Raphanus sativus Linn.
Capparaceae
Cleome aspera Koen. ex DC.
C. monophylSa Linn.
Viol ace ae
Viola cinerea Boiss. var. stockii
Beck, forma kathiawarensis
Beck.
CAR YOP H YLLACE AE
Spergula arvensis Linn.
PORTULACACEAE
Portulaca tuberosa Roxb.
Talinum portulacastrum (Forsk.)
Aschers. & Schweinf.
A. manihof (Linn.) Medic.
Abutilon glaucuin (Cav.) Sw.
Azauza lampas (Cav.) Alef.
Hibiscus hirtus Linn.
H. vitifolius Linn.
Seura iueaua Cav.
Sida acuta Burm. f.
S. gSutinosa Cav.
Linum usitatissimum Linn.
Triunifetta rhomboidea Jacq.
T. pentandra A. Rich.
Grewia damine Gaertn.
Grewia tiliaefolia Vahl
S. rhombifolia Linn. var. retusa
Mast.
Abelmoschus ficulneus (Linn.)
Wt. & Arn.
Malvaceae
Tiliaceae
Linaceae
60 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
OXALIDACEAE
Biophytum sensitivum (Linn.)
DC.
Burseraceae
Commiphora wightii (Arn.)
Bhand.
Garuga pinnata Roxb.
Rhamnaceae
Zizyphus horrida Roth
Z. xylopyra Willd.
VlTACEAE
Cissus quadrangularis Linn.
C. repanda Vahl
Papilionaceae
Alysicarpus rugosus DC. var.
minor Prain
Clitoria biflora Dalz.
Crotalaria albida Heyne ex Roth
C. triquetra Dalz.
Dalbergia latifolia Roxb.
Desmodium laxiflorum DC.
D. neomexicanum A. Gray
Dolichos biflorus Linn.
"Lathy ms aphaca Linn.
Medicago polymorpha Linn.
M. lacinitata All.
M. sativa Linn.
Phaseolus angularis (Willd.) Wt. .
P. dalzelii Cooke
P. mungo Linn.
P. radiatus Linn.
Pueraria tuberosa (Roxb.) DC.
Rhynchosia aurea DC.
Sesbania cannabina (Retz.) Pers.
Smithia conferta Sm.
*Tephrosia hamiltonii Drumm.
T. pauciflora Grah.
T. purpurea (Linn.) Pers.
Vigna capensis Walp.
Caesalpiniaceae
Bauhinia tomentosa Linn.
Cassia angustifolia Vahl
C. fistula Linn.
C. kleinii Wt. & Arn.
C. obtusifolia Linn.
C. sophera Linn.
Mimosaceae
Acacia ferruginea DC.
Albizzia odoratissima Bth.
COMBRETACEAE
Anogeissus latifolia (Roxb.)
Wall, ex Bedd.
Combretum ovalifolium Roxb.
Tenninalia bellerica (Gaertn.)
Roxb.
Lythraceae
*Ammannia desertorum Blatt. &
Hallb.
CUCURBITACEAE
Solena heterophylla Lour.
Trichosanthes bracteata (Lam.)
Voigt.
Apiaceae (Umbelliferae)
Centella asiatica (Linn.) Urb.
Trachyspermum stictocarpum
var. stictocarpum
Rubiaceae
Adina cordifolia (Roxb.) Hook.
f. ex Brandis
Ixora brachiata Roxb.
Xeromphis spinosa (Thunb.)
Keay
Asteraceae (Compositae)
Acanthospermum hispidum DC.
Blumea bifoliata DC.
B. membranacea DC.
B. oxydonta DC.
Gnaphalium luteoalbum Linn.
Laggera alata (Don) Sch.-Bip.
ex Oliver
L. aurita (Linn, f.) Sch.-Bip.
Lauuaea residifolia (Linn.)
Druce
Pluchea wallichiana DC.
*Pulkaria crispa Sch.-Bip.
Sonchus asper (Linn.) Hill.
S. brachyotus DC.
ADDITIONS TO THE FLORA OF NORTH GUJARAT
61
Plumbaginaceae
Dyerophytum indicum (Gibs, ex
Wt.) O. Ktze.
Salvadoraceae
Azima tetracantha Lam.
Apocynaceae
Wrightia tomentosa Roem. &
Schult.
Asclepiadaceae
CONVOLVULACEAE
Ipomoea coptica (Linn.) Roth
SCROP H U L ARI ACEAE
Lindernia oppositifolia (Retz.)
Muk.
L. verbenaefolia (Colsm.) Pennell
Gesneriaceae
Didyniocarpus pygmaea Cl.
Bignoniaceae
Tecomella undidata (Sm.) Seem.
ACANTH ACEAE
Barleria cuspidata Heyne ex
Nees
*B. prattensis Sant.
Dipteracanthus patulus (Jacq.)
Nees
Eranthemum roseum (Vahl) R.
Br.
Justicia diffusa Willd.
J. heterocarpa T. Anders.
J. simplex D. Don
Lepidagathis cristata Willd.
Verbenaceae
Gmelina arborea Roxb.
Lantana salvifolia Jacq.
Labiatae
Acrocephalus indicus (Burin, f.)
O. Ktze.
Leucas longifolia Benth.
L. zeylanica R. Br.
Salvia plebeia R. Br.
PLANTAGIN ACEAE
Plantago ovata Forsk.
*P. psyllium Linn.
Amaranthaceae
*Achyrauthes aspera var. prop-
hyristachya Hook. f.
Aerva sanguinolenta (Linn.) Bl.
Amarauthus hybridus Linn. ssp.
cruentus (Linn.) Thell. var.
paniculatus (Linn.) Hell.
A. tricolor Linn.
A. viridis Linn.
*Gomphrena celosioides Mart.
Chenopodiaceae
Salsola baryosma (Roem. &
Schult.) Dandy
Polygon aceae
Polygonum glabrum Willd.
Aristolochiaceae
Aristolochia bracteolata Lam.
Euphorbiaceae
Baliospermum montanum
(Willd.) Muell.-Arg.
Bridelia squamosa (Lam.)
Gehrm.
*DaIechampia scandens Linn.
var. cordofana (Hochst. ex A.
Rich.) Muell.-Arg.
62 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Euphorbia chamaesyce Linn.
E. clarkeana Hook. f.
E. geniculata Orteg.
Jatropha curcas Linn.
Phyllanthus simplex Linn.
P. urinaria Linn.
Putranjiva roxburghii Wall.
Securinega virosa (Roxb. ex
Willd.) Pax & Hoffm.
Moraceae
i
Ficus aniplissima Sm.
F. arnottiana Miq.
Cannabaceae
Cannabis saliva Linn.
Hydrocharitaceae
Nechamandra alternifolia
(Roxb.) Thw.
Oltelia alisnioides (Linn.) Pers.
ZlNGIBERACEAE
Curcuma inodora Blatt.
Amaryllidaceae
Crinuni pratcnse Herb.
Hypoxidaceae
Curculigo orchioides Gaertn.
Dioscoreaceae
Dioscorea hispida Linn.
Do pentaphylla Linn.
Liliaceae
Asparagus gonoclados Baker
Chlorophytum tuberosum
(Roxb.) Baker
Arecaceae (Palmae)
Borassus habelliffer Linn.
Calamus rotang Linn.
Phoenix sylvestris (Linn.) Roxb.
COMMELINACEAE
Commelma forskalaei Vahl
*C. kurzii Clke.
*C. paludosa Bl.
Cyanotis cristala Schult. f.
Araceae
Amorphophallus sp.
Pistia stratiotes Linn. var. cune-
ata Engl.
Sauromalum venosum (Ait.)
Kunth
Lemnaceae
Lenina paucicostata Hegelm.
Wolffia microscopica (Griff.)
Kurz
Najadaceae
Potamogeton crisp us Linn.
P. nodosus Linn.
Eriocaulaceae
Eriocaulon eleanorae Fyson
Cyperaceae
*Cyperus alulatus Kern
C. compressus Linn.
C. cyperioides (Linn.) O. Ktze.
Eriophoruin comosum Wall, ex
Nees
*Fimbristylis sieberriana Kunth
Rhynchospora wightiana Steud.
POACEAE (GrAMINEAE)
Aristida setacea Retz.
Arena saliva Linn.
Cenchms pennisetiformis Hochst.
& Steud. ex Steud.
Crypsis schoenoides (Linn.) Lam.
Cymbopogon citratus (DC.)
Stapf
*C. gidarba (Ham. ex Hook, f.)
Haines
C. martini! Wats.
*Cynodon barber! Rang.
*Digitaria adscendens H.B.K.
ssp. adscendens var. crinifor-
mis Henr.
Echinochloa stagnina (Retz.)
Beauv.
*Ischaemum goebelii Hack.
*Setaria pallide-fusca (Schum.)
Stapf & C. E. Hubb.
Sorghum vulgare Pers.
Sporobolus piliferus (Trin.)
Kunth
Triticum aestivum Linn.
ADDITIONS TO THE FLORA OF NORTH GUJARAT
63
ACK N OWLEDGE M E N TS
We are deeply grateful to late Dr. H. Santapau, and Prof. P. V.
Bole of St. Xavier’s College, Bombay for facilities to work in the
Blatter Herbarium, Bombay. Sincere thanks are also due to Prof.
G. T. Pandya for allowing us to consult the collections of Saxton and
Sedkwick and Dr. R. S. Rao, Regional Botanist, Botanical Survey of
India, Poona, for confirming the identifications of some grasses.
References
Cooke, T. H. (1901-08): The flora
of the Presidency of Bombay. Lon-
don.
Rau, M. A. (1969): Flora of the
upper Gangetic plain and of the ad-
jacent Siwalik and sub-Himalayan
tracts. Bull. hot. surv. India 10
(Suppl. 2) : 1-87.
Santapau, H. & Janardhanan, K. P.
(1967): The flora of Saurashtra:
Check-list. ibid. (Suppl. 1 ) : 1-58.
Shah, C. K. (1963): Sedges, of
Sabarmati. /. Gujarat Univ. 6:179-185.
Shah G. L. (1969): Nomencla-
tural changes in some Bombay plants
— III. J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 66:
231-233.
Saxton, W. T. (1922) : Additional
notes on plants of Northern Gujarat.
Rec. bot. Surv. India 4: 251-262.
& Sedgwick, L. J.
(1918) : Plants of Northern Gujarat,
ibid. 6(7) : 209-323.
Three new species of
Aphelinidae (Hymenoptera :
Aonidiella orientalis (Newst.)
from India1
Zoology Department, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh
The coccid Aonidiella orientalis (Newst.), an important pest of
fruit trees, is parasitized by several species of chalcids. From India the
following encyrtid and aphelinid parasites have been so far recorded:
Encyrtidae: 1. Comperiella bifasciata Howard, 1906
2. Comperiella lemniscata Compere & Annecke, 1961
3. Comperiella unifasciata Ishii, 1925
4. Thomsonisca indica Hayat, 1970
Aphelinidae: 5. Aphytis chrysomphali (Mercet 1912)
6. Aphytis lingnanensis Compere, 1955
7. Azotus qadrii Agarwal, 1964
8. Coccophagoides orientalis (Agarwal, 1964)
9. Marietta javensis (Howard, 1907)
10. Physcus reticulatus Compere & Annecke, 1961
11. Physcus sp. (near flaviventris Howard)
In this paper three new species belonging to the aphelinid genera
Marlattiella Howard, Physcus Howard, and Ablerus Howard are des-
cribed. The genera Marlattiella and Ablerus are new records for India.
3 Accepted December 23, 1971.
2 Present address'. Desert Regional Station, Z.S.I., Paota, B Road, Jodhpur
(Rajasthan).
parasitic on
BY
Mohammad Hayat2
{With fifteen text-figures)
Introduction
THREE NEW SPECIES OF APHELINIDA E
65
Marl at dell a Howard
Howard, 1907, U. S. Dep. agric. Bur. Ent. Tech. Ser. 12:73
Type species: Marlattiella prima Howard
Marlattiella maculata sp. nov.
(Figs. 1-3)
Female —
Length, 0.86 mm. Head whitish; epistoma, basal half of genal
sulcus and an inverted ‘Y’ shaped patch on occiput above foramen
brown. Antennae whitish except club which is brown on basal two-
thirds and yellow on apical third. Thorax whitish with brown or dusky
as follows: Centre of pronotum and propodeum except sides brown;
three patches on anterior margin of mesoscutum and two patches on
posterior fourth, two patches on anterior third and whole of posterior
margin of scutellum dusky. Fore wings hyaline with a faint infuscated
patch below marginal vein. Hind wings hyaline. Legs whitish. Gaster
whitish with a dark brown patch on dorsum extending from base to
level of cereal plates, sides and tenth tergum white.
Fig. 1-3. Marlattiella maculata sp. n. Q . 1. antenna; 2. fore wing; 2a. stigmal
vein; 3. distal part of middle leg.
Head as wide as thorax; frontovertex width nearly one third head
width (6.75:18), one and a half times as long as wide; eyes with short
hairs; ocelli arranged in acute triangle, lateral ocelli removed from eye
rim by one ocellus diameter and from occipital margin by two ocellar
diameters. Proportions of antennal components as in Fig. 1.
Prontoum composed of two triangular plates joined in middle by a
membrane, postero-lateral angles with a long seta; mesoscutum, parap-
5
66 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
sides and scutellum with 6, 2+2 and 4 setae respectively.
Fore wings a little less than three times as long as wide (20:7);
marginal vein longer than submarginal vein (17.5:7.5), these veins
with 12 and 1 setae; postmarginal vein absent; stigmal vein as in Fig.
2a; marginal fringe one fifth width of wing (Fig. 2). Hind wings six
times as long as wide; marginal fringe as long as width of wing.
Tibial spur of middle leg (Fig. 3) a little longer than basitarsus.
Gaster slightly longer than thorax (25:23); ovipositor extends from
second segment, exserted part one fifth length of gaster.
Male — Not known.
material studied: Holotype $ , India: Uttar Pradesh, Aligarh, ex
Aonidiella orientalis (Newst.), on Ficus sp., 22.vii.1968, Coll. M.
Hayat. Holotype will be deposited in the Zoological Survey of India,
Calcutta.
Comments. — M. maculata can be easily separated from the other
two known species by the following key characters:
1. Club about as long as scape; mesoscutum, scutellum and parapsides with
26, 4 and 1+1 setae respectively; submarginal vein with 2 setae
secuda Compere3
1. Club longer than scape, pedicel and funicle combined; mesoscutum, scutel-
lum and parapsides with 6, 4 and 2+2 setae respectively; submarginal
vein with 1 seta 2
2. General colour orange yellow; fore wings hyaline, speculum mesally bound-
ed by about 40 setae, marginal fringe about one third of width of wing
prima Howard
2. General colour whitish with dusky or brown patches, dorsum of gaster
except sides and tenth tergum brown; fore wings with a faint infuscated
patch below marginal vein, speculum mesially bounded by about 70
setae, marginal fringe one fifth of width of wing .... maculata sp. nov.
Physcus Howard
Howard, 1895, U. S. Dep. agric. Ent. Tech. Ser. 1:43
Type species: Coccophagus varicornis Howard
Physcus alisarhensis sp. nov.
(Figs. 4-9)
Female —
Length, 0.83 mm. Head blackish brown; eye rim and frontovertex
testaceous yellow. Thorax blackish brown with testaceous yellow por-
tions as shown in Fig. 4 (unstippled areas). Gaster white with a longi-
tudinal brown band on each side extending from base to cereal plates.
Scape except apex brown, apex of scape and rest of antenna pale
yellow. Wings hyaline. Legs pale yellow, marked with dusky as follows:
3 Rosen and De Bach (1970) consider it as a ‘dubious species of Aphytis,
possibly a “connecting link” between Aphytis and Marlattiella’.
THREE NEW SPECIES OF A PHEL1NIDA E
67
Fig. 4-9. Physcus aligarhensis sp. n. 9 , d • 4. entire female, antennae, wings
and legs removed; 5. antenna, female; 6. antenna, male; 7. stigmal
vein; 8. distal part of middle leg; 9. outer plate of ovipositor.
coxae, femora except distal ends and basal half of tibiae of fore legs;
distal half of femora and basal half of tibiae of middle legs; apices
of coxae, apices of femora and basal half of tibiae of hind legs.
Head broader than thorax (9:7.5); frontovertex about one half
of head width; ocelli arranged in obtuse triangle; antennal sockets
situated far above oral margin, their upper margins a little above an
imaginary line drawn across lower eye margins. Proportions of anten-
nal components as in Fig. 5.
Fore wings two and a half times as long as wide (22:9); sub-
marginal vein as long as marginal vein, these veins with 8 and 9 setae;
stigmal vein short (Fig. 7); postmarginal vein absent; length of mar-
ginal fringe one fifth width of wing. Hind wings six times as long as
wide, marginal fringe shorter than wing width.
Tibial spur of middle leg as long as basitarsus (Fig. 8).
Gaster as long as thorax; outer plates of ovipositor (Fig. 9) with a
submarginal ridge along dorsal margin; third valvulae one and a half
68 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
times longer than tibial spur of middle leg; ovipositor not exserted.
Male — Essentially similar to the female except for the following dif-
ferences :
Body completely blackish; scape except apex, pedicel and first
funicle segment brown, rest of antenna yellow; proportions of antennal
components as in Fig. 6.
material studied: Holotype 9 : 2 9 , 1 c? , paratypes, India: Uttar
Pradesh, Aligarh, ex Aonidiella orientalis (Newst.), on Ficus sp.
18 . vii . 1968, Coll. M. Hayat. Material will be deposited in the Zoolo-
gical Survey of India, Calcutta.
Comments — P. aligarhensis sp. n. comes closest to P. flavoflagel-
latus De Santis, 1940, but differs by the specific body colour, length
of marginal fringe of both fore and hind wings, and in the male by
the brown colour of the first funicle segment.
Ablerus Howard
Howard, 1894, Insect Life 7:7
Type species: Centrodora clisiocampae Ashmead
Ablerus aonidiellae sp. nov.
(Figs. 10-15)
Female —
Length, (excluding exserted part of oyipositor), 0.61 mm (0.09
mm). Head white; occiput blackish, shiny; malar space with a brown
band extending from postgenae, passing below the eyes, and touching
antennal sockets. Thorax and gaster dark brown with faint violet and
greenish reflections. Dorsal surface of scape, basal two-thirds of pedi-
cel, funicles I and III and club brownish; rest of antenna white. Fore
wings infuscated with apical third hyaline. Hind wings hyaline. Legs:
coxae except apices, fore and middle femora except base and apical
half, hind femora except base and apex narrowly, fore and middle
tibiae except base and apical half, hind tibiae except apex, and last
tarsal segment of all legs brown; rest of parts white.
Frontovertex width one fourth head width (1:4), a third longer
than its own width (3:2); ocelli in obtuse triangle, lateral ocelli near
to eye rim and removed from occipital margin by one ocellus diameter;
antennal sockets removed from facial margin by a distance equal to
length of a socket; malar space as long as eye width; mandibles with
two teeth and a dorsal truncation. Proportions of antennal components
as in Fig. 10.
Thorax shorter than gaster (3:5); pronotum (Fig. 12) with ante-
rior and posterior margins concave, each postero-lateral side with 2
brown setae; mesoscutum, axillae and scutellum with 4, 1+1 and 4
THREE NEW SPECIES OF APHEEINIDAE
69
setae respectively; scutellum over twice wider than long (25:11);
median length of propodeum a trifle over three times that of metano-
tum (13:4); mesopostphragma one-third length of gaster, its apex
truncate.
14
Fig. 10-15. Ablerus aonidiellae sp. n. Q . 10. antenna; 11. fore wing; 12. pro-
notum; 13. distal part of middle leg; 14. outer plate of ovipositor;
15. subgenital plate.
Fore wings (Fig. 11) with submarginal vein longer than marginal
vein, these veins with 2 and 4 setae; length of marginal fringe 1/3 width
of disc. Hind wings six times as long as wide; marginal fringe as long
as width of wing.
Tibial spur of middle leg shorter than basitarsus (Fig. 13).
Gaster longer than thorax; outer plates of ovipositor (Fig. 14)
narrow, dorsal margin with an inflexion extending from base to two-
thirds length of the plate; subgenital plate (Fig. 15) with a notch in
middle of posterior margin, sides of notch followed by wavy ridges,
mid-longitudinal groove and antero-lateral apodemes present; exserted
70 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
part of ovipositor one third length of gaster.
Male — Not known.
material studied: Holotype $ : 2 9 9 paratypes, India: Uttar Pradesh,
Aligarh, ex Aonidiella orientalis (Newst.), on Psidium guajava L.,
12. ix. 1969, Coll. M. Hayat. Material will be deposited in the Zoolo-
gical Survey of India, Calcutta.
Comments — A. aonidiellae sp. n. can be easily separated from
A. clisiocampae (Ashmead) and A. magistrettii Blanchard, to which
it is most closely related, by the following key characters:
1. Marginal vein with 4 setae; apical one third of fore wing hyaline; length
of marginal fringe one third width of wing. Hind wing with marginal
fringe as long as width of wing. Basitarsi of all legs whitish
aonidiellae sp. n.
1. Marginal vein with 3 setae; apical one fourth of fore wing hyaline; length
of marginal fringe 1/5 to 1/6 width of wing. Hind wing with marginal
fringe shorter than width of wing. Basitarsi of all legs brown 2
2. Submarginal vein with 2 setae. Second tarsal segment of all legs whitish.
Tibial spur of middle leg shorter than basitarsus
magistrettii Blanchard
2. Submarginal vein with 1 seta. Second tarsal segment of all legs brown.
Tibial spur of middle leg as long as basitarsus
clisiocampae (Ashmead)
ACK NOWLEDGE M E N TS
I am grateful to Prof. S. Mashhood Alam, Head of the Zoology
Department, for his helpful criticism and for facilities. Thanks are due
to Dr. R. F. Wilkey, California Department of Agriculture, Sacramento,
C.A. (U.S.A.), for identification of the coccids. Financial assistance
from the USDA under PL 480 A-7-ENT-36, grant No. 299, is grate-
fully acknowledged.
References
Agarwal, M. M. (1964a) : Studies
of forms of Aphelinidae (Hymenop-
tera-Chalcidoidea) collected at Aligarh
(India) — I. — Proc. Indian Acad. Sci.
B. 59: 263-286.
(1964b): Studies of
forms & c. II.— ibid. 60:315-335.
(1965) : Taxonomy
of Encyrtid parasites (Hymenoptera:
Chalcidoidea) of Indian Coccoidea. —
Acta ILymenopt. 2:37-97.
Compere. H. & Annecke, D. P.
(1961) : Descriptions of parasitic
Hymenoptera and comments (Aph.,
Eul., Ency.). — J. ent. Soc. South Afr.
24:17-11.
De Bach, P. (1959) : New species
and strains of Aphytis (Hymenoptera,
Eulophidae) parasitic on the Cali-
fornia red scale Aonidiella aurantii
(Mask.), in the Orient. — Ann. ent.
Soc. Am. 52: 354-362.
Glover, P. M. (1935): An account
of the occurrence of Chrysomphalus
THREE NEW SPECIES OF APHELIN1DAE
7i
aurantii Mask and Laccifer lacca
Kerr on grape fruit in Ranchi district,
Chota Nagpur, with a note on the
Chalcidoid parasites of Aspidiotus
orientalis Newst. J. Bombay nat. Hist.
Soc. 38 : 151-153.
Hayat, M. (1970): New species of
Encyrtidae (Hymenoptera : Chalcido-
idea) reared from coccids. Mushi 44:
55-63.
(1971): Two new and
known species of Aphelinidae (Hym-
enoptera: Chalcidoidea) from India.
Bull. Ent. 72:118-121. (1972).
(1973) : On some Indian
species of Aphelinidae with a descrip-
tion of a new Coccophagus (Hymen-
optera : Chalcidoidea) . — /. nat. Hist. 7.
Rosen, D. & De Bach, P. (1970):
Notes on the genus Marlattiella Ho-
ward (Hymenoptera: Aphelinidae).
Mushi 43: 39-44.
Smithsonia (Orcliidaceae),
a new Genus from Western
India1
BY
Cecil J. S aldan ha
St. Joseph's College, Bangalore
{With two plates )
In his study on Sarcochilus R. Br. and Pteroceras Hassk., Holttum
(Kew Bull. 14:263-276, 1960) doubted the generic status of two orchids
described by Dalzell from Western India.
The first was described as Micropera maculata Dalz. This species
was transferred to Sarcochilus R. Br. by Pfitzer, shifted to Saccola-
bium Bl. by J. D. Hooker and placed in Gastrochilus Don by Otto
Kuntze. Holttum withheld his opinion with the remark “I would like
to see fresh flowers of this species before assigning it to a genus.”
The second plant was named Micropera viridiflora Dalz. This was
transferred to Saccolabium by Lindley, to Sarcochilus by Cooke and
to Gastrochilus by Santapau & Kapadia. While accepting the view of
Santapau & Kapadia, Holttum observed “the lip of the species has a
rather narrow spur in place of the wide sac of Malaysian species of
Gastrochilus.”
The plants described by Dalzell cannot be retained in Micropera
Lindley as the type of the genus has itself been transferred to Cama-
rotis. As Holttum points out, the name Micropera Lindl. has no status.
These plants cannot be included in Saccolabium Bl. as this genus is
characterised by the presence of a fleshy callus inside the spur cavity
and by two, entire pollinia. Neither can they be assigned to Sarcoch-
ilus R. Br. which has four pollinia in two unequal pairs and a movable
sac-like lip with a prominent callus inside the spur. They cannot be
included in Gastrochilus Don which has a saccate-cupular, broad lip,
a transverse fringed mid-lobe and 2, only slightly notched or indented
pollinia.
Both Micropera maculata Dalz. and M. viridiflora Dalz. — fairly
common plants in Western India — have pointed spurs devoid of septa.
Accepted May 25, 1972.
J. Bombay nat. Hist.
Saldanha : Smithsonia
SMITHSONIA GEN. NOV.
73
calli or tongue-like projections within the spur cavity. The spur cavity
is hairy in the former and glabrous in the latter. The pollinia are 2,
deeply grooved and unequally lobed. I have collected a third orchid
with somewhat similar spur and pollinia. These three form a distinct
genus that can be segregated from the other genera in this group. I
am naming this genus Smithsonia in honour of James Smithson.
Smithsonia gen. nov.
Pertinet ad tribum Sarcanthinearum et distinguibile calcare amo-
vibile, attenuate, non-septato, intus glabro vel pubescente, sine callosi-
tatibus distinctis vel projecturis liguliformibus. Label lum 3-lobatum,
lobis lateralibus erectis et lobo mediano transversali plus minusve calcar
obtegente. Pollinia 2, profunde in lobis inaequalibus sulcata. Stipes
indivisus, exilis, ad apicem glandula bifida. Rostellum bifidum in direc-
tionem calcaris productum.
Dilfert a Saccolabio calcare attenuate, sine septis vel callositatibus
et polliniis profunde sulcatis. Differt etiam a Sarcochilo absentia in
calcare prominentiarum numeroque polliniorum. Distinguibile a Gas-
trochilo calcaris forma et polliniorum sulco.
Smithsonia gen. nov.
The genus belongs to the tribe Sarcanthineae and is characterised
by an immovable, attenuated, non-septate spur that may be glabrous
or hairy within and is devoid of callus pads or tongue-like projections.
Lip 3 -lobed, with lateral lobes erect and a transverse central lobe more
or less covering the spur. Pollinia 2, deeply furrowed into 2 unequal
lobes. Stipe undivided, slender with a bifid gland at tip. Rostellum bifid
pointing towards spur.
Differs from Saccolabium by the attenuated spur which is devoid
of septa and by the deeply furrowed pollinia. It differs from Sarco-
chilus by the absence of projections in the spur and by the number of
pollinia. It is distinguished from Gastrochilus by the shape of the spur
and the groove of the pollinia.
The following three species are included in the genus.
Smithsonia strain iot a sp. nov. Generis typus
Planta epiphytica. Radices 3-6 ex basi caulis orientes, usque 10 cm
longae, 0.4 cm diam. Caulis brevissimus. Folia 2-4, disticha, coriacea,
elliptico-oblonga, paulo canaliculata, ad apicem integra vel bilobata,
versus basim attenuata articulata et imbricata, usque 0.7 x 2 cm.
Racemi 1-2, generatim infrafoliares foliisque breviores, 4-8 floribus.
Flores diuturni, bracteati, sessiles, 0.5 cm diam.; sepala subsimilia,
obovata, straminea maculisque rubris. Labellum amovibile, calcaratum,
3-lobatum. Calcar roseum, subconicum, rectum, nec callositatibus nec
74 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
projecturis praeditum, 3-4 mm longum; lobi laterales albi, erecti, acuti,
sicuti calcaris marginis prolongationes; lobus medianus albus, trans-
versalis, arcuatus, integer, lateraiiter breviter obtusus, prope cum cal-
care juncturam paulo torulosus. Columna rosea, brevis, cum calcaris
margine conjuncta. Operculum stramineum. Pollinia 2, profunde
sulcata. Stipes simplex, angustatus ad apicem glandula ligulata. Ros-
tellum 2-lobatum, in directionem calcaris productum. Capsula ellip-
tico-obovata, prominenter costata, 0.5 x 1.5 cm.
A S. viridiflora statura coloreque florum, forma calcaris labellique
loborum differt. A S. maculata plantae statura, inflorescentiae longi-
tudine, forma staturaque florum facile distinguibilis.
Smithsonia straminea sp. nov.
An epiphyte. Roots 3-6, arising from the base of the stem, up to
10 cm long and 0.4 cm in diam. Stem very short. Leaves 2-4, distichous,
coriaceous elliptic-oblong and slightly channelled, imbricating, bilobed
or entire at apex, narrowed and articulated at base. Racemes 1-2,
generally below and shorter than the leaves, 4-8 flowered. Flowers
lasting for several days, bracteate, sessile, 0.5 cm across. Sepals straw-
coloured with red spots, subsimilar, obovate, 1.5 x 3 mm; petals slightly
smaller and narrower, yellow with red spots. Lip immovable, spurred,
3-lobed. Spur pink, sub-conical, straight, without calli or projections
within, 3-4 mm long; lateral lobes white, erect, acute, as prolongations
of the rim of the spur; mid-lobe white, transverse, arching downwards,
entire, shortly obtuse on the sides, with a small knob near junction
with the spur. Anther cap yellowish. Pollinia 2, deeply cleft. Stipe
single, narrow, ending in a tongue-like gland. Rostellum 2-lobed, point-
ing towards spur. Capsule elliptic-obovate, strongly ribbed, 0.5 x 1.5 cm.
Differs from Smithsonia viridiflora in size and colour of flowers,
shape of the spur and lobes of the lip. It is easily separated from
S. maculata by the size of the entire plant, length of the inflorescence
and by the shape and size of the flowers.
Holotype : Saldanha 13361 collected at Devalkere in Hassan Dis-
trict, Mysore State on 14 April 1969 and preserved in the Herbarium
of St. Joseph’s College, Bangalore. Paratypes: HFP 1608 and 1675
collected in the same district in April-May 1971.
Smithsonia maculata (Dalz.) comb. nov.
Micropera maculata Dalzell, Hooker’s T. Bot. 3:282. 1851.
Sarcochilus maculatus (Dalz.) Pfitzer, Vergl. Morph. Orch. 15. 1881.
Saccolabium maculatum (Dalz.) J. D. Hooker, FI. Brit. India 6:64. 1890.
Gastrochilus maculatus (Dalz.) O. Kuntze, Rev. Gen. PI. 2:661. 1891;
Santapau & Kapadia, J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 59:841. 1963.
SMITHSONIA GEN. NOV.
75
Smithsonia viridiflora (Dalz.) comb. nov.
Micropera viridiflora Dalzell, Hooker's J. Bot. 3:282. 1851.
Saccolabium viridiflorum (Dalz.) Lindley, J. Linn. Soc. Bot. 3:36. 1858.
Sarcochilus viridiflorus (Dalz.) Cooke, FI. Pres. Bombay 2:697. 1907. (non
Hooker, 1890).
Sarcochilus dalzellianus Santapau, Kew Bull. 1948:498. 1949.
Gastrochilus dalzellianus (Sant.) Santapau & Kapadia, J. Bombay nat.
Hist. Soc. 59:842. t. 52A. 1963.
Key to the species
A Inflorescence longer than the leaves S. maculata
AA Inflorescence shorter than the leaves
B Midlobe of lip overhanging spur completely, prolonged
into triangular, acute lateral wings. FIs. greenish-white,
1-1.5 cm wide S. viridiflora
BB Midlobe of lip not overhanging spur completely; lateral
wings short, obtuse. Flowers straw-coloured spotted with
red, 0.5 cm wide S. straminea
Ack nowledge m e n ts
I am grateful to Prof. R. E. Holttum and Dr. Dan H. Nicolson
for their valuable suggestions and to the Smithsonian Research Found-
ation for support.
The Avifauna of introduced
Eucalyptus plantations in
Maharashtra
BY
Lincoln Gray
Department of Veterinary Biology, University of Minnesota 55101, USA
A study of the avifauna of two small introduced Eucalyptus
plantations indicated extensive changes in species composition at
the end of the monsoon season, and changes in resident species
with advancing stages of plantation development. The birds seemed
to be attracted to the outer areas of the plantation which offer
more diverse vegetation. These plantations provide an opportunity
to study the effects of introduced vegetation on local fauna.
Introduction
Small Eucalyptus plantations, started by the Indian Government
to control soil erosion, provided rare opportunities to study the wildlife
of isolated, introduced, islands of vegetation. Awsari and Pachgaon
are two such plantations, situated on the leeward side of the Western
Ghats approximately 170 kilometres east of Bombay. Eucalyptus has
been introduced extensively throughout the sub-continent to start new
plantations. In this area, plantations appeared to be widely scattered,
separated by approximately 80 or 90 kilometres. These small planta-
tions could have an important effect on the fauna of the area. Not only
are they concentrated islands of an introduced tree, but they are fenced,
cultivated, and protected. This maintenance is important because, dur-
ing the monsoon, plants grow and fruit and food seems abundant, but
after the rains the land outside the plantation fences is soon dry and
quickly over-grazed.
The two plantations presented contrasting vegetation. The planta-
tion at Awsari, started in 1966, covers 87 hectares and is planted with
Eucalyptus (E. tereticornis) , Sissu ( Dalbergia sissn), Siras ( Albizzia
lebbek), Neem ( Melia azaclirachta) , and Tarwad ( Cassia auriculata).
Accepted July 26, 1973.
AVIFAUNA OF EUCALYPTUS PLANTATIONS
77
The plantation consists of two distinct areas: one, called the “inner
area” in this paper, is almost 100 per cent Eucalyptus trees, 10-14
metres high, with little understory; the other, called “the outer area”,
has approximately 50 per cent of the ground covered with trees of
several species, 3-7 metres high, with the remainder of the ground
covered by grass and underbrush fading into the surrounding barren
grasslands. The Pachgaon plantation, 57 kilometres to the south, covers
238 hectares and is planted with Eucalyptus, Babul ( Acacia arabica ),
Silver Oak ( Grevillea sp.), and a species of bamboo. The trees are
small (7-10 metres high) and very widely scattered. The extensive
understory is composed of grass and shrubs up to one metre high.
The two plantations show stages of vegetation structure similar to
ecological succession. These stages do not represent a natural succes-
sion because the tree species are introduced and maintained by man
but they can be thought of as stages in a plantation development: from
barren grassland, through protective fencing with high grass and scatter-
ed small trees, to thick plantations with outer areas of diverse vegeta-
tion.
The aim of this study was to categorize the avifauna of each planta-
tion by species, abundance, position, and nesting activity. The study
began in July during the height of the monsoon and continued for a
total of five months into the December dry season.
Methods and Materials
Awsari or Pachgaon plantation was observed during 34 days bet-
ween 11 July 1970 and 4 December 1970. Birds were identified by
plumage with 7 x 35 binoculars on systematically walked routes through
the plantations. After September, two mist nets (12.8 x 2.1 m, 38 mm
mesh) were available which were put up for a total of 400 net-hours
in various locations within the study areas. Other observations at
Awsari included perching and nest locations of selected common species
of birds.
Results and Discussion
Extensive changes in species composition were observed at the
monsoon season. Table 1 shows that 20 of the 48 identified species
were observed in either area for the entire length of the study. Nine
species were observed for the first time at the end of the monsoon and
stayed in the area until the end of the study. Three species left the area
after the monsoon and 16 species were observed for only a short time.
Immigrants Emigrants Residents
78 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
As only five of these species ( Coturnix coturnix, Sylvia hortensis, S.
curruca, Carpodacus erythrinus, and Emberiza bruniceps) are des-
cribed as being migratory (Ali 1968), the extensive seasonal changes
in species could indicate the principal effect of these plantations on
local avifauna. After the monsoon, as the grazed grasslands surround-
ing the plantations become dry, the vegetative structure within the
plantations remains stable. Even though there is no additional fruiting
associated with these changes, opportunistic local birds can invade
Table 1
Identified Species
Species
Dates Observed Approx.
J. A.S.O. N.D.* No.
House Crow ( Corvus splendens ) _______ c
Jungle Babbler ( Turdoides striatus ) q
Baybacked Shrike ( Lanius vittatus ) q
House Sparrow ( Passer domesticus ) q
House Swift (A pus affinis) ______ c
White Scavenger Vulture ( Neophron percnopterus ) C
Jungle Crow ( Corvus macrorhynchos ) _ + _ + _ + c
Redvented Bulbul ( Pycnonotus cafer ) _ + _ + -+ C
Drongo ( Dicrurus adsimilis ) _ + _ + _ + n
Indian Wren Warbler ( Prinia subflava ) _ + _ + _+ n
Common Myna ( Acridotheres tristis ) _ + _ + _ + c
Whitethroated Munia ( Lonchura malabarica ) _ + _ -f _ + c
Common Green Bee-eater ( Merops orientalis ) _ + _ + _+ c
Pariah Kite ( Milvus migrans ) _ + _ + _ + c
Little Brown Dove ( Streptopelia senegalensis ) _ + _ + _ + Q
Indian Robin ( Saxicoloides fulicata ) + + _j_ _j_ C
Rufousbacked Shrike ( Lanius schach ) _|_ _i_ _j_ _j_ _j_ _j_ C
Roseringed Parakeet ( Psittacula krameri ) + + _j_ _j_ _j_ C
Alpine Swift {Apus melba) + _f _l_ _(_ _j_ _j_ C
Ring Dove ( Streptopelia decaocto ) _(_ _}_ _j_ _|_ _j_ C
Crested Lark ( Galerida cristata )
Redwattled Lapwing ( Vanellus indicus )
Common Weaver Bird ( Ploceus philippinus )
Purple Sunbird ( Nectarinia asiatica )
Blackwinged Kite ( Elanus caeruleus )
Small Skylark ( Alauda gulgula )
Common Quail ( Coturnix coturnix )
Crow Pheasant ( Centropus sinensis )
Common Babbler ( Turdoides caudatus )
Orphean Warbler ( Sylvia hortensis )
Common Rosefinch ( Carpodacus erythrinus )
Rufoustailed Finch-Lark ( Ammomanes phoenicurus )
+ - +
+ + +
+ + +
- +
- +
- +
5
2
C
C
4
C
5
2
3
Transients
AVIFAUNA OF EUCALYPTUS PLANTATIONS
79
Common Nightjar ( Caprimulgus asiaticus) +
Grey Shrike ( Lanius excubitor ) - +
Small Minivet ( Pericrocotus cinnamomeus ) — — —
Lesser Whitethroat ( Sylvia curruca) +
Rain Quail ( Coturnix coromandelica ) —
Pied Bushchat ( Saxicola caprata) — —
Yelloweyed Babbler ( Chrysomma sinense ) +
Purplerumped Sunbird ( Nectarinia zeylonica ) +
Indian Pipit ( Anthus novaeseelandiae ) — +
Quaker Babbler ( Alcippe poioicephala ) +
Redwinged Bush Lark ( Mirafra erythroptera ) +
Wood Shrike {T ephrodornis pondicerianus ) - +
Redheaded Bunting ( EMberiza bruniceps ) + +
Ashy Wren-Warbler ( Prinia socialis ) +
Whitebacked Munia ( Lonchura striata ) +
Spotted Munia ( Lonchura punctulata) -!-
1
2
2
1
1
2
C
1
12
1
1
3
2
3
1
1
Species observed at Pachgaon only , Awsari only +++, both f K
C means common. *J=July, A=August, etc.
the plantations and take advantage of the protection and food sources
offered by the more stable vegetation.
During the dry months, the grasslands outside the plantations were
observed to contain only a few Larks, Pipits, and Crows. Table 1 shows
that 13 species were observed at Pachgaon and not Awsari, 18 at both,
and 17 at only Awsari. The definite increase in vegetation seen in the
stages of plantation development and these concomitant changes in
resident species further suggest the parallel of plantation development
to ecological succession.
The results of mist netting showed that the birds at Awsari were
concentrated in the outer, more diverse, area. Over three times as
many species and almost seven times as many birds per net-hour were
captured in the outer area as in the inner area. Perhaps the higher
foliage of the Eucalyptus tree caused fewer birds to be captured in the
ground-level nets in the inner area, but walking observations support-
ed the conclusion that few birds forage in the inner area. Data taken
over nine days shows that as many birds were seen perching on Euca-
lyptus as other trees. However, tabulation of the nest locations of the
Common Weaverbird ( Ploceus philippinus ), Redvented Bulbul
( Pycnonotus cafer), Rufousbacked Shrike ( Lanius schach ), and Little
Brown Dove ( Streptopelia senegalensis ) at Awsari showed that no
nests were found in Eucalyptus trees or in the inner area but 74 nests
were found in the outer area on Babul, Cassia, Sissu, and one Toddy
Palm ( Borassus flabellifer) .
Orians (1969) has stated that the number of bird species in undis-
80 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
turbed forests in Costa Rica is not measurably affected by the number
of species of trees in the forest. The difference in the bird species
diversity between the inner and outer areas at Awsari seems to con-
tradict this finding. Even though there is a wider vertical distribution
of foliage in the primarily single species inner area, more birds and
more species were observed in the outer area containing multiple species
of trees. This difference could be associated with a “quality” of the
Eucalyptus tree to support bird life rather than the height of foliage
distribution or tree species diversity.
Thus, besides their economic importance and despite the contro-
versial usefulness of Eucalyptus to wildlife, these introduced planta-
tions have enhanced the local avifauna by providing stable vegetation,
It is probable that the usefulness of these plantations to wildlife would
be much increased if more diverse tree species were planted.
ACK N OWLFDGE M E N TS
This project was done under the Associated Colleges of the Mid-
west’s India Studies Programme, directed by Dr. John Stanley. Thanks
are due to Shri S. M. Ketkar, my project advisor. Drs. Paul Jenson,
Dean Amadou, Penny Williamson, Eugene Morton, and Charles South-
wick helpfully criticized the manuscript.
References
Ali S. (1968) : The Book of Indian
Birds. Bombay Natural History So-
ciety, Bombay.
Orians G. H. (1969): The number
of bird species in some tropical
forests. Ecology 50(5) :783-801.
A new species of Eriocaulon
from Maharashtra
BY
A. R. Kulkarni and M. H. Desai
Botany Department, Shivaji University, Kolhapur
(With a plate )
Eriocaulon tuberiferuin sp. nov.
•
Herbae tuberiferae, tuberibus 5-15 stipitatis c. 4 mm longis 2.5
mm latis ovalibus vel bilobatis dense pilosis, pilis unicellularibus, caule
reducto, foliis basalibus rosulatis linearilanceolatis recurvatis 1.6-4. 3
cm longis, medio 2-3 mm latis, acutis utrinque glabris 5-7 nervatis,
vaginis viridibus ad pedunculos arete adpressis 2.5-4.5 cm longis gla-
bris ad apicem oblique fissis, pedunculis 1 vel 2 (raro 3) gracilibus
11-18 cm longis 5- vel 6-costatis, in siccitate conspicue tortis glabris,
capitulis globosis niveis 3-7 mm diametro, bracteis involucrantibus
numerosis lanceolatis c. 1.7 mm longis 1.1 mm latis obtusis glabris
nigris, receptaculo glabro, bracteis receptacularibus atroviridibus con-
cavis 2-2.8 mm longis c. 1 mm latis obtusis versus apicem dorso vil-
losis; floribus masculis in omnes partes capituli numerosis, calyce spat-
haceo atroviridi c. 2.3 mm longo 1.8 mm lato distincte 3-lobato sur-
sum dorso dense piloso, petalis 3 pilosis in tubum membranaceum
album c. 1.4 mm longum connatis, loborum petalorum uno distincte
magniore et ultra bracteolos receptaculares exserto c. 2 mm longo
1 mm lato, lobis minoribus c. 1.1 mm longis c. 0.5 mm latis, lobis
omnibus medio glanduliferis, staminibus 6, antheris juventute albis
senectute nigrescentibus, pistillodiis 3 flavidis in tubo petalorum occul-
tis; floribus foemineis paucis solum in peripheria capituli dispositis,
sepalis 3 libris viridibus concavis rotundatis c. 1.9 mm longis c. 0.4
mm latis sursum dorso dense pilosis, petalis 3 subaequalibus papyraceis
spathulatis 1.9-2. 7 mm longis 0.25-0.5 mm latis dense pilosis, glandula
subapicali, ovario parvo trigono c. 0.6 mm longo c. 0.25 mm lato
triloculari, stigmatibus 3 c. 0.6 mm longis subsessilibus.
Tuberiferous herbs; tubers stalked, 5-15 per plant, about 4 mm
long, 2.5 mm broad, oval or bilobed, covered with dense growth of
1 Accepted July 27, 1972.
6
82 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
I
unicellular hairs. Stem reduced; leaves basal, rosulate, linearlanceolate,
recurved, 1.6-4. 3 cm long, 2-3 mm wide in the middle, acute at apex,
glabrous on both the surfaces, 5-7 nerved; sheaths green, closely ap-
pressed to the peduncles, 2.5-4.5 cm long, glabrous, obliquely split at
the apex; peduncles 1-2 (rarely 3) per plant, slender, 11-18 cm long,
5-6 costate, conspicuously twisted in the dried specimens, glabrous;
heads globose, snow white, 3-7 mm in diameter; involucral bractlets
many, lanceolate, about 1.7 mm long, 1.1 mm wide, obtuse at apex,
glabrous, black; receptacle glabrous; receptacular bractlets deep green,
concave, 2-2.8 mm long, about 1 mm wide, obtuse at apex, densely
white villous on the back towards the apex: Staminate florets numer-
ous, both towards periphery and the centre of the head; calyx spath-
aceous, deep green, about 2.3 mm long, 1.8 mm wide, distinctly 3-lobed,
densely hairy on the back towards the apex; petals 3, hairy, united
into a whitish membraneous tube about 1.4 mm long, one of the petal
lobes distinctly larger and protruding beyond the receptacular bractlets;
the larger lobe about 2 mm long, 1 mm wide, the smaller ones about
1.1 mm long, about 0.5 mm wide; all the lobes medially gland-tipped;
stamens 6, anthers white when young but become blackish at maturity;
pollen grains spheroidal varying from 26.6 to 53.2 ^ in diameter,
spiraperturate or with many distinct convoluted unthickened bands,
exine smooth; pistillodes 3, pale yellow, hidden in petal tube: Female
florets few, restricted to the periphery of the head; sepals 3, free, green,
concave, rounded at apex, about 1.9 mm long, about 0.4 mm broad,
densely hairy on the back towards the apex; petals 3, subequal, papery,
spathulate, 1.9-2. 7 mm long, 0.25-0.5 mm wide, densely hairy, gland
subapical; ovary small, trigonous, about 0.6 mm long, about 0.25 mm
wide, trilocular, 3-ovuled; stigmas 3, about 0.6 mm long, subsessile.
Holotype was collected from Panhala (938 m alt.), Kolhapur dis-
trict, Maharashtra, along the margins of puddles on 28th July 1968
and is deposited in National Herbarium, Calcutta under Kulkarni and
Desai 537 and the Isotypes 538-540 are deposited in the Herbarium
of the Shivaji University, Botany Department, Kolhapur.
E. tuberiferum is closely related to E. ritchieanum Ruhl. and E.
leucomelas Steud. From the former it differs in the transition of the
anther colour from white in younger condition to blackish at maturity
and in its distinct anisopetalous male flower, the largest petal of which
projects beyond the receptacular bractlets giving fringed appearance
to the head. From the latter species it differs in the petal characters
of the male flowers and in having distinctly oblique mouth for the
penduncular sheaths. It differs from all the species of Eriocaulon known
so far in its tuberiferous habit.
Members of this species are commonly seen along the margins of
puddles at Panhala from July-September. They grow in association
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (1) Plate
Kulkarni and Desai: Eriocaulon tuberiferum
Eriocaulon tuberiferum Kulkarni et Desai
Fig. 1. Male flower. Fig. 2. Female flower. Fig. 3. Stamen. Figs. 4-6. Pollen
grains. Fig. 7. Entire plant. Fig. 8. Leaf. Fig. 9. Involucral bractlet. Fig. 10.
Receptacular bractlet. Fig. 11. Basal part of the plant showing tubers. Fig. 12.
Stalked tuber. Fig. 13. A part of peduncle showing twists. Fig. 14. Germinated
tuber. Fig. 15. Gynoecium. Fig. 16. Gynoecium with sepals. Figs. 17-19. Petals
of the female flower.
NEW SPECIES OF ERIOCAULON
83
with Isoetes. The species has also been collected from Radhanagari
(Kolhapur district) where it grows in similar habitat. Further intensive
collections may reveal its presence in other areas of Sahyadri ranges
enjoying similar ecological conditions.
Inspite of very close observations during the last three years,
we have failed to collect fruiting specimens of this species from
both the localities. It appears probable that the species mainly repro-
duces by tubers in nature.
The Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, when referred to, informed us
that the specimens resembled E. leucomelas Steud. ( E . melaleucum
Mart.) superficially, appearing to be distinct both in foliage and flower
and belonged to Eriocaulon ritchieanum Ruhl. but with abnormal
flowers possibly due to nematode attack. The structures referred here
as tubers were suspected by the authorities of Kew to be nematode
cysts. However, later studies by us on the ontogeny and the germin-
ability of the tubers (Kulkarni & Desai 1970), precluded the possibility
of these being nematode cysts. Further, detailed examination of the
specimens of Eriocaulon ritchieanum represented in national and re-
gional herbaria of the Botanical Survey of India revealed that the
tuberiferous specimens differed in some of their vegetative as well as
floral characters apart from their tuberiferous habit from E. ritchie-
anum. Compartive account of the differentiating features of E. rit-
chieanum, E. leucomelas and E. tuberiferum is given in Table I.
Table I
E. leucomelas
E. ritchieanum E. tuberiferum
Peduncular
Sheath
mouth truncate,
narrowly
scarious
mouth oblique
or divided in 2-5
segments
mouth distinctly
oblique not
scarious
Peduncles
1-4, 5-8-ribbed 1-many, not
ribbed
1-3, 5-6 ribbed,
twisted
MALE FLOWER
Calyx
spathaceous, spathaceous, spathaceous, split
split on one side split on one on one side, dis-
side, truncate or tinctly 3-lobed
obscurely 3-lobed
Corolla
2 lobes subequal lobes subequal lobes unequal,
the largest pro-
truding beyond
the receptacular
bractlet giving
fringed appearance
to the head
84 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (1)
2 Though many workers (Fyson 1921, 1922; Moldenke 1969 a and b) have
described petals of the male flowers in E. leucomelas to be subequal, Fischer
(1935) describes them to be distinctly unequal with the largest petal protruding
beyond the receptacular bractlets.
Considering all these features it has now been proposed to assign
the tuberiferous specimens to a distinct species, Eriocaulon tuberiferum.
The specific epithet has been chosen from their remarkable tuberifer-
ous habit, a feature unique to the genus Eriocaulon.
Acknowledgements
We are deeply indebted to the authorities of the Royal Botanic
Gardens, Kew, England for their opinion and to Dr. H. N. Moldenke
of U.S.A. for critically going through the manuscript and translating
the description into Latin. They are also thankful to the authorities
of the Botanical Survey of India for lending the specimens of Erio-
caulon ritchieanum from their herbaria for comparison.
References
Fischer, C. E. C. (1935): Eriocau-
laceae in the Flora of the Presidency
of Madras 3, 1119-1128. Reprinted
by Govt, of India, Calcutta.
Fyson, P. F. (1921): The Indian
species of Eriocaulon, E. geoffreyi
Fyson. Journ. Indian Bot. Soc. 2: 196.
(1922): The Ind-
ian species of Eriocaulon, E. horsley-
konde var. megalocephala Fyson. ibid.
3:14.
Kulkarni, A. R. & Desai, M. H.
(1970): Tubers in Eriocaulon ritch-
ieanum Ruhl. J. Bombay nat. Hist.
Soc. 67:134-135.
Moldenke, H. N. (1969a): Addi-
tional notes on the Eriocaulaceae XX,
E. leucomelas Steud. Phytologia 18:
(4), 262-265.
(1969b): Addi-
tional notes on the Eriocaulaceae
XXV, E. leucomelas Steud. ibid.
79(2) : 74-75.
Fishery resources of Ullal
(Mangalore) in relation to
certain environmental factors
during 1963-671
BY
M. S. Prabhu2, S. Ramamurthy3, M. H. Dhulkhed4,
N. S, Radhakrishnan5 and G. P. Kumaraswamy Achari6
Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute
{With four text-figures)
Introduction
Ullal, an important fishing centre situated 3 Km south of Mangalore,
was known for shark fishery in the past. However, owing to the decline
in the shark fishery, fishing for sardine, mackerel etc has been resorted
to bottom dwelling during the past two decades. While Mangalore is
at present a landing centre for ground fishes of the mechanised boats,
Ullal is of special significance, being the nearest fishing village where
various types of indigenous gears are employed mainly for pelagic
fishes. Yet, the fishery potentiality of this area has remained unknown.
However, certain observations on the mackerel fishery of this area have
been made by Rao et al. (1962). This account relates to the total fish
landings and the major categories of fishes contributing to the fishery
with observations on the relation of sardine and mackerel catches to
plankton, salinity, temperature and rainfall.
Fishing Methods
The types of gears operated at Ullal are shown in Table I.
1 Accepted May 6, 1972.
2 Present address: University of Calicut, Dept, of Fisheries, Calicut
University P.O., Kerala.
3, 4, 5 „ Central Marine Fisheries Research Substation, Bolar,
Mangalore-1, (Karnataka State).
„ Central Marine Fisheries Research Substation, Vizhin-
gam, via- Trivandrum, Kerala.
Details of fishing gears
86 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
■ rj ©
© >
©
IS
©
©
d
H
d
o
bU
d
T3
CQ
8
a)
’H X
lO rt
S 2
2 c
o ^
PQ'oo
o
bD
d
-a
JH VO
©
Cd o
© -M
co
8 x
■g©
dim
O O
a
d
O
bO
d
J3 VO
©
cd O
© +->
8 x
.2o
O —i
a
d
o
bfl
d
o)
d3<N
© —V
cd
© o
s©
© ^
©
•g x
d
O
oo n
o 2
a
d
o
oo
d
T3
— ■ “ Whether selective Area of operation
Name of the Unit Man power Type of net Dimensions of the net* or non_seiective
FISHERY RESOURCES OF ULLAL
87
SO
y
ctf o
03
0>
o X
<D
© o
r— I -4— »
X! so
o
o
<L) -M
<U ,
o X
<u
'ShO
^ ^ o
03
<U
*Sh x
o o
<N <N
of O
in
'ax
8 so
o -2
rl
Mesh in cm depth in metres
88 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
While most of the nets are operated by the fishermen of Ullal, fish-
ing by Rampant and Kollibale at this centre is done by fishermen from
the neighbouring villages north and south of Ullal respectively. Nor-
mally, fishing is suspended from the middle of June to end of July due
to the unfavourable conditions during the south-west monsoon. Fishing
is resumed with cast net ( Beesubale ) operations mainly for prawns,
soles and sardines during August-October following which this gear
together with Chalabale and Idabale are employed for catching sardines
exclusively. Occasionally, a small meshed (about 1 cm) cast net called
Kooribale is also operated during the monsoon for catching small
varieties of fishes. Although big meshed gill nets namely Pattabale and
Kanthabale are operated for catching medium and big-sized mackerel,
other fishes like Hi Isa kanagurta, Anadontostoma chachunda, sharks
and rays and prawns consisting of mostly Penaeus sp. are also caught.
The other types of gill nets namely Manangubale and Bolingerbale are
operated exclusively for Thrissocles spp. and Kowala coval respectively.
Odubale usually operated from September to February, catch mainly
Cybium spp., Chirocentrus spp., and sharks and rays. Kollibale and
Rampani are employed when large shoals of pelagic fishes like sardine
and mackerel occur. During the summer months of March to May
Maribale operations are carried out for catching cat fishes.
Collection of Data and Estimation of Landings
The data presented here relate to the period July 1963 to June 1967
when observations were made on all the working days. Usually about
20 per cent of the total number of each type of unit operated were
examined and the monthly total catch in respect of each type of unit
was estimated as was followed by Rao et al. (1962). While estimating
the catch, the weights of major categories of fishes such as sardine,
mackerel, prawns etc. were noted down separately. Surface plankton
and water samples for salinity estimation were collected off Ullal once
a week together with temperature readings. An attempt was made to
correlate these data with the fluctuations in the pelagic fishery resources
of this area.
Analysis of Data
The data collected have been analysed to study the seasonal vari-
ations in the catch during the different years, fluctuations in the annual
catch and the dominant species contributing to the fishery. In order to
determine the relative importance of the different gears and the com-
FISHERY RESOURCES OF ULLAL
89
mercially important species caught by them, the data have been sub-
jected to an analysis on a gearwise basis. Since the fishery for oil sar-
dine and mackerel is known to fluctuate from year to year, data on
plankton volume, temperature, salinity and rainfall of this area have
been plotted against the landings of these species during the period of
this investigation to find out the relationship, if any.
a) Annual and seasonal variations in the total catch
Comparing the total fish landings of the different years (Table II)
it is seen that catches during 1964-65 and 1966-67 (718.4 and 747.2
tonnes respectively) were better than those of 1963-64 and 1965-66
(228.8 and 454.9 tonnes respectively). From the monthly variations in
the catch for different years, it has been observed that the fishery was
generally good between September and April with the peaks occurring
during September-October and January- April, the latter being dominant
during most of the years. Usually, the catches dwindled after April
and the poor landings recorded during June- July may be attributed
to the decreased fishing activity during the peak of the south-west
monsoon.
b) Catch composition and gearwise landings
Although the category of fishes such as Arius spp. Kowala coval,
Cynoglossus spp., Leiognathus spp. and Thrissocles spp. together clas-
sified as ‘others’ constituted the bulk of the landings during 1963-64
and 1964-65 (Table II), oil sardine remained the single largest fishery
in all the years. It is interesting to note that the oil sardine landings
even exceeded those of ‘others’ during 1965-66 and 1966-67 constitut-
ing 62.4 and 51.6 per cent respectively. The trend of the monthly oil
sardine catches generally coincided with that of the total catch.
The mackerel fishery was good only during 1963-64 when it formed
29.3 per cent which was even higher than the oil sardine catch (22.8%).
Subsequently, the fishery declined with a tendency for revival during
1966-67. Unlike the sardine fishery, the mackerel fishery was restricted
to short periods with the peak occurring during October and Novem-
ber. However, a secondary peak was noticed in May during all the
years except in 1966-67. Comparing the trend of oil sardine and mack-
erel fishery, no definite relation was discernible on a monthwise basis.
However, from the annual trend it was observed that while the oil
sardine catches were on the increase leading to a bumper fishery in
1966-67, the mackerel fishery was declining touching its lowest ebb in
1965-66.
As in the case of mackerel, the prawn fishery also was active only
for brief periods during July-September which coincided with the south-
west monsoon season. The fishery was supported chiefly by a single
species namely, Metapenaeus dobsoni. The prawn fishery noticed dur-
ing January, February and sometimes April was meagre and it was
Monthwise catch in Kg of different categories of fishes during different years
90
JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
1963-64 1964-65 1965-66 1966-67
FISHERY RESOURCES OF ULLAL
91
constituted by bigger varieties such as Penaeus indicus and P. mergui-
ensis.
Among the ‘other’ categories. Anus spp. accounted for the bulk
of this group during 1964-65 and 1966-67 forming 73 and 82 per cent
respectively, whereas Kowala coval, Cynoglossus spp., Leiognathus
spp. and A. chacundci together formed about 72 per cent during 1963-
64 and Cynoglossus spp., Leiognathus spp., A. chacunda and H.
kanagurta 73 per cent during 1965-66. It was interesting to note that
the cat fish fishery was prevalent only during alternate years. Though
this fishery was restricted to one or two months in a year ( February -
March 1965 and April 1967), huge quantities were landed within this
short period. When the cat fish shoals are sighted, the fishermen gener-
ally fish them exclusively because of the better returns. The
fishery for Kowala coval, generally lasting from December to May,
constituted about 38.0, 3.1, 13.0 and 3.0 per cent respectively during
the years 1963-64 to 1966-67. Cynoglossus spp. and Leiognathus spp.,
appeared together in large quantities from August to October, forming
about 19.0, 13.3, 51.3 and 1.5 per cent respectively during the above
years. Thrissocles spp. were caught throughout the year but the maxi-
mum quantity was landed generally between July and October, They
constituted 10.4, 3.4, 11.8 and 2.1 per cent respectively among the ‘other’
categories during the years of study.
For a study of the importance of the various types of gears, the
catches landed by these during the different years are given in Table III
from which it can be seen that Mari hale, Chalabale, Cast nets, Bolin-
gerbale, Pattabale and Kanthabale were the most important gears
accounting for the major portion of the catch during the entire period.
Among these, Mari bale landed the maximum catches during 1964-65
and 1966-67 and Chalabale during 1965-66. The landings by cast nets
were consistently good throughout the period. Except during 1966-67,
Bolingerbale brought fairly good catch. The landings by Pattabale were
best in 1963-64 and those of Kanthabale in 1966-67.
The proportion of each of the major category of fishes caught by
the different gears (Table IV), shows that sardines are netted mainly
by Chalabale and cast nets. Kollibale , the most commonly used gear
in the southern region for sardine fishery, was operated only on a few
occasions during 1964-65 and 1966-67, which accounted for a small
percentage of the sardine catch. Similarly, Rampani, a shoreseine
operated for sardine and mackerel in the northern region, was employed
only once in 1966-67 accounting for 6.2 per cent. For the other pelagic
variety namely mackerel, Pattabale was found to be the most success-
ful gear accounting for more than two-thirds of the entire mackerel
catch during all the years. The rest of the catch was by Kanthabale .
Majority of the prawn catch was by cast nets during all the years.
Gearwise catch in Kg of the major categories of fishes during different years
92
JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
c
3
Oh
B
3
&
3 <u
O x>
a xi
T3 3
HH X,
Ih
OX) .V
G JO
S 01
o *
CO
o 73
03
£}
o3 o3
CO JD
3
OX)
3
03 «
S «*
03 x
3
f* 03
U
1963-64 1964-65 1965-66 1966-67
Percentages of major categories of fishes caught by different gears
FISHERY RESOURCES OF ULLAL
93
c
cd
Co
s
cd
Pi
O
7d
X
P
00
a
cd
a
i i i
! I I
I I
O m
U cl
I I I
o
s I I
S5 I
o S
I I I
I I
3 I I
I £ I
I I 2
rf o
o r4
■o «
t-i 5rj t»
cd J> c
C/) >
- S 1
oS£
I I
2 I I
I I I
I 5
I vn
I ©
T3 <L>
Im ti
cd 0)
«3 ^
— cd cd
o S £
I I I
I 88 I
Tf '-H
00 o od
I I
i. I
r-- rj
t~-’ I
rr •> l ns
6 S
1963-64
1964-65 1965-66 1966-67
94 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
However, fairly good proportion of the prawn catches was landed by
Kanthabale during 1963-64 and 1965-66.
Relation of the Pelagic Fisheries to Ecological conditions
Mean monthly temperature, salinity and displacement volume of
plankton of the surface waters off Ullal together with the sardine and
mackerel landings are shown in Text Figs. 1 to 4. Temperature was
low during August- January, the minimum value ranging between 25.4
to 25.6°C. However, within this period it showed an increase in Octo-
ber except in 1963-64 when it was in November. Temperature remain-
ed high during April-May (29.8 to 31.0°C). Salinity was low during
August-September (13.9 to 30.9%0) followed by an increase till Decem-
Fig. 1 . Monthly landings of oil sardine and mackerel in relation to temperature,
salinity, rainfall and plankton volume during 1963-64.
PLAN KTO N
FISHERY RESOURCES OF ULLAL
95
ber (29.4 to 35.1 %0) with a drop in January-February (Figs. 2 to 4)
except in 1963-64 when the salinity values were steadily rising (Fig. 1).
Maximum values for salinity were obtained during April-May (34.2
to 37.0%0). The period of low salinity coincided with the south-west
monsoon season (June to September) when the monthly maximum
rainfall ranged from 86.8 to 95.0 cm. Comparing the annual rainfall
during the four years of study, it was found to be highest in 1963-64
(306.5 cm) and lowest in 1965-66 (274.1 cm).
The characteristics of the plankton volume varied widely from year
to year with peaks in December ’63 (18.9 ml), March ’64 (22.0 ml),
October ’64 (39.0 ml). May ’65 (13.7 ml), October-November ’65
23.3-24.5 ml) and February (13.0 ml) and May ’66 (17.7 ml) and March
’67 (37.8 ml). The minimum plankton volume was recorded during
November ’66 (1.8 ml) and the maximum in October ’64 (39.0 ml).
Considering the monthly variations of the plankton volume during
£
u
_J 40
<
u_
E80
<
40
>
^30
s
5 20
\
EL*
£
K 10
60
40
120
w
w
SALINITY Vo
TEMPERATURE °c
PLANKTON ml,
OIL SARDINE
MACKEREL
RAINFALL
1— «.
.60
>
40 z
7Z
H
o
20Z
M
M
J A S O N A J F
1964-65
Fig. 2. Monthly landings of oil sardine and mackerel in relation to temperature,
salinity, rainfall and plankton volume during 1964-65.
96 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
the different years, no definite relationship was discernible between
these and the sardine and mackerel fisheries.
When the sardine fishery was good the temperature was found to
range from 25.4 to 27.7°C and salinity from 30.1 to 33.8%0. However,
in the course of this study, good catches of oil sardine were recorded
even in higher ranges of temperature (28.0 to 30.5 °C) and salinity
(33.8 to 35.5%0) during the period February- April ’67. At Calicut,
while a temperature range of 28.0 to 29.0°C was found to be favour-
able for the sardine fishery, no consistent relation was noticed between
salinity and the fishery (Sekharan 1962a). Along North Kanara coast
the period of sardine fishery had temperature and salinity ranges of
26.8 to 30.3°C and 22.2 to 34.53%0 respectively (Ramamurthy 1965).
In general, the mackerel fishery was not as good as that of oil
sardine, its peaks coinciding with the temperature and salinity ranges
40
80
40
30
<
J)20
Q_
£
H 10
o)60
40
X20
to
I
SALINITY %0
TEMPERATURE °c
PLANKTON
OIL SARDINE
MACKEREL
RAINFALL
11
M
Lit
N D J
19 65-66
M
M
.60
40
20
Fig. 3. Monthly landings of oil sardine and mackerel in relation to temperature,
salinity, rainfall and plankton volume during 1965-66.
PLANKTON
FISHERY RESOURCES OF ULLAL
91
of 26.9 to 30.5 °C and 29.4 to 34.4%0 respectively. In 1963-64, however,
the fishery was good even at a higher salinity of 37.0%0 in May.
Sekharan (1962b) stated that intermediate values for temperature
(27.0 to 28.0°C) and salinity (34.2 to 35.44%0) representing an up-
ward trend after their minimum values occurred during the mackerel
season at Mandapam. Subsequently, while dealing with the mackerel
fishery of Calicut, Pradhan & Reddy (1962) have reported that high
temperature and salinity affect the fishery adversely. The mackerel
season in North Kanara coast coincided with the transition period from
the low salinity and temperature conditions during the south west mon-
soon period to the high salinity and warmer conditions in summer
(Ramamurthy 1965).
Normally, the bulk of the sardine catch was landed following the
period of heavy rainfall during the south-west monsoon season. How-
i
«40l_
_i
z80
I
M
XX
KX
<X
o
*
W
SALINITY Vo
TEMPERATURE °c
PLANKTON rryi.
OIL SARDINE
MACKEREL
RAINFALL
■p*r
at
K*
XX
»
XX
at
«
XX
XX
Fig. 4. Monthly landings of oil sardine and mackerel in relation to temperature,
salinity, rainfall and plankton volume during 1966-67.
7
PLANKTON
98 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
ever, fairly good quantities of oil sardine were also caught late in the
season viz., February ’64 and February and April ’67 when the rain-
fall was negligible during the preceding months. The best catches of
mackerel were also made following the south-west monsoon rains. The
total mackerel landings appeared to have a direct relation to the annual
rainfall, the maximum catch (67.0 tonnes) and rainfall (306.5 cm)
occurring in 1963-64 and the minimum (9.97 tonnes and 274.1 cm
respectively) in 1965-66. Pradhan & Reddy (1962), on the contrary,
found an inverse relation between the annual rainfall and mackerel
at Calicut. The sardine fishery at Ullal, on the other hand, was at its
lowest (52.1 tonnes) in 1963-64 when the rainfall was heaviest (306.5
cm). The catches were better during 1965-66 and 1966-67 (283.7 and
385.6 tonnes respectively) when the annual rainfall was comparatively
low (274.1 and 283.6 cm respectively).
References
Pradhan, L. B. & Reddy, C. V. C.
(1962): Fluctuations in mackerel
landings at Calicut in relation to
hydrological factors. Indian J. Fish.
9 A: 100-109.
Ramamurthy, S. (1965) : Studies
on the plankton of the North Kanara
Coast in relation to the pelagic fishery.
J. Mar. biol. Ass. India 7:127-149.
Rao, V. Ramamohana, Sekharan,
K. V. & Pradhan, M. J. (1962): On
the mackerel fishery of the Manga-
lore area during the period 1957-61.
Indian J. Fish. 9 A: 653-678.
Sekharan, K. V. (1962a): On the
oil sardine fishery of the Calicut area
during the years 1955-56 to 1958-59.
ibid. 9A: 679-700.
(1962b): On the
mackerel fishery of the Mandapam
area. ibid. 9A: 714-727.
Observations on the breeding
mechanism of Biophytum
candolleanum Wt.
BY
R. Vasudevan Nair
Victoria College, Pal ghat, Kerala
{With a plate)
Among angiosperms there are 28 families with heterostylous genera
(Beryl S. Vuilleumier 1965). Of these, 5 families include trimorphic
heterostyled genera. Plants reported to be trimorphic are: Oxalis
(Mulcahy 1964; Ornduff 1964); Averrhoa (Ornduff, Pers. comm.);
Lythrum (Darwin 1877; East 1940); Nasaea (Darwin 1877; East 1940);
Houstonia (Darwin 1877); Eichhornia (Johnson 1924; Uchida 1953);
Pontedaria (Hazen 1918; Ornduff 1966); Reussia (East 1940); Anie-
lema (Vogel 1955) and Biophytum (Mayura Devi 1964).
In trimorphic hererostyly, a species will have 3 floral forms regard-
ing length of style and height of anthers. This morphological hetero-
morphism is accompanied by biological specialisation in breeding.
Considerable work has been done on the breeding mechanism of
dimorphic heterostylous plants since Hildebrand (1866) and Darwin
(1877) but relatively less is known about breeding of tristylous plants.
Nora Barlow, grand daughter of Darwin, was the first to study the
genetic mechanism of heterostylous plants viz. Lythrum salicaria and
species of Oxalis. Since then Hazen (1918), Johnson (1924), East
(1940), Lewis (1943), Uchida (1953), Vogel (1955), Bahadur (1963)
and Ornduff (1964) have investigated this phenomenon.
Mayura Devi reported in 1964, that in the tristylous Biophytum
sensitivum DC. floral trimorphism is associated with an incompatibility
system. I studied the breeding mechanism of another species of the
same genus viz. B. candolleanum, described by J. S. Gamble in his
Flora of Madras Presidency, vol. i, 94.
Biophytum candolleanum {B. sensitivium var. candolleana Edgw. &
Hook, f.) is a small unbranched annual with pinnately compound,
sensitive leaves crowded at the apex of a narrow stem up to 35 cm
in height. Peduncles many, axillary, up to 20 cm long but shorter
100 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
usually. Flowers pedicellate, hermaphrodite, actinomorphic, hypogyn-
ous and trimorphic. The 3 forms of flowers are:
long- styled with mid and short stamens,
mid-styled with long and short stamens and
short-styled with long and mid stamens.
Fruits 5-valved loculicidal capsules protected by persisting sepals. Seeds
20-25 per fruit, very small, brownish red, tubercled and arillate. Grow-
ing season of the plant is from July to November.
Table 1
Pollen grains are similar to those of B. sensitivum DC., in shape.
There is gradation in size of pollen from short stamen to that of long.
They form almost a regular series gradually increasing in size.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Young plants of B. candolleanum collected from wild populations
at Dharmadam, Tellicherry, Kerala, in July 1969 were used for the
study initially. In 1970, plants collected from Palghat, Kerala, were
used to repeat some of the crosses done previously. Plants were trans-
planted in the laboratory, in small wooden boxes. After flowering they
were sorted out into long, mid and short-styled forms. Out of 135
plants, 30 were long-styled, 55 mid-styled and 50 short-styled.
Pollination experiments were conducted to find out incompatibility
system, if any, in this species. To prevent visit of insects and contami-
nation of pollen, inflorescences were kept enclosed in bags of poly-
thene. In short-styled flowers, sepals had to be cut short to do artificial
pollination. Flowers emasculated in the evening were often found
withering by next morning. So when emasculation was necessary, it
was done at midnight, before dehiscence of anthers. Pollinated flowers
were again kept bagged.
BREEDING MECHANISM OF BIOPHYTUM CANDOLLEANUM 101
POPULATION STRUCTURE
Eliot (1892) recorded a population composition of 25 long; 54
mid: 21 short or about 1:2:1 ratio in the tristylous Oxalis suksdorfii.
In 1939, Faberge also reported a similar representation of forms in a
population of the same species, which was composed of 246 long:
453 mid: 207 short. Ornduff, in 1964 examined ten sample populations.
The mid-styled form made up the largest class in four of these.
As the random collection made for transplantation showed difference
in proportion of the 3 forms in B. candolleanum, 3 more populations
were counted to find out the frequency of the 3 types. Result is shown
in table 2.
Table 2
Population composition of B. candolleanum
Finney (1952) called anisoplethy (inequality of different floral forms).
In all observed cases the mid-styled form makes up the largest class
and long-styled the smallest. Short-styled form comes close to the mid-
styled, in number. But there is no definite 1:2:1 ratio.
Pollination
To find out whether self pollination was taking place, flowers of
the 3 forms were kept bagged and unpollinated, for several days.
Though flowers opened regularly, there was no fruit-setting even in one.
This shows that insect visit is essential for pollination and setting of
fruits. Insects like honey-bees, bugs and flies were found visiting the
flowers in field.
Self fertility of the 3 forms of flowers was determined by artificial
pollination. Flowers opened inside polythene bags were used for this.
In the first instance, pollen from the longer set of stafnens was trans-
ferred to the stigmas of the same flower. Later the same experiments
were repeated with pollen from the short stamens. Results are shown
below.
102 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
A SELFING WITH POLLEN FROM LONGER STAMENS OF SAME FLOWER
The above data show that in B. candolleanam, the 3 forms of
flowers have self sterility in varying degree. The mid-styled form is
relatively unspecialised, being fully self-fertile. Short-styled form is also
very highly self compatible. Maximum self incompatibility is found
in the long-styled form. The unspecialised mid-styled form does not
show specificity to type of pollen received; pollen from both sets of
stamens are equally effective. But in long-styled flowers, pollen from
shorter stamens is totally ineffective.
In heterostylous plants self-pollination is called ‘illegitimate’
(Darwin 1865). In Ly thrum salicaria, several tristylous species of
Oxalis, and many distylous species, the morphological adaptation for
cross-pollination is reinforced by incompatibility system, preventing
fertilization after illegitimate pollinations. But in some plants such
incompatibility does not accompany heterostyly (Hildebrand 1887;
Ray & Chisaki 1957). In B. candolleanum, there is an incompati-
bility system, though not perfect. The long-styled form is highly self-
incompatible.
BREEDING MECHANISM OF BIOPHYTUM CANDOLLEANUM 103
Cross-pollinations
Pollination between anther and stigma at the same level in dif-
ferent forms of flowers is called ‘legitimate’ (Darwin 1865), because
it is believed that heterostyly is an adaptation to promote cross breed-
ing in hermaphrodite flowers and that such pollinations are the most
productive. Where pollen grains of the different sets of anthers are
markedly different in morphology, it is easier to find out which type
of pollen falls on a stigma. But in B. candolleanum it is difficult be-
cause the pollen grains show a gradation in size. So crossing was con-
ducted to determine the productivity of pollen from different sets of
anthers. Results of some legitimate and illegitimate crosses are given
below.
A Legitimate Cross
Type of cross Number of Number of fruits Seed range
pollination formed
Long-styled flower as seed parent
Long style x Long stamen
From the above data it is evident that B. candolleanum is similar
to B. sensitivum DC. in legitimate crosses. In natural populations there
is apparently little difference in the rate of fruit and seed setting bet-
ween the 3 types of flowers. The comparatively lower rate of fruiting
observed in short-styled form in artificial legitimate crossing may pos-
sibly be due to imperfection of pollen transfer. In these flowers styles
curve out and bend down so that the stigmas are horizontal or even
104 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
facing down. In emasculated flowers this curving is even more. In hand
pollination it is probable that enough pollen grains do not stick on to
the stigmas.
B Illegitimate crosses
Percentage of seed formation with respect to pollination was not
determined, though the range of variation in number of seeds was
noted. It is found that the number of ovules is not constant in all
ovaries of even the same type of flower. It varies from 15 to 30. Occa-
sionally, aborted ovules are also seen. Hence, determination of fertility
on the basis of number of seeds could be exact only when large number
of pollinations are considered. Ready setting of fruits with well formed
seeds has therefore been taken as indicating compatibility.
Pollination experiments show that B. candolleanum is slightly dif-
ferent from B. sensitivum DC. in the case of illegitimate crosses. Short-
styled form of B. sensitivum DC. is reported to be self compatible only
in low degree (Mayura Devi 1964), whereas in B. candolleanum, self
compatibility is more than 70 per cent. Mid-styled form of this species
is even more self compatible than in B. sensitivum DC. and unlike in
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (1) Plate
Nair : Biophytum candolleanum
Biophytum candolleanum Wt.
Fig. 1 & 2, Open flowers; Figs. 3, 4, 5, essential organs of mid, long and short-
styled flowers; Figs. 6, 7, 8, gynoetium of mid, long and short-styled flowers.
i nn
BREEDING MECHANISM OF BIOPHYTUM CAN DO L LEAN U Vi 105
the latter, there is little difference in the productivity of pollen from
long and short stamens in selling. That the mid-styled flower of Bio-
phytum is comparatively unspecialised in breeding habits, seems to be
supported by the behaviour of the closely allied species B. reinwardtii
Edgw. & Hook. f.
Specimens of B. reinwardtii Edgw. & Hook. f. were collected from
Vadakumpad village, Tellicherry, Kerala, in July 1970. The species
was identified at Kew, based on herbarium specimens and flowers kept
in liquid preservative. This species is very much like B. sensitivum
DC. in morphology, but smaller, weaker and of shorter duration. It is
more susceptible to fungal diseases. Approximate measurements in
mm of floral parts are given below.
Length of peduncle up to 100
Length of pedicel 5-6
Diameter of corolla 7-10
Length of corolla 7-9
Length of sepals 3
Width of petal 4 at apex
Length of stamen:
Long stamen .... 2-3
Short stamen .... 1
Length of pistil 2
In spite of the close similarity to B . candolleanum this species is
remarkable in its breeding habits. Two populations were observed,
collecting more than 100 plants from each. All these plants were of the
same kind, being very similar to the midstyled flower of B. candolle-
anum but the styles slightly shorter. Typical long and short-styled
forms were not found. The erect styles are held at an angle of about
45° so that their stigmas are just above the short stamens or even
touching their anthers. Because of this, at anthesis the stigmas get a
good supply of pollen from the short stamens. If this pollen is produc-
tive as in B. candolleanum , there is no need of insect agent for polli-
nation in this species. To ascertain this, inflorescence were bagged for
days on end. Of the 100 flowers which opened inside bags, 96 formed
well developed fruits with number of seeds ranging from 20 to 30.
Then, 100 bagged flowers were self pollinated with pollen from the
long stamens. All of them set fruits, with 20-30 seeds in each. From
these observations it is clear that B. reinwardtii is a totally self com-
patible species which is also remarkable in being adapted for self
pollination.
B. reinwardtii also shows partial compatibility with B. candolle-
106 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
anum . Results of some crosses between these two species are as shown
below.
Wnen long-styled dower of B. candolleanum is selected as seed parent,
total incompatibility is observed, though cross may be said to be legiti-
mate. But the mid and short-styled flowers show compatibility to some
extent. Reciprocal crosses with B. candolleanum as pollen parent also
show compatibility in varying degree. However, to arrive at definite
conclusions further investigation is required.
Summary and Discussion
Results of artificial breeding in B. candolleanum indicate the pre-
sence of incompatibility system associated with tristyly and varying in
degree. Long-styled form is highly self incompatible. Mid-styled form
is totally self compatible. Short-styled form is also very highly self-
fertile. Maximum self sterility is seen in the form which has the stigmas
far above all the anthers. Forms with at least one set of anthers above
the stigmas are highly self fertile.
B. reinwardtii is adapted for self pollination and is totally self fertile.
In this species the long and short-styled forms seem to have disappear-
ed, leaving only the mid-styled form with necessary modifications to
ensure self pollination.
Mather & de Winton (1941) are of the opinion that incompatibility
reaction and morphological dimorphism arose together as one insepar-
able unit and not as distinct outbreeding mechanisms which are found
together because of mutual reinforcement. <But this conclusion has
since been proved unacceptable. It is generally assumed that a homo-
morphic multiallelic incompatibility system is primarily in angiosperms
(Stebbins 1947, 1950, 1960; Whitehouse 1950; Crowe 1964). Hetero-
styly which is found in more advanced taxa is believed to be derived
from an ancestral multiallelic system either by degeneration of all
except two alleles or by the degeneration of all alleles and subsequent
BREEDING MECHANISM OF BIOPHYTUM CANDOLLEANUM 107
rise of a diallelic system and or heteromorphy (Vuilleumier 1964).
According to Crowe (1964) heterostyly is “a degenerate form of homo-
morphic incompatibility from which it arise by loss of alleles.” But
this view is not accepted by Vuilleumier who on the basis of available
evidence suggests that as alleles were lost homomorphic species became
self fertile and possibly subsequently lost all incompatibility alleles
later when environmental conditions changed, outbreeding in some
taxa could have again been selected for and diallelic system evolved.
Ornduff (1964) also supports this view.
Earlier investigators like Hildebrand (1867) and Darwin (1877)
considered that heterostyly originated as adaptation to specialised insect
visitors which would transfer pollen from a given anther level to stig-
mas of same level in other flowers, thus effecting cross pollination. The
expectation is that the same part of the body of the insect would touch
the anthers and stigmas at the same level in different flowers. But this
could hardly be an exact mechanism to ensure cross breeding. It is
more a theoretical possibility than a practical certainty. Moreover in
flowers with one set of anthers above the stigmas, visit of insect is
likely to cause shedding of some pollen from these anthers on the
stigmas below. Such flowers would therefore be getting a mixture of
own and foreign pollen. This possibility would defeat the purpose of
heterostyly as an adaptation for cross pollination. A better and surer
mechanism would be required to ensure out breeding. Incompatibility
system might ’have developed for this. Morphological heteromorphism
reducing chances of a stigma getting own pollen could have led to
physiological specialisation and brought in an incompatibility system
in course of time. In B. candolleanum while morphological hetero-
morphism is complete, incompatibility system is not so perfect, prob-
ably showing that the latter is a secondary modification. The long-
styled flower which has least chance of getting own pollen is also the
most self incompatible.
If homomorphic multiallelic incompatibility system is the primitive
condition, origin of heterostyly would appear to be an accident rather
than a definite adaptation. Self incompatibility itself being a sure me-
chanism preventing in breeding, there is no need for a less effective
adaptation. It is not reasonable to assume that such an unnecessary
adaptation appeared in so many families. That heterostyly may lead to
unisexuality or break up by losing one or more floral forms has been
shown by Ornduff (1964) in Oxalis suksdorfii and species of Nym-
phoides. Such a loss of floral forms seems to have taken place in B.
reinwardtii. Adaptation for self pollination is a derived condition in
this; otherwise the floral organisation could have been simpler.
108 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Acknowledgements
1 am deeply indebted to Dr. Robert Ornduff, University of Cali-
fornia, for initiating me into the study of heterostyly, giving me reprints
of many papers on the subject and helping me with valuable advice.
I am also obliged to Mr. K. Sasidharan, Lecturer, Govt. College, Mada-
ppally, for getting me literature on B. sensilivum and helping me collect
plants.
References
Gamble, J. S. : Flora of the Presi-
dency of Madras Vol. i.
Ornduff, R. (1964): The breed-
ing system of Oxalis suksdorfii. Amer.
Journ. Bot. 57(3).
Vuilleumier, B. S. (1965): The
origin and evolutionary development
of heterostyly in the angiosperms.
Evolution 21. June, 1967.
Mayura Devi, P. (1964): Hetero^
styly in Biophytum sensitivum. Journ.
Genetics. 59(1).
Observations on sy sterna tics of
Sessile Barnacles from West
Coast of India- 1
BY
Arun B. Wagh1 2 and D. V. Bal3
{With ten text-figures)
Introduction
Studies on systematics of any group of animals is an essential
prerequisite for bio-ecological investigation. The present studies were
undertaken with this view and have been followed by investigations
on various aspects of bio-ecology of barnacles which are being publish-
ed elsewhere.
Material and methods
The present paper contains a description of sessile barnacles collect-
ed from the coast of Maharashtra which is the area lying between
20°05'N to 15°48'N on the west coast of India. The collections were
made from the intertidal region.
The usual method of treating the valves, compartments, mouth-
parts and other appendages of the specimens with caustic potash, was
employed. For staining, borax-carmine as well as picro-indigocarmine
stains were used. The diagrams were drawn with the aid of camera
lucida.
Observations
A classified list of the various forms described is as follows:
Sub-order balanomorpha Pilsbry, 1916.
1 Accepted February 13, 1970.
2 National Institute of Oceanography, Panaji — Goa.
3 Kirti College, Bombay 400 028.
110 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Family Chthamalidae Darwin, 1854.
Genus Chthamalus Ranzani, 1817.
1. Chthamalus malayensis Pilsbry, 1916.
2. Chthamalus wither si Pilsbry, 1916.
Family Balanidae Gray, 1925.
Sub-family Balaninae Darwin, 1854.
Genus Balanus Da Costa, 1778.
Sub-genus Megabalanus Hoek, 1913.
3. Balanus tintinnahulum var. tintinnahulum Linne, 1758.
Sub-genus Balanus Da Costa, 1778.
4. Balanus amphitrite var. communis Darwin, 1854.
5. Balanus amphitrite var. venustus Darwin, 1854.
6. Balanus amphitrite var. stutsburi Darwin, 1854.
7. Balanus amphitrite var. hawaiiensis Broch, 1922.
Sub-genus Chirona Gray, 1835.
8. Balanus amaryllis Darwin, 1854.
forma euamaryllis Broch, 1922.
Sub-family Chelonibiinae Pilsbry, 1916.
Genus Chelonibia Leach, 1817.
9. Chelonibia testudinaria Linne, 1758.
10. Chelonibia patula Ranzani, 1818.
Sub-family Tetraclitinae Nilsson-Cantell, 1921.
Genus Tetraclita Schumacher, 1817.
11. Tetraclita ( Tetraclitella ) purpurescens Wood, 1818.
Species Description
Chthamalus malayensis Pilsbry, 1916. (Figure 1)
Remarks : The specimens conforming to both types, namely Ch.
malayensis as well as Ch. moro were collected. However, all the forms
have been described as Ch. malayensis because the view point of Uti-
nomi (1954) and Karande & Palekar (1963) is being followed.
Colour of the shell, externally, varies from light brown to grey-
brown. Some forms exhibited slightly greenish tinge. The diameter of
the shell varies from 5-6 mm to 10-12 mm Opercular valves resemble
with those described by Utinomi (1954). Tergum bears 4-5 short crests
for the attachment of depressor muscles.
Mandible possesses 3 or 4 teeth. The row of spines below the fourth
tooth consists of 10-14 spines. Maxilla has three upper spines which are
separated by a small notch from the lower spines. Hairy labrum bears
16-17 teeth out of which first two are comparatively longer and more
stout. Cirrus II is with both, toothed and serrated types of spines.
Localities’. Bombay (north and south), Alibag, Murud-Janjira, Shri
SESSILE BARNACLES FROM WEST COAST OF INDIA
111
wardhan, Harnai, Ladghar, Jaigad, Nandivade, Ganapati-Pule, Ratna-
giri, Vijaydurg, Deogad, Malvan, Vengurla, Redi.
Distribution : Indian Ocean and Malay Archipelago.
Fig. 1. Chthamalus malayensis Pilsbry
Opercular valves and mouth-parts
A. Scutum — outer view; B. Scutum — inner view; C. Tergum — outer view;
D. Tergum — inner view; E. Mandible; F. Maxilla I; G. Labrum (labail palps
not shown).
112 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Voi. 71 (1)
Fig. 2. Chthamalus withcrsi Pilsbry
Opercular valves and mouth parts
A. Tergum — inner view; B. Tergum — outer view; C. Scutum — outer view;
D. Scutum — inner view; E. Mandible; F. Maxilla 1; G. Labrum (labial palps
not shown).
SESSILE BARNACLES FROM WEST COAST OF INDIA
113
Chthanialus withersi Pilsbry, 1916. (Figure 2)
Remarks : Colour, dirty brown or dirty grey. Carino-rostral diameter
6-7 mm. Compartments without ridges, with simple sutures and broad
alae. The description of opercular valves generally agrees with that
given by Nilsson-Cantell (1938). Thus, spur is almost united with the
basi-scutal angle. Similarly, the narrow carinal lobe with few crests
for the depressor muscle is also found to be present. Scutum, however,
bears a distinct pit for the lateral depressor muscle and thereby differs
from that described by Nilsson-Cantell.
Mandible bears 3 teeth and a pecten of 6-7 spines. Edge of maxilla
_ has two notches thereby dividing the spines into three groups. Out of
them, upper two spines look more stout. Labrum bears numerous
minute teeth.
Localities : Bordi, Gholvad, Bassein, Bombay (south), Elephanta,
Anjarle, Ganapati-Pule, Ratnagiri, Deogad, Malvan, Shiroda.
Distribution : Indian Ocean, Malay Archipelago.
Balanus tintinnabulum tintinnabulum Linne, 1758. (Figure 3)
Remarks : The present collection contains two different sets of in-
dividuals. Those collected from Madh Island, Bandra and Chowpatty
rocks (all grouped under Bombay) have blackish purple compartments
that are moderately ribbed longitudinally and with conical shape. The
specimens collected at other localities have tubulo-conical shells; the
compartments smooth and purplish-pink in colour. Shell-walls and the
opercular valves of the former are quite thick as compared to those
of the latter. Size of the shells varies from 35 mm to 60 mm in their
basal diameters. Opercular valves agree with those described by Hiro
(1939). The scutum, however, shows a slight difference by possessing
a well-developed pit for the lateral depressor muscle.
Mandible has 5 teeth, of which, the second and third are bifid.
Maxilla I has a straight edge with its spines arranged in three groups.
Labrum shows 1-2 teeth on either side of the median notch.
Localities'. Bombay, Murud-Janjira, Hamai, Ladghar, Nandivade,
Ganapati-Pule, Ratnagiri, Vijaydurg, Mumbri, Malvan, Vengurla and
Redi.
Distribution : Definitely known from Mediterranean sea, Atlantic and
Indian Ocean.
Balanus amphitrite communis Darwin, 1854. (Figure 4)
Remarks: Coloration of shell shows a great degree of variation.
Most of them have pink coloured stripes whereas some exhibit dark
brown stripes. Shape of shell conical, but a few of them were tubulo-
conical, probably due to crowding.
8
JOtfRWAL: BOMBAY N. AYU RA WHISK." SOCIETY, YokYi (1)
Scutum is reddish brown . externally and bears a conspicuous white
stripe f long its .tergal ^iBargin.^M^n^ble has 5 teeth of which the fourth
a>nd fift^ are small and khdbjjikd! Maxilla I lias h straight edge. Labrum
deeply,, patched ..with teeth on either side of it, numbering from 4 to 8.
Spme -porkers, arc,, of the opinion that multi-denticulated forms should
b.egpuppd under dmticulaXa. However, Nilsson-Cantell ( 1938),'
Tajaspr and Zerina;’(l 957) have grouped even multidenticulate fornfis
C
($■ -TYlgAA. . ^BklanuS fintihnabtilum tintinnabulum Linn.
;o
jpp^ular^ valves ; and mouth parts;
^ ^rguth1^ dhter VieWv h: Tergum ^ -ihri^r View; C. Scutum — outer view;
BO .‘.SdilAnf inftMiMkW;VE.!' Maridihle; F.:
not shown). -
Maxilla I; G; Lab rum {labial palps
( SESSILE BARNACLES FROM WEST COAST OF INDIA
115
undtt vsLT. communis on the contention that it is merely a minor vari-
ation which does not warrant the creation of a separate variety. In
the present investigations the latter view has been accepted.
Fig. 4.
Balanus aniphitrite communis Darwin
Opercular valves and mouth parts
^.^prgroj— .irnier.1;vfew; B. -Tergum —.outer view; C. Scutum inner view;
O'. Seuturpi— outer view; E. Mandible; F. Maxilla I; G, Labrum (labial palps
not shown).
116 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Localities : Bombay, Elephanta, Alibag, Shriwardhan, Harnai, Dabhol,
Jaigad, Nandivade, Ganapati-Pule, Ratnagiri, Vijaydurg, Deogad, Mal-
van, Vengurla, Tak, Shiroda and Redi.
Distribution : West India, European waters, Mediterranean, west and
south Africa, Indian Ocean, Malay Archipelago, New South Wales,
Pacific Ocean, Japan, Hawaii Islands.
Balanus amphitrite venustus Darwin, 1854. (Figure 5)
Remarks : Shells are pale rosy in colour. Orifice of the shell dent-
A. Tergum — outer view; B. Tergum — inner view; C. Scutum — outer view;
D. Scutum — inner view; E. Mandible; F. Maxilla I; G. Labrum (labial palps
not shown).
SESSILE BARNACLES FROM WEST COAST OF INDIA
117
ated. Radii are narrow with their summits parallel to the base. Tergum
possesses a broad, inclined spur with rounded head. Basi-scutal angle
is quite acute, thereby giving it a pointed appearance. Scutum is very
thin and bears a well-developed articular ridge. Mandible has 5 teeth
of which the fourth and fifth are knob-like. Maxilla I has almost a
straight edge bearing two pairs of long spines with 7 smaller spines
in between them. Labrum with a deep and narrow median notch. On
either side of the notch are 4 teeth.
Localities : Bandra, Jaigad, Ganapati-Pule, Ratnagiri, Vengurla and
Shiroda.
Distribution : Mediterranean sea, west and south Africa, Indian Ocean
and Japan.
Balanus amphitrite stutsburi Darwin, 1854. (Figure 6)
Remarks : About twelve specimens settled on a wooden test panel
were collected at Trombay (Bombay). They are all ‘typical stutsburi ’
forms. As described by Stubbings (1961) the shell is conical and has
a robust appearance. There is also incurving of the compartments to-
wards the shell opening, so that the shell presents a convex appearance
in profile.
Tergum is of typical shape with its spur very much elongated. The
longitudinal furrow is represented by a depression. The basi-carinal
lobe is well-developed and bears on its inner surface crests for tergal
depressors. Scutum has well-developed, adductor as well as articular
ridge. Pit for the lateral depressor is quite pronounced.
Mandible bears 5 teeth and 2-3 spinelike projections at its lower
angle. Maxilla I has the lower part of its edge slightly protruded which
in turn carries a pair of long spines. Labrum has deep median notch
with 3-4 teeth on either side of it.
Localities : Trombay.
Distribution : West Africa.
Balanus amphitrite hawaiiensis Broch, 1922. (Figure 7)
Remarks : Colour of the shell dirty white with violet vertical stripes.
Shell has a large rhomboid orifice and thick compartments. Apex of
the rostral plate is either straight or slightly incurved. The opercular
valves agree in appearance with those described by Utinomi (1960).
The suture between two opercular valves of the same side present a
sinuous appearance.
Mandible bears 5 teeth. Maxilla I is of the typical B. amphitrite
shape. Labrum bears numerous teeth on either side of the notch. Based
on this character alone, Broch (1922) created variety denticulata.
However, as stated previously, it is being treated as minor variation in
the present communication and hence the forms are assigned either
118 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Fig. 6. Balanus am phitrite Atutsburi Darwin
Opercular valves and mouth parts
A. Tergum — outer view; B. Tergum — inner view; C. Scutum — outer view;
D. Scutum — inner view; E. Mandible; F. Maxilla I; 0. Labrum (labial palps
not shown). 1 A ■
SESSILE BARNACLES EROMAVEST, COAST OF INDIA \ 119
'!)M\
A. Tergum outor^iews? B-r.lEetfgM 'feiJMtuml-^-®uter view;
D. Scutum — inner view; E. Mandible; F. ,M axilla I; Q. Labrum (labial palps
not shown).
to communis Or ytowtiiiemi&Nkrieiy "dej^nMing upon their xntte“ Set Si
characters, • tat
120 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Localities : Gholvad, Bombay, Elephanta, Dabhol, Harnai, Tak and
Aronda.
Distribution : Indian Ocean, Persian Gulf, Malay Archipelago, Hawaii
Islands, Honolulu.
Balanus amaryllis forma euamaryllis Broch, 1922. (Figure 8)
Remarks : Parietes are rosy pink in colour with bluish white alae.
Fig. 8. Balanus amaryllis Darwin forma euamaryllis Broch
Opercular valves and mouth parts
A. Scutum — outer view; B. Scutum — inner view; C. Tergum — outer view;
D. Tergum — inner view; E. Mandible; F. Maxilla I; G. Labrum (labial palps
not shown).
SESSILE BARNACLES FROM WEST COAST OF INDIA
121
Radii are oblique and are covered by persistent yellow epidermis. Alae
are comparatively broader.
Tergum externally bears a deep longitudinal furrow which is closed
in fully grown specimens. Spur is long and narrow with its end
bluntly pointed. Scutum is plainly striated longitudinally, with the striae
dividing the lines of growth into squarish beads. Depression for the
attachment of lateral depressor muscle is quite deep.
Mandible bears 5 teeth of which the second one is large and double.
Maxilla I bears a pair of long spines at the apex and another pair at
base with 7 shorter spines in between. Labrum has 2-3 small teeth on
either side of the notch.
Localities : Cuffe Parade, Chowpatty, Breach Candy, Manori.
Distribution : Indian Ocean, Malay Archipelago, China, Japan, nor-
thern coast of Australia.
Chelonibia testudinaria Linne 1761. (Figure 9)
Remarks'. Fourteen specimens were obtained from the back of a
sea-turtle ( Eretmochelys imbricata) that was brought to the Tarapore-
vala Marine Biological Station, Bombay. All the specimens were fairly
well-developed and had attained large size; some of them admeasuring
45 mm in their rostro-carinal diameter.
Remarks'. Shell much depressed and oval in outline. Colour dirty
white. Parietes are thick with numerous vertical plates extending from
the outer lamina towards the inner lamina. Radii are narrow. A hard,
yellow and horny membrane representing the articular ridge of the
tergum unites the tergum and scutum.
Labrum bears numerous teeth on either side of the notch. Mandible
has 5 teeth of which the second and third are double. Lower angle of
mandible is pectinated. Maxilla I is without any notch and its straight
edge bears 15-16 spines without any definite pattern.
Distribution: Tropical and temperate seas, attached to turtles.
Tetraclita (Tetraclitella) purpurascens Wood, 1818. (Figure 10)
Remarks’. Shell coloration of these forms is dirty brown or greenish
in the field. However, on cleaning the shell it becomes white or greyish
white. Shell is much depressed with 22-28 ribs on its outer surface.
Compartment walls are thick with parietal tubes arranged in rows. Radii
are broad with horizontal summits.
Scutum transversely elongated and with the pit for depressor muscle
being indistinct. Tergum has extremely short spur that is situated very
close to basi-scutal angle. Crests for the depressor muscle well-develop-
ed and are six in number.
Mandible bears 5 teeth with third and fourth being double. The
lower angle is pectinated. Maxilla I slightly notched.
Localities: Bombay-Cuffe Parade, Madh Island, Breach Candy.
.122 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Distribution: Madagascar, Malay Archipelago, China and India.
Chelonibia patula Ranzani, 1820.
Four specimens were found attached to a spiny lobster, Panulirus
polyphagus (Herbst).
Remarks'. Shell is light, fragile and loosely cemented. Radii are
broad and smooth. The opercular valves are very much similar to those
of Chelonibia testudinaria but narrow comparatively.
Distribution: Atlantic Ocean, Mediterranean Sea, Indian Ocean, Malay
Archipelago, Pacific Ocean.
SESSILE BARNACLES FROM WEST COAST OF INDIA
123
- 1-ig. 10. Tciraclitd '(Tefraclilelta) puTpurescens Wood ! °
Opercular valves and mouth parts.
Key to .abbreviations for Figs. 9 & 10.
A. Tergum — outer view; B. Tergum — inner view; C. Scutum — outer view;
D. Scutum — inner view; E. Mandible; ;F'. Maxilla I; G. Labrum (labial palps
mot shown), . _ . .. ^ u ; .
(to he continued)
Am J.I -jari r
The copulatory complex of
Neurobasis chinensis chinensis
(Linn.) (Agriidae: Zygoptera)1
BY
Basit Ali Khan
Zoology Dept., Agra College, Agra, ( U.P .)
(With three text-figures)
This paper describes the structure of the copulatory complex of
Neurohasis chinensis chinensis (Linn.).
Neurobasis chinensis chinensis (Linn.) is distributed throughout
India, except in desert areas. The genus Neurobasis Selys, has two
species, and one Neurobasis chinensis chinensis (Linn.) is found within
Indian limits, along the banks of streams. They are generally character-
ised by the brilliant metallic green thorax, with very long and slim
legs, wings moderately rounded at apices, especially hind wings, fore-
wings considerably longer than hind wings, hind wings opaque, basal
two thirds appearing brilliant metallic green or peacock-blue, ptero-
stigma absent in all wings. Abdomen narrow, cylindrical, much longer
than wings. Anal appendages black, supra-anal appendages much
longer than the tenth abdominal segment.
As in other Zygoptera Neurobasis chinensis chinensis (Linn.) bears
two sets of copulatory apparatus the first set which is primary in nature,
is situated on the venter of the ninth and tenth abdominal segments as
in other insects. The second set, regarded as the secondary complex
is located ventrally on the entire second and the apical part of the
third abdominal segments.
The first set is used for holding the female during copulation while
the second set is used in actual coition.
Primary Copulatory Complex
Fig. 1.
The primary copulatory complex consists of a median vestigial
1 Accepted June 11, 1971.
COPUL AT ORY COMPLEX OF NEUROBASIS C. CHINENSIS 125
or primitive penis (VP), a pair of reduced appendages or gonocoxites
(C) (=gonapophyses, Fraser 1956; gonopods, Snodgrass 1935; coxites,
George 1928; valvules, Whedon 1918), a pair of supra-anal appendages
(SAA) (=cerci, Snodgrass 1935), and a pair of infra-anal appendages
(IAA) (=cerci, Fraser 1956; epiproct, Snodgrass 1935).
\
1
Fig. 1. Ventral view of the primary copulatory complex.
(i) Vestigial penis (VP). — The vestigial penis is represented by a
reduced sclerite situated almost in the middle of the ventral surface
of the ninth abdominal segment (AS). The vestigial penis has an
elongated opening, the male gonopore (MGP) (=genital meatus, Fraser
1956).
(ii) Coxites (C). — The male gonopore (MGP) and the vestigial
penis (VP) are guarded laterally by a pair of reduced, oval append-
ages or gonocoxites. The portions of the ninth sternum lying anterior
and posterior to the male gonopore are modified to form the anterior
and posterior genital plates (AGP & PGP) respectively. The anterior
genital plate (AGP) is comparatively well developed.
(iii) Supra-anal appendages (SAA). — The supra anal appendages
arise from the terminal end of the tenth abdominal segment (AS) from
its dorso-lateral sides. They are long, sub-cylindrical near the base,
forcepate, and curved towards each other, with rounded and slightly
flattened apices. Each supra-anal appendage bears many spines (SP)
on the outer and lateral margins near the apex and a prominent conical
projection on the inner and lateral side, heavily covered with hairs.
(iv) Infra-anal appendages (IAA). — The infra-anal appendages
also arise from the terminal end of the tenth abdominal segment, and
lie ventral to supra-anal appendages and lateral to anus. They are
r26 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATVRA L HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 ( 1 )
shorter than supra-anal appendages and broader proximal ly and nar-
rower distally with blunt apices. The infra-anal appendages aree widely
separated at the base and covered with hairs and spines. . v: v: . ;
■ .. sdni 10 : £ baM JfLLVt .. oa. : (AA«&)
; • w :v- /'.Vi .■ : ' ... \ (AAI)
Secondary Copulatory Complex
L x;t ’’ Figs. 2 & 3. .
The secondary copulatory complex consists of the genital fossa
(GF) (^fenestra, Fraser 1956), the anterior lamina (AL), the posterior
lamina, the lamina-balilliformis (LAB), the chitinous supporting frame-
work (APSF & PPSF), the hamules, the penis vesicle (PV) (-yesicula
spermalis, Fraser 1956; sperm -receptacle, Snodgrass 1935), the perils
( P) (%rophallus, Fraser 1956; intromittent organ,, Snodgrass 1935*N
(i) The genital fossa (GF). — The genital fossa is a median, shal-
low and membranous depression on the entire second and apical part
of third sterna. It is supported by three main sclerites. Anteriorly it is
supported by the anterior lamina (AL), and lamina-batilliformis
(LAB), posteriorly by a posterior lamina, and laterally by a compli-
cated chitinous framework of sclerites. All the structures of the secon-
dary complex, are placed inside the fossa.
(ii) Anterior lamina (AL). -The anterior lamina is a chitinous,
hoOd-like sclerite occupying the front part of the second venter and
extending in between the two ventral margins of the second tergurn.
e.:- If. .'.is somewhat inverted V-shaped structure. The anterior margin
of the1 anterior lamina (AL) is more or less straight and bears promi-
nent laminar processes (LP), while the posterior margin is deeply
notched. The Inner and lateral walls of the notch are furnished with
hairs and it encloses the proximal portion of the penis. The anterior
lamina has two prominent borders, the inner border (IB) and the
Outer border (OB), the inner border is broader than the outer one;'
(iii) Lamina-batilliformis (LAB).— The lamina-batilliformis is-
forceps-like chitinous structure lying inside the notch, in between the
tWQ arms of the inverted V-shaped anterior lamina (AL). According
to Thompson (T908T • the lamina-batilliformis may be regarded as :
penis sheath in Zygoptera, because it lies exactly in the same position
as the penis sheath in Anisoptera and it also ^covers the prOximal
portion of the penisi The two arms (AR) of the lamina-batilliformis
(LAB) are widely divergent, ' terminating into rounded apices and
furim^ed;wilfa)ihafels. r r ban v$smi ‘ no naaoc-mg
i: • (iv) Posterior lamina.— The posterior lamina is a simple chitinous
plate, dying at the posterior end of the genital fossa/ It is' not visible
externally, because it Uscompletely covered by the anterior portion of
CQPUL AT ORY COMPLEX OF NEUROBASIS C. CHINENSIS 127
the penis vesicle (PV).
(v) Supporting frame-work (APSF & PPSF).— The genital fossa
(GF) is strengthened and supported by a number of chitinous rods,
which together constitute the complicated net work of chitinous bars,
the supporting frame- work. The supporting framework supports the
various parts of the copulatory complex and also provides the various
surfaces or facets for the articulation of the copulatory organs with
each other.
It is divisible into two portions, the anterior portion (APSF) and
the posterior portion (PPSF). The anterior portion of the supporting
framework lies below the anterior lamina (AL), and lamina-batilli-
formis (LAB). It consists of two promient chitinous lateral bars (LB)
which unite with each other at one end below the lamina-batilliformis,
while on the other end the lateral bars are free, divergent and articulat-
ed with the posterior portion of the supporting framework (PPSF).
The anterior portion of the framework (APSF) supports the ante-
128 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
rior lamina (AL), the lamina-batilliformis (LAB), the anterior pair of
hamules (AH) and also the proximal part of the penis (P).
The posterior portion of the framework is very thick and well
developed. It is somewhat U-shaped structure with two thick lateral
bars (LB) and a horizontal bar (HB), lying below the anterior portion
of the penis vesicle (PV). The posterior portion of the supporting
framework (PPSF) supports the anterior portion of the supporting
framework (APSF), posterior pair of hamules (PH), the apical por-
tion of the penis vesicle (PV), together with the distal part of the
penis (P).
(vi) Hamules (AH & PH). — The hamules are chitinous and robust
structures, situated behind the anterior lamina (AL) and articulated
with the framework. There are two pairs of hamules. The anterior pair
of hamules (AH) are well developed while the posterior pair of ham-
ules (PH) are reduced to papillae and situated at the junction of the
anterior and posterior portions of the supporting framework. The
anterior hamules have four prominent plates, two inner (IP) and two
outer (OP), furnished with marginal hairs.
(vii) Penis vesicle (PV). — The penis vesicle is developed on the
anterior part of the third sternum (ST), and projects forward under-
neath the second sternum. It is enormously developed, flask-shaped,
with plane dorsal surface and convex ventral surface. At the apical
part of the penis vesicle on the ventral convex surface, there is a pro-
minent lipped groove (GR) in which the glans of the penis is placed
during rest.
(viii) Penis (P). — The penis is found on the second segment and
it does not arise from the penis vesicle as in Anisoptera. It lies on the
ventral surface of second abdominal segment in an exactly homologous
position to that of the penis sheath in Anisoptera.
It is an unsegmented, slightly curved structure and consists of a
highly chitinized stem, attached to the floor of the genital fossa by its
base, near the apex of the penis vesicle (PV). The apex of the stem, the
glans (GLA) is bulbous, partly membraneous and partly chitinous;
and bears a short flagellum (FL) and many lobes.
Acknowledgements
I am grateful to Dr. H. N. Baijal, Zoology Department, Agra Col-
lege, Agra (India), for guidance and criticism. I thank Principal, Dr.
S. Sinha and Prof. C. P. Singh, Head of the Zoology Department,
Agra College, Agra (India), for providing laboratory and library
facilities.
COPUL AT ORY COMPLEX OF NEUROBASIS C. CHINENSIS 129
— Ill ST
Fig. 3. Venetral view of the secondary copulatory complex with penis, dis-
placed from its natural position.
9
130 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
References
George, C. J. (1928): The mor-
phology and development of the geni-
talia and genital ducts of Homoptera
and Zygoptera as shown in the life-
histories of Philaenus and Agrion.
Quart. J. micr. Sci. London, 72:447-
485, pis. iii.
Snodgrass, R. E. (1935) : Principles
of Insect Morphology. New York-
London: McGraw-Hill Book Co.,
pp. 1-667, 319 figs.
Thompson, O. S. (1908): Append-
ages of the second abdominal segment
of male Dragonflies (Odonata). Rep.
Ent. Albany, New York, St. Ed. Dept.
Mus. Bull. 724(23) : 249-263, 12 figs.
Tuxen, S. L. (1956): Taxonomist’s
Glossary of Genitalia in Insects. Co-
penhagen: Ejnar Munksgaard (Odo-
nata). (by F. C. Fraser), pp. 25-30.
Whedon, A. D. (1918): The com-
parative morphology and possible ad-
aptation of the abdomen in the Odo-
nata. Trans. Amer. ent. Soc. 44:373-
437, 9 pis.
ABBREVIATIONS
AGP — Anterior genital plate; AH — Anterior hamule; AL — Anterior
Lamina; APSF — Anterior portion of supporting framework; AR — Arm;
C — Coxite; FL — Flagellum; GF — Genital fossa; GLA — Gians; GR —
Groove; HA — Hair; HB — Horizontal bar; IAA — Infra-anal appendages;
IB — Inner border; IP — Inner plate; LA — Lamina analis; LAB — Lamina-
batilliformis; LBy — Lateral bar; LI — Lip; LP — Laminar process; MGP —
Male gonopore; N — Notch; OB — Outer border; OP — Outer plate; P —
Penis; PGP — Posterior genital plate; PH — Posterior hamule; PPSF —
Posterior portion of supporting framework; PV — Penis vesicle; SAA — Supra-
anal appendage; SP — Spine; ST — Sternum; VP — Vestigial penis.
Reviews
1. ECOLOGICAL PRINCIPLES LOR ECONOMIC DEVELOP-
MENT. By Raymond F. Dasmann, John P. Milton and Peter H.
Freeman, pp. viii + 252 (23 x 15 cm), with 31 text-figures. London,
1973. John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Price?
One of the cherished projects of the International Union for Con-
servation of Nature and Natural Resources had been to produce a
book that would draw the attention of planners of developing countries
to the mistakes of the over-developed West and to point out that there
was no purely technological solution available to solve the problems
of the human race. Oxygen must still be produced by green plants
and for the conservation of much needed freshwater a whole range of
natural factors must be taken account of. Almost any development
which man undertakes today impinges on the natural ecosystem and
to ensure that economic planning is undertaken in such a manner that
nature is not forced to hit back and undermine these developments is
the purpose of this book.
Apart from analysing the general ecological considerations of which
planners should take note there are valuable guidelines for the develop-
ment of humid tropical lands, pastoral lands of semi-arid regions,
tourism, agriculture and river basin development.
The rate at which deforestation is going on in India, a matter of
serious concern for our country, the following statement in the chapter
on River Basin Development Projects is of great relevance to our
country:
Any change in the watershed area will affect the flow of water and
quantity of sediment carried downstream. The protective role of
forests in maintaining a relatively stable flow of water for reservoir
impoundments and irrigation works is well established. Not only does
protective vegetation decrease flood peaks, but it also usually increases
water discharge during dry periods. Forests and their root systems are
also of great importance in preventing erosion and reducing sediment
loads in streams and rivers.
It is also significant that the water hyacinth which has become such
a menace in our country by interfering with navigation, fish cultivation,
etc. should also be responsible for so much loss of water through
evapotranspiration. According to the authors ‘in the dry atmosphere
of India the loss of water through water hyacinth was 7-8 times that
of open water’. Obviously there is need for widespread research to
find some biological controls against the spread of this exotic water
132 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
plant. It has been suggested that the manatee ( Trichechus sp.), a herbi-
vorous freshwater mammal inhabiting parts of Africa and Latin
America and consumes large quantities of aquatic plant material may
be one possible control species.
Z. F.
2. A FIRST GUIDE TO THE INDIAN OCEAN SEASHORE.
By F. M. J. Finn. pp. 72 (19.5 x 14 cm), with many illustrations.
Nairobi, 1973. Oxford University Press. Price Rs. 11.00.
From the rather bombastic, too-inclusive title of this booklet,
accompanied by a very professional appearance of the colour photo-
graph of the head and fore-body of a hermit crab on the cover, the
reader would be led to believe that it is a taxonomic account of the
intertidal animals from several countries bordering the Indian Ocean.
It is only when one browses through the first few pages and looks at
the amateurish sketches, or cares to read the matter on the back cover,
that he gets a true idea — that the booklet is meant for schoolchildren.
If that was its intention it is a fair performance, but it should have
been so labelled.
The title is unfortunate in another respect, too. It would lead the
reader to believe that the animals treated in the booklet come from
all over, or at least from a fairly wide and representative coverage of
regions of the Indian Ocean. In reality the author would have covered
only a few of the East African beaches. It is fortunate for him that
many of the animals described therein enjoy a cosmopolitan distri-
bution, thus giving some support to his claim. It is for this reason that
the booklet might also appeal to readers from other tropical countries.
The text is clearly written and free of the coy overtones that often
ruin books intended for children. The illustrations, however, are
shoddy. Those of sea-shells are tolerable, but one would be hard press-
ed to restrain a smile when he looks at the almost droll fish which is
being squirted by the cuttlefish on page 46, or the inflated porcupine
fish on page 68. And, after looking at the crab with one claw and both
eyes missing (on page 20), the other crab (on page 22) with bent
eyes, only four legs, and rectangular mouth, or the rosebud-like goose
barnacles on page 26, one wonders how it is claimed (on the outer
cover) that the “superbly accurate and detailed” drawings “will greatly
help in the precise identification of the fish, shells and coral. ...” The
drawings, in the reviewer’s opinion, are too poor and impressionistic
and are ill-suited to be helpful to even the amateur naturalist, let alone
to the serious student of animal classification.
REVIEWS
133
The Table showing tide times and heights (on page 10) is super-
fluous in a booklet meant for children, and would better have been
left out.
The appropriateness of the booklet is best left to the young reader
to judge. If it effectively does what it is intended to do — namely, stimu-
late interest for seashore life, it will be the kind of book that makes
an attractive present for the youngster beginning to take an interest
in marine biology.
B.F.C.
3. A REVISED HANDBOOK TO THE FLORA OF CEYLON.
Edited by B. A. Abeywickrama, Volume 1 (Part 1). pp. ii + 109
(24.5 x 16.5 cm), with 11 figures. Sri Lanka, 1973. University of Sri
Lanka. Available from Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington,
D.C. 20560, USA. Price $4.50 (Sterling £1.90).
Continuing advances in plant taxonomy call for revision of most
works on the plants of tropical Asia. A combined effort on the part
of the University of Sri Lanka, the Department of Agriculture of Sri
Lanka, and the Smithsonian Institute (Washington, D.C., USA) has
resulted in the beginning of a revision of Trimen’s Handbook of the
Flora of Ceylon, published from 1893-1901 with a supplement by
Alston in 1931, a work long out of print. The first part presents nine
angiospermous families: Apocynaceae, Asclepiadaceae, and Periplo-
caceae by H. Hueber (Botanisches Institute II, Wuerzburg, Germany),
Loranthaceae and Viscaceae by D. Wiens (University of Utah, Salt
Lake City, Utah, USA), Bignoniaceae by W. Theobald (Occidental
College, Los Angeles, California, USA), Pedaliaceae, Gesneriaceae,
and Martyniaceae by W. Theobald and D. Grupe (Occidental College,
Los Angeles, California, USA).
This work has a number of fundamental strengths. It is based on
careful restudy of the original Singhalese collections made and studied
by Trimen which fortunately have been preserved in Peradeniya. The
revision is also based on unusually ample modern collections being
made in Ceylon. Finally, whenever possible, there has been an effort
to recruit specialists and to send them in the field where they can study
the populations at first hand. All of this adds greatly to the value of
the work. Drs. Abeywickrama and Fosberg and their supporters have
rendered a genuine service by initiating this happy and hopefully
serendipitous venture.
It should be noted that the title word ‘‘Handbook”, with its con-
cept of something that fits the hand, was misapplied to the original
134 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
edition by Trimen. That edition came out in five parts (volumes) and
totalled 2,044 pages. The “Revised Handbook” promises to be even
larger since the nine families published use 109 pages and only re-
quired 73 pages in the original edition. A rather small type face (6
point) is much used in the revision. Thus, the revision is substantially
enlarged.
Not all family treatments are of the same scope. Dr. Hueber’s
treatment include synopses of suprageneric taxa, citation of place of
publication of generic names, generic synonymy, type species of genera,
chromosome numbers, and uses of plants. Dr. Theobald omits some of
these features but includes illustrations. Dr. Wiens omitted these extras.
Users of this work will be grateful that the editors have decided to
include such valuable information when it has been submitted by an
author, rather than eliminating it for the sake of consistency or ex-
pediency.
Only a few author errors could be detected. Aganosma cymosum
(page 19) is incorrectly treated as neuter instead of feminine. Tylophora
tenuissima (Roxb.) Wight (p. 44) was accepted instead of Tylophora
tenuis Blume because Roxburgh’s basionym, Asclepias tenuissima, was
incorrectly attributed to the first edition of Roxburgh’s Flora Indica
(as “1821”). In fact, Roxburgh’s basionym dates from the second
edition (1832) and Tylophora tenuis Blume (1826-7) is the correct
name, being priorable. The authorship of Macrosolen (p. 63) and
Tolypanthus (p. 69) was attributed to “(Blume) Reichenb” [1841]
when it should be attributed to “(Blume) Blume” [1830]. The specific
epithet in Dendrophthoe lonchiphyllus (p. 66) uses an incorrect con-
necting vowel and the wrong gender and should be “lonchophylla’ .
The binomial Epithema carnosum Bentham (1835) on page 103 is
incorrectly treated as if it had Aikinia carnosa G. Don (1838) as a
basionym, instead of the other way around. The citation in the same
place of Bentham’s publication of “Scroph. Ind. 57:665. 1835” is an
error for “Scroph. Ind. 57. 1835.”
These few and minor errors only emphasize the extremely high
standards of this work. Anyone dealing with tropical plants, parti-
cularly those of tropical Asia, will need this work. The first part is
the beginning of a promising series that will have a major impact on
botany in this part of the world.
D.H.N.
C.J.S.
REVIEWS
135
4. TROPICAL AQUARIA. By G. E. Williams, pp. 48 (18 x 12
cm). Second Edition. Horniman Museum & Library, London, 1973.
Published by the London Education Authority.
The growing interest of the general public in fish-keeping at home
has prompted an increasing number of popular books on this subject.
In the present one, the author has done the fish-oriented a favour in
bringing together in popular treatment the dos and don’ts of the hobby.
The book is basically a how-to-do-it and is directed to the beginner
aquarist.
The starting “chapters”, each of two to four pages, deal with the
construction and setting up of aquarium tanks, and their lighting and
heating. That on circulation takes up more space but deals mostly
with the systems used at the Horniman Museum. A list of the most
interesting plants and fishes, with minimal description, comprises what
would be the main chapters in books of this type. Hints on feeding,
and on diagnosing and treating six common fish diseases make up the
rest of the book, being contained in two “chapters”, totalling less than
eight pages.
The book is written with considerably more accuracy than most
of the current flood of popular books in this hobby. Although written
by a scientist, it is devoid of scientific jargon, and its explicit style
shows how a technical subject matter can be written without using
fancy language. However, the book suffers considerably from its ex-
treme condensation. Readers should not, therefore, expect much more
than bare service from this overcrowded little book with its compact
arrangement.
The arrangement of the book, appropriately, appears to have been
determined as much by questions put to the author in the course of
his official duties as by the subject itself.
The few illustrations that are neat and simple, but deal only with
technicalities. Apart from two electric circuit diagrams and two water-
circulation devices, the only other pictures are those of six fishes on
the cover. More illustrations of popular fishes, aquarium plants, and
common live foods would have been appreciated.
Although the author claims that one of the aims of the handbook
is to give a description of some of the fish exhibits in the Museum, his
chapter “The Fish” is more on the lines of such chapters is most hobby
books. For example, for most of the fishes he has given colour des-
criptions. These are not at all useful to visitors to the Museum, as, any-
way, they would be seeing these colours on the bodies of the fishes.
He could have avoided this and, instead, devoted more space to des-
cribing peculiar habits, etc.
For the beautiful glossy cover and neat printing on good quality
136 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
paper, the price of the handbook, at 15 p. is surprisingly low.
Except for the principal shortcoming, viz. lack of detailed treat-
ment of the subjects covered therein, it is a good elementary hand-
book— hobbyists wishing to learn more will find the list of books and
periodicals on the last page very handy.
B.F.C.
5. CLASSIFICATION OF THE ANIMAL KINGDOM — An
Illustrated Guide, pp. 55 (31 x 23.5 cm), with many illustrations.
London, 1972. The Universities Press Ltd. and the Reader’s Digest
Association Ltd. Price £1.35 net in U.K.
This book first appeared as a section The Living World of
Animals published by the Reader’s Digest Association Ltd. and is
now available in a separate edition for the use of students.
The introduction by Richard Freeman, a reader in zoology at the
University College, London, discusses in not too difficult terms the
need for and systems of classification. When studying an animal, the
morphological, physiological, behavioural and genetic characteristics
are all considered and these are compared with similar sets of charac-
teristics relating to another. In this way, relationships are established
and the hierarchy of groups in classification is determined.
The contributions of Francis Willughby (who, in 1676, published
a work on all the species of birds then known) and Linnaeus who
provided the starting point for all generic and specific names for animals,
are described in some detail and Freeman points out some odd results
that arose out of Linnaeus’s system of classification — for instance, the
Swedish zoologist divided mammals into orders on their dentition,
resulting in a bracketing of rhinos with mice!
Inevitably, some groups have been treated in greater detail than
others, but no phylum has been omitted. All terrestrial vertebrates — as
these are the groups that observations of nature and field workers are
most likely to encounter — have been taken down as far as families,
with brief notes on appearance and habits and examples that are illus-
trated. The very large number of families among insects and fishes
and the technical language involved. Freeman points out, precluded
their treatment in the same detail.
A useful book with excellent illustrations and not too involved.
Perhaps it is a failing that it is so simple, for the student will quickly
outgrow it.
NEELA D’SOUZA
Miscellaneous Notes
1. STATUS OF THE TIGER IN BURMA
In wild life sanctuaries by Kyaw Gyi, Sarpay Brikman of the
Printing and Publishing Corporation 1973, the author states that accor-
ding to Forest Department’s estimate there were 1621 tigers in Burma
in 1962.
Outside Reserves 1195
Inside Reserves 426
7621
The total land area of Burma is 261227 square miles. The area
under forests in known to be 149783 square miles or 57 per cent of
the total land area in the Union. The area under Reserved Forests is
34068 square miles or 13 per cent of the total land area in the Union.
J. D. Bitkinson 1948 (Forests and Forestry in Burma. Jour . Roy.
Soc. Arts, London 96:478-491) states that Burma has almost the same
area of actual forest as India.
The author of wild life sanctuaries is a retired Chief Conser-
vator of Forests, Burma.
25, Inya Myaing Road, TUN YIN
University P.O.,
Rangoon, Burma,
September 17, 1973.
2. WEIGHT AND SIZE AT BIRTH OF TWO SPECIES OF WILD
MAMMALS IN CAPTIVITY
This note deals with the weight and size at birth of two species of
wild mammals observed at Nandankanan Biological Park, Orissa. The
weight and measurements were taken within twelve hours of birth.
Jungle Cat ( Felis chaus)
The four kittens born in one litter on 17.1.1973 weighed from 103
to 126 gm with an average of 111.25 gm and measured from 22 to
24 cm with an average of 22.5 cm from nose tip to tail tip including
6 cm to 7 cm (average 6.5 cm) long tail at birth.
In available literature, there appears to be no report on weight and
size of this cat at birth.
138 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Indian Wild Boar {Sus scrofci cristatus)
The seven piglets (one out of 4 born in one litter on 10.viii.’72 and
6 born in one litter on 23. ix. 1972) weighed from 325 to 665 gm
with an average of 557.43 gm and measured from 31.5 to 37 cm with
an average of 35 cm from nose tip to tail tip including 4.5 cm to 6 cm
(average 5.36 cm) long tail. The shoulder heights were from 14 to
16.5 cm with an average of 15.36 cm. The one young which weighed
325 gm and measured 31.5 cm could not stand without support as it
was very weak at birth.
The literature available to us has no report on this subject.
Veterinary Asst. Surgeon, L. N. ACHARJYO
Nandankanan Biological Park,
P.O. Rarang, Dist: Cuttack.
Wild Life Conservation Officer, R. MISRA
Old Secretariate Building,
Cuttack- 1 (Orissa),
February 21, 1973. ^
3. BURROWING HABITS OF THE GREATER BANDICOOT
RAT {BAN DICOT A INDICA)
{With a text-figure)
Introduction
The Greater Bandicoot Rat is one of our largest rodents, weighing
on an average more than one kilogram. It is a confirmed commensal
of man, always living in close vicinity of human dwellings and feeding
on refuse and storage products. The Greater Bandicoot Rat is not
conspicuous for its large burrows which cause considerable damage
to huts and godowns. Practically nothing is known of the biology of
this animal in spite of its being one of most serious rodent pests of
India. The present note is an account of its burrowing habits.
Materials and Methods
This account is based on an investigation of the structure of eighty-
three bandicoot burrows. All the burrows under study were currently
or very recently occupied as evidenced by the presence of soil produced
by fresh diggings and sighting of the bandicoot rats by local inhabit-
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
139
ants. The study involved a careful excavation of each burrow, noting
down their dimensions and any contents. The excavations were carried
out at three times of the year: 30 burrows during the second week of
October 1972, 23 burrows during the fourth week of February 1973,
and 30 burrows during the fourth week of July 1973. All the burrows
were located in the vicinity of the Chatushringi hill in Poona.
Results and Discussion
The burrow is a winding tunnel roughly circular in cross-section,
its diameter ranging from 8 to 15 cm. The tunnel is of a fairly constant
diameter throughout, and does not enlarge into any chamber-like
spaces. The tunnel makes a number of twists and turns under the
ground and may lead to several blind alleys. The total length of the
burrows excavated ranged from 44 to 520 cm. The maximum depth
of the burrows ranged from 23 to 115 cm. A single burrow may open
above ground by one to four separate openings. Fig. 1 is a sketch of
one of the burrows and Table 1 provides more detailed statistics on
the dimensions of the burrows.
None of the excavated burrows were found to harbour any stored
food materials. Many but not all of the burrows contained accumula-
tions of cloth and paper pieces, particularly at the end of a blind alley
or near a turning in the tunnel. We found a number of commensals
in many of the burrows; these included isopods, spiders, centipedes,
beetles and lizards. As we have covered a number of burrows in all
the major seasons of the year, we may safely conclude that the burrow
140 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
does not serve for food storage, but as a shelter for the Greater Bandi-
coot Rat.
Table I
Characteristics of the burrows of Bandicota indica
Bandicoot burrows were found to be organized into colonies of
2 to 15 burrows. Distances between openings of neighbouring burrows
in a colony ranged from 20 to 700 cm, tfie average separation being
about 100 cm. The colonies are always next to a house or a grain
storage godown generally lying at the back of the houses close to a
fence or compound wall. The burrows often extend under the floor
or the house and occasional burrow openings are produced inside the
house especially if it has a mud flooring. The burrows within each
colony are fairly compactly aligned next to each other and each colony is
a clearly discrete entity. One colony may be separated from an adja-
cent colony by several hundred metres. Whether such colonies consti-
tute a genuine deme will depend on the extent of migration of indi-
viduals from colony to colony. No data are as yet available on this
problem.
Ack n owledge men t
We wish to acknowledge the kind support of Dr. G. B. Deodikar,
Director, M.A.C.S., Poona.
Biology Department, A. V. ARJUNWADKAR
Fergusson College,
Poona 411 004.
Maharashtra Association for the MADHAV GADGIL* 1
Cultivation of Science,
Poona 411 004,
September 11, 1973.
1 |
1 Present address : Centre for Theoretical Studies, Indian Institute of Science,
Bangalore 560 012.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
141
4. STORKS PREYING ON LIVE BIRDS
In 1969, I had been informed by Shri V. S. Saxena the then Divi-
sional Forest Officer, Bharatpur, that Blacknecked Storks ( Xeno -
rhynchus asiaticus ) capture and eat coot; one of our shikaris confirm-
ed this, but I found it hard to believe.
In April 1973 during the fag end of our Bird Migration camp. I
twice observed Blacknecked Storks hunting down diving coot in
shallow water which they captured and swallowed whole. On a third
occasion another stork of the same species snapped up a flying coot
out of a group it flushed while skimming over the water.
At the same period Adjutant Storks ( Leptoptilos dubius) and
Blacknecked Storks were seen walking down flightless injured ducks
which could not dive away in the foot or two of water remaining. The
victims were invariably snapped up by the neck, and shaken till dead
and swallowed whole.
BNHS Bird Migration Camp, JAMSHED D. PANDAY
Bharatpur,
Rajasthan,
December 10, 1973.
5. BREEDING OF THE LESSER FLAMINGO, PHOENICONAIAS
MINOR (GEOFFROY) IN KUTCH
{With two photographs)
In 1945 I wrote in the birds of kutch: “Lester’s (1903) presump-
tion that it [Lesser Flamingo] breeds in Kutch has not been confirm-
ed. So far it is not known to breed within Indian limits at all.” Later
(1954), in my paper on the birds of Gujarat ( JBNHS 52: 384) I re-
corded as follows: “Between 25 February and 2 March 1946, enormous
concentrations roughly estimated as close on a hundred thousand birds
[! ?] with no admixture of ruber, were observed on the flat muddy
expanse of the shallow Banas River near its mouth (opposite Dhutari
Bet) in the Little Rann of Kutch. The species has so far not been found
breeding within Indian limits, but there seems high probability of its
doing so in the Great or Little Rann. The gathering here included
numerous birds in the brown postjuvenal plumage, perhaps not more
than 2 or 3 months old, which could well be from this undiscovered
breeding ground.” Sustained enquiry in the intervening years of likely
persons living in Kutch and visitors to the suspect areas had failed to
elicit any positive evidence, and the question of whether, and where,
the Lesser Flamingo breeds in the Rann remained baffling.
142 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
It is thus of particular interest to record that on a recent visit to
‘Flamingo City’ off Nir in the Great Rann (January 24, 1974) with
Shri Shivrajkumar Khachar of Jasdan and Shri Ramsinhji Rathod,
DFO Kutch, we were finally rewarded with firsthand proof of the
species breeding within Indian limits. Water conditions in the Rann
and logistics of our expedition to the colony were more or less identi-
cal with those recorded in my note “Flamingo City re-visited” in
March 1960 ( JBNHS 57: 413-15) and need not be recounted. After
the heavy monsoon inundation the edge of the Rann was still wet and
boggy and impassable for jeeps, so — as on the previous occasion — we
motored from Khavda to Kuran (c. 15 km) and then transferred to
camel-back. The route to Nir lay along the stony base of the Kala
Dongar hills across rocky hummocks and dry stony water courses,
sparsely scattered with Euphorbia, Salvadora, Zizyphus and Prosopis
scrub. The distance from Kuran to Nir, said to be c. 22 km, took 44
hours of merciless pounding in some of the most uncomfortable saddles
ever designed! The distance from our bivouac at Nir to Flamingo
City, approximately 10 km, was covered on the same mounts in 2\
hours next morning, over alarmingly slithery slush alternating with
shallow brine and stretches of billiard-table flat dry compacted sand.
Owing to abnormally heavy monsoon rains in northwestern Gujarat
in the 1973 season, the Great Rann had been deeply inundated by the
Luni River and the water level in the Flamingo City area apparently
did not become favourable for nesting till late October or early Nov-
ember. Dr. Philip Kahl, who is making a comparative study of all the
flamingo species of the world, flew over the breeding ground on 15
November and took the accompanying aerial photographs to support
his visual estimate of 10,000 nests in the two sectors of the City. On
these he was able to count 7132 nests in occupation. The majority of
birds were apparently the larger species, and he found no indication
that the few Lesser Flamingos present among them were engaged in
any breeding activity. As the nesting had apparently begun only a short
while before. Dr. Kahl felt that the numbers would increase as water
conditions improved, and he suggested our visiting the place a couple
of months later to check the position.
As our camelcade neared the ‘City’ the sight, as usual, grew increas-
ingly breath-taking. The muffled ‘roar’ of the birds in the distance sound-
ed exceedingly like the continuous grind of some mighty electric gener-
ator in action. Through binocular could be marked down on the hori-
zon at least three other separate, fairly large, breeding colonies between
the traditional Flamingo City and Bhanjda Bet, towards the east and
south. I have no recollection of these colonies from my previous visits,
and it may be that they are new extensions. They were too far to give
any idea of size, but seemed well populated. Flamingo City itself
Photo 1. Flamingo colony — Great Rann of Kutch — 15 Nov. 1973,
(photographed from the NE).
{Photo: M. P. Kahl )
Photo 2. Flamingo colony — Great Rann of Kutch — 15 Nov. 1973,
(photographed from the S).
Counts from photo show approx. 4856 nests in ‘'south colony'’ (nearest camera)
& 2272 nests in “north colony” (top of photo), for a total of approx. 7132 nests.
{Photo: M. P. Kahl)
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
143
appeared to be in two major sectors connected by a rather sparsely
populated “neck”. I have grown sceptical of visual estimates of num-
bers, including my own — specially when made from ground level But
for what it is worth, it may be mentioned that among the enormous
number of birds present (estimated as 25 to 30,000) we guessed the
total number of Lesser Flamingo in the more congested sector of the
mixed colony (“north colony”, photo 2) to be between 2000 (SA)
and 5000 (Shivrajkumar). The nests, with these birds sitting on eggs
or newly hatched chicks, were scattered among those of the Larger,
but some sections were patronized almost exclusively by P. minor.
These segregated mohallas or ‘ghettos’ stood out clearly in the distance
as patches of dark rosy pink against the white masses of roseus. Nearly
all nests of both species contained eggs in every stage of development
— mostly hard-set or chipping or just hatched — in addition to a great
many newly hatched chicks in french grey velvety powder-pulf down,
and hordes of older grey plumaged runners (pullets) of more or less
uniform size, between c. 30 and 60 cm tall (estimated as 30-40 days
old), looking like a vast stretch of mobile undergrowth around the
parents’ legs while being herded away at our instrusion. No significant
difference was apparent between the architecture of the nests or colour
and egg-size of the two species, though my impression is that eggs of
minor were somewhat less narrow and elongate. No marked difference
was noticeable in the newly hatched chicks either, except that those
of minor were perhaps of a slightly browner grey velvet. In fact the
two were not recognizable apart, and the nests of minor had to be
carefully marked down from a distance for closer examination. There
were one or two small unoccupied satellite colonies in the ‘suburbs’,
separated from the ‘metropolis’ by 200 metres or so of dry flat ground
— which had probably got left high and dry by the receding water
line before they could be fully occupied (top right, photo 1). Although
some of these nests looked freshly made there was little evidence of
their having been used, except some of them possibly by the earliest
breeders of the season. A vast area — perhaps a square kilometre or
more — on the leeward side of the City was littered fairly evenly with
individual wind-scattered white feathers which, in the lengthening
shadows of the setting sun, looked curiosuly like glistening snow flakes
or the aftermath of a hail storm.
That P. minor was breeding in Flamingo City in such large numbers
this year when none were found doing so on my previous visits, may
possibly be due to some hydrologic disturbance caused by the throw-
ing of the bund across the Little Rann (Banas River outflow) for the
National Highway to Kandla in the southern section, forcing the
birds to transfer their (suspected) breeding ground to the Great Rann.
It will be interesting to watch whether the birds will breed regularly
144 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
in Flamingo City hereafter.
It will be remembered that the first records of the breeding within
Indian limits of the Avocet and Rosy Pelican were also obtained
fortuitously during flying visits to Flamingo City in 1945 and 1960
respectively ( JBNHS 45:420-21; 57:413-15). The present discovery
of Lesser Flamingo breeding further highlights the potentiality of the
Great Rann as a repository of ornithological, and doubtless other,
surprises, and emphasizes the desirability of a properly planned bio-
logical survey of the entire area.
46 Pali Hill, SALIM ALI
Bandra,
Bombay 400 050,
March 19, 1974.
6. NOTES ON A SOOTY TERN ( STERNA FUSCATA
NUBILOSA SPARRMAN) COLLECTED NEAR CALICUT
In the first week of June this year a female Sooty Tern was brought
to Professor K. J. Joseph of the Zoology Department, Calicut Univer-
sity by a person who had trapped it near the campus. It was an adult
bird with very worn and moulting flight feathers. Presumably, it had
finished breeding and was blown inland from the coastal area. The
campus is about 7 miles distant from the coast of the Arabian Sea
and in June we had many strong gales.
This species breeds in the Lakshadweep from December /January
to May [Salim Ali and Dillon Ripley, 1969, handbook of the birds
of India and Pakistan Vol. 3:63]. In the specimen examined moult
of the feathers of the body had been completed, but the flight feathers
(both remiges and rectrices) were still moulting. It measured: wing
297 mm; outer tail feathers 147 mm; bill 39 mm from feathers; tarsus
23 mm. Both wing and tail had broken tips. The ovary had regressed.
Primaries 2 to 8 (counting from the proximal end) had recently
completed their growth. In the right wing the 8th primary was about
three-fourths and in the left, one-fourth grown. In both wings primaries
9-10 were old. Alula were moulting. As some of the secondaries (in-
cluding the feathers of the skin overlying the humerus) were missing,
they could not be numbered exactly, but we could count 19 in one
wing and twenty in the other. The colour, texture, and moult of the
secondary feathers suggested that their moult had started at three
different points. The outermost or first secondary was moulting in
both wings, and the 14th in the left wing alone. In both wings, second-
aries 2 to 13 were old and very much worn. The innermost group of
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES 145
5-6 secondaries (or tertiaries) had apparently completed growth much
earlier and were faded to some extent but strong. This suggested that
the tertiaries had moulted at a different time.
The greater upper coverts of the remiges had either recently com-
pleted growth or were in the final stages of growth, so were the upper
lesser wing-coverts and the upper tail-coverts. The upper median wing-
coverts were old. All the body tracts of feathers had fresh feathers
suggesting a recently completed moult.
The overall pattern of moult of flight feathers suggested a gradual
exchange of flight feathers without impairing flight completely at any
point. This is important for the survival of the bird as it spends most
of its time in the air. Renewal of the upper greater wing-coverts in
advance of the moult of remiges themselves, and completing the moult
of the tertiaries earlier, are protective. Fully grown upper greater
coverts protect the sensitive areas at the base of the growing wing
quills; the tertiaries protect the rest of the wing quills in the folded
wing.
Subdivision of Ecology & Ornithology, D. N. MATHEW
Zoology Department, E. A. A. SHUKKUR
Calicut University 673635,
June 9, 1973.
7. MORE CUCKOO PROBLEMS
In the nineteen-thirties the Journal of the Bombay Natural History
Society had devoted a number of pages to “cuckoo problems” concern-
ing the parasitic habits of this bird. The present note is intended to call
attention to another “problem”: the winter quarters of some cuckoos,
especially the Common Cuckoo Cuculus canorus. It seems to be an
accepted fact that some of the Cuckoo populations spend the winter in
India. I have come to doubt this fact after checking the Indian liter-
ature and finding that we possess too few records between October
and March to accept the assumption that India is a wintering ground
for the Cuckoo; these records are: North Kanara, November and
February (Davidson, JBNHS 72:51), Trivandrum, February (Ferguson,
ibid. 75:664), Maidive Islands, January (Philipps, ibid. 60:519) and
Andaman Islands, November. (Hume, Stray Feathers 4: 288). The
two known records from Sri Lanka are from October (one) and un-
dated (one). The November records may well pertain to belated
migrants. Vaurie (the birds of the palaeargtic fauna, Non- Pas-
seriformes 1965, p. 569) writes that the Cuckoo “winters in Africa. . .
in small numbers in India* and in smaller numbers in the Indochinese
10
146 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
countries.” Even if we account for the fact that the cuckoo is un-
obtrusive and silent in winter, it would be very surprising that such an
abundant, widespread and highly migratory species in the Palaearctic
would pass almost un-noticed in southeast Asia. I therefore suspect
that the main winter ground of the species including the Asiatic popu-
lation is in Africa. It is the opinion of Moreau (the palaearctic-
african bird migration systems, 1972, p. 183) that probably a large
proportion of the Asiatic birds winter in Africa. Unfortunately, the
two subspecies presently recognized besides the nominate race are
so poorly differentiated as to be of no value in determining the pro-
venance of African winter guests.
Although it is usually stated that Cuculus canorus winters in south-
eastern Asia, it should be noticed that data for December to February
are almost entirely lacking for the whole area. The winter status of
this species for southeastern Asia including the Philippines, should
probably better be changed to “straggler”.
The Cuckoo appears to be abundant on passage in central India
in September and October (Butler, Stray Feathers 5:221, Barnes,
JBNHS 4: 18, and others). Indeed the pattern of autumn migration
in India is somewhat similar to that of the Redfooted Falcon Falco
vespertinus which is known to winter in Africa. Whistler was similarly
impressed by the lack of winter data for the Pied Crested Cuckoo
Clamator jacobinas and also brought to attention the possibility that
it might spend the winter in Africa ( JBNHS 55:136-145 and 57:523).
See also Wells, D. R., JBNHS 69:179-185, for an amendment to the
winter range of both Cuculus saturatus and C. poliocephalus given by
Ali and Ripley in the handbook of the birds of India and Pakistan
vol. 5, 1969. The winter range of C. canorus will also have to be
amended there.
Concerning the Emerald Cuckoo Chalcites maculatus, I have not
found any definite winter records from India. Most observers in the
Himalayan foothills refer to it as a summer visitor. In Assam, Flume
(Stray Feathers 11:15) found it only in summer. The species is known
to winter in the Malay peninsula and in southern Thailand but is a
summer visitor in northern Thailand. In winter it reaches Sumatra
and, probably at this season only, the Andaman and Nicobar Islands.
The winter status of the Violet Cuckoo Chalcites xanthorhynchus in
India is quite unknown.
U. S. National Museum, NHB 336, MICHEL DESFAYES
Smithsonian Institute,
Washington, D. C. 20560,
March 22, 1974.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
147
8. ON THE OCCURRENCE OF THE COMMON GREY HORN-
BILL TOCKUS BIROSTRIS (SCOPOLI) NEAR BOMBAY
The note on the occurrence of the Common Grey Hornbill Tockus
birostris (Scopoli) in the Government House Gardens in Bombay City
(S. R. Amladi & J. C. Daniel, JBNHS 70(2) : 378-379) prompts a
few remarks.
I did record seeing a Malabar Grey Hornbill T. griseus (Latham)
at Ghodbunder in Salsette Island on 17 April 1943. The bird was being
chivvied by crows and the fleeting glimpse was put down as griseus,
for this was the nearest recorded species (from the Ghat area of
Khandala) and there was no evidence of birostris occurring in the
Konkan, away from the Deccan.
In 1945, a bird flying across at Powai was definitely noted as
'birostris (JBNHS 45, p. 242) and many subsequent sightings more
carefully examined convince me:
1) that the earlier records of Tockus griseus from Salsette and
the Konkan were in error for T. birostris, and
2) that birostris has either newly entered this area or increased
appreciably in numbers. Its occurrence in the neighbourhood of Bom-
bay was not referred to by earlier authors but in recent years it has
been seen on most trips to the Borivli National Park and also at
Kihim, across the harbour in Kolaba district, where 8 were seen to-
gether. The birds in the Government House Gardens were mentioned
to me a few years ago, but I did not have the opportunity of seeing
them.
Having been specifically noted in April, May and December, it is
unlikely that they are migratory to any large extent. The Grey Horn-
bill is essentially a bird of deciduous forests and open plains (or
gardens) interspersed with large trees. I have seen it feeding on the
fruit of the teak (Tectona grandis) and Manilkara hexandra.
75 Abdul Rehman Street, HUMAYUN ABDULALI
Bombay 400 003,
March 19, 1974.
9. FEEDING HABITS OF THE STAR TORTOISE—
GEOCHELONE ELEGANS
(With a photograph)
In keeping several pairs of the land tortoise G. elegans we note
that they are mostly vegetarians, feeding on a wide variety of grasses
and shrubs which grow in our large snake enclosure. On several occa-
148 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (1)
sions we have noticed that the tortoises show an interest in dead rats
which had been placed for the snakes. The tortoise has difficulty in
breaking the tough rat skin but will consume the flesh of a rat’s leg
Geochelone elegans starts to feed on a dead rat.
in about half an hour of pulling and “chewing”. Pritchard in his
living turtles of the world mentions that G. elegans is known to
eat snails, but flesh eating by land tortoises seems a phenomenon and
perhaps applies only to captive specimens deprived of a complete
natural diet.
Madras Snake Park, R. WHITAKER
Guindy Deer Sanctuary,
Madras 600 022,
February 10, 1974.
10. BEHAVIOUR OF THE AGAMID GARDEN LIZARD,
CALOTES VERSICOLOR
Only within the last few years, thermoregulation in tropical lizards
has been investigated. The general conclusion is that selection of habitat,
behaviour and thermal sensitivity are closely interrelated. The temper-
ature is perhaps the most important limiting factor in the ecology of
an ecfotherm.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
149
The object of this report is to study some aspects of observation on
behaviour of the agamid garden lizard, Calotes versicolor.
Activity of the lizards : The activity of the C. versicolor was studied
in great detail on a section of the Ravenshaw College campus area
during the period June to December, 1971. The study involved not only
behavioural studies but also counting of the population, sex-ratio
observed on the plot at different times of the day. During this study
no distinction with respect to size or stage of thermoregulatory be-
haviour was made but the conditions of temperature and light were
noted.
Diurnal activity : C. versicolor is a diurnal lizard. The lizard starts
activity in summer at about 6.00 a.m. and at about 7.00 a.m. during
winter. Morning active phase may extend up to sunset with a short
period of rest at noon. However, these active phases are dependent
on factors like light and rain. During bright and warm weather most
of them were found at rest under some shade in the field. During
rain or stormy weather, lizards, took shelter on trunks of trees or in
bushes. Observations of marked adults indicate that most of them
were active throughout the morning when the weather conditions are
normal and many remain in the bushes.
The lizards were found active in the morning hours when the sky
was clear. Many of them left the bushes before 11.00 a.m. under
‘cloudy’ conditions of the sky, the lizards took longer time to reach
their activity threshold and they were seen basking on the rock or
stem till noon. The intensity of light in rock and stem shadow was
found to vary from c. 100-400 and 75-375 ft. respectively.
Nocturnal activity : The adult and juvenile (S-V length range: 24-60
mm) of C. versicolor were observed to be inactive during nights irres-
pective of weather conditions. The lizards just rested or slept under the
bush or on tree trunk or on branches of the tree.
Sleeping habits : The sleeping habits of adult lizards were observed.
C. versicolor was observed to prefer the tree trunks and branches. They
slept in a horizontal position, in such a habitat with their bellies touch-
ing the tree. During sleep, the legs of the garden lizard were folded
close to the body and the tail was fully extended. The average height
of the place to where they climbed and slept was 1.5 m (Range: 0.4-
3.5 m). Sometimes, rarely both, adult males and females were observed
sleeping close to each other irrespective of seasons at about 6.00 p.m.
and they awoke at about 6.00 a.m.
Thermoregulation and temperature preferences’. The adults and juve-
niles of C. versicolor were seen basking during sunshine. Mature, adults
were observed to spend more time for basking especially orientating
their bodies to receive maximum sunshine. The basking range in C,
versicolor is up to 35.0°C,
150 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Since the basking behaviour was observed only during sunshine, it
is considered to be related to the thermoregulation of the lizard.
Furthermore, the activity of the lizard was found to be influenced
mostly by the environmental temperature. The preferred temperature
(is the mean of normal activity range) for the garden lizard, C. versi-
color studied here fell around 36.0°C.
The body temperature in C. versicolor was higher than their habitat
temperature (both air and substratum) during day time but almost
same during night.
Thermal thresholds : The thermal thresholds (°C) in C. versicolor were
observed as follows
Moulting behaviour : C. versicolor moults frequently, starting with
the head and finally the posterior region. During moulting the
colour of the lizards was dark brown. The moulting takes place from
3 to 10 days.
Acknowledgements
Thanks are due to : Dr. R. Mohanty, Vice-Chancellor, Utkal Univer-
sity for permission to study the lizards in his garden; Prof. B. K.
Behura, Head of the Department of Zoology for laboratory facilities
and the Secretary, U.G.C. for financial support.
Post-Graduate Dept, of Zoology, M. V. SUBBA RAO
Utkal University,
Bhubaneswar, Orissa,
November 30, 1973.
11. COBRA WITH KINGFISHER CAUGHT IN THROAT
Recently a cobra (Naja n. naja) was brought to us alive with the
head and bill of a white-breasted kingfisher {Halcyon smyrensis)
caught in its throat. The long beak and broad head of the bird
was too much for the cobra to swallow or regurgitate and the snake
would probably have died if we hadn’t carefully removed the bird.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
151
There are few records of cobras swallowing large, active birds. This
adult kingfisher was perhaps caught by the cobra on its roost at night.
Madras Snake Park, R. WHITAKER
Guindy Deer Sanctuary,
Madras 600 022,
February 10, 1974.
(
12. ALGAL POOD OP APLOCHEILUS BLOCHU (ARNOLD)
Aplocheilus blochii (Arnold) is a small fish found in the streams
of Nagpur. The fish is used as food by the poor. Microscopical study
of the intestinal contents of the fish from their natural habitats showed
the species of Oscillatoria, Spirogyra, Cosmarium and a number of
diatoms.
It is known that the study of intestinal contents only do not give
a correct idea of the food (Kamat 1966, 1969) and so a number of
algae belonging to Chlorophyceae, Euglenophyceae and Cyanophyceae
were tried to find out the algae used as food by the author’s method
(Kamat, loc. cit.).
It was found that species of Oscillatoria, Anabaenopsis (veg.),
Euglena and diatoms are digested by the fish; species of Spirogyra
and Closterium are partially digested while species of Cosmarium,
Oedogonium, Rhizoclonium, Chlorella, Scenedesmus, Pediastrum, Pan-
dorina, Elakatothrix, Trachelomonas, Chroococcus, Microcystis, Meris-
mopedia, Gloeothece, Lyngbya, Aulosira and Scytonema are not digest-
ed at all. These algae when separated and cleaned from the excreta
were found to be unaffected and could be grown in cultures. It may
be mentioned here that Pandorina colonies when freed from excreta
started swimming immediately.
The fish even when starved, did not take species of Pithophora,
Cladophora, Dichotomo siphon, Nitella, Lychnothamnus and Chara,
probably because they were too big.
One to four days old fry was found to grow much better on species
of Oscillatoria alone than on a mixture of Oscillatoria, Euglena and
diatoms. When a number of algae are given as food, the fish shows
first preference for Oscillatoria.
Twenty five medium and large sized fishes were kept in a small
cistern (3' x 3' x 3' ) containing species of Oscillatoria, Euglena and
Cladophora with epiphytic diatoms and after three years their number
rose to 832,
152 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vo\. 71 (1)
Ack NOWLEDGE M E N TS
I take this opportunity to thank Shri M. G. Radke of the Fisheries
Dept., Nagpur for kindly identifying the fish.
Botany Dept., N. D. KAMAT
Institute of Science,
Nagpur 1,
October 28, 1971.
Referen ces
Kamat, N. D. (1966): Food of (1969): Algae as
Planispira nagporensis Pfeiffer. Curr. food of Barbus conchonius Ham. et
Scl 35(7) : 179. Buch. ibid. 38( 2):50.
13. ON A NEW RECORD OF A MURREL, CHANNA LEUCO-
PUNCTATUS (SYKES) FROM RAJASTHAN
i
While collecting in lake Kailana (c. 13 km N. W. of Jodhpur,
Rajasthan) a floating dead specimen of Channa leucopunctatus, measur-
ing 647 mm in total length was collected. Subsequently, a fresh speci-
men of this species, measuring 560 mm in total length was collected
from the same lake. Freshly caught specimens of this species have also
been found in the local fish market. However, the occurrence of this
species in Rajasthan is reported here for the first time.
Four species of Channa, namely, C. punctatus (Bloch), C. marulius
(Hamilton), C. striatus (Bloch) and C. gachua (Hamilton) are re-
ported earlier from Rajasthan (Datta & Majumdar 1970). Of these
only C. punctatus and C. marulius have been recorded earlier from
lake Kailana (Menon & Krishna 1958). I have also collected C. pun-
ctatus and C. marulius along with C. leucopunctatus from this lake.
Day (1889) gives the distribution of C. leucopunctatus as Coro-
mandel and Western coasts of India, some of the rivers in the Deccan
and Cauvery in Mysore, it is also said to be found in China. The
present find, therefore, extends the known range of distribution of this
species in India further north to Rajasthan. This species is not known
to occur elsewhere in the northern and north eastern parts of India,
along the Himalayas (Menon 1962). Thus the occurrence of this species
in China presents an interesting example of discontinuous distribution.
C. leucopunctatus belongs to the ; family Channidae. The fishes of
this family are air-breathing and are commonly called murrels. They
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES j yi 153
constitute one of the important groups of food fish.
This species resembles C. marulius, but can be easily distinguished
from it by the lack of a black white-edged ocellus on the caudal fin
and numerous white spots on the caudal and dorsal fins.
ACK N OWLEDGE M E N TS
I wish tQ express my sincere thanks to Dr. A. P. Kapur, Director,
Zoological Survey of India, Calcutta for providing with necessary faci-
lities and to Dr. Asket Singh, Officer-in-Charge, Northern Regional
Station, Zoological Survey of India, Dehra Dun for encouragement.
Northern Regional Station, R. N. BHARGAVA
Zoological Survey of India,
Dehra Dun,
December 7, 1972.
Qr -1. • '• -C r..:; - - •>.
References
r. ,, •. , , • . ■ „ ‘ j-,,,,-,...,
Datta, A. K. & Majumdar, N. tributional list of fishes of tjfie Him-
(1970): Fauna of Rajasthan, India.: alayas. J. Zool: Soc. India, Calcutta,
Part 7. Fishes. Rec. Zool. Surv. India, 14(1-2) : 23-32.
Calcutta, 62(1-2) :63-100.
Day, F. (1889): The fauna of Bri- Menon, C. B. & Krishna, D.
fish Indii, including Ceylon and Bur- (1958) : A note on the, fishes of
ma. Fishes. Vol. 2. London (Taylor & Jodhpur (Rajasthan). (In Hindi).
Francis). Vijnan Parishad Anusandhan Patrika,
Menon, A. G. K. (1962): A dis- Allahabad (4) : 207-209.
14. A SPECIAL METHOD OF FISH TRAPPING IN RIVER
GANGA AT VARANASI
(With a text -figure)
Fishing methods used in river Ganga have been described in some
detail by several earlier workers. In the present communication, a
method, locally known as Koli, which had not attracted the attention
of earlier workers, and is extensively employed in Ganga at Varanasi,
is described. The method is effective for catching Chela spp., Aspido-
paria spp., Puntius spp., Mugil spp., Mystus spp., etc. along shallow,
sandy, banks where the current is sluggish. Two to six fishermen, two
to four long bamboos (4m-5m), one or two short bamboos (2m-3m),
four short “Y” shaped sticks (0.5m- lm), one big split bamboo or reed
154 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
screen (1.8m-2.4m x 3.6in-4.5m), one rectangular split bamboo screen
(0.3m-0.6m x 3.6m-4.5m), another comparatively smaller split bamboo
or reed screen (0.6m-0.9m x 1.5m-2.4m), one to two iron discs (0.3m-
0.4m diameter) and a few baskets of split bamboo are essential pre-
requisites for Koli fishing.
A small water area of 0.3m-0.4m depth along the shallow, sandy,
bank of the river is enclosed by raising temporary sand bunds, (0.61m-
0. 91. high). This enclosure has one or more openings connecting it
with the main river (A, Fig. 1). The enclosure remains connected with
the river all through night but is closed by bamboo screen, straw or
sand quite early in the morning before sunrise, when the fishing oper-
ation starts. (B, Fig. 1). The fishes which enter the enclosure from
the main river during night are enclosed and their escape is thus pre-
vented. The fishes, so trapped are fished out almost completely in the
following three operations, which take about two hours time.
1 . A wide, shallow, channel (4m-8m width) is prepared by the side
of the enclosure, by removing the sand from the bed with the
help of iron disc. This channel connects the enclosure with the
river. A large platform screen is made in the enclosure near its
junction with the channel (C, Fig. 1), by spreading the screen
on two long bamboos placed horizontally on four “Y” shaped
sticks fixed in the bed. The rectangular split bamboo screen is
then fixed in a slanting position in such a way that the lower side
remains embedded in the sand bed of the enclosure, while the
upper side rests a little above the screen platform. An opening is
now made removing the sand at the mouth of the channel (D,
Fig. 1) to allow the flow of water into the channel. The fishes,
mostly Chela spp., Aspidoparia spp., Mugil spp., etc. trapped in
the enclosure, move towards the channel and finding a barrier
of the slanting screen, jump, and are thus stranded on the hori-
zontal platform. These fishes are then collected by rolling the plat-
form from both the sides and then the catch is kept in the basket.
2. In the second operation, the rectangular split bamboo screen is
changed from slanting to vertical position. The fishermen, there-
after, start scaring the fish by beating the water in the enclosure
and move towards the vertical screen. The fishermen use the short
bamboos, holding them by hand and beating the water hori-
zontally. As the fishermen approach the vertical screen, another
vertical screen is fixed behind them in the enclosure, thereby
reducing the area of operation and checking the escape of fishes
into the enclosure again. In this process, the fishes which strike
against the bamboo or legs of the fishermen, are caught by hand.
Catfishes like Mystus spp., R. rita, etc., which do not jump over
the horizontal platform in the first operation, are thus trapped
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
155
and are removed by hand by the fishermen.
3. Fishes that have escaped capture, during first two operations are
generally small sized (5-10 cm) and are caught in the third and
last operation. A shallow, narrow drain (0.8m- 1m) is dug by
removing sand by iron disc as in the second operation, connecting
the enclosure with the river. A screen is fixed in the drain verti-
cally near its junction with river (E, Fig. 1). Water is allowed
to pass through the drain removing the sand at the junction of
enclosure and channel (F, Fig. 1). After, it is noticed that the
movement of fishes into the drain from enclosure has stopped,
the mouth of the drain at the enclosure is closed by putting sand.
Most of the fishes get stranded near the screen while some get
trapped on the wet sand after the flow of water ceases. Both are
picked up by hand.
The catch is collected in baskets and taken to fish market. The
enclosure is again connected with the river by removing the screens
for operation on the next morning.
This method is employed all round the year except the rainy season
(June-September). The average catch of the fish per operation per day
ranges from 10 kg to 30 kg. The effectiveness of this method may be
due to the fact that on the approach of dusk, small sized fishes moving
along the shallow banks of the river, enter the enclosure, which are
156: JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
devoid of current to secure rest and protection.. The efficacy of this
method, particularly during dark nights, is further supported by the
observations of the catch during moonlit nights, which is generally
much less than the catch on dark nights.
Central Inland Fisheries S. P. SINGH
Research Substation,
24, Pannalal Road,
Allahabad,
November 13, 1971.
15. CANNIBALISM AMONG SCORPIONS
The question whether scorpions ever eat each other has not been
discussed in Max Vachon’s admirable Note on “The Biology of Scor-
pions’’ ( JBNHS 54, No. 1). Having recently kept some of these
interesting arthropods,' T offer the following observations.
(1) On 3-xi-’73 I obtained a female of the common “grey-and-
yellow” type (cephalothorax and abdomen grey on top, legs and
pedipalps yellow or pale orange) with some 20-25 babies crawling
over her. The babies were so recently born that they were still colour-
less, only developing the typical colouring some-4-5 days later. Deciding
to test the widespread belief that a mother scorpion offers her body
for her babies’ first meal, I kept the family in a glass jar with no food
supply.
The babies died off one by one, while at the same time there was
a decrease in the number of bodies (both living and dead) which
could be seen. Since I feel reasonably certain that the mother ate none
of her babies, this suggests that the stronger progeny devoured the
weaker. By early December all the babies had died. Twelve bodies
were counted in the jar, and these were left for some more days, during
which the mother never touched them. That she was very hungry
was proved by the eagerness with which she seized and totally devoured
a cricket which I offered, after removing the babies’ dead bodies, on
24 December.
The common belief in scorpions’ matriphagy thus appears to be
just another popular superstition.
(2) On 26-x-’73 two full-grown “grey-and-yellow” scorpions were
found, a few inches apart, under a large stone. Not possessing the
knowledge to sex them, I assumed that they were male and female,
and kept them together in a large glass jar. As food, they were offered
large cockroaches; these however seemed to inspire the scorpions with
alarm, and were never captured and eaten in spite of being left there
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
157
for many days. For many subsequent days I was prevented from catch-
ing crickets, and it thus came about that the two scorpions fasted for
some seven weeks.
One day, about the middle of December, I examined the jar and
found the slightly larger scorpion dead, with the slightly smaller insect
in the act of feeding on its left side. All the legs on this side had been
bitten off, and the left pedipalp had been sucked hollow; there was
also a fairly extensive wound on the body’s left side between the
cephalothorax and the abdomen.
This observation suggests that scorpions — at least of the same
generation — do eat each other if no alternative food is available.
(3) On the other hand, I have three small scorpions (two “grey-
and-yellow”, one black) which have lived together peaceably in the
same jar for the last two months, during which their food supply of
crickets and grasshoppers has had to be very irregular. When these
insects encounter each other, they feel one another with their pedi-
palps and then separate in different directions. They can even crawl
over each other’s bodies without provoking any aggressive response.
Those persons who may be interested in making further obser-
vations, may rest assured that scorpions cannot climb perpendicular
glass surfaces and may be safely kept in deep glass jars. The bottom
of the jar should be covered in sifted soil, and a piece of coconut shell,
fitted with a wire hook on top for purposes of easy removal, makes a
satisfactory “stone” for the scorpions to hide under, being light enough
to cause no damage in case it is accidentally dropped into the jar.
Dev ICunj, THOMAS GAY
Prabhat Road,
Poona 411 004,
January 11, 1974.
16. ALEURO DOTH RIPS FASCIAPENNIS (FRANKLIN)
PREDATORY ON COCCIDS AND ALEYRODIDS
{With a text-figure )
Franklin (1908) described the species Cryptothrips fasciapennis
based on a solitary female on the leaf of lime in West Indies and in
the very next year erected the genus Aleurodothrips with C. fascia-
pennis as the Type, Priesner (1949) synonymised Cephalothrips
spoinous. Bagnall (1909) subsequently transferred it to the genus Micra-
canthothrips (Bagnall 1914). Aleurodothrips fasciapennis enjoys a
wide distribution being recorded from Barbados, Bermuda, Sri Lanka,
China, Cuba, Fiji, Florida, Formosa, Hawaii, Java, Jamaica and even
158 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 11 (1)
from Brussels and New York. This species was first recorded in this
country by the author in 1964 feeding on coccids on the leaves of
Palmyra (Borassus flabellifer). Since then this species has been record-
ed more frequently and recently a good series was taken on drying
Pandanus infested with coccids, in West Bengal. Its introduction from
Java to Fiji for the control of Aspidiotus destructor on coconut palms
and its close association with other aleyrodids and coccids point to
the possibility of its usefulness in biological control.
Examination of a good series of both sexes offered good evidence
for the presence of major and minor females and oedymerous and
gynaecoid males. While the genus Aleurodothrips is characterised
among other features by the banded wings, lack of epimeral suture
on pronotum, the divided pelta and by the strongly developed fore-
Fig. 1. Aleurodothrips fasciapennis: A. Head & Prothorax of major female,
a. Forelimb of normal female; b. Antenna of female; c. Head and prothorax
of normal male; d. Foreleg of oedymerous male.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
159
femoral spur or tooth in the males, the distinct presence of a com-
paratively small spur on the forefemora of major females appears
to be of interest. This is absent in the minor and normal females.
Correspondingly the three or four seta bearing warts become more
emphasised in oedymerous males and absent in gynaecoid males
(Fig. 1).
While Stannard (1968) has characterised this species in detail, it
would be proper to give the range of essential measurements (in
microns) so as to have an idea of the intraspecific variation of this
important species, information on which is lacking.
Macropterous female {male) :
Head 112-115 long (92-96), 124 (99-106) wide across eyes, 129-
131 (99-106) across cheeks and 124-126 (97-103) at base. Eyes 46
(44) long, 37-44 (34-36) wide. Antennal segments, 1-8, length (width):
Female : 18-23 (23); 32-34 (23); 51-53 (18-21); 44-46 (21-23); 37-
39 (21-23); 32-34 (18); 25-28 (11-14); 23-25 (7).
Male : 14-16 (18-21); 25-28 (18); 44-46 (14-16); 37-41 (21); 32-
37- ( 18-21 ) ; 30-34 (16-18); 23 (11); 18-23 (7-9).
Mouth cone broadly rounded, 122-124 (92-101) wide at base and 71
(48-55) at apex.
Prothorax 103-115 (76-94) long, 131-140 (103-115) wide at ante-
rior margin, 92-107 (133-166) across posterior; anteroangulars 16-21
(11-16), epimerals 16-23 (21-23) expanded at apex. Forefemora 80-
92 (80-103) wide, foretarsal tooth absent in female, with a minute
tooth in males, 5-9 long; forefemora of normal and minor females
unarmed, major females with a distinct spur; forefemora of males
with a strong tooth, reduced in gynaecoid males and well developed
in oedymerous males, 21-32 long; foretibia of males with a series of
2-3, rarely 4 emphasised tubercles better developed in oedymerous
individuals. Forewing 520 (395-441) long, comparatively narrow, and
without double fringes; basal wing bristles very short 5 (5-7), 5-7
(7-11), 7-11 (9-11) long, expanded.
Abdomen 226-237 (136-162) wide at base, 249-260 (124-136) at
middle, 158-169 (90-102) and 79-102 (68) across VIII and IX. B1-B3
of IX 39-41 (56); 64-69 (34-36) and 69 (69) long. Tube 94 (80) long,
46 (34-37), 34(25-34) and 23 (23-32) respectively wide at base,middle
and apex. Anal setae 69-80 (46-73) long.
Total body length: 1.051-1.445 (0.836-0.842) mm long.
Material'. Sibpore (West Bengal), drying Pandanus, 27-i-72; 14
females, 8 males, Kolathur, Kerala, Palmyra leaves, 3 l-vii-64; 10
females, 9 males; Calicut (Kerala), grass, 4-xi-63, 8 females, 6 males;
Chalakudi (Kerala), bamboo leaves, 5-xii-63, 4 females, 2 males;
Mangalore (Mysore), grass, 26-i-64, 4 females, 2 males.
Thanks are due to the U.S. Department of Agriculture for the
160 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, VoL 71 (1)
award of a PL 480 grant during the tenure of which this work was
done.
Entomology Research Unit, T. N. ANANTHAKRISHNAN
Loyola College,
Madras 34,
May 11, 1972.
References
Bagnall, R. S. (1909): Annls. Soc.
ent. Belg. 53:174-75.
(1914) : Brief des-
criptions of New Thysanoptera. III.
Ann. Mag., Nat. Hist. 8( 13) : 295.
Franklin, H. J. (1908): A collec-
tion of Thysanopterous insects from
Proc. U.S. National Museum 33:721-
29.
Priesner, H. (1^49) : Genera Thy-
sanopterorum. Bull. Soc. Found ler
Ent. 33: 119.
Stannard, L. J. (1968): The Thrips
or Thysanoptera of Illinois. III. Nat.
Barbados and St. Vincent Islands. Hist. Sur. Bull. 29(4) : 399-401.
17. NOTE ON THE PECULIAR BEHAVIOUR OF
DRAGONFLIES
It is now known that certain dragonflies have the habit of follow-
ing, without any apparent reason, moving objects both animate and
inanimate. For example, Acharya (1961) and Worth (1962) reported
unspecified dragonflies following bicycles and Corbet (1962) reported
Brachythemis leucostcta following a walking man over a concrete pave-
ment in Africa. I have observed an Ictinogomphus rapax Ramb. fol-
lowing a moving tram car for about 10 metres on a June evening in
1966, and a Pantala flavescens (Fab.) following for about 6-7 metres
another tram car in an afternoon of April, 1968. On the latter occasion
the dragonfly was found to hit against the roof of the vehicle. One
morning in July, 1970, some examples of Crocothemis servilia (Dr.)
were observed to follow motor vehicles running along a main trunk
road in the suburbs of Calcutta for about 4 to 5 metres and then to
come back their original place. Sometimes seven
(Ramb.) and Brachythemis contaminata (Fab.)
to follow men walking along grasslands.
Acharya (1961) considered this behaviour o
but Worth (1962) considered it as hunting strategy. But Corbet (1962)
did not consider it as a preying technique because no small-winged
insect was found to rest on the concrete pavement. Similarly, no wing-
ed insect could possibly be resting near moving vehicles and men. From
the above facts it is clear, as Corbet (1962) has already suggested
il Di placodes trivialis
dragonflies are found
f dragonflies as fun.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
161 7
that the response of dragonflies towards moving objects offers promis-
ing field for research in odonata behaviour.
Entomology Laboratory, TRIDIB RAN JAN MITRA
Deptt. of Zoology,
Calcutta University,
Calcutta,
October 30, 1971.
R EFEREN CES
Acharya, H. G. (1961): Strange
behaviour of some dragonflies. J.
Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 58(3 ) : 819-20.
Corbet, P. S. (1962): A Biology
of dragonflies, London.
Worth, C. B. (1962) : Dragonflies
and bicycles. J. Bombay nat. Hist.
Soc. 59(2) :676-77.
18. FOOD PREFERENCES IN THE LARVAE OF TWO MOTHS:
SPODOPTERA LITURA F. (FAM. NOCTUIDAE) AND
DIACRISIA OBLIQUA WALK. (FAM. ARCTIIDAE)
(With a text -figure)
The larvae of the moths Spodoptera litura and Diacrisia obliqua
are serious pests of cruciferous plants in Saharanpur (U.P.) and are
responsible for considerable damage. The larvae of the former (S.
litura) hatch out in early September, and have an average larval period
of about ten days completed in five moults and mainly feed upon
cauliflower leaves of the early crop. The larvae of the latter (D. obliqua)
hatch out in late October, and have an average larval period of about
thirty eight days completed in six moults and are mainly pests on
raddish leaves. In the light of thermal constant derived by Muggeridge
( 1942) 1 in regard to the development of Pieris rapae, difference bet-
ween the duration of their larval periods — 10 days in the former and
38 days in the latter — is perhaps accountable since the normal room
temperature recorded in early September was around 30°C as against
20°-18°C in late October.
With a view to determine the extent of food preference in the
larvae of the two moths (S. litura and D. obliqua) their comparative
rate of feeding during the entire larval period was studied on their
usual food (cauliflower leaves in the case of S. litura and raddish
1 Muggeridge, J. (1942): The White Butterfly (Pieris rapae L.) : Its
establishment, spread and control in New Zeland. N. Z J. Sci. & Tech. 24(3).
11
162 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
leaves in case of D. obliqua) as well as unusual food (raddish leaves
in case of S. litura and cauliflower in case of D. obliqua ), as indicated
by the faecal matter produced by them in 24 hours.
S. litura lays eggs in early September on the underside of the leaves
of cauliflower plants, usually of those situated on the periphery of
the fields. D. obliqua lays eggs from late October to early December on
the underside of the leaves of raddish plants. The leaves of the host
plants with the corresponding eggs on them were taken to the labora-
tory. Eggs were reared in glass-chimneys and were observed every eight
hours for hatching.
Of the freshly hatched larvae, twelve in each case were placed in
a large petri-dish covered over by a rearing glass-chimney and fed on
leaves (of cauliflower or raddish, as per the requisite of the experi-
ment), which were replaced by fresh ones every day, between 10.00
and 11.00 a.m. During the same period every day, the faecal matter
accumulated in the petri-dish during the past 24 hours was collected
by means of a fine camel hair brush. The faecal matter was then
weighed as such, as well as after drying it in oven for 24 hours at
100°C, with a view to obtain comparative rate of feeding of the larvae
of the tv/o moths on their usual and unusual foods during their entire
larval periods, till they stopped feeding preparatory to pupation.
Results
The comparative amounts of faecal matter (wet without drying)
produced by twelve larvae each of S. litura and D. obliqua, during
their entire larval period are shown in Fig. 1. These results may be
interpreted to suggest the following
1. The larvae of S. litura have preference for cauliflower leaves
for their food as indicated by the fact that twelve of them produce
19.8 gm of faecal matter (wet) when fed on cauliflower leaves (their
usual food) but produce only 13.2 gm of it when fed on raddish leaves
(not their usual food).
2. The larvae of D. obliqua on the other hand, do not have any
appreciable preference for any one of them since they produce 18.8
gm of faecal matter when fed on raddish leaves (their usual food) as
against 18.4 gm when fed on cauliflower leaves (not their usual food).
3. Although the larval period in S. litura is completed in 10 days
and in D. obliqua in 38-39 days, the total amount of faecal matter
produced is not much different indicating thereby that the damage
done in a day by the larvae of the former is nearly four times of that
done by the larvae of the latter.
4. The shorter larval period in S. litura is perhaps due to a higher
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
163
temperature (room temp, about 30°C) during September and the con-
sequent higher metabolic activity, as also co-related by their higher
food intake. Evidently it is on this account that the early cauliflower
crops are prone to a much higher damage than the later crops when
temperature is lower.
A B A B
Fig. 1. — Comparative amount of faecal matter (wet, without oven — drying;
in gm) passed by 12 larvae each of S. litura and D. obliqua during their entire
larval periods extending over 10 days (5 moults) in the former and 38-39
days (6 moults) in the latter. A — While feeding on their usual food (cauli-
flower leaves for IS. litura and raddish leaves for D. obliqua)’, B — while feed-
ing on their unusual food (raddish leaves for S. litura and cauliflower leaves
for D. obliqua).
Acknowledgements
I am extremely grateful to Dr. Surendra Sharma, Professor of
Zoology, M. S. College, Saharanpur, for guidance and encouragement.
Also I am thankful to the College authorities for the facilities and to
Dr. Fennah, Director, Commonwealth Institute of Entomology, London,
for identification of the moths.
Department of Zoology, ASHA BASSI
M. S. College,
Saharanpur, (U.P),
December 31, 1971.
164 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
19. ORTHETRUM GLAUCUM (BRAUER) PREYING UPON
PALPOPLEURA SEXMACULATA SEXMACULATA (FABR.)
(ODONATA: LIBELLULXDAE)
Hobby (1934) describes the dragonflies as one of the best known
entomorphagous predators. According to Tillyard (1917) they are
the most powerful determining factors in preserving the balance of
insect life in ponds, rivers, lakes and their surroundings. They not only
prey upon other groups of insect but do not spare even weaker mem-
bers of their own kind. An interesting case was observed during our
visit to the Corbett National Park (U.P.) in November 1971. A speci-
men of O. glaucum was observed resting on a grass stalk, (grasping
a smaller dragonfly) between its extended legs. The head of the
prey had already been devoured and its thorax was in the process of
being consumed. The two specimens were collected at this stage and
no further observations could be recorded.. The prey was later deter-
mined to be a specimen of P. s. sexmaculata.
Zoological Survey of India,
13, Subhas Road,
Dehra Dun, (U.P.),
April 24, 1972.
References
Hobby, B. M. (1934): The prey Tillyard, R. J. (1917): The Bio-
of British dragonflies. Trans, ent. Soc. logy of Dragonflies. Cambridge.
S. England 8:65-16.
20. ARCHIDIACEAE FROM WESTERN INDIA
(With fifteen text figures)
Archidiaceae is a small family consisting of a single tropical genus
Archidium Brid. They are tiny perennial mosses growing on ground
in meadow, barren places usually with high silicious content. A note-
worthy characteristic of the genus is the large polyhedral spores, the
largest among the mosses so far known. Those of Archidium alterni-
folium (Hedw.) Mitt, are as much as 200 |i in diameter.
Genus Archidium Brid., Bryol. Univ. 1:747.1826.
Being the only genus of the family, its characters are the
same as those of the family Archidiaceae. They are small perennating
mosses, perennating by means of underground protonema and stolon-
R. N. BHARGAVA
MAHABIR PRASAD
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
165
like branches. Narrow, ovate, lanceolate to lanceolate-subulate leaves
with comose tuft arise on the upperside. Leaf base cells rectangular
to quadrate. Upper leaf cells prosenchymatous. Nerve rather homo-
genous.
Sporophyte immersed, with or without reduced seta. Capsule
spherical, sunken at the tip of the gametophyte and with a bulbous
foot covered by delicate calyptra. Stomata and columella absent.
Varied size of the polygonal spores range from 100 to 200 p. in dia-
meter.
There are four species in India namely A. indicum C. MuelL, A.
microthecium Dix. et P. Vard., A. octosporum Dix. et. P. Vard. and
A. birmannicum Mitt, et Dix. (Bruhl 1931). Out of these A. birman-
nicum Mitt. ex. Dix. and A. indicum C. Muell. are common in western
India. A. birmannicum Mitt, ex Dix. recorded by Sedgwick (1919)
from Jog Falls, Dharwar and Karwar in Karnataka (Dixon 1921),
whereas the A. indicum C. Muell. has been recorded by O. N. Handoo
(1966) from Pachmarhi in Madhya Pradesh and by Norkett (1966)
from Bhakra-Nangal in Punjab. A. indicum C. Muell. in western
India is a new record. The specimens of the two species were collected
at Khandala, Borivli (Bombay), Mumbra and Matheran.
Key to species
Plants comose, sporophytes on innovations, leaves widely ovate-lanceolate
with broad at basal and middle region, slowly narrowed at apex, percurrent
nerve A. indicum
Plants non-comose, sterile, lax leaved, leaves broad at base, gradually narrowed
at apex, lanceolate, nerve percurrent, concolor A. birmannicum
Archidium birmannicum Mitt, ex Dix., /. Ind. Bot. Soc., 2:175, t. 1,
1921— (Figs. 1-6).
Non-comose, sterile plants of 5-8 mm high growing on moist
ground with lax leaves (Figs. 1-2). Leaves narrow in the apical and
middle regions, broad at the base, ovate-lanceolate, 0.5 to 0.7 mm
in length and 0.2 to 0.3 mm in breadth (Fig. 3). Nerve concolor, per-
current, reaching below the apical cells (Fig. 4). Upper cells prosen-
chymatous, subrectangular to irregularly rhomboidal, 13 a long and
6-7 [i broad (Fig. 5). Leaf base cells rectangular to subrectangular
quadrate, 15 ji long and 8-10 jju broad. Border leaf base margin with
two rows of rhomboidal to rectangular cells. These cells are 20 p long
and 6 g broad. Leaf margin slightly undulated (Fig. 6). Occur
on moist ground at Khandala near Railway Station, Nov. 1966; Mum-
bar hill. National Park at Borivli, (Bombay); Matheran, near Railway
Station, July 1970.
166 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Archidium indicum C. Muell., Flora. 71:8, 1888. (Figs. 7-15).
Plants comose, in the form of glossy green tufted patches, reaching
a height of 1 cm and growing on moist rocks and ground (Figs. 7-8).
Stem with innovations. Ovate-lanceolate leaves broad in middle and
basal region, 0.5-0. 7 mm long and 0.2-0.3 mm broad, acuminate
(Figs. 8-9). All the leaves alike. Upper leaf cells prosenchymatous,
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
167
chlorophyllose, hexagonal to rhomboidal-rectangular, 29 ji long and
5-9 jjl broad (Figs. 11-12). Leaf base cells rectangular to quadrate,
22.4 jx long and 1 1.7 p. broad. Leaf margin slightly undulated (Fig.
13). Leaf apex cell triangular, pyramidal or dome-shaped, cutting new
cells on tree sides resulting in a new leaf laterally (Fig. 10). Nerve
percurrent.
Sporophyte present on innovating branches of stem. Seta reduced.
Foot bulbous foot, immersed cleistocarpic capsule. Sporophyte reach-
ing a length of 0.9 mm (Figs. 8 and 14). Spores few, 10 to 12, large,
hexagonal to polygonal, with yellowish exosporium 6.9 jx in thickness.
Spores brownish yellow in colour, with 125.8 jx in diameter. They
contain a large number of oil globules (Fig. 15).
Occurrence : This tropical comose moss grows on barren rocks at
Khandala, December 1968.
Discussion : A comparative analysis of the distinguishing characters
of A. birmannicum Mitt, ex Dix. and A. indicum C. Muell. shows
that these two species differ from each other in regard to their shape
of leaves, sterility or fertility of the plant and size of the spores. Leaf
of A. birmannicum Mitt, ex Dix., is broad at base and gradually narrow
from middle to apical region whereas the leaf of A. indicum C. Muell.,
is broad in the basal and middle regions and highly acuminate. Ano-
ther important differentiating character is sexuality. A. birmannicum
Mitt, ex Dix. is mostly sterile. Sporophyte of A. indicum C. Muell.
has reduced seta on innovating stem. Lastly the spores of A. indicum
C. Muell. are large, 125 ^ in diameter, polygonal in shape and limited
10-12 in number.
Acknowledgements
I am grateful to Dr. T. S. Mahabale, F.N.I., F.N.A.Sc., F.A.Sc.,
F.B.S., Professor of Botany, Maharashtra Association for Cultivation
of Science, Poona-4, for guidance and help. I am also thankful to
Mr. A. H. Norkett of British Museum (Natural History), London,
for the determination of the species.
Bandodkar Science College, G. T. DABHADE
Thana, Maharashtra State,
November 18, 1972.
168 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
References
Bruhl, P. (1931): Census of In-
dian Mosses. Rec. Bot. Sur. India,
75(1) : 50.
Dixon, H. N. (1921): On a collec-
tion of Mosses from the Kanara Dis-
trict. J. Ind. Bot. Soc. 2:\14, t. 1.
Handoo, O. N. (1966) : Mosses of
Pachmarhi. A paper read at Seminar
in Recent Advances in Indian Bryo-
logy, Chandigarh, (unpublished) .
Norkett, A. H. (1966) : Bryolo-
gical collection in North-West Him-
alayas (unpublished).
Wijk, R. Vander, Margadant,
W. D. & Florschutz, P. A. (1961) :
Index Muscorum. 7:93-94.
21. HEDY OTIS TAVOYENSIS BALAKR. (RUBIACEAE)—
A NEW SPECIES FROM BURMA
{With a plate)
Hedy otis tavoyensis sp. nov.
Pertinent ad sectionem Diplophragma Wt. & Arn., affinisque est
H. eleganti Wall, ex Hook, f., a qua tamen differt stipite acute angu-
lato et saepe alato, stipulis maioribus glanduloso — pectinatis, petiolis
longioribus inflorescentia axillari longe pedunculata.
Frutex ad 1 m altus, erectus, glaber, caule principe tereti, levi,
ramis et ramulis acute quadrangularibus, saepe ad angulos aliquantum
alatis. Folia glabra, chartacea, crassa, sub-olivacea cum sicca, pallida
infra, fusciora supra, elliptico — oblonga, lanceolata, acuta vel acumi-
nata ad utrumque apicem, 10-15 cm longa, 2.5-5. 5 cm lata, marginibus
integris, nervo medio supra impresso; nervi laterales 6-10-jugi, distincti,
caeteris obscuris; petioli 0.5-2.0 cm longi, ad basin lati, anguste alati
versus laminam. Stipulae triangulares, acuminatae, 5-8 mm longae,
3- 4 mm latae ad basin, marginibus glanduloso-pectinatis, saepe inter-
gris, raro revolutis. Cymae glabrae, axillares, solitariae, longe pedun-
culatae, pedunculo principe 8-14 cm longo; rami primarii trichotomi,
4- 7 cm longi, ornati bracteis duabus ovato-oblongis acutis, 1-2 cm
longis, 5-8 mm latis; rami secondarii verticillatim dispositi ad apicem;
bracteis ornati similibus sed minoribus. Flores cymose capitati ad
apicem ramorum ultimorum; bracteis ovatis acutis, 4- 0.5 cm longis,
milliter purpureo-nitentibus. Calycis laciniae 4, persistentes, + 2.5
mm longae, dentibus subulatis ad apicem glandulosis interpositis,
pallide purpureis. Corolla alba, purpuree tincta, -L- 0.5 cm longa;
laciniae 4, valvatae, + 1.5 mm longae, subobtusae, pilis albis adpressis
mollibus intus vestitae. Stamina 4, prope os corollae inserta; antheris
longitudinaliter dehiscentibus. Ovarium biloculare, compressum; stylus
paulum protrudens supra corollae tubum; stigmate bilobo. Capsula
obovoidea, turbinata, 4h 3 mm longa, calycis dentibus ovatis subacutis
persistentibus ornata.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (1)
Balakrishnan : Hedyotis tavoyensis
Plate
NM
MM
Hedyotis tavoyensis Balakr.
1. plants; 2. cymule; 3. flower; 4. calyx; 5. corolla, split open; 6. stamens;
7. style; 8. l.s. of fruit.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
169
Burma: Talaingya Chaung, Tavoy, Alt. 900 m, 7-2-1919, A. T.
Gage 68 A (Holotypus in CAL); ibid. T. T. Gage 68 B (Iso-
typus in CAL); Heinye Faung, Tavoy, 1000 m, 10-3-1919, P. T.
Russell 24 (CAL); Heinye Faung, Tavoy, Alt. 950 m, 6-4-1919, P. T.
Russell 181 (CAL); Tavoy, sine nom. coll. 1805 (CAL).
Hedyotis tavoyensis sp. nov. Sect. Diplophragma Wt. & Arn.)
related to H. elegans Wall, ex Hook. f. but differs in the acutely angled
and often winged stems, the larger glandular-pectinate stipules, longer
petioles and the axillary long-peduncled inflorescences.
Shrub, up to 1 m tall, erect, glabrous; main stem terete, smooth;
branches and branchlets acutely quadrangular, often slightly winged
at the angles. Leaves glabrous, chartaceous, thick, subolivaceous when
dry, pale beneath, darker above, elliptic-oblong, lanceolate, acute or
acuminate at both ends, 10-15 cm long, 2. 5-5. 5 cm wide; margins
entire; midrib impressed above; lateral nerves 6-10 pairs, distinct,
ascending; reticulations obscure; petiole 0. 5-2.0 cm long, broad at
base, narrowly winged to the blade. Stipules triangular, acuminate, 5-8
mm long, 3-4 mm wide at base; margins glandular-pectinate, often
entire, rarerly revolute. Cymes glabrous, axillary, solitary, long-ped-
uncled; main peduncle 8-14 cm long; primary branches trichotomous,
4-7 cm long, with two ovate-oblong acute bracts, 1-2 x 0.5-0. 8 cm;
secondary branches verticillately arranged at the top with similar but
smaller bracts. Flowers capitate at the top of ultimate branches; bracts
ovate, acute, + 5 mm long, slightly shining, purple in colour. Calyx
lobes 4, large, persistent, + 2.5 mm long, with interposed glandular-
tipped, subulate teeth, tinged purplish. Corolla white, tinged purplish,
+ 5 mm long; lobes 4, valvate, 4-1.5 mm long, obtuse, clothed with
appressed white soft hairs inside. Stamens 4, attached near the mouth
of the corolla tube; cells longitudinally dehiscing. Ovary 2-celled, com-
pressed; style slightly protruding above the corolla-tube; stigma 2-lobed.
Capsules obovoid, turbinate, + 3 mm long with persistent ovate
subacute calyx-teeth (Figs. 1-8).
Auk N OWLEDGE M E N T
I am greatly indebted to Rev. Fr. K. M. Mathew, S.J. of St. Joseph’s
College, Tiruchirapalli for kindly rendering the description into Latin.
Botanical Survey of India,
Andaman & Nicobar Circle,
Port Blair,
July, 17, 1973.
N. P. BALAKRISHNAN
170 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
22. A NOTEWORTHY SARCOPY RAMIS FROM EASTERN
HIMALAYAS
(With a text-figure)
Sarcopyramis hum ills sp. nov. (Fig. 1)
Affinis S. subramanii Nayar, sed calycis tubo longiore, lobis caly-
cinis longioribus, integeris, antheris subrotundatis differt.
Herba parva, 3-7 cm alta. Caulis obsolete angulatus, insicco
rubescens. Folia opposita, ovato-lanceolata, 2-5.5 cm x 0.7- 1.8 cm,
basi obtusa vel subtruncata, apice acuta, margine ciliato-serrata, supra
parace setosa, subtus glabra, supra et subtus in sicco pallide viridia,
3-5 nervia, subtus venulis transversis distinctis; petiolus 5-10 mm
longus. Inflorscentia terminalis, 1-3 flora; pedicellus 2-3 mm longus;
Fig. 1. Sarcopyramis humilis sp. nov. (After Kingdon Ward 6647)
A. Plant — Habit; B. Calyx tube; C. Stamen — dorsal view,
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
171
bractease spathulato-obovatae, 5-5.5 mm longae, margine ciliatae.
Calycis tubus campanulatus, 3.5 mm x 2.5 mm, extus glaber, limbus
4-lobatus, lobibus triangularibus, 1.5 mm longis, margine haud ciliatis.
Petala obovato-oblonga, 8-10 mm x 6-7 mm. Stamina 8, aequalia,
filamentis 3 mm longis, antheris subrotundatis vel rotundato-oblongis,
1-1.2 mm longis, thecis apice haud divergentibus, connectivo basi 0.4
mm producto, connectivo postice 0.8 mm prolongato. Ovarium calycis
tubo totum adnatum, 4-loculare. Stylus crassus, 4-4.5 mm longus;
stigmate capitato, papilloso.
Typus: Kingdon Ward 6647 (K).
Herb small, 3-7 cm tall, erect. Stem obscurely angular, when dry
reddish. Leaves opposite, ovate-lanceolate, 2-5.5 cm x 0.7-1. 8 cm, base
obtuse or subtruncate, apex acute, margin ciliate-serrate, upper surface
sparsely setose, under surface glabrous, upper and lower surface when
dry pale green, 3-5 nerved, transverse venules on the under surface
distinct; petiole 5-10 mm long. Inflorescence terminal, 1-3 flowered;
pedicel 2-3 mm long; bracts spathulate obovate, 5-5.5 mm long, margin
ciliate. Calyx tube campanulate, 3.5 mm x 2.5 mm, outer surface
glabrous, 4 lobed, lobes triangular, 1.5 mm long, margin not ciliate
petals obovate-oblong, 8-10 mm x 6-7 mm. Stamens 8, equal, filament
3 mm long, anther subordinate or rotundate-oblong, 1-1.2 mm long,
anther lobes at the apex not divergent, connective 0.4 mm long pro-
duced at the base, dorsally ends in a spur 0.8 mm long. Ovary totally
adnate to the calyx tube, 4-loculed. Style thick 4-4.5 mm long; stigma
capitate, papillose.
Distribution : Frontier of Tibet and Burma, Nogmung, growing amongst
roots and rocks on the edge of the jungle in the shaded valleys, alt.
500-666 m, 25 Apr. 1926, Kingdon Ward 6647 (Holotype K).
S. humilis is allied to S. subramanii Nayar, but differs in the nature
of calyx lobes, the size of anthers and the shape of the dorsal staminal
appendage. In S. subramanii the calyx tube is shorter (2-2.5 mm long)
and calyx lobes are slightly smaller and 2-3 ciliate; whereas in S.
humilis the calyx tube is longer (3.5 mm long), the calyx lobes are
slightly larger and margin entire. The shape of anther in S. subramanii
is elliptic-obovate with prominently diverging anther lobes at the apex;
whereas in S. humilis the anthers are subordinate at the apex and the
anther lobes are not divergenet.
Ack n owledge m e n t
I wish to express my gratitude to Dr. Subramanyam, Director,
Botanical Survey of India for his encouragement.
172 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Central National Herbarium, M. P. NAYAR
Botanical Garden P.O.,
Howrah 3,
October 10, 1972.
23. A SYNOPSIS OF THE GENUS PERI LIMN ASTES RIDLEY
(MELASTOMATACEAE)
{With a text-figure)
Introduction
I carried out a taxonomic study of several genera in the family
Melastomataceae at the Herbarium, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, the
Rijksherbarium, Leiden and Central National Herbarium, Calcutta
from 1960-68. The present paper deals with the genus Perilimnastes
Ridl. belonging to the tribe Oxysporeae Triana.
The genus Perilimnastes is characterised by its small branching
suffruticose, rupicolous habit, its tubular or campanulate 4-angled or
8 -ribbed calyx tube having long narrowly triangular calyx lobes and
eight equal or subequal stamens which are inappendiculate both dor-
sally and ventrally. Ridley (in Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Straits Br. 79:70,
1918) established the genus on the basis of the type species Anerin-
cleistus fruticosus Ridl. typified by the specimen Robinson 5453 which
he transferred to the new genus as P. fruticosa (Ridl.) Ridl. Ridley
(in Fi. Mai. Penin. 1:761, 1922) assigned this genus to the tribe Oxy-
sporeae. The second species Perilimnastes rupicola Nayar from Mt.
Dulit in Sarawak represents an extension of the generic range. The
generic description is emended and is given below.
Perilaiimastes Ridl. in Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Straits Br. 79:70,1918;
Ridley, FI. Mai. Penin. 1:761, 1922.
Shrub or Herb. Branches glabrous or puberulous, nodes glabrous
or setose, subterete, young branches compressed. Leaves opposite,
narrowly elliptic-lanceolate base narrowed, apex acuminate, entire,
3 -nerved, cross-venules absent on the upper surface and usually indis-
tinct on the lower surface, coriaceous or membraneous, petiolate. In-
florescence terminal, few flowered cymes. Calyx tube tubular or cam-
panulate, 4-angular or 8-ribbed, limb 4-lobed, lobes long. Petals 4,
spreading, lanceolate. Stamens 8, equal, lanceolate, apex acuminate
or shortly rostrate, 1-porose, connective not produced, dorsally and
ventrally inappendiculate. Ovary concrescent with the calyx tube by
8 septa, extraovarial chambers 8, all descending to the middle of the
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
173
ovary. Disc present. Style filiform, stigma inconspicuous. Capsule
obconic, dehiscence by 4 large valves.
Type species: Perilimnastes fruticosa Ridl.
Distribution : Malaya and Borneo.
The name Perilimnastes is derived from Greek, ‘ PerV - near,
around; ‘ limne = marsh or pond, in allusion to the plants growing near
water courses.
This is an interesting genus comprising 2 species so far recorded
from the mountains of Gunong Tahan in Malaya and Mt. Dulit in
Sarawak. Perilimnastes fruticosa Ridl. is endemic to the mountains
of Gunong Tahan (alt. 666 m) which lies on the eastern side of
Malaya. Whereas P. rupicola Nayar is recorded from Mt. Dulit in
Sarawak. According to Ridley (FI. Mai. Penin. 1:761, 1922) P. fruti-
cosa “forms cushions about twelve inches tall in cracks of rocks in
the streams.” As per the field note (specimen Synge S. 503), it is
mentioned that P. rupicola grows on exposed rocks by the side of
rivers.
Key to the species of Perilimnastes
1. Branches glabrous; calyx tube 4-angled P. fruticosa
2. Branches and nodes setose, becomes glabrous when old; calyx tube
8-ribbed P. rupicola
1. Perilimnastes fruticosa Ridl. in Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Str. Br. 79:
70, 1918; Ridley, FI. Mai. Penin. 1:761, 1922.
Anerincleistus fruticosus Ridl. in Journ. Linn. Soc. 38:309, 1908;
Ridl. in Journ. Roy. As. Soc. Str. Br. 57:47 1911; Ridl. in Journ. Fed.
Mai. States Mus. 6:148, 1915.
Distribution : malaya: Pahang, Gunong Tahan, Robinson 5453
(Holotype BM); ibid., July 1911, Ridley 16044 (K, BM); ibid., alt.
666 m, 22 June 1922, Md. Haniff & Nur 8309 (K).
2. Perilimnastes rupicola sp. nov. (text-fig.)
Affinis P. fruticosae Ridl., sed caulibus ad nodos setosis, folds
junioribus villosis, calycis tubo 8-costato differt.
Herba adscendens, 15-35 cm alta. Caulis angularis, ad nodos
setosus, setis 4-7 mm longis. Folia opposita, aequalia, elliptico-lanceo-
lata, 4-7 cm x 0.5- 1.4 cm, basi cuneata, apice acuminata, margine in-
tegra, juniore supra et subtus villosa, ad maturitatem glabra, 3-nervia,
venulis transversis indistinctis, chartacea; petiolus 4-7 mm longus. In-
florescentia terminalis, cymulis 4-6 floris; pedicellus 1-1.7 cm longus,
glaber. Calycis tubus campanulatus, 3-4 mm longus, blaber, limbus
4-lobatus, lobis triangularibus, 3 mm longis. Petala 4, elliptico-oblonga,
10-11 mm x 4-4.5 mm. Stamina 8, aequalia, filamentis 4.5 mm longis,
antheris anguste lanceolatis, 5.5 mm longis, connectivo basi baud pro-
174 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
ducto, inappendiculato. Ovarium coronatum, calycis tubo septis 8
adnatum, loculi 8. Stylus fiiliformis, 8-9 mm longus, glaber, stigmate
punctiformi.
Typus: Synge S. 503 (K).
Fig. 1. Perilimnastes rupicola sp. nov. A. Habit; B. Stamen — side view;
C. L. S. of calyx tube.
Herb, 15-35 cm tall. Stem angular, setose at the nodes, hairs 4-7 mm
long. Leaves opposite, equal, elliptico-lanceolate, 4-7 cm x 0.5- 1.4 cm.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
175
base cuneate, apex acuminate, margin entire, when young upper and
lower surface villose, when old becomes glabrous, 3 -nerved, transverse
venules indistinct chartaceous; petiole 4-7 mm long. Inflorescence ter-
minal, 4-6 flowered cymes; pedicel 1-1.7 cm long, glabrous. Calyx tube
campanulate, 3-4 mm long, glabrous, 4-lobed, lobes triangular, 3 mm
long. Petals 4, elliptic oblong, 10-11 mm x 4-4.5 mm. Stamens 8, equal,
filament 4.5 mm long, anther narrowly lanceolate, 5.5 mm long, con-
nective not produced at the base, inappendiculate. Ovary adnate to
the calyx tube by 8 septa, extraovarial chambers 8, disc present. Style
filiform, 8-9 mm long, glabrous, stigma punctiform.
Borneo: Sarawak, Mt. Dulit, Ulu Koyan, alt. 800 m, 16 Sept. 1932,
Synge S. 503 (K); ibid., alt. c. 800 m, 7 Feb. 1932, Richards 2498
(K).
This species is immediately distinguishable by the presence of
bristles at the nodes of young branches and villose tomentum in young
leaves. In P. rupicola the calyx tube is 8-ribbed, whereas in P. fruti-
cosa the calyx tube is 4-angular.
ACK N OWLEDGDM E N TS
I wish to express my gratitude to Sir George Taylor, Director,
Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, U.K. for all facilities during my stay
at Kew from 1961-67 and to the Director, Botanical Survey of India
for encouragement.
Central National Herbarium, M. P. NAYAR
Botanic Gardens P.O.,
Howrah 3,
September 7, 1972.
24. ON THE CITATION OF PALAQUIUM ELLIPTICUM
(DALZ.) BAILLON
Under article no. 46 of the ICBN, for the indication of the name
of a taxon to be accurate and complete, for purposes of precision, it
is necessary that the citation of author’s name and of literature is
correctly recorded. The note presents the case of the Indian gutta-
percha tree, popularly called as Panchoti-palla in T “Cooke’s Flora
of the presidency of Bombay” (2:154, 1958, reprinted). The tree grows
to a height of 30 m and is distributed in the Western Ghats from
North Kanara southwards. The correct citation and synonymy are
given below:-
176 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Palaquium ellipticum (Dalz.) Baillon, Traite Bot. Med. Phan. 1500,
1884; Lam in Bull. Jard. bot. Bzg, ser. 3, 8:414, 1927; van
Royen in Blumea 10(2): 509, 1960.
P. ellipticum (Dalz.) Engler, Bot. Jahrb. 12:511, 1890; Brandis,
Indian Trees 424, 1906; Gamble, FI. Madras 4:764, 1921 (2:
537, 1957, rep. ed.); Lam in Bull. Jard. bot. Bzg, ser. 3, 7:107,
258, 1925.
Bassia elliptica Dalzell in Hooker’s J. Bot. & Kew Misc. 3:36, 1851;
Dalz. & Gibs. Bombay FI. 139, 1861; Beddome, FI. Sylv. t. 43,
1869.
Dichopsis elliptica Bentham, Gen. PI. 2:658, 1876; Clarke in Hook,
f. FI. Br. India 3:542, 1882.
Isonandra acuminata Drury, LTseful Indian PI. 260, 1858.
The type specimen — Dalzell s. n. is preserved in K.
General Education Centre, G. M. OZA
M. S. University of Baroda,
Baroda 2,
March 15, 1973.
25. ON THE OCCURRENCE OF SYMPAGIS PETIOLARES
(NEES) BREM. AND CANSCORA PERFOLIATA LAMK.
ON THE EASTERN GHATS
During the course of our exploration work on the eastern ghats we
collected Sympagis petiolares (Nees) Brem., and Canscora perfoliata
Lamk. Their occurrence in these parts drew our attention to their dis-
tribution in South India, which is mainly discussed here. The relevant
data regarding the distribution of the plants were collected from Central
National Herbarium, Calcutta, Forest Research Institute, Dehradun,
and Botanical Survey of India, Southern Circle, Coimbatore. The her-
barium sheets are deposited at Jawahar Bharati Herbarium, Kavali.
Sympagis petiolares (Nees) Brem. in Mat. Mon. Strobilanthinae
255, 1944. Strobilanthes petiolares Ness in DC. Prodr. 11:189, 1947,
(pro-parte); FI. Brit. India 4:458, 1855.
Under shrubs, 60-90 cm tall. Leaves 3-11 x 1.5-6 cm, ovate, serrate,
main nerves 7-8 pairs, acuminate at both ends. Petioles 1-4 cm long.
Inflorescence 6-15 cm long, interrupted, spikes or leafy panicles, ter-
minal or from upper axils. Flowers 2. 2-2. 5 cm long, ventricose, blue.
Capsules 6-1 mm long, oblong, glabrous when mature. Seeds 4, 1-1.5
mm across, hairy.
Common and abundant on hill slopes, scattered or in mixed stands
among large bushes. The plants are eye catching by their beautiful
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
111
blue masses of flowers. It has been collected from Udayagiri hills on
the eastern ghats (A.P.).
The identity of this plant is confirmed by the courtesy of the Central
National Herbarium, Calcutta.
The herbarium specimens examined: Udayagiri: BS 4308, 30-l-’72.
distribution: Assam : Mawsami, Sonapur, 27/3 mile from Shillong
to Cherrapunji, Khasia and Jaintia hills. W. Bengal : Kurseong, Dar-
jeeling 3500' alt. Sikkim : Sitong 5000', Rungli 4000'. Bhutan. * And-
hra Pradesh : Udayagiri (Author’s collection).
From the available data on the distribution of this plant it is a new
record for south India.
Canscora pcrfoliafa Lamk. Encycl. Method. 1:601, 1783; FI. Brit.
Ind. 4:104, 1885; FI. Pres. Madras, 2:618, 1957 (Rep. ed.). C. grandi-
flora Wt. Icon. t. 1326.
An erect herb , 30-45 cm tall. Stems 4-angular, winged. Leaves lax,
2-2.5 x 0.7-0.8 cm, oblong or oblong-lanceolate, acute at both ends,
glabrous, 3 -nerved, sessile. Inflorescence dichasial cymes, terminal.
Bracts of inflorescence 1-1.5 x 0.7-1 cm, perfoliate, orbicular-elliptic.
Flowers 1.4- 1.6 cm long, bright rose, calyx 1-1.2 cm long winged;
pedicels 0.5- 1.5 cm long, winged. Capsules 6-7 mm long.
Rare in the undergrowth, under cool and shady conditions.
The identification of this plant is confirmed by matching the her-
barium sheets with those at Botanical Survey of India, Coimbatore by
one of us (B. Suryanarayana).
The herbarium specimens examined: Venkatagiri hills: BS 3901,
26-12-’70; Udayagiri hills: BS 4333, 30-l-’72.
distribution : From Bombay to Travancore (Kerala) up to 3500'
alt. Kerala : (Travancore), Malabar, Wynaad. Tamil Nadu: Coim-
batore. Karnataka : South Canara, North Canara. Andhra Pradesh:
Nellore District: Venkatagiri and Udayagiri (Authors’ collections).
Though the plant is recorded to occur widely in south India, it is
interesting to note that, it is hitherto reported only from the western side
of Deccan. Our collections are the first report for the entire belt of
eastern part of the peninsula.
Acknowledgements
Our thanks are due to Prof. P. V. Bole, St. Xavier’s College,
Bombay for his valuable suggestions. We thank Dr. M. P. Nair, Keeper,
Central National Herbarium, Calcutta; authorities of the Botanical
Survey of India, Southern Circle, Coimbatore and the Forest Research
Institute, Dehradun for furnishing necessary information and help. We
are also thankful to UGC for financial help to conduct tour to Udaya-
178 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
giri under College Science Improvement Programme (CoSIP).
Department of Botany, B. SURYANARAYANA
Jawahar Bharati, D. RADHAKRISHNA MURTHY
Kavali, (A.P.),
March 15, 1973.
26. CHENOPODIUM AMBROSIOIDES LINN. (CHENOPOD-
ACEAE) — A NEW RECORD FOR CHAMOLI DISTRICT IN
WESTERN HIMALAYAS
Che no podium ambrosioides Linn. C. vulpinum Wall. Cat. 695 B. is
characterized by strong unpleasant aromatic odour and long axillary
spikes of pale green flowers. Distributed mainly in Bengal, Sylhet,
Western Ghats and the Deccan. Raizada ( 193 1 ) 1 recorded it for the first
time as a weed of waste places in and around Dehradun of the Upper
Gangetic Plain.
During botanical explorations of the district, I collected this species
near Palwara (140 m) in the vicinity of Hampur village at the border
of cultivated fields (23.4/71, Nautiyal 71). The species appears to be
recently introduced into the area.
Department of Botany, K. N. NAUTIYAL
Meerut University,
Meerut,
April 30, 1973.
27. BOTANICAL IDENTITY OF ‘CENTURY PLANT’ IN
WESTERN INDIA
{With a photograph )
For nearly one hundred years, Indian botanists have identified
the naturalised American aloe, popularly known as ‘century plant’,
occurring in Western India as A gave americana Linn. The note at-
tempts to bring to light the position of the Indian literature on the
subject.
Th. Cooke (1908) in his FI. Pres. Bombay separates Agave ameri-
cana Linn, and A. vera-cruz Mill, on the basis of neck of leaf sharply
constricted and neck of leaf hardly constricted respectively. He listed
1 Raizada, M. B. (1931): Contribution to Duthie’s Flora of the Upper
Gangetic Plain from the neighbourhood of Dehra Dun. J. Indian bot. Soc.
70:155-58.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
179
A. americana Linn. var. variegata Hook, in Bombay flora stating that
the native country is unknown; commonly grown as an ornamental
plant in parks and large gardens; nowhere naturalised in India (italics
mine).
The identity of the species and its synonymy is confused. The
origin and geographical distribution have not been described accurately.
The Indian literature records A. angustifolia Haw, A. americana Linn.,
A. sisalana Perr., A. vera-cruz Mill, and A. vivipara Linn, for India.
However, A. cantula Roxb. is relegated to synonymy under A. ameri-
cana Linn. And Cooke (loc. cit.) treats A. cantula Dalz. & Gibs. Bom .
FI. Suppl. p. 93 ( not of Roxb.) as synonym of A. wightii Drummond
& Prain in Agric. Ledg. no. 7:91, 1960! At the same time A. wightii
(1906) is considered as a synonym of A. angustifolia Haw.
H. Santapau (1967) in his “Flora of Khandala on the Western
Ghats of India”, p. 280, following Berger’s monograph. Die Agaven,
1915, writes that the Khandala specimens (Western India) are all Agave
ingens Berger and treats A. vera-cruz Mill.? in the synonymy. Berger
and Agave monographer Gentry consider vera-cruz Drum. & Prain a
synonym of americana.
Agave americana is a polymorphic species, occurring in wild forms
from southern Texas to the State of Hidalgo in Mexico along the
middle slopes and valleys of the Sierra Madre Oriental. Contiguous
to this region it has been cultivated for its fibre, pulp, and juice for
several years. Many of the larger variants, mostly polyploids, were
selected for pulque culture, were propagated vegetatively by suckers,
and Gentry observed them from Durango and Coahuila to Jalisco,
Michoacan, and Oaxaca.
Gentry (1972, in a personal communication) states that in the Kew
Herbarium there is a good specimen from Berger, from La Mortola,
which he labelled as Agave ingens , but which Gentry interprets as
Agave lurida Aiton, according to other specimens in the Kew Her-
barium, the earliest being sent in 1883 from Ricasoli in Italy. The
specimen was made up almost a century after Aiton’s publication
(1789) of the taxon. That taxon cannot be determined solely by the
brief description given by Aiton. Berger interpreted Aiton’s species
in one way. Baker and R. E. Brown of Kew in another way. Gentry
is inclined to accept the older Kew specimen from Italy as the correct
or arbitrary guide and nominate it as the lectotype of Agave lurida
Aiton.
Agave lurida Aiton has not been recorded from India. It is, there-
fore, a new record. Index Kewensis gives Mexico as the home of this
plant.
180 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (1)
Agave lurida Aiton — the endangered Baroda species.
The widely scattered populations of Agave in Kamathi Baug, Baroda, consisted
of small colonies extending over few areas and numbering hundreds of indi-
viduals.
In recent years, such plant colonies have been cleared extensively to make
way for common ornamental plants!
Acknowledgement
The author owes a tremendous debt of gratitude to Dr. Howard
Scott Gentry, Botanist, Desert Botanical Garden, Arizona, U.S.A., for
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
181
his notes and excellent literature which has served as a basis in the
preparation of this note.
General Education Centre, G. M. OZA
M. S. University of Baroda,
Baroda 2,
June 18, 1973.
28. ON THE OCCURRENCE OF VEGETATIVE SHOOTS AT
THE CROWN AREA IN COCOS NUCIFERA L.
During a recent study tour along the Karnataka (Mysore) coast
we saw a coconut palm of unusual interest in the vicinity of the sea-
shore at Surathkal, 3 Km away from Mangalore city. A striking
feature of this palm is the periodic production of sixty to hundred
vegetative shoots in two to three rows in place of spadices. The
tree is about 10 metres high and looked normal with a well developed
crown and was growing on the raised bund of a cultivated land. The
owner of the tree reported that this palm at no time bore fertile spad-
ices but produced vigorously growing vegetative shoots at regular in-
tervals.
Such vegetative shoots resembling bulbils at the crown of many
palms have been reported by various authors (Davis & Basu 1969). 1
The local people called this plant in Kannada language as ‘gandu
gida’ (Male tree) even though they had not seen the plant in flower.
It appears that attempts were made to grow the vegetative shoots in
the nearby villages. But our attempts to grow them in the Indian
Botanic garden, Sibpur were not successful.
Ecology Section, T. ANANDA RAO
Botanical Survey of India, G. C. DAS
76, Acharya Jagadish Bose Road,
Calcutta 14,
June 4, 1973.
1 Davis, T. A. & Basu, S. K. (1969): Two cases of Bulbil bearing Boras-
sus flabellifer L. J. Indian bot. Soc. 48: 198-201.
THE SOCIETY’S PUBLICATIONS
Mammals
The Book of Indian Animals, by S. H. Prater. 3rd (revised) edition. 28 plates
in colour by Paul Barruel and many other monochrome illustrations. Rs. 40
{Price to members Rs. 35)
The Ecology of the Lesser Bandicoot Rat in Calcutta, by James Juan Spillet.
Rs. 10
Birds
The Book of Indian Birds, by Salim Ali. 9th (revised) edition. 66 coloured and
Rs. 35
many monochrome plates.
( Price to members Rs. 30)
Rs. 2.50
Checklist of the Birds of Maharashtra, by Humayun Abdulali.
( Price to members Rs. 2)
Snakes
Identification of Poisonous Snakes, Wall chart in English, Gujarati, and Marathi.
Miscellaneous
Picture Postcards of 12 representative Indian Birds (In colour) per set Rs. 2.50
Glimpses of Nature Series Booklets :
1. Our Birds I (with 8 coloured plates) in Hindi, and Marathi,
Kannada.
2. Our Birds II (with 8 coloured plates) in Hindi.
3. Our Beautiful Trees (with 8 coloured plates) in Hindi and
Marathi.
4. Our Monsoon Plants (with 8 coloured plates) in English,
Gujarati, Hindi, and Marathi.
5. Our Animals (with 8 coloured plates) in English, Gujarati,
Hindi, and Marathi.
Glimpses of Nature in India (with 40 coloured plates) in English
( Price to members Rs. 5)
Back numbers of the Society’s Journal. Rates on application.
Correspond with :
The Honorary Secretary,
Bombay Natural History Society,
Hornbill House, Shahid Bhagat Singh Road, Bombay 400 023.
The Society will gratefully accept back numbers of the Journal, from
members who may not wish to preserve them.
TERMS OF MEMBERSHIP
Life Members pay an entrance fee of Rs. 5 (2 5p) and a life membership fee
of Rs. 600 (Inland), £45-50 (Foreign).
Ordinary Members pay an entrance fee of Rs. 5 (25 p) and an annual sub-
scription of Rs. 36 (Inland), £3 (Foreign).
Members residing outside India should pay their subscription by means of
orders on their Bankers to pay the amount of the subscription to the Society
in Bombay on the 1st January in each year. If this cannot be done, then the
sum of £3 -00 should be paid annually to the Society’s London Bankers — The
National & Grindlays Bank Ltd., 23 Fenchurch Street, London E.C. 3. Account
No. 101095.
The subscription of members elected in October, November, and December
covers the period from the date of their election to the end of the following
year.
CONTENTS
Bonelli's Hawk-Eagle, Hieraaetus fasciatus (Vieillot). By S. M. Osman 1
Indian Mammals on Texas Rangelands. By Ernest D. Abies and
Charles W. Ramsey . . . . . . . . . . 18
Common edible Mushrooms of Jammu and Kashmir. By T. N. Kaul
and J. L. Kachroo . . . . 26
Preliminary observations on the breeding of pearl oysters, Pinctada
fucata (Gould) of the Gulf of Kutch. By K. R. Narayanan . . 32
Taxonomy and distribution of Sardinella leiogaster Valenciennes,
1847 (Pisces: Clupeidae) from the Indian Seas. By A. G. K.
Menon and P. K. Talwar . . 41
A new Copepod from Ratnagiri. By M. R. Ranade . . . . 46
Records and observations on Bats of Himalayan region of Uttar
Pradesh and West Bengal, India. By H. R. Bhat . . 51
Additions to the Flora of North Gujarat (Ahmedabad-Mehsana-
Sabarkantha District). By G. L. Shah and D. V. Yogi 58
Three new species of Aphelinidae (Hymenoptera Chalcidoidea)
parasitic on Aonidiella orientalis (Newst.) from India.
By Mohammad Hayat . . . . 64
Smithsonia (Orchidacea), a new Genus from Western India. By Cecil
J. Saldanha . . . . . . . . 72
The Avifauna of introduced Eucalyptus plantations in Maha-
rashtra. By Lincoln Gray . . . . . . 76
Fishery resources of Ullal (Mangalore) in relation to certain
environmental factors during 1963-67. By M. S. Prabhu, S.
Ramamurthy, N. H. Dhulkhed, N. S. Radhakrishnan and G. P.
Kumarasvvamy Achari . . . . . . . . . . 85
Observations on the breeding mechanism of Biophytum candolleanum
Wt. By R. Vasudevan Nair . . . . 99
Observations on systematics of Sessile Barnacles from West Coast
of India — 1. By Arun B. Wagh and D. V. Bal . . . . 109
The copulatory complex of Neurobasis chinensis chinensis (Linn.)
(Agriidae: Zygoptera) 1. By Basit Ali Khan .. .. .. 124
Reviews .. .. .. .. .. .. ..131
Miscellaneous Notes . . . . 137
Printed by Bro. Leo at St. Francis I.T.I., Borivli, Bombay 400 092 and published
by Editors: J. C. Daniel, P. V. Bole and A. N. D. Nanavati for the Bombay
Natural History Society, Bombay 400 023.
1 Journal of the
Bombay Natural History Society
Vol. 71, No, 2
Editors
J. C. DANIEL, P. V. BOLE & A. N, D. NAN A VAT I
AUGUST 1974
Rs. 18 {Inland), £ I '50 (Foreign)
NOTICE TO CONTRIBUTORS
Contributors of scientific articles are requested to assist the
editors by observing the following instructions :
1 . Papers which have at the same time been offered for publica-
tion to other journals or periodicals, or have already been published
elsewhere, should not be submitted.
2. The MS. should be typed (double spacing) on one side of &
sheet only, and the sheets properly numbered.
3. All scientific names to be printed in italics should be under-
lined.
4. Trinomials referring to subspecies should only be used where
identification has been authentically established by comparison of
specimens actually collected.
5. Photographs for reproduction must be clear and show good
contrast. Prints must be of a size not smaller than 8*20x5*60 cm.
(No. 2 Brownie) and on glossy glazed paper.
6. Text-figures, line drawings, and maps should be in Indian ink,
preferably on Bristol board.
7. References to literature should be placed at the end of the
paper, alphabetically arranged under author’s name, with the abridged
titles of journals or periodicals underlined (italics) and titles of books
not underlined (roman type), thus :
Banerji, M. L. (1958) : Botanical Exploration in East Nepal.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 55(2): 243-268.
Prater, S. H. (1948): The Book of Indian Animals. Bombay.
Titles of papers should not be underlined.
8. Reference to literature in the text should be made by quoting
the author’s name and year of publication, thus : (Banerji 1958).
9. Synopsis : Each scientific paper should be accompanied by
a concise, clearly written synopsis, normally not exceeding 200 words.
10. Reprints : Authors are supplied 25 reprints of their articles
free of charge. In the case of joint authorship, 50 copies will be
given gratis to be distributed among the two or more authors. Orders
for additional reprints should be in multiples of 25 and should be
received within two weeks after the author is informed of the acceptance
of the manuscript. They will be charged for at cost plus postage and
packing.
11. The editors reserve the right, other things being equal, to
publish a member’s contribution earlier than a non-member’s.
Editors,
Journal of the Bombay Natural
History Society
Hornbill House,
Shahid Bhagat
Singh Road,
Bombay 400023
VOLUME 71 No. 2— AUGUST 1974
Date of Publication : 20-2-1975
CONTENTS
PAGE
Observations at the dens of the dhole or Indian wild dog ( Cuon alpinus).
By E. R. C. Davidar .. . . .. . . .. 183
Food-habits of water-birds of the Sundarban, 24 Parganas District, West
Bengal, India — IV. By Ajit Kumar Mukherjee . . . . . . 188
A list of Aphids (Homoptera : Aphididae) from India and adjacent countries.
By A. K. Ghosh . . . . . . . . . . 201
On the Specificity of Madras Backwater Oyster Crassostrea madrasensis
Preston and the American Oyster Crassostrea virginica Gmelin.
By V. S. Durve. ( With two text-figures) . . . . . . . . 226
Flora of Mothronwala Swamp Forest (District : Dehr a Dun, U.P., India).
By K. M. M. Dakshini . . . . . . . . . . 235
A Catalogue of the Birds in the Collection of the Bombay Natural History
Society — 16. By Humayun Abdulali .. .. .. .. 244
Contribution to the Flora of Tirap Frontier Division. By D. B. Deb and
R. M. Dutta. . . . . . . . . . . . . 266
Miscellaneous Notes :
Mammals: 1. Further attempts to determine the food habits of the Indian Rhino-
cerosat Kaziranga.By R. L. Brahmachary, B. Rakshit and B. Malik, (p.295).
Birds: 2. On the increasing occurrence of typically Plains birds in the Kumaon
Hills. By Victor Smetacek (p. 299) ; 3 . Tawny Eagle as a scavenger. By Prakash
V. Gole (p. 302); 4. Stomach contents of the Great Indian Bustard, Choriotis nigri-
ceps (Vigors). By P. D. Gupta (p. 303) ; 5. TheNilgiri Wood Pigeon, Columba
elphinstonii (Sykes) onSalsette Island, Bombay. By J.C. Daniel and S.R. Amladi
(p. 304) ; 6. The Brownwinged Storkbilled Kingfisher Pelargopsis amauroptera
(Pearson) in Orissa. By J. C. Daniel and S. A. Hussain (p. 304); 7. Developmental
period and feeding habits of Bank Myna, Acridotheres ginginianus (Latham) in
Punjab. By G. S. Simwat and A. S. Sidhu (p. 305); 8. Study on the stomach
contents of Common Baya, Ploceus philippinus (Linnaeus). By A. K. Mukherjee
and B. C. Saha (p. 308).
Reptiles : 9. The record (?) Salt water Crocodile ( Crocodylus porosus
Schneider). By J. C. Daniel and S. A. Hussain (p. 309).
Fishes : 10. Note on Cristiceps halei Day, 1888 (Pisces : Clinidae) a junior
synonym of Springeratus xanthosoma (Sleeker), 1857. By R. S. Lai Mohan
(p. 312) ; 11. On the identity of Rat-tailed Anchovy Coilia neglecta Whitehead,
1967. By S. Dutt and B. V. Seshagiri Rao (p. 316).
Arthropoda : 12. Some soil Arthropods collected from paddy fields at Varanasi .
By S. P. Mukharji and G. P. Gupta (p. 319).
Crustacea : 13. Dispersal of intertidal Sessile Barnacle Tetraclita squamosa rufo-
tincta (Pilsbry) by water currents. {With two text-figures). ByArun B. Wagh
(p. 322).
Insects : 14. Abundance of Fleas — a review. By D. M. Munshi (p. 324); 15.
Foraging activity of Apis dor sat a Fab. on Brassica juncea Hook. & Thomas. By
R. P. Kapil and Surendra Kumar (p. 327); 16. A note on the early development
of the Marine insect Halobates sp. from the Gulf of Mannar near Mandapam.
{With a text-figure ). By R. Alfred Selvakumar (p. 333).
Botany: 17. Buttress-like structures on the upper part of the trunk of Ceiba
pentandra (L.) Gaertn. {With a plate). By V. M. Meher-Homji (p. 336); 18. Studies
on the Limestone vegetation of Sahasradhara near Dehra Dun (U.P.) — 4
‘Indicator value of Plants’. By S. K. Malhotra (p. 338); 19. Nicotiana glauca
Graham — A tree Tobacco in Maharashtra. By A. R.Kulkarni (p.340); 20. Axil-
lary Archegonia in Splachnobryum indicum Hamp. et Muell. from Bombay. {With
eleven text-figures). By G. T. Dabhade (p.342) ; 21. On the occurrence of Zizy-
phus glaberrima Sant, in Northern India. By K. P. Janardhanan and R. Prasad
(p. 344) ; 22. Stipular condition in Maytenus emarginata (Willd.) Ding-Hou.
{With two text-figures). By P. H. V. Vasudeva Rao (p. 345); 23. A few unrecorded
Taxa for the Flora of Kanyakumari shore (Cape Comorin), Tamil Nadu. By
T. Ananda Rao, L. K. Banerjee and A. K. Mukherjee (p. 346).
JOURNAL
OF THE
BOMBAY NATURAL
HISTORY SOCIETY
1974 AUGUST Vol. 71 No. 2
Observations at the dens of the dhole
or Indian wild dog ( Cuon alpinus)1
BY
E. R. C. Davidar
‘ Canowie Coonoor- 1, Nilgiris
On Christmas Day 1969, my Shikari Sidda and I went looking for a
hyena den in Chemmanatham in the Sigur Reserved Forest (east of the
Mudumalai Wild Life Sanctuary) in the Nilgiris in Tamil Nadu when
forcing our way into a thicket on the west bank of the Sigur River we
found that we Were in the midst of dhole burrows. Sidda went forward
to the nearest earth to see if it was tenanted. It was. A very angry
dhole charged him. We bolted. Fortunately it did not carry home its
charge.
In the centre of the thicket it was comparatively open. I could see
three dens. Later, after the dhole had vacated, I went in again and
counted four. The burrows were all freshly dug and occupied an area of
approximately 20' x 15L They were 2 to 3 feet deep, sloping at an angle
of 45°. Tracks led into the thicket from different directions. The river
took a wide turn at this place and one spot in particular outside the
thicket commanded a fine view of the river. The dhole used this spot
as a lookout point and had worn the turf down to bare earth by con-
stant usage.
Sidda and I selected a mango tree across the river which was about
40 yards broad at this place and spent the rest of the afternoon in it.
Between 25-xii-1969 and 14-ii-1970 I spent altogether six days (on 2
days from about 0700 hours until 1700 hours and on the other 4 days from
2 to 4 hours) on the tree keeping the thicket, the burrows not being visible
Accepted March 2, 1972.
184 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
from outside, under observation. That part of the jungle was elephant
infested and on that score it was not possible to get to my post earlier
or leave it later. On the day I tried to sit up until dusk I had a nasty
experience which cured me of any desire to remain there late. A tusker
came and stood under my tree, and I discovered that my perch, which I
had thought was beyond an elephant’s reach was not high enough and
that my feet were almost resting on the bull elephant’s back ! While I
was contemplating my awful predicament I found another tusker making
its way down to get his back also scratched.
At 0815 hrs on 26-xii-1969, four female dhole approached the thicket
from my side of the river. Two of them were lactating and the other
two were full grown cubs and acted like cubs of the older bitches from the
previous litter. The dhole suspected my presence and tried to sniff me out.
Then they lay down about 100 yards away for half an hour and watched.
As I did not give myself away, their suspicion dispelled, the two older
females entered the thicket, after spending a minute or so at the look-out
point. The younger females made no attempt to enter the thicket and
disappeared from the scene. At 12.30 a female came to the river from the
thicket. Otherwise there was no activity until 1630 hours, when I left.
On 1st January 1970, an encounter with a panther enroute delayed
me and it was past 0800 hours when I got to my observation post. When
I neared the mango tree the dhole were walking away. Between 0830
and 0900 hours, the dhole visited the thicket thrice. There were 5
dhole this time — the two nursing mothers and the two yearling females
and with them was another adult female in an advanced state of preg-
nancy. (The younger dogs tangled with a sounder of pigs which were
ready to put up a fight but the older ones discouraged the youngsters by
showing no interest. Incidentally, in spite of the presence of the dhole
deer freely used that section of the river.) On the last trip only the two
lactating bitches were there. There was no activity until about 1300 hours
when I left.
I could not visit the dens until 19-i-1970. At 0835 two females
approached the thicket, stopped at the look-out point for about 5 minutes,
one of them a little longer, before entering the thicket. One of the
females was limping slightly and was probably a new entrant to the
colony. On 25-i-1970 I was at my post by about 0700 hours, 4 bitches
came to the thicket at 0810 hours. Suspicious at the beginning, they
behaved normally later. At 1020 hours and 1300 hours single females
were seen coming out of the thicket. I went home after 6 hours and
when I returned at 1500 hours the whole pack was hunting in the area.
I saw five dhole at the look-out point and there were a dozen animals
altogether. On the last day I spent at my look-out post, there was no
activity, the last of the earths in use having been abandoned a few days
earlier.
THE DENS OF THE INDIAN WILD DOG
185
I tried to locate active dhole dens during the 1970/71 season,
but failed. However, I was shown 2 dens which had been abandoned
in the middle of the breeding season. I have come across single burrows
previously and evidence of dhole vacating a burrow and digging a fresh
one in a new area. A whelping female may set up a den on its own either
at the outset or on quitting a common nursery.
On 4-xii-71 a cattle grazier of Moyar guided my son Peter and me to
a den, where he had seen a pack of wild dogs ten days previously. The
den was a deep cave under a large shelving rock and was situated in the
Mudumalai Wild Life Sanctuary on the bank of a stream flowing
parallel to the Moyar-Masinigudi road. It was well located on a bend
and commanded a good view of both arms of the nallah. It was one of
the caves I had visited the previous year shortly after it had been
abandoned.
It was 1400 hours when we reached the cave. As we stood watching
the entrance from across the narrow stream, a single bitch which was
obviously lactating emerged growling. It was a relief when it rushed
away. After sending my companions back to the car, I climbed into a
tamarind tree about 25 yards to one side of the cave and sat on a bare
limb of the tree after cutting and hanging a few branches to hide my
perch, and waited.
At 1610 hours a female, probably the same animal which had left
earlier in the afternoon returned. It sat not far from my tree and watched
suspiciously for 20 minutes. Then the pack (actually a part of it as it
turned out) appeared and the female entered the den. Two other dhole also
went in but came out almost at once. Meanwhile a large male lay at the
cave entrance and the other dhole lay about, scattered. Some 10 minutes
later the female emerged and seeing the dog approached submissively
whining and wagging its tail. The dog got up and ran with the bitch
following till both stopped behind a screen of bamboos from where I heard
the female feeding — which could only be on what the male had regurgi-
tated. Dusk was setting and I left.
5-xii-71 — I was on my perch at 0705 hours. While approaching
the tree I took care not to disturb any dhole which might be in the den
area. It was not until 0900 hours that the first animal arrived. It was the
whelping bitch. It waited alertly changing its position every 10 minutes
or so. At 0955 hours the pack came and I could see four besides the
whelping bitch. The whelping bitch, after visiting the den briefly ran after
a large male in a submissive attiude, wagging its tail, whining and whim-
pering as cubs do when trying to attract attention or soliciting food. It
passed under the dog, ran pressing against its side, pushing its mouth
against the side of the dog’s mouth. Thereupon the dog regurgitated
twice, each lump seemed to be about a kilogram in weight, which the
bitch ate continuing to whimper like a cub. The same dog brought up
186 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
food once more, a smaller quantity this time. The bitch repeated the act
with two more dhole but these were more reluctant to oblige. She had
to run chasing them up and down the stream bed for over 100 metres
and pass under them frequently before they would regurgitate. One of
these could have been a female.
Three dhole besides the whelping bitch entered the den briefly. From
the manner in which they fumbled with the false entrance it was obvious
that they were not familiar with it.
At 1015 hours a herd of domestic buffaloes ambled down the nallah
grazing. The dogs joined in chasing them away from the den area. But
they took a long time doing this and I expected better planning and per-
formance from a pack of trained hunting dogs.
But for the buffaloes I would have thought that there were only 5
dhole in the pack. The herd brought 3 more within sight. Half the
pack did not go too close to the den but remained 50 to 100 yards away.
There were altogether 8 (4 cT> 4 $). Such an equal proportion between
sexes may not, however, be the rule.
By 1045 hours all the dogs had left the area and at 1050 hours the
lactating bitch came back but sat outside until 11 30 hours when it entered
the den. It stayed inside for 10 minutes and on emerging lay at the
mouth of the cave for another 10 minutes, suspiciously looking around
and into trees a-1 the time. Between 1140 hours and 1305 hours it went
away and came back 4 times. But most of the time was spent in keeping
vigil from its favourite look-out point among the roots of a banyan tree
directly above the den.
At 1305 hours it entered the den and stayed inside for 12 minutes.
When it came out it went directly to the stream and lay in the water
for 5 minutes. It did not come back until 1315 hours when I, feeling
sore in every limb decided to call it a day.
On my way back, I ran into the pack as they were resting lying scat-
tered under clumps of bamboo about 100 metres off the den.
10-xii-71 — I got into the tree at 0710 hours. Until 1025 there was
no activity, when two dhole inspected the cave and went away. I spent
a couple of hours more waiting. It was apparent that the den had
been deserted. Closer inspection confirmed my suspicion.
Cubs were not seen outside the thicket or outside the cave in the
latter case, even once. But tracks of cubs were seen along the river
bed. It would appear that cubs are not brought out until they were
ready to accompany their mothers and leave the nursery permanently.
A pregnant female was seen on l-i-1970 and the colony was vacated
around 10-ii-1970. It is probable that the dhole, when undisturbed,
use the dens for about 5 weeks before abandoning them. This would
also mean that the cubs were ready to accompany their mothers when 5
weeks old. There is evidence to support this assumption. On 17-i-72
THE DENS OF THE INDIAN WILD DOG
187
a 5 week old cub was captured near my place when it strayed near the
road along with other cubs, having been temporarily abandoned by the
pack in the course of a hunt. Even at that age it was more used to and
preferred a meat diet to milk.
In my view, the fact that no particular male was seen attending to or
showed a special attachment to a particular whelping female, and the fact
that more than one male brought food to a particular female coupled with
the habit of breeding in colonies militates against the widely held belief
of pair bond among dhole.
Peak activity took place early in the morning when most of the
hunting is done.
The nursing mothers left as a pack or with the pack as the case may be
to hunt very early in the morning and returned with the others between
0800 and 1000 hours depending upon their success in hunting. There-
after they were not seen to leave or return together.
In the ease first observed the pack was seen near the thicket only once.
But it was evident from the alarm calls of deer that it was not far off*.
However in the latter instance half the pack was seen entering the den
or in the immediate vicinity, and the rest within 50 to 100 metres of
the den.
There was no evidence of a ‘ guard bitch ’ as mentioned by Phythian
Adams and others. If a bitch remained behind it was purely to look
after her motherly duties. In the mornings, all the animals left the
colony and none was left behind to 4 Guard \
Some of the adult females in the pack were not breeding. It is pos-
sible that every female in the pack did not bring up a litter every season.
There appeared to be some sort of birth control among them, when their
numbers were large as in the area in question.
Food-habits of water-birds of the
Sundarban, 24 Parganas District,
West Bengal, India — IV1 *
Stork, Teal, Moorhen and Coot
BY
Ajit Kumar Mukherjee
Superintending Zoologist , Zoological Survey of India , Calcutta
[Continued from Vol. 68 (3) : 716]
Anastomus oscitans (Boddaert), The Openbilled Stork
The Openbilled Stork, Anastomus oscitans (Boddaert), is a marsh-
loving bird found around tanks, lakes, rivers and estuarine mud-flats,
and also foraging nearby in paddy fields.
About the food-habits of the Openbilled Stork, Jerdon (1864, p. 766)
stated : 4 It lives chiefly on molluscs, especially on the large Ampullaria
but also on various others.’ He further quotes Colonel Sykes’ statement
that it fed on species of Unio. He also found that in default of its proper
food, this snail-eater will eat fish, frogs, etc., but shell-fish are its special
favourite. Blanford (1898, p. 378) mentioned : 4 They occasionally eat
fish, crabs, etc., but subsist mainly on mollusca.’ Baker (1929, p. 334)
writes that it feeds principally on Mollusca, chiefly the Apple-snails, land-
snails, crabs and small Mollusca which it crushes first and then swallows
the entire contents including the shells. It also eats worms, frogs,
lizards, small snakes, insects and fishes. Ali (1955, p. 102) recorded:
4 . . . . soft body and viscera of ... . [Ampullaria snails] form a large
proportion of its food in due seasons. It also eats frogs, crabs, large
insects and other small living things.’
The detailed analysis of the stomach-contents of 72 adult specimens
that the author collected in the Sundarban is given in Table 14.
1 Accepted April 24, 1972.
[71]
FOOD-HABITS OF WATER-BIRDS
189
Table 14
Analysis of the stomach-contents of the Openbilled Stork
[72]
190 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol 71 (2)
Items of diet No. Wt.(g) %(Wt.) Remarks
Phylum Arthropoda
Class Crustacea
Total: 33+ 66 4-35
Phylum Annelida
Class Chaetopoda
Order Oligochaeta
Family Megascolecidae
Pheretima sp . ? In bits. Partially
digested.
Not identifiable.
Total : 32 2*09
(N = Number of examples.
Weight = Total weight (in grammes) of examples of all species under a Class.
Length of fish = Its standard length.)
[73]
FOOD-HABITS OF WATER-BIRDS
191
The food of the Openbilled Stork consists solely of animal matter
comprising mainly of Mollusca (53*64%). Crustacea comes next in
bulk (25*37%). The proportions of other groups are : Reptilia (snakes)
7*40%, Amphibia (Toads and frogs) 2*55%, Insects (grasshoppers and
bugs) 4*35%, Oligochaeta (earthworms) 2*09% and fishes 4*59%.
The fishes taken are mostly air-breathing freshwater mudfishes
which venture out of water. From the contents of stomachs it is
seen that the bird is mostly dependent on freshwater forms, as well as
on a few land forms.
The food of the Openbilled Stork appreciably differs in wet and dry
seasons. During the monsoon when the paddy-fields are inundated, it
searches out Pila which during this season is dispersed over a great area
and is found in abundance. It is then its principal food. It is interest-
ing to note that generally it takes out the fleshy part of larger gastropods
but the smaller ones are crushed and taken with the shells. The larger
crabs are also appropriated in the same manner. During dry months it
congregates largely on the edges of ponds and gheries (brackish water
fish ponds) where it feeds largely on crabs, fishes, amphibia, snakes,
insects, and earthworms.
Out of the 72 birds obtained from the Sundarban area, 46 were col-
lected during the wet season (May-October) and 26 during the dry season
(November- April). Analysis of their stomach contents reveals the
following seasonal differences in its food-habits :
Animal groups
Wet season
(food percentage)
Dry season
(food percentage)
Reptilia 6 8-80
Amphibia — 5*10
Pisces — 9 00
Mollusca 85 22-28
Crustacea 8 42-14
Insecta — 8-00
Oligochaeta — 4-10
Since the Openbilled Stork feeds principally on molluscs (Gastropods)
during the wet season, it is not harmful to human economics. The
destruction of the snails helps the agriculturists to save their nursery
crops from being nibbled and destroyed by snails. Furthermore, the
spread of certain helminth parasites is also checked by the destruction
of snails which are their intermediate hosts. During the dry season,
however, more than half of its food is composed of fishes and crustaceans
of commercial value. Its role, during this season therefore, appears
to be partially adverse.
[74]
192 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Nettapus coromandelianus coromandelianus (Gmelin), Cotton Teal
The Cotton Teal, Nettapus coromandelianus coromandelianus (Gmelin)
is the smallest of the Indian ducks. It is a resident species in the fresh-
water or slightly brackish water pools of the Sundarban reclaimed area.
It prefers more or less open Waters having reedy borders, and plenty of
aquatic vegetation and animal life. It is gregarious, and flocks of 10 to
40 are not uncommon.
Not much information is available about the food -habits of this bird.
Hume & Marshall (1880, p. 104) stated: ‘Their food consists of rice
grain, specially the seed of wild rice known as “ Pasaie ” in Upper India
and of the shoots of various kinds of aquatic plants, worms, water
insects, and their larvae. Once or twice I have found what I believed to
be the remains of minute fishes and fresh-water crustaceans in their
stomachs, but of this I could not be quite certain.’ Baker (1929, p. 394)
reports that the Cotton Teal feeds on shoots of land and water plants,
wild rice and grain and also on insects, worms, snails and small Crustacea
and Mollusca, though these latter form quite a small percentage of the
diet. Ali (1955, p. 108) stated that the food consists chiefly of vegetable
matter, also insects, crustaceans, etc.
The detailed analysis of the stomach-contents of 43 adult specimens
that the author collected in the Sundarban is given in Table 15.
Table 15
Analysis of the stomach-contents of the Cotton Teal
Items of diet No. Wt.(g) %(Wt.) Remarks
[75]
FOOD-HABITS OF WATER-BIRDS
193
Items of diet
Phylum Mollusca
Class Gastropoda
Order Mesogastropoda
Family Viviparidae
Viviparus bengalensis (Lamarck)
Family Melaniidae
Melanoides sp.
Order Basommatophora
Family Lymnaeidae
Lymnaea sp.
Family Planorbidae
Indoplanorbis sp.
Shell fragments
Total :
Phylum Arthropoda
Class Crustacea
Order Decapoda
Family Palaemonidae
Macrobrachium lamarrei (Milne-
Edward)
Family Alphidae
Leander styliferus (Milne-Edward)
Family Atyidae
Caridina gracilipes de Man
Family Potamonidae
Paratalphusa sp. ?
Crustacean fragments
Total :
Class Insec ta
Order Odonata
Suborder Anisoptera
Family Aeschnidae
Aeschna sp. ?
Suborder Zygoptera
Family Coenagriidae
Ceriagrion sp,
Ischneura sp. ?
Order Hemiptera
Family Nepidae
Laccotrephes sp.
Family Gyrinidae
Dineutus indicus Aube
Family Hydrophilidae
Hydrophilus sp.
Insect fragments
No. Wt.(g) %(Wt.) Remarks
129+ 150 7*50
Total :
194 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vo\. 71 (2)
Items of diet No. Wt.(g) %(Wt.) Remarks
Vegetable matter :
Family Convolvulaceae
Ipomoea sp. Roots and tender
shoots.
Family Ceratophyllaceae
Ceratophyllum sp. Part of plant.
Family Hydrocharifaceae
Hydrilla verticillata
Family Naiadaceae
Ruppia rostellata
Miscellaneous vegetable matter Not identifiable.
Total : 1360 68-00
The food of the Cotton Teal is of mixed type, composed mainly of
vegetable matter (68%) with a small percentage of animal matter (32%).
The vegetable matter consists of submerged and floating weeds. The
major portion of animal matter consists of Mollusca (18.50%). Insects
form a small proportion (7.50%) of its diet, the fare consisting mostly
of naiads of dragon- and .dmnselflies, aquatic beetles and bugs. The
other animals are small freshwater shrimps (18*50%) and freshwater fish
fry (standard length 3-15 mm) both of commercial value (Fig. 5).
Although the Cotton Teal consumes fishes and crustaceans of fisheries
importance the percentage is so small that it cannot be considered
harmful.
Gallinula chloropus indica Blyth, The Indian Moorhen
The Indian Moorhen, Gallinula chloropus indica Blyth, is a resident
bird of the marshes. It is commonly met with in the freshwater marshes
of the reclaimed area, preferring undisturbed water-reservoirs which have
plenty of submerged weeds, floating vegetation, reeds and rushes growing
in them and shaded by trees on their edges.
About the food-habits of the Indian Moorhen, Jerdon (1864, p. 719)
records that its food is chiefly vegetable but it also takes aquatic insects,
larvae and even small fish. Blanford (1896, p. 176) states that it feeds on
various kinds of vegetable food and on insects. Baker (1929, p. 29)
finds that its food consists of water-weeds and berries, grass-insects,
snails, worms, frogs and even small fish. Ali (1955) states that its food is
insects, worms, molluscs, grain and shoots of paddy and marsh plants.
Regarding another subspecies of the species, the Florida Gallinule,
Gallinula chloropus cachinnans Bangs, Barrows (1912) states that the food
consists largely of insects, chiefly aquatic. Wetmore (1916, p. 326)
[77]
195
FOOD-HABITS OF WATER-BIRDS
found that in Porto Rico, 96*75 per cent of its food was vegetable, grass
and rootlets forming 90*75 per cent and the other 6 per cent consisting
of seeds of grass and various weeds, much of which must have been picked
up on dry land. The remaining 3*25 per cent was made up of insects and
a few small molluscs. Bent (1926, p. 352) mentions that its food consists
of seeds, roots, and soft parts of succulent water-plants, snails and other
small molluscs, grasshoppers and various other insects and worms.
On the European subspecies, Gallinula chloropus chloropus
(Linnaeus), Collinge (1927, p.278) who examined ten stomachs found that
in Great Britain of the total food-contents 25 per cent consists of animal
matter, viz., 1 per cent fish remains, 1*5 per cent tadpoles, 6*5 percent
injurious insects, 1 per cent beneficial insects, 5*5 per cent neutral insects,
4 per cent slugs and snails and 5.5 per cent earthworms ; vegetable food
forms 75 per cent of the total diet and consists of 55 per cent seeds and
fruits of weeds, etc., 15 per cent grass and 5 per cent leaves, moss and
vegetable fragment. Yoous (1960, p. 86) states that its food consists of
mixed animal and vegetable matters and is extremely variable, compris-
ing a great number of marshwater insects (mosquito and their larvae),
and all sorts of small water animals, seeds and fruits.
The detailed analysis of the stomach contents of 12 adult specimens of
the Indian Moorhen that the author collected in the Sundarban is given
in Table 16.
Table 16
Analysis of the stomach-contents of the Indian Moorhen
Items of diet No. Wt.(g) %(Wt.) Remarks
Phylum Mollusca
Class Gastropoda
Order Mesogastropoda
Family Viviparidae
Viviparus bengalensis (Lamarck) 1 3
Family Littorinidae
Littorina melanostoma Gray 9
Family Hydrobiidae
Digoino stoma pulchella (Benson) 7
Family Melaniidae
Melanoides tuberculatus (Muller) 25
Order Basommatophora
Family Lymnaeidae
Lymnaea sp. 18
Shells in fragments
Some complete and
a few crushed
shells.
Invariably present
in stomachs.
Partly broken.
Invariably present
in stomachs.
Not identifiable.
Total: 72 102 6-18
[78]
196 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
Items of diet No. Wt.(g) %(Wt.) Remarks
FOOD-HABITS OF WATER-BIRDS
197
Items of diet
No. Wt.(g) %(Wt.) Remarks
Vegetable matter
Family Convolvulaceae
Ipomoea sp.
Family Lentibulariaceae
Utricularia sp.
Family Ceratophyllaceae
Ceratophyllum sp .
Family Hydrocharifaceae
Hydrilla verticillata
Vallisneria spiralis
Family Araceae
Pistia stratiotes
Family Naiad aceae
Ruppia sp.
Naias minor
Miscellaneous vegetable (fragments)
Aquatic weed,
-do-
Floating weed.
Submerged weed.
Floating weed.
Submerged weed,
-do-
Not identifiable.
Total :
1485 90-00
Of the total food consumed by the Moorhen, 90% consists
of vegetable matter and 10% animal matter. The submerged or floating
aquatic weeds form the chief vegetable food. The animal food con-
sists of 2*09% insect, 6*18% freshwater molluscs and 0*90% freshwater
Oligochaeta. The insect food is composed of aquatic forms, such as
dragon- and damselfly naiads, aquatic beetles, larvae and pupae of
mosquitoes and chironomids, and some semi-aquatic and terrestrial
grasshoppers. No bugs have been found. Of the 151 examples
of insects comprising 15 species, 120 examples representing three species
were found to be injurious to public health, such as the mosquitoes and
chironomid, and 12 examples representing five species of grasshoppers
which are pests of crop and cultivated vegetables.
The Indian Moorhen, therefore, appears to be beneficial since it
devours a large number of pests of crop and some disease-carrying insects.
The Coot, Fulica atra atra Linnaeus, is a bird of the open waters.
In the Sundarban, it is usually seen in freshwater stretches which have
plenty of submerged aquatic herbage skirted by reeds, sedges and bul-
rushes. It is generally seen in small flocks of 4 to 12 birds, and occa-
sionally singly or in pairs. In winter, the local populations of the
Sundarban are augmented by migrants from adjacent areas for food.
Regarding the Coot in India, Jerdon (1864, p. 716) states that it feeds
chiefly on vegetable matter, seed and shoots of aquatic plants. Blanford
(1898, p. 181) observes that the food consists of water plants, insects
Fulica atra atra Linnaeus, The Coot
[80]
198 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, VoL 71 (2)
and Mollusca. Whistler (1928, p. 339) stated : ‘ Its food consists largely
of vegetable matter which is taken both on the surface and by diving, but
it also eats small fish, insects and mollusca, and is not above devouring
the eggs and chicks of other aquatic birds.’ According to Baker (1929,
p. 35) it often resorts, in the mornings and evenings, to the fields to feed
both on young crops and on insects, snails, worms, etc. It is also known
to steal other birds’ eggs and have been accused of eating their chicks.
Ali (1955, p. 85) records that its food is grass and paddy shoots, aquatic
weeds, and insects, molluscs, etc.
In Europe, Townsend (cited by Bent, 1926, pp. 356-357) found that
its food consists of aquatic insects, molluscs, slugs, worms and small
fishes, seeds, buds and tender shoots of aquatic plants. It also eats
meadow grass and berries. Voous (1960, p. 87) states that its food is
mixed but mainly vegetable, quantities of the submerged parts of plants
obtained by diving, also seeds, fruits, buds and petals of flowers of marsh
and water plants, in winter grass and in summer minute water animals.
The detailed analysis of the stomach contents of 36 adult specimens
that I collected in the Sundarbans is given in Table 17.
Table 17
Analysis of the stomach-contents of the Coot
Items of diet
No. Wt.(g) %(Wt.) Remarks
Phylum Chordata
Class Amphibia
Order Anura
Family Ranidae
Rana sp. (tadpoles) 27
Rana limno charts Boie ? 3 Partly digested.
Total : 30 50 2-81
Series Pisces
Class Teleostomi
Order Cypriniformes
Family Cyprinidae
Chela sp. 32
Labeo sp . 6
Punt ius sarana (Hamilton) ? 14
Length 10-15 mm
Freshwater form.
Invariably present
in stomachs.
Length 15-25 mm
Freshwater form.
Freshwater form.
Partly digested.
Identification
doubtful.
[31]
FOOD-HABITS OF WATER-BIRDS
199
2
[82]
200 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Items of diet No. Wt.(g) % (Wt.) Remarks
Family Grinidae
Dineutes indicus Aube 2 Aquatic form.
Order Diptera
Family Culicidae
Larvae and pupae 100+
Total : 169 150 7 00
Phylum Annelida
Class Chaetopoda
Order Oligochaeta
Family Naididae
Limnodrilus sp.
Family Megascoucidae
Pheretima sp .
Total :
Vegetable matter
Family Convolvulaceae
Ipomoea sp.
Family Ceratophyllaceae
Ceratophyllum sp.
Family Hydrocharifaceae
Hydrilla verticillata
Vallisneria spiralis
Family Graminaeae
Oryza sativa
Panicum sp.
Total :
100+ Tangled mass.
6
106+ 120 6-25
Roots and tender
shoots.
1220 63-53
The food of the Coot consists of both vegetable matter (63.53%)
and animal matter (36.47%). The vegetable matter consists of sub-
merged and floating weeds, tender roots and shoots, grass, paddy shoots
and buds, immature grains, etc. The animal matter consists of 6.25%
of freshwater and land Oligochaeta (earthworm), 13.02% of freshwater
gastropods, 7% of aquatic insects consisting mostly of naiads of dragon-
and damselflies, mosquito larvae and pupae, aquatic Coleoptera etc. ;
fishes consisting of small freshwater species (standard length 10-50 mm.)
of commercial value, 6.77%.
On the whole the bird does not appear to be a harmful one. The
total amount of paddy shoots, grain and fishes taken is negligible, and
this is largely compensated by the good it does by consuming large
numbers of mosquito larvae and pupae.
[83]
{to be continued)
A list of Aphids (Homoptera :
Aphididae) from India and adjacent
countries1
BY
A. K. Ghosh2
Entomology Laboratory , Department of Zoology ,
University of Calcutta , Calcutta
This paper presents a systematic list of the species (344) and genera (142)
of aphids so far known from India and adjacent countries, namely Ceylon,
Pakistan, Nepal & Sikkim and provides notes on their host plants, first re-
ference, distribution in the region and sexual forms. The genera and
species of aphids originally described from this region are also indicated.
Relevant references are provided.
Introduction
Aphids are small Homoptera colonising almost all types of plants.
They usually infest the stems and underside of leaves, though some
species have been reported from the roots and hard woody parts. They
are known to be the largest group of insect vectors for plant viruses and
they also cause considerable damage by sucking the sap of the host plant ;
some species are well known for their role in forming plant galls. A
number of species are cosmopolitian in distribution, while others have
restricted distribution. Many of the tropical species reproduce by par-
thenogenesis, although completion of life-cycle in temperate region are
known. Some species are attended by ants.
Parasites and predators of aphids have attracted considerable atten-
tion in recent times, a short resume of which has been published by
Eastop (1966).
India, with its diversity in altitude, rainfall and vegetation, resulting
in tropical, sub- tropical and temperate conditions, is rich in aphids.
Taxonomy of aphids was started in the last decade of the nineteenth
century. Lefroy & Howlett (1909) presented for the first time a con-
solidated list of species known till then from India. Later Behura (1963)
1 Accepted July 8, 1968.
2 Present Address : Eastern Regional Station, Zoological Survey of India,
Shillong-3, Meghalaya.
202 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 7l (2)
gave a similar account, in which he reported 131 species from India.
These authors were apparently not aware of the exact taxonomic status
of quite a number of species. Moreover, review of literature and exa-
mination of available material reveals that quite a number of species have
not been incorporated even in the rather recent list of Behura (op. cit).
Since a number of researchers are now engaged in the study of the
aphid fauna of India and its adjacent countries, an up-to-date list (up to
1968) of aphids from Ceylon, India, Nepal, Pakistan and Sikkim will
facilitate future studies. Countries adjacent to India have been taken into
account because the aphid fauna of these countries do not differ much
from the Indian ones, as revealed from the works of Das (1918), Alam &
Hafiz (1963), Judenko & Eastop (1963), Eastop (1966) and Hille Ris Lam-
bers (1966).
The species numbered 21, 28, 37, 38. 56, 59, 67, 72, 92, 100, 103, 104,
110, 111, 135, 137, 138,. 140, 142, 154, 155, 167, 168, 188, 210, 245, 246,
265, 280, 281, 290, 309, 310 in the text are known only from Pakistan;
Nos. 25, 27, 82, 116, 119, 121, 132, 145, 147, 200, 216, 252, 277, 283,
284, 325, 331, 342 are known only from Nepal ; Nos. 57, 79, 86, 95,
126, 198, 199, 219, 225, 242, 251, 261, 319 are known only from Sik-
kim ; and Nos. 47, 88, 162, 182, 209, 229, 236, 237, 238, 240 are
known only from Ceylon. These species as also the ones which are distri-
buted in one or more adjacent countries in addition to India are denoted
by abbreviations namely C — Ceylon, N — Nepal, P — Pakistan, and
S — Sikkim ; if there is no such abbreviation the species is then known
only from India. References in the parentheses relate to the first record.
The genera and species described as new from this geographical area
have been marked by (*#) and (*) respectively.
The British Museum Collection, London, and the Zoological Survey
of India Collection, Calcutta, are abbreviated as B.M. Coll, and Z.S.I.
Coll, in the text.
1 Acyrthosiphon (Metopolophium) dirhodum (Walk.). Rosa sp.,
(R. Kumar, B.M. Coll.).
2 A. malvae (Mosley). Calceolaria sp., (Basu 1961b).
3 A. pi sum (Harris). Alhagi maurosum , Clianthus dampieri , Dolichos
lablab , Lathyrus odoratum , Medicago denticulata , Medicago
falcatum , Medicago lupulina , Medicago sativa, Melilotus alba ,
Peganum harmala, Pisum sativum , Sesbania grandiflora , Trigo -
nella foenum-graecum, (Deshpande 1937). P
4* A. rubi Narz., elliptica Stroyan & Nagaich. Rubus elliptica ,
(Stroyan & Nagaich 1964).
5# A. sesbaniae David. Sesbania grandiflora , (David 1956a).
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
203
6 Adelges hiraalayensis Stebbing. Abies webbiana, Picea morinda ,
[Cotes 1896 (1893) as Chermes abietis L. & Kalt. ; Stebbing 1904
described this species as Chermes abietis piceae Stebbing].
7* A. (Dreyfusia) joshi Schneider-Orelli & Schneider. Abies pindrow ,
(Schneider-Orelli & Schneider 1954). P
8* A. (Dreyfusia) knuchelli Schneider-Orelli & Schneider. Abies
pindrow , (Schneider-Orelli & Schneider 1959), [Ghani & Rao
(1966) opined that ‘ both these species are likely the aphids
mentioned by Stebbing (1904, 1910) as Chermes abites piciae
Stebbing and later as Chermes himalayensis Stebbing]. P
9* Aiceona litseae Basil H.R.L. Litsea polyantha , (Basu & H.R.L.
1968).
10* Akkaia bengalensis Basu, Polygonum sp., (Basu 1967).
11 Aleurodaphis blumeae van der Goot. Cynoglossum wallichi,
[Ghosh and Raychaudhuri 1963 (1962)].
12* Amphicercidus indicus H.R.L. and Basu, Lonicera glabrata9
(H.R.L, & Basu 1966).
13 Amphorophora ampullata Buckton. Unidentified fern (Verma
1965).
14* A. ampullata bengalensis H.R.L. & Basu. Various ferns (H.R.L. &
Basu 1966). N
15 Anoecia ? cornii (Fabricius). Cornus to grass roots (R. Kumar,
B.M. Coll.).
16 Aphidura sp. David. Host plant not mentioned. (David 1967).
17 Aphis achyranthii Theobald. Achyranthes sp., Punica granatum,
(Theobald 1929).
18 Aphis sp. nr. clematidis Koch. Clematis , (R. Kumar, B.M. Coll.)
[Later described as Aphis clematidis simlaensis Kumar & Burk.]
19 A. craccivora Koch. A large number of Leguminosae, Cucurbita-
ceae, Labiatae, Menispermaceae, Nyctagenaceae, Rosaceae,
Scitaminaceae and Urticaceae, (Lefroy & Howlett 1909 ; earlier
records of Aphis medicaginis Koch refer to this species ; Basu
et al. 1968, described the sexual forms of this species). C, P
20 A. euonymi Fabricius. Benincasa cerifera , Centauria sp., Cestrum
nocturnum, Chenopodium revely , Cnicus arvensis , Pyrus com-
munis, Rumex dentatus , Solanum nigrum , Vigna catjang s
204 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
(Lefroy & Howlett 1909 ; David 1954, opined that fabae Scop,
rumicis Linne, of Indian authors, refer to this species).
21 A. fabae Scop. Daucus carota, Malva syhestris , Rumex dentata ,
Solanum nigrum , (B.M. Coll.). P
22 A. fabae solanella Theo. Solanum nigrum , (Alam & Hafiz 1963). C
23 A. farinosa yanagicola, Salix sp., (K. D. Verma, B.M. Coll.).
24 A. gossypii Glover. Wide host range [Lefroy & Howlett 1909 ;
Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1964 (1962) recorded male from
India]. P, S
25 A. glycines Mats. Glycine max , (K. C. Sharma, B. M. Coll.
from Nepal). N
26 A. ? hardyi Eastop. Psidium guajava , (B. M. Coll.).
27 A. kurosawai Takahashi. Artemisia sp., (K. C. Sharma, B. M.
Coll.). N
28* A. longituba H.R.L. Host plant unknown, (H.R.L. 1966 from
Pakistan). P
29 A. malvae Koch. Compositae, Cucurbitaceae, (Lefroy & Howlett
1909, Bodenheimer & Swirski 1957 list it as synonym of A.
nasturtii in part and A. umbrella Bomer).
30 A. nasturtii (Kalt.). Nasturtium indicum , Rorippa indica, (Lefroy &
Howlett 1909). P
31 A. nerii (B.D.F.). Asclepias sp., Calotropis gig ant ea, Calotropis
procera , Cryptostegia grandi flora, Cynanchum dalhousiae , Drega
volubilis , Hoy a longifolia , Hoya viridis , Jatropha sp., Marsdenia
volubilis , Nerium odorum, Pergularia extensa , (Lefroy & Howlett
1909 ; A. asclepiadis Pass, of many Indian authors). C, P, S
32 A. pomi De Geer. Pyrus sp., (Krishnamurti 1950).
33 A. punicae Passerini. Punica granatum , (David 1956 c ; Das’s
1918, Aphis durantii is a synonym). P
34 A. rubifolii Thomas. Rubus ellipticus , (B.M. Coll.).
35 A. ruborum Borner, Rubus fruticosus. (B. M. Coll.).
36 A. spiraecola Patch. Bidens pilosa, Emilia sonchifolia , Spirea sp.,
Mikania scandens , Eupatorium sp., (Theobald 1929 ; also known
as malvoides v.d. Goot). C, P, S
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
205
37 A. ? umbrella Borner. Malvastrum sp., (B. M. Coll.). P
38 A. ? urticata Fabricius. Urtica dioica, (B. M. Coll.). P
39 A. verbasci Schrank. Buddleia paniculata, Polygonum atatum ,
(Chowdhuri et al. 1968).
40 Aphrastasia funiticta Prey. Tsuga brunoniana, (B. M. Coll.).
41 Aploneura sp., (K. C. Sharma, B. M. Coll, from Nepal). N
42* Asiphonella cynodonti (Das). Cynodon dactylon , (George 1927
as Geoica cynodontii ; Das 1918 as Pemphigus cynodonti from
Pakistan). P
43** Aspidophorodon harvensis Verma. Salix sp., (Verma 1966b).
44* Astegopteryx bambusae (Buckton). Bambusa arundinacea,
Dendrocalamus giganteus, [Buckton 1896b (1893), as Oregma
bambusae].
45* A. formosana (Takahashi). Bambusa arundinacea , (David 1959).
46 A. formosana neelgiriensis David. Bambusa sp., (David 1958a).
47 A. insularis (v.d. Goot). Dendrocalamus strictus, (v.d. Goot
1918, from Ceylon). C
48 A. lutecens (v.d. Goot). Bambusa sp., (Basu 1961a, v.d. Goot
1918). C
49 A. minuta (v.d. Goot). Bambusa sp., (David 1959).
50* A. mysorensis (Theobald). Bambusa arundinacea , (Theobald
1929, David 1956c)
51 Aulacorthum solani (Kalt.). Citrus sp. , Digitalis purpurea , Solanum
tuberosum , (David 1958c)
52 A. ? simplicois v.d. Goot. Acronychia pedunculata (= laurifolia ),
(Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1962)
53 A. (Neomyzus) circumflexus (Buckton). Antirrhinum sp., Begonia
sp., Calceolaria sp., and many other glasshouse plants, (Basu &
Banerjee 1958). C, S
54* A. (Neomyzus) dicentrae Basu. Dicentra thalictrifolia, (Basu 1967).
55 A. (Neomyzus) dispersum (v.d. Goot). Emilia javanica , Emilia
sonchifolia , (David 1956d),
206 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
56 Baizongia pistaciae (Linn.)* Pistacia integerrima , (Buckton 1896a,
as Pemphigus aedifactor). p
57 Betacallis odaiensis Takahashi. Acanthaceae and Araliaceae,
(Ghosh & Raychaudhuri (1968a), from Sikkim). S
58 Brachycaudus helichrysi (Kalt.). Ageratum conyzoides , Bhimea
lacera, Bomarea caldasiana , Chrysanthemum sp., Cineraria
sp., Cynoglossum furcatum , Erigeron canadensis , Prunus amyg-
dalis, Prunus armeniaca , Prunus domesticus , Prunus padus , Prunus
persica , Prunus sinensis , (Das 1918, also known earlier as £.
pruni Koch).
59 B. (Acaudus)cardui(L.). Cnicuswallichi, (Alam & Hafiz 1963). P
60 B. (Appelia) tragopognonis (Kalt.). Host plant unknown. (B. M.
Coll.).
61 B. (Thuleaphis) rumexicolens Patch. Rumex sp., (R. Kumar, B. M.
Coll.).
62**Brachymyzus jasmini Basu. Jasminum humile , (Basu 1964).
63 Brachysiphoniella montana (v. d. Goot). Cynodon plectosta-
chyum, (Das 1918, in the collection of Z.S.I. No. 8284/5/6 as
Aphis sp.).
64* Brachyunguis calotropicus Menon & Pawar. Calotropis procera,
(Menon & Pawar 1957 ; probably Brachyunguis sp. of Raychau-
dhuri & Ghosh 1959).
65**B. carthami Das. Carthamus oxy carpi, Carthamus oxycantha ,
Vernonia cinerea and other weeds, (Fletcher 1920). P
66**B. harmalae Das. Peganum harmala, (Kapur 1942). (Das 1918,
reported sexual male and female from Pakistan ; Lahore). P
67**B. letsoniae Das. Letsonia scandens , (Das 1918). P
68 B. ? plotnikovi Nevskii. Peganum harmala , (B. M. Coll.).
69 B. ? tamaricis (Lichtenstein). Tamarix articulata , (B. M. Coll.) P
70 Brevicoryne brassicae (Linnaeus). Cruciferae, (Lefroy & Howlett
1909 ; David 1958, recorded sexual female from India). P
71 Capitophorus archangelskii Nevskii. Host plant unknown,
Elaeagnus elsewhere, (B. M. Coll.).
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES 207
72 C. carduinus Walker. Cnicus wallichii, (Alam & Hafiz 1963). P
73 C. eleagni (del Guercio). Cynara seolymus , (David 1956d). N
74 C. formosartimisae (Takahashi). Artemisia dentata , (Basu 1961b).
75 C. hippophaes (Walker). Polygonum hydropiper , (Verma 1965).
76* C. hippophaes indicus Ghosh & Raychaudhuri. Polygonum
chinense, (Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1968).
77 C. hippophaes javanicus H.R.L. Polygonum sp., Polygonum caespi-
tosum, (Basu 1961b). P
78 C. hippophaes mittegoni Eastop. Polygonum glabrum, (B. M.
Coll.).
79* C. vernoniae Ghosh & Raychaudhuri. Vernonia sp., (Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri, 1968 ; only from Sikkim). S
80 Cavariella aegopdii (Scopoli). Salix sp., (Verma 1965).
81* C. nigra Basu. Salix eleganus , (Basu 1964).
82 C. salicicola Mats. Trapped (K. C. Sharma, B. M. Coll, from
Nepal)'. N
83 Ceratoglyphina bambusae v.d. Goot. Bambusa sp., (Basu 1961b).
84* Cerataphis variabilis H.R.L. Areca catechu , Cocos nucifera ,
(David 1959, opined that Cerataphis species mentioned by
Lefroy and Howlett (1909) as lataniae Bois. is probably not
lataniae but variabilis). C
85* C. variabilis H.R.L. unknown var. Calamus rotang , Cocos sp.,
(David 1959).
86 Cerataphis sp. Cinchona sp., (Cotes 1893). S
87* Ceratopemphigiella delhiensis Menon & Pawar. Host plant
unknown, (Menon & Pawar 1958).
88* Ceratopemphigus zehntneri Schoutedon. Brunfelsia uniflora ,
(Doncaster 1956). C
89 Ceratovacuna arundinariae Takahashi. Bambusa sp., (B.M. Coll.).
90 C. lanigera Zehrtner. Saccharum officinarum, plant of N.O.
Combretaceae (Basu & Banerjee 1958). S
91 C. orientalis Takahashi. Host plant unknown, (B. M. Coll.).
208 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
92* Ceruraphis eastopi H.R L. Viburnum cotinifolium , (H.R.L. 1966
from Pakistan). P
93* Cervaphis rappardi H.R L. ssp. indica Basu. Cajanus indicus ,
(Basu 1961b).
94 C. schoutedeniae v.d. Goot. Tabernaemontana divaricata, (Kri-
shnamurti 1930).
95 Chaetogeoica foliodentata Remaudiere & Tao. Alate from Vicia
faba, [Ghosh & Raychaudhuri (1968a), from Sikkim].
96 Chaetogeoica sp. Host unknown, (B. M. Coll.).
97**Chaetomyzus rhododendri Ghosh & Raychaudhuri. Rhododendron
arboreum , [Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1964 (1962b)].
98 Chaetosiphon (Pentatrichopus) fraegifoli (Cockerell). Rosa sp.,
(David 1958a).
99 Chaitophorus albus Mordv. Populus alba , (B. M. Coll.).
100* C. himalayensis (Das). Salix tetrasperma , Salix sp., (Das 1918
from Pakistan). P
101* C. kapuri H.R.L. Populus sp., (H.R.L. 1966). p
102* C. niger Mordv. Salix sp., (Verma 1966).
103* C. nigritus H.R.L. Salix sp., (H.R.L. 1966, from Pakistan). P
104* C. pakistanicus H.R.L. Salix tetrasperma , Salix spp., (H.R.L. 1966,
from Pakistan). P
105 C. versicolor Koch. Populus sp., (B.M. Coll.).
106* Chaitoregma tattakana H.RL. and Basu. Arundinaria sp.,
(H.R.L. & Basu 1966).
107 Chromaphis jugaldicola Kalt. Juglans regia , (Verma 1965).
108* Cinara eastopi Pintera. On snow (Pintera 1965).
109* C. indica Verma. Cedrus deodara , (Verma 1966).
110* C. lachnirostris H.R L. Pinus sp. (H.R.L. 1966, from Pakistan). P
111 C. maculipes H.R.L. Pinus wallichiana (excelsa), (H.R.L. 1966,
from Pakistan). P
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
209
112 C. orientalis (Takahashi). Pinus sp., (S. N. Chatterjee, 1922, det.
V.F.E., B. M. Coll.).
113 C. radicicola Well. On snow, (A. P. Kapur, Z.S.I. Coll. 1955).
114 Cinara Sp. near schimitscheki Borner. Pinus insularis, (Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri 1962 as pineus).
115 Cinara (Cinaropsis) sp. nr. piceicola Choi. Host plant unknown,
(B. M. Coll.).
116 Cinara (Cupressobium) tujafiiina Del Guer. From Conifers,
(B. M. Coll.). N
117 Cinara (Dinolachnus) ? abieticola (Choi.). Underbark of Cedrus
libani {= deodara), (S. N. Chatterjee 1920, B. M. Coll.).
118 Cinara (Lachniella) comata Doncaster. On snow, (Doncaster 1956).
1 19 Coloradoa ? artimisae Del Guercio. Artemisia sp. , (K. C. Sharma,
B. M. Coll.). N
120 Coloradoa rufomaculata Wilson. Chrysanthemum sp., (Fletcher
1920, Das 1918, as Stephensoia labor ensis). P
121 C. (Lidaja)?? heinzei Borner. Artemisia sp., (K. C. Sharma,
B. M. Coll.). N
j
122 Dactynotus kashmiricus Yerma. Campanula colorata , (Verma
1965).
123* D. pseudotanaceti Verma. Helianthus tuberosus, (Verma 1966).
124 D. sonchi (Geoffroy). Carthamus tinctorius, Lactusa uncinata ,
Sonchus arvensis , Sonchus oleraceus , (Lefroy & Howlett 1909
as Macrosiphum ).
125 Dactynotus sp. Host unidentified, [Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1964
(1962b)].
126 Dactynotus sp. Host unidentified, (Ghosh & Raychaudhuri in
press a). S
127 Dactynotus (Uromelan) carthami H.R.L. Carthamus tinctorius ,
(David 1956d).
128 D. (Uromelan) compositae (Theobald). Calendula sp., Cosmos sp.,
Zinnia sp., etc. (Basu & Banerjee 1958).
129* D. (Uromelan) dravidiana David, Vernonia cineria, (David 1956a).
210 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
130 D. (Uromelan)? nigrocampanulae (Theo.) rapunculoides Borner.
Centaura moschata, Sonchus spp., (Z.S.I. Coll. 9598/19 leg
Anandale, dt. v.d. Goot, 1915 as M. solidaganis Fab.).
131 D. (Uromelan) similis H.R.L. Urtica dioica , (Yerma & Mathur,
1966).
132 Diuraphis? noxuis Mordwilko. Hordeum vulgare , (B. M. Coll.). N
133 Dysaphis emicis Memeur. Rumex sp., (R. Kumar, B. M. Coll.).
134 Dysaphis foeniculus Theobald. Rumex sp., (B.M. Coll.).
135 D. gahani Stroyan. Cnicus wallichii , (B. M. Coll.). p
136 D. ? plautaginea (Passeriui). Malus sp., (B. M. Coll.)
137 D. pyri B.D.F. Pyrus communis , (B. M. Coll.). P
138 Dysaphis sp. Rumex dentatus , (Alam & Hafiz 1963, from
Pakistan). P
139 Ephedrephis ephedrae (Nevsky), Ephedrus sp., (Yerma 1966).
140 Epipemphigus imaicus Chold. Populus ciliata , (H.R.L. 1966). P
141 Eriosoma lanigerum (Hausmann). Pyrus malus, (Cotes 1891). P
142 E. phaenax Mord. Alatae only in Androchne cordifolia , (B. M.
Coll., from Pakistan). P
143 Eriosoma sp. Host plant unknown, (B. M. Coll.).
144 Eucarizza elaegnus Ferr. Host Plant unknown, (B.M. Coll.).
145 Euceraphis ? chuansiensis Tao. Trapped, (K. C. Sharma, B. M.
Coll.). N
146 Eulachnus thunbergi Wilson. Pinus insularis , (Ghosh & Ray-
chaudhuri in 1968b).
147 Euthoracaphis sp. Host plant unknown, (B. M. Coll.). N
148* Eutrichosiphum davidi Raychaudhuri. Quercus serrata, (Ray-
chaudhuri 1956).
149 Eutrichosiphum pasaniae (Okajima). Quercus coccinea , Quercus
prinus ( montana ), Quercus serrata , (David 1956d, as lithocarpi).
150 E. vandergooti Raychaudhuri. Quercus serrata , (Basu 1961b).
Aphids from india and adjacent countries 2ii
151 Forda orientalis George. Pennisetum typhoideum, Sorghum vulgare ,
(George 1927).
152 Formosanaphis micheliae Takabashi. Magnolia campbellii , Magno-
lia stellata, (Basu 1961b).
153 Geoica lucifaga (Zebntner). Sorghum vulgare , Triticum vulgare ,
(George 1924 as Geoica sp.).
154*#Gharesia polunini Stroyan. Cara; sp., (Stroyan 1963, from
Pakistan). P
155#*Globulicaudaphis pakistanicus H.R.L. Quercus dilatata , (H.R.L.
1966, from Pakistan). P
156 Glyphinaphis bambusae (v.d. Goot). Bambusa sp., (Basu 1961b).
157* Greenidea artocarpi Westwood. Artocarpus incisa, Artocarpus
integra, (George 1927) C
158 Greenidea sp. Dalbergia sissoo, Echnocarpus dorsy carpus, (Anony-
mous 1956).
159 Greenidea (Trichosiphum) anonae(Pergande).? Nicotiana tabacum,
(Raychaudhuri 1956).
160 G. (Trichosiphum) ficicola Takahashi. Ficus spp., (Raychaudhuri
1956).
161 G- (Trichosiphum) formosana (Maki). Eugenia sp. , Psidium guajava,
(Raychaudhuri 1956).
162 Greenideoida ceyloniae v.d. Goot. Trapped, (Judenko & Eastop
1963). C
163* G’ lambersi Basu. Hymenodictyon sp., (Basu 1964).
164** Hillerislambersia darjeelingi Basu. Lonicera sp., (Basu 1967).
165* Holotrichosiphon dubius, v.d. Goot. Host plant unknown, (van
der Goot 1917).
166* Hyadaphis coriandri (Das). Carum can away, Carum copticum ,
Coriandrum sativum , Cuminum sativum , Daucus carota , Foeni-
culum vulgare, Peucedanum graveolens, (Theobald 1929 as
Hyalopterus carii Theo. ; Das 1918 reported alate male of this
species as Brevicoryne, from Pakistan). P
167 Hyadaphis foeniculi Pass. Host plant unknown (B. M. Coll.). P
212 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
168 Hyalopterus amygdali Blanchard. Prunus amygdalus , Primus
armeniaca , Prunus bokhariensis , Prunus persica , (B. M. Coll.). P
169 H. atriplicis (Linnaeus). Chenopodium album, Chenopodium spp.,
(Das 1918, reported it as Brevicoryne chenopodii (Schrank),
from India (Delhi) and Pakistan (Lahore). N,P
170 H. primi (Geoggroy). Arundo donax, Chenopodium album,
Coriandrum sativum , Datura sp., Phaseolus vulgaris , Phragmites
karka, Prunus americana, Prunus persica , Prunus sp., (Fletcher
1920 ; Das 1918, reported male and female from Pakistan). P
171 Hyperomyzus carduellinus (Theobald). Sonchus arvensis, (B.M.
Coll.).
172 Hyperomyzus lactucae Linn. Sonchus oleraceus, Sonchus spp.
and also from Ribes spp., (B. M. Coll. ; Das 1918, recorded
this species as Rhopalosiphum from Pakistan). P
173 Hyperomyzus oleracea (v.d. Goot). Sonchus arvensis, (David
1958b).
174 Hysteroneura setariae (Thomas). Oryza sativa and a number of
Graminaceous plants, (David et al. 1967).
175 Idoopterus sp. From Fern, (A. N. Basu, W. B. Govt. Coll., Dept.
Agric. Res. Inst.)
176 Impatientimim impatiens (Shinji). Impatiens sp., (Ghosh & Ray-
chaudhuri 1968).
177**Indiochaitophorus furcatus Verma. Ulmus wallachina, (Verma
1966).
178 Indomegoura indicum (v.d. Goot). Unidentified host plant, (v.d.
Goot 1917, as Rhopalosiphum).
179 Jacksonia conandri (Takahashi). Graminaceous host, (Gbosh &
Raychaudhuri, 1968a). S
180 Kalltenbachiella sp. Trapped, (Judenko & Eastop 1963). C
181* Kurisakia indica Basu. Engelhardtia spicata , (Basu 1967).
182* Lachnus greeni v.d. Goot. Cryptomeria sp., (v.d. Goot 1918, from
Ceylon). C
183* L. himalayensis v.d. Goot. Host plant unknown, (v.d. Goot 1917).
184* L. krishni (George). Pyrus communis, (George 1927 as Dilachnus).
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
213
185* L. similis v.d. Goot. Host plant unknown, (v.d. Goot 1917).
186* L. titabarensis Raychaudhuri & Ghosh. Heteropnax fragnens ,
(Raychaudhuri & Ghosh 1964).
187* L. tropicalis (v.d. Goot). Host plant unknown, (v.d. Goot 1916).
188* Liosomaphis atra H.R.L. Berberis sp., (H.R.L. 1966) (H.R.L.
1966 from Pakistan). P
189 L. berberidis (Kalt.). From perennials, (David 1958). C
190* L. himalzayensis Basu. Berberis umbellata , (Basu 1964). N
191 Lipaphis crysimi (Kalt.). Cultivated cruciferae, also fromAralaiceae,
Solanaceae, (George 1927 ; also known as Siphocoryne indo-
brasicae Das and Rhopalosiphum pseudobrassicae Davis ;
Yerma & Mathur 1966, recorded males from India). C,P
192 L. (Lipaphisdiella) lepidii Nevskii. Lepidium repens , (B. M.
Coll.) C,P
193* Longicaudus himalayensis H.R.L. Quercus sp., (H.R.L. 1965).
194 Longiunguis donacis (Passerini). Arundo donax, (George 1927,
as Aphis donacis). P
195* L. indosacchari David. Iseilema laxum, Saccharum officinarum,
(David 1956a).
196 Longiunguis sacchari (Zehntner). Saccharum officinarum also from
Eleusine coracana, Panicium colonum, Sorghum vulgar e, and
Zea mays , [George 1927 ; recorded as Aphis sacchari Zehnt. by
early authors ; Menon, (personal communication, May 5,
1968) recorded sexuales from Delhi].
197 Macrorhinarum ensigallis T. & T. Ailantkus sp., (Choudhuri
et al. 1968 ; According to Tao, this species is a synonym of
Kaburagia rhusicola Takagi var. ensigallis Tsai & Tang, personal
communication to Dr. D. N. Raychaudhuri).
198 Macrosiphoniella artimisae (Boyer). Artemesia vulgaris , (Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri 1968a, from Sikkim). S
199 M. kikungshana Takahashi. Asclepias currasivica , (Ghosh & Ray-
chaudhuri 1968a, from Sikkim). S
200 M. ? oblonga Mord. Chrysanthemum sp., (B. M. Coll.). N
201 M. pseudoartimisae Shinji. Artemisia sp., (Verma & Mathur 1966).
214 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vot. 71 (2)
202 M. sanborni (Gillette). Chrysanthemum indicum , Chrysanthemum
sinense , Vernonia sp.,(v.d. Goot 1917, as Macrosiphum). N,S
203* M. spinipes Basil. Artemisia vulgaris , (Basu 1967).
204* M. yomogifoliae (Shinji). Artemisia vulgaris , (Krishnamurti
1950 as M. plutea Buckton ; some authors regard this species
as a subspecies of M. artimisae).
PART II
205 Macrosiphum euphorbiae (Thomas). Chrysanthemum sp., Mangi-
fera indica , Rosa sp., (David 1958b).
206* M. gravelli v.d. Goot. Host plant unknown, (v.d. Goot 1917).
207 M. hellebori Theobald & Walton. Agrostimma coelirosa , Echeveria
sp., Ranunculus sp., (David 1956a).
208 M. jaceae Linnaeus. Arctotis grandiflora, Calendula sp., Callopsis
tinctora, Cannabis sativa, Carthamus tinctorius, Corchorus
olitorius. Dahlia viriabilis , Ficus religiosa , Guizotia abyssynica ,
(Trehan & Halleppanawar 1949).
209* M. minutum v.d. Goot. Vernonia cineria, (v.d. Goot 1918, from
Ceylon). C
210* M. pachysiphon H.R.L. Rubus lasiocarpus , (H.R.L. 1966). P
211 M. (Sitobion) africanum (H.R.L.) Chrysopogon zeylanicus , (David
1958b).
212 M. (Sitobion) avanae (Fabricius). Avena sativa , Hordeum vulgare,
Pennisetum typhoideum , Sorghum vulgare , Triticum vulgare ,
Zea mays , (Fletcher 1920, Das 1918 ; recorded it as Macrosi-
phum granarium from India & Pakistan). N,P
213 M. (Sitobion) fragariae (Walker). Chrysopogon zeylanicus ,
Entropogon sp., (David 1958b).
214 M. (Sitobion) graminis (Takahashi). Agapanthus umbellatus , Andro-
pogon lividus , Bidens pilosa, Chloris barbata, Chrysopogon
zeylanicus , Eragrostis gangetica , Glyceria fluitans , (David 1958b).
215* M. (Sitobion) indicum Basu. Cymbidium sp., (Basu 1964).
216 M. (Sitobion) ibarae Mats, sp., (B.M. Coll.)
N
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
215
217# M. (Sitobion) lambersi David. Chloris barbata , Cynodon dactylon ,
Digitaria marginalis , Eremopogon foveolatus , Ischaemum arista -
mm, Paspalum conjugation, (David 1956a).
218* M. (Sitobion) leelamaniae David. Eleusine coracana, Sorghum
vulgare, Pennisetum typhoideum, (David 1958c).
219 M. (Sitobion) luteum (Buckton). Dendrobium densiflorum, (Ghosh
& Raychaudhuri, 1968a). S
220 M. (Sitobion) miscanthi (Takahashi). Agrostis sp., Amphilopsis
pertusa, Avena sativa, Bothriochloa insculpa , Chloris barbata,
Chrysopogon zeylanicus, Cineraria sp., Cymbopogon martini,
Dactyloctenium aegyptium, Eleusine coracana, Eragrostis superba ,
Hordeum vulgare, Ischaemum rugosum, Oryza sativa , Sorghum
vulgare , Triticum vulgare, Zea mays, [Theobald 1929, described
this species as Macrosiphum eleusine and David (1956c)
considered elusine Theobald, as subspecies of avanae (Fab.),
Eastop (1966) opined that elusine Theobald seems to be a
synonym of miscanthi Takahashi].
221 M. (Sitobion) phyllanthi (Takahashi). Phyllanthus maderaspatensis,
Phyllanthus niruri, (David 1958b ; David also mentioned a
subspecies of this species from Emblica officinalis).
222 M. (Sitobion) rosae, Rosa sp., (Basu & Banerjee 1958 ; Lefroy’s
(1909) record of Siphonophora rosae, may refer to this species
or to rosaeformis Das ; in Z.S.I. specimens of rosae from
Kurseong and Kumaon hills, det. B. Das 1909 were seen). C,P
223* M. (Sitobion) rosaeformis Das. Rosa centofolia, Rosa damascena,
Rosa moschata, (George 1927 ; Das 1918 described this species
originally from Lahore). P
224 M. (Sitobion) smilaceti dalhousiensis Verma. Smilax parvifolia,
(Verma 1966).
225 M. (Sitobion) smilacicola Takahashi ssp. sikkimensis Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri. Smilax sp., (Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1968,
from Sikkim). S
226 M. (Sitobion)? takahashii Eastop. Emblica sp., (B. M. Coll.).
227* Masonaphis anaphilidis Basu. Anaphilis triplinervis, (Basu 1964).
228* Matsumuraja capitophoridesH.R.L. Rubus macilentus, [Chowdhuri
et al. 1968, H.R.L. (1966) described this species from
Pakistan]. P
3
216 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
229 Matsumuraja sp. Host unknown, (Judenko & Eastop 1963). C
230 Melanaphis bambusae (Fullaway). Bambusa sp., (Basu 1961b).
231 Melanaphis? pahalensis Takahasbi. Plant of N.O. Combretaceae,
(Ghosh Coll. 1962). S
232 Metaphordon polygoni (v.d. Goot). Nicotiana tabacum , probably
a migrant, [Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1968a]. S
233 Microlophium ?? evansi (Theobald). Urtica sp. , (Verma, B. M. Coll.).
234**Micromyzodium iilicum David. Gymnograma peruviana , Nepro-
lepeds sp., Polypodium sp., (David 1958d).
235 M. dasi Verma. From unidentified fern, (Verma 1966).
236 Micromyzus dispersion v.d.G. Emilia sp., (B. M. Coll.). C
237 M. eastopi Carver. Host plant unknown, (Carver 1965). C
238 M. judenkoi Carver. Host plant unknown, (Carver 1965) [Pro-
bably last two are same species recorded by Judenko & Eastop
1963 as Micromyzus spp.]. C
239* M. kalimpongensis Basu. Hedychium coronarium , (Basu 1967).
240* M. nigrum v.d.G., Cinnamomum sp., (v.d.G. 1918 from Ceylon). C
241 Mindarus japonicus Tak. Abies pindrow, (B. M. Coll.).
242 Mollitrichosiphum tenuicorpus (Okajima). Castanospermum sp.,
[Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1968 (a), from Sikkim]. S
243* M. (Metatrichosiphon) nandii Basu. Aims nepalensis, (Basu 1964).
244 Mordvilkomemor sp. Artemisia vestata , (Choudhuri et al. 1968).
245 Mordvilkomemor sp. Cnicus wallichii , (Alam & Hafiz 1963). P
246 Myzaphis rosarum (Lltb.). Rosa sp., (B. M. Coll.). P
247 Myzocallis bambusifoliae (Takahashi). Phyllostacus manii (Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri 1962a).
248* M. flooribundi Verma. Quercus floribunda, (Verma 1965).
249 M. kahawalokalani Kirkaldy. Lagerstroemia sp., Lawsonia alba ,
(Anonymous 1956).
250 Myzus cerasi Fabricius. Rubus sp., (R. Kumar, B. M. Coll.).
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
217
251 M. dycei Carver. Glycine max , probably a migrant, (Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri 1968a, from Sikkim). S
252 M. formosana Takabashi. Polygonum sp., (B. M. Coll.). N
253 M. ? hemerocallis Takahashi. Agapanthus umbellata , Hemerocallis
fulva (David 1956d).
254 M. ? geranicola Shinji. Geranium sp., (K. D. Verma, B. M. Coll. ;
According to Takahashi 1965, M. geranicola , Shinji 1935 is not
a Myzus).
255 M. ornatus Laing. Cineraria sp., Duranta plumieri, (David 1956d).
C
256 M. (Nectarosiphon) persicae (Sulzer) Extremely polyphagous
species, [Barlow 1896, as Rhopalosiphum dianthi ; Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri 1962c, recorded male and Menon 1968 (personal
communication), recorded female from Delhi]. C,P,S
257* M. (Prunomyzus) sp. Prunus cerasoides, (Choudhuri et al. 1968).
258 M. (Sciamyzus) ascolonicus Doncaster. Fragaria sp., Plectranthus
coetsa , (Choudhuri et al. 1968)
259* Nasonovia jammuansis Verma, Delphinium sp., (Verma 1965 ;
B. M. Coll, includes a species Kakimia n.sp. Verma, which is this
species according to Dr. Verma, in personal communication).
260**Neobetulaphis pusilla Basu. Betula utilis , (Basu 1964).
261 **Neorhopalosiphoniniis smilacifoliae Ghosh & Raychaudhuri. Smilax
sp., (Ghosh & Raychaudhuri, 1968a, from Sikkim). S
262* Nippolachnus bengalensis Basu. Eriobotrya dubia , (Basu & H.R.L.
1968).
263* N. erybotryae Basu & H.R.L. Eriobotrya petiolata , (Basu &
H.R.L. 1968).
264 N. pyri Matsumara. Pyrus insularis (= khasya), [Ghosh & Ray-
chaudhuri 1963 (1962)].
265 Obtusicaudus sp. Artemisia sp., (B. M. Coll.). P
266* Oedisiphum soureni Basu. Anaphilis triplinervis , (Basu 1964).
267 Ovatus crataegarius (Walker). Mentha sp., (Verma 1965), P
268 Panaphis juglandis (Goetze). from Juglans regia , (Verma 1965).
218 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (2)
269**Paracallipterus kalipadi Raychaudhuri & Ghosh. Anon a squamosa,
(Raychaudhuri & Ghosh 1964).
270 Paratrichosiphum alnicola Basu. Alnus nepalensis (Basu 1967).
271* P. minutum (v.d. Goot), Host plant unknown, (v.d. Goot 1917),
(Raychaudhuri 1956).
272 P. tattakanum (Takahashi). Quercus sp. (Basu 1961b).
273* P. tattakanum assamensis Ghosh & Raychaudhuri. Quercus sp.,
(Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1962b.).
274**Paratrichosiphum sp. Solanum nigrum , (Raychaudhuri 1956,
reported sexual female).
275**P. (Neoparatrichosiphum) khasyanum Ghosh & Raychaudhuri.
Quercus sp., [Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1964 (1962)].
276* Pemphigus lichtenstani Tullgren. Populus sp., Populus nigra ,
(Buckton 1897, as immunis).
277 P. ? mordwilkoi Choi. Populus ciliata, (B. M. Coll.). N
278* P. napaeus Buckton. Populus sp., (Buckton 1897).
Note . — Pemphigus cinchonae Buckton, from Cinchona sp. [Cotes
1893 (1892), is not an aphid, but an aleyrodid, accord-
ing to V. F. Eastop].
279 Pentalonia nigronervosa Coquerel. Alocasia macrorhiza, Caladium
sp., Calocasia antiquorum , Elettaria cardamomum , Musa para-
disica and various Musa spp., (George 1927). C
280 Periphyllus vandenboschii H.R.L. Acer sp., (H.R.L. 1966 from
Pakistan). P
281 Phorodon (Diphorodon) cannabis Passerini. Artemisia sp., Cannabis
indica , Cnicus arvensis , Cnicus sp., (Das 1918). P
282 Pineus laevis (Masked). Pinus spp., (Eastop 1966 mentioned its
probable distribution in Pakistan).
283 P. pini Macquart. Pinus excelsa, (B. M. Coll.). N
284 Pleotrichophorus ? chrysanthemii (Theobald). Host plant unknown,
(B. M. Coll.). N
285 Prociphilus micheliae H.R.L. Michella champaca, (HRL 1933).
286 P. oriens Mord. Host plant unknown, (B.M. Coll.).
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
219
287 P. osmanthae Essig & Kuwana. Host plant unknown, (Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri 1968b).
288 Prociphilus sp. Tsuga brunonianci , (Basil 1961 b).
289# Protrama penecaeca Stroyan. Helianthus tuberosus , (Stroyan 1964 ;
Verma & Mathur 1966, recorded male of this species).
290 Pseudoessigella brachycheata H.R.L. Pirns wallichiana , (H.R.L.
1966 from Pakistan). P
291 Pseudoregma bambusicola (Takahashi). Bambusa sp., (Putta-
rudriah & Chennabasavanna 1952 as Oregma).
292 P. panicola (Takahashi). Oplismenus compositus , (David 1959 as
Oregma).
293 Pterochloides persicae (Choi.). Prunus amygdalis, Prunus armenica,
Prunus bokhariensis , Prunus communis , Prunus persica , Prunus
spp., (Fletcher 1920 ; Das 1918, described it as Tuberodryobius
persicae Cholod & also recorded sexual female). P
294 Pterocomma pilosa Buckton. Salix sp., (Verma 1965).
295 P. populea Kaltenbach. Host plant unknown, (v.d. Goot 1917).
296**Pyrolachnus pyri (Buckton). Pyrus sp., (Buckton 1899 a, as
Lachnus).
297 Reticulaphis ? shiiae Tak. Host plant unknown, (B. M. Coll.).
298 Rhodobium porosum (Sanderson). Rosa spp., (Krishnamurti 1930,
as Macrosiphum rosaefolium Theo.).
299 Rhopalosiphoninus latisiphon Davidson, sprouts of Solanum
tuberosum (David 1954b).
300 Rhopalosiphum maidis (Fitch). Collected from many host plants,
mainly of N. O. Graminae, [Lefroy 1909; Das 1918 recorded
alate male from Pakistan ; Menon 1968, (personal communi-
cation), collected oviparous female from Delhi]. C,N,P
301 R. nymphaeae (Linnaeus). Aponogeton monchar ias, Eichhornia
speciosa ( crassipes ), Lemna sp., Nelumbia speciosum, Prunus
persica , Scripus lacustris, Vallisneria spiralis also from plants of
Cactaceae, & Leguminosae, (Lefroy 1909 ; Das 1918 and David
1958b, collected males of the species from Pakistan & India). P
220 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
302 Rhopalosiphum padi Linnaeus. Arena sativa, Panicum crusgalli ,
Triticum vulgare , Zea mays , (v.d.Goot 1917 as Siphonaphis padi
L.) probably Siphocoryne avcnae (Fabr.) of Das 1918. N,P
303 Rhopalosiphum rufiabdominalis (Sasaki). Wide host range but
mostly on Graminae, (Das 1918, as Siphocoryne avenae & Aphis
sp., as seen in the collection of Z.S.I.). C,P
304# R. vagans v.d. Goot. Host plant unknown, (v.d. Goot 1917, pro-
bably belongs to Sinomegoura , Meguroparsus group of genera).
Note. — Rhizobius jujubae Buckton, recorded from Zizyphus
jujuba by Buckton 1899b, is not an aphid, but a coccid.
305 Saltusaphis scripus Theobald. Host plant unknown, (Menon &
Pawar 1958 as S. africana Eastop).
306 Schizaphis cyperi (v.d. Goot). Cyperus rotundus . (Das 1918 as
Toxoptera). C,P
307 S . gramimim (Rondani). Arena satira , Cynodon dactylon , Cyperus
nireus , Cyperus rotundus , Eleusine coracana , Hordeum rulgare,
Sorghum rulgare , Triticum satirum, Triticum rulgare , (George
1927 as Toxoptera graminum ). C,P
308 S. minuta v.d.G. Cyperus rotundus , (Eastop 1966).
309 S. ? ? pilepes Oss. Host plant unknown, (B.M. Coll.). P
310 S. pyricola Mats. Pyrus communis , (Das 1918, as Toxoptera punja -
bipyri Das from Pakistan). P
311 S. ? ? pyri Shapsnikov. Pyrus sp., (B. M. Coll.).
312 Schoutedenia bougaiimlliae (Theobald). Emblica officinalis ,
(George 1927, as Setaphis bougainrilliae Theobald ; S. emblica
Patel & Kulkarni & S. emblica andhraka David & Lambers
1956b, are considered synonyms of this species by Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri 1962 ; David 1956b recorded sexual forms of
this species.
313 Schoutedina lutea (v.d.Goot.). Boehmeria polystachya, (Basu
1961b). C
314 Semiaphis sp. Lonicera angustifolia , (Chowdhuri et al. 1968).
315 Shinjia pteridifoliae Shinji. Dryopteris sp., (Ghosh, Coll. 1962). N
316**Shivaphis celti Das. Celtis australis , Celtis tetrandra var. hamiU
tonii , (Das 1918 ; also described sexual forms). C,P
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
221
317 Sinomegoura citricola (v.d. Goot). Citrus reticulata , Litsea poly -
antha, Photinia integrifolia , migrant on Bambusa sp., (Basu
1961b, recorded it as Ayrtchosiphon citricola ). S
318* S. pyri Ghosh & Raychaudhuri. Pyrus communis , (Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri 1968b).
319 S. rhododendri Takahashi. Migrant from Smilax sp., (Ghosh &
Raychaudhuri 1968a, from Sikkim). S
320 Sipha (Rungsia) maydis Pass. From Grass, (B. M. Coll.).
321 Smynthurodes betae Westwood. Roots of Compositae, (Basu 1961b).
322* S. gossypii Kulkarny. Roots of Gossypium sp., (Kulkarny 1956 as
Trifidaphis ).
323* Stomaphis mordwilkoi H.R.L. From Walnut, (H.R.L. 1933).
324**Subovatomyzus leucoscephtri Basu. Leucosceptrum canum , (Basu
1964).
325* Sumatraphis ? celti Tak. Trapped, (K. C. Sharma, B. M. Coll.). N
/
326* Tetraneura heterohirsuta Carver & Basu. Imperata arundinacea ,
(Carver & Basu 1961).
327 T. javensis v. d. Goot. Saccharum officinarum , (George 1927,
as T. cynodontis coimbatorensis George, according to David
3958c).
328 T. nigriabdominalis (Sasaki). Roots of various Graminae including
Oryza sativa , [Fletcher 1914 as T. ulmi De Guer, according to
David 1954a, who recorded it as T. hirsuta Baker, which is a
synonym of T. nigrabdominalis (Sasaki)]. C,P,S
329 T. yezoensis Mats. From Grass roots, (B. M. Coll.).
330 Therioaphis trifolii (Monell). Cyperus rotundus , Medicago lupalina ,
Medicago sativa , (Buckton 1899b as Chaitophorus maculatum
Buckton).
331 Tiliaphis sp. Host plant unknown, (B. M. Coll.). N
332 Titanosiphon bellicosum "Nevskii. Artemisia shop aria, (B. M.
Coll.). P
333 Toxoptera aurantii (Fonscolombe). Acalypha sp., Albizzia odor a-
tissima , Anona squamosa , Artocarpus spp., Bougainvillea specta -
bill's, Caesalpinia cariaria, Camellia spp., Citrus spp., Coffea
222 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
arabica , Combretum sp., Dalbergia sissoo, Echites rubrovenosa,
Gordinia obtusa, Ixora sp Lit chi sinensis, Litsea spp., Piper sp.,
Macleania punctata , Mangifera indica , Moringa oleifera , Photina
japonia, Saccharum officinarum , Santalum album , Schima walli-
chi,Tamarindus indicus,Theobroma cacao, etc, [Cotes 1896(1893)
as Cey Ionia thaecola , Buckton]. C,S
334 T. citricidus (Kirkaldy). Artocarpus incisa , CZ/ras spp., (George
1927, as Aphis tavahsi Del Guercio). C,N
335 T. odioae (v.d. Goot). Anacardium occidentale , Achras sapota ,
Hamelia patens , Hibiscus rosasinensis , Mangifera indica , Odina
sp., sp., Vibrunum foetidum, (George 1927 as
odinae v. d. Goot ; Longiunguis spathodeae v.d.G, is probably
a synonym according to Judenko & Eastop 1963).
33 6# Tricaudatus polygoni Narz. s.sp. tuberculatus H.R.L. & Basu.
Spirea corymbosa , (H.R.L. & Basu 1966).
337* Trichaitophorus recurvispinosus H.R.L. & Basu. Actinidia callosa ,
(H.R.L. & Basu 1966).
338 Trichosdphoniella ? momonis Mats. Prunus cerasoides, (B.M. Coll.).
339# Tuberoaphis hydrangeae Tseng & Tao, s.sp. digitata H.R.L. &
Basu. Hydrangea robusta9 (H.R.L. & Basu 1966).
340 Tuberolachnus saligna (Gmelin). Salix aegyptica, Salix baby -
lonica, Salix tetrasperma , (Ghosh & Raychaudhuri 1962a,
Das 1918, as T. viminalis).
341* Unipterus n. sp. Host plant not mentioned, (David 1967).
342 Vesiculaphis ? caricis (Tull.) Trapped, (K. C. Sharma, B. M.
Coll.). N
343 V. grandis Basu. Rhododendron sp., (Basu 1964).
344* V. pieridis Basu. Pier is ovalifolia , (Basu 1964).
Acknowledgements
I am deeply indebted to Dr. D. N. Raychaudhuri, Department of
Zoology, University of Calcutta, for his continuous encouragement
during the course of this study ; Dr. M. S. Mani for going through
the manuscript ; Dr. V. F. Eastop, Department of Entomology, British
Museum (Natural History)’, London, for his valuable help in supplying
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
223
the data of aphid material in the British Museum collection ;
Dr. G. Ramadas Menon, Division of Entomology, I.A.R.I., New Delhi,
Dr. K. D. Verma, Central Potato Research Institute, Simla,
Dr. S. K. David, Madras Christian College, Madras, for some helpful
information ; Dr. S. N. Banerjee, Dept, of Agriculture, Govt, of West
Bengal, Dr. A. P. Kapoor, Diiector, Zoological Survey of India, Calcutta,
for allowing the author to see the aphid collections in their institute ;
Sri G. K. Chakkravarty, Head of the Department of Zoology, Calcutta
University, for providing working facilities as a Pool Officer, C.S.I.R.,
Govt, of India.
I wish to thank Mr. J. Ganguly, Zoological Society of Calcutta, for
his patience in typing out the manuscript.
References
Anonymous (1956) : Entomology
Section — A brief Review. Dept. Agric.,
Govt. West Bengal.
Alam, M. M. & Hafiz, I. A. (1963):
Some Natural Enemies of Aphids of
Pakistan. Technical Bulletin, Common-
wealth Institute of Biological Control 3 :
41 : 44.
Barlow, E. (1899) : Miscellaneous
notes. Indian Mus. Notes, 4 (1) : 23-25.
Basu, A. N. (1961a) Addition to the
Aphid fauna of West Bangal. Sci. &
Cult. 27 (9)456.
(1961b): Some aphids new
to India with description of a new sub-
species. Curr. Sci. 30 (10): 390.
(1964): New genera and
species of Aphididae from Darjeeling
district, India. J. Linn. Soc . (Zool.)
45 (305) : 223-243.
(1967) : One new genus and
seven new species of aphid from
Darjeeling district, West Bengal (Homop-
tera : Aphididae). Bull. Ent. 8 (2) :
143-157.
& Banerjee, S. N. (1958):
Aphids of Economic plants of West
Bengal. Indian Agric. 2(2): 87-112.
& Hille Ris Lambers, D.
(1968) : One new genus and three new
species of Indian aphids. Ent. Ber.
28(1): 7-14.
Basu, R. C., Chakravarti, S. &
Raychaudhuri, D. N. (1968) : Sexuales
of Aphis craccivora Koch (Homoptera :
Aphididae) recorded for the first time
from India. Oriental Insects. 2: 249-351 .
Behura, B. K. (1963) : Aphids of
India : A survey of published infor-
mation. Proc. First Summer School
of Zoology (Simla, 1961) : 25-78.
Bodenheimer, F. S. & Swriski, E.
(1957) : The Aphidoidea of the Middle
East. Weizmann Science Press of Israel,
378 pp.
Buckton, G. B. (1896a) : A new gall
making aphid. Indian Mus. Notes 3(1) :
71-73 (1893).
(1896b) : Notes on Indian
aphids, ibid. 3 (2) : 87-88 (1893).
,(1897): Notes on two new
species of gall aphids from the North
Western Himalayan region, ibid. 4(2) :
50-51 (1894).
(1899a) : Pear tree aphis —
Lachnus pyri Buckton. ibid. 4(5) : 274-
276.
(1899b) : Notes on two new
species of aphids, ibid. 4(5) : 277-278.
Carver, M. (1965) : Two new species
of Micromyzus van der Goot 1917
(Homoptera : Aphididae). Proc. R. ent.
Soc. London (B) 34 (9-10) : 113-116.
— & Basu, A. N. (1961) : A
new species of Tetraneura Hartig. ibid.
30 : 83-84.
Chowdhuri, A. N., Basu, R. C.,
Chakrabarti, S. & Raychaudhuri, D.N
(1968) : A list of aphids of Simla includ-
ing some new and few hitherto not known
from India. Sci. & Cult. 34(3): 133-134.
Cotes, E. C. (1891a) : Miscellaneous
notes. Indian Mus. Notes 1(4) : 208.
(1891b) : Miscellaneous
notes, ibid. 2(1) : 34-35.
(1893) : A conspectus of
insects which affect crop pests in India,
ibid. 2(6) : 167.
(1896) : Miscellaneous notes.
Indian Mus. Notes.
Das, B. (1918) : The Aphididae of
Lahore. Mem. Indian Mus. 6 : 135-274.
224 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
David, S. K. (1954a) : Synonymy
of aphids listed from Coimbatore,
Indian J. Ent. 15(4) : 293-296.
(1954b) : Rhopalosiphoninus
latisiphon (Davidson) — A new record
from India, ibid. 16(2) : 196.
(1956a) : Notes on South
Indian Aphids I. Descriptions of four
new species, ibid., 18(1) : 1-9.
& Hille Ris Lambers, D.
(1956b) : Notes on South Indian Aphids
II. Sexual forms in Schoutedenia Rubsa-
mann. ibid. 18(1) : 41-44.
— (1956c) : Taxonomic notes
on six species of Mysore aphids described
as new by Theobald in 1929. ibid. 18(2) :
141-145.
(1956d) : Additions to the
aphid fauna of India. J. Bombay nat.
Hist. Soc. 53 : 479-482.
— (1956e) : Additional notes
on some aphids in Madras State.
Madras agric. J., 43(3) : 103-107.
(1958a) : Notes on South
Indian Aphids III. Lachninae to Aphi-
dinae (Part). Indian J. Ent . 19(3) :
171-180. (1957).
(1958b) : Notes on South
Indian Aphids IV. Aphidinae (cont.).
ibid. 19(4) : 289-299. (1957).
(1958c) : Some rare Indian
aphids. J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc.
55(1) : 110-116.
(1958d) : New genus and
three new species of Aphids from India.
Indian J. Ent. 20(3) : 175-180.
(1959) : Notes on South
Indian aphids V. Greenidinae, Thelaxi-
nae and Eriosomatinae. ibid. 20(2) :
124-129. (1958).
(1967) : in Aphidologisf s
newsletter . 6(2) : 7.
— , Rajasingh, S. G. &
Narayanan, K. (1967) : The rusty plum
aphid, Hysteroneura setariae (Thomas)
in Southern India. J. Bombay nat.
Hist. Soc. 64(2): 380-381.
Deshpande, V. G. (1937) : A prelimi-
nary account of Aphidoidea of Poona.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 34(4) : 740-744.
Doncaster, J. P. (1956) : Two aphids
from the Indian region. Proc. R. ent.
Soc. London (B). 25(7-8) : 11 1-1 16.
(1966) : Notes on some
Indian aphids described by G. B.
Buckton. Entomologist 98 : 157-160.
Eastop, V. F. (1966) : A taxonomic
study of Australian Aphidoidea (Homo-
ptera). Aust. J. Zool. 14 : 399-592.
Fletcher, T. B. (1914) : Some South
Indian Insects. Madras. 499-507
(Aphids).
— — - — — (1920) : Annotated list of
Indian crop pests. Proc. 3rd ent. Meet-
ing, Pusa 1 : 279-286.
George, C. J. (1924) : Root sucking
aphids of Coimbatore. J. Asiat. Soc.
Bengal, (N.S.)20 : 308-311.
— (1927) : South Indian Aphi-
didae. ibid. 23 : 1-12.
Ghani, M. A. & Rao, V. P. (1966) :
Investigations on the Morphology,
Phenology & Biology of Adelges (Drey-
fusia) joshii (Schneider-Orelli & Schnei-
der) (Hem. : Adelgidae) in North West
Himalayan region (India & Pakistan).
Tech. Bull. Comm. Inst. Biol. Control
7: 1-58.
Ghosh, A. K. & Raychaudhuri, D. N.
(1962) : Schoutedenia bougainvilleae
(Theobald) : Redescription and its
synonyms. J. Asiat. Soc. Bengal 4(1) :
1-4.
- & (1962a): A
preliminary account of the bionomics
and taxonomy of aphids from Assam.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 59(1) : 238-
253.
& _ (1962b) : A
preliminary account of bionomics and
taxonomy of aphids from Assam II.
J. Asiat. Soc. Bengal 4 (3-4) : 101-113.
& (1962c) : Sexual
form of Myzus persicae (Sulz.) (Homo-
ptera : Aphididae) from Delhi. Sci. &
Cult. 28: 539-540.
& (1968): New
aphids from North East India. Ann .
Ent. Soc. Amer. 61(3) : 752-755.
— - — - — & (1968a) : Aphids
of Sikkim. Proc. Zool. Soc. Calcutta.
21 : 179-195.
& (1968b): Two new
records of aphids from India. Bull. Ent.
9 (2) : 147-148.
Goot, P. van der (1916) : On some
undescribed aphids from the collection of
the Indian Museum. Rec. Indian Mus.
12(1) : 1-4.
(1917) : Notes on some
Indian aphids, ibid. 13(4): 175-183.
(1918) : Aphididae of
Ceylon. Spolia Zeyl. 11(40) : 70-75.
Hille Ris Lambers, D. (1933) A new
genus and some new species of aphids.
Sty lops 2 : 197-201.
(1965) : On some Japanese
Aphididae (Homoptera : Aphididae).
Tijdschr. Ent. 108(7) : 189-203.
(1966) : New and little
known aphids from Pakistan (Homo-
ptera, Aphididae). ibid. 109(8) : 193-220.
& Basu, A. N. (1966):
Some new or little known genera, sub-
genera, species and subspecies of Aphi-
didae from India (Homoptera, Aphididae)
Ent. Ber. 26: 12-20, 27-36.
Judenko, E. & Eastop, V. F. (1963) :
A list of Sinhalese aphids. (Hem. &
Aphididae). Entom. mon. Mag. 99 :
62-63.
APHIDS FROM INDIA AND ADJACENT COUNTRIES
225
Krishnamurti, B. (1930) : Aphididae
of Mysore II. J. Bombay nat. Hist.
Soc. 34(2) : 411-419.
(1950) : Aphididae of
Mysore III. Indian J. Ent. 10(1) :
51-53. (1948).
Kulkarny, H. L. (1956): Trifidaphis
gossypii. sp. nov.anew species of aphid
pest in Bombay, Karnatak. Curr. Sci.
25(1) : 21.
Lefroy, H. M. & Howlett, F. M.
(1909) : Indian Insect Life. Calcutta.
786 pp.
Menon, M. G. & Pa war, J. G.
(1957) : Taxonomic studies of the Indian
Aphididae I. Additions to the aphid
fauna of Delhi. Proc. 45 th lnd. Sci.
Cong. 3 : 348.
Patel, G. A. & Kulkarny, H. R.
(1952) : Cerciaphis emblica sp. nov. a
new aphid pest on Emblica officinalis.
Curr. Sci. 21(12) : 350.
Pintera, A. (1965) : Two new species
of Lachnidae in the collection of British
Museum (Hemiptera : Aphididae).
Entomologist 98 : 60-63.
Raychaudhuri, D. N. (1956) :
Revision of Greenidea and related
genera (Homoptera : Aphididae). Zool.
Verb. Leiden. 31 : 1-106.
— — — — & Ghosh, A. K. (1959) :
A preliminary account of aphids of
Rajasthan. Indian Agric. 3(1) : 17-22.
& (1964) : Addi-
tions to the aphid fauna of North East
India. Zool. Meded. 39 : 257-262.
Schneider-Orelli, O. & Schneider,
F. (1954) : Dreyfusia Befall on Abies
pindrow in Nordwesthimalaya. Mitt.
Schweiz, ent. Ges. 27 : 413-422.
& (1959) : Weitere
Untersuchungen uber Dreyfusia-Befall
im Nordwesthimalaya. ibid. 32 : 258-
270.
StebbiNg, E. P. (1904) : Life history
of Chermes abietispiceae Stebb. J.
Asiat. Soc. Bengal, (N.S.) 72 : 229-235.
(1910) : On the life history
of Chermes himalayensis Stebb. on spruce
( Piceae morinda) and silver-fir ( Abies
webbiana). Trans. Linn. Soc. London 11 :
99-124.
Stroyan, H. L. G. (1963) : A new
species of Protrama Baker from North
Western India. Indian J. Ent. 26(3) :
211-214.
(1963) : A new genus and
species of Eriosomatinae (Homoptera :
Aphidiodea). Proc. R. ent. Soc. London
(B) . 32 : 81-85.
— & Nagaich, B. B.
(1964) : A new subspecies of Acyrtho-
siphon Mordwilko 1914 from Rubus ellip-
ticus in North India, ibid. 33 (3-4) :
59-62.
Takahashi, R. (1965) : Myzus of
Japan (Aphididae). Mushi, 38(9) : 43-
78.
Theobald, F. V. (1929) : Some aphids
from southern India with descriptions of
six new species. Entomologist 62(795) :
177-181, (796): 196-201.
Trehan, K. N. & Halleppnawar,
N. L. (1949) : Life history, bionomics and
control of safflower aphid, ( Macrosiphum
jaceae L.). Curr. Sci. 18(6) : 211-212.
Verma, K. D. (1965) : Additions to
the aphid fauna of North West India.
Sci. & Cult. 31(7) : 389.
(1966) : The Aphididae of
North West India with special reference
to the aphids of Jammu & Kashmir.
Ph.D. Thesis, J. & K. University.
(1966a) : A new aphid from
North Western India. Indian J. Ent.
28(2) : 265-267.
(1966b) : A new aphid genus
from North Western India, ibid. 28(4) :
507-509.
& Mathur, A. C. (1966) :
First record of two species and
males of Lipaphis pseudobrassicae Davis
and Protrama penecaecae Stroyan from
India, ibid. 28(2) : 277-285.
Westwood, J. O. (1890) : On a species
of Aphideous insects infesting the bread
fruit trees in Ceylon. Trans R. ent.
Soc. London (B) 4 : 649-65 1 .
On the Specificity of Madras Backwater
Oyster Crassostrea madrasensis Preston
and the American Oyster Crassostrea
virginica Gmelin1
BY
V. S. Durve2
Central Regional Station , Zoological Survey of India , Jabalpur
( With two text-figures)
Several conchological and malacological characters were studied in two
oysters viz-, Crassostrea madrasensis Preston and Crassostrea virginica Gmelin,
to find out whether they are synonymous as indicated by earlier workers.
The studies indicate that these are two distinct species though apparently of
close similarity.
Introduction
Whatever little is known about the systematics of oysters of the Indian
coast is confusing. Recently the author (Durve 1967) attempted to clarify
this confusion and place the two well-known backwater oysters of India
into two distinct species namely Crassostrea madrasensis Preston and
Crassostrea gryphoides (Schlotheim) . However, this work does not clarify
the position of C. madrasensis as a synonym of the American oyster C.
virginica Gmelin, as opined by Yredenburg and reported by Annandale
and Kemp (1916) and also by Hornell (1918, 1949 and 1951).
Preston (1916) had, of course, observed the close similarity between
C. madrasensis and C. virginica (=Ostrea canadensis LK.) but noted that
the Indian backwater oyster (C. madrasensis ) is of a straighter form and
thinner texture and is much foliaceous externally. The left valve is more
concave and the inner margins of both valves as well as the muscular
scars are of a dark purple colour. He thus considered the Madras oyster
as a distinct species namely O. (C.) madrasensis . Gravely (1941) and
Satyamurthi (1955) supported the identification by Preston. In view of
this controversy, it was felt desirable to study the conchologica1 and mala-
1 Accepted June 25, 1969.
2 Present address : Division of Limnology and Fisheries, University of Udaipur,
Udaipur (Rajasthan).
MADRAS BACKWATER OYSTER AND AMERICAN OYSTER 111
cological characters of C. madrasensis and C. virginica to establish the
correct identity of the former.
A sample of C. virginica was obtained from the U.S. Shellfish Advisory
Service. The soft parts of this sample of 4 medium-sized oysters were
received preserved in Davidson’s fixative while their shells came dry,
cleaned and properly numbered. Though the sample was small, there
is a considerable literature available on this oyster which could be pro-
fitably used for the present study. A sample of twelve specimens of
C. madrasensis from Ennore backwaters near Madras was obtained from
the Southern Regional Station of the Zoological Survey of India. In
all 28 different characters both from the shell and soft parts of C. madras-
ensis and C. virginica were studied and compared. All the measure-
ments reported in this paper have been taken by a vernier calliper and
fine mathematical divider.
Observations and Remarks
There is a diversity of opinion regarding the validity of any character
in a highly variable form like an oyster. It is well known that the so-
called diagnostic characters of oysters undergo considerable changes
due to the environment ; with the result, at times, the same species passes
under several names. However, recently, there have been attempts to
standardize these characters. In spite of this, the so-called generally
constant characters do show deviations. For instance, the deep cup-
shaped nature of the left (lower) valve has been generally reckoned as a
diagnostic character ; but the author has seen this being altered due to
the environment such as bottom contour, surf beaten coast-line with ex-
posed or semi-exposed rocks etc. Galtsoff (1964) states 4 size, shape,
curvature and proportion of the beak i.e., the pointed (dorsal) end of an
oyster shell, are useful generic characters, but like other parts of the shell
they are variable and cannot be entirely depended upon for identification.’
He also states 4 the position of the muscle scar and its outline differs in
various species and therefore, is used as a taxonomic character.’ But,
records considerable variations in the scar shapes in the individuals of
the same species i.e., C. virginica. The author has also observed
differences in the scar-shapes in the specimens collected from the same
locality but different substrata. However, it is felt that the scars in
general may show some constancy in shape which could perhaps be
specific.
Thomson (1954) and Galtsoff (op. cit.) observed that the soft anatomy
of the oyster is not very variable but its taxonomic usefulness is limited.
However, Thomson found several characters of the soft anatomy useful in
his work on Australian oysters. The usefulness of the different concho-
logical and malacological characters in the classification of oysters has
228 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
been well discussed by Thomson and GaltsofF. So far as the oysters of
the present investigation are concerned, it was possible to separate some
characters out of 28 examined ; which showed appreciable differences
leading to the understanding of the species.
The following characters were found to differ appreciably in C.
virginica and C. madrasensis though in the case of some characters there
was slight similarity in a few individuals.
Conchological characters Malacological characters
1. External sculpture on the right
(upper) valve.
2. Coloration of the external surface of
the shell.
3. Internal coloration of the shell-valves.
4. The recess below the beak of the left
(lower) valve and its depth.
5. The shape and colour of the muscle-
scar.
6. The width and depth of the hinge-
area (beak) groove in the lower
valve.
7. The colour of hinge ligament.
1. The shape of adductor muscle.
2. The position of anal opening in
relation to the adductor muscle.
3. The nature of anal opening.
These characters are dealt with separately below.
Conchological Characters
1. External sculpture on the right {upper) valve :
The sculpture of the shell is a greatly variable character depending
on local conditions. In oysters of the present study, it was found that
C. madrasensis was much more foliaceous externally than C. virginica .
The extent of growth fringes in both the species varied considerably in
different specimens. The comparison of the external sculpture of C.
virginica when made with C. madrasensis collected from Athankarai
estuary near Mandapam also confirmed the earlier inference. Galtsoff
(1964) states that the external sculpture in the American oyster varies
greatly and supports this by a few figures of this oyster collected from
different localities on the coast of America.
2. Coloration of the external surface of the shell :
While no taxonomic significance is attached by Galtsoff (op. cit.)
to the external coloration, Thomson (op. cit.) states, 4 For each species
there is a range of pigment patterns and a range of shades of colour
from which specimens do not vary though they may overlap the range
MADRAS BACKWATER OYSTER AND AMERICAN OYSTER 229
of another species.’ Iredale (1939) attempted to use coloration for
taxonomic purpose.
In the case of C. madrasensis , the pattern of coloration ranged from
one uniform colour to the various mixtures of 3-4 different colours,
patches of one or more colours to their localization on different portions
of the surface. In the case of C. madrasensis , the normal colours are
purple, white, brown and their various shades. The white colour is
invariably restricted to the top surface of the right valve and also the
sides of the left valve which may be due to the bleaching of this portion by
sunlight in the case of exposed or semi-exposed specimens. The purple
colour is generally in the form of suffusion and at times in patches or
streaks. The brown colour is invariably restricted to the growth fringes.
In C. virginica , white and brown or blackish-brown colours are pre-
dominant. The purplish shade is slight and is obliterated by blackish-
brown shade. Sides of the lower valve are white with brownish and purple
shades.
3. Internal coloration of the shell-valves :
Internal coloration, according to Thomson (op. cit.), is specifically
constant. He feels that there may be only one colour or ranges of a few
shades characteristic of each species.
In C. madrasensis the internal coloration is white but almost always
it has purple around the whole or part of the margin. This coloration
is absent in the middle portion of both the valves and also near the
hinge region. The coloration ranges from light pink-purple and deep
purple to almost black. The deeper colour is invariably restricted
to the ventral margin facing the posterior portion of the gill, especially
in the case of the lower valve. The purple coloration is generally
about 5 to 10 mm inside from the edge of the shell. Thus a strip of 5
to 10 mm left towards the edge is almost invariably pure white and nacre-
ous. The purple coloration of the margin appears to be a constant
feature of this species as it was also noticed in the case of specimens
collected from Athankarai estuary near Mandapam.
In the case of C. virginica, the internal coloration is pure white or
nacreous white with yellowish patches here and there only in some
specimens.
4. The recess below the beak of the left {lower) valve and its depth :
The recess below the hinge of the lower valve has been known to be
of taxonomic value. In C. madrasensis, the recess beneath the beak is
invariably very well developed. In specimens examined for the present
study, it ranged from 2 to 10 mm in depth. Individuals having the recess
depth of more than 2 mm were in majority. In C. virginica the maxi-
mum depth of the recess recorded in the sample received from U.S.A.
was 4*00 mm and the minimum Was TOO mm.
230 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
5. The shape and colour of the muscle scar :
The shape and colour of the adductor impression varies with species.
There is a variation even in the individuals of the same species. How-
ever, the general shape and coloration could be regarded as more or less
constant for any species. In C. madrasensis , the shape of the scar varies
with the individual but is either elliptical, transversely broad or oblong ;
the last two being more or less overlapping. In case the scar is roundish
in any specimen, its one end will invariably taper to a blunt point. Only
in rare cases a broad bean-shaped scar occurs. Its colour is always more
or less deep black. No light bands or patches have so far been noticed
by the author on the scar.
On the other hand, the shape of the scar in the case of C. virginica
is almost roundish, somewhat bean-shaped with the dorsal margin of
the scar having slight concavity in the centre. The differences in the
dimensions of the scars from both the valves in these two oysters are thus
obvious. Galtsoff (op. cit.) however states that the shape of the muscle
scar in C. virginica is a variable character and to some extent reflects
the shape of the shell. The colour of the scar in C. virginica is light to
deep purple but never deep black as in C. madrasensis. The colour may
be uniformly purple or deep purple bands may alternate with lighter
bands. At times, the colour is splotched with lighter sprinklings.
6. The width and depth of the hinge area groove in the lower valve :
From the casual observation of the shells of C. madrasensis and C.
virginica , it was felt that the groove in the centre of the beak or hinge
area is narrow and shallow in the case of the former. When the actual
measurements were taken it was found that narrowness of the hinge area
groove is not specific. However, its depth though could not be measured,
appeared to be constantly more in the case of C. virginica when compared
with that of C. madrasensis.
7. The colour of hinge ligament :
The significance of the ligament in the systematics of bivalves in
general has been studied by Bowerbank (1844), Jackson (1890, 1891),
Dali (1889, 1895), Biedermann (1902) and others. The entire work in
this direction has been well reviewed by Haas (1935). Recently,
Thomson (op. cit.) made use of this character to separate two well-known
Australian oysters namely C. commercialis and C. tuberculata. Galtsoff
(1964) makes no mention of the significance of this character in the
taxonomy of oysters.
In the case of C. madrasensis , the colour of the ligament was observed
to be invariably black at two ends but brown in the central bulging por-
tion. However, slight variations were also noticed in some oysters. In
C. virginica , the ligament was found to be black in all the specimens of
MADRAS BACKWATER OYSTER AND AMERICAN OYSTER 231
the sample except one, where it was brownish-black in the central bulging
portion. This character may perhaps prove to be of significance so far
as the systematics of these two oysters is concerned.
Malacological Characters
8. The shape of the adductor muscle :
The adductor muscle does not have the taxonomic significance.
Thomson (op. cit.) used the relative proportions of the catch and quick
areas of this muscle for the separation of genera. However, Hopkins
(1930) has reported that this ratio of catch and quick areas with each
other depends on ecological conditions.
The shape of the adductor muscle was found to be more or less con-
stant in two species of oysters studied for this investigation. It was
either elliptical or oblong in the case of C. madrasensis and almost
round — slightly flat and concaved on the dorsal margin, in the case of
C. virginica.
9. The position of anal opening in relation to adductor muscle :
This feature was found to differ in the two oysters under investi-
gation. Along with the position of the anal opening, the size of the
rectum differs. It was noticed that the size of the rectum (from the
dorsal margin of the adductor to the anal opening) is more in the case of
C. madrasensis than in C. virginica except in one or two specimens. The
position of the anus also differs. In C. madrasensis , the opening is
always invariably situated about the middle of the ventral margin of the
adductor muscle while in C. virginica , it is at the comer of the posterior
and ventral margins of the adductor (Fig. 1). This character has not
so far been used in the systematics of oysters.
r — Rectum ; adm — Adductor muscle ; an — Anus.
4
232 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
10. The nature of anal opening :
This character appeared to be strikingly different in the two oysters
viz., C. madrasensis and C. virginica. In the case of former, the open-
ing is not simple. The wall of the anus is extra-ordinarily thickened
and turned backwards forming a sort of collar to the anal opening. This
collar is thinner at one end of the anal opening forming a small notch
(Fig. 2). This collar is not always tightly folded but at times is loose and
lessens in width at one end giving an appearance of a valve-like structure
attached to the anus. The collar was noticed to have folds and lobed
appearance in two specimens. The three varieties of collars observed in
the sample of 12 specimens of C. madrasensis have been figured in Fig. 2.
Only in one individual the anus was observed to be simple. In the case
of C. virginica , the anus is simple, without any collar. This character
has also not so far been used in the systematics of oysters.
Fig. 2. Anal opening in C. madrasensis.
A — Anal opening ; B — Collar.
From the account given above, it could be noticed that the two oysters
viz., C. madrasensis and C. virginica which were earlier considered as
synonymous by some workers have several striking differences which
could separate them into two distinct species. These differences have
been tabulated below.
CONCHOLOGICAL CHARACTERS
C. madrasensis C. virginica
1 . More foliaceous externally. Less foliaceous externally.
2. More variously coloured externally. Less coloured externally.
MADRAS BACKWATER OYSTER AMD AMERICAN OYSTER 233
3. Purple suffusion or streak around the
internal margins and especially
in the region opposite the posterior
portion of the gills.
4. The recess beneath the hinge area
(beak) in the lower valve invariably
very well-developed.
5. The shape of the muscle scar is gene-
rally elliptical or oblong.
6. Colour of the muscle scar almost deep
black.
7. The central groove of the hinge area
shallow.
Internal surface pure white.
The recess not very well-developed.
The shape of the muscle scar generally
reniform (bean-shaped) or even
roundish.
Colour of the muscle scar ranges from
light to deep purple but never deep
black.
The central groove of the hinge area
comparatively deep.
8. Colour of the ligament is black at sides Colour of the ligament is generally black
but brown in the central bulging throughout,
portion.
Malacological Characters
9. The adductor muscle is either ellip-
tical or oblong.
10. The size of rectum generally large.
11 Anal opening situated about the
middle of the ventral margin of
the adductor muscle.
The adductor muscle is either roundish
or bean-shaped.
The size of rectum generally small.
Anal opening situated at the corner of
the posterior and ventral margins of
the adductor muscle.
In view of the above differences in two oysters viz., C. madrasensis
and C. virginica, the description of the former given by the author (Durve
1967) could be slightly amended in respect of the development of the
recess beneath the hinge-area (beak) of the lower valve. When the
type of C. madrasensis was compared with the type of C. gryphoides var.
cuttackensis, the recess in the former was found to be less developed than
in the latter. In the present investigation, this recess in C. madrasensis
Was noticed to be better developed when compared with its counterpart
in C. virginica. However, such a thing could be expected in a com-
parative study and does not alter the systematic position of the oysters.
Acknowledgements
I am grateful to Mr. J. B. Engle, Chief, U.S. Shellfish Advisory
Service, Maryland, U.S.A., for supplying the sample of Crassostrea
virginica. I am also grateful to Dr. K. Reddiah, of the Southern
234 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vot. 71 (2)
Regional Station of the Zoological Survey of India, for supplying
the sample of Crassostrea madrasensis . Thanks are also due to
Shri H. Khajuria, Officer-in -charge of the Central Regional Station,
Zoological Survey of India, for giving facilities for the completion of
this work.
References
AnNandale, N. & Kemp, S. (1916):
Fauna of Chilka lake. Mem. Indian
Mus. 5(4) : 348-349.
Biedermann, W. (1902) : Untersuch-
ungen uber Bau und Entstehung der
Molluskenschalen. Jenaische Jenai-
sche Zeitschrift fur Naturwissenschaft,
Neue Folge, Band 29 : 1-164.
Bowerbank, J. S. (1844) : On the
structure of the shell of molluscus and
conchiferous animals. Trans. Micr. Soc.
London 1 : 123-154.
Dall, W. H. (1889) : On the hinge of
Pelecypods and its development with an
attempt towards a better subdivision of
the group. Amer. J. Sci ., Sr. 3, 38 :
445-462.
(1895) : Contribution to the
tertiary fauna of Florida, with special
reference to the Miocene silex-beds of
the Caloosahatchie river. Part III. A
new classification of the Pelecypoda.
Trans. Wag. Free Inst. Sci. Phila. 3, pt.
3 : 479-570.
Durve, V. S. (1967) : On the nomen-
clature of two Indian backwater oysters.
J. Mar. biol. Ass. India 9(1) : 173-178.
Galtsoff, P. S. (1964) : The American
Oyster Crassostrea virginica Gmelin.
U.S. Fish. Bull. 64.
Gravely, F. H. (1941) : Shells and
other animal remains found on the
Madras beach. Bull. Madras Govt.
Mus. N.S.— Natural History section
5(1).
Hass, F. (1935) : Bivalvia. Teil 1.
Dr. H. G. Bronns Klassen und Ordnun-
gen des Tierreichs. Band 3 : Mollusca ;
Abteilung 3 : Bivalvia, Akademische
Verlagsges ellschaft, Leipzig, 984 pp.
Hopkins, H. S. (1930) : Mascular
differentiation in oysters exposed for
diverse periods of time (Abstract).
Anat. Rec. 47(3) : 305.
Hornell, J. (1918): The edible
Molluscs of Madras Presidency. Bull.
Madras Fish. Dept. 11 : 12.
(1949) : The study of Indian
Molluscs, Pt. III. J. Bombay nat. Hist.
Soc. 48(4) : 750-774.
(1951) : Indian Molluscs.
Bombay Natural History Society, p. 58-
60.
Iredale, I. (1939) : Mollusca : Pt. I,
Sci. Rep. Gr. Barrier Reef Exped. 5(6) :
209-245.
Jackson, R. T. (1890) : Phylogeny of
the Pelecypoda. The aviculidae and
their allies. Mem. Boston Soc. Nat.
Hist. 4(8) : 277-400.
(1891) : The mechanical
origin of structure in Pelecypods. Amer.
nat. 25(289): 11-21.
Preston, H. B. (1916) : Report on a
collection of Mollusca from the Cochin
and Ennur backwaters. Rec. Indian
Mus. 12 : 27-39.
Satyamurti, S. T. (1956) : Mollusca
of Krusadai island (in the Gulf of
Mannar)— II— Scaphopoda, Pelecypoda
and Cephalopoda. Bull. Madras Govt.
Mus., N.S. — Natural History Section
1(2), Pt. 7 : 1-202.
Thomson, J. M. (1954) : The genera
of oysters and the Australian species.
Aust. J. Mar. Freshw. Res. 5(1) : 132-
168.
Flora of Mothronwala Swamp Forest
(District : Dehra Dun, U.P., India)
BY
K. M. M. Dakshini
Department of Botany , University of Delhi , Delhi-110001
[Continued from Vol. 67 (2) : 186]
SCROPHULARIACEAE
Mimulus strictus Benth. (3911)
Flowers — Throughout the year.
Limnophila rugosa (Rotht Merrill
(5558)
Flowers — July /August.
Bacopa monnieri (Linn.) Pennell
(7259)
Flowers — Almost throughout the
year.
Torenia cordifolia Roxb. (6247)
Flowers — August/September.
Lindernia Crustacea (Linn.) F.
Muell. (5591; 7258)
Flowers — August/September.
L. hookeri (Clarke) Wettst.
subsp. kumaunensis Pennell
(6247 A)
Flowers — October.
Note : A very rare plant.
L. cordifolia (Colsmann) Merrill
(5552 ; 5557)
Flowers — July/August.
L. ciliata (Colsmann) Pennell
(7257)
Flowers — July/August.
L. anagallis (N. L. Burm.) Pennell
var. grandiflora (Retz.) Muker-
jee (5565)
Flowers — August/September.
Veronica anagallis-aquatica Linn.
(3931 ; 6282)
Flowers — Throughout the cold
season.
Centranthera nepalensis D. Don
(5553)
Flowers — September/October.
Pedaliaceae
Sesamum indicum Linn. (5583)
Flowers — July/August .
Acanthaceae
Nelsonia canescens (Lamk.)
Spreng. (3935 ; 5520 ; 8016)
Flowers — February to June.
Hygrophila polysperma (Roxb.)
T. Anders. (5519 ; 8043)
Flowers — May/June.
H. salicifolia (Vahl) Nees (3930,
5527, 7276)
Flowers — March/April and July
to September,
236 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Eranthemum nervosum (Vahl)
R. Br. (3915 ; 8031)
Flowers — March/April.
Hemigraphis latebrosa Nees var.
heyneana Bran. (8010)
Flowers — January/February.
Barleria cristata Linn. (6261)
Flowers— September/October.
Lepidagathis incurva D. Don
(3927 ; 5499 ; 8018)
Flowers — December to March.
Justicia quinqueangularis Koen.
ex Roxb. (5478 ; 5525 ; 6242)
Flowers — June to September.
J. procumbens Linn. var. simplex
(D. Don) Yamazaki (6225,
7242)
Flowers — August/September.
Adhatoda vasica Nees (3928)
Flowers — March/April.
Rungia repens (Linn.) Nees
(3925 ; 6288)
Flowers — Cold season.
R. pectinata (Linn.) Nees (6251)
Flowers — September/October.
Dicliptera roxburghiana Nees
(3997)
Flowers — March to May.
Verbenaceae
Lantana camara Linn. var.
aculeata (Linn.) Moldenke
(3983)
Flowers — Most part of the year.
L. crenulata Otto & Dietr. (6295)
Flowers — Most part of the year.
Phyla nodiflora (Linn.) Greene
(5508)
Flowers — May/ June .
Callicarpa macrophylla Vahl
(3955)
Flowers — March /Apri 1 .
Premna latifolia Roxb. var.
mucronata (Roxb.) Clarke (8048)
Flowers — April/May.
Clerodendrum indicum (Linn.)
O. Ktze. (7233)
Flowers — August/ September .
C. viscosum Vent. (3921)
Flowers — February to May.
C. serratum (Linn.) Moon (5590)
Flowers — August/September.
Caryopteris wallichiana Schauer
(3954)
Flowers — February to April.
Labiatae
Acrocephalus indicus (Burm.)
O. Ktze. (6217; 8068; 8069)
Flowers — September/October.
Orthosiphon rubicundus Benth.
(5539)
Flowers — June/July.
Plectranthus japonicus (Burm.
f.) Koidz. (8799)
Flowers — October to December.
Colebrookea oppositifolia Smith
(8005)
Flowers — January/February.
Mosla dianthera (Buch.-Ham. ex
Roxb.) Maxim. (5526, 7269)
Flowers — June to September,
FLORA OF MOTHRONWALA SWAMP FOREST
237
Nepeta hindostana (Roth) Haines
(6219)
Flowers — Augus t/ September .
Anisomeles indica(Linn.) O. Ktze.
(8084)
Flowers — December.
Leucas lanata Benth. (3994)
Flowers — April to June.
L. mollissima Wall. (7282)
Flowers — August/September.
L. nutans Spreng. (5584)
Flowers — August.
Teucrium stoloniferum Roxb.
(5517)
Flowers — May/ June .
Ajuga bracteosa Wall, ex Benth.
(7238)
Flowers — July to September.
Nyctaginaceae
Boerhaavia diffusa Linn. (7240)
Flowers — August to November.
Amaranthaceae
Celosia argentea Linn. (6257 ;
8012)
Flowers — October to January.
Amaranthus spinosus Linn. (5568)
Flowers — July/August.
Aerva sanguinolenta (Linn.)
Blume (3981)
Flowers — March/May.
Achyranthes aspera Linn. (8086)
Flowers — September to Novem-
ber,
A. bidentata Blume (7275)
Flowers — August/September.
Alternanthera sessilis (Linn.)
DC. (5566)
Flowers — July/September.
POLYGONACEAE
Polygonum plebejum R. Br. (3916)
Flowers— Cold season.
P. stagninum Buch.-Ham. ex
Meissn. (5513; 8075; 8078;
12484 ; 5528)
Flowers — August to November.
P. barbatum Linn, subsp. gracile
Danser (5504)
Flowers — April to June.
P. hydropiper Linn. (8074 ;
5547)
Flowers — August to November.
Lauraceae
Persea odoratissima (Nees) Kos-
term. (3958)
Flowers — March/April.
P. gamblei (King ex Hook, f.)
Kosterm. (8026)
Flowers — March.
Phoebe lanceolata Nees (8039)
Flowers — Late March/Late April.
Elaeagnaceae
Elaeagnus conferta Roxb. (3910)
Flowers — November to January,
238 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Euphorbiaceae
Euphorbia hypericifolia Linn.
(5587)
Flowers — July to September.
E. hirta Linn. (5569)
Flowers — Throughout the year.
E. dracunculoides Lamk. (5536)
Flowers — June/July.
Phyllanthus urinaria Linn. (7234)
Flowers — Cold season.
P. virgatus J. G. Forst. (6267)
Flowers — September/ October .
Bischofia javanica Blume (3901 ;
3902)
Flowers — March. Fruits — Ripen
in June.
Antidesma diandrum Roth (5521)
Flowers — May/ J une .
Note : Leaves have an acid
taste.
Mallotus philippensis (Lamk.)
Muell.-Arg. (3945)
Flowers — November to January ;
Fruits — April/May.
Baliospermum montanum (Willd.)
Muell.-Arg. (8046)
Flowers — April to June.
Sapium sebiferum (Linn.) Roxb.
(3995)
Flowers — May/ June .
Urticaceae
(Inch Moraceae)
Broussonetia papyrifera Vent.
(1799)
Flowers — June/ July,
Morus alba Linn. (8024)
Flowers — March / April .
Ficus gibbosa Blume var. cuspids* -
fera Miq. (8092)
Receptacles ripen during January
to March.
F. rumphii Blume (8096 A)
Receptacles ripen during May /
June.
F. religiosa Linn. (3999)
Receptacles ripen during March
to May.
F. arnottiana Miq. (8096 B)
Receptacles ripen during July.
F. hispida Linn. f. (3968, 8033)
Receptacles ripen April onwards.
F. semicordata Buch.-Ham. (8096
C)
Receptacles ripen during August/
September.
F. hederacea Roxb. (5492)
Receptacles ripen during rainy
season.
F. palmata Forsk. (8096)
Receptacles ripen during July
and October.
F. auriculata Lour. (8096 D)
Receptacles ripen during rainy
season.
F. racemosa Linn. (8096 E)
Receptacles ripen during April
to July.
Maclura cochinchinensis (Lour.)
Corner (3944)
Flowers — March to May; Fruits —
September to November,
FLORA OF MOTHRONWALA SWAMP FOREST
239
Elatostema cuneatum Wight (7283)
Flowers — August/ September .
Boehmeria platyphylla D. Don
(7293)
Flowers— September/October.
Pouzolzia pentandra Benn. (5524)
Flowers — May to July.
Salicaceae
Salix tetrasperma Roxb. (6245 ;
6278 ; 8072)
Flowers — September/ October.
Orchidaceae
Eulophia flava (Lindl. ex Royle)
Hook. f. (553 ; 8050)
Flowers — June.
Zeuxine strateumatica (Linn.)
Schlechter (8014)
Flowers — February.
Habenaria commelinifolia Wall.
ex Lindl. (7249)
Flowers — August/September.
H. diphylla Dalz. (5579)
Flowers — August.
Peristylus lawii Wight (5580)
Flowers — August.
ZlNGIBERACEAE
Globba orixensis Roxb. (5582)
Flowers — August.
Curcuma angustifolia Roxb.
(5518)
Flowers — June,
C. longa Linn. (7262)
Flowers — August.
Hedychium coronarium Koen. ex
Retz. (5570)
Flowers — May/June.
Zingiber roseum Rose. (5477)
Flowers — November.
Costus speciosus Smith (5563)
Flowers — July/August.
Alpinia bracteata Roxb. (7261)
Flowers — August.
Hypoxidaceae
Curculigo orchioides Gaertn.
(5542)
Flowers — July.
Dioscoreaceae
Dioscorea belophylla Voigt (6271,
8065)
Flowers — October.
D. bulbifera Linn. (5562 ; 8057)
Flowers — August to October.
D. pentaphylla Linn. (7272)
Flowers — Augus t/ September .
Liliaceae
Smilax glaucophylla Klotzsch
(5489 ; 6226)
Fruits — November/December.
Asparagus adscendens Roxb.
(5544 ; 6294)
Flowers — October to December.
Gagea reticulata Schultes f.
(8091)
Flowers — February.
240 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Gloriosa superba Lina. (12486)
Flowers — January/February.
COMMELINACEAE
Commelina benghalensis Linn.
(7243)
Flowers — July to September.
C. paludosa Blume (5570 ; 8056)
Flowers — July/August .
Murdannia scapiflorum (Roxb.)
Royle (5545)
Flowers — July.
M. nudiflorum (Linn.) Brenan
(5581)
Flowers — August.
Floscopa scandens Lour. (3971 ;
6260)
Flowers — September/October
and also March/April.
Juncaceae
Juncus bufonius Linn. (8020)
Flowers — February.
Palmae
Calamus tenuis Roxb. (7292)
Flowers — September.
Araceae
Arisaema tortuosum (Wall.)
Schott (5555)
Flowers — July/ August.
Remusatia vivipara Schott (7232)
Flowers — August/September.
Acorus calamus Linn. (3904)
Flowers — March to August.
Cyperaceae
Cyperus kyllingia Endl. (3972)
Flowers — April.
C. globosus Allioni (5532, 5511)
Flowers — M ay/ June .
C. iria Linn. (8100)
Flowers — August/September.
C. distans Linn. f. (5596)
Flowers — J uly/August .
C. nutans Vahl (3985 ; 5561 ;
6286)
Flowers — May to October.
C. pilosus Vahl (5529)
Flowers — July to September.
C. rotundus Linn. [5600 (2)]
Flowers — August to October.
C. cyperoides (Linn.) O. Ktze.
(5557)
Flowers — July/ August .
Fimbristylis dichotoma (Linn).
Vahl (5531)
Flowers — June to October.
Scirpus erectus Poir. (6230)
Flowers — August/September.
Scleria tessellata Willd. (7263)
Flowers — August/September.
S. levis Retz. (7264; 5599)
Flowers — August/September.
Carex fedia Nees (3907 ; 8032 ;
8036)
Flowers — Throughout cold sea-
son,
FLORA OF MOTHRONWALA SWAMP FOREST
241
Gramineae
Paspalum scrobiculatum Linn.
(5550, 5560, 5575, 6296)
Flowers — July to October.
Digitaria adscendens (H.B.K.)
Hear. (8052, 8778)
Flowers — July to September.
Cyrtococcum patens (Linn.) A.
Camus (6229, 6266)
Flowers — September .
Echinochloa colonum (Linn.) Link
(5797 ; 5533)
Flowers — June to August.
E. crusgalli (Linn.) P. Beauv.
(5576 ; 5598 ; 6231)
Flowers— August/September.
Oplismenus compositus (Linn.) P.
Beauv. (6281)
Flowers — September to Novem-
ber.
Arundinella nepalensis Trin.
(6298, 8002, 8795)
Flowers — October /N ovember .
Setaria plicata (Lamk.) T. Cooke
(6300)
Flowers — October/November.
S. glauca (Linn.) P. Beauv. (5546 ;
5556)
Flowers — June to November.
Pennisetum orientate L. C. Rich.
(5597)
Flowers — July to September.
Coix lacryma-jobi Linn. (6232)
Flowers — August/September.
Chionachne koenigii (Spreng.)
Thw. (8003)
Flowers — Late December/
January.
Hemarthria compressa (Linn, f.)
R.Br. [5600 (1)]
Flowers — July/August .
Imperata cylindrica (Linn.) P.
Beauv. (3984, 5559)
Flowers — May to August.
I. cylindrica (Linn.) Beauv. var.
latifolia (Hook, f.) C. E. Hub-
bard (6276 ; 8796)
Flowers — October.
Saccharum spontaneum Linn.
(6233 ; 5498)
Flowers — September/October.
Narenga porphyrocoma (Hance)
Bor (8019)
Flowers — February.
Arthraxon prionodes (Steud.)
Dandy (8793)
Flowers — Late November /
December.
A. lancifolius (Trin.) Hochst.
(8070)
Flowers — October.
Apluda mutica Linn. (6252 ;
6269 ; 6287)
Flowers — August to November.
Rottboellia exaltata Linn. f.
(6280)
Flowers — September/October.
Capillipedium assimile (Steud.)
A. Camus (6285 ; 8004, 8087)
Flowers— September/October.
242 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Sorghum halepense (Linn.) Pers.
(6237)
Flowers — September.
Pseudosorghum fasciculare (Roxb.)
A. Camus (6283 ; 6299)
Flowers — October.
Vetiveria zizanioides (Linn.) Nash
(7265 ; 9794)
Flowers — August/September.
Dichanthium annulatum (Forsk.)
Stapf (8099)
Flowers — March/ April .
Themeda arundinacea (Roxb.)
Ridley (8001)
Flowers — January.
Polypogon monspeliensis (Linn.)
Desf. (3979 ; 3979 A)
Flowers — April to June.
Chrysopogon fulvus (Spreng.)
Chiov.
Flowers — August/September.
Eleusine indica (Linn.) Gaertn.
(8040)
Flowers — March/ April .
E. coracana (Linn.) Gaertn.
(6268)
Flowers — September/ October.
Arundo donax Linn. (6277A)
Flowers — September/October.
Phragmites communis Trin. var.
communis Bor (6277 ; 8076)
Flowers — October,
Eragrostis tenella (Linn.) P.
Beauv. ex Roem. et Schult.
(5530)
Flowers — June.
E. unioloides (Retz.) Nees ex
Steud. (5600 ; 8081)
Flowers — July to November.
E. gangetica (Roxb.) Steud.
(8009)
Flowers — Late January to
February.
Desmostachya bipinnata (Linn.)
Stapf (5549 ; 5574)
Flowers — July/August .
POLYPODIACEAE
Cheilanthes farinosa (Forsk.)
Kaulf. (7287)
Sori — August/September.
Adiantum caudatum Linn. (8041)
Sori — March/April .
A. philippense Linn. (7288)
Sori — August/September.
Diplazium esculentum (Retz. )Sw.
(5481 ; 8789; 6289)
Sori — October to December.
D. polypodioides Blume (7289)
Sori — August/September.
Dryopteris extensa (Blume) O.
Ktze. (5480)
Son— November/December,
FLORA OF MOTHRONWALA SWAMP FOREST
243
D. moulminensis (Bedd.) C. Chr.
(8792)
Sori — November.
D. prolifera (Retz.) C. Chr. (5485,
7290, 8782)
Sori — October to Dceember.
D. arida (Don) O. Ktze. (7284,
8008, 8781)
Sori — September to January.
D. papyracea (Bedd.) C. Chr.
(8059)
Sori — June/ July.
SCHIZEACEAE
Lygodium flexuosum (Linn.) Sw.
Sori — September.
In conclusion it may be indicated that in this swamp forest flora,
Malayan species dominate (120) and Leguminosae has the maximum
representation (51 species). Interestingly, the following species which
generally occur at higher altitudes (1500-2000 m) are also represen-
ted in this flora :
1. Acer oblongum Wall, ex DC.
2. Acr onychia pedunculata Miq.
3. Elaeagnus confer ta Roxb.
4. Gagea reticulata Schultes f.
5. Lindernia hookeri (Clarke) Wettst. subsp. kumaunensis Pennell.
6. Perse a gamblei (King ex Hook, f.) Kosterm.
7. P. odoratissima (Nees) Kosterm.
8. Phoebe lanceolata Nees.
9. Sabia paniculata Edgew.
10. Viola canescens Wall, ex Roxb.
Acknowledgements
This work was done during the tenure of a Government of India
Research Training Scholarship at the Botanical Survey of India, Northern
Circle, Dehra Dun. I am grateful to Dr. M. A. Rau, Regional Botanist,
and Prof. M. B. Raizada, Dehra Dun, for helpful suggestions and encour-
agement.
A Catalogue of the Birds in the
Collection of the Bombay Natural
History Society— 16
Capitonidae, Indicatoridae and Picidae (part)
BY
Humayun Abdulali
[Continued from Vol. 70 (2) : 345]
{With a sketch)
This part deals with 537 specimens of 48 species and subspecies.
Mr. S. A. Hussain, Research Assistant, helped with the measurements
and prepared the accompanying sketch.
777 Megalaima virens marshallorum Swinhoe (Himalayas) Himalayan
Great Barbet 4 : 106
16:7.c?<? (3 juv.) 7?$ 2o?
1 Kowar, Kistwar, Kashmir ;1 Kangra Dist., Punjab ; 1 Mashobra, Koti
State, 7 Simla Hills ; 1 Rampur, Guptakashi, Garhwal, 2 Almora; 3 no data.
Six specimens from Central and Eastern Bhutan, not yet registered,
have been examined and are referred to under the next subspecies,
No. 778.
3 juveniles all males obtained in July can be separated from the
adults by their smaller bills, and the yellowish green of the collar appear-
ing more scattered and lacking the streaked effect. The heads also show
a tinge of green.
dc?
$?
Wing Bill
143(2), 146, — 40,41,42
141-150 av. 145-8 40-41
(<J? 146-152 c. 46
Tarsus
32, 33, 34
29-33 av. 32
23
Tail
97, 98, 100
94-103 av. 100
100-109)
778 Megalaima virens magnifica Baker (Machi, Manipur) Assam
Great Barbet 4* 107 (part)
8:6cJ<J 2$$
1 Chalna Khel, Nepal ; 1 Kurseong ; 2 Temi, West Sikkim, 1 Sikkim
1 Humgrum, N. Cachar, 1 Naga Hills, 1 Margherita, Lakhimpur, Assam.
[258]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION— 16 245
As indicated under 777 , six unregistered specimens from Bhutan
have also been examined. All of them, as well as those listed above,
differ from marshallorum in showing more yellow on the underparts.
Those from Nepal, Kurseong, Sikkim, and Central Bhutan (1) differ
from those from Eastern Bhutan and Assam in having the brown of
the back and breast duller than in magnified , forming an intermediate
population which is included here in accordance with the distribution
in IND. HANDBOOK.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
33 140-148 av. 143 one 35, 40-45 29-33 av. 31 86-100
$$ 138,140,141,148 41,43,44(2) 31,32,33(2) 90,91,97,99
The measurements include those of the unregistered specimens from
Bhutan.
The amount of black on the bill increases eastwards into Bhutan, but
those from Margherita and Humgrum have only the tips black.
779 Megalaima virens mayri Ripley (Dreyi, Mishmi Hills, N.E.
Assam) Mishmi Great Barbet 4 : 107 (part)
nil.
EL Megalaima virens clamator Mayr (Shweli-Salween Divide, 8000' ,
Burma)
2 33 Nit. Victoria , Pakokku Hill Tracts, Burma.
Wing 148 ; bill 43, 44 ; tarsus 29, 32 ; tail 89, 95.
The bills are much heavier than indicated by the measurements.
The tertials do not appear to differ from those in magnified nor do
the bills show a greater amount of black ; but the almost complete
absence of the yellow streaks on the nape and the generally duller
plumage show a closer affinity to the description of clamator than to
magnified.
780 Megalaima zeylanica caniceps (Franklin) (On the Ganges between
Calcutta and Benares, and the Vindhiyan Hills between the latter place
and Gurrah Mundela on the Nerbudda) Northern Green Barbet 4:110
17:9 33 5 ?? 3 o ?
1 Madhopur, 1 Dharmasala, Punjab ; 1 Delhi ; 1 Chikalda, Berar ; 1 Anantagiri,
Vizagapatam ; 1 Kameli, Bailadila, 1 Basrur, 1 Amraoti, Bastar, M.P. ;
1 Chamundia, Daspalla, 1 Badrama, Bamra, 1 Koira, Bonai ; 1 Harbhanga
Bund, Orissa ; 1 Dehra Dun, 2 Pilibit Terai, U.P. ; 2 no data.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
15 northern 3 9 117-128 av. 124*6 31-35 av. 33 27-31 av. 29 78-84
10 southern 113-123 av. 118 30-36 av. 32 26-32 av. 29 70-79 av. 74*5
[259]
246 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
Whistler’s kangrae described for its larger size is not now accepted,
but the usual north-south cline is evidenced by the above measurements.
There are variations in the intensity of the brown of the head and four
(2 Punjab, 2 Pilibhit Terai) have their heads paler and the streaks broader
than in the others .
781 Megalaima zeylanica inornata Walden (Malabar) Western Green
Barbet 4 : 110
13 : 6 (1 juv.) 3$$ 4 o ? (2juv.)
1 Andheri, 1 Bhandup, Bombay ; 1 Karnala, Kolaba ; 3 Khandala ; 4 Ratnagiri;
1 Kadra, 1 Karwar, N. Kanara ; 1 Kuravenuth, Travancore.
All of them have the upperparts washed with brown, and very few
signs of streaking particularly on the head and nape. Specimens from
Ratnagiri show more brown and very little green on the underparts.
No. 21284, collected at Karnala on 15th March while being fed by
another, has a short bill and pale head, and is no doubt a juvenile.
781a Megalaima zeylanica subsp.
3 : 2 (J<? 1 $
1 Hathidari, Palanpur, N. Gujarat ; 1 Malegaon, 1 Laochali, Surat Dangs.
Salim Ali in ‘ Birds of Gujarat ’ (JBNHS 52 : 448) recorded 11 speci-
mens from Gujarat as inornata , but in ind. handbook (4 : 150) Gujarat
is said to be within the range of caniceps. The only three from Surat
Dangs (2) and Hathidari, Palanpur, N. Gujarat, available here have
pale un streaked heads and resemble the juvenile of inornata. One
obtained on 10th March 1948 is marked as having enlarged gonads and
there is no evidence of any of them not being adult. If this is supported
by additional material, there is no doubt that they are sufficiently distinct
to be trinomially separated.
782 Megalaima zeylanica zeylanica (Gmelin) (Ceylon) Ceylon Green
Barbet 4: 108
1 Ceylon $ ? No. 10435
Wing 113 ; bill 32 ; tarsus 27 ; tail 70.
The head and breast are darker than in inornata , and both head and
breast are streaked with pale shaft-streaks. The wings also carry tiny
white spots which are absent in most inornata. One $ No. 10443 from
Kuravenuth, Travancore, approaches it in darkness of colour and streak-
ing and was one of the two specimens available to Whistler ( JBNHS
38 : 187) when he decided that birds from South Travancore were nomi-
nate zeylanica. It lacks the prominent shaft-streaks on the head and
breast, and can be well matched with inornata from further north. With
the material available, I would not admit zeylanica to the Indian main-
land.
[260]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION— 16 247
783 Megalaima lineata rana Ripley (Bajora, Dailekh District, West
Nepal) Western Lineated Barbet
784 Megalaima lineata hodgsoni Bonaparte (Nepal, restricted to
Simra, Central Nepal) Eastern Lineated Barbet 4: 111
23 : 7 13?? 3 o ?
The material available does not permit the separation of any bird
as rana , nor is it possible to geographically isolate those with the brighter
green lower underparts ( kutru Mukherjee). Eastern and Burmese birds,
however, have heavier and more conical beaks than those from the west,
but three specimens from Burma, under (c), are confusing, and I am for
the moment only drawing attention to the differences.
(a) hodgsoni 8 : 4 4??
2 Partapur, 1 Bankulwa Morang, Nepal ; 1 Ranibag, U.P. ; 1 Baghowni, Bihar ;
1 Gurguria, Simlipal District, Orissa ; 1 Kurseong, 1 Sevoke, Darjeeling,
Bengal.
Wing Bill
123, 123, 135 32, 32-5, 34*3, 35
?? 133(3), 136 32,36, 36-4,36*5
(<?? 123-137 30-33
Depth at base Tail
13-6, 14-2, 14-3, 14-6 76,77,84,87
14, 14-6, 14-7, 15-3 73,77,80,82
— 82-86)
(b) Assam and Burma, with conical bills 12 : 3 <$<J 8 ?? 1 o ?
1 Sadiya, 1 Goalpara, 1 South Sylhet, 1 North Cachar, 1 Roopchena, 1 Laisingh,
Cachar, Assam ; 1 Laindon, Thayetmyo, 1 Theme, Prome, 1 Legongyi, Henzada*
2 May my o, 1 Sabagyi Village, west of Yomas, Bassein, Burma.
Wing Bill Depth at base Tail
c?<J 123,125,135 32-5,34,34-5 15-1,15-4,16-1 78(2), 85
?? 123-138 av. 130-4 31-9-37 av. 34-2 14-16-3 av. 15-2 75-82 av. 79
The depth of the bill at base and the conical shape is better shown
in the accompanying sketch than by the measurements.
MSGAUIMA LINEAfA
EASTERN
Pill of 10472 9
Pill of 10464 «
[261]
5
248 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Sp. No. 19467 from west of Yomas, Bassein, Burma (wing 123 ;
bill 32 ; depth 16 ; tail 78) is distinguishable from all the other specimens
by the uniformly blackish brown chin and upper breast, with no streaks,
and the head broadly streaked with buff as in the three referred
to as juveniles under (c) below.
$ No. 10465 from Bankulwa Morang, Eastern Nepal, has a similar
trend to darkness of the throat and upper breast, but not so pronounced.
This is presumably a juvenile character also exhibited in Megalaima
viridis No. 785 (q.v.).
(c) 3:1$ 2 o ?
1 Lower Chindwin ; 2 Southern Shan States, Burma.
Nos. 10461, 10462 and 10468 (wing 130, 131, 134 ; bill 34*3, 34-5, 34*7 X 14*4,
15-5, 15*6; tail 79, 80, 80).
These have prominent wide pale streaks at the centre of the feathers
of the head, giving the whole area a whitish rather than brown effect as
in the other specimens. Mr. Bond, to whom a specimen was sent,
thinks that this represents a juvenile plumage. The three however lack
the thick bills of the others from Burma .
785 Megalaima viridis (Boddaert) (Mahe, India) Small Green Barbet
4: 113
21 : 11 <?<? 9$? lo?
1 Malegaon, Surat Dangs, Gujerat ; 2 Khandala, 1700', 1 Lohgad, Malavi,
Poona ; 1 Ratnagiri, 1 Gowadsagar, Goa Frontier ; 4 Karwar, 2 Santgal ;
1 Katgal, 1 Sirsi, N. Kanara ; 2 Shembaganur, 2 Palni Ghats, 1 Kodaikanal ;
1 Karupadana, Cochin State ; 1 Shevaroy Hills , Salem District.
J. Hayes-Lloyd ( Ibis 1873, p. 125, reproduced in Stray Feathers 1 : 419)
had separated northern birds as M. sykesi as ‘ distinguished by their
larger size and pronounced markings.’ There is some variation in the
colour of the head and also the markings on the breast, but they do not
appear to represent any distinct populations.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
Northern 13* 3$$ 103, 106*(2), 107 24*, 25(2), 27 24, 25, 26*(2) 60*(2), 65(2)
Ratnagiri south-
wards 10 33 6$$ 96-102, av. 100-5 22-26, av. 24 24-25, av. 24-5 53-64, av. 58-3
(ih 97-113 from skull 24-29 c. 27 65-70)
Four southern birds [Ratnagiri, N. Kanara (2) and Palnis] obtained
in May and June have brown heads, in which the absence of pale edges
to the feathers shows a sleekness absent in the others. In Sp. No. 20709
from Shembaganur, obtained on 18 February 1958, the edges of the
feathers of the head are tinged with pale green. Sp. No. 10482 a 3 from
Karwar, has a dark chin and breast similar to that in the larger barbet
[262]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECT ION — 16 249 -
lineata from Sabagyi Village, west of Yomas,Bassein, Burma, and this is
presumably a juvenile character.
786 Megalaima flavifrons (Cuvier) (Ceylon) Yellowfronted Bar bet
4: 120
4 : 2 $$ 1 $ 1 o ?
1 Rygam Korale, 1 Walgama, 1 Rasagatli-Balangordi (?), 1 Pundulaya, Ceylon.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
<?? 90(2), 91, 92 20,21,22(2) 20(2), 23, 24 53,54(3)
(ih 87-93 from skull 21-25 22-25 52-58)
787 Megalaima franklinii franklinii (Blyth) (Darjeeling) Golden-
throated Barbet 4: 124
15:4<?<J 2 $$ 9 o ?
1 Dharamsala, Punjab (?) ; 1 Bans Bahari, Nepal ; 1 Singhik, N. Sikkim,
1 Sikkim ; 1* Mishmi (Abor Expedition), 2 * Rotung, Abor Country ; 2 Hum-
grum, N. Cachar ; 1 Loi Song, 1 Loi Pengye, 2 North Shan States ; 1 Bamboo
Camp, 1 Mt. Victoria, Burma.
All have a black stripe over the eye and there is nothing to suggest
ramsayi. There is considerable variation in the shades of green on the
upper and lower parts, which cannot be localised except for 3
from Mishmi and Abor Country and another from N. Shan States which
are deeper green above and have a curious olive wash below (marked with
asterisk above). Three others from the N. Shan States have their upper-
parts equally dark, but the underparts distinctly paler than in all the
others. The material available does not permit any conclusions.
A series of eight from eastern and central Bhutan, not yet registered,
has been examined and is included in the measurements. Those from
central Bhutan show more green than the eastern specimens, but the
differences may be included in the range of variation over the whole
series.
Specimen No. 10534 is marked ‘ Dharamsala, Punjab, Col:
H. W. Wells 5 and the labeL bears the printed words ‘ Bombay Natural
History Society — Mammal Survey \ The serial number however does
not appear on this label. Wells collected some birds in Assam while
directing the Mammal Survey in Assam in 1919-1920, and later also in
the Punjab. It would appear that there has been mix-up in the labels
and I do not accept this as extending the accepted range of this species
west of Central Nepal.
788 Megalaima asiatica asiatica (Latham) (Calcutta) Bluethroated
Barbet 4 : 116
32 : 18 <$$ 8?? 6 o ?
[263]
250 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 11 (2)
Though no races have yet been named from this area, the 31 speci-
mens (1 missing) available can be separated into 2 groups.
24 : 15 3d (1 juv.) 5 ?$ 4 o ? (1* missing).
(a) 1 Dharamsala, Kangra ; 3* Bhagat State, 1 Bhajji State, Simla ; 1 Dehra
Dun, 1 Almora, U.P. ; 1 Tribeni, Nepal ; 1 Rangpo, 1 Martam, Rogni Valley,
Sikkim, 1 Darjeeling, 1 Calcutta ; 1 Tenai T.E., Goalpara, 3 Dibrugarh,
1 Sadiya, 1 Bagho Bahar, Cachar, Assam ; 2 Dinapur Road, 1 Imphal area,
Manipur ; 1 Pumsin, 1 Gora, 1 Taw maw, Chindwin Expedition.
One (J N o. 10501 from Bagho Bahar, Cachar, has an olive-green wash
on the underparts, similar to that shown by M.franklinii from the Mishmi
and Abor Country (q.v.b
Four unregistered specimens from Bhutan agree with this group and
include one with the upper and underparts splashed with red. A red
form rubescens described by Baker from ‘ the highest ranges in the east
of the Cachar Hills ’ is said to be an erythristic form of the nominate
race.
( b ) Similar to ( a ) but with thicker and more conical bills.
8: 3c?<? 3 $?■ 2o?
1 Gusyang, N. Cachar, 1 A’ Krang, Upper Burma ; 1 Ft. Stedman, 1 Chin Hills ;
1 Thayetmyo, 2 Nyaunggyo, Prome Dist. , 1 Chandaung, Henzada Dist.
There is not much difference in size between the two groups :
Some birds show shiny yellowish green on the upperparts and I
accept Mr. Bond’s suggestion that this is seasonal and due to wear.
Mr. Bond writes : ‘ The colour is only on the top of the feather, the under-
side is dark grey. Unlike the barbs of most bird feathers which dis-
appear with wear, the yellow barbs of these feathers appear to be very
tough and remain on the rachis after the barbules have worn away.
The tips of these remaining barbs then produce a yellowish cast to the
upperparts, so the yellowish appearance is produced by wear.’
789 Megalaima australis cyanotis (Blyth) (Arakan) Indian Blue-eared
Barbet 4 : 121
4 : 3 <?<? 1 o ?
1 Roopchena, 2 Bagho Bahar, Cachar ; 1 Konka , N. Shan States.
[264]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION— 16 251
In ind. handbook (4 : 160) the reference to Stuart Baker’s fauna is
inadvertently omitted.
790 Megalaima rubricapilla malabarica (Blyth) (Malabar) Malabar
Crimsonthroated Barbet 4 : 129
15:SAA (ljuv.) 5 $$ 2o?
1 Kadra, 1 Ramankoli, 2 Hattikeri, 1 Maigui, 1 Akkgodda, 1 Kumta Div.,
1 North Kanara ; 1 Mercara, Coorg ; 2 Gudalur, Nilgiris ; 2 Wynaad;
1 Murchiston, Ponmudi, 1 Santhanpara, Cardamom Hills, Kerala.
There is some variation in the green both on the upper and lower
parts which cannot be associated with any place or season. No. 10589
collected on 31 March 1900 in N. Kanara is presumably juvenile and lacks
the red round the eye, on the head, chin, and breast. The area round
the eye and the chin are yellowish, and though paler and less distinct
are very suggestive of the nominate race from Ceylon.
791 Megalaima rubricapilla rubricapilla (Gmelin) (Ceylon) Ceylon
Small Barbet 4 : 130
1 $ Colombo, Ceylon.
Wing 78 ; bill 17 ; tarsus 19 ; tail 33.
792 Megalaima haemacephala indica (Latham) (Calcutta) Crimson-
breasted Barbet 4: 127
56:27<J<J 20?? 9o?
In ind. handbook (4 : 163) the type locality is said to be ‘ India *
and luteus Lesson (Pondicherry) is synonymised with this race. Stuart
Baker indicated the type locality of indica as Calcutta and called it the
4 Burmese Crimsonbreasted Barbet ’.
Six specimens from Burma could be separated from the others by the
heavier greenish streaking on the underparts, in which the paler inter-
spaces in four (Sandoway, Henzada) are well washed with yellow. Of
three specimens, 1 Calcutta, 1 Salt Lake, 24-Parganas, Bengal, and 1
Kamrup, Assam, borrowed from the Zoological Survey, the single bird
from Calcutta shows a tendency towards the brightness of those from
Burma but this is not evident in specimens from Assam. Larger series
from different areas are necessary to determine the separability of luteus
from Pondicherry (and peninsular India).
In some specimens, including one from Taungyi, and others from
[265]
252 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Assam and India, the streaks on the underparts are so dark as to appear
grey rather than green.
(a) 50 : 25 (1* juv.) 19 ?$ 6 o ?
2 Rawalpindi, 2 Ambala, Punjab ; 1 Delhi ; 1 Bharatpur, Rajasthan ; 1 Deesa,
Palanpur, 1 Amreli, Kathiawar, 1 Gir Forest, 1 Dabka, Baroda, 1 Dediapada,
Rajpipla, 1 Sarwar, 1 Malegaon, Surat Dangs ; 3 Bombay, 3 Hhandala,
1 Poona, 2 Satara, 1 Rajapur, Ratnagiri; 1 Andie, 1 Silloor, 2 Karwar, 1 Katti-
keri, N. Kanara ; 1 Mysore ; 1 Tope, Palnis ; 1 St. Thomas’s Mount, Madras,
1 Palkonda Hills, 1 Koduru, 1 Cumbum Valley; 1 Anantagiri, 1 Jeypore Agency,
Vizagapatam; 1 Konta; 1 Amraoti, Bastar Dt., 1 Saugor, C.P. ; 2 Barkul,
1 Mayurbhanj, Orissa ; 1 Meerut; 1 Pilibhit, 1 Cawnpur ; 2 Baghownie,
Tirhut, Bihar, 1* Dibrugarh, Assam; 2 no data.
(b) 6: 2 ?? 1 $ 3 o ?
1 North Shan States , 2 Taungyi, S. Shan States, 1 Prome Dt., 1 Sandoway, 1 Myog-
win, Henzada Dt.
12 specimens from the north (Punjab, Delhi, Cawnpore, Meerut,
Baghowni, Tirhut, and Pilibhit) have their upperparts a paler uniform
green with a tinge of yellow. Except for similar tendency in five from
Palkonda Hills and Kodur in S. Cuddappah, Cumbum Valley, Kurnool
Dist., and two from Orissa, this colour does not appear uniformly in any
of the others .
Sp. No. 10553 from Mysore (February 1915) shows no green on the
head and body and, except for the red on the forehead and upper breast,
is largely white or yellowish. In the wing except for 2 primaries (6th &
7th) on one side and 3 (4th, 5th, & 6th) on the other, the primaries and a
few of the secondaries are brown with fine green edges, as in normal
birds.
793 Indicator xanthonotus radcliffi Hume (Kalabagh, Hazara Dist.
W. Punjab) West Pakistan Orangerumped Honeyguide
nil.
794 Indicator xanthonotus xanthonotus Blyth (Darjeeling) Nepal
Orangerumped Honeyguide 4 : 131
nil.
795 Indicator xanthonotus fulvus Ripley (Pfutsero, eastern Naga
Hills, Assam) Nagaland Orangerumped Honeyguide
nil.
[266]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION— 16 253
796 Jynx torquilla torquilla Linnaeus (Sweden) European Wryneck
4: 99
35 : 18 33 15 $$ 2 o?
1 Fao, 1 Basra, Mesopotamia ; 1 Chitral ; 1 Koti State, 2 Simla ; 1 Shikohpur,
Jullunder, 1 Ambala, 1 Dhirpur, Karnal, 1 Chandigarh, 2 Bhawalpur, Punjab ;
4 Delhi ; 1 Pithora, Sind ; 4 Kutch ; 1 Bharatpur ; 1 Maval*, 1 Hamawas Lake,
Pali, 1 Ajmere, Rajasthan ; 1 Deesa, Palanpur, 1 Amreli, 1 Ajwa, Baroda ;
1 Juhu, 1 Bombay Island ; 1 Bhanupratappur, 1 Bailadila, Bastar, 1 Central
Provinces ; 1 Cawnpore ; 1 Chitwan, Central Nepal. * Missing
797 Jynx torquilla chinensis Hesse (China, Tsingtao, Shantung)
Chinese Wryneck
5:2 33 1$ 2 o ?
4 Baghowni, Darbhanga, Bihar ; 1 N. Shan States , Burma.
These birds are slightly darker above than nominate torquilla and
also have a more consistently rufous chin. The upperparts also show
a slight wash of rufous, a character shown in specimens from Fao, Basra,
and Chitral, but which have larger wings 90, 90, and 85 mm. Ticehurst
(JBNHS 36 : 933) recorded intermedia Stegmann from Burma, but this
is now synonymous with chinensis , which has also been recorded from
Nepal by Fleming & Traylor ( Fieldiana , 1964, p. 524).
797a Jynx torquilla himalayana Vaurie (Inshan, Wardwan Valley,
Kashmir) Kashmir Wryneck
3:2<te 1$ (juv.)
2 Liddar Valley, 1 Haowan Village, Kashmir.
The juvenile has a large first primary contra tiny in adults.
798 Picumnus innominatus innominatus Burton (Himalayas = Sikkim)
Northern Speckled Piculet 4 : 92
14 : 9 33
2 Koti State, 2 Simla, NW Himalayas ; 1 Dehra Dun, 2 Bhim Tal, Kumaon,
1 Mornaula, Garhwal ; 2 Longview, Darjeeling, 4 Margherita, Upper Assam.
[267]
254 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
799 Picumnus innominatus malayorum Hartert (Gunong Ijau, Perak,
Malaya) Southern Speckled Piculet 4 : 94
18 : 2 16 $$ (4 by plumage)
1 Lamasinghi, 3 Sankrametta, Vizagapatam Hills ; 2 Bailadila, 2 Chota Dongar,
1 Antagarh, 1 Geedam, Bastar, 1 Kuldia, Nilgiri, 2 Berbera, Puri Dist., 2
Badrama, Bamra, 1 Garguria, Simlipal Hills, Orissa ; 1 N. Shan States ; 1 Shan
States , Burma.
The material available appears to show more variation than indicated
in ind. handbook, but has for the moment been grouped in. accordance
with the distribution therein. The following comments may assist
future workers.
In ind. handbook Ticehurst’s simlaensis is identified with nominate
form. In spite of the name, the type locality of simlaensis is further west
at Murree, whence there is no material for comparison. The difference
in wing size 58-61 av. 59*9 as against 55-58 av. 56‘7 is small but accepted
as consistent by Vaurie (1965, p. 686).
The birds available to as far east as Garhwal are brighter above but
a yet unregistered male (BH/861) from Shamgong, Bhutan, has a dark
head similar to those from S. India.
In those under malayorum , 9 females from Bastar and Orissa show
in series duller upperparts than those from the north, and have the heads
of the same colour. Two females (by plumage) from North Shan States
and Shan States have their heads a clearer olive-green like the back, and
not darker, as is required for malayorum — Ripley ( JBNHS 48 : 15)
noted a similar difference in one from Laukkong, E. Burma.
Three from Eastern Ghats show dark heads and may be linked either
with the southern avunculorum {infra) or northeastern birds.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
$$ innominatus
1 268 ]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION — 16 255
$$ malayorum
2 Shan States
10 Bastar & 1
Orissa 1
3 Vizagapatam Hills 58, 58, 61
53,58 11,12 13,13
58-60 av. 58-6 11-12 av. 11-4 12-14av. 13*3
11,12,12 13(3)
29, 34
30-34 av. 31-2
30,31,33
$$ avunculorum
2 N. Kanara 56, 59
11,12 12,13 30,32
It will be noticed that the four (2 (J<J, 2 $?) from Margherita, Assam,
have consistently shorter wings than the others except for one from
Darjeeling.
799a Picumnus innominatus avunculorum Hartert (Nilgiris) Nilgiri
Speckled Piculet 4 : 94
5:3<te 2$$
1 Anshi, 1 Mankibail, N. Kanara ; 1 Coonoor Ghat, 1 Wynaad, Nilgiris ;
1 Manalur, Palnis.
The two males from Coonoor Ghat and Wynaad differ from all the
others available by their darker heads marked with black spots which are
absent in the single male from the Palnis.
The limited material indicates that avunculorum from the Nilgiris is
valid and for the sake of convenience, others with dark heads from
neighbouring areas are grouped with them.
The measurements are under 799.
800 Sasia ochracea ochracea Hodgson (Nepal) Himalayan Rufous
Piculet 4 : 95
4 : 2 <J(J (1 by plumage) 2 ??
1 Darjeeling ; 1 Dickchu, N. Sikkim ; 1 Dibrugarh, 1 Sadiya, Upper Assam.
Wing
Bill Tarsus Tail
2 S<$
2 $9
52, 54 12, 12
53,54 13,13
(ih 52-53 from skull 12-15
13, 13
13, 14
14-15
26 +,-
20, 23
22-24)
The underparts of the two females are deeper rufous than in the
others, including the male from Dibrugarh. In four yet unregistered
specimens from Bhutan (1 o ? 3 $$) the unsexed bird which has the gold
front of the male, is paler, than the females, both above and below.
The statement in the fauna (4 : 96) repeated in ind. handbook
(4 : 175) that the forehead of the female is almost concolorous with the
crown is not correct, for the crown is dark olive-grey and forms a very
distinct cap. This cap is least distinct in the four males referred to
herein,
[269]
256 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
801 Sasia ochracea reichenowi Hesse (Burma, type from Thayet
Chaung, Tenasserim) Burmese Rufous Piculet 4 : 97
4 <JcJ (1 by plumage)
1 Bagho Bahar, 1 Laisingh, Cachar ; 1 Laikinsaw, Khasia Hills ; 1 Kamaing ,
U. Burma.
Sp. No. 10380 from Cachar is marked but has the rufous forehead
of the female and may be in juvenile plumage. Though they show some
variation of colour among themselves, all of them are more rufous, less
olive-green above, and can be separated from those from Bhutan. Three
are marked querulivox Baker by Salim Ali and it is possible that this race
may be worth retaining. The few specimens show differences in colour,
but in the absence of suitable series from any one place it is not possible
to comment on them.
802 Micropternus brachyurus humei Kloss (Kumaon bhabar)
Western Rufous Woodpecker 4 : 64
nil.
803 Micropternus brachyurus phaioceps Blyth (Arrakan) Eastern
Rufous Woodpecker 4: 63
26 : 1 1 S3 (2 by plumage) 11?$ 4 o ?
When described the bird was said to be found in ‘ India proper ex-
tending eastwards to Tipperah and Arrakan and the type locality has
finally been restricted to Arrakan. In the meantime mesos was described
(Kloss 1918) from Orissa (Cuttack), Calcutta, and Bengal. This is
not accepted in ind. handbook, but the material available falls into
separate groups. Though the differences are insufficient to permit any
very decisive conclusion, I am for the moment drawing attention to them.
(a) 5:2 $$ (1 by plumage) 3 o ?
1 Lower Chindwin, 1 Bhamo, 2 S. Shan States, 1 Taunggyi, Burma.
These five extralimital birds from Burma are an appreciably brighter
chestnut above and larger than those from the adjacent areas of Assam
and Bengal. Considering the final restriction of type locality to Arrakan,
I presume that they are phaioceps. They however show differences
among themselves which I am unable to clarify.
Sp. 10199 (Capt. H. Wood, R.E.) is marked Bhamo, South Shan
States, while the only Bhamo on the maps available is in North Shan
States. No. 10201 (c? by plumage) and 10202 o? were both collected
by S. S. Lightfoot on 30 December 1912 in Southern Shan States. The
unsexed bird without any red on the cheeks, has the head and neck buffish
with narrow chestnut centres which leaves the area pale coloured and
very different from the second collected on the same day and from the
1270]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION— 16 257
others available and approaches fokiensis (Swinhoe) as described in La
Touche’s handbook of birds of eastern china, Pt. 2 : 26, though the
wings are smaller (129-135). Mo. 10200 from Taunggyi, further south,
is very heavily barred on the upperparts, a character shared almost to
the same extent by 10202. All have their chins prominently streaked on
a buff background. An unregistered <? + [wing 128 from Mangdechu,
Bhutan (BH 730)] is also similarly coloured above.
In all these birds the primary shafts are pale and concolorous. Their
chins vary to some extent but the centre of the feather, which is brownish
like the abdomen, has a relatively wide buff border on both sides.
(b) 8 : 4 3 $$ 1 o ? (juv.)
1 Sevoke, 1 Darjeeling, Bengal ; 1 Goalpara, 2 Dibrugarh, 1 Lasmyah, Cachar,
1 Rema T. E., S. Sylhet, 1 Wahlong, Assam.
These birds are much darker above and below than those under
(a) and have almost unmarked throats, except for the two westernmost
from Darjeeling which in this respect resemble birds in group (c). The
juvenile from Wahlong, collected by Stuart Baker in 1906, approaches
group ( a ) in its lighter colour and streaking on the chin.
(c) 11 : 5 (1 by plumage) 6 $$
1 Bsrbera, Puri Dt., 1 Chahala, Simlipal Hills, 1 Badrama, Bamra, Orissa;
1 Rajaputtee, Saran, 5 Baghowni, 1 Narbar, Madhubani, Bihar ; 1 no data.
These form another group in which the chins are marked with broader
streaks with less buff at the sides, and which in series are distinctly paler
all over than (b).
Three individuals, a <J from Badrama, Orissa, a $ from Baghowni,
Dharbhanga, and 1 unsexed from Rajaputtee, Saran, are brighter bay
in colour and resemble (a) from Burma. Stuart Baker (1919, Ibis , p. 199)
referred to the same trait in specimens from Ceylon, Travancore, Oota-
camund and Madras, and Nepal and Assam, and described the character
as valueless.
(d) 1 $ Bastar, M.P.
(<?) 1 $ Anantgiri, 3000' Eastern Ghats.
The 2 southernmost females, from Bastar and Anantgiri, have darker
centres to the feathers of the throat, approaching the squamation of
southern jerdonii.
As the sexes show no consistent difference in size, they are measured
258 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
804 Micropternus brachyurus jerdonii (Malherbe) (Indian Peninsula ;
restricted to Travancore) Southern Rufous Woodpecker 4 : 65
16 : 5 $$ (1 by plumage) 9 2 o ?
2 Pimpri, Surat Dangs ; 2 Borivli, 1 Andheri, Bombay ; 1 Dorli, Ratnagiri ;
1 Kadra ; 1 Yellapur, 1 Karwar, N. Kanara ; 1 Antarsante, SW. Mysore ;
1 Parambikolam, Cochin ; 1 Thekadi, 1 Thattakad, 2 Trivandrum, Travan-
core ; 1 Shevaroy Hills, Salem, Tamil Nadu.
This series from western India covers the accepted range of jerdonii
but in the northern birds from the Surat Dangs south to Ratnagiri the
squamationsonthe chin and throat are obsolete and almost absent while
they are much more prominent further south. In all however the
feathers of the chin and throat are more squarish and not elongated as
in those under phaioceps.
The single female No. 10020, from Shevaroy Hills, 4000 ft., is paler
and earthy brown all over, while another female No. 10222 from
Parambikolam, 1650 ft., Cochin State, is appreciably darker than all the
others. Three others from Travancore further south, from the low
country, do not have this character and are similar to those from North
Kanara. It is possible that distinct populations exist in isolated biotopes.
The measurements are under No. 803.
806 Picus squamatus fiavirostris (Menzbier) (Murghab, Transcaspia)
Transcaspian Scalybellied Green Woodpecker 4 : 8
nil.
[272}
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION— 16 259
807 Picus squamatus squamatus Vigors (Himalayas, restricted to
Simla-Almora Districts) Himalayan Scalybellied Green Woodpecker 4 : 7
34: 20 AA (1 by plumage, 4 juv.) 14 $$ (5 juv.)
1 Kilia Drosh, 5 Chitral, N.W.F.P.; 1 Kashmir; 2 Dalhousie, Punjab, 1 Nichar,
7000', 1 Himalayas ; 12 Simla, 2 Mussoorie, 1 Mouna Khal, 1 Ramni,
Garhwal, 2 Dakhuri, 1 Dinopani, 1 Pithoragarh, 1 Ramgarh, Nainital}
Kumaon, 1 Bodiar (?), 1 no data.
Wing
16 <?c? 159-166 av. 162*6
9 $9 153-164 av. 160*2
(<J? 155-172
Bill
40-44 av. 42*4
36-42 av. 40*7
27-33
Tarsus
29-32 av. 30*5
27-32 av. 30
c. 27
Tail
99-118 av. 105.8
92-115 av. 109
127-136)
The bill is much larger and the tail smaller than indicated in fauna
and repeated in ind. handbook.
In the males there is some difference in the nature of the red on the
head, and two, Simla (9 Oct.) and Kumaon (1 May), have a yellowish
wash on the underparts.
Males (5) and females (4) obtained in September (1) and October (8)
show more green on the upperparts than the others — December (2),
February (1), March (4), April (2), May (2), June (1) and July (1).
808 Picus myrmecophoneus Stresemann (Himalaya and Central India)
Little Scalybellied Green Woodpecker 4 : 10
16 (details below)
According to ind. handbook (4 : 184) no subspecies are acceptable
but the material available does show differences :
(a) 10 : 7 (1 juv.) 3 $$
1 Ketti,Nilgiris ; 1 Shembaganur, Palnis ; 1 Aramboli, 1 Thekkadi, Travancore;
1 Chitteri Range, Salem ; 2 Amraoti, 1 Darba, Bastar ; 1 Pilibhit Terai ; 1
Bankulwa Morang, Nepal.
These birds, presumably including topo types, have margins to the
feathers of the underparts darker than in ( b ). Birds from Bastar and
further south have the darkest upperparts.
The juvenile <J has very scattered red on the head.
(b) 3
1 Jagadhri, Ambala, 1 Ladhwa, Karnal, Punjab ; 1 Sanchi, Bhopal, C.I.
These birds, including two marked adult by the collector, are paler
above than («), and the feathers of the underparts lack the black
scalloping.
(c) 3:2 1 ?
2 Kani, Lower Chindwin ; 1 Pakokku, Magwe, Burma .
[273]
260 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
In addition to being larger, their rumps and upper tail-coverts are
greenish yellowish and show no orange. Both males have their heads
orange-red (as in one viridanus q.v.) and not crimson (as in Indian
birds).
As the sexes show no differences in size, their measurements are
placed together :
Though the colour differences in the small series in Group ( c ) may
be of no significance, the birds are distinctly larger than the others.
EL Picus vittatus viridanus Blyth (Arakan) Burmese Scalybellied
Woodpecker 4 : 12
4: lc? 3$?
1 Sandoway, 1 Bassein> 1 S. Irrawady, 1 Ataran, Amherst Dist., Burma.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
138(2), 141, 143 33(2), 34,— 27(3), 28 97, 102, 102, 106
(125-148 almost 29-36 generally c. 26 92-104)
invariably over over 32
132
There are no streaks on the chin, throat and upper breast, which are
strongly washed with brownish and tinged with greenish. This together
with the longer tail (which was referred to by Blyth) separates them
distinctly from Group (c) under No. 808.
The Smithsonian Institution was good enough to lend me a series of
P. v. viridanus collected at Ban Khlua Klang, Prachuap Khiri Khan,
Thailand, and so marked by Deignan. These however do not agree with
the above specimens, lacking the ochraceous tone, and I am prompted
to draw attention to Paynter’s recent note {Bull. B.O.C. 90 : 118, 1970)
regarding a female obtained in Khulna District, Sunderbans, which he says
does not agree with viridanus , as it has no streaks on the upper breast,
throat, and neck, and suggests that it is closer to eisenhoferi. U.S.N.M,
Sp. No. 449438 from Akyab, Arakan, north of those in the B.N.H.S.
collection, appears to be similar, but is again quite different from a pair
marked eisenhoferi by Deignan. I cannot help feeling that there is consi-
derable confusion relating to the identity and distribution of the several
races viridanus , eisenhoferi , weberi , eurous , and connectens , said to occur
over a very restricted area in Thailand, and that an extensive reappraisal
is necessary.
[274]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION— 16 261
The single male has the head orange-red as in two myrmecophoneus
from Kani, Lower Chindwin (q.v.), and Mr. Derek Goodwin of British
Museum (Natural History) to whom it was sent stated that one specimen
of P. vittatus , a male from Pulau Langkawi, Malay Peninsula (B.M.
No. 1936.4.12.586) has its head nearly the same colour.
EL Picus canus jessoensis Stejneger (Sapporo, Hokkaido, Japan)
Japanese Greyheaded Woodpecker
6:3^ 3$? (ljuv.)
All Peking, China, collected by Major H. J. Walton in 1901.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
143, 144, 146 35, 36,— 24, 26, 27 90, 96, 96
juv. & mltg. 32, 35 25, 26 93
The juvenile has a slight brownish wash all over. All the males
have different coloured heads ranging from all-grey to largely black after
the red forehead.
Birds from this area were described as zimmermanni by Reichenow
but have been synonymised with this form (1965, Vaurie, p. 693).
809 Picus canus sanguiniceps Baker (Himalayas, Simla- Almora Dist.)
Indian Blacknaped Green Woodpecker 4 : 13
11 :6 5$$ (l*juv.)
1 Siroli, 1 Koti State, NW Himalayas, 4 Simla ; 2 Mussoorie, 1* Mornaula, 1
Yoshimath, Garhwal, 1 Bhimtal, Kumaon, U.P.
810 Picus canus gyldenstolpei Baker (Sadiya, north Lakhimpur,
Assam) Assam Blacknaped Green Woodpecker 4:15
28 : 12 J4 (2 juv.) 16 $$ (2 juv.)
1 Chalna Khel, 1 Tribine, Nepal ; 1 Rinchingpong, 1 Rangpo, Sikkim ; 3 Long-
view, Darjeeling, 1 Goma Reserve, Goalpara, 2 Sadiya, Upper Assam,
2 Gusyong, 2** North Cachar, 1* Roopchena, 1 Bagho Bahar, Cachar,
1 Mishmi, Assam ; 1 Kalewa, Upper Chindwin, 1 Kani, Lower Chindwin, 1
Fort White, Chin Hills', 1 SE. of May my o, Mandalay Dt., 1* Hsipaw, N.
162 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
This group is separated from sanguiniceps by the golden sheen on the
upperparts and its smaller size.
There is Some variation in colour but it is not possible to separate
Indian specimens from those from Burma which are accepted as identical
with hessei Gyldenstolpe (Northern Siam) and which is an older name.
I am however leaving them as gyldenstolpei until a definite decision is
taken.
Two (Nos. 21144 and 21145) from Sikkim are a darker green below
and agree with 7 unregistered birds from Bhutan. However they (9)
are the freshest skins and this may be the reason.
The juveniles, which can be separated by the broader and rounder
tipped first primary, are duller green above and show more brown than
green below. The tail is less distinctly barred (contra ind. handbook
4 : 186) than in the adults and only one, a female from Roopchena,
Cachar (4 July 1893) has traces of barring on the lower belly.
811 Picus cairns kogo (Bianchi) (Bartschou, affluent, fl. Nomu-tschu,
tribut. fl. Mekong sup.) Tibetan Blacknaped Green Woodpecker
nil.
EL Picus erythropygius nigrigenis (Hume) (No locality) Redrumped
Green Woodpecker 4 : 22
3??
1* Fort White , Chin Hills , 1 Hsipaw, North Shan States ; 1 Taunggyi, Yawng-
hwe, Burma.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
146, 156, 162* 31, 32, 34* 29*, 30, 30 —,104,117*
((£$ 147-157 30-35 30-31 99-114)
The birds from Fort White and Hsipaw slightly extend the northern
limits of the species which are said to be Tounghoo and Karenni (fauna)
repeated in Peters’s checklist (6 : 138) and extended to ‘Foothills of
Maymyo ’ by Smythies (1940, birds of Burma, p. 295).
No. 9957* from Fort White, Chin Hills, is the largest and with rump
brighter and larger than in the others.
EL Picus viridis karelini Brandt (Astarabad, northern Iran)
1 S Bandar-e-Gaz, W. Astarabad , Caspian Province, Iran .
Wing 158 ; bill 40 ; tarsus 33 ; tail 98.
The subspecific identification is based on the distribution in Peters’s
checklist. Vaurie (1965 : 688) has synonymized it with nominate
viridis.
[276]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT . HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION— 16 263
812 Picus flavinucha kumaonensis (Koelz) (Kathgodam, Naini Tal
Dist., U.P.) Kumaon Large Yellownaped Woodpecker
2: 1<J 1?
2 Ranibagh, Kumaon, U.P.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
<?? 183,179 40,37 30,29 130, 132
(ih ‘Wing over 180 ; tail over 131 mm — Biswas ’).
813 Picus flavinucha flavinucha Gould (Himalayas, Darjeeling)
Eastern Large Yellownaped Woodpecker 4 : 23
20 : 1 1 (ljuv.) 9$? (ljuv.)
1 Chahala, Simlipal Hills, Orissa ; 1 Digla, 1 Bijaypur, Nepal ; 1 Darjeeling,
5000', l Kurseong Division, 1 Singtam, Tista Valley, 1 Temi, 1 Gangtok ,
Sikkim ; 1 Tegu, Lohit Valley, 1 Margherita, Upper Assam, 1 Naga Hills,
1 N. Cachar, 2 Bagho Bahar, 1 Roopchena, Cachar, Assam ; 1 Lower Chind-
win, 1 Loi Kaw, N. Shan States, 1 Upper Burma, 1 Sandoway Dt., 1 Ataran,
Amherst Dt., Burma.
The <J and $ from Nepal have the shortest wing.
* Sp. No. 9971, the female from Ataran, Amherst Dist., Burma,
has the rufous barring extending to the tips of the primaries, a character
of ricketti (Biswas, 1954, Ibis: 214). Apart from the fact that Ataran is
far from the habitat of this race, another (<J No. 9963) from Bagho Bahar,
Cachar, has similar wing quills, and is marked ‘ juvenile ’ by the collector,
and the barred primaries would appear to be shared with adjacent races
in juvenile plumage.
The specimens available show differences in colour but it is not pos-
sible to localize them.
814 Picus chlorolophus sinflae Meinertzhagen (Dehra Dun) West
Himalayan Small Yellownaped Woodpecker 4:18
6:3<J<J 3??
1* Simla, 1 Konda Ghat, Patiala State ; 2 Dehra Dun, U.P. ; 1* Mouna Khal,
Garhwal ; 1* Hathibari, Nepal.
Wing Bill Tarsus
A6 140, 140*, mltg.* 22*, 28*, 29 21*, 23, 25*
(ih ex Biswas 135-146 from skull 30-33 —
Tail
mltg.*, 93+, 95*
96-104)
?? 134* + , 144, 148 24*, 30, 31
22, 22, 25* mltg.*, 104, 105
[277]
6
264 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
The 3 marked with an asterisk (2 1$) have greyish and not green
heads and presumably represent an immature phase. The breasts are
also duskier, less greenish than in the others.
815 Picus chlorolophus chlorolophus Vieillot (Bengal) East Himalayan
Small Yellownaped Woodpecker 4:17
26 : 12 14 $9(1 by plumage)
1 Vizagapatam Hills, 1 Jeypore Agency, Vizagapatam ; 1 Badrama, Bamra,
1 Koira, Bonai, 1 Chahala, 2 Gurguria, Simlipal Hills, Orissa ; 1 Hazaria,
Patherghata, Bihar ; 1 Longview, Darjeeling, 2 Kurseong Div. ; 1 Martam,
Rongni Valley, Sikkim; 1 Buxa, 1 Goma Reserve, Goalpara, 1 Denning, Lohit
Valley, 1 Abor Expedition, 1 Dibrugarh, 1 Naga Hills 8000', 2 Rema T.E.,
S. Sylhet, 2 N. Cachar, 2 Kamaing, Upper Burma, 1 Mansum ( Chindwin Exp.),
1 Nindon Yoma Pass, Thayetmyo, Burma.
The northern birds show more green on the underparts, and the
Burmese specimens cannot be separated by size or colour except that
none of them have any green tinge on the breast, which is apparently
an adult character in Indian birds. Females from Vizagapatam Hills
(one, a very poor specimen) have their wings 123 and 124 mm, and to-
gether with a third female from Simlipal Hills (wing 126) lack the
Excluding two green-backed females referred to above, this race is
well distinguished from chlorigaster not only by the absence of the bronze
sheen on the back, but by the fact that in the male the red on the forehead,
lores, and nape encircles a large patch of green, which area is all red in
the southern birds. With this character, the birds from Vizagapatam
Hills and Mayurbhanj, Orissa, should be of this race and not chlorigaster
as stated in ind. handbook (4 : 194). Whistler in the Eastern Ghats
report ( JBNHS 37 : 287) also identified one of the specimens as of the
nominate race but his reference to the * golden sheen ’ on the back of
Himalayan birds is confusing ; this may perhaps be better termed a
yellowish wash.
[ 278 ]
BIRDS IN BOMBAY NAT. HIST. SOCIETY COLLECTION — 16 265
816 Picus chlorolophus chlorigaster Jerdon (Southern India) South
Indian Small Yellownaped Woodpecker 4 : 19
" 18 : 11 <?<$ (1 by plumage) 7
2 Songadh, Navsari, 1 Malegaon, Surat Dangs ; 1 Anshi Ghat, 1 Santgal, 2
Karwar, 2 North Kanara ; 1 Somvarpet, Coorg ; 1 Wynaad ; 1 Parambikolam,
Cochin ; 2 Manalur, Palnis ; 2 Thattakad, North Travancore ; 1 Cape
Comorin ; 1 no data.
Ten males (1 by plumage) have a varying amount of red on the head.
Another (No. 20001) from Palni Hills has no red on the head
but is marked <?, and is probably an error in sexing, having no character
which would indicate a juvenile. A few specimens show a few white
spots on the lower back.
817 Picus chlorolophus wellsi
Yellownaped Woodpecker
Meinertzhagen (Ceylon) Ceylon Small
4:20
1 c? Bibile, Ceylon.
Wing Bill Tarsus
117 22 20
(ih 115-123 from skull 24-25 19-20
Tail
77
78-86)
(to be continued)
Contribution to the Flora of Tirap
Frontier Division
BY
D. B. Deb and R. M. Dutta
Botanical Survey of India , Calcutta
[Continued from Vol. 70 (1) : 94]
SOLANACEAE
Datura metel Linn.
A shrub in flowers ; scarce. Margharita-Jairampur, Oct. 1959,
Rao 19910.
D. suaveolens Humb. & Bonpl. ex Willd.
A shrub with white flowers ; cultivated ; common. Wakka, July
1961, Deb 26503.
Lycopersicon lycopersicum (L.) Karsten. Tomato
A herb on moist soil with deep yellow flowers. An escape of culti-
vation. Chenglang, March 1958, Murthy 12901.
Lycianthes macrodon (Wall, ex Nees) Bitter
A herb in flowers with enlarged calyx in fruits. Forms societies as an
undergrowth ; common. Raho-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26406 ;
Langsang forest, June 1961, Deb 26139 ; Pungchow, July 1961, Deb
26622.
L. pachypetala (Spreng.) Bitter
A shrub with blood red fruits ; scarce. Nampong-Pangsupass, March
1958, Murthy 12992.
L. subtruncata (Wall, ex Dunal) Bitter
A herb with woody base in whitish or bluish white flowers ; rare.
Longsek hillock, 1500 m, June 1961, Deb 25735.
Pauia belladonna Deb et Dutta
A herb with perennial base. A monotypic genus published by the
authors in Ind. For. 91 (6) : 363. 1965. Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26422.
THE FLORA OF T1RAP FRONTIER DIVISION
267
The genus is named in honour of the late Rev. Dr. H. Santapau, Director,
Botanical Survey of India. The specific name is chosen after Indian
Belladonna for its apparent similarity in general appearance. It contains
an alkaloid and deserves thorough chemical investigation for medicinal
properties .
Solanum indicum Linn.
A shrub with white flowers ; scarce. Pungchow, July 1961, Deb 26582.
S. kurzii Brace ex Prain
A shrub with white flowers ; common. The fruit is used by local
people as a medicine in stomach disorder ; Nampong-Pangsupass,
March 1958, Murthy 13001 ; Chenglang-Khela, March 1958, Murthy
12927, 12943 & 12944 ; Lailongsong, June 1961, Deb 25794; Margharita-
Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19935.
CONVOLVULACEAE
Argyreia capitata (Vahl) Choisy
A twiner with red fruits ; scarce. Chenglang-Khela, Oct. 1959, Rao
20260 ; Jairampur, Oct. 1959. Rao 19978 ; Khela, March 1958, Murthy
12985.
A. roxburghii Choisy
A climber with deep chocolate coloured flowers ; rare. Kheti-
Tinchha, Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14617.
Ipomoea kingii Prain
A climber with white flowers; scarce. Chenglang-Khela, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20289 ; Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19981 ; Pungchow-Niausa, July
1961, Deb 26648.
Merremia mammosa (Lour.) Hall. f.
A large twiner with white flowers; common. Margharita- Jairampur,
Oct. 1959, Rao 19915 ; Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20166.
Porana racemosa Roxb.
A twiner with white flowers; scarce. Soha village, 1850 m., Oct. 1959,
Rao 20353.
S CROPHUL ARIACEAE
Hemiphragma heterophyllum Wall, ex Tent.
A herb forming societies ; common. Noglo, June 1961, Deb 26331,
268 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Scoparia dulcis Linn.
A herb with white flowers ; very common. Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao
19977.
Torenia cordata (Griff.) Dutta
A small herb with pinkish violet or deep-violet flowers in pure stands
in open ground ; very common. Tipang, June 1961, Deb 25709.
T. vagans Roxb.
A prostrate herb with bluish pink or violet flowers ; rare. Nampong-
Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20090 ; Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26067.
T. violacea (Azaola ex Blanco) Pennell
A herb with violet flowers; common. Jangkeng village, June 1961,
Deb 25850.
Vandellia antipoda (L.) Yamazaki
A small prostrate herb ; common. Namchick, 152 m, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20180 ; Deomali, Oct. 1959, Rao 20314 & 20315; Lailongsong,
510 m, June 1961, Deb 25817 ; Khonsa-Laju, June 1961, Deb 26005.
V. Crustacea (L.) Benth.
A prostrate herb with bright mauve flowers ; common. Jairampur,
Oct. 1959, Rao 19969 & 20002.
V. mollis Benth.
An annual with white flowers ; rare. Jangkeng village, June 1961,
Deb 25870 ; Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20084 ; Jairampur,
Oct. 1959, Rao 19976 ; Lunwa, July 1961, Deb 26644.
V. pusilla (Willd.) Yamazaki
A diffused herb with green flowers ; rare. Longhoi-Rusa, Sept.
1958, Panigrahi 16763.
Acanthaceae
Mackaya neesiana (Wall.) Das
An undershrub with lilac red flowers ; rare. Laju hills, 1575 m,
Aug. 1958, Panigrahi , 14647.
Phlogocanthus tubeflorus Nees
A shrub with pink or blood red flowers ; common. Chennhang,
June 1961, Deb s.n.
THE FLORA OF T1RAP FRONTIER DIVISION
269
Strobilanthes coloratus (Nees) T. Ander.
An undershrub with pink flowers ; common. Nampong-Pangsupass,
300-1100 m, Oct. 1959, Rao , 20160 ; Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26703.
S. glabratus Nees
A shrub with violet flowers / common. Uptil now this is known
to occur in Khasia and Jaintia hills only. The present record extends
its distributions to NEFA. Jangkeng village, June 1961 ; Deb 25853.
S. echinata Wall, ex Nees
A shrub with deep violet flowers ; scarce. Raho-Vokanoska, Aug.
1958, Panigrahi 16836.
S. helictus R. Ander.
An undershrub with yellow flowers; scarce. Raho-Vokanoska,
Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 16838.
S. pentstemonoides (Nees) T. Ander.
An undershrub with white flowers ; scarce. Jadua-Banfera, July
1961, Deb 26669.
Thunbergia coccinea Wall.
A climber with red flowers ; scarce. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct.
1959* Rao 20156 ; Chenglang, 600 m, March 1958, Murthy 12931 ;
Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26216.
T. grandiflora (Roxb. ex Rottl.) Roxb.
A large climber with bluish white flowers ; common. Deomali, 116m,
Oct. 1959, Rao 20307 ; Deomali, June 1961, Deb 25896.
Gesneriaceae
Aeschynanthus bracteata Wall, ex DC.
An epiphyte with blood red flowers ; rare. Noglo, June 1961, Deb
26346.
A. gracilis Parish ex C. B. Clarke
An epiphyte with fruits on Litsea monopetalaPtrs.; scarce. Longsek
hillock, 1500 m., June 1961, Deb 25751.
A. parasiticus (Roxb.) Wall.
A. grandiflorus (D. Don) Spreng.
An epiphyte with flowers, scattered. Chennhang, June 1961, Deb
26217; Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26028.
270 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
A. hookeri C. B. Clarke
An epiphyte with red flowers ; scattered. Chegum-Wakka, July 1961,
Deb 26482 ; Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26266 ; Pungchow-Niausa, July
1961, Deb 26647.
A. maculatus Lindl.
An epiphyte with red flowers ; common. Rusa-Bimalpur, Oct. 1958,
Panigrahi 16921 ; Namchick, Oct. 1959, Rao 20169.
A. maculatus Lindl. var. stenophylla C. B. Clarke
An epiphyte with small red flowers ; rare. Chennhang, June 1961,
Deb 26181.
A. masoniae Kurz
A creeper on rocks, with red flowers ; scarce. Nampong-Pangsu-
pass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20157.
A. philippinensis C. B. Clarke
An epiphyte with solitary, blood red flower with long peduncle ;
scattered. Raho-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26424.
A. superba C. B. Clarke
An epiphyte with flowers with pinkish, brown or deep red streaks ;
scarce. Khela-Khonsa, Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14481 ; Chenglang-Khela,
Oct. 1959, Rao 20270.
Boeica filiformis C. B. Clarke
A herb in moist situations in the ground floor of the forest ; flowers
small, pink ; scarce. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20022 ;
Jadua, July 1961, Deb 26681 ; Lailongsong, 510 m, June 1961, Deb
25825.
Boea multiflora R. Br.
A herb in fruits. In moist places. Lailongsong ; 510 m, June 1961,
Deb 25828.
Chirita oblongifolia (Roxb.) Sinclair
C. acuminata R. Br.
A succulent herb with yellowish white flowers ; scarce. Nampong-
Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20020.
C. hookeri C. B. Clarke
A herb with yellowish white flowers with grey lines inside the corolla ;
common. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20079.
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
271
C. macrophylla Wall. var. macrophylla
A succulent herb with violet flowers ; common. Jangkeng village,
June 1961, Deb 25849 ; Raho-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26449.
C. macrophylla Wall. var. tirapensis (Panigr.) Deb et Dutta
Comb. & Stat. nov.
Basionym : Chirita macrophylla Wall, subsp. tirapensis Panigr.
in Bull. Bot. Soc. Bengal 21(1) : 32, 1967.
A herb with bluish purple or violet tinged flowers. This is reduced
here to a variety as it does not deserve a higher taxonomic position on the
basis of taxonomic differences, from the type variety. Most of the
differences enumerated by the author (l.c.) are of no taxonomic signi-
ficance. Glabrous stem and lesser lobation of the calyx only appear to
stand as the difference. Being the only flowering material available
for describing the new taxon, Deb 26312 treated as paratype should have
been treated as the holotype in place of Panigrahi 14795 which does not
have any flower.
C. polyneura Miq. var. thomsonii C. B. Clarke
A herb with violet tinged flowers. Khonsa-Laju, June 1961, Deb
25979.
C. pumila D. Don
A herb with violet flowers; rare. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20071 ; Chenglang-Khela, Oct. 1959, Rao 20262 ; Chennhang, June
1961, Deb 26179.
C. urticaefolia Buch.-Ham. ex D. Don
A tall herb with yellow flowers ; common. Namchick-Chenglang,
Oct. 1959, Rao 20212.
Loxostigma griffithii (Wight) C. B. Clarke
A herb with violet flowers. Noglo-Laju, June 1961, Deb 26375.
Didymocarpus punduanus Wall, ex DC.
A herb about 30 cm in height in white flowers ; scarce. Jangkeng
village, June 1961, Deb 25851, Kanubari, July 1961, Deb 26760.
Lysionotus serrata D. Don
An epiphytic shrub in violet-pink or bluish-pink flowers ; common.
Raho, July 1961, Deb 26384 ; Longsek hillock, 1500 m, June 1961, Deb
25738 & 25750 ; Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26542 ; Jadua, July 1961, Deb
26659 ; Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26276.
272 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
L. turnifolia DC.
A shrub in pinkish white flowers ; common. Khonsa-Kheti, Aug.
1958, Panigrahi 14515; Chegum-Wakka. July 1961, Deb 26492,
Rhynchotechum ellipticum (Wall, ex Dietr.) A. DC.
An undershrub in small reddish or pink red flowers. Forms under-
growth in the forest ; common. Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 20001 ;
Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20023 ; Pungchow, July 1961,
Deb 26572.
Orobanchaceae
Aeginetia indica Linn.
A light pinkish coloured root parasite with whitish violet flowers,
with long pedicel ; scarce. Chenglang-Khela, Oct. 1959, Rao 20287 ;
Soha village, Oct. 1959, Rao 20368.
Geraniaceae
Geranium nepalense Sw.
A diffused herb, with long peduncled orange coloured flowers ; scarce.
Raho, July 1961, Deb 26383.
Balsaminaceae
Impatiens acuminata Benth.
A small herb in violet or pinkish-red flowers, in moist places
in diffused light. Namsang-Soha, Oct. 1959, Rao 20341 ; Khonsa-Laju,
June 1961, Deb 26004 ; Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20080.
I. angustiflora Hook. f.
A herb with violet or yellow flowers. Forms societies in moist and
shaded regions ; common. Raho-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26409 ;
Khonsa-Laju, June 1961, Deb 25986.
I. assamica Brace
A herb with violet flowers. Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26710.
I. bella Hook. f. & Thoms.
A perennial herb with whitish pink to red flowers ; scarce. Rusa-
Bimalpur, Sept. 1958, Panigrahi 16964.
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
273
I. drapanophora Hook. f. & Thoms.
A herb with yellow, saccate flowers. Forms small societies; com-
mon. Noglo, June 1961, Deb 26337.
I. hypoleuca Hook. f.
A small prostrate herb with pink flowers with recurved spur ;
common. Khonsa-Laju, June 1961, Deb 25950; Tipang, June 1961,
Deb 25707 ; Khonsa, June 1961, Deb 25920; Jangkeng village, June 1961,
Deb 25848,
I. latiflora Hook. f. & Thoms.
A much branched succulent herb with red flowers with long curved
spur ; in moist situation, very common. Chenglang-Khela, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20286 ; Jangkeng village, June 1961, Deb 25847 ; Nampong-
Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20076 & 20077.
I. lutea Hook. f. & Thoms.
A herb with yellow flowers with a large conical sac ; common. Chenn-
hang, June 1961, Deb 26260 ; Chegum-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26471 &
26472.
I. marlanai Roxb.
A herb in flower; scarce. Raho-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26417.
I. porrecta Wall.
A small herb with mauve or violet tinged flowers ; common. Noglo?
June 1961, Deb 26313 ; Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20078 &
20089.
I. tripetala Roxb. ex DC.
A soft herfcr with pink flowers ; in moist and shaded regions forms
societies ; common. Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 20002 ; Deomali, Oct.
1959, Rao 20389 ; Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26039 & 26096.
I. urticifolia Wall.
A herb with swollen nodes ; scarce. Langsang forest, June 1961.
Deb 26135.
Boraginaceae
Cynoglossum wallichii G. Don
An undershrub, hairy all over, with bluish flowers; scarce. Khonsa-
Laju, June 1961, Deb 25984 ; Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26024 & 26066 ;
Langsang forest, June 1961, Deb 26137 ; Noglo, June 1961, Deb 26304.
274 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Tournefortia candollii C. B. Clarke
A rambling shrub with yellow flowers. Raho-Wakka, July 1961,
Deb 26392.
T. viridiflora Wall.
A scandent shrub with creamy white fruits ; scarce. Nampong-
Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20042 ; Niausa, July 1961, Deb 26557.
T. viridilora Wall. var. griffithii C. B. Clarke
A scandent shrub in fruit, rare. Lailongsong, 510 m, June 1961,
Deb 25787.
Labiatae
Ajuga bracteosa Wall, ex Benth.
A herb with white flowers ; rare. Noglo, June 1961, Deb 26356.
Calamintha gracilis Benth.
A herb, common. Jangkeng village, June 1961, Deb 26863.
Clinopodium umbrosum (M.-B.) C. Koch
Calamintha umbrosa (M.-Bieb.) Fisch. & May
An aromatic annual herb with pinkish white flowers ; common.
Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26071 ; Khonsa-Laju, June 1961, Deb 25981.
Dysophylla auricularia Bl.
A branching herb with white or pinkish flowers ; scarce. Margharita-
Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19932; Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26698;
Niausa, July 1961, Deb 26565.
Elsholtzia blanda Benth.
A much branched shrub with small, white flowers ; scarce. Noglo-
Laju, June 1961, Deb 26366 ; Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26522 ; Khonsa,
June 1961, Deb 25923.
Gomphostemma mastersii Benth. ex Hook. f.
A perennial herb with yellow flowers and with nodulose root, common.
Deomali, June 1961, Deb 25885.
G. parviflorum Wall, ex Benth.
An undershrub with yellow flowers ; scarce. Pungchow, July 1961,
Deb 26625 ; Margharita-Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao, 19951 ; Jadua-
Ranfera, July 1961, Deb 26663.
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
275
Leucas lavandulaefolia Rees
A small herb with white flowers ; scarce, Chenglang-Margharita &
Nampong, March 1958, Mur thy 12990.
Melissa axillaris (Benth.) Bakh. f.
Melissa parviflora Benth.
A diffused undershrub with white flowers and mostly in marshy places,
common. Khonsa-Kheti, Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14528 ; Langs ang forest,
June 1961, Deb 26115 ; Chegum-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26466.
Mosla dianthera (Buch.-Ham.) Maxim.
A small herb with white flowers ; common. Margharita-Jairampur,
Oct. 1959, Rao 19936 ; Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20083 ;
Niausa, July 1961, Deb 26563.
Nothochaete hamosa Benth.
A herb with pinkish white flowers ; common. Kothong, June 1961,
Deb 26043 ; Khonsa-Laju, June 1961, Deb 25954 & 26003.
Ocimum sanctum Linn.
A small aromatic shrub ; scarce. Chenglang-Margharita-Nampong,
March 1958, Mur thy 12991.
Paraphlomis rugosa Prain
A shrub with white flowers; common. Chegum-Wakka, July 1961,
Deb 26464.
Perilla frutescens (Linn.) Britt.
A herb. This species is cultivated along with paddy for seeds from
which oil is extracted. Soha village, Oct. 1959, Rao 20352.
Plectranthus griffithii Hook. f.
A herb about 1 m in height with pinkish flowers ; scarce. Nampong-
Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20070.
Salvia japonica Thunb.var. parvifolia Hamst.
A herb with pinkish red flowers ; scarce. Margharita-Jairampur,
Oct. 1959, Rao 19909.
Teucrium viscidum Bl.
An annual, in fruit; common. Jangkeng village, June 1961, Deb
25862.
276 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY _ Vol. 71 (2)
MONOCOTYLEDONS
Hydrocharitaceae
Ottelia alismoides (Linn.) Pers .
A hydrophyte with white flowers and ridged fruits ; common.
Namchick-Chenglang, Oct. 1959, Rao 20222 & 20223.
COMMELINACEAE
Aclisia umbellata (Clarke) Bruckner
A herb, in fruit. Fruits on maturity turn deep blue ; common.
Chenglang-Khela, Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14427 ; Chenglang, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20253 ; Deomali, Oct. 1959, Rao 20321.
Aneilema scaberrimum (Bl.) Kunth
A slender herb with small bluish flowers ; scarce. Jairampur, Oct.
1959, Rao 19998.
A. thomsoni C. B. Clarke
A herb with pink flowers ; very common. Langsang forest, June 1961,
Deb 26161.
Commelina paludosa BL
A perennial herb with blue or bluish white flowers ; common.
Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19999 ; Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20144 ; Longsek hillock, 1500 m, June 1961, Deb 25753.
C, maculata Edgew.
A herb with blue flowers. Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26204.
C. sikkimensis C. B. Clarke
A herb with small, bluish white or deep blue flowers ; scarce.
Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20073.
Floscopa scandens Lour.
A trailing herb among herbaceous bushes with bluish white or pin-
kish flowers ; mostly in wet places ; common. Margharita- Jairampur,
Oct. 1959, Rao 19953 ; Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao, 20032 &
20143 ; Chenglang-Khela, Oct. 1959, Rao 20272.
Forrestia mollissima (BL) Koorder. var. hispida (Less, et A. Rich.) Baker
A herb with violet flowers and fruits ; common. Chenglang, Oct.
1959, Rao 20229 ; Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20145 ;
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
277
Niausa, July 1961 , Deb26558 ; Longsek hillock, 1500 m, June 1961, Deb
25754.
Murdannia nudiflora (Linn.) Brenan
A small prostrate herb with small, bluish white flowers and fruits ;
common. Chenglang, Oct. 1959, Rao 20255 ; Jairampur, Oct. 1959,
Rao 19980 ; Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20081.
M. lariformis (Hassk.) Rolla Rao et Kammathy
A prostrate herb with violet flowers on humus cover; scarce. Lai-
longsong, 510m, June 1961, Deb 25836, Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19972.
Pollia hasskerlii Rolla Rao
Pollia aclisia Hassk.
A scandent herb with purplish white flowers and blue-black fruits in
the shade of the forest ; common. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959,
Rau20143A.; Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26092 ; Longsek hillock, 1500 m,
June 1961, Deb 25752 ; Pungchow, July 1961, Deb 26591.
P. sor^ogonensis Endl.
A herb with white flowers ; rare. Banfera-Kanubari , July 1961,
Deb 26750.
Streptolirion volubile Edgew.
A climber with pinkish, pale creamy or yellowish white flowers
subtended by a leafy bract at the base ; scarce. Kothong* June 1961,
Deb 26086 ; Khonsa-Laju, June 1961, Deb 25914.
Musaceae
Musa bulbisiana Colla.
A succulent herb with greyish green seeded fruits; edible. Rusa-
Bimalpur, Sept. 1958, Pani grain 17020.
M. rubra Wall, ex Baker
A wild annual herb ; scarce. Lailongsong, 510 m, June 1961, Deb
25838 ; Deb s.n.
M. sanguinea Hook. f.
An wild banana with small, thin, pale yellowish green fruits, common.
Chenglang-Khela, March 1958, Murthy 12947, 12948 & 12949.
278 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
M. velutina Wendl. & Drude.
An wild plantain with rosy red or pink fruits ; common. Nampong-
Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Kao 20164; Namchick-Chenglang, Oct. 1959,
Kao 20221 ; Deomali, Oct. 1959, Kao 20328 ; Rusa-Bimalpur, Sept.
1958, Panigrahi 17055 ; Deomali, June 1961, Deb 25902 & 25903.
ZlNGIBERACEAE
Alpinia allughas Rose.
A perennial herb with whitish pink or pinkish red flowers ; common.
Forms societies in swampy area . Jadua-Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26689.
A. malaccensis (Burm. f.) Rose.
A stout herb with dull yellowish or very pale brownish flowers and
globose fruits ; scarce. Nampong-Pangsupass, March 1958, Murthy
13007; Raho-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26443.
Amomum aromaticum Roxb.
A rhizomatous herb in fruit. Cultivated. Khela, June 1961, Deb
25939.
A. dealbatum Roxb .
A herb with yellowish white flowers ; rare. Banfera, July 1961, Deb
26711.
A. linguiferme (Roxb.) Benth.
A rhizomatous herb in fruits only ; scarce. Longsek hillock, 1500 m,
June 1961, Deb 25758.
Cautleya gracilis (Smith) Dandy
An epiphyte with yellow flowers ; rare. Noglo, June 1961, Deb
26358.
Costus speciosus (Koen.) Smith
A herb with white flowered spadix; rare. Pungchow, July 1961,
Deb 26577.
C. speciosus (Koen.) Smith var. argyrophylus Wall, ex Baker
A perennial herb with white flowered spadix ; scarce. Namchick,
Oct. 1959, Kao 20182 ; Pungchow, July 1961, Deb 26577.
Globba multiflora Wall, ex Baker
A perennial herb with orange yellow flower and fruits; scarce. Cheng-
lang, Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14473 ; Jangkeng village, June 1961, Deb
25872.
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
279
G. orixensis Roxb.
A perennial herb with yellowish or orange red flower ; scarce. Raho-
Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26444.
Hedychium cernuum Wight
A herb in fruit and with perennial rhizome ; scarce. Deb s.n.
H. coccinium Buch.-Ham. ex Smith
A herb. Deomali, June 1961, Deb 25904.
H. coccinium Buch.-Ham. ex Smith var. angustifolium Roxb.
A herb with blood red flowers ; rare. Wakka, Sept. 1958, Panigrahi
16902.
H. coccinium Buch.-Ham. ex Smith var. longifolium (Rose.) Baker
A tall herb with red flowers ; scarce. Jadua, July 1961, Deb 26655.
H. coronarium Koening
A herb in swamp and marshy area. Flowers white ; perianth sweet
scented; scarce. Chenglang-Khela, Oct. 1959, Rao 20288; Deomali,
Oct. 1959, Rao 20390.
H. marginatum Clarke
A herb with sweet scented flowers ; rare. Jadua-Banfera, July 1961,
Deb 26688.
H. stenopetalum Lodd.
A perennial herb with sweet scented white flowers ; scarce. Laju hills,
Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14691 ; Lailongsong, 510 m, June 1961, Deb 25832;
Wakka-Nagminu, July 1961, Deb 26548.
H. villosum Wall .
A herb with light brown flowers. Mostly on moist slopes and rocky
crevices ; scarce. Chenglang-Khela, March 1958, Mur thy 12939 ;
Wakka-Nagminu, July 1961, Deb 26547.
Hitchenia carey ana (Wall.) Benth.
A tall herb with slightly pinkish white flowers ; scarce. Jairampur,
Oct. 1959, Rao 20004.
Cannaceae
Canna flaccida Salisb.
An ornamental plant with rosy red flowers ; cultivated. Cheng-
lang-Khela, Oct. 1959, Rao 20284.
7
280 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Marantaceae
Phrynium placentarium (Lour.) Merr.
A perennial herb in inflorescence; forming large societies; common.
Lailongsong, 510 m, June 1961, Deb 25837 ; Longsek hillock, 1500 m,
June 1961, Deb 25759.
Liliacea
Asparagus filicinus Buch.-Ham. ex D. Don
A climber in open areas of the forest; scarce. Chennhang, June 1961,
Deb 26283 & 26288.
Dianella ensifolia Redoute
A perennial herb with small, bluish-white flowers and pale green
fruits ; rare; mostly on moist slopes. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20110.
Disporum cantoniense (Lour.) Merr.
Disporum pullum Salisb.
A herb in flowers and fruits ; fairly abundant. Langsang forest,
June 1961, Deb 26159 ; Raho-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26456.
Ophiopogon intermedius D. Don
A herb with white flowers : common. Chennhang, June 1961, Deb
26284.
O. wallichianus (Kunth) Hook. f.
A perennial herb with white flowers ; forms societies ; very common.
Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26285, 26286 & 26287.
Polygonatum brevistylum Baker
An epiphyte in flowers and fruits. Noglo, June 1961, Deb 26357.
This is of restricted distribution in Sikkim, Abor Hills, Nagaland
and Tirap.
Polygonatum oppositifolium (Wall.) Royle
An epiphyte in flowers and fruits. Pungchow, July 1961, Deb 26633.
Smilacina fusca Wall .
A herb in fruits ; forms an undergrowth ; common. Chennhang,
June 1961, Deb 26289.
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
281
Trilliaceae
Paris polyphylla Smith
A small herb in flowers and fruits ; as an undergrowth in the ever-
green forest ; scarce. Langsang forest, June 1961, Deb 26162 ; Wakka,
July 1961, Deb 26526 ; Chegum- Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26462.
Smilacaceae
Smilax lanceifolia Roxb.
A climber; in flower; scarce. Chegum- Wakka, July 1961, Deb
26489.
S. perfoliata Lour.
A climber ; in flower and fruit. Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19988.
S. zeylanica L.
A climber. Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26087
S. orthoptera A. DC.
S. roxburghiana Wall, ex Hook. f.
A spiny climber ; in fruit; scarce. Chenglang, March 1958, Murthy
12909 ; Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26228 ; Langsang forest, June 1961,
Deb 26156.
Araceae
Alocasia fornicata (Roxb.) Schott.
A herb. Wakka-Nagminu , July 1961, Deb 26546.
A. indica (Roxb.) Schott.
A tall herb in fleshy, golden yellow spathe ; scarce. Banfera-
Kanubari, July 1961, Deb 26751 ; Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26229.
Amorphophallus bulbifera (Roxb. )B1.
A herb in red fruits. Khonsa-Laju, June 1961, Deb 26011.
Arisaema consanguineum Schott.
A succulent herb with palmate and digitate leaves ; scarce. Langsang
forest, June 1961, Deb 26160 ; Chegum-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26496.
Colocasia atfinis Schott .
It is an extensively cultivated herb. Soha village, Oct. 1959, Rao
20357 ; Jangkeng village, June 1961, Deb 25874; Longsek hillock, June
1961, Deb 25760.
282 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (20
C. esculenta (L.) Schott.
A herb with large yellowish spathe ; scarce. Tipang, June 1961,
Deb 25712.
Homalomena aromatica Schott.
A herb with perennial root stock ; forms the ground cover ; scarce.
Banfera-Kanubari, July 1961, Deb 26752.
Pothos cathcarti Schott .
A branched climber ; in fruit ; common. Crushed leaves without
juice is commonly used as a bandage for sprain and bone fractures by the
Thangsias as a medicinal plant. Chenglang-Khela, March 1958, Murthy
12936 ; Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26093 ; Khonsa-Laju, June, 1961, Deb
26009.
P. scandens Linn.
An epiphytic herb ; in fruit ; common. Chenglang-Khela, March,
1958, Murthy 12936A; Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26290; Way to
Niausa, July, 1961, Deb 26560.
Rhaphidophora decursiva (Roxb.) Schott.
A large epiphytic climber ; in fruit ; common. Kothong, June 1961,
Deb 26088 ; Raho-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26445.
R. glauca (Wall.) Schott.
A small herb on dry mossy rocks. Pangsupass, March 1958, Murthy
13011.
R. hooker! Schott.
An epiphyte, very common. Pungchow-Niausa, July 1961, Deb
26652; Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26282.
Amaryllidaceae
Crinum pratense Herb.
A herb with white flowers and underground bulb. Cultivated mostly
in plains. Soha village, Oct. 1959, Rao 20371 ; Pungchow, July 1961,
Deb 26581.
Roxburghiaceae
Stemone tuberosa Lour.
A twiner: in fruit ; scarce. Lailongsong, 510 m, June 1961, Deb
25839.
THE FLORA OF II RAP FRONTIER DIVISION
283
Dioscoreaceae
Dioscorea anguina Roxb.
A twiner with creamy white flowers ; common. Deomali, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20319 ; Nampong-Soha, Oct. 1959, Rao 20348.
D. bulbifera Linn.
A large twiner with small white flowers ; scarce. Chenglang-Khela,
Oct. 1959, Rao 20302 ; Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 1997 4 ; Kothong, June
1961, Deb 26091 ; Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26199 ; Pungchow-Niausa,
July 1961, Deb 26650.
D. glabra Roxb .
A climber in flowers ; bulbils dark brown ; scarce. Margharita-
Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19927 ; Chenglang, Oct. 1959, Rao 20251.
D. hamiltoni Hook. f.
A twiner with small yellow flowers ; rare. Jairampur, Oct. 1959,
Rao 19983.
D. laurifolia Wall. ex. Hook. f.
A climber with small flowers, rare. Pungchow, July 1961, Deb
26589. This is a Malaysian plant recorded for India by Deb & Kataki
in Bull. Bot. Surv. India 5(2) : 163, 1963.
D. oppositifolia Linn.
A climber ; in fruit ; scarce. Jangkeng village, June 1961, Deb 25873.
D. pentaphylla Linn .
A climber ; in flowers and fruits ; scarce. Laju-Raho, Aug. 1958,
Panigrahi 14721, Chenglang-Khela, Oct. 1959, Rao 20301 ; Soha village,
Oct. 1959, Rao 20362.
Agavaceae
Fleomele angustifolia (Roxb.) N.E. Brown
Dracaena angustifolia Roxb.
A shrub; scarce. Pungchow, July 1961, Deb 26632.
P. petiolata (Hook, f.) N.E. Brown
Dracaena petiolata Hk. f.
A tall herb with dark green fruits ; rare. Deomali, Oct. 1959, Rao
20330.
284 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol 71 (2)
Palmae
Arenga saccharifera Labill.
A tree ; scarce. Chenglang, June 1961, Deb 26197.
Calamus erectus Roxb. var. macrocarpa (Griff.) Becc.
An erect palm with big bunches of brown fruits. Chenglang, Oct.
1959, Rao 20227.
C. flagellum Griff.
A straggler with prickly fruits ; prickles strong ; fruits edible ; com-
mon. Banfera-Kanubari, July 1961, Deb 26749 ; Margharita-Jairampur,
Oct. 1959, Rao 19957.
C. floribundus Griff.
A climber; common. Longsek hillock, 1500 m, June 1961, Deb
25756.
C. gracilis Roxb.
Cane ; prickles curved downwards ; inflorescence long pendent.
Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26714.
C. leptospadix Griff.
A climber ; in fruit, growing together on slopes. Common in humid
valleys. Jadua, July 1961, Deb 26654.
Didymosperma nana H. Wendle & Drude
A tree ; rare. Niausa-Wanu, Sept. 1958, Panigrahi 15078.
Licuala spinosa Wurmb.
A tree with bluish green fruits and circular leaves, fairly common.
Niausa-Wanu, Sept. 1958, Panigrahi 15076.
Pinanga gracilis Bl.
A common perennial shrub with female flowers in spike from the
lower nodes ; fruits oval, green, smooth ; Namsang-Soha, Oct. 1959, Rao
20351 A ; Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26715 & 26716.
Wallichia caryotoides Roxb.
A tree; in fruit; common. Chenglang, Oct. 1959, Rao 20228;
Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26099 ; Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26197.
W. densiflora Mart .
An evergreen shrub with red ripe fruits ; common. Namchick-
Chenglang, Oct. 1959; Rao 20220; Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26717;
Longsek hillock (Chenglang), 1500 m, June 1961, Deb 25757.
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
285
Hypoxidaceae
Hypoxis aurea Lour.
A herb with yellow flowers. Chennhang, June, 1961, Deb 26200 ;
Noglo-Laju, June 1961, Deb 26367.
Taccaceae
Tacca integrifolia Ker-Gawl.
A perennial herb with pink to chocolate brown flowers ; rare.
Jadua-Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26666.
T. laevis Roxb.
A perennial herb with winged fruits ; fairly common. Niausa-Wanu,
Sept. 1958, Panigrahi 15068.
Orchidaceae
Acampe longifolia (Lindl.) Lindl.
Saccolabium longifolium (Lindl.) Hook. f.
A large epiphyte in young fruits and greenish pink flower buds;
scarce. Namchick-Changlang, Oct. 1959, Rao 20219.
Agrostophyllum khasianum Griff.
An epiphytic on trees ; pseudo-bulb 15 cm long, flower white, sessile,
Deomali, Oct. 1959, Rao 20329 ; Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26718'.
Arachnis flos-aeris (L.) Reichb. f.
An epiphyte ; in fruit ; rare. Namchick, Oct. 1959, Rao 20208.
Arundina graminifolia (D. Don) Hochreutiner
Terrestrial among the grasses on the hill slopes with bright mauve or
lilac red flowers, labellum white with reddish tinge. Nampong-Pangsu-
pass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20074, 20075 ; Margharita-Jairampur, Oct. 1959,
Rao 19958.
Bulbophyllum confertum Hook, f .
A lithophyte. Grows in clusters on rocks with small pseudo-bulb
and a single leaf ; scarce. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20137.
B. reptans Lindl.
An epiphyte ; pseudo-bulb one flowered ; scarce. Chennhang, June
1961, Deb 26301.
286 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
B. triste Reichb. f.
An epiphyte in light yellow flowers ; fairly common. Pungchow,
July 1961, Deb 26635.
Bulleyia yunnanensis Schltr.
Grows on trunks of trees and in humus covered boulders in mixed
forest at 1000-2700 m in altitude ; flowering in June-August. A native
of China recorded from India by Deb in Ind. For. 91(3) : 193, 1965.
Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26291.
Calanthe densiflora Lindl.
Terrestrial among grasses on hill slopes ; rare. Nampong-Pang-
supass, Oct. 1959, Rao 201 11.
Coelogyne fuscescens Lindl.
Terrestrial in humid environment ; in fruit ; fairly common.
Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20118.
C. ovalis Lindl.
A lithophyte with creamy-white flowers ; Labellum with chocolate
brown ridges on the upper surface ; the rim is covered with hairy out-
growth ; scarce. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20123; Soha
village, Oct. 1959, Rao 20381.
C. prolifera Lindl.
An epiphyte ; pseudo-bulb two-leaved. Longsek hillock, 1500 m,
June 1961, Deb 25766.
Cryptochilus lutea Lindl.
An epiphyte ; in fruit; scarce. Raho-Vokanoska, Aug. 1958, Pani -
grahi 16866.
C. sanguinea Wall.
An epiphyte with yellow flowers ; common. Chennhang, June 1961,
Deb 26295.
Cymbidium simulans Rolfe
An epiphyte with pinkish-yellow flowers; fairly common. Jadua-
Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26690.
C. devonianum Paxt.
An epiphyte; in fruit ; fairly common. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct.
1959, Rao 20115.
THE FLORA OF T1RAP FRONTIER DIVISION
287
Dendrobium acinaciforme Roxb.
An epiphyte with White flowers with brownish patch in the labellum;
and long stalked fruits; rare. Niausa-Wanu, Sept. 1958, Pcmigrahi
15100 ; Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26719.
D. calceolaria Carey
An epiphyte; in fruit; common. Banfera-Kanubari, July 1961,
Deb 26753.
D. candidum Wall .
An epiphyte. Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26720.
D. chrysanthum Wall, ex Lindl.
An epiphyte; in fruits ; rare. Khonsa, June 1961, Deb 25914.
D. lituiflorum Lindl.
An epiphyte ; common. Chenglang, Oct. 1959, Rao 20242 ; Soha
village, Oct. 1959, Rao 20370A.
D. nobile Lindl.
A lithophyte ; not rare. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao
20114.
Ephemerantha macraei (Lindl.) P. F. Hunt & Summerhayes
Dendrobium macraei Lindl.
An epiphyte ; common. Nginu, Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14840;
Margharita-Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19963 ; Wakka-Nagminu ,
July 1961, Deb 26550.
Eria acervata Lindl.
A small epiphyte ; in flower; common. Wakka-Nginu, July 1961,
Deb 26551.
E. flava Lindl.
A lithophyte with brown fruits; rare. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct.
1959, Rao 20116.
E. paniculata Lindl. ex Wall.
An epiphyte on Saurauja sp. with small whitish flowers ; rare. Khonsa-
Laju, June 1961, Deb 26013 ; Deomali, June 1961, Deb 25907.
E. rufmula Reichb. f.
An epiphyte or a lithophyte with small white and axillary flowers ;
rare. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20131 ; Deomali, Oct.
1959, Rao 20326.
288 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (2)
Galeola falconeri Hook. f.
A very delicate terrestrial orchid with small white flower buds ; not
scarce. Nampong-Pangsupass, March 1958, Murthy 13009.
Gastrochilus calceolaris (Smith) D. Don
An epiphyte ; scarce- Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26231 ; Langsang
forest, June 1961, Deb 26164.
Liparis assamica K. & P.
An epiphyte in small yellow flowers ; scarce. Chenglang, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20236 ; Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26100.
L. caespitosa (Thouars) Lindl.
An epiphyte in Small, greenish yellow flowers and green fruits ;
common. Chennhang, June 1961, Deb 26293.
Malaxis wallichii (Lindl.) Deb
A terrestrial orchid in flower. Longsek hillock, 1500 m, June
1961, Deb 25765.
Oberonia emarginata King & Prantl.
An epiphytic orchid in flower. Longsek hillock, 1500 m, June 1961,
Deb 25767.
O. iridifolia (Roxb.) Lindl.
An epiphyte with inconspicuous flowers ; scarce. Kothong, June
1961, Deb 26097.
O. myriantha Lindl .
An epiphytic orchid ; scarce. Soha village, 1067 m, Oct. 1959, Rao
20379.
Ophrys muscifera Huds.
An epiphyte on mossy bark of trees with greenish-yellow flowers ;
rare. Nagnu, August 1958, Panigrahi 14851.
Otochilus porrecta Lindl.
An epiphyte with a very long pendulous inflorescence ; fruits pinkish ;
fairly common. Soha village, 1067 m, Oct. 1959, Rao 20373.
Phajus longipes (Hook, f.) Holtt.
A ground orchid on very damp and moist slopes with lemon-yellow
flowers. Nampong-Pangsupass, March 1958, Murthy 13005.
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
289
Pholidota articulata Lindl.
An orchid on dry soil or hard rocky slopes or epiphytic; in fruit ;
common. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20092 ; Nampong-
Pangsupass, March 1958, Murthy 13010 ; Khonsa-Laju, June 1961,
Deb 26012.
P. imbricata (Roxb.) Lindl.
An epiphyte with pink flowers and brown bracts ; not scarce. Soha
village, Oct. 1959, Rao 20374 ; Margharita-Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao
19960.
Pleione praecox (Smith) D, Don
An epiphyte ; scarce. Deomali, June 1961, Deb 25910.
Podochilus cultratus Lindl.
An epiphyte ; rare. Deomali, June 1961, Deb 25906.
Polystachya wightii Reichb. f .
An epiphyte ; scarce. Jadua-Banfera, July 1961, Deb 26692.
This has been reported from Malabar only. This record from NEFA
is interesting.
Sarcanthus filiformis Lindl.
An epiphyte with whitish purple flowers ; not rare. Pungchow-Niausa,
July 1961, Deb 26653.
S. subulatus (Bl.) Reichb. f.
An epiphyte with white flowers and fruits ; not scarce. Jadua-Banfera,
July 1961, Deb 26691 ; Deomali, Oct. 1959, Rao 20327 ; Chennhang,
June 1961, Deb 26292.
Schoenorchis gemmata (Lindl.) J. J. Smith
An epiphyte with violet flowers and white labellum ; rare. Khonsa-
Laju, June 1961, Deb 26014.
Stauropsis undulatus Benth.
An epiphyte ; not rare. Chenglang, Oct. 1959, Rao 20244.
Thunia marshalliana Reichb. f.
An epiphyte ; in fruit ; perianth persistent ; common. Nagnu-Niausa,
Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14844.
Uncifera acuminata Lindl .
Saccolabium acuminatum (Lindl.) Hook. f.
An epiphyte ; not rare. Langsang forest, June 1961, Deb 26 165.
290 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
U. obtusifolia Lindl.
An epiphytic orchid ; not rare. Chenglang, Oct. 1959, Rao 20245.
Vanda caerulea Griff, ex Lindl. (Eng : Blue Vanda)
An epiphyte with showy light blue flowers and long, ribbed fruits ;
not rare, Chenglang, Oct, 1959, Rao 20241.
Cyperaceae
Carex indica Linn.
A perennial herb ; rare, Chenglang, Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14458.
C. insignis Boott.
A herb; common along foot paths. Langsang forest, June 1961,
Deb 26163.
C. remota Linn.
A herb ; very common. Chegum-Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26498,
C. spiculata Boott. var. nobilis (Boott.) Hook. f.
A perennial herb with greenish-brown fruits. Laju-Raho, Aug. 1958,
Panigrahi 14742.
C. cyperoides (Linn.) O. Kuntze var. evolutor C. B. Clarke
An annual in moist situation; not rare. Noglo, June 1961, Deb
26302.
Cyperus diffusus Vahl
A herb with umbellate heads ; common. Longsek hillock, June 1961,
Deb 25761.
C. iria Linn.
A perennial herb in swampy area; common. Khonsa, June 1961,
Deb 25924.
C. uncinatus Poir.
An annual herb in brown alluvial soil ; common. Longhoi-Rusa,
Sept. 1958, Panigrahi 16765.
Fimbristylis diphylla (Retz.) Vahl
A herb ; common. Khonsa, June 1961, Deb 25925 ; Longsek hillock,
1500 m, June.1961, Deb 25764.
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
291
Mariscus cyperinus Vahl var. bengalensis C. B. Clarke
A perennial herb; not rare. Kheti-Tinchha, Aug, 1968, Panigrahi
14576.
Selena cochinchinensis (Lour) Druce
A tall herb in wet places ; common. Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao
19991.
Gramineae
Agrostis myriantha Hook. f.
A herb; common. Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26102; Langsang
forest, June 1961, Deb 26157.
Arthrazon midus (Steud.) Hochst.
A scandent herb in forest clearances; common. Nampong-Pang-
supass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20086.
Bambusa nutans Wall, ex Munro
A tall climbing bamboo ; not rare. Chennhang, June 1961, Deb
26226.
B. pallida Munro
A tall bamboo about 20-30 m in height, bracts small ; not rare.
Soha village, Oct. 1959, Rao 20364.
Capillipedium assimile (Steud.) A. Camus
An annual semiprostrate herb; spikelets greyish green, crowded
awned ; common. Wakka, July 1961, Deb 26525.
Centotheca lappacea (Linn.) Desv.
A grass of the way side with broad leaf ; very common. Nampong-
Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20052.
Coix lacryma-jobi Linn.
A perennial grass in swampy places and on hill slopes ; not scarce.
Niausa, July 1961, Deb 26559.
C. lacryma-jobi Linn. var. mayuen (Romanet) Stapf
A cultivated grass. This is chiefly used for the packing of beverage.
Soha village, Oct. 1959, Rao 20366.
Dendrocalamus hamiltonii Nees et Arn. ex Munro
A tall bamboo ; in flower. It is one of the commonest bamboo in
Assam; very common. Pungchow, July 1961, Deb 26634 ; Tipang,
540 m, June 1961, Deb 25714 ; Banfera-Kanubari, July 1961, Deb 26755.
292 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
D. hookeri Munro
A bamboo ; bracts pinkish-brown. Shoot is not edible. Fruits
are in cluster at the nodes, ash grey in colour, not rare. Kothong,
June 1961, Deb 26089 ; Namsang-Soha, Oct. 1959, Rao 20349 ; Soha
village, Oct. 1959, Rao 20365.
Digitaria ternata (A. Rich.) Stapf ex Dyer
It is one of the commonest way side grasses ; very common.
Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20085.
Echinochloa colonum (Linn.) Link.
A common grass. Namchick, Oct- 1959, Rao 20171.
Eleusine indie a (L.) Gaertn.
A small grass in marshy places ; not rare. Namchick, Oct. 1959,
Rao 20172
Eragrostis unioloides (Retz.) Nees ex Steud.
A prostrate grass all along the way side with a panicle of spikelets ;
common. Margharita-Jairampur, Oct. *1959, Rao 19923 ; Nampong-
Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20068 ; Namchick, Oct. 1959, Rao 20186.
Hordeum vulgare Linn.
Cultivated along the moist soil slopes and rocky edges ; common.
Khela, March 1958, Murthy 12882.
Imperata cylindrica (Linn.) P. Beauv. var. major (Nees) C. E. Hubb.
A perennial herb; common. Kothong, June 1961, Deb 26023.
Microstegium vagans (Nees ex Steud.) A. Camus
A perennial herb, hairy ; common. Niausa-Wanu, Sept. 1958,
Panigrahi 15006.
Neyraudia reynaudiana (Kunth) King ex Hitch.
A tall grass about 2-3 m in height ; among bushes ; very common.
Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao 20162 ; Namsang-Soha, Oct.
1959, Rao 20343.
Oplismenus compositus (Linn.) P. Beauv.
A very common herb. Longsek hillock, 1500 m, June 1961, Deb
25762.
Oryza sativa L.
Cultivated paddy, awnless on dry hill slopes. Soha village, Oct.
1959, Rao 20367.
THE FLORA OF TIRAP FRONTIER DIVISION
293
Panicum auritum Presl. ex Nees
A perennial tall grass ; not rare. Namchick, Oct. 1959, Rao 20187.
Panicum khasianum Munro ex Hook, f .
A herb. Aug. 1958, Panigrahi s.n,
P. miliaceum Linn.
An annual herb, cultivated, grain awnless. Khonsa-Laju, June 1961 ,
Deb 26008.
P. montanum Retz.
A herb ; not common. Banfera-Kanubari, July 1961, Deb 26754.
Paspalum conjugatum Berg.
A perennial creeper amidst rocks ; common. Nampong-Pangsupass,
Oct. 1959, Rao 20046.
P. scrobiculatum Linn.
A herb. Sometimes cultivated ; common. Longsek Hillock,
1500 m, June 1961, Deb 25763.
Phragmites karka (Retz.) Trin. ex Steud.
A tall perennial grass. A dominant species from Niausa. Lailong-
song, 510 m, June 1961, Deb 25835 ; Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19996.
Pogonatherum crinitum (Thunb.) Kunth
A herb on rocks of slopes. Common. Kothong, June 1961, Deb
26101 ; Khonsa-Laju, June 1961, Deb 26010.
Pseudoechinolaena polystachya (H.B.K.) Stapf
A herb, very common. Pungchow, July 1961, Deb 26636.
Pseudostachyum polymorphum Munro
A bamboo about 5-10 m in height ; common. Chenglang-Khela,
Oct. 1959, Rao 20299.
Saccharum arundinaceum Retz.
Common plant in clearances. Nampong-Pangsupass. Oct. 1959,
Rao 20159.
Sacciolepis indica (Linn.) A. Chase
A herb ; common. Lailongsong, 510 m, June 1961, Deb 25833.
Setaria glauca (Linn.) P, Beauv.
An annual grass; common. Kheti-Tinchha, Aug. 1958, Panigrahi
14577 ; Laju-Raho, Aug. 1958, Panigrahi 14750.
294 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
S. italica (Linn.) P. Beauv.
A herb ; cultivated widely for grains used in preparing beverages ;
Khonsa, June 1961, Deb 26007.
S. pallide-fusca (Schum.) Stapf et C. E. Hubb.
An annual grass ; common. Nampong-Pangsupass, Oct. 1959, Rao
20088.
S. palmifolia (Koen.) Stapf
A tall perennial grass ; common. Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19992 ;
Rusa, Sept. 1958, Panigrahi 16996.
Sporobolus fertilis (Steud.) W. D . Clayton
A gras s . Pan igrah i s . n .
Themeda villosa (Poir.) A. Camus
A tall grass forming mostly impenetrable thickets ; common.
Margharita-Jairampur, Oct. 1959, Rao 19930.
Thysanolaena maxima (Roxb.) O. Kuntze
One of the very common long grasses in this area. Nampong, Oct.
1959, Rao 20163 ; Lailongsong, 510 m, June 1961, Deb 25834.
References
Literature consulted in connection
with determination, correct nomenclature
and distribution of the taxa are very
numerous and are considered unneces-
sary to cite here. Those publications
which have a direct bearing on the text
of the paper are cited below.
Chowdhury, A. K. (1960) : A short
note on Shorea assamica (Makai). Ind.
For. 86 : 205-206.
Deb, D. JB. (1965) : Plants new to
India, ibid. 91(3): 193-194.
— & Kataki, S. K. (1963):
Interesting plants from Eastern India — 1.
Bull. Bot. Surv. India 5(2) : 163-164.
& Dutta, R. M. (1964) :
A new species of Boehmeria Jacq. from
North East India. Ind. For. 90(11):
782-784.
(1965) : Pauia Deb et
Dutta — A remarkable new genus and
species from Tirap Frontier Division,
ibid. 91(6) : 363-366.
(1965) : Interesting plants
from Eastern India II. Bull. Bot. Soc.
Bengal 19(1) : 37-38.
(1969) : An addition to
Umbelliferae from North East India.
J. Sen Mem. Vol., pp. 421-424.
Hut chinson, J. (1959) : The families
of Flowering Plants, ed. 2, I-II.
Oxford Univ. Press, London.
Mehra, P. N. (1961) : Proc. Indian
Sci. Cong. Assocn. 48th Session, 1961(2) :
130.
Panigrahi, G. (1967) : Two new taxa
from Eastern India. Bull. Bot. Soc.
Bengal 21(1): 29-32.
& Joseph, J. (1966) .; A
botanical tour to Tirap Frontier Division,
NEFA (India). Bull. Bot. Surv. India
8(2) : 142-157.
Miscellaneous Notes
1. FURTHER ATTEMPTS TO DETERMINE THE FOOD HABITS
OF THE INDIAN RHINOCEROS AT KAZIRANGA
In an earlier communication (Brahmachary et al 1971) the attempt
to determine the food habits of the Rhino in Jaldapara, was described.
It was concluded that observing the microscopic sections of the
vegetal remains in the dung was a gocd technique, especially for
Jaldapara or other similar places where direct observation is difficult
due to the nature of the terrain and vegetation.
The present report describes results of a study in Kaziranga
during about a fortnight in January, 1972. Unlike at Jaldapara, d r:ct
observation at Kaziranga turned out to be very simple because one
can approach the rhinos to very close quarters while mounted cn
elephants and the grass being short in certain seasons, the actual grass
species fed on by the rhinos can be noted. Over the years the
mahouts have also noticed these grasses and plants so that the food
habits are largely known. The following are our findings.
Plants germinated in the dung:
This, according to us, is the most important result of the present
study. Old dung balls, examined on breaking open, revealed plants
germinated inside them. We did not examine the old dung balls in
Jaldapara and therefore missed this aspect. At Arimora (Kaziranga)
startlingly large numbers of grass stems, producing roots and stems
with leaflets at nodes, were found inside the dung balls. We also
detected two dicot seedlings. As we were not equipped for carrying
these back to Calcutta and cultivating them, we tried to bring only
a few packed in a very small tin container and practically none
survived the ordeal.
Only one grass stem with leaves, on being transplanted to a pot
in Calcutta, grew up to a certain small but detectable size. Although
precise identification is not possible under these circumstances, this
grass seemed to be almost certainly Cynodon dactylon, one of the
common lawn grasses. Practically all other grass stems germinated
inside the dung balls at Arimora were of a different type. They
were certainly of the creeping type and from the description
8
296 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
‘rooting at nodes’ by Mahanta and Neog (1968) seem to be
‘Alaijabari’ ( Drymaria cordata).
The interesting point about this preliminary observation is that
this can be developed into a technique for determining the food
habits in terrain where direct observation is difficult or impossible
for, the plants can be cultivated, locally, in pots or in plots of
garden; secondly, the implication points out a new means of dispersal
for grass and is therefore of ecological importance. Bor (1960)
describes the different mechanisms for dispersal of grass through animal
agents but dispersal through alimentation has not been considered
probably1 because the herbivores in general (like cattle or deer) digest
the grass thoroughly. The rhino and the elephant pass on large
undigested pieces through their alimentary canal and into the dung.
We did not find germinating grasses inside the old elephant dung
but the large quantities observed in rhino dung effectively prove that
this animal plays a role in the dispersal of grass.
Solanum khasianum (Ban-Begun) is often found to grow around
rhino dung, as has also been noticed by the local people. We noticed
20 cases of such luxuriant growth of this plant around rhino dung.
Not a single case of such growth was found in the few plants we
noticed in places where no dung had been excreted. We also assured
that the young plant were growing from inside the dung ball, and
not from the soil below. Birds can also drop the seeds, accidentally,
on the fresh dung but this is unlikely in so many instances. The
Rhino, therefore, seems to act as an agent for dispersal and
concentration of this plant. Apparently, the dung also acts as a
source of manure and/or moisture, which in turn may affect the
chemical contents of the plant like solasodine (see later).
Direct observation : -
We observed Rhinos feeding voraciously on Flemingia lineata, a
small shrub. Even plants partially burnt black and apparently totally
dry were plentifully eaten. This is the only non-grass species we
could directly observe during the actual process of eating. The
prehensile upper lip is very handy in manipulating such shrubs and
clumps of tall grasses.
The hhinos fed on almost all the grassy growths, the very short
grasses creeping on the soil as well as tall grasses from part of
their menu. All these grasses can easily be identified if the
inflorescence is available.
We could collect inflorescence of the following 11 species while
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
297
Mahanta and Neog (loc. cit.) list 26 species of common grasses.
Attempts at other seasons, in particular early monsoon, would no
doubt be very fruitful for collecting the remainig species:
local name
[one of these, locally known as Birina, was identified by the
Botanical Survey of India, Calcutta, as Vetiveria zizuniodies although
according to Mahanta and Neog (loc. cit.) it is Erianthus elephant ius ].
Examination of vegetal remains in the dung:
It is well known at Kaziranga that the rhinos now plentifully eat
water-hyacinth. We also detected numerous remains of water-hyacinth
strips in various dung balls near the marshy places.
More than 1500 undigested stems were collected from various dung
balls but it became soon apparent that the technique of examining
the microscopic sections of these remains would be unnecessary in
case of the openland rhino at Kaziranga. Unfortunately very few
stems in good condition were found in the dung balls collected from
the woodland. Of the 12 stems which allowed sectioning only
3 were dicot species.
Chemical studies, (a) It is of great interest to study the nutritional
and other chemical aspects of the local plants consumed by the
wild animals. Apart from the question of wild game management,
such studies might lead to the discovery of superior food for domestic
livestock and of useful drugs.
Mahanta and Neog (loc. cit.) sum up the data on total nitrogen
content, mineral content etc. in some of the commoner grasses of
Assam. An important new aspect of study will be the estimation
of certain amino-acids like lysine, cystein, methionine etc. Lysine-rich
corn or wheat has appeared as a great boon. Harpstead (1971) reviews
298 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
the experiments on lysine-rich com and shows how it may spell the
difference between life and death. Leaf protein is however rich in
lysine (Pirie 1969) (unlike seeds, grains etc.). Again, in certain
grasses, TCA-soluble and TCA-insoluble nitrogen are about equal in
amount (Pirie 1971) so that free amino-acids are present in large
quantities and are therefore worth estimating.
( b ) These studies can be carried out only in a local laboratory
but we have made some preliminary tests with the leaves of solanum
and lawn grass ( Cynodon dactylori) obtained from the outskirts of
Calcutta (which may thus differ from the Kaziranga samples).
One dimensional paper chromatography showed only one or two
large free pools of amino-acids in solanum leaves while 5 such pools
were traceable in Cynodon. With 2-dimensional chromatography, the
latter would probably resolve a larger number of amino-acids. None
of these amino-acids seemed to coincide with ‘marker’ lysine.
(c) Remarks:
Laijabari grass ( Drymaria cordata) is the richest in calcium of all
the Assam grasses which are generally calcium poor (Mahanta & Neog
1968). It is good that rhinos eat this species plentifully.
Water-hyacinth is not a very good food for its dry weight is only
about 9-10% and cf that about 10% is protein (Matai, pers. comm.).
Good grass is preferable to this pestiferous weed.
Cynodon dactylon (dub or lawn grass) can produce HCN (Bor,
loc. cit.) under certain conditions of drying so that in certain years,
such as cf extreme drought, places with extensive growth of this grass
should perhaps be burnt off.
Solanum khasianum has gained some reputation as the source of
an alkaloid (solasodine) which may act as a precursor of steroid
hormones and as such may be of interest as a commercial source for
drug manufacturers (Maiti et ah 1964; Maiti & Mathew 1967; Saini
1966). As manuring has an influence on the alkaloid content (Biswas,
pers. comm.), the vigorously growing plants around the rhino dung
are worth studying.
Indian Statistical Institute,
Calcutta 700 035,
July 29, 1972.
R. L. BRAHMACHARY
B. RAKSHIT
B. MALLIK
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
299
References
Biswas, R. C. : Personal Communi-
cation.
Bor, N. L. (1960) : The grasses of
Burma, Ceylon, India and Pakistan.
Pergamon Press, Oxford.
Brahmachary, R. L., Mallik, B. &
Rakshit, B. (1971) : An attempt to
determine the food habits of the Indian
Rhinoceros. J. Bombay nat. Hist .
Soc.610): 558-560.
Harpstead, D. D. (1971) : Scientific
American, p. 34, August 1971.
Mahanta, K. C. & Neog, A.K. (1968):
Agriculture and Animal Husbandry in
Assam. Thacker Spink.
Maiti, P. C., Mookerjee, S., Mathew,
R. & Henry, A. N. (1964) : Current
Science, 33 : 730.
— — & Mathew, R. (1967) :
Rich sources of Solasodine. ibid. 36 :
126.
Matai, S. : Personal Communication.
Pirie, N. W. (1969) : International
Botanical Congress, All Congress Sym-
posium, World Food Supply.
(1971) : Leaf Protein, IBP
Handbook No. 20, Blackwells.
Saini, A. D. (1969) : Alkaloidal con-
tent of Solanum khasianum Clarke.
Current Science 36 : 600.
2. ON THE INCREASING OCCURRENCE OF TYPICALLY
PLAIN S-BIRDS IN THE KUMAON HILLS
For many years now, I have been bird-watching in the Lake region
of Kumaon, comprising the five lakes of Sattal, Naukuchiatal, Bhimtal,
Khurpatal and Nainital as well as the surrounding hills. The area under
observation extends from 1286 m (4220') which is the level of the Sattal
lakes, to 2591 m (8500'), the height of Cheena Peak above Nainital, and
has direct access to the plains by means of several steep river valleys.
In the fifties and early sixties I had made a detailed list of the birds
occurring in the area with some notes on distribution, status and habitat,
but since 1964 I have been abroad, returning to India about once every
two years for a month or two, generally in winter and early spring.
During each visit, I have made new entries in my list, of birds not observed
before in the area. Surprisingly almost all of the ‘new ’ birds are typical
low-elevation species, no new records of high-elevation species having
been made during the same interval. A list of these birds that have now
become resident in the area is given below :
1. Purple Sunbird Nectarinia asiatica . Although this bird is known
to ascend to 5000' in the Himalayas (Whistler 1941) it is mentioned here
as its status has changed from that of a scarce summer visitor to a com-
mon resident at Bhimtal, 4340' (1320 m).
2. Crowpheasant Centropus sinensis. This bird is also known to
occur up to 6000' (1830 m), but whereas it had never been observed in the
Lake Region before, a pair have now taken up residence at the head-
quarters of the Bhimtal lake.
3. Blackwinged Kite Elanus caeruleus. This is also a low-elevation
bird that was only rarely seen before, but now regularly breeds at Bhimtal.
It is however, not resident, being only rarely seen in winter.
300 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
4. Grey Partridge Francolinus pondicerianus. A party of these
birds has been resident at Mehragaon above Bhimtal for many years,
and are not newcomers like the others. However, this is probably a new
altitudinal record, as both Whistler (1941) and Salim Ali (1946) give 1500'
as the height to which this bird ascends in the Himalayas and Mehragaon
is situated at 4500' (1370 m).
5. Whitebreasted Waterhen Amaurornis phoenicurus. This bird
was first observed in 1962 at Bhimtal. Since then observations were
sporadic, although it was also seen at Naukuchiatal, 4240' (1292 m).
Since about 1969 it has firmly established itself at both these lakes and is
now a common resident having displaced the Waterhen ( GaJlinula chloro -
pus) to some extent in the process. According to Whistler (1941), it
does not ascend the hill ranges.
6. Paddybird Ardeola grayii. It was first observed at Bhimtal in the
winter of 1969/70. Now a pair has taken up residence and are reported
to breed there.
7. Cattle Egret Bubulcus ibis. This is the most spectacular of the
‘new arrivals ’, as they are so conspicuous. Three of these herons first
arrived at Bhimtal in 1970. They were almost always to be seen in the
Stretch of partly cultivated land, swampy in some places, to the
north of Bhimtal, occasionally visiting either Sattal or Naukuchiatal.
Now their numbers have increased to a flock of about 12 birds that roost
every night in the tall Eucalyptus trees bordering the Bhimtal lake.
According to my brothers, they not only breed here but there is another
flock of about 12 birds also in the area. Both Whistler and Salim Ali
(1941 & 1946) state that this is a plains bird not found in the hills.
All the birds mentioned above are now conspicuous resident birds
that have definitely not escaped observation before. There is therefore
not the slightest doubt that these birds are newcomers to the area and
have become residents since about 1969. Two other low-elevation
species have also been sighted here recently, but I presume that they were
stray specimens. The Coppersmith Megalaima haemacephala) and
the Blackheaded Oriole ( Oriolus xanthornus). A solitary specimen
of the former was observed in January 1972 above Bhimtal at 1475 m
(4800'). Salim Ali (1946) and Whistler give 2500' (762 m) and 3000'
(915 m) respectively as the height this species ascends to in the Outer
Himalayas . A Black-headed Oriole in juvenile plumage was collected at
Bhimtal in December 1970.
From the above data one can conclude that many low-elevation
species have started extending their range to higher elevations during the
past few years. Other observations in the same area support this view.
The Green Bee-eater ( Merops orientalis) has become fairly common now
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
301
at Bhimtal, where it was formerly a rare straggler. The Blossomheaded
Parakeet ( Psittacula cyanocephala ) is also no longer a scarce summer
visitor but a common resident at Bhimtal.
On the other hand, high-elevation species such as the Red-crowned
Jay ( Garrulus bispecularis) — formerly a regular winter visitor to the
Bhimtal/Sattal region and now absent for some years— and the various
Thrushes such as the Greywinged Blackbird ( Turdus boulboul), the
Greyheaded Thrush (Turdus rubrocanus) and Tickell’s Thrush ( Turdus
unicolor) — formerly very common in winter and now rarely seen — have
definitely undergone a change in status here. Another surprising
development in this connection is the rapid decline of the Chukor (Alec-
toris graeca) in areas where it once used to be plentiful. The barren
hill slopes above Bhimtal and Sattal used to resound to its calls but since
the past five or six years it has been neither seen nor heard. No expla-
nation can be given for its disappearance, as its former habitat has not
changed and to my knowledge it has been neither hunted nor trapped.
I am unable to give any definite reasons why the abovementioned
birds have started extending their range to higher elevations. There
has not been any major change in habitat during the past few years and
the slow but steady denudation of forests in the hills does not seem to have
been accelerated. This denudation however, is not so much due to felling
of trees as it is to lopping for fodder and fuel and grazing by cattle and
goats, which reduces trees to 4 tooth-picks ’ and prevents any new growth
from coming up. Such a forest is one only by name and not by function .
It is possible that this type of deforestation has had at least some effect
on the climate of the area, as rainfall at Nainital has gone down from the
customary 2700 mm to about 2000 mm per year. Of course these
‘ changes ’ in climate are much too short-term to be taken seriously yet
as they could very well be temporary variations caused by other factors ;
however, this extension of range by the abovementioned birds, could
indeed be interpreted as further evidence that the climate in these hills
is undergoing a slow change.
Of course, one could also conjecture that due to various reasons,
conditions in the surrounding plains have become less attractive to the
birds in question and thus forced some of the birds to ‘ take to the hills \
This argument is weakened by the fact that the new arrivals seem to
thrive here and do not give the impression of being reluctant
immigrants.
It Would therefore be very interesting to find out whether similar
changes have also been observed in the bird population of other hill-
stations and if so what explanations can be put forward there.
No noticeable change has been observed in the butterfly population
of the region, on which we are also keeping a close watch. However,
butterflies, not being as conspicuous as birds, could escape notice if
302 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Fo/. 71 (2)
new species begin establishing themselves. Besides, they are generally
bound to specific food-plants and would therefore take longer than
birds to establish themselves in a new area. Of course, this only applies
to butterflies that do not migrate or wander about a great deal.
It is my sincere hope that these ‘ new developments ’ within the bird
community are not an indication of other, more profound changes to
come in the ecology of the area. Even a slight change in climate would be
disastrous to the fruit orchards, as the temperate fruit trees growing at
lower elevations such as apples, plums and apricots would suffer. What
makes the new development so important is the number of species in-
volved, all occupying more or less separate ecological niches.
A much more detailed and thorough study of the above phenomenon
is necessary before any firm conclusions can be drawn and then it would
be wise to carry out such an investigation within the framework of the
general ecology of the area. As neither my family members nor I am in
a position to undertake further studies of this phenomenon yet, it was my
aim to draw the attention of others to what is perhaps a new problem.
4 The Retreat \ VICTOR SMETACEK
Bhimtal P.O. 263136,
Dist. Nainital, U.P.,
April Z 0, 1973.
References
Ali, Salim (1946) : The Book of Whistler, H. (1941) : Popular Hand-
Indian Biros. 4th ed. Bombay Natural book of Indian Birds. 3rd ed. Gurney
History Society, Bombay. and Jackson, London.
3. TAWNY EAGLE AS A SCAVENGER
Eagles are rare birds. They are not common in and around busy
cities. Yet a place about three miles south-west of Poona offers
a spectacle probably uncommon in any part of the country. On view
here is a 200-strong contigent of Tawny Eagles ( Aquila rapax ).
The Tawny Eagle is known to be a scavenger and an opportunist.
Its opportunistic behaviour is best seen at this place where waste material
from a chicken-dressing plantprovides itwith regular and easily obtainable
food. Abundant food supply has attracted a large number of eagles
who feed in the early morning and then spend the day perched on nearby
trees and hill-sides. They are well-accustomed to human presence. I
have approached them quite close for photography. Their number has
apparently deterred vultures.
By their habits birds of prey are solitary creatures. But in this case
plentiful food supply has probably reversed this natural tendency. The
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
303
eagles have become quite sociable and are often seen sitting quite close
to each other. It will also be interesting to see if this easy life has dimi-
nished their breeding urge. For even during the breeding season, i.e.
November to April, no nest was found in the vicinity of this site. Eagles
were never seen carrying nesting material or to build nests. In fact a
majority of them used to roost at night on nearby hill slopes and
apparently never left the site at all. The problem however, needs fuller
investigation.
184 Shaniwar Peth, PRAKASH V. GOLE
Poona-30,
May 18, 1973.
4. STOMACH CONTENTS OF THE GREAT INDIAN BUSTARD,
CHORTOTIS NIGRICEPS (VIGORS)
The Great Indian Bustard, Choriotis nigriceps (Vigors) is one of the
most magnificent of Indian birds. Its dwindling population has been
a matter of great concern to conservationists for a number of years.
Through the kindness of Shri H. C. Gupta, Divisional Forest Officer,
Jodhpur and Shri Y. D. Singh, Zoo Supervisor, Jodhpur, I had an oppor-
tunity of examining the stomach contents of a bird caught in August,
1970, nearPokaran (Jaisalmer District, Rajasthan). The stomach was full
being filled with Uromastix hardwickii , scorpion fragments, sun-spider
( Galeodes oriental is), beetles ( Gymnopleurus ? sindensis and Atactogaster
sp.), fruits of Capparis sp., and a few seeds of undetermined species.
The weight of each item is given in Table 1 below. Before taking the
weight the stomach contents had been preserved in rectified spirit and
then dried by soaking the moisture on a blotting paper. As such the
data is only suggestive of the quantity of food a bird may require for one
feed.
Table 1
Food items and their weight
Seeds negligible in weight
Total
106*80 gm 99*97%
304 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
I am thankful to Dr. B. K. Tikader and Dr. T. G. Vazirani for identi-
fication of spider and beetles respectively.
Desert Regional Station, P. D. GUPTA
Zoological Survey of India,
Jodhpur,
February 22, 1973.
5. THE NILGIRI WOOD PIGEON, COLUMBA ELPHINSTONII
(SYKES) ON SALSETTE ISLAND, BOMBAY
On 17th November 1973, we, along with Mr. Bansi Mehta, sat up
in a forest covered valley in the Borivli National Park to see a leopard
which was said to pass through the valley. As dusk fell several birds
(mainly jungle crows) arrived to roost for the night on the trees in the
valley. Among these, we were pleasantly surprised to see a Nilgiri
Wood Pigeon Columba elphinstonii (Sykes) land on a tree close to where
we were sitting. The large size, and ‘ chessboard 5 patch on the hind
neck were very definitive. The bird spent the night on the tree and the
identification was confirmed when it left early in the morning. The
handbook of the birds of India and Pakistan 3 : 133 gives the northern
range of the species as ‘ c. 19°N. lat. (a little beyond Bombay) \ A bird
of higher elevation1 it is rarely recorded below c. 600 m and the specimen
seen was probably a bird in passage. The species is an addition
to the birds of Bombay and Salsette Islands.
Bombay Natural History Society,
Hornbill House,
Bombay 400023 .
Department of Pharmacology,
Seth Gordhandas Sunderdas Medical College,
Parel, Bombay-400012,
February 2, 1974.
6. THE BROWNWINGED STORKBILLED KINGFISHER
PELARGOPSIS AMAUROPTERA (PEARSON) IN ORISSA
While on a visit to the mangrove forests of the Chandbali coast of
Orissa (c 20°47'N ; 86°55'E) we saw a large species of Kingfisher un-
familiar to us . A pair was collected and later identified at the Society
as the Brownwinged Storkbilled Kingfisher. This remarkably handsome
J. C. DANIEL
S. R. AMLADI
i Found at Khandala, Matheran and common at Mahableshwar — Salim Ali.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
305
bird was quite common in the area as were the other four species that we
noticed, namely the Small Blue Kingfisher (. Alcedo atthis), the White-
breasted Kingfisher ( Halcyon smyrnensis ), Blackcapped Kingfisher
{Halcyon pileata) and the Whitecollared Kingfisher {Halcyon Moris),
The latter is also an addition to the Orissa bird list.
The Brownwinged Kingfisher has not been recorded south-west of
the Sunderbans in West Bengal but is likely to occur in suitable biotopes
along the coast south of the present location. A race of the White-
collared Kingfisher is known from the west coast of India.
Bombay Natural History Society, J. C. DANIEL
Shahid Bhagat Singh Road, S. A. HUSSAIN
Bombay 400 023,
February 12, 1974.
7. DEVELOPMENTAL PERIOD AND FEEDING HABITS OF
BANK MYNA, A GRID OTHERES GIN G INI A NU S (LATHAM)
IN PUNJAB
Developmental period and feeding habits of bank myna, Acrido-
theres ginginianus (Latham) were made during 1970-1972. The birds reared
1-2 broods from Mid April to August, each time laying 2-5 eggs. The
incubation was done by both sexes. The egg stage lasted for 13 '3 days.
Newly hatched young were pink, naked and with eyes closed. Nestlings
opened their eyes within 5-6 days. Both sexes fed the nestlings c. 15
times/hour. Feathers started sprouting within first week. Nestlings
left the nest in 20*4 days. The nesting success Was 38.5% (37/96).
Fruits of winegrapes {Vitis vinifera L.), seeds of pearl millet {Fennisetum
typhoideum L. C. Rich.), maize {Zea mays L.), wheat {Triticum aestivum
L.), berries of banyan {Ficus benghalensis L.), peepul {Ficus religiosa L.),
carpenter ants {Camponotus compressus Fab.), black ants {Monomorium
indicum Forel.), house-fly {Musca domestica L.), rat-tailed larvae of
hover fly {Eristalis tenax L.), tiger beetles {Cicindela sexpunctata Fab.),
mole crickets {Gryllotalpa africana Beauvois), grasshoppers {Oxya
nitidula Walker), caterpillars, ground and dungbeetles (unidentified)
constituted the food of birds.
The bank myna, Acridotheres ginginianus (Latham) which is
found only in North India and Pakistan (Ripley 1961) has now become a
pest of grapes. The birds puncture and eat the berries and also feed
the berries to the nestlings. Notes on the breeding season, nesting habits
and clutch-size have been given by Whistler (1963) and Ali (1964). The
306 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, VoL 71 (2)
information regarding the developmental period and month-wise feeding-
habits were lacking, and are presented in this paper.
Six colonial nesting sites were selected for studying the developmental
period. The feeding-habits of the bird were observed every month
throughout the year by direct observations in the field, as well as by
examining the gut contents of 159 birds1.
The birds reared 1-2 broods during Mid April-August. Incubation
was started as soon as the first egg was laid. The interval between two
eggs was 1-2 days. In one nest it was as long as 6 days. Both sexes
incubated. The birds sit facing the entrance when incubating. During
incubation and early stage of nestling development, the female stayed in
the nest at night. The eggs hatched after 13*3 days (n = 19)2 and empty
egg shells were thrown off the nest. The hatching of young took place on
different days. Newly hatched nestlings were naked (except small white
tufts of nestling down on head and back), pink, and had the eyes closed.
The eyes opened in 5-6 days . Week-old nestlings excreted when handled ;
possibly a defensive act. The feathers on the body appeared within a
week when the length of tail was 2-3 cm. The white wing patch appeared
on 12th day and by 17th day, the whole of the body except the anal area
was feathered. Both sexes fed the nestlings and the rate of feeding was
15 times/hour. Nestlings left the nest in 20*4 days (n = 12)3. The
nesting success was 38*5% (37/96).
The Bank Myna is omnivorous. Grapes which are quite economi-
cally important was heavily attacked by the birds in June. During the
rest of the year, except for occasionally feeding on pearl millet in the
field, insects especially carpenter ants, house-flies, hoverflies, lepido-
pterous caterpillars, crickets, grasshoppers and berries of peepul and
banyan constituted the major part of the diet. Small sized insects
e.g. house-fly, ants and caterpillars were found whole in the gut but
larger insects like grasshoppers and mole crickets, were broken up. At
times, the guts were full with larvae of Eristalis tenax L., larvae, pupae
and adults of house-fly, lepidopterous caterpillars, grasshoppers ( Oxya
nitidula Walker), carpenter ants and mole crickets. Feeding mostly
took place near ditches, ponds, rubbish and dung heaps. The birds also
followed cultivators and grazing cattle to take the disturbed insects.
The birds are serious pest of grapes in June and in other months they
took mostly harmful insects. It is, therefore, suggested that measures
regarding control of birds should be confined to the month of June.
1 Except from mid May to mid June (peak nestling feeding period) when 7 birds
a week were shot, 3 birds a week were shot throughout the year.
3 n = 19 n here stands for the number of eggs. The 13*3 days incubation period
is the average of the incubation period of 19 eggs of different nests.
3 n = 12 n here stands for the number of nestlings i.e. 12. The 20*4 days nestling
period is average of the nestling period of 12 nestlings of many nests.
Miscellaneous notes
307
Acknowledgements
We are thankful to Dr. O. S. Bindra, Professor and Head, Department
of Entomology, Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana, for providing
necessary facilities during this study and to Shri Sham Dass and Shri
Kabal Singh for help.
Asst. Ornithologist,
Dept, of Zoology,
Punjab Agric. University,
Ludhiana.
Entomologist (Research),
Dept, of Entomology,
Punjab Agric. University,
Ludhiana,
June 11, 1973.
Table
Food taken by the bank mynas in different months during 1970-71
G. S. SIMWAT
A. S. SIDHU
308 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Refer
Ali, S. (1964) : The bank myna,
Acridotheres ginginianus (Latham). The
Book of Indian birds, p. 30. Bombay
Natural History Society, Bombay.
Ripley, S. D. (1961) : A synopsis of
N CES
the Birds of India and Pakistan, p. 302 .
Bombay Natural History Society,
Bombay.
Whistler, H. (1963) : Popular Hand
Book of Indian Birds, pp. 205-6.
Oliver & Boyd, Edinburgh and London.
8. STUDY ON THE STOMACH CONTENTS OF COMMON
BAYA, PLOCEUS PHILIPPINES (LINNAEUS)
While studying the stomach-contents of the Common Baya (56 adults
and 80 chicks) in the paddy cultivating area, of Orissa and West
Bengal, the following observations on the food of the birds were made :
In the case of very young chicks (3 to 6 days), the stomach-contents
consisted mainly of weed seeds (Graminiae) and a number of minute
stone chips. In some cases, a few broken mollusc-shells were also found.
As the chicks grew up (7 to 10 days) a change of food was also
noticed. The contents were mostly insect fragments. With develop-
ment, the intake of mollusc shells increased. The insects were mostly
of the Orthoptera group (in nymphal stage). In one case, one egg case
of a spider was also found. At the fledgling stage a few soft rice grains
could be traced in some cases. Stone chips were still present but gra-
dually their number was reduced in all the stomachs of the developed
nestling. The mollusc shells were of two types, Gastropoda and
Pelecypoda.
In the non-breeding adults (collected in October from rice cultiva-
tion), the stomach-contents consisted mostly of rice grains together with
2 or 3 stone chips in each stomach. In a very few cases, insects were also
found. The insects were nymph of Jassids, Hemipterous nymphs and
Lepidoptera larvae which were associated with the paddy ear-heads and
seemed to have been accidently swallowed. The stomach-contents of the
male bird during the breeding season were mostly rice grains, a little
amount of insect fragments, few stone-chips and mollusc shells. In
one case the number of pebbles was fifteen.
Breeding female : Same as breeding male. In some cases, mostly
weed seeds were found, perhaps for feeding new born chicks.
Zoological Survey of India,
Calcutta,
May 30, 1973.
A. K. MUKHERJEE
B. C. SAHA
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
309
9. THE RECORD (?) SALT WATER CROCODILE
( CROCODYLUS POROSUS SCHNEIDER)
In January 1973, while on a survey of the status of the Estuarine
Crocodile in the Rhitar Kanika Island area of Orissa, off the Chandbali
Coast ( c 20° 47'N ; 86°59/E) we noticed a large crocodile skull in the
Palace of the Raja of Kanika at Chandbali. The skull measured 1 metre
from tip of snout to occiput and the ratio of skull length to total length
generally being 1:7 in this species, the animal when alive would have
measured approximately 7 metres ( c . 23 ft). According to the Raja of
Kanika :
4 This crocodile was about 23 to 24 ft. and was known as Kalia. It was
very dark skinned. It was very notorious. It had a range of 10 miles in the
Dhamra river. It eluded Shikaris for about 50 years. My grandfather, my
father’s elder brother and my father tried to shoot it. Nobody succeeded.
The story goes that it was shot by the Captain of a ship which was on its run
from Chandbali to Calcutta. Previously small coasting tramps had regular
sailing between Chandbali and Calcutta. The crocodile after being hit and
wounded went into the bank where there was a lot of reed and dry grass. The
villagers set fire to the grass and the crocodile died. This crocodile was well
known to every boatman and every villager.’
The Raja has also given us some interesting information on the
Crocodiles of the area which we quote
In Bhitar Kanika island one could see 30 to 40 crocodiles and if a shoot-
ing party went round they could come back with 15 to 20 crocodiles mostly
juveniles. We once shot 3 big crocodiles which were 16-footers. This 16 to
18 ft. crocodiles are the standard full grown crocodiles which were found in
fairly large numbers. Those which were slightly bigger than these had defi-
nitely marked territories about 6 to 8 miles in a reach of a particular river.
One may find one big crocodile who will be the monarch of that territory and
it will soon become well-known and notorious causing danger to the lives of
cattle and human beings specially the cattle. When I was a boy, it was said
to be dangerous to wash vegetables, rice etc. by dipping the baskets overboard
in the river. It was also dangerous to loiter or stand on the bank near the
water specially if the bank is gradually sloping to the water because even if
you are 2 or 3 feet from the water, the crocodile will rush with such velocity
that you will be caught and the water brought up the bank by the backwash
you will lose your balance. They aim at their prey from a great distance may
be several hundred feet and dive and come up may be few inches from the
target. I had once this experience. I was scanning the river all around to
locate a crocodile which had been floating down the river a minute or two
before and had gone under water. To my surprise it came up two or three
feet from my feet on the river bank. I was saved as there were some formi-
dable stump of the thick mangrove forest after the tops were cut to make a
310 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol 11 (2)
clearing rising above the water like a fence between me and the crocodile. It
could never had passed through this barrier. The stumps were about 3 to 4 ft.
in height. I saw the head of the crocodile for a second or two. The hissing
noise of the deep breathing of the crocodile made me look near my feet on
the other side of the fence. While I was looking at the river the crocodile had
come close to me and I had remiined unaware. I was told that this crocodile
was 27 ft. It was killed by some East Bengal trappers who used harpoon,
torch light and guns for killing such crocodiles for the skin. This poaching
is still going on, but as the crocodiles are few now, they do not attract many
of these poachers nowadays.
The island of Bhitar Kanika was in the past a sanctuary for the
Rajas of Kanika in times of stress. The deep channels surrounding it
and its impenetrable forest made it a perfect hide-out. The Rajas in the
settled years of this century had converted it into a wildlife reserve and
had introduced Sambar and Chital. The fine mangrove forests on the
Island are being rapidly removed especially from the side of the western
silted channel. The forest on the mainland opposite the east face of
the island is also being cut down. There are no forests on other main-
land areas opposite the Island.
In our trips along the creeks leading into the Island we were shown
several well used crocodile paths leading to belts of thick undergrowth
through which the animals had tunnelled in. They are said to stay in this
cover. The crocodile that we saw in Shivadri Creek had rushed into the
water from one such lair. The presence of juvenile crocodiles probably 3 to 5
months old in the creeks of Bhitar Kanika suggests that this uninhabited
Islands is used for nesting by the crocodile. The local forest guards
some stationed for many years in the area believe that the crocodiles go
up the creeks to lay eggs and that eggs are laid within the forests, but
none of the forests guards nor the local people of whom we enquired,
have seen the nest or the eggs of the crocodile. However hatchlings
have been caught during the rainy season from the heads of the creeks
deep within the Island.
During our stay we saw only ten crocodiles (4 adults and 6 juveniles)
in an area where they were said to be once abundant and are still con-
sidered to be fairly numerous. One of the reasons for the small number
seen is probably the large number of country boats loading wood from
the bank opposite to the Island and the disturbance that resulted. The
areas where they are usually seen sunning themselves at low tide had
been abandoned along the main eastern channel.
In a very informative little booklet entitled ‘ The coast and Tidal
Regions of Orissa (Their problem with an approach to Regional plan-
ning) ’ the Raja of Kanika, Shri S. N. Bhanja Deo, speaks of the wild
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
311
life position in former years especially of the blackbuck herds seen
commonly along the sea coast which have now become extinct. The
position of wild life has deteriorated and there is no doubt that the
crocodiles in the Bhitar Kanika area are also rapidly on the decline and
if present conditions persist we do not expect them to last beyond another
decade.
We believe there are two main reasons for the decline, habitat destruc-
tion and poaching. The estuarine forest composed mainly of mangroves,
Avicennia officinalis , A. alba , Sonneratia apetala , Rhizophora mucro-
nata , R. caudelaria , Ceriops roxburghiana and littoral species such as
Hibiscus tiliaceus, Xylocarpus obovatus, Excoecaria agallocha, Thespesia
populnea, Strychnos nux-vomica and others are, if timber-bearing, removed
for firewood. Wood felling was the major forestry activity in the
Bhitar Kanika area during our visit and from the quantity that was being
removed in large country boats it was evident that the forests of the main-
land to the east and north of the Island would not last long. The forest
on the Island, especially that on the west are being surreptitiously removed
as they are accessible from across the shallow creek.
The estuarine forest is essential for the crocodile as it provides cover
and more important, nesting facility. Removal of the forest would mean
automatic extinction of the crocodile.
Poaching directly affects the breeding potential of the population
as the large adults are selectively removed. Animals over 4 metres in
length are now rare. Crocodiles which were well known in particular
localities and used to be shown to visitors have been poached. The me-
thod used is harpooning at night when the animals lie out on mudbanks.
The poacher shines a powerful torch from a boat on the crocodile lying
ashore and the animal instead of escaping into the water keeps moving
inland away from the light source making it easy to approach and
harpoon and to later recover it from the water. There is very little
chance of saving the large crocodiles as long as trade is permitted in
crocodile artifacts within the country. Export of crocodile leather is
prohibited but not material made out of crocodile leather.
The crocodiles of Bhitar Kanika are perhaps the only remaining
representatives of the salt water crocodiles (Crocodylus porosus) left in
the peninsular area of India. The reason they have managed to exist so
far is probably because the area is very poorly developed. To permit
this endangered species to continue to exist in the area which has little
potential for use by man, it is only necessary to have some minimal
management procedures put into effect. The following recommendations
may help :
(1) The mangrove forests of Bhitar Kanika Island and surrounding
areas should be retained. This would not only help to
9
312 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 11 (2)
preserve the crocodile but also act as a buffer to save agri-
cultural lands lying to their west from the effect of the severe
cyclonic storms which periodically ravage the area.
(2) The Bhitar Kanika Island and the surrounding areas should be
declared a sanctuary and left inviolate so that the crocodile’s
breeding areas are undisturbed.
(3) Trade in any form in crocodile skin should be prohibited by
the State and Central Governments.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful for the financial support from World Wildlife Fund,
India, with which the survey was undertaken.
We are indebted to Shri Sailendra Narayan Bhanja Deo, Raja of
Kanika, whose assistance at every stage made the survey possible. We are
grateful to the Chief Conservator of Forests, Orissa and the many mem-
bers of the staff of the Forest Department who generously assisted us in
many ways during the survey.
Bombay Natural History Society, J. C. DANIEL
Hornbill House, S. A. HUSSAIN
Shahid Bhagat Singh Road,
Bombay-400 023,
May 5, 1973.
10. NOTE ON CRISTICEPS HALEI DAY, 1888 (PISCES :
CLINIDAE) A JUNIOR SYNONYM OF SPRINGERATUS
XANTHOSOMA (BLEEKER), 1857
Bleeker (1857) first described Clinus xanthosoma from Java. Later
Gunther (1861), Herre (1936, 1939, 1953) and de Beaufort (1951) des-
cribed it as Cristiceps xanthosoma from East Indies and Philippines.
Day (1888) recorded a new clinid fish Cristiceps halei from Colombo.
Since Day (1889) C. halei has not been recorded and the type speci-
men of the species is also not traceable. Shen (1971) recorded it from
Philippine and Formosa and created a new genus Springer atus for Clinus
xanthosoma Bleeker.
MISCELLANEOUS notes
313
While collecting shore fishes from Shingle island (Gulf of Mannar),
very near to the type locality of Cristiceps halei Day, one specimen of
Springer atus xanthosoma (Bleeker) was obtained. The live specimen
was deep orange with three rows of blue spots on the body and a blue
blotch over the pectoral peduncle. But this coloration fades in formalin
and the preserved specimens are uniformly yellow. Probably this may
be the reason for the confusion in the identity of the Species.
Cristiceps halei Day and Springeratus xanthosoma (Bleeker) from
Shingle island differ slightly in fin formula (C. halei : D. Ill, XXVII, 4 ,
P. 13 ; V. 1/2 ; C. 14 ; A. II, 19., S. xanthosoma : D. Ill, XXVI, 6, P. 11-
13 ; V. I, 2 ; C. 13 ; A. II, 20) and in coloration (no white marking in
S. xanthosoma ). But these variations are within the range for this
species which has a wide distribution from Philippines to Indian coast.
However, Cristiceps halei Day is not a valid species and is here con-
sidered as a junior synonym of Springeratus xanthosoma (Bleeker).
As it is the first record of this species from the Indian coast since Day
(1889) and as there are some variations, a short descriptions is given.
Family : Clinidae
Springeratus xanthosoma (Bleeker)
(Fig. I, A)
Clinus xanthosoma Bleeker, Nat. Tijds Ned.-Ind., 13 : 340, 1857 ; Java.
Cristiceps xanthosoma Gunther, Cat. Fish. Br. Mus . 3 : 273, 1871 (compiled). Herre,
Philippine J. Sci. 70 : 321, 1939 ; Luzon. Weber and de Beaufort, Fish. Indo-
Aust. Archipel. 9 : 390-391, 1951 ; Java. Herre. Check-list of Philippine fishes,
788, 1953 ; Luzon.
Cristiceps halei Day, Fishes of India , Supplement : 799, 1888 (Colombo). Fauna
of British India, Fishes, 2 : 326, 1889.
Springeratus xanthosoma Shih-Chieh Shen, Rep. Inst. Fish. Biol. Minis. Econ.
Affairs Natn. Taiwan Univ., Vol. 11, No. 4 : 16-39, 1971.
D. Ill, XXVI, 6 : A. II, 20 ; P. 11-12 ; C. 13 ; V. 3 ; Ltr. 8/1/38.
Head 23*8 in standard length, 24T in total length ; depth 23*8 in
standard length and 24*1 in total length. In head length eye 30*0, snout
25*9, first dorsal spine 70'0, second dorsal fin height 30*0, third dorsal
fin 50*0, pectoral fin length 70'0, ventral fin 65‘0, caudal peduncle 45*0 ;
all measurements in per cent.
Mouth upturned, cleft of mouth in line with upper margin of eye ;
preopercle with three flat spines, opercle smooth ; gill membrane free
from isthmus ; scales cycloid, minute ; cheeks and opercle devoid of
scales ; first dorsal fin originates above preopercle, first and second
314 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
spines long, third spine short and not connected with second dorsal
fin which is confluent with third dorsal ; last ray of third dorsal attached
to caudal peduncle ; anal fin free from caudal peduncle ; an anteriorly
curved intromittent organ with a stout base and pointed tip just posterior
to anus (Fig. I, D) ; caudal fin emarginate, caudal and pectoral fin rays
not divided ; lateral line originates above opercle, curves below sixth
spine of second dorsal fin and terminates on caudal peduncle with 25
tubules ; anterior tubules with double pores and posterior ones with single
pore ; nasal opening tubular, nasal cirri divided at tip ; orbital cirri flat,
tip divided, 0-75 in eye (Fig. I, B) upper and lower jaws stout ; premaxil-
lary teeth minute, 2-3 rows ; vomerine teeth minute, in two patches on
each sides ; mandible with 2-3 rows of acicular teeth (Fig. I, C) ; maxil-
lary membrane present ; gill rakers ten, short, stumpy, with minute simple
spines on each side ; only one lower arm of gill arches-
Fig. 1. A. Springeratus xanthosoma (Bleeker) CMFRI. No. 119/636 ; total length
49 mm. ; male ; Shingle island (Gulf of Mannar).
B. Enlarged view of upper part of head showing nasal and orbital cirri.
C. Dentition : (i) Maxillary teeth, (ii) Vomerine teeth, (iii) Mandibular
teeth.
D. Vent region : (i) Intromittant organ, (ii) Vent.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
315
Deep orange mottled with three rows of blue spots, pectoral peduncle
and upper corner of opercle with deep red blotches ; all this colour fades
in formalin and the preseived specimen appears yellow.
Habitat : In coral stones and sea weeds along the shore.
Distribution : Philippines, Java, Ceylon and south-east coast of
India (Gulf of Mannar).
Material: C.M.F.R.I./F. No. 119/636; Total length 49 mm;
male ; Shingle Island, (Gulf of Mannar) ; 24-xii-69.
Acknowledgements
I am thankful to Dr. S. Z. Qasim, Director and Dr. R. V. Nair,
Deputy Director, Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute,
Mandapam Camp, for going through the paper and offering their com-
ments. My thanks are also due to Dr. Shih-Chieh Shen of National
Taiwan University and Dr. Victor G. Springer of U.S. National Museum
for identifying the specimen and expressing their views.
Regional Centre of Central R. S. LAL MOHAN
Marine Fisheries Research Institute,
Marine Fisheries Post,
Mandapam Camp, Tamil Nadu,
July 27, 1971.
References
Beaufort, L. F. de (1951) : In: L. F.
de Beaufort and W. M. Chapman. The
fishes of the Indo-Australian Archi-
pelago, 9 : 390-391, E. J. Brill, Leiden.
Bleeker, P. (1857) : Descriptions
specierum piscium Javanesium. Nat.
Tijdsch. Ned. Ind. 13 : 340-341.
Day, F. (1888) : A natural history of
the fishes known to inhabit the seas and
fresh waters of India, Burma and Ceylon.
Suppl. Fish. India , pp. 779-816, London.
(1889) : Fauna of British
India. Fishes 2 : 326 (Fig. 106), London.
Gunther, A. (1861) : Catalogue of
the Acanthopterygian fishes in the col-
lection of the British Museum. 3 : 273,
London,
Herre, A. W. (1936) : Note on the
fishes in the Zoological museum of the
Stanford University. V. New or rare
Philippine fishes from the Herre 1933
expedition. Phil. J. Sci. 59(3) : 357-382.
— (1939) : Philippine biennis.
Philip. J. Fish. 70(4) : 315-372.
(1953) : Checklist of Philip-
pine fishes. U.S. Govt, printing Office.
Washington, D.C. pp. 1-788.
Shen, Shih-Chieh (1971) : Osteo-
logical study on Springeratus xanthosoma
(Bleeker) from the Indo-Pacific region,
exclusive of South Africa, Australia and
New Zealand. Rep. Inst. Fish. Biol.
Minis. Econ. Affrs. Natn. Taiwan Univ.
2(4): 16-39,
316 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
11. ON THE IDENTITY OF RAT-TAILED ANCHOVY
COILIA NEGLECTA WHITEHEAD, 1967
Whitehead (1967b) described a new species of rat-tailed anchovy,
Coilia neglecta from the collections of the International Indian Ocean
Expedition made during 1963-64, on the basis of one holotype and 10
paratypes. In these eleven specimens the number of post-pelvic scutes
is 8-9 ; however, in his key to ten species of Coilia (p. 30) he states that in
C. neglecta the number of post-pelvic scutes is 9-11. In the same key
he indicates that the number of post-pelvic scutes in C. dussumieri Val.
1848, is 6-8. In the two specimens of C. dussumieri described by him
earlier (RMNH 7073, Whitehead et al. 1966 ; MNHN 3749, Whitehead
1967a), the number of post-pelvic scutes is 8. In the 30 specimens of
C. dussumieri from Gollapalem (Krishna District, Andhra Pradesh),
all of which had pearly spots in fresh condition, the number of poSt-
pelvic scutes is 7-9. According to Whitehead’s Key, C. dussumieri is
distinguished from the other 9 species in possessing pearly spots on
flanks. Haneda (1961) identified them as light organs and according to
him ‘ — if this material is preserved in formalin for several months, the
golden orange colour of the luminous organ fades away completely, and
it becomes almost impossible to recognise the luminous organ on oper-
cular or body surface’ (p. 49-50).
Characters usually employed in distinguishing the species of Coilia
are : (a) number of ventral rays, ( b ) length of maxilla, (c) presence or
absence of pre-pelvic scutes, ( d ) number of pectoral filaments, ( e ) number
of abdominal scutes, and (/) gill rakers. A comparison of the characters
of C. neglecta Whitehead and C. dussumieri Val., shows considerable or
complete overlap in all biometric characters (Tables I and II) ; the only
positive difference between them is with regard to the pearly spots, which
are absent in C. neglecta . Examination of C. dussumieri collected from
Gollapalem shows that the pearly spots which are very distinct in fresh
specimens disappear partially or completely, after preservation in for-
malin, as observed by Haneda. Since the description of C. neglecta
was based on preserved material, and as stated earlier, the light organs
in C. dussumieri may disappear after preservation in formalin, C. dussu-
mieri could possibly be mistaken for C. neglecta , while working
on preserved material.
A pseudobranch is present both in C. neglecta (Whitehead 1967b)
and in the specimen of C. dussumieri in RMNH (No. 7073), but it was not
found in the lectotype of C. dussumieri (Whitehead 1967a).
In the circumstances, it is suggested that the validity of C. neglecta
remains doubtful until some stable characters are found to distinguish
it from C, dussumieri , because formalin-preserved specimens of
Lectotype Lectotype
Character C.neglecta Whitehead1 (MNHN3749)of (RMNH 7073) of C. dussumieri Va\.
C. dussumieri Val.2 Leptonuruschrysostigma (Gollapalem, n = 30)
Blkr. (= C. dussumieri )3
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
317
o
d.oo.S “ -h :s
vo
<Noo
+ +
I 10
— . !-h tJJ
' . Tj _ o C "*
■go m ^
<u 3 Q M ^ c» 00
S^Sis +«Cg++
£ O § ft;*!
G l-H
55 «
8 8
X> D
< &
I>
n7q 2
O.^ Os
I— ( >
VO
<N
• OV
ro i
<N oo
+ +
Os vo
erf
«S
111,'-
® U V I? " M Mi
£?•§•! 2i3£| 5
O ^ •— * »-i erf Fl
3 fl
*5, erf *5 3 3 erf -2
GjOoovhOidSg G3
S &«P *d a £ 3 64
Crf <»
<U
4)
•S
*n
a
3
Museum National d’ Histoire Naturelle, Paris.
Riksmuseum van Natuurlijke Historic, Leiden.
Table 2
318 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (2)
o
_*• co
CO
VO O
tS tsj
VO TJ T3
• <L> <U
cN n rj- tj- ^ oo ooco
• oj C3
^ "O T3
O oo co
co m
<N cs co
ovt>cb^vbtN6v«bocbt^ob
— < ,-H rHrtfCI VOCNtNCO
CO
c3
X
X<§
x ^
xx£$Jj§Sl
o fl § § d £ ^cg O
^ cd O O q-5 c
8 <u
a a <D
S-D-g
.2^ ctf
x .22
73. a ’’S
M 5-h
MX (tf
0 « S
X p. cS
1 I I
g<u ju
M tH t-(
a a a
H « « ^
Whitehead 1967a.
Whitehead 1967b.
Whitehead etal. 1966.
1NHN : Museum National d’ Histoire Naturelle, Paris.
LMNH : Rijksmuseum van Natuurlijke Historic, Leiden.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
319
C. dussumieri in which the pearly spots have become indistinct or have
disappeared could be easily mistaken for C. neglecta.
The junior author is thankful to Mr. S. Rama Rao, M.sc., Head of
the Department of Zoology, D.N.R. College, Bhimavaram, for the facili-
ties provided and to the University Grants Commission for financial
assistance.
Haneda, Y. (1961) : A preliminary Whitehead, P. J. P. (1967b) : Indian
report on two luminous fish from Bombay Ocean Anchovies Collected by the Anton
and Hong Kong. Sci. Rept. Yokosuka Bruun and Te vega, 1963-64. J. Mar.
CityMus. 6:45-50. biol. Ass. India 9(1): 13-37.
Whitehead , P. J. P. (1967a) : The , Boeseman, M. & Wheeler,
clupeoid fishes described by Lacepede, A. C.(1966): The types ofBleeker’s Indo-
Cuvier & Valenciennes, ibid. Suppl. Pacific elopoid and clupeoid fishes.
2 : 148-155. Zool. Verhandel. Leiden 84 : 135-145.
12. SOME SOIL ARTHROPODS COLLECTED FROM PADDY
FIELDS AT VARANASI
Very little is known about the mesofauna of Indian soil. The present
paper is the result of a quantitative investigation of the mesofauna col-
lected from the paddy fields under drought conditions during September
to November, 1966. Soil moisture, soil temperature, and percentage of
organic matter was also recorded during the period of investigation.
The sampling plots were located on the Agriculture farm of the
Faculty of Agriculture, Banaras Hindu University. Two plots of the
size 12 X 12 m were selected and total of 32 soil samples (16 from each
plot) Were taken during the period of study up to the depth of 22*5 cm
at randomized cores with a sampling unit 7*5 X 10 X 22*5 cm in size.
Soil was carried to the laboratory in polythene bags . All the soil samples
were processed in the Ladell Apparatus (Ladell 1936) by flotation
method. The fauna collected and stored in glycerated 70% alcohol,
Were examined by using a binocular microscope. Oudman’s fluid,
Diaphane, DPX and Canada balsam were employed as mountant, Lacto-
1 Present Address’. Department of Zoology, D.N.R. College, Bhimavaram
A.P.).
Acknowledgements
Zoology Department,
A.U. Post-graduate Centre,
Guntur-5, A.P.,
June 29, 1971.
S. DUTT
B. V. SESHAGIRI RAO1
References
320 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
phenol and Xylol were used as clearing media. On each sampling date
additional soil samples were taken from both the plots, from which the
percentage of moisture content was estimated by the loss of weight on
drying, organic carbon was estimated by diphenylamine method and
organic matter by multiplying the organic carbon with arbitrary factor
1*724. Soil temperature were recorded at the time of soil sampling
from both the plots at the depth of 11*5 cm using mercury-in-glass ther-
mometer.
Table I shows that a much higher population of soil arthropods was
recorded in Plot I (Paddy field with succulent growth) than in Plot II
(Paddy field with fairly advanced growth). Under drought conditions
it seems that soil arthropods thrive better in the soil comparatively rich
in organic content, and high moisture with low temperature. The
Table 1
Comparison of numbers of soil arthropods from the two paddy plots
mites (Acarina) preferred dry and poor soil, whereas Collembola and
Pauropods were found more in rich and moist soil (Table II). Total
number of 2705 soil arthropods was collected in 32 samples, of which
Acarina were more than 71%.
Table II
Mean percentage of Collembola, Acarina, Pauropods and
OTHER SOIL ARTHROPODS PER SAMPLE IN THE TWO PLOTS
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
321
Among the 28 identified specimens, the 12 Collembola, 11 Acarina
and 5 other soil arthropods, collected from the paddy fields are listed in
the Appendix.
We wish to express our gratefulness to Dr. M. S. Pavgi,
Dean, Faculty of Agriculture, for providing necessary facilities. We
are also grateful to Dr. P. N. Lawrance and D. Macfarlane of the
Commonwealth Institute of Entomology, London, for the identification
of specimens .
We wish to acknowledge the financial aid given by the Indian Council
of Agricultural Research, New Delhi.
Faculty of Agriculture, S. P. MUKHARJI
Banaras Hindu University, G. P. GUPTA
Varanasi-5,
December 9, 1970.
Acknowledgements
Appendix
COLLEMBOLA :
Onychiurus armatus Tulb.
Sminthurus viridis annulatus Folsom
Isotoma viridis Bourlet
Isotomina thermophila Axelson
Isotomina pontica Stach
Isotoma pinnate fasciata Borner
Isotomurus palustria Muller
Folsomia fimltaris Linn.
Folsomides parvulus Stach
Entomobrya santeris Borner
Neanura muscorum Templeton
Seira biformis Mitra
Cunaxa setirostris Hermann
Scheloribates sp.
Epilohmannia cylindrica Berlese
Epilohmannia pallida pacifica Aoki
Parasitus consanguineus Oudemans &
Voigts
Gamasiphis ( Neogamasiphis )
bengalensis Battacharya
Oppia sp.
acarina :
Typhlodromus sp.
Coccotydeus sp.
Microfrombidium hystricinum
Allothrombium australiense Hirst
MISCELLANEOUS :
Tailless whip scorpion
Tri thy reus sp.
Japyx sp.
Symphyla
Scutigerella sp.
Scolopendrella sp.
Pauropoda
Pauropus sp.
322 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
13. DISPERSAL OF INTERTIDAL SESSILE BARNACLE
TETRACLITA SQUAMOSA RUFOTINCTA (PILSBRY)
BY WATER CURRENTS
( With two text-figures)
A report on the occurrence of Tetraclita ( Tetraclita ) squamosa rufo-
tincta Pilsbry at two localities on the west coast of India (Wagh & Bal
1969) was based on the observations made prior to 1965 and was thought
to be a case of stray occurrence. However, further observations at
other localities on the Kathiawar Coast of Western India show that these
forms are well established in the region. In addition, Utinomi (1969)
has recorded their occurrence from Madagascar, Red Sea, Gulf of Aden
and Strait of Hormus of Iranian Gulf. Thus, it appears that this sub-
species has almost a continuous distribution all along the area extending
from east coast of Africa to southern Kathiawar Coast.
In this communication an attempt has been made to explain the dis-
persal of this non-fouling, intertidal barnacle believed to be an endemic
form of the east African Coast (Ekman 1967). It is assumed that this
Spreading might be through its planktonic larvae in turn carried by the
water currents prevailing in this region. Similar dispersal of certain
species of echinoderms from East Africa or Red Sea to Hawaii or Outer
Polynesia has been reported by Mortensen (1931, 1937, 1938). This
assumption is also supported by the observations on breeding activity of
intertidal sessile barnacles of the Indian West Coast as well as on the
circulation of surface waters in the northern region of Indian Ocean. It
has been observed that breeding activity of different species of sessile
barnacles found in the intertidal region at Bombay and at other places
on the west coast of India is at its highest during March- June and
September-October (Pillai 1958 ; Karande & Palekar 1963 ; John 1964 ;
Wagh 1965). The circulation of surface waters during these months
(Figs. 1 & 2) especially near the Arabian and Kathiawar coasts (Varada-
chari & Sharma 1967) appears to be helpful for carrying planktonic
larvae to suitable locations thereby enabling their settlement!
Thus, there are very strong indications of such a phenomenon taking
place although it needs further factual data on breeding behaviour of
these forms in particular and examination of plankton samples of the
area. It is also expected that further spread of these barnacles along the
west coast of India may be possible if their planktonic larvae find the
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
323
Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Figures 1 and 2 showing the mean surface circulation near the Arabian and
Kathiawar coast for the months of April and September respectively.
(after Varadachari and Sharma 1967).
324 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
hydrographic conditions in the area between the Kathiawar and Konkan
coasts (Gulf of Cambay) favourable.
National Institute of Oceanography, ARUN B. WAGH1
Sassoon Docks,
Colaba, Bombay-400 005,
July 23, 1971.
Refer
Ekman, S. (1967) : Zoogeography of
the Sea. Sidgwick and Jackson, London.
John, P. A. (1964) : Biology of Balanus
amphitrite communis (Darwin) in the
Cochin Harbour water. Fish Tech.
1(2) : 189.
Karande, A. A. & Palekar, V. C.
(1963) : Observations on the breeding
activity of the shore barnacle Chthamalus
malayensis Pilsbry in Bombay Harbour.
Def. Sci. J. 13 : 130.
Mortensen, T. H. (1931, 1937-38):
Contributions to the study of the develop-
ment and larval forms of Echinoderms,
1-4. Mem. Acad. R. Sci. et Letters de
Danemark , Copenhagen, Sect. Sci. 9,
1931, Ser. 4:1; 1937, Ser. 7:1; 1938,
Ser.7: 3.
N CES
Pill AX, N. K. (1958) : Development of
Balanus amphitrite with a note on the
early larvae of Chelonibia testudinaria.
Bull . Res. Inst. Univ. Kerala 6 : 111.
Utinomi, H. (1969) : Cirripedia of
the Iranian Gulf. Videnk-Meddr. dank
naturh. Foren. 132 : 79.
Varadachari, V. V. R. & Sharma,
G. S. (1967) : Circulation of the surface
waters in the north Indian Ocean. J.
India Geophyl. Union IV(2) : 61.
Wagh, A. B. (1965) : Study of
Barnacles, Ph.D. Thesis, University of
Bombay.
— & Bal, D. V. (1969) : New
records of inter-tidal barnacles from
India. Curr. Sci. 38(14) : 344.
14. ABUNDANCE OF FLEAS— A REVIEW
There seems to be nothing unusual in the information communicated
by Leonard Woolf in his an autobiography of the years 1904-1911
[/. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 68 (3) : 862], as his observations constitute a
mere duplication of similar experiences reported long before him (as far
back as the sixteenth century).
Extremely large number of fleas are usually found in uninhabited
places like deserted huts, vacant houses, grain storage, vacant godowns,
etc. Here the fleas lie dormant within their cocoons for an indefinitely
long period until they receive the requisite mechanical stimulus for their
emergence. Any disturbance however slight such as vibration caused by
the foot-fall of a passing animal or a human being is enough to precipitate
hatching, and the fleas burst out in enormous number within a split
second. It is also fact that when their cocoons are opened for exami-
nation, they are found to contain living fleas. Also, the houses that
have been vacant for several weeks may be badly infested with adult
fleas, because these insects are able to live without food for a very long
1 Present address : N.I.O., Sea-shell, 7 Bungalows, Versova, Bombay-400 061
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
325
period of time. Fleas have been kept living under experimental condi-
tions ‘ for as long as seventeen months without feeding.’
Large number of fleas can exist in long deserted huts and houses
because in presence of abundant food for the larvae, generations of these
insects could be reared in spite of an entire absence of food supply for
their adults. The nourishment absorbed during the larval stage is
enough for egg production as well as for the development of sperms in the
adult fleas. It has also been proved experimentally that 4 the fleas can
undergo lengthy resting periods in their cocoons under a wide range of
temperature and humidity.’
All fleas being negatively geotropic have a tendency to climb upwards
and away from the ground. People travelling in the East and in Africa
have bitter experience of the abundance and voracity of fleas, and of their
clothing being densely covered with myriads of these noxious insects, on
entering the huts in deserted villages. It therefore appears that Leonard
Woolf had the same bitter experience in Jaffna (Ceylon).
Thousands of human fleas have been captured in the Oriental coun-
tries by sending a bare-legged man into a deserted house, and then picking
them off his leg. During the Plague Investigations in India (1911) men
with bare legs were likewise used to collect the fleas from godowns which
had remained vacant for some time. Another way of disposing of fleas
in a large number is that of walking about in vacant rooms with flypapers
wrapped round the legs. The regular flea collectors usually put on white
apparels consisting of white shirts with long tight sleeves, and the shirts
are tightly thrust underneath white trousers. They wear long, white
stockings covering the trousers upto the knees and their feet are closely
covered by white shoes. This facilitates their task of spotting,
picking and collecting the fleas .
The 4 handful of some herb ’ given to Leonard Woolf by a 4 very old
bent Tamil Woman ’ must have been a common wayside bushy
odoriferous plant, probably the Fleabane. His great surprise at the so-
called 4 miracle ’ was rather uncalled for as such plants and their efficacy
have been very well known since ages. The following is a statement
given by Butler (1893) on page 263 of his book on 4 Our Household
Pests ’
4 That fleas can be excluded from houses by the use of odoriferous
plants has long been a firmly believed tradition, witness the name of
our common wayside plant viz. the Fleabane. The smoke of this when
burnt was held to be particularly distasteful to fleas, which would forth-
with abandon any premises in which they detected it. Several species of
Compositae have been credited with this potency. A preparation made
from the leaves of Pyrethrum from the Caucasus was at one time exten-
sively used in Russia for driving away fleas. Wormwood {Artemisia)
also was believed to possess similar powers.’
326 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (20
Prof. P. V. Bole, Head of the Botany Dept, of St. Xavier’s College,
has been kind enough to enlighten me in regard to some of the spp. of
Erigeron (Fleabane) such as E. canadensis , E. philadelphicus , E. hetero-
phyllus, etc. They all belong to Compositae.
A flea attractor known as the ‘ flea-fur ’ likewise used to serve in
the past the purpose of getting rid of the fleas. In Europe during the
sixteenth century ladies of high rank used to wear the ‘ flea-fur ’ around
their shoulders in order to attract these agile insects from more vulnerable
parts of their person. The fleas thus trapped were later destroyed.
Apart from the human beings some animals also have been said to be
possessing the skill of warding off the attacks by fleas. The fox which is
fabled for his cleverness, is credited for having devised an ingenious
method of ridding himself of fleas. The following are the two extracts
from page 156 of a really interesting book on ‘Insects Fact and Folklore *
by Lucy W. Clausen : —
(1) ‘ As early as 1634 Thomas Muffett saw a fox pestered by fleas
gathering up bits of hair adhering to thorn and briar bushes
and rolling them up into a compact mass. Holding one end
of this mass firmly between his front teeth, the fox slowly
waded backwards into a cold river. In this way he gradually
submerged himself until his snout with the mass of hair was
just above the level of Water. The fleas, in order to get away
from the slowly rising water gradually leaped off to congre-
gate in the mass of hair so cleverly held by the fox in his teeth.
Finally the fox spat out this flea-laden mass and swam back
to the land.’
(2) ‘ Nearly three hundred years after the great age of Muffett’s
story, an article verifying the same appeared in the August
5th 1944 issue of the Saturday Evening Post . The
author of the article who himself had no knowledge of
Muffett’s experience, reported a similar incident to have taken
place in Southern Illinois. The fox in this story collected in
his mouth the Wool that festooned the barbed wire fence
where sheep had brushed against it. When his mouth was
fully packed with the wool he trotted off to the edge of a
nearby pool, turned round and waded backwards into the water.
When he was entirely submerged except for the tip of his
nose and the bunch of wool sticking out of his mouth, he
suddenly leaped out of the water, dropped the wool and
dashed away. Out of sheer curiosity the author of this
article walked down to the pool, picked up the wool and
found it to be alive with fleas. On communicating enthusias-
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
327
tically this information to a friend, the author was retaliated
with a story about a pet
a similar manner.’
Dept, of Zoology,
St. Xavier’s College,
Bombay- 400 001,
August 30, 1972.
R'ef e
Busvine, J. (1951): Insect and
Hygiene. Methuen &Co.,Lond., pp. 240-
241.
Butler, E. A. (1893) : Our House-
hold Insects. Longmans, Green & Co.,
Lond. & New York, p. 263.
Clausen, L. W. (1958) : Insect Fact
and Folklore. Macmillan Co., New York,
p. 156.
Herms, W. S. (1956) : Medical Ento-
mology. Macmillan Co., New York,
p. 446.
Imms, A. D. (1965) : A General Text
Book of Entomology. Eng. Language
Book Society and Methuen & Co.,
p. 672.
Karandikar, K. R. & Munshi, D. M.
(1950). Life-history and bionomics of
the Cat-flea, Ctenocephalide felis Bouche.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 49(2) : 173.
racoon who rid himself of fleas in
D. M. MUNSHI
E N'C E S
Munshi, D. M. (1966) : Insects as
our Friends and Foes. Everyman’s
Science, Vol. 1(2) : 87 (2).
Patton, W. S. (1930) : Insects, Ticks,
Mites, and Venomous Animals of
Medical and Veterinary Importance.
H. R. Crubb Ltd., Croydon, p. 658.
Reports on Plague Investigation in
India (1911): Vol. I, part 1, University
Press, Cambridge, p. 268.
Plague Reports (1914) : Vol. II,
part 1, Cambridge University Press,
p. 475.
ibid., pp. 479-480.
ibid. : pp. 539.
Rothschild, M. & Clay, T. (1952) :
Fleas, Flukes and Cuckoos. New
Naturalist Special Volume, Collins, Lond.
pp. 73 & 78.
Russell, H. (1913): The Flea. Cam-
bridge University Press, pp. 65-66.
15. FORAGING ACTIVITY OF APIS DORS AT A FAB. ON
BRASSICA JUNCEA HOOK. AND THOMAS
Like other species of Apis bees, Apis dorsata Fab. the wild bee, also
lives in socialised colonies. Its food requirements as nectar and pollen
are constant throughout the year. On account of domestication and
management of Apis cerana Fab. and A. mellifera Linn., their colonies
are either moved close to the selected crops serving as bee host plants or
they are fed artificially during lean periods by man. Apis dorsata , how-
ever, migrates from one location to another in search of new crops. It
suggests that Apis dorsata may be adapted to a large variety of seasonal
flowers differing structurally and to the attractants offered by them.
Previous experience shows that in the plains of the Punjab and Haryana,
Apis dorsata is associated with flowers of rape-seed and mustard(Family
Cruciferae) during winter (Kapil et al. 1969) and with crops belonging to
10
328 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 7i (2)
the families Solanaceae, Cucurbitaceae and Leguminosae from summer
through autumn (data unpublished). This wide spectrum of adaptation
will make behavioural differences by this bee on different flowers and it
would be of interest to determine the differential behaviour in relation
to the plants with which it is associated. The present study, however,
aims to explore the behaviour of Apis dorsata on the flowers of raya,
Brassica juncea Hook. & Thomas.
Method
A normal crop of ( Brassica juncea) raya var. R.L.-18 was selected
on the University Farm for observations. The bees visiting the crop on
marked areas of 3 square metre were observed and the time each bee
took to visit a certain number of flowers was recorded with a chronometer
having an accuracy of ± 10 seconds. Temperature and humidity during
the hours of observations, ranged between IT to 22’2°C and 42-100%,
respectively. The observations were taken at intervals of 10 days.
Results and Discussion
The four petals of the flowers of Brassica are not joined with each
other and have nectaries at their bases. The anther sutures face the
stigma at the time of dehiscence (Singh 1958). The bee on alighting on
the petal should presumably behave in a manner that she could collect
her requirements of pollen and nectar and at the same time pollinate the
flowers. The posture or attitude she adopts on the flowers would be the
parameter, constituting her foraging activity.
Type of visits : Apis dorsata foragers have been observed assuming
different types of postures on B. juncea flowers. These postures for the
purpose of pollination have been categorised as follows
{a) the bee alights on the petal and inserts her proboscis for nectar
once only;
(b) a bee alights as in (a) and while holding the genital parts of the
flowers, makes a second probe on the opposite end,
( c ) a bee steals nectar between the petals without entering the flower.
Of all the behavioural postures, (a) and (b) attitudes appear purposive
and evidently useful for the pollination of the flowers. Attitude (b) is
superior to (a). Hence a bee performing more of (b) type behaviour
will obviously be superior as a pollinator. Table 1 contains the data on
the types of behaviour and it is observed that generally a bee performed
maximum (b) type visits, only on January 22, 1968 (a) type visits far
exceeded the (b). Behavioural indices (a/b) between visits type (a) and
Frequency of different types of visits by Apis dorsata on Brassica juncea flowers
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
330 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vot. 71 (2)
(b) varied from 4 to 25 during different hours of the day with larger
aggregation between 7-13. The attitudes (a) and (b) are meant to collect
nectar by the foragers but the pollen gets accidentally attached to their
bodies, for which chances are seemingly more when a bee adopts (b) type
attitude. The high frequency of nectar collecting attitudes (Table 1)
is indicative of the fact that B. juncea flowers are relatively high nectar
yielding types. The observation conforms with the data on greater
abundance of nectar collectors on juncea flowers (Table 2, Col. 4). The
flowers need only 14% crossing (Howard & Khan 1915, Singh 1958)
and the rest of their pollination occurs through selfing. The data sug-
gests that the high nectar producing property of the flowers, serving as a
factor of attractiveness, is probably in some way correlated with their
self-compatibility.
Visitation of flowers : Tables 2 and 3 show that Apis dorsata foragers
started field activity at about 09.30 hr on February 18, 1966, around
10.00 hr on February 23 and March 1, 1968 and at 12.30 hr on January
22 and February 1, 1968. Notwithstanding these variations in the
timings, it is observed that the prevailing temperature in all the cases is
never less than 15°C at the hour the activity started. Before the hours
of activity, the temperature was less than 15°C and the bees did not visit
the crop. The higher temperatures, however, do not seem to affect
their activity to any great extent. The bees were found coming in fairly
good numbers and actively visiting a number of flowers even at 17.00 hr
when the temperatures ranged between 21° and 23°C in early March where
as they stopped their activity as early as at 16.00 hr when the tempera-
tures were much lower in January and February. It is clear, therefore,
that it is not the temperature alone that regulates their activity but there
Table 2
Number of Brassica juncea flowers visited per minute by Apis dorsata
on 18.2.1966 (hourly observations)
Table 3
Number of Brassica juncea flowers visited per minute by Apis dorsata during 1968 (hourly observations)
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
U
a •*-
H as
g o
§ ^
H ON
o
o
o o
PL, U
: 43
E ^
<D n
H 3
U U
o o
m to
li ii
43 43
to O
Tf O
a,
E
H
331
Pollen Collector(s) = 1 12.00 h = 14°C Pollen Pollen
12.15 h = 14°C Collectors = 4 Collectors = 13
Pollen collectors = 0
332 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
are other factors which actively participate individually and in combi-
nation with the temperature. A similar observation was recorded on
the field activity of the foragers of Apis florea Fab. (Brar 1968).
Tables 2 and 3 indicate that Apis dorsata foragers visited an average
of 12*30 and 10*79 juncea flowers/minute (range 9*23-16*00 and 4*73 to
16*43) and visits were comparatively larger in number at the start of
days’ activity on January 22 and February 1, 1968 and their visits there-
after decreased toward the end of diurnal activity with some marginal
fluctuations occurring during the hours of observation. Observations
taken on February 8, 1966 and February 23, and March 1, 1968 show that
the number of flowers visited per minute were less in the morning between
09.30-11.00 hr and the number visited increased with the advance of the
day and their maximum visits occurred between 14.30 and 15.45 hr. It
seems that during the early blooming period (January 22-February 1,
1968) of the crop, the temperature during forenoon was less than 15°C,
that affected both nectar secretion and bee activity. During the latter
part of blooming period, the temperature rose during early hours and,
therefore, the bees started working in the field by about 10.00 hr when
the air temperature was around 15°C.
Haryana Agriculture University, R. P. KAPIL
Hissar, SURENDRA KUMAR
October 16, 1970.
References
Brar, H. S. (1968) : Studies on the
field activities of Apis florea Fab. with
relation to some Brassica crops. Un-
published Master’s Thesis, Punjab Agri-
cultural University, pp. 54.
♦Howard, A., Howard, G. L. C. &
Khan, A. R. (1915) : Flowering, polli-
nation and fertilization of Indian
Mustard, B. juncea. Mem. Dept. Agri.
India (Botanical series) 7: 213-237.
Kapil, R. P., Grewal, G. S., Kumar,
S. & Atwal, A. S. (1969) : Insect
pollinators of rape-seeds and mustard.
Proc. 56 th lnd. Sci. Cong, part III ;
509 ; Indian J. Ent. (In press).
Singh, D. P. (1958) : Rape and mus-
tard, Monograph, Indian Central Oil-
seeds Committee, pp. 105.
♦ Paper not seen in original,
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
333
16. A NOTE ON THE EARLY DEVELOPMENT OF THE
MARINE INSECT HALOBATES SP. FROM THE GULF OF
MANNAR NEAR MANDApAM
( With a text-figure)
The occurrence of Halohates eggs on different floating material has
been reported earlier by various authors. A cuttle-bone with eggs of
Halobates sp. (Fig. 1A) was collected four miles off Vedalai (09° 15' N,
79° 07' E) on 24th September 1965. Since there is little information
on the Halobates eggs and their development from this region, some
observations were made on them and are presented in this note.
Several barnacles of the genus Lepas , with their shells covered by
the eggs of the insect were attached to both sides of the cuttle-bone.
A number of polychaetes were also seen in the burrows on the cuttle-
bone which suggests that the cuttle-bone must have been floating in the
sea for a number of days.
The convex side of the cuttle-bone was more densely covered by the
eggs (12 per sq mm) than the concave side (4 per sq mm) (Fig. 1, B).
The eggs were embedded in a transparent gelatinous matrix. The
eggs were long and uniformly broad with smooth egg membrane. The
length varied from 0*64 to 0*87 mm and the breadth 0*35 to 0*41 mm
(of Delsmans 1*1 and 0*42). Majority of the eggs were orange-yellow
in colour but scattered amongst them were a few patches of brownish-
black eggs, evidently in an advanced stage of development. Certain
other eggs Were yellowish-white in colour with premature embryos inside.
These different degrees of development of the eggs clearly indicate that
several females must have laid the eggs at different times, on the cuttle-
bone as was pointed out by previous authors.
Inside the early stages of eggs which were orange-yellow, the embryo
Was characterised by three pairs of unsegmented legs, a pair of eyes and
the rudiment of the labrum (Fig. 1, C & D) and in the advanced stage of
eggs the legs had become segmented and the compound eyes prominent
(Fig. 1, E). The cuttle-bone with eggs was kept in running sea water in
the aquarium at a temperature of 27* 5° C and room temperature of 31 ‘5°C.
Transition into the nymphal stage was rapid and the nymphs hatched out
on the fifth day after collection. The eggs hatched out in a natural
rhythm, batch after batch, as if they had been laid at different times.
The nymphs were carefully transferred to a big glass trough containing
sea water which was changed once a day. The newly hatched nymphs
were pale yellow in colour but turned dark brown in about six hours.
The head, thorax and segmented abdomen were distinct. The antennae
and mouth parts were well developed (Fig. I, F & G). The nymphs
334 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
A. Cuttle-bone showing the intensity of eggs of Halobates sp. on the
convex side.
B. The arrangement of eggs and their number in one sq. mm (at the
area marked X in Fig. 1 A).
C. Early embryos.
D. Enlarged view of an early embryo, ventral view.
E. Enlarged view of a late embryo, ventral view.
F. The nymph (larva) dorsal view.
G. Enlarged view of anterior portion of the nymph, ventral view, to
show the mouth parts,
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
335
were observed to move swiftly on the surface of the water just like the
adult. There was a tendency to prefer the edges of the trough rather
than the centre. Attempts to feed them with mashed fresh clam meat
suspended in water and alternatively in dry glass trough proved futile.
They survived for two days only. The nymphs continued to hatch in
good numbers on the first two days but the hatching rate gradually
declined and finally ceased on the tenth day after collection.
I am not quite sure as yet to which species of Halobates these eggs
belong. Herring (1958) has classified Halobates into two distinct groups.
The * open Ocean ’ group which occurs at considerable distance from land
with individuals taken near the shore only after severe storms and the
‘ coastal ’ group with species that are highly endemic to islands or island
groups. According to this division the present material in all probability
belongs to the second one as they were collected near an island. Herring
(1961) observed that twelve days were required for the egg to hatch.
The present material hatched out into tiny nymphs on the fifth day after
collection. It is reasonable to think that it might not have travelled many
miles in about seven days specially when there was practically no storm or
heavy winds during this time. Again, as mentioned earlier the eggs con-
taining premature embryos inside suggest that they must have been laid
only a few days before collection. Based on these facts it is probable
that this insect belongs to coastal group of species.
Gravely (1927) collected some female specimens from almost the
same area as the present one and feels that his specimens agree in all
respects with White’s H. sobrinus. But according to Herring (1961,
p. 252) ‘ judging from extensive collections it now appears certain that
sobrinus is confined to the west coast of America and the Kinberg’s
label of Tahiti is in error.’ Herring in his monograph has described
38 species belonging to the genus Halobates and has for 36 species shown
their geographical distribution on a map. Among these two species
H. micans Eschscholtz and H.flaviventris Eschscholtz have been recorded
close to the area of the present material. Besides these two, H.formida -
bilis Distant has been recorded from the Chilka Lake on the Bay of
Bengal by Annandale and Kemp (1915). H. germanus White (1883)
H. trynae Herring (1964) have also been reported from the Bay of Bengal
and H. galatea Herring (1961) near Bombay on the Arabian Sea.
In a recent paper Lana (1971) has mentioned that ten species of
Halobates were recorded from the Indian Ocean and the adjacent seas.
These include two Oceanic species, H. micans and H. germanus , and eight
species, H. alluaudi , H. formidabilis, H. prcavus , H. tethys , H. poseidon,
H. galatea , H. hay anus and H . flaviventris , confined to coastal waters.
Comparing the above species to those of Herring’s geographical distri-
bution map, we get two species, H. micans and H.flaviventris which occur
close to the place of present material. Lana (1971) has observed that
336 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
most of the eight species mentioned as coastal are rather restricted in
their distribution in the Indian Ocean area but H. flaviventris is found
from the Bay of Bengal to the coast of Tanzania.
It is probable that the eggs and nymphs described belong to H. flavi-
ventris as H. micans is considered to be an oceanic species.
Central Marine Fisheries
Research Institute,
Mandapam Camp, S. India,
August 21, 1971.
Refe
Annandale, N. & Kemp, S. (1915) :
Fauna of Chilka Lake, 2 Aquatic Insects.
Mem. Ind. Mus. 5 : 181-187, PI. 11, figs.
1-7.
Gravely, F. H. (1927) : The littoral
fauna of Krusadai Island in the Gulf of
Mannar. Insecta. Bull. Madras Govt.
Mus. (N.S.) 1 (1) : 162.
Herring, J. L. (1958) : The marine
water-striders of the ‘Dana’ Expedition
(Insecta : Hemiptera). Dana Report 44 :
14.
- — (1961) : The genus Halobates
R. ALFRED SELVAKUMAR1
iNCES
(Hemiptera : Gerridea). Pacific Insects
3(2-3): 223-305.
Herring (1964) : A new species of
Halobates from the Bay of Bengal.
(Hemiptera : Gerridae). Proc. Ent. Soc.
Wash. 66(2) : 85-86.
Lana, Cheng (1971) : The Ocean-
Strider Halobates (Insecta : Hemiptera).
Abstracts, Symposium on Indian Ocean
and adjacent seas. Cochin.
White, F. B. (1883) : Report on the
pelagic Hemiptera. Voy. Challenger
Rept.Zool. 7(19): 82.
17. BUTTRESS-LIKE STRUCTURES ON THE UPPER PART
OF THE TRUNK OF CEIBA PENT AND RA (L.) GAERTN.
{With a plate)
The White Silk Cotton tree, Ceiba pentandra (Syn. Eriodendron
anfractuosum DC.) is well known for its basal buttresses (Plate).
The object of the present note is to point out the occurrence of wing-
like structures resembling buttresses in the angles between the branches
and the main trunk, observed in two large specimens of C. pentandra ,
one growing in the Botanical Garden and the other in a private garden in
Pondicherry. Buttress-like structures are also observed on the main
trunk, having no connections either with the branches or the true
buttresses. In smaller trees a tendency towards formation of such
structures on the trunk is noted though they are not well formed. The
only other tree for which this phenomenon is observed is a Burseraceae,
Canarium commune L. (Richards 1957).
Buttresses are defined as the supporting roots arising above the ground
level and growing downwards and outwards into the ground (Lloyd
1950). Richards (l.c.) defines them as the flat, triangular plates sub-
X Present address : ISfational Institute of Oceanography, Miramar, Panjim, Goa,
Jo Bombay nat0 Hist. Soc. 71 (2) Plate
Meher-Homji : Ceiba pentandra
Photos. I : Normal buttresses in Ceiba pentandra ; 2 : Wing-like structures resembling
buttresses (marked with x ) in the axils of the larger branches and on the
main trunk ; 3 : Enlargement of the lowermost 4 buttress * on the main
trunk noted in photo 2 ; 4 : Closer view of the buttress-like structures
(marked X ) in the angles between the branches and the trunk, and on the trunk.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
337
tended by the angle between the trunk and the lateral roots running near
the surface of the soil ; they are produced by epinastic secondary growth
along the upper side of 'lateral roots. As such the term buttress is in-
applicable to the wing-like expansions at the insertion of branches and
trunk and on the main trunk noted in C. pentandra. However, these
structures serve in distinguishing the genus Ceiba from Bombax , both
of which quite resemble each other in leaf and general growth.
The function of these appendages seems to be more or less the same
as that of the buttresses . Several theories have been advanced to explain
the formation of buttresses (Richards 1957). According to the adapta-
tion theory , they enable the tree to withstand both compressive and
tensile stresses.
The strain theory akin to the adaptation theory, postulates that the
buttress formation is the response of the tree to the mechanical stimu-
lation of strains set up by the wind (Whitford 1906 ; Senn 1923 ; Navez
1924, 1930).
Francis (1924) put forth the negative geotropism theory : the upper
part of the principal surface roots being affected by negative geotro-
pism and photo tropism. Petch (1930) suggested the conductive current
theory : the transpiration stream bringing in dissolved nutrients from the
soil is restricted in the trunk to limited tracts on the same radii as the
lateral roots. The currents of water and nutrients encourage growth
in the sectors of cambium on the same radii as the lateral roots at the
expense of the intervening sectors ; this leads to the formation of ridges
which subsequently become buttresses.
Correlations have also been established between the size of buttresses
in the most abundant tree species and the texture and the depth of soil
(Davis and Richards 1933-34 ; Richards 1957) but for the aerial struc-
tures observed in Ceiba in Pondicherry, the role of a climatic factor like
strong wind associated with the severe depressions of the N.E. monsoon
season (October to January) or occasionally with the cyclones occurring
from March to May, may be emphasised. In three years — 1968 to
1970 — there were 13 cyclonic depressions and 7 cyclones on the Coro-
mandel coast involving the months September to December (Legris &
Rlasco 1974). These structures may have been induced by tension as in
the case of true buttresses.
Buttress habit seems to be partly a genetically determined character,
inherited by certain taxa only ; even the giant trees like the Sequoia of
California or the Eucalyptus of Australia are devoid of it. Again it is
so little developed in the temperate countries subject to violent winds.
Institut FRAN9AIS, V, M. MEHER-HOMJI
Pondicherry, S. India,
August 29, 1972,
338 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
References
Davis, T. A. & Richards, P. W.
(1933-34): The vegetation of Muraballi
Creek, British Guiana ; an ecological
study of a limited area of tropical rain
forest. I & II. /. Ecol. 21 : 350-384 ;
22 : 106-155.
Francis, W. D. (1924) : The develop-
ment of buttresses in Queensland trees.
Proc. Roy. Soc. Qd. 36 : 21-37.
Legris, P. & Blasco, F. (1974) : Dry
evergreen forest of Point Calimere and
Marakanam. J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc.
70 (2) : 279-294.
Lloyd, B. (1950) : The dictionary of
botanical terms. Univ. of London Press
Ltd., London.
Navez, A. (1924) : La foret equa-
torial bresilienne, I. Bull. Soc. Bot.
Belg. 57 : 7-17.
Navez (1930) : On the distribution
of tabular roots in Ceiba (Bombacaceae).
Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., Washington 16:
339-344.
Petch, T. (1930) : Buttress roots. Ann.
R. Bot. Gdns., Peradeniya 11 : 277-285.
Richards, P. W. (1957) : The tropical
rain forest. Univ. Press, Cambridge.
Senn, G. (1923) : Ueber die Uraschen
der Brettwurzelbildung bei der Pyra-
miden-Pappel. Verh. naturf. Ges. Basel
35 : 405-435.
Whifford, H. N. (1906) : The vege-
tation of the Lambao Forest Reserve.
Phillip. J. Sci. 1 : 373-431, 637-682.
18. STUDIES ON THE LIMESTONE VEGETATION OF
SAHAS RADHARA NEAR DEHRA DUN (U.P.)— 4
‘INDICATOR VALUE OF PLANTS 5
The probable plant indicators for the mineral calcium have been
discussed in this paper.
The studies on the limestone vegetation of Sahasradhara area have
revealed certain facts regarding the calcicole and calcifuge plants.
Glibber (1945) stated that the rain water charged with carbon dioxide
dissolves the limestone rocks and thus the hollows, caves and caverns
are formed. Such caves with stalactites and stalagmites are observed
along the rocks opposite to the sulphur spring. The soil in. these places
is calcareous and it is covered with a carpet of plants which include
Adiantum capillus-veneris Linn., Pogonatherum paniceum (Lamk.) Hack.,
Primula floribunda Linn. etc.
According to Puri (1950) ‘on new soils e.g., river gravels, shingle
islands, or boulder bed, or those which are topographically immature
and contain high amount of calcium carbonate (steep slopes and scrap
face etc.). Sal community is not present though a solitary tree may
be found locally in pockets of mature soils \
In the present study, the soil samples analysed from the eastern
slope, where Shorea robusta Gaertn. dominates, are acidic. This is
clear from the following data :
Calcium carbonate = 0*75-0*92%
Nitrogen = 0*04134-0*04627%
pH ,, 6*l-6-3
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
339
Thus the present studies at Sahasradhara agree with those made by
Puri (1950) showing clearly that Shorea robusta Gaertn. does not grow on
alkaline soils.
The surface soils underneath herbs like Campanula colorata Wall,
ex Roxb., Eriophorum comosum Wall, ex Nees and Galium vestitum
D. Don from the rocky crevices were analysed and they were found to
be alkaline. This is clear from the following data : —
This shows that these plants can grow on alkaline soils which possess
a greater percentage of calcium carbonate. There are other calcicole
plants collected from the rocky crevices namely Cerbera gossypina (Roxb.)
Raizada and Saxena, Herminium mono phy Hum (D. Don) F. F. Hunt
and Summerhayes, Inula cuspidata Clarke, Origanum vulgare Linn. etc.
Further these plants are conspicuous by their complete absence from the
eastern slope (Shorea robusta Gaertn. belt), which is acidic and deficient
in calcium.
Thus the occurrence of Adiantum capillus-veneris Linn., Campanula
colorata Wall, ex Roxb., Eriophorum comosum Wall, ex Nees, Galium
vesjitum D. Don, Cerbera gossypina (Roxb.) Raizada and Saxena.
Herminium monophyllum (D. Don.) F. F. Hunt and Summerhayes, Inula
cuspidata Clarke, Origanum vulgare Linn., and Pogonatherum paniceum
(Lamk.) Hack, exclusively on calcium rich soils shows that they are indi-
cators for the mineral calcium.
The following species have been collected exclusively from the cal-
careous soils and hence there is every possibility that these species are
probable indicators for the mineral calcium Arenaria serpyllifolia Linn.,
Argostemma verticillatum Wall., Begonia picta Sm., Bergenia ligulata
(Wall.) Engl, v&r.ciliata (Royle) Engl., Corallodiscus langinosus (Wall,
ex DC.) B. L. Burtt, Galium aparine Linn., Lindenbergia macrostachya
Benth., Taraxacum officinale Weber, Poa annua Linn, and Viola serpens
Wall, ex Roxb.
I am indebted to Prof. B. Tiagi, Head of the Department of Botany,
University of Rajasthan, Jaipur. Thanks are due to the Director,
Botanical Survey of India, Calcutta, Dr. R. S. Rao, Regional Botanist,
Western Circle, Botanical Survey of India, Poona and Dr. M. A. Rau,
Calcium carbonate
Nitrogen
pH
= 73*15-88*30%
= 0*01790-0-3591%
. . 8*3-8*4
Acknowledgements
340 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
Regional Botanist, Northern Circle, Botanical Survey of India, Dehra
Dun.
Botanical Survey of India, S. K. MALHOTRA
Western Circle, Poona- 1,
April 24, 1972.
References
Chibber, H. L. (1945) : Physical Basis communities in the Sal ( Shorea robusta )
of Geography of India, Banaras. forests of the Dun valley. Indian For.
Puri, G. S. (1950) : Soil pH and forest 76 : 292-309.
19. NICOTIANA GLAUCA GRAHAM— A TREE TOBACCO
IN MAHARASHTRA
In January 1971 I was informed that there are some plants called
in Marathi as ‘ Mahapurusha ’ "or ‘ Mahasatpurusha ’ growing at
Kundlapur (Sangli district) whose leaves when chewed produce a
sort of hallucination or trance effect and are often used locally for various
pulmonary disorders. Subsequently, I visited the locality to collect
flowering and fruiting specimens and found that the species belonged to
the genus Nicotiana. The species identification could not be confirmed
since the characters did not tally with any of the four species of Nicotiana
found under cultivation or as exotics in India (Haines 1922 ; Patel 1960).
Some of the herbarium specimens along with my notes were sent to Royal
Botanical Gardens, Kew, England, where they have been identified as
belonging to Nicotiana glauca Graham.
The species has so far been collected by me from Kundlapur
and Jarandi of Kavathe Mahankal Taluka of Sangli District. The
plants grow wild about these villages . They do not however form a part
of the natural vegetation. Inquiry with the local people revealed that
the plants have grown in the area for the last 35-40 years though their
importance has been realized only quite recently.
Nicotiana glauca belongs to the subgenus Rustica, section Paniculatae
and occurs in Argentina, Mexico and parts of North America (Good-
speed 1954). Its occurrence in India has not been reported so far and
hence a brief description of the species and a key to separating it from
other species of Nicotiana found in India has been given below.
Nicotiana glauca Graham. A perennial shrub reaching 3 m height.
Leaves alternate, petiole 2 *5-3 *5 cm long, lamina 7-4*5 cm long, 3*5-
2*3 cm broad in the middle, margin entire, acute-acuminate, main
nerves 6-10 pairs ; lower leaves much larger, inflorescence terminal
Miscellaneous notes 341
paniculate raceme. Flowers bracteate, bract about 1 mm long, hairy ;
pedicel 7-7*5 mm long ; calyx (1 X 0*4 cm) tubular, 5-lobed, lobes about
3 mm long, acute, margin ciliate ; corolla greenish-white, villose, tube
cylindric, 3 *2-3 *4 cm long, about 4 mm broad, slightly constricted at
base, slightly enlarged (5 mm wide) below the lobes ; lobes 5, rounded,
apiculate, erect. Stamens 5, included, inserted at about 7 mm above
the base of the corolla tube, filament 2-5 cm long, cylindrical, anthers
bithecous, deeply basifixed dehiscing longitudinally. Hypogynous disk
prominent. Ovary superior, ovoid, 2*5 x 2*0 mm, bilocular, placen-
tation axile, ovules numerous. Style 2/5-3 cm long, stigma slightly
bilobed. Capsule 0*8-1 cm long, 0*5 cm wide in the middle, dehiscing
in four halves from top, enclosed partially or completely in the calyx
tube which is often split on one side. Seeds numerous, brownish-black,
angular, reticulate. Flowers and fruits. February, July-August.
The species can be easily distinguished from other species in India
by its shrubby habit, petiolate leaves and the floral peculiarities as
follows : —
Leaves petiolate
Seasonal herbs, calyx teeth sub-obtuse, corolla tube campanulate, yellowish,
lobes obtuse N. rustica
Perennial shrub, calyx teeth acute, corolla tube linear, slightly swollen above,
greenish white, lobes round apiculate N. glauca
Leaves sessile
Corolla tube ventricose above, rosy N. tabacum
Corolla tube linear, white or greenish white or pale pink, lobes acute
N. plumbaginifolia
Corolla tube linear, slightly swollen above, white, lobes obtuse N. alata
Acknowledgements
I am indebted to the Director, Royal Botanical Gardens, Kew,
England, for confirming the identification and to Dr. B. A. Patil, of
Willingdon College, Sangli, for help in arranging the trip to Kundlapur.
Botany Department, A. R. KULKARNl1
Shiyaji University,
Kolhapur,
November 18, 1972.
1 Present address : Botany Dept., Ramnarain Ruia College, Matunga, Bombay-
400 019.
342 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (2)
References
Goodspeed, T. H. (1954) : The genus
Nicotiana. Cnronica Botanica com-
pany, Waltham, Mass. U.S.A.
Haines, M. M. (1922) : Genus Nico-
tiana in Botany of Bihar and Orissa
Vol. II, pp. 646-647. Reprinted by
Govt, of India, Calcutta.
Patel, M. S. (I960) : Indian
Tobacco — A monograph. Indian
Central Tobacco Committee, Madras.
20. AXILLARY ARCHEGONIA IN SPLACHNOBRYUM
INDICUM HAMP. ET C. MUELL. FROM BOMBAY
( With eleven text-figures in a plate)
The genus Splachnobryum C. Muell. belongs to the family Splachna-
ceae having perstomate capsule, heterogenous nerve and central strand
in stem. Five species of the genus occur in India. In two of them S.
indicum Hamp. et C. Muell. archegonia are found in a position namely
axillary or super axillary. Morphologically S. indicum Hamp. et
C. Muell. (Plate, Figs. 1-11) differs from S. flaccidum (Harv.) Braithw. in
having erect, Ungulate to spathulate leaves (Fig. 2) which are narrower
towards the apex, wider at base with undulate margin which is crenu-
late to serrulate (Fig. 4). The nerve is broad at base and narrow at the
apex ending below the leaf apex (Fig. 4). In S. indicum Hamp. et
C. Muell. leaf cells are thin-walled, chlorophyllose, obliquely rhomboidal,
35 a long and 16 p broad. Leaf base cells rectangular to irregularly
rectangular, 50 p long and 20 p broad (Fig. 5). Seta erect, 1*5 to 2 cm
in height, dark brown coloured (Fig. 8), Capsule cylindrical, brownish,
with narrow, pointed opercular lid (Figs. 8, 10). Peristome teeth sixteen,
deeply inserted, with cleft at base, and narrowed at apex (Fig. 1 1). Spores
brown, globose, smooth-walled, 15 to 20 p in diameter (Fig. 11). S.
indicum Hamp. et C. Muell. grows luxuriantly on the old walls of houses
and compounds at Mumbra in Bombay. Only female plants are seen.
Careful observations, revealed that there are ten to twelve brownish,
long necked, naked archegonia growing in unusual positions on the stem
of the female plants. Most of them are lateral in position on stem a
few in the axil of leaves and at the apex of stem (Figs. 6, 7). They are
stalked (Figs. 6, 7). Well developed sporophytes are formed by them
(Figs. 1, 8). Antherdial plants are not seen.
Discussion : Lateral archegonia on stem were recorded in S. flacci-
dum (Harv.) Braithw. from Delhi (Chopra & Rashid 1969). Other
mosses like Atrichum sp. (Chopra & Bhandari 1959), Oilgotrichum
semilamellatum and Lyellia crispa (Sharma & Chopra 1964), and Fis si-
dens j>p. also show this anacrogynous condition. In these mosses
archegonia are mainly confined to the apices of shoots, but in S. indicum
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (2)
Dabhade : Splachnobryum indicum
Plate
Splachnobryum indicum (Hamp.) et C. Muelh (Figs. 1 to 11) showing axillary
archegonia :
1. Plants under 10 x . 2. Enlarged view of a entire leaf. 3. Enlarged view
of the enlarged part of plant. 4. Enlarged view of leaf apex. 5, Leaf base cells.
6. The axillary and lateral position of the archegonia. 7. Magnified view of a lateral
archegonium. 8. Sporophyte arising in axillary position. 9. Calyptra enlarged.
10. Capsule enlarged. 11. Peristome and spores.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
343
Hamp. et C. Muell., it is lateral and axillary in distribution in addition
to the normal apical position (Figs. 3, 6, 7). Sporophyte is also present
in axillary position (Figs. 1,8). Apparently this is a unique and very
primitive character. Such a lateral and axillary distribution of arche-
gonia. S. indicum Hamp. et C. Muell. and other species of Splachno-
bryum resemble with that in the fossil bryophyt Q-Naidetia (Harris 1939)
and Takakia (Hattori et al. 1968). In Naidetia archegonia are sessile
and lateral in position, but in S. indicum Hamp. et C. Muell. they are
stalked lateral, axillary and also some apical (Figs. 3, 6, 7).
Some botanists like Campbell (1918) are of the opinion that the
development of lateral of axillary archegonia may be due to the repeated
anticlinal and periclinal division of the apical growing cell of the stem,
but this view is not clearly established with experimental work.
Acknowledgements
I am grateful to Prof. T. S. Mahabale of University of Poona,
Poona-7 and Prof. H. C. Gangulee, Head of the Botany Department of
Presidency College, Calcutta-12, for guidance and to Prof. R. S. Chopra
of the Punjab University, Chandigarh for suggestions and help.
Bandodkar Science College, G. T. DABHADE
Thana, Maharashtra State,
November 18, 1972.
R eferences
Campbell, D. H. (1918) : Mosses and
Ferns, New York.
Chopra, R. N. & Rashid, A. (1969) :
The Archegonia of Splachnobryum. The
Bryologist 72 : 525-527 .
Chopra, R. S. & Bhandari, N. N.
(1959) : Cytomorphological studies of
genus Atrichum. Res. Bull. Punjab
Univ.-n. ser. (10) 10: 221-231.
Harris, T. M. (1939) : Naidetia , a
fossil bryophyte with reproductive
organs.
Hattori, .S. J. , Sharp, M. , Mizutani &
Iwatsuki, Z. (1968) : The Takakia cera-
tophylla and T. lepidozoides of pacific
North America and a short life history
of the genus. Misc. Bryol. and Lichenol.
4 : 137-149.
Sharma, P. D. & Chopra, R. S.
(1964) : The life history of Lyellia
orispa R. Bt. The Bryologist 67 : 329-
343.
ii
344 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 7i (2)
21. ON THE OCCURRENCE OF ZIZYPHUS GLABERRIMA
SANT. IN NORTHERN INDIA
While working on the flora of Corbett National Park, Uttar Pradesh,
we came across a few plants of this species collected at Sarpaduli. The
plant has so far been reported in our floras from Several areas in Maha-
rashtra State and certain areas in Gujarat State. The present report
from Sarpaduli in Uttar Pradesh provides additional information about
its distribution in the country and is its first record from areas north of
Vindhya ranges. A careful search in herbaria and field may probably
provide more data about its distribution in northern India.
The species resembles closely Z. xylopyrus Willd., and has been
considered a variety (var. glaberrima Sedgw.) of it by Sedgwick, Santapau
(in Kew Bulletin) 11. cc. etc., but differs mainly in that in the present
species the undersurface of the leaves is completely glabrous or at most
sparsely pubescent on the primary nerves beneath at all stages, the leaf
nerves not converging towards the apex of the leaf but remaining parallel
from the middle of the leaf upto the apex of the same and the fruit en-
tirely glabrous at all stages. The nomenclature of the plant is as
follows : —
Zizyphus glaberrima Santapau in J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 51 : 803,
1953. Z. xylopyra Willd. var. glaberrima Sedgw. in Ind. For. 45 : 71-
72, 1919 ; Santapau in Kew Bull. 1948 : 489-490, 1949.
The plant is frequently seen in the Shorea robusta forest at and around
Sarpaduli especially towards the margins of the forests and in jungle
clearings. Leaves in our specimens are sub-acute or obtuse or rarely
Slightly emarginate, the undersurface of which are completely glabrous
. except for a thinly scattered pubescence on the nerves.
Herbarium specimen examined : uttar pradesh : Sarpaduli,
Corbett National Park, 13.11.1970, P. C. Pant 43189 (BSD).
Acknowledgement
We wish to thank Prof. P. V. Bole, St. Xavier’s College, Bombay,
for help in critically checking the identity of our specimen in Blatter
Herbarium, Bombay.
Botanical Survey of India,
Dehra Dun,
July 28, 1972.
K. P. JANARDHANAN
R. PRASAD
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
345
22. STIPULAR CONDITION IN MAYTENUS EMARG1NATA
(WILLD.) D1NG-HOU
{With two text-figures)
Out of the thirteen species of the family Celastraceae reported from
India (Hooker 1872) five genera have stipules in all their species and
six genera have no stipules in any of their species as given in the Table 1.
Table 1
Stipulate and Exstipulate Genera of Celastraceae
Stipulate
a. Euonymus
b. Kurrimia
c. Elaeodendron
d. Hippocrataea
e. Siphonodon
Exstipulate
a. Glyptopetalum
b. Lophopetalum
c. Microtropis
d. Gymnosporia
e. Pleurostylia
f. Salacia
In the genus Celastrus certain species are described as stipulate and others
as exstipulate. Nothing has been mentioned in the Flora of British
India (Hooker 1872) regarding the presence or absence of stipules in the
genus Kokoona.
346 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (2)
Cooke (1902), Gamble (1915), and Hooker (1872) described the genus
Gymnosporia as exstipulate. In our observations of 350 plants of May.
tenus emarginata (synonym of Gymnosporia montana) collected from
Vallabh Vidyanagar, Gujarat, the leaf has a pair of scaly outgrowths on
either side of its base (Fig. 1). Its size ranges from 0*5 to 0*75 cm. They
are caducous, approximately triangular with deeply lobed margins on
one side only (Fig. 2). They can as well be designated as stipules, as their
function has been observed to be protection of the leaves in young condi-
tion. Their stipular nature can also be inferred from their morphological
position.
Department of Biology, P. H. V. VASUDEVA RAO
R.P.T.P. Science College,
Vallabh Vidyanagar,
Gujarat,
July 8, 1972.
References
Cooxe, T. (1902): Flora of the the Presidency of Madras. London.
Presidency of Bombay. London. Hooker, D. J. (1872) : Flora of
British India, Vol. 1. London, pp. 606-
Gamble, J. S. (1915) : Flora of 629.
23. A FEW UNRECORDED TAXA FOR THE FLORA OF
KAN Y AKUMARI SHORE (CAPE COMORIN), TAMIL NADU
During ecological studies on the coast of India a few plants collected
near Kanyakumari shores were found to be new records for this region
(Gamble 1915, Nayar 1959 and Lawrence 1960).
Burseraceae
Commiphore mukul (Hook, ex Stocks) Engl. A small sized tree with
spinescent branches ; a common shore plant. No. 8081 (CAL).
Fabaceae
Rothia Mica (L.) Druce. A prostrate branched, annual herb.
Common on sand along shore. No. 8227 (CAL).
Crotalaria medicaginea Lamk. A small prostrate herb with dark
yellow flowers mainly confined to dry sand along shore. No. 8220 (CAL).
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
347
Xndigofera aspalathoides Vabl. A hoary undershrub with small red
flowers frequent on seashore sand. No. 8219 (CAL).
Rhynchosla aurea DC. A slender trailing annual herb with yellow
flowers, growing on red sand. No. 8218 (CAL).
Cissia italica (Mill.) Lamk. A diffuse perennial herb with pale yellow
flowers, frequent on seashore red sand. No. 8062 (CAL).
Cassia leschenaultiana DC. A suberect undershrub with yellow
flowers and brown pods growing on red sand. No. 8222 .(CAL) .
CUCURBITACEAE
Citrullus colocynthis (Linn.) Schr. A trailing scabrid herb growing
on dry sand. No. 8077 (CAL).
Ficoideae
Trianthema triquetra Willd. ex Rottl. A prostrate scabrid herb
frequent on red sandy soil. No. 8238 (CAL).
Rubiaceae
Oldenlandia stricta Linn. A tall wiry annual herb common along
seashore sand. No. 8228 (CAL).
CoMPOSITAE
Launaea sarmentosa (Willd.) Alston. A trailing herb with yellow
flower very common on sandy soil. No. 8205 (CAL).
Asclepiadaceae
Hemidesmus indicus (Linn.) Schult. A twining undershrub with
dimorphic leaves growing frequently on seashore red sand. No. 8236
(CAL).
Pentatropis capensis (Linn, f.) Bullock. A slender climber with
purple flowers spreading on Commiphora mukul Engl, along shore.
No. 8204 (CAL).
Pergularia daemia (Forsk.) Choiv. A slender milky climber growing
along hedges. No. 8076 (CAL).
348 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (2)
Boraginaceae
Heliotropium scabrum Retz. A small prostrate scabrid herb or under-
shrub with strigose leaves and white flowers. No. 8229 (CAL).
Acanthaceae
Blepharis maluginifolia Pers. A prostrate small wiry undershrub
with blue flowers, growing along seashore sand. No. 8203 (CAL).
Labiatae
Geniosporum tenuiflorum (Linn.) Merr. A prostrate herb many
branches from a woody root stock ; leaves hispid and glabrous ; growing
on rocky coast carpeted with sea sand. No. 8224 (CAL).
Chenopodiaceae
Atriplex stockesii Boiss. A undershrub with long procumbent
branches ; Obovate leaves completely covered with white shining scales ;
common on granite rocks along seashore. No. 8097 (CAL).
Aristolqchiaceae
Aristolochia bracteolata Lamk. A perennial herb with greenish
corolla tube and purple lip ; common on granite rock crevices along sea-
shore. No. 8201 (CAL).
Euphorbiaceae
Phyllanthus rotundifolius Klein. A prostrate fleshy herb with stout
root stock and trailing branches, common on seashore sand. No.
8232 (CAL).
Phyllanthus maderaspatensis Linn. A decumbent herb with woody
root stock. No. 8096 (CAL).
Euphorbia thymifolia Linn. An annual prostrate herb with hispid
hairy stem. Rare on sand. No. 8095 (CAL).
Euphorbia rosea Retz. A prostrate herbs with long root stock and
beautiful pink flowers ; common on shore sand. No. 8233 (CAL).
Liliaceae
Scilla hyacisithma (Roth) Macbr. A scapigerous herb with white
globose bulb and purple flowers. Common on granite rocks covered
with sand along sea coast. No. 8090 (CAL).
Cyperaceae
Fimbristylis cymosa R. Br. An erect rigid sedge, leaves crowded on
the short rhizome stock ; a good sand binder ; Common on shore sand
along sea coast. No. 8210 (CAL).
Miscellaneous notes
349
Cypertis pactiyrrhizus Nees. A sedge with robust, trigonous stem
covered with chestnut coloured scale ; rootlets densely woolly ; Common
on rocky back shore. No. 8207 (CAL).
Cyperus rotundas Linn. A tuberous sedge with trigonous stem fre-
quent on seashore sand. No. 8240 (CAL).
Gramineae
Mamsuris myurus Linn. A perennial tufted grass, on sandy shore
No. 8221 (CAL).
Sporobolus inaderaspateniis Bor. A perennial erect grass with narrow
pointed convolute leaves ; growing frequently on rocky shore on cal-
careous sand. No. 8066 (CAL).
Perotis indlca (L.) Kuntze. A tufted, wiry grass geniculated at base,
common on sand. No. 8067 (CAL).
Eragrostis coarctata Stapf. An annual or perennial grass with
narrow flat leaves and panicled spikelets ; Common on shore sand. No.
8065 (CAL).
Eragrostis riparia Nees. A slender annual with narrow leaves.
Common on rock sand. No. 8100 (CAL).
Pennisetum pediceliatum Trin. A perennial, tall, branched grass with
narrow flat leaves, common on seashore sand. No. 8242 (CAL).
Acknowledgement
We wish to thank Dr. K. Subramanyam, Director, Botanical Survey
of India, for encouragement.
Ecology Section,
Botanical Survey of India,
76-Acharya J.C. Bose Road,
Calcutta-14,
May 6, 1972.
References
Gamble, J. S. (1915) : The Flora Comorin). J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc.
of the Presidency of Madras. London. 57 : 184-195.
Nayar, M. P. (1959) : The vegetation
Lawrence, C. A. (1960) : The vege- of Kanyakumari District. Bull, bov
tation of Kanyakumari district (Cape Surv. India 1 : 122-126.
T. ANANDA RAO
L. K. BANERJEE
A. K. MUKHERJEE
PRINTED AND PUBLISHED BY I. DURAI AT THE DIOCESAN PRESS,
10 CHURCH ROAD, VEPERY, MADRAS — 20-2-1975. C6732
EDITORS: J. C. DANIEL, P V. BOLE & A. N. D. NANAY ATI
THE SOCIETY’S PUBLICATIONS
Mammals
The R<K>k of Indian Animals, by S. H, Prater. 3rd (revised) edition. 28 plates in
colour by Pan! Barruel and many other monochrome illustrations. Rs. 40
(. Price to members Rs. 35)
The Ecology of the Lesser Bandicoot Rat in Calcutta, by James Juan Spillett. Rs. 10
Birds
The Book of India® Birds, by SAIim Ah. 9th (revised) edition. 66 coloured and
many monochrome plates. Rs. 35
{Price to members Rs. 30)
Checklist of the Birds of Maharashtra, by Humayun Abdulali. Rs. 2*50
(Price to members Rs. 2)
Snakes
Ideatillca (ioa of Poisonous Snakes. Wall chart in English, Gujarati, and Marathi.
Rs. 5
Miscellaneous
Glimpses of Nature Series Booklets :
1. Our Birds I (with 8 coloured plates) in Hindi, and Marathi, Rs. 0*80
Kannada. Rs* O'®
2. Our Birds II (with 8 coloured plates) in Hindi. Rs* 0 62
3. Our Beautiful Trees (with 8 coloured plates) in Hindi and Marathi. Rs. 0*62
4. Our Monsoon Plants (with 8 coloured plates) in English,
Gujarati, Hindi, and Marathi. Rs. 0’8@
5. Our Animals (with 8 coloured plates) in English, Gujarati,
Hindi, and Marathi. Rs. 1*25
Glimpses of Nature in India (witSi 40 coloured plates) in English. Rs. 7.50
( Price to members Rs. 5)
Back numbers of the Society’s Journal. Rates on application.
The Society will gratefully accept back numbers of the Journal , from
members who may not wish to preserve them.
TERMS OF MEMBERSHIP
Entrance Fees :
Ordinary and Life Members
Forest Department Nominees . .
Student Members
Subscription :
(a) Ordinary individual Members
(b) Ordinary Corporate Members
(c) Ordinary Members resident outside India . .
{£ 3 plus 50 p to cover extra postage on Journal)
Life Members
(Rs.
250 after 20 years)
Members residing outside India should pay their subscription by means of orders
on their Bankers to pay the amount of the subscription to the Society in
Bombay on the 1st January in each year. If this cannot be done, then the sum of
/3*50 should be paid annually to the Society’s London Bankers— The National &
Grindlays Bank Ltd., 23 Fenchurch Street, London E.C. 3. Account No, 101095.
The subscription of members elected in October, November, and December
covers the period from the date of their election to the end of the following year •
CONTENTS
PAGE
Observations at the dens of the dhole or Indian wild dog (Cuon alpitws).
By E. R. C. Davidar .. .. .. .. .. 183
Food-habits of water-birds of the Sundarban, 24 Paroanas District, West
Bengal, India — TV. By Ajit Kumar Mukherjee . . . . . . 188
A list of Aphlds (Homoptera : Aphididae) from India and adjacent countries.
By A. K. Ghosh .. .. .. ... .. 201
On the Specificity of Madras Back water Oyster Crassostrea madrasensis
Preston and the American Oyster Crassostrea virginica Gmelin. By
V. S. Durve . . . . . . . . . . . . 226
Flora of Mo thro n wala Swamp Forest (District : Dehra Dun, U.P., India).
By K. M. M. Dakshini .. .. .. ..235
A Catalogue of the Birds in the Collection of the Bombay Natural
History Society — 16. By Humayun Abdulali .. .. .. 244
Contribution to the flora of Tirap Frontier Division. By D. B. Deb and
R. M. Dutta . . . . . . . . . . . . 266
Miscellaneous Notes . . . . . . . . . . 295
s&g .o-y
*5 7 2_
Vol. 71, No. 3
Editors
J. C. DANIEL, P. V. BOLE & A. N. D. NANAVATI
DECEMBER 1974
Rs. 18 (Inland), £ 1-50 (Foreign)
NOTICE TO CONTRIBUTORS
Contributors of scientific articles are requested to assist the
editors by observing the following instructions :
1. Papers which have at the same time been offered for publica-
tion to other journals or periodicals, or have already been published
elsewhere, should not be submitted.
2. The MS. should be typed (double spacing) on one side of a
sheet only, and the sheets properly numbered.
3. All scientific names to be printed in italics should be under-
lined.
4. Trinomials referring to subspecies should only be used where
identification has been authentically established by comparison of
specimens actually collected.
5. Photographs for reproduction must be clear and show good
contrast. Prints must be of a size not smaller than 8*20x5*60 cm.
(No. 2 Brownie) and on glossy glazed paper.
6. Text-figures, line drawings, and maps should be in Indian ink,
preferably on Bristol board.
7. References to literature should be placed at the end of the
paper, alphabetically arranged under author’s name, with the abridged
titles of journals or periodicals underlined (italics) and titles of bdoks
not underlined (roman type), thus :
Banerji, M. L. (1958): Botanical Exploration in East Nepal.
J. Bombay nat . Hist. Soc. 55 (2) : 243-268.
Prater, S. H. (1948) : The Book of Indian Animals, Bombay.
Titles of papers should not be underlined.
8. Reference to literature in the text should be made by quoting
the author’s name and year of publication, thus : (Banerji 1958).
9. Synopsis : Each scientific paper should be accompanied by
a concise, clearly written synopsis, normally not exceeding 200 words.
10. Reprints : Authors are supplied 25 reprints of their articles
free of charge. In the case of joint authorship, 50 copies will be
given gratis to be distributed among the two or more authors. Orders
for additional reprints should be in multiples of 25 and should be
received within two weeks after the author is informed of the acceptance
of the manuscript. They will be charged for at cost plus postage and
packing.
11. The editors reserve the right, other things being equal, to
publish a member’s contribution earlier than a non-member’s.
Editors,
Hombill House, Journal of the Bombay Natural
Shahid Bhagat Singh Road, History Society.
Bombay 400023
VOLUME 71 NO. 3 : DECEMBER 1974
FESTSCHRIFT VOLUME
Date of Publication : 10-3-1976
Selection of nesting trees and the frequency of nest visits by Baya Weaver-
bird. By T. Antony Davis. {With five figures — 2 in text, 3 inset) .. 356
On the biology of the Olivaceous Leaf Warbler of the Tian-Shan
Mountain. By A. F. Kovshar and E. I. Gavrilov. {With three plates ) . . 367
The food of Collocalia swiftlets (Aves, Apodidae) at Nlah Great Cave
in Borneo. By Tom Harris:on {With a plate) .. .. .. 376
Physiological adaptations in the Rosy Pastor wintering in India. By J. C.
George . . . . . . . . . . . . 394
The voice of the Indian Hill Myna {Gracula religiosa ) in the wild. By Brian
Bertram . . . . . . . . . . . . 405
Bird vocalizations as systems of communication. By W. H. Thorpe. {With
eleven text-figures) .. .. .. .. ..414
The Asian Honeyguides. By Herbert Friedmann .. .. .. 426
Present distribution and population status of the Great Bustard, Otis
tarda Linnaeus. By Yu. A. Isakov. {With three maps) . . . . 433
Zoogeography and Systematics
Problems resulting from the discontinuous distribution of Muscicapa
latirostris Raffles. By Erwin and Vesta Stresemann . . . . 445
Similitudes and differences of the Indian and Indochinese avifaunas.
By J. Delacour . . . . . . . . . . . . 452
Zoological results of the Daily Mail Himalayan Expedition 1954 : notes
on some birds of Eastern Nepal. By Biswamoy Biswas . . . . 456
The fauna of Narcondam Island Part 1 — Birds. By Humayun Abdulali . . 496
Adaptations of Andean and Tibetan birds : a brief comparison. By Jean
Dorst . . . . . . . . . . . . 506
Two tropical forests and their birds. By H. Elliott McClure . . . . 517
Geographical distribution of the avian lice (Phthiraptera) : a review.
By Theresa Clay . . .. .. .. .. .. 536
Migration, Bio-medicine and Learning
The migration of the Gannet into the Mediterranean. By A. Landsborough
Thomson . . . . . . . . . . . . 548
The role of birds in the natural foci of tick-borne arboviruses in Western
Siberia. By G. I. Netsky, G. B. Maikov and 1. 1. Bogdanov .. .. 554
Visual learning capacity and retention in the Tree Shrew {Tupaia) : an
extension. By Rudolf Altevogt and Sigrid Zeller. {With three figures —
1 in text, 2 inset) . . . . . . . . . . 564
What leads to increases in the range of certain birds ? By Horace Alexan der 571
Reminiscences and Biographical
Dr. Salim Ali and I. By Yoshimaro Yamashina . . . . . . 577
A portrait of Salim Ali. By Zafar Futehally. {With two plates) .. 579
PAGE
Reviews :
1. Seventy years of Bird watching. (R.E.H.) .. .. ..587
2. Plant galls of India. (T.N.A.) .. .. .. .. 588
3. General entomology. (M.D.) .. .. .. .. 590
4. Main trends in psychology.
Main trends in inter-disciplinary research. (A.N.D.N.) . . . . 590
5. Fundamentals of high altitude biology. (T.N.A.) .. .. 592
Miscellaneous Notes :
General : 1. R. H. Waller’s observations on wild life sanctuaries in India : A
partial rejoinder. By M. Krishnan (p. 594).
Mammals : 2. Record of a Piebald Fulvous Fruitbat, Rousettus leschenaulti
Desmarest. (With a text-figure). By M. A. Sreenivasan and H. R. Bhat
(p. 598) ; 3. New methods of collection of Bats. By H. Khajuria (p. 600) ;
4. A note on body colour and breeding habits in captivity of Common
Palm Civet ( Paradoxurus her maphro dims) of Orissa. By L. N. Acharjyo and
A. P. Tripathy (p. 601) ; 5. An observation on the behaviour of Nilgiri Tahr
( Hemitragus hylocrius ) when threatened by Wild Dog or Dhole ( Cuon alpinus).
By J. C. Gouldsbury (p. 603) ; 6. Food requirement of ‘Black Rat’, Rattus
rattusE. By Devendra Bhardwaj and Jamil Ahmad Khan (p. 605).
Birds : 7. Goliath Heron in the Sunderbans, West Bengal. By Peter F. R.
Jackson (p. 608) ; 8. ?The Little Gull, Larus minutus Pallas, in Kutch. By
Salim Ali (p. 609) ; 9. Whitecheeked Tern Sterna repressa Hartert in Bombay.
By Prabhakara Menon (p. 610) ; 10. Note on the collar appearance in the male
Rose-Ringed Parakeet, Psittacula krameri (Scopoli). By G. S. Simwat and A. S.
Sidhu (p. 611) ; 11. Extension of the range of Cetti’s Warbler Cettia cetti albi-
ventris Severtzov. By S. A. Hussain (p. 611); 12. Nest construction techni-
que of the Spotted Munia, Lonchura punctulata. By B. S. Lamba (p. 613).
Reptiles: 13. A note on Enhydrina schistosa (Daudin) (Hydrcphiidae : Ser-
pentes). By T. Venkateswarlu (p. 616) ; 14. Echis collection in Ratnagiri
District. By R. Whitaker (p. 617) ; 15. Occurrence of the Bat-Fish, Pegasus
volitans Linnaeus (Pegasiformes : Pegasidae) from the coastal waters of India.
By T. Venkateswarlu (p.620 ).
Molluscs : 16. Note on the record of genus Amnicola from Ahmedabad. By
Y. M. Dalai and G. T. Pandya (p. 622).
Insects : 17. Addition to the record of host plants of Chilo zonel/us (Swinhce)
(Lepidoptera : Pyralidae). By M. Vishakantaiah and B. L. Visweswara Gowda
(p. 622) ; 18. Occurrence of pests on Kodo Millet (Paspalum scrobiculatum) .
By V. D. Guruswamy Raja and U.S. Natarajan (p. 623) ; 19. Systematics of
Indian Rhopalidae (Hemiptera). By N. P. Chopra (p. 624) ; 20. Distributional
records of Muscidae (Diptera). By R. S. Gokulpure (p. 627).
Botany : 21. Shepherd’s purse — an edible plant of Kashmir. By A. K. Koul
and J. L. Karihaloo (p. 628) ; 22. Taxonomical notes on Cleome aspera Keen,
ex DC., C. Burmanni Wt. & Arn. and C. Rutidosperma DC. (Cleomaceae). By
C. R. Babu and N. C. Majumdar (p. 629) : 23. Anew species of Sonerila
(Melastomataceae) from Kerala, S. India. ( With a plate). By M. P. Nayar
(p. 632) ; 24. Hemigraphis hirta (Vahl) T. Anders. — A new record for Bombay.
(With a text-figure). By G. M. Oza (p. 614) ; 25. Hermaphroditism in Cassava
(Manihot esculenta Crantz.). (With two photographs and nine text-figures). By
Philomena Madhavadian, Susan Abraham and C. A. Ninan (p. 635).
Annual Report of the Bombay Natural History Society for the year
1973-74. . . . . . . . . . . 640
Statement of Accounts of the Bombay Natural History Society . . 648
Minutes of the Annual General Meeting
.. 662
Salim
Ali at Bharatpur, March 1969.
(Photo: V. S. Saxena )
Journal
OF THE
BOMBAY NATURAL
HISTORY SOCIETY
1974 DECEMBER Vol. 71 No. 3
Prefatory Note
It is now two years since Salim Ali’s 75th birthday, which this volume
was to commemorate. Instead it will be appearing in his seventy-eighth
year. Hale and hearty, our distinguished Salim Ali and the author
with trekking party and family recently celebrated his seventy-seventh
birthday in the field, studying birds in Bhutan. On that occasion the
author composed a jingle which expresses some of this contributor’s
admiration for the doyen of Indian ornithology.
S.D.R.
ODE TO SALIM ON HIS SEVENTY-SEVENTH BIRTHDAY
12 November 1973, in camp, Bhutan
From the Wakhan and the Rann
To Point Calimere and Kandy
In monsoon rain or sun,
In dak bungalow or dandy,
Wherever there are birds
You will hear the reverent words :
Oh Salim's our hero , Salim's the man
Whose knowledge is always on tap .
The terror of wrens, Finn's Baya's fan ,
A truly remarkable chap.
352 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. H (3)
So ho for the Wedgebilled Wren
And hey for the tragopan hen ;
So ho for the tweet tweet tseep
And hey for the leopard’s cheep.1
Let’s squeak like Blewitt’s Owl
And honk like water fowl
As through thicket, bog and heather
We hunt for Hume’s stray feather.
Oh Salim's our hero , Salim's the man
Whose knowledge is always on tap.
The terror of wrens , Finn's Baya's fan ,
A truly remarkable chap.
For our part we know his knowledge will glow
For ages to come, his lamp will shine out.
His birthday we sing while pheasants all crow
And birds of all kinds join in tuneful shout.
Nor Hodgson nor Baker knows more about life
Nor Coltart nor Inglis have weathered the strife
About bird lore and bird song with steadier light
Than our hero whose birthday we welcome tonight.
Oh Salim's our hero , Salim's the man
Whose knowledge is always on tap.
The terror of wrens , Finn's Baya's fan9
A truly remarkable chap.
1 Laboured. This reference is to the man who described the call of Molesworth’s
race of Blyth’s tragopan, from where it sat in the middle of a bamboo clump, as sound-
ing like a leopard ! One of our pet jokes.
Introduction
S. Dillon Ripley
The concept of dedicating a special issue of the Bombay Natural History
Society Journal to Salim Ali on the occasion of his seventy-fifth birthday
is an eminently sensible one. Salim Ali has been the moving spirit
behind the Society and its publications for more time than most of us can
visualize. It is indeed right that these contributions by his friends and
colleagues should appear in the pages of the Journal which he has helped
to shape for so many years.
The Journal is a journal in many unexpected ways, having survived
the middle years of this Century successfully, the years when there was
a temporary decline in the prestige of the term natural history . The
early years of this Century were still dedicated to the necessary surveys
and summaries of taxonomical reviews and field notes. It was Salim
Ali himself who introduced the more modern-day concepts of ecology
to India. His papers, appearing in this Journal, on life history and
behaviour of birds in the Survey series, and his notes on the biogeo-
graphy of India as expressed in recent historical zoology, helped to revo-
lutionize Indian biology, no less than his Book of Indian Birds helped to
awaken the minds of countless Indians as well as foreigners to the delights
of field observation.
And so Salim Ali has spanned the generations from the days of the
amateur and sportsman, many of them British, but not a few famous
shikaris of Indian parentage, in the first years of the Bombay Society,
to the present day when ecology has come into its own, and natural
history in the best sense has had a renaissance all over the world. It
is, therefore, a special privilege to help to preside over this issue for one
who not only holds Salim Ali in the highest esteem as a great scientist,
but also holds him in affection as a close friend. Scholars and scientists
alike in India will always treasure Salim Ali’s contributions in science
as well as in humanity.
The list of contributors is long and would have been longer were it
not for the heavy burdens of many of our colleagues. We greet with
sadness the recent death of one of the most notable contributors,
Professor Stresemann, and we mourn the loss of another colleague David
Lack, who would have contributed but for the preoccupations of a fatal
illness. We regret that others have found it impossible to be present
in these pages, all admirers and friends of Salim Ali ; Bernhard Rensch,
354 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
K. S. Dharmakumarsinhji, A. I. Ivanov among them. But the felicitous
Dr Yoshimaro Yamashina has commented on his noted colleague as
follows : ‘ I am awfully pleased to have heard that a “ Festschrift ”
volume is to be published honouring the 75th birthday of our good friend,
Dr Salim Ali. I am delighted and wish to join your suggestion and will
write a short article for its memorable publication of my friend of long
standing.’
The papers included in this assemblage are from a variety of authors
representing Salim Ali’s wide range of personal interests and friendships.
Some are essentially biographical as those of Messrs Futehally and
Yamashina. Others are concerned with comparative field observations
as those of Dr McClure and Professor Dorst where two types of similar
habitats and their accompanying faunal differences are described. Zoo-
geographical considerations are the preoccupations of Messrs Abdulali
and Delacour and Dr Biswas. The late Professor Stresemann describes
a provocative systematic problem of presumably sibling populations of
the same species, while Professor George considers the physiological
phenomena concerned with a migratory population. Two authors
speculate on the biology or changing distribution of bird species ;
Dr Friedmann in preparation perhaps for more field work on honey-
guides and Mr Horace Alexander in connexion with problems of human
interference with the landscape.
In connexion with Salim Ali’s interest in migratory studies of birds
some of his Russian colleagues, Professor Netsky and Dr Maikov and
Dr Bogdanov, have contributed a paper on tick-borne arboviruses, while
Dr Theresa Clay has speculated on avian lice and their speciation in
connexion presumably with environmental modifications of host species.
An additional migration study based on ringing returns is that of Sir
Landsborough Thomson on the Gannet. Vocalization in birds is the
subject of two papers by Professor Thorpe and Dr Brian Bertram, while
field biology of a warbler, and competing swift species are the topics of
Professor Gavrilov and Dr A.F. Kovshar, and Professor Tom Harrisson,
the expert on the Niah caves of Sarawak.
One of Salim Ali’s most notable contributions in field biology is
represented by a paper by Professor T. A. Davis. This is a paper on the
Baya, and its selection of nesting sites. The breadth of Dr Salim Ali’s
interests is represented by the contribution of Professor Altevogt and
Dr Zeller on visual learning in the Tree Shrew, Tupaia glis. A paper
on the distribution and numbers of the Great Bustard, Otis tarda , of
Eurasia, by Dr Isakov, completes the series.
In my own case I can only contribute a continuing interest in high-
altitude observations in the eastern Himalayas. I have reported briefly
on observations made in Bhutan in 1968 while on a joint field trip, under-
taken at Salim Ali’s behest (Proc. XV International Ornithological Con-
INTRODUCTION
355
gress, The Hague, 1972, pp. 682-3), and continuing in 1973. It is my
hope eventually to join with him as well as Dr Biswas in publishing our
Bhutan observations, as well perhaps as notes on comparative ecology
of migrant and resident species. Meanwhile our work together on the
Indian Handbook has been my own reward for the privilege of knowing
this felicitous man.
Selection of nesting trees and
the frequency of nest visits
by Baya weaverbird1
T. Antony Davis
Indian Statistical Institute , Calcutta
(With five figures)
Introduction
Dr Salim Ali inspired me to study birds. I am particularly delighted,
therefore, to have an opportunity to join colleagues to felicitate this
eminent ornithologist on this auspicious occasion by presenting a paper.
Dr Ali was the earliest to investigate thoroughly the nesting habits of the
baya weaverbird Ploceus philippinus (L.). I consider it appropriate,
therefore, to report here some of my own observations on this fascinating
species, so dear to village folk of India.
The baya weaverbird, noted for its complex, retort-shaped, dangling
nest, woven with strips of grass and palm leaves, is familiar throughout
the Indian subcontinent and the adjoining countries of Pakistan, Bangla-
desh, Burma, Thailand, Malaysia and Sri Lanka. The adult male baya
is sparrow-like but streaked with brown, and with a thick bill and short
rounded tail (Fig. 1). Being sexually dimorphic during the breeding
season, the male acquires golden yellow plumage on the breast and head.
The female is more drab, rather like a hen sparrow but for her stouter
bill and shorter tail.
In India the baya selects a variety of trees, shrubs and other sites
for nesting, the most favoured among them being the thorny acacias and
certain species of palms. Moreover, the birds in each particular region
seem to prefer a particular type of nesting site. To understand the
reason for such a preference, I toured over all the Indian states and
recorded as many baya colonies as possible. Details on the survey
are summarized in this paper.
The baya nest is woven almost exclusively by the male who acquires
a mate when the nest reaches the ‘ helmet 9 stage. The pair live together
until the female has stopped laying and begins to incubate the clutch of
2-4 eggs. By this time the male completes the nest- weaving, including
the tubular entrance. The hen hatches the eggs and feeds the young
1 Received December 1972.
NESTING TREES AND NEST VISITS BY BAY A WEAVERBIRD. 357
practically on her own. Detailed records were kept by watching the
birds continuously for over 12 hours daily on the nest-building activities
of males in a colony in a suburb of Calcutta, and the activities of hens
brooding the eggs and nursing the young were also recorded. Details
on the nest visits of the male as well as the female baya are also dis»
cussed in this paper.
Host trees, shrubs and structures of baya colonies
The baya weaverbird in India has been found to colonize a surprising
variety of plants. Structures like house eaves (Davis 1971a), telegraph
and power lines (Ambedkar 1970), the sides of irrigation wells (Ali 1931,
Crook 1960a, 1963) are occasionally selected for hanging their nests.
When first travelling from the southern tip of India (Kanyakumari)
to Calcutta in 1960, in observing the host plants of the baya, I felt that
the birds of different regions seemed to prefer different species of plants
for colonization. So I decided to make a survey of the Indian sub-
continent covering all the states for studying the host range of baya
colonies. During the following six years, I covered about 15,000 km
in various states almost exclusively for observing the baya colonies by
travelling in slow-moving trains, omnibuses, bullock carts or on foot.
I should mention here that the survey was not designed statistically and
so I might have covered proportionately more area in one region/state:
than in the others. But the proportion of the different host plants would
remain more or less the same within a given region. Such a proportion
between some states varies considerably.
Altogether 1485 colonies were recorded as shown in the Table. The
number of nests per colony varied from one to about two hundred and
fifty. About forty different species of plants were found to carry
baya nests. Mathew (1972) has added a species to this list. In
Uttar Pradesh alone, at least 25 species of plants were colonized.
It is clear from the Table that plants having prominent thorns, prickles
or similar devices which may act as deterrents to predators, notably
marauding monkeys and snakes, have attracted the baya most. About
68 per cent of colonies were located on such trees beset with thorns,
prickles and similar defensive structures, besides those on electric or
telegraph lines and inside irrigation wells which are very well protected
from most predators . In some cases the nesting trees were not themselves
spiny but were surrounded by thick brambles. The coconut ( Cocos
nucifera) and the areca palm {Areca catechu ), both without spines, to-
gether account for about 15 per cent of the plants which were preferred
in two regions for nesting. The tall,, unbranched, smooth trunk and the
long, swaying leaves which keep away many predators and provide a
convenient source of leaf strips for weaving may compensate for lack of
Host plants and structures for Baya colonies in different regions of India
358
JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
pn°i
uoiSsj messy
<oor^'soa\rt-(Nrtr^noso\
— cn nin
Tj- m *-H
~ I I
I " I 2“° I M | I | I | I |
•il'S
S3 ~cs 25
St .2
m
<j 5U Q
3 O V
0^3
I 3 -a
8 gs
1
ass’s
M « ^
„ C/3 O
•S2
03 — <
H
Xft,aq^OtS)Q
^c4rn-^iovor^eoaNO^c^fnTj-«o\oi<ooa\
<u a
^ I
■sgl
<*■§ «
■ s s 1
J||
C/3 0* K
«2 to
to a *3
■% cs g
&1 8-
<= B a"
>>
U H
%
°§l!
a* r. .3-'§£
2 u «« « « °
i3 >
D O +2 +- d ci
HCLOOPtf}
Total .. 155 396 33 43 96 20 98 66 29 31 56 54 75 255 78 1485
Plate I
OMBAY NAT. HlST. SOC. 71 (3)
s: Baya
Fig. 2.
A large colony on a mar-
gosa tree standing close to
a house. Nests are also hung
on the roof of the house.
{Photo: Author )
Fig. 1.
1 male baya weaverbird
n nonbreeding plumage.
{Photo: Author)
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (3)
Davis : Baya
Plate II
Fig. 3. Preferred host trees for founding baya colonies in different regions of
India.
NESTING TREES AND NEST VISITS BY BAY A WEAVERBIRD 359
spines. Other unprotected trees are also used for nesting, like Terminalia
arjuna whose trunk is extremely slippery. At other times, the bird builds
nests on unarmed trees like margosa (Fig. 2), drumstick and mahua
standing in close proximity to human habitations or whose stems are
surrounded by a sheet of water. In most of these cases there is a good
source of nesting fibre in the vicinity.
The most preferred host tree seems to be Acacia sp. With the
exception of three states all have colonies on one or more species of
Acacia. Acacia arabica and A. leucophloea are the most common species.
The prominent and profuse thorns present all around the plant, the nu-
merous slender branches that form a dense crown, and the tree’s capa-
city to withstand waterlogging for long periods keep off most enemies
including crawling predators like tree snakes, tree rats and even the curio-
hunters. It is striking that even shorter acacias standing in water are
preferred over nearby bigger ones of the same species on dry ground.
As acacias are devoid of nesting fibre, it may be inferred that the safety
of the nest and inmates becomes the foremost consideration in choosing
a nest site and takes precedence over availability of nesting fibre or food.
Critical examination of the figures in the Table shows that the baya
colonies in different localities seem to prefer different host trees or struc-
tures for nesting. For example, in the Assam region, over 84 per cent
of the colonies were located on Areca palm, and about 60 per cent of the
colonies in Andhra Pradesh were on wild date ( Phoenix sylvestris) :
see map of India in Fig. 3. In the region of Bihar, Orissa and south-west
Bengal (presumably Bangladesh also), palmyra (Borassus jiabellifer)
is the preferred host tree. Similarly, in southern India comprising the
states of Kerala, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, over 60 per cent of the
colonies were established on the coconut palm. In the remaining
states of northwestern India (Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh,
Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Haryana, Punjab, Himachal Pradesh, and
Jammu & Kashmir), acacias are the most preferred hosts. It is also
striking that telegraph lines are popular as sites in Assam.
The choice of host trees by baya may be variously motivated, and
unless the vegetation and ecology of the various tracts, and the nature
of predators, are studied thoroughly, it may not be possible to under-
stand the whole of a situation. It is not always a tree which provides
nesting fibre or one that is most common in a locality that is preferred.
However, in Kerala, Karnataka, and Tamil Nadu, coconut, the pre-
ferred host, is the most common tree and it yields the nesting fibre. But
the reason occurring to me is the fact that in this region, people tradi-
tionally do not disturb the baya colonies on coconut as some ‘ wise men ’
in the past had spread the rumour that the yield of coconut would drop
suddenly if baya colonies on them were destroyed. Hence, although
the palmyra palms armed with serrated leaf-stalks are abundant in
360 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
these states, coconut is mostly preferred. Since coconut cannot protect
from tree snakes that are prevalent in this regior, as an adaptation
the nests are usually provided with very long entrance tubes to prevent
snakes reaching the egg-chamber (Davis 1971b).
In the region comprising Orissa, Bihar and West Bengal (south)
where palmyra is the preferred host, coconut, arecanut, wild date and
acacias are equally common. Palmyra leaf is incidentally too hard for
the baya to collect strands from it and hence nests on palmyra are always
woven with fibre from other plants. One would, therefore, expect more
colonies on acacias or on wild date than on the palmyra. Further,
palmyra is the most common tree in Andhra Pradesh. But in this region,
most of the colonies are established on wild date. Anyone travelling
through Andhra Pradesh can see for himself how the palmyras are cruelly
defoliated, leaving only a couple of the very young leaves. Palmyra
leaves are traditionally cut for making various articles such as baskets,
hats and mats. Past experience of calamities resulting from cutting
of leaves hosting nests must have induced the bird in Andhra Pradesh
to select trees other than palmyra for nesting. In the northwestern
states of India where acacia has been the most preferred host, wild date,
which provides fibre, grows abundantly. But acacias are preferred even
though they don’t provide the nesting fibre. The rainfall of this region
is very low and the monsoon commences from July when the rain-fed
crops of millets and maize are grown. Moreover, several species of
grasses spread their numerous leaves. Sugarcane (where cultivated)
also produces large and abundant leaves during the monsoon. All
these graminaceous plants supply the leaf strands for woven nests.
Moreover, the acacias are usually small trees surrounded by the millet
crops, and carrying the leaf strands cannot be a serious problem. Of
the acacias, the bird usually prefers those which are surrounded by
water. Another factor which seems favourable with acacia is that the
foundation for a nest is more easily attached on its twig than on the
leaflets of palms. Thus, in spite of the lack of fibre strands, acacia seems
to be the most perfect host tree for a baya colony.
The map of India (Fig. 3) further reveals that along the east coast and
in Assam, colonies of baya are mainly founded on palms (coconut, wild
date, palmyra and areca). Exceptional baya colonies were also noticed
on palms such as Arenga pinnata, Caryota mens , Hyphaene thebaica ,
Livistona chinensis , Phoenix dactylifera , P. fariniera and Roystonea
regia. This region receives relatively more rain, which is well distri-
buted. Therefore, rivers, ponds and tanks abound here which sustain
green vegetation over a greater part of the year. Most of the palms pro-
vide nest-weaving fibre round the year. Such a situation induces the baya
to have a prolonged nesting season which usually extends from May to
early November. On the other hand, the birds in northwestern India,
NESTING TREES AND NEST VISITS BY BAY A WEAVERBIRD 361
preferring the acacias for nesting, have a shorter period which extends
generally from July to the end of October. The birds in this region
must await the monsoon, which commences from July, not only for the
supply of insects to feed the young, but also for the nesting fibre which
comes mostly from millets and other grasses.
Is ESJ -BUILDING ACTIVITIES OF THE MALE
Nest-building activities in the weaverbirds have been studied by many
workers (Ali 1931, Crook 1960b, 1964 ; Collias & Collias, 1962, 1963).
I studied the progress of nest-building in sixbaya nests of a colony
on a palmyra palm located at the northern end of Calcutta by observing
them continuously for 12-14 hours daily during April-May from a 5 m
high platform (a machan not a hide) erected within 4 m from the host
tree. It was flanked to the south 4 m away by a date palm and on the
north about 25 m away by a row of five coconut palms. There was a
pond on the eastern side. The bamboo platform was due west of the
colony from where I could make out clearly whether a bird at a parti-
cular time brought a load of coconut fibre, date fibre, a load of mud or
nothing at all. After nearly an hour’s initial caution, the baya quietly
acclimatized and ignored the observer’s presence.
Amazingly, a male baya works for twelve to thirteen hours a day
during the nesting season, not breaking for more than 30 minutes at a
time for foraging, preening, resting or pursuing a female in courtship.
If the male has already completed a nest, the site for the new nest is
often chosen very close to it. Otherwise, any suitable and strong palm
leaflet is selected and one or two small slots or wedges made to fix or tie
the initial fibres. In a dicotyledonous plant like Acacia , usually the tip of
a horizontal thin shoot forms the nesting site. Making the foundation
is the most difficult job, which is done by long sugarcane or coconut fibres
where available. On the first day, for the construction of the wad and
suspension of one of the nests studied, the male brought fibre at the rate
of four loads per hour. The initial ring was also formed in the course of
the first day itself. From the graph (Fig. 4) it is seen that the frequency
of bringing fibre increased steadily when once the nest suspension was
completed. On the second day he brought 8 loads per hour, which
frequency increased to 26 on the fifth day when the nest was half com-
plete with two distinct openings at the bottom intercepted by a narrow
bridge. The latter served as a platform for the bird to perch and rest or
work. This stage is usually called the ‘ helmet ’ stage and thus it is the
home of a ‘ bachelor ’ who is yet to acquire a mate. Then, on the fifth
day, almost once every two minutes he was able to bring and weave a
load of fibre. In addition, the bird visited the nest without any fibre
362 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
several times. Such barren visits were at the maximum when he was
engaged in luring a female. It is known that a male baya brings loads
of mud or cattle-dung and deposits them on the inner walls of the egg-
Fig. 4. Graph showing the frequency of male baya’s visits to the nest
with building material.
chamber (Davis 1972). From the second day of starting a nest such
pasty materials are brought, and the frequency of such loads per nest
varies with regions. The graph in Fig. 4 does not include the visits with
mud or dung which per day was not more than six.
NESTING TREES AND NEST VISITS BY BAY A WEAVERBIRt) 363
From the sixth day there was a decline in the nest-weaving activity
which indicates an important behavioural change. The two openings of
the nest continue to remain until its owner is able to secure a mate, for
nests are completed only if the hens approve them. At this time the
female baya in her egg-laying stage starts visiting the palm in search of a
nest and a mate. When a female is sighted from afar, the males of the
colony are beside themselves with excitement, and there is a big commo-
tion with hectic flights around the trees. Each male in his nuptial golden
plumage displays himself by perching on his nest and fluttering his wings
and lifting the nest towards the female. This display is accompanied by
a deafening chorus of bird-song and violent flutterings of wings. By
the manipulation of the tail, he swings to and fro, often hanging head
downward. At the climax, he sometimes reaches the approaching female
and escorts her to his nest. The hen, apparently calm and sedate amidst
the amorous daylight serenades and chattering advances of the cock,
alights on the narrow bridge of the nest. She tests the strength of the
nest by poking her beak into the wall and pulling out some fibre as if
performing a ritualized test of building standards. During these tense
moments, the male watches her hopefully, often chasing off other males
who may approach. But after some time the female gets out of the nest
and tries another vacant home. She inspects all nests available for
occupation likewise, thereby apparently assessing the weaving competence
of the males. It is strange that though she is unable to weave a single
fibre, she seems competent to judge and select the best nest. The same
or the following day she repeats her visit to the nest of her choice, and
more frequently thereafter, indicating her willingness to accept the archi-
tect of that nest as her mate. The first mating of the pair, usually taking
place while the hen is perched on the bridge of the nest, revives the nest-
building activity of the cock. During the period when the male entices
a hen, he makes several visits to the nest without any fibre. On some
days such empty visits may equal the number of loads of fibre brought.
On the eighth day, a cup-like egg-chamber was actively built by doss-
ing one of the openings and this activity is shown by the second node in
Fig. 4. The four-day period (from the fifth day) represents the cock’s
intense activities to lure a hen, and such a period is prolonged in the case
of the less efficient males not capable of weaving ideal nests. From the
second opening, a tubular entrance is woven downwards. The female
collects fine feathers or cotton wool and prepares a soft lining in the egg-
chamber and lays a clutch of 2-4 eggs. By the end of this period when
the nest with its tubular entrance is completed, the cock leaves both nest
and hen, and his interest shifts to building another nest for another
prospective mate. At a later stage the male makes occasional visits
to the original nest to feed the young. Such visits are not shown in the
graph.
364 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 11 (3)
Nest visits of the female
After the short conjugal life, the hen undertakes the strenuous job
of hatching the eggs and feeding the young almost single-handed. The
incubation period is 12 to 14 days. The female does not sit on the eggs
continuously for more than two hours, but gets out and perches on the
helmet part of the nest preening and relaxing, or flies away to forage.
The frequent interruptions in the brooding seem as if to keep the eggs
from overheating. In the Cape Weaver Bird ( Hyphantornis capensis
olivaceus) incubation of the eggs is mostly at night, the warmth from the
sun presumably being sufficient during the day. Jayakar & Spurway
(1965) recorded another interesting phenomenon with the yellow-wattled
lapwing. During the hotter parts of the day, the parent pair cooled the
eggs of their clutch by wetting their breasts and bellies in standing water
immediately before walking on to the nest.
The day the eggs hatch, the mother baya is visibly excited and she goes
in and out of the nest frequently. The broken shells of the eggs are drop-
ped directly beneath the nest. Perhaps one reason for the baya’ s pre-
ference to nest on locations overhanging water is to conceal from enemies
the droppings and shells. Now she spends more time nursing and
brooding the young, and flies out only during the feeding time in search
of food. The first day the hen under observation brought food at the
rate of about 3*5 trips per hour and remained active for over twelve
hours in the day. On the second day, the frequency increased to 6 per
hour, and thereafter as the appetite of the nestlings increased, the mother
brought more food at frequent intervals (Fig. 5). On the ninth day she
brought food at the rate of 17 times an hour, being the maximum for
feeding three nestlings. The frequency of food- visits gradually de-
creased either due to the decreasing appetite, or possibly the mother
brought bigger loads of food. On the seventeenth day, the fledgelings
left the nest. In some nests, fledgelings left on the sixteenth day. Very
rarely the father brought food, but his visits appeared to be motivated by
curiosity rather than responsibility. Ambedkar (1964) reported a fairly
high degree of active participation of the cock in feeding the young.
A pair of crows (Corvus splendens) nesting on a palmyra palm oppo-
site my home at Calcutta were observed for a month. The graph (Fig. 5)
shows that the crow-parents together did not make half the number of
food visits as the single baya mother. The baya feeds the young with
animal food although the adults mainly eat grain. The crows of this
nest were found to feed the young with discarded food and grain from
nearby houses. As the baya brings usually one insect or a worm each
time, it can satiate only a single nestling in one visit. On the contrary,
the crow is able to feed more than one nestling in each visit as the food it
carries is easy to share.
NESTING TREES AND NEST VISITS BY BAY A WEAVERB1RD 365
FjG4 5* Graphs showing food visits of the female baya ; and food visits
of a pair of crows nursing 3 young.
366 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NAtURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Summary
The baya weaverbird Ploceus philip pinus(L.) in India has been found
to colonize a surprising variety of plants, as well as structures like house
eaves, telegraph and power lines and the sides of irrigation wells. During
a survey of the Indian states, 1485 colonies were recorded. 68 per cent
of the colonies were located on plants beset with thorns, prickles and
similar defensive structures, besides those on electric or telegraph lines
and inside irrigation wells which are adequately protected against
predators. The most preferred tree is Acacia sp. The choice of a host
tree seems to be variously motivated subject to local ecological condi-
tions. Thus, baya colonies, depending on locality, prefer different host
plants for nesting and often ignore apparently ideal trees which are
also available. From data collected it may be inferred that the safety
of the nest and inmates is the foremost consideration in choosing a
nest site, taking precedence over availability of nesting fibre or food.
By watching a colony continuously for 12-14 hours daily, the specia-
lized nest-building activities of the male, and the number of visits the
female made feeding the young single-handed, were studied. Amazingly,
the bayas remain active for 12-13 hours a day during the breeding sea-
son. On a peak day, the male brought a load of fibres and completed
weaving them in about two minutes and this pace was maintained the
whole day. The female brought a maximum of 17 loads of food an hour
to feed the nine-day-old nestlings.
I thank Mr S. K. De, artist, for making the drawings.
References
Ali, S. (1931) : The nesting habits
of the baya ( Ploceus philippinus). A new
interpretation of their domestic relations.
Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 34 : 947-64.
Ambedkar, V. C. (1964) : Some Indian
weaverbirds. A contribution to their
breeding biology. University of Bombay.
— — (1970) : Nests of the baya,
Ploceus philippinus (Linnaeus) on tele-
graph wires. J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc.
66 : 624.
Collias, N. E. & Colli as, E. C.
(1962) : An experimental study of the
mechanisms of nest building in a weaver-
bird. The Auk 79: 568-95.
— & (1963) : Evolu-
tionary trends in nest building by the
weaverbirds (Ploceidae). Proc. XIII
Internat. Ornithol. Cong. 518-30.
Crook, J. H. (1960a) : Studies on the
reproductive behaviour of the baya
weaver Ploceus philippinus (L). J. Bom-
bay nat. Hist. Soc. 57 : 1-44.
(1960b) : Nest form and
construction in certain West African
weaver-birds, ibid. 102 : 1-25.
— (1963) : The Asian weaver-
birds ; problems of co-existence and evo-
lution with particular reference to beha-
viour. J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 60 :
1-48.
(1964) : Field experiments
on the nest construction and repair
behaviour of certain weaver-birds. Proc.
Zool. Soc. Lond. 142 : 217-55.
Davis, T. A. (1971a) : Baya weaver-
bird nesting on human habitations. /.
Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 68 : 246-8.
(1971b) : Variation in nest-
structure of the common weaver-bird
Ploceus philippinus (L.) of India. Forma
et Functio 4 : 225-39.
(1972) : Mud and dung plas-
tering in baya nests. J. Bombay nat.
Hist. Soc. 70 : 57-71.
Jayakar, S. D. & Spurway, H. (1965):
The yellow-wattled lapwing, Vanellus
malabaricus (Boddaert), a tropical dry
season nester. II. Additional data
on breeding biology, ibid. 62 : 1-14.
Mathew, D. N. (1972) : The ecology
of the baya in Rajampet, Cuddapah
district, Andhra Pradesh, ibid. 69
188-91.
On the biology of the Olivaceous
Leaf Warbler of the Tian-Shan
Mountain1
. A. F. Kovshar and E. I. Gavrilov
institute of Zoology of the Academy of Sciences of the Kazakh SSR
( With three plates)
The Olivaceous Leaf Warbler ( Phylloscopus griseolus Blyth) is a typical
representative of the avian fauna of the mountainous regions of Middle
and Central Asia and partly in south-western Siberia, from Upper
India on the south to the sources of the Ob on the north. It inhabits the
Western Himalayas, the northern border of the Tibet upland and the
Kuen-Lun Mts approximately up to 91°E., the mountain ranges in
Afghanistan to the north of Ziarat (in Baluchistan), the Hindukush,
Western Kashgaria, Pamir, Kuhitang and Tian-Shan Mts, the
Dzungarskiy Alatau and Tarbagatai ridges, the central and north-
western parts of Altai, the Khangai Altai and Gobi Altai approximately
up to the 85°E. It nests sporadically in the eastern part of the
Kazakh plateau. The Olivaceous Leaf Warbler winters in Pakistan and
India as far as Hyderabad in the south.
The biology of this species is still very little known. The data on the
way of life of this warbler in diverse ranges of the Tian-Shan moun-
tainous country available in the literature (Zarudniy & Koreev 1906 ;
Shnitnikov 1949 ; Korelov 1956a, 1956b ; Stepanian 1959 ; Yanushevich
et al. 1960) are rather scanty and fragmentary. The main materials for
this paper were collected in the Bolshoye Almatinskoye canyon of the
Zailiyskiy Alatau range (in the northern Tian-Shan, near Alma-Ata)
in 1964-5 by I. A. Dolgushin, E. I. Gavrilov, E. F. Rodionov and M. A.
Kuzmina, in 1967 and 1969 by E. F. Rodionov, and 1971-2 by A. F.
Kovshar. The observations of A. F. Kovshar in the Talasskiy Alatau
ridge (in the western Tian-Shan) in 1960-66 and the data from literature
on other ridges of the Tian-Shan were also used.
Unlike other representatives of the genus Phylloscopus , the Oliva-
ceous Leaf Warbler is not a forest bird and during the nest period avoids
forests and soft grassy slopes, preferring rocky slopes with thinly growing
1 Received October 1972.
2
368 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
shrubs. In the Tian-Shan it usually nests above the upper limit of fir-
groves but it can descend to the forested zone along stone screes : in the
Zailiyskiy Alatau ridge at least up to 2300 m, and in the Terskei Alatau
ridge up to 1900 m (Kovshar 1972a). In the Terskei Alatau the vertical
distribution of this warbler is rather peculiar. In the eastern portion of
the ridge it inhabits the Alpine and Subalpine zones up to 3700-3800 m,
is absent in the forest zone and reappears on the slopes of the foothills
facing the Issykkul Lake depression ; in its western part, where the tree
zone is not continuous, the Olivaceous Leaf Warbler probably nests
everywhere from the foothills up to the Alpine grasslands (Stepanian
1959).
The favourite places of nesting of the Olivaceous Leaf Warbler in the
Bolshoye Almatinskoye canyon are the stony taluses and deposits with
large boulders and some patches of creeping juniper ( Juniperus turces-
tanica) or stunted little bushes of Lonicera sp., Spiraea, Atraphaxis,
Cotoneaster. Under such conditions it also nests on the edges of spruce-
groves, but does not enter the depths of the forest. Only once, in June
1971, a couple of birds made an unsuccessful attempt to build their nest
on a fir-tree in a relatively thick forest (2315 m).
The numbers of the Olivaceous Leaf Warblers in the Tian-Shan
are low. It is rare in the Terskei Alatau ridge (Stepanian 1959), not
numerous in the Talas skiy Alatau (Kovshar 1966) and on the northern
slopes of the Kungei Alatau, but rather frequent in the Zailiyskiy Alatau.
In spring the warblers appear in their nesting places by the last ten
days of April. In the Bolshoye Almatinskoye canyon in 1965 the first
was seen on 29 April, and in 1972 on 23 April. In the neighbouring
Kaskelen canyon the arrival was registered on 28 April 1954. To the
southern slopes of the Talasskiy Alatau in 1954 the warblers arrived on
21 April, to the western part of the range in 1958 on 27 April, to the
northern slopes in 1966 on 27 April and in 1965 on 28 April. In the
Issykkul Lake area and to the south of it they appear a little earlier. For
example, in Naryn (Central Tian-Shan) in 1909 they arrived on 15 April*
on the southern slopes of the Kungei Alatau ridge a male was taken on
15 April 1952 and in the Terskei Alatau on 26 April 1956 (Yanushevich
et al. 1960). A very early arrival was registered in the Terskei Alatau
ridge in 1961 : two males were observed there on 25 and 26 March, but
after that they evidently did not appear till 12 April (Shukurov 1968).
In the beginning the warblers are rather secretive and only their
characteristic call, strikingly resembling the sound of water drops drip-
ping on to a wet stone, betrays them. But in a few days the males begin
singing : in 1972 the first song was heard on 28 April and in 1965 on
3 May, i.e. 5 and 4 days after the arrival. The song consists of 3-9
usually 4-5 notes of the same pitch closely following one after another
They can be represented as t ivt ivtivtivti v, t wit witwitwit wi, kwikwikwikwikwi ,
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (3) Plate
Kovshar & Gavrilov: Olivaceous Leaf Warbler
The surroundings of the Bolshoye Almatinskoye lake.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (3)
Kovshar & Gavrilov: Olivaceous Leaf Warbler
Plate II
Figs. 2 & 3. Nesting places of the Olivaceous Leaf Warbler.
BIOLOGY OF OLIVACEOUS LEAF WARBLER
369
wiwiwiwiwi or ktititititi , all in the same key. Sometimes the song is
preceded by a call resembling the smacking of lips. The birds sing more
frequently perched on stones, but sometimes they sing in bushes and even
in the crowns of fir-trees.
In the beginning the birds sing very rarely, usually single songs with
great pauses between them. In early May sometimes 30-40 calls may be
heard in succession and in the middle of the month it is possible to count
50 calls in 15 minutes, emitted by one bird. The peak of the vocal
activity falls in late May — before the beginning of nidification. On 24
May 1971 at 8.00 a.m. a male sang 102 songs in 15 minutes. During
this period the males sing not only when moving or collecting food, but
also sitting in one place. At the moment of highest excitement (when
the female is by him) the male’s wings often quiver and the tail is raised
upward almost like a wren’s.
During the building of the nest the males sing intermittently, emitting
several songs at a time and accompanying the female who is flying in
search of materials. They also sing briefly but often in the breeding
period, when they come flying to the nest and especially before flying
off for a new portion of insects. After the young begin to fly the singing
of the Olivaceous Leaf Warbler not only does not stop, but even increases.
For example, on 18 July 1971 a male feeding nestlings that had begun
to fly sang 144 times from 8.00 to 9.00 a.m., and 109 times during the
next hour. Throughout the second half of July, when the Olivaceous
Leaf Warblers fed their fledgelings, their singing can be often heard at
any hour of the day, from 5.50 a.m. till 19.40 p,m» In August they
sing more rarely but regularly till the end of the month.
The last song in the Bolshoye Almatinskoye canyon was heard on
the 7th of September, 1972.
The birds nest in separate pairs settling at a considerable distance
from one another, which in the Bolshoye Almatinskoye canyon averages
150 m. Their attitude to other species is indifferent ; one Olivaceous
Leaf Warbler’s nest was found at a distance of only 10 m from the nest
of a Yellowbrowed Warbler.
The pairs form apparently not later than the first half of May, as
till this time only single birds are seen, in most cases singing males. The
earliest sighting of a pair was on 16 May, 1965. However, the singing
males obstinately prefer some places, the future nesting territories, even
before pair formation. The birds while nesting show a preference for
well warmed southern and eastern slopes. In the Bolshoye Almatinskoye
canyon 13 nests (86*6%) out of 15 were on the eastern, south-eastern
and southern slopes and only 2 (13*4%) on the northern ones. In the
Terskei Alatau ridge 8 cases of nesting on the slopes facing the southern
compass points have been observed and not a single one on the northern
(Kovshar 1966).
370, JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
After the middle of May the Olivaceous Leaf Warblers begin to build
their nests which they arrange in the bushes or on grass stems not very
high above the ground. In most cases nests are built on the low bushes
of creeping juniper. Eleven nests from 23 found in the Bolshoye
Almatinskoye canyon were built on juniper, the rest were found as
follows : 6 on low stunted leaf-bearing shrubs with not dense foliage
(honeysuckle 3, sweetbriar 2, rowan tree 1) and 5 on grass stems, mostly
cereals growing near stones or under the crowns of bushes. The height
of the nests above the ground may be 5-50, usually only 5-15 cm (50%
of the nests), and one nest was situated so that it almost touched the
earth. Only once the birds made an attempt to build their nest on the
lower branches of a 25 m fir-tree at a height of 2 m from the ground but
they abandoned it half-made.
In the Terskei Alatau ridge a nest was found in a bush of creeping
juniper (Stepanian 1959), and in the Talasskiy Alatau, besides creeping
juniper, meadowsweet, wormwood (2 nests) and astragalus, two nests
were constructed on the lower branches of 15 m-old juniper trees ( Juni -
perus zeravshanica ) at a distance of 40 cm from the ground.
The nest is a closed elliptical construction with the entrance on one
side. It is woven from dry grass stems and narrow strips of bast and the
inside covered with down and feathers. When the nest is made so warm
it may seem that the orientation of the entrance does not play an im-
portant role, but according to data collected in the Zailiyskiy Alatau
ridge the Olivaceous Leaf Warblers prefer the southern and eastern
cardinal points. Thus, out of 19 nests the entrances of 6 were directed
to the east, 4 to the south, 2 each to the south-east, south-west, west and
north-east, and one to the north-west. The sizes of 7 nests from the
Zailiyskiy Alatau were : length (along the axial line passing through
the entrance) 90-170 (aver. 139) mm, width 115-190 (aver. 118) mm,
height 85-150 (aver. 126) mm, the diameter of the chute 50-70 mm, its
depth 20-45 mm. The height of the chamber of one nest was 73 mm.
The entrance has the form of a horizontal oval, its width equals 40-46
(aver. 43) mm, its height 28-40 (aver. 34) mm. About the same sizes
are reported for nests from central and western Tian-Shan (Stepanian
1959 ; Kovshar 1966).
The nest is built by the female,1 and the male in the meanwhile re-
mains nearby, sings, sometimes accompanies the female and in one case
obviously tried to take away from her the building material which she
was carrying to the nest. The female carries bast from bushes growing
at a distance of 20 to 60 m, flying repeatedly to the same selected shrub
(mostly honeysuckle). Jumping from one branch to another, she pulls
off with force natrow strips of bast, fluttering with her wings, setting
1 Indications that the male participates in the nest-building (Abdusaliamov 1964)
are not confirmed by our observations, made over many years.
BIOLOGY OF OLIVACEOUS LEAF WARBLER
371
her feet against the branch and sometimes even trying to take flight
without having completely torn off the strip. After having gathered in
her beak some ten strips, she flies swiftly and without stopping towards
the nest, but does not enter it at once ; instead she sits on some branch
not far distant and looks around, emitting a low ‘ smacking ’ sound.
Depositing the material in the nest takes only half a minute. A little
more time is spent in the gathering of bast and grass, but sometimes the
female returns to the nest with the material in one or two minutes. To
one of the nests the female during an hour, from 11.25 hrs. to 12.25 hrs.,
brought bast of honeysuckle 9 times; to another in the period of one
hour and a half (from 10.30 till 12 noon) 17 times. The bird brings
down and feathers much more seldom, as it has to fly 200-300 min search
of them. Thus, during 7 hours of observation (from 6 to 13 hours),
the female arrived at the nest only thrice, at 9, 12 and 13 hours. Building
is carried on chiefly in the first half of the day, especially in the forenoon
(in 7 nests it was observed between 10.00 and 12.00 and only in one at
7.30), rarely in the evening : females with material in their bills were seen
only 3 times, at 16.00, 19.00 and 20.00.
The building of the nest takes 4-10 days and sometimes more. As a
rule if the construction was begun earlier it takes more time than with
the late ones. Thus, one nest was one-third built on 22 May and
finished only on 31 May ; another one on 22 May had already an ellip-
tical form, but was finished only on 29 May. Yet a nest begun on 29
May was finished by 5 June, and another begun on 19 June finished
on 23 June.
The female begins laying eggs 2-6 days after finishing the nest, on
the average (8 birds counted) 4J days after. The shortest interval is
when the nest has been built very late. Eggs are laid every day in the
morning. In a full clutch there can be 4-6, as a rule 5 eggs. In the
Zailiyskiy Alatau ridge in four nests were 4 eggs, in thirteen 5 and in one
6 eggs. In two nests only 2 and 3 eggs were found, but these layings were
seemingly not completed. In the Terskei Alatau a nest was found with
5 nestlings (Stepanian 1959) and in the Talasskiy Alatau in three nests
there were 5 and in one 6 eggs (Kovshar 1966). The incubation begins
after laying the last egg and lasts 14-17 days ; in the 5 cases known to
us the young were hatched 14, 15, 15, 15 and 17 days after the laying of
the last egg.
The young hatch in a period of 24 hours and in size have almost no
difference at all. The sparse greyish down grows in bundles over the
supraocular, occipital and humeral parts of the body. The skin is yellow.
The ends of the mouth are whitish, its inner surface is yellow and the
tongue without spots. The eyes and the acoustic duct are closed.
The young are fed by both parents. The first days the female warms
them for most of the time and the food is carried by the male, but when
372 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
they are already a week old the young receive food more or less equally
from both parents. Thus, in one nest with 5 two-day-old nestlings, the
male brought food 64 times during the day (from 5.05 till 20.10). The
female who sat warming the young left the nest 19 times during the day
each time being absent for 2-11, mostly for 5-8, minutes (only once, at
noon, she was absent for 25 minutes), but she only brought food 7 times
and the remaining 12 flights she apparently used in order to feed herself.
Six days later the parents brought to this nest 120 portions of food,
of which 58 were brought by the male and 62 by the female, the latter
leaving the nest each time after the feeding. In another nest four 8-day-
old young were brought 174 portions of food ; it was carried by both
parents, but the female sat 4 times on the nest for 15, 8, 12 and 6
minutes, mainly during rain. Five days later the warblers brought to
these young 175 portions of food (86 by the male and 89 by the female).
It seems that the intensity of feeding noticeably increases only during the
first week of life of the young and in the following 7 days it remains
constant.
Each portion of food consists, as a rule, of several insects, sometimes
of a big caterpillar or butterfly. Accordingly it is distributed between
the young or given to one of them. In one of the nests the male more
often fed one of the young, rarely two of them, but the female usually
divided the food between two or three of them, the bulk of the portion
of food being given to one of the nestlings. The flights for food usually
are not far, a distance of 70-80 m, but sometimes the warblers may
fly away for 100-150 m.-Insects are usually gathered and caught on the
surface of stones and in the cracks between them, often in the grass and
branches of low leaf-bearing shrubs. They collect food much more
rarely in the crowns of spruce-trees, picking the insects and their larvae
among the needles ; in one case we observed the male who, fluttering his
wings and hanging in the air for several seconds in front of a fir branch,
swiftly and deftly picked something from among the needles ; this method
was used by him several times. The ability of the Olivaceous Leaf
Warblers to move with certainty on vertical planes allows them to seek
for food even in an unusual environment. We had the opportunity of
observing how a warbler during half an hour fed on wooden electro-
transmission poles, searching one pole after another for food. Sitting
at the foot of the pole, the bird quickly examined the cracks in the wood
and the fissures between the wood and the iron rail container, then it
began to move up the pole, taking from the cracks the insects
hidden there, mainly flies. During the ascent she turned freely in all
directions, even head down, but moved only upwards.
The young are fed chiefly insects, rarely spiders. In 21 samples of
food, taken in two nests with the help of ligatures round the neck
(Malchevsky & Kadochnikov 1953), there were 10 butterflies, 7 cater-
BIOLOGY OF OLIVACEOUS LEAF WARBLER
373
pillars, 6 flies, 2 collembola, 1 grasshopper and 5 spiders. Visual obser-
vation near the nests gave 102 (37%) cases of butterflies and 132 (48%)
of caterpillars. The remaining 15% consisted of flies (23 cases), mos-
quitoes (7), bot-flies (1), collembola, grasshoppers (2) and spiders (7).
There is practically no difference between the food carried by the male
and the female. Both parents equally share the task of keeping the nest
clean and take away the faecal capsules with regularity.
The young grow rather quickly and when 1 1 days’ old are already so
active that they can easily leave the nest if frightened. Sometimes this
may happen without any obvious cause. Thus, in one nest on the twelfth
day two young scrambled out of the nest and hid beneath it. When we
put them on their former place they remained there, but two days later
without obvious reasons they again one after another (at 9.41
and 10.19) left the nest and sat on a stone within 2 m of it. Only after
6 hours of hunger (their parents fed only those sitting in the nest) both
young one after another independently returned to the nest. Normally
the flights of the young take place in the morning (in one nest at 9.00,
in another at 10.00), 15-17 days after they hatched. In three instances
the young left the nest after 15 days, in one after 16 and in one
after 17.1
The young that have left the nest hide not far from it in the shadow of
bushes or overhanging stones and keep very still— at feeding time they can
be located by the song of the male or the low call of the female. After
a week the young fly rather well but keep close to the nest ; we met two of
them on the 7th day at a distance of only 3 and 10 m. They apparently
return to the surroundings of the nest periodically. Thus, on the above-
cited day, the male took two young away with him to 50-70 m.
In both cases he behaved identically : having flown without food to the
bush under which the young was hidden he began to sing and when the
latter climbed into the bush asking for food, he suddenly flew away for
10 m, then again and again, thus leading the young bird in the desired
direction. Next morning, the young were again hidden near the nest.
This bird kept in the neighbourhood of the nest for 15 days, from the
12th till the 27th of July, and all this time the male went on singing and
feeding the young that could already fly.
The calendar period of breeding of the Olivaceous Leaf Warbler i&
everywhere rather compressed, as can be seen in the Table.
In the Zailiyskiy Alatau ridge at the altitude of 2370-2700 m the
Olivaceous Leaf Warblers begin to lay eggs chiefly during the first 20 days
of June. The earliest layings here were begun on 4 June, 1964, and on
4 June, 1971, the latest on 28 June, 1969. It should be noted that late
layings were observed only in the years 1960 and 1969, characterized by
1 In this nest the hatching also took 17 days, i.e. more than in the other cases.
374 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
their cold and delayed spring. For the Alpine zone of this ridge there is
only one observation as yet : on 29 July, 1965, at the altitude of 3009 m
a brood of flying young was met ; which means that this pair began
laying eggs in early June, i.e. at the same period they did it at
2370-2700 m.
Table
Dates of the beginning of egg-laying by the Olivaceous
Leaf Warbler in the Tian-Shan Mountains
* Data established by observation of broods with incipient flight. The months
are divided into 10-day periods, 1 = Ist-lOth, etc.
In the Western Tian-Shan (Talas skiy Alatau ridge, 2000 m ;
Karzhantau ridge, 2500 m) the dates of nesting of the Olivaceous Leaf
Warblers are somewhat earlier; some pairs begin laying eggs in the middle
of May. At this same date they begin laying in the foothills of
the Terskei Alatau ridge (Stepanian 1959).
On the whole in the Tian-Shan mountains the Olivaceous Leaf Warb-
lers nest from the middle of May till the middle or second half of June. In
May they build their nests, till the 20th of June the bulk of the popu-
lation lay eggs, in the second half of July the nestlings leave their nests
and at least for two weeks continue to be nursed by their parents. Thus,
the nesting period lasts about two months. It is natural that because of
so delayed a cycle and rather late nesting these birds can raise nestlings
in the Tian-Shan only once in summer.
About the same date this warbler nests somewhat to the south, in the
Pamiro-Alai Mountains, where in three observed nests the laying of eggs
Figs. 4 & 5. Nest on a juniper tree, and Olivaceous Leaf Warbler at the entrance
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (3)
Kovshar & Gavrilov: Olivaceous Leaf Warbler
Plate III
to a nest.
BIOLOGY OF OLIVACEOUS LEAF WARBLER
375
began in the last days of May and first days of June (Ivanov 1969).
Therefore the supposition of the above author that the Olivaceous
Leaf Warbler has two layings during the Summer is doubtful.
There are data on the breeding success only for the Zailiyskiy Alatau.
Here 76 eggs were laid in 16 nests and 49 (64*4%) nestlings left them.
Unfertilized eggs amounted to 7T % (in three nests only one, and in one
nest two eggs). Five (31 %) nests from 16 were destroyed : three by pre-
dators (one with eggs and two with nestlings), one nest with a full laying
was abandoned by the birds after a thorny plant had grown through it,
and in one nest the single young was dead. This last nest was the latest
in date (the laying began on 28 June, 1969), only two eggs were laid, one
of which proved infertile and the hatched nestling perished the same
day. It apparently was a second laying and its fate may serve as a testi-
mony of the poor adaptation of this species to the restoration of
lost layings in a late period.
On the whole the success of reproduction of the Olivaceous Leaf
Warblers in the Zailiyskiy Alatau ridge is the same as among most pas-
serines inhabiting the upper border of the forest zone of this range
(Gavrilov & Rodionov 1965 ; Kovshar 1972b).
References
Abdusaliamov, I. A. (1964) : Ptitzy
gornogo Zeravshana.
Gavrilov, E. I. & Rodionov, E. F.
(1965) : O gibeli ptich’ih gnezd. In the
book Novosti ornitologii.
Ivanov, A. I. (1969) : Ptitzy Pamiro-
Alaya.
Korelov, M. N. (1956a) : Fauna
pozvonochnyh zhivotnyh Bostandyka.
In the book Priroda i hozyaystvennyie
usloviya gornoi chasti Bostandyka.
(1956b) : Materialy k avi-
faune hrebta Ketmen (Tian-Shan).
Izv. AN Kaz.SSR, VII.
Kovshar, A. F. (1966) : Ptitzy Talas-
skogo Alatau. Tr. zapovednikov Kaza-
khstan, 1. 1.
(1972a) : Rod buraya peno-
chka. In the book Ptitzy Kazakhstana,
t. IV.
(1972b) : Ob effektivnosti
razmnozheniya gornyh vorob’inyh. Eko-
logiya, 3.
Malchevsky, A. S. & Kadochnikov,
N. P. (1953) : Metodika prizhisnennogo
izntsheniya pitaniya gnezdovich pterzov
nasekomogadnich plitz. Zool. Zhurnal ,
No. 2.
Shnitnikov, V. N. (1949) : Ptitzy
SemirecKya.
Shukurov, E. D. (1968) : Ekologo-
geograficheskiy analiz avifauny yelovyh
lesov Tian-Shanya. Diss. na soiskaniye
uchenoi stepeni kandidata biologicheskih
nauk.
Stepanian, L. S. (1959) : K biologii
indiiskoi penochki. Zool. zhurnal, 7.
Yanushevich, A. I., Tyurin, P. S.,
Yakovleva, I. D., Kydyraliyev, A. &
Somenova, N. N. (1960) : Ptitzy Kirgizii,
t. II.
Zarudniy, N. A. & Koreev, B. P.
(1906) : Ornitologicheskaya fauna
Semirechenskogo kraya. Mat. k posn.
fauny i flory Ross, imperii, VII.
The food of Collocalia swiftlets
(Aves, Apodidae) at Niah
Great Cave in Borneo1
Tom Harrisson
Cornell and Sussex Universities
{With a plate)
I Borneo cave swiftlets in the Regional context.
II Aerial flight and feeding observations
i Super-canopy : lateral scatter
ii Vertical trends
iii * Swarming ’
iv Movements through the cave formation.
Ill Laboratory analyses
i Stomach contents
ii The food spectrum
iii Ants in particular
iv The total meal
v Swallowing and fragmentation
vi Size factors.
IV How much do C. salangana and maxima differ in food habits ?
Appendix : Swarming insects
References
I. Borneo cave swiftlets in the regional context
The Great Cave at Niah (113°48'E, 3°47'N) lies 13 miles behind the
South China Sea near Miri in northern Sarawak, a state in Malaysian
Borneo. It soars to 220 feet high, 800 feet wide at the largest (west)
1 Received November 1972.
FOOD OF COLLOCALIA SWIFTLETS
377
of five main mouths, the bottom of which is still above the forest
canopy below. The 27-acre floor has yielded some of the oldest pre-
historic human remains yet for the area (Harrisson 1964a; Ripley 1967 :
168-72 ; Howells 1972 : 13). The geologically not very old Niah (Subis)
limestone (Wilford 1964) is honeycombed with chimneys, tunnels, grottos.
In this vast labyrinth, a sort of huge gruyere cheese, throughout the equa-
torial year move and roost some 4,500,000 swiftlets (Apodidae) of three
species, though the third and very much less numerous Collocalia
esculenta only frequents the light sections. Intimately intertwined with
the birds are at least half a million bats of seven resident species, six
insectivorous (Medway 1958b ; Harrisson 1967). This teeming mass
feeds through and/or over the permanently green rainforest which inland
runs almost unbroken into the sparsely inhabited interior (Harrisson
1959a; Richards 1936).
At dawn (soon after 0600 hours Malaysian Local Time = 2330 GMT)
the great part of this bird population pours out, to remain away twelve
or more hours on the wing, while dense streams of bats come back the
other Way. Before dusk (sunset c. 1830 LT) the process is reversed. This
terrific traffic would be unmanageable were it not that all but one of the
bats and both the dark-roosting birds give out constant echo-location
signals. Collocalia is one of only two bird genera — the other Steatornis
of central American caves — with this specialization (Griffin 1958 ;
Medway 1959 ; Harrisson 1964b). Although this system possibly is not
sufficiently refined to enable insect-catching in the dark, it can be valuable
in extending dusk for late insect swarms and on moonlight nights (cf.
Medway 1962 ; T.H.).
The writer began the Sarawak Museum’s investigations at Niah in
1954 and has since spent eleven ‘seasons’ totalling three years, largely
living inside the caves (Harrisson 1957 ; 1959b ; 1970). In 1957 we
recruited Loid Medway to develop the faunistic side of the project, with
rewarding results now well-known (Medway 1958a, etc ; Harrisson &
Medway 1962, etc.). The present study is firmly based on that earlier
shared experience, plus the felt need to supplement one somewhat neg-
lected aspect of the previous major swiftlet study (Medway 1962, cf.
1968) : the food problem. Indeed, mainly because of the difficulty of
identifying tiny insect fragments from out of these delicate little birds
and the impossibility of detecting what they take closely on the wing,
swiftlet food has everywhere tended to be taken for granted. Even in
the second edition of his great the birds of Borneo, B. E. Smythies
(1968 : 292-7) conspicuously omits the food section for Collocalia
species.
Hitherto most of the meagre information for the Oriental Region (as
defined by Salim Ali 1964) has come from the Indian sub-region. This is
378 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
summarized in Salim Ali & Dillon Ripley’s handbook (1970, 4 : 27-32),
which files a nil report for food of C. maxima , there well-named the Black-
nest Swiftlet (in Malaysia previously, unsuitably, Low’s Swiftlet ; cf.
Medway 1966 ; Smythies 1968). Salim Ali & Ripley suggest it is ‘doubt-
less’ as their No. 683, the closely similar C. brevirostris , the Himalayan
Swiftlet, said to take 4 mainly dipterous and hymenopterous insects ’.
More exact information is given for the closely related Indian Edible-
nest Swiftlet, C. unicolor. Four stomachs, studied in February, held two
forms of mango-hopper (also at Niah, III, ii, below), other Hemiptera-
Homoptera, Coleoptera, Odonata, Hymen optera, Diptera and Trichop-
tera ; no emphasis on ants, no mention of termites (Isoptera).
At Niah we have the interesting situation where two monocolour
species co-exist: C. maxima lowi , with the 4 Black-nest’ (edible when
cleaned), and C. salangana natunae , the Mossy or Thunberg’s Swiftlet
(cf. Medway 1961), the former more numerous but both mixed up, nesting
inside one cave. They are almost indistinguishable in flight, sometimes
difficult even in hand. The only fairly sure differences are over 129 mm
wing and more feathered tarsus for maxima ; wing 119-129 mm, and little
or no tarsus feathering on salangana. Each species normally nests once
a year on numerous but separate patches of wall ; maxima lays one egg,
salangana two. Both have protracted breeding cycles, minimum 5
months and up to 7 for maxima , peaking broadly between November
and March.
From 1947 I was responsible for controlling and conserving swiftlets
in this and other caves, including 4 harvesting ’ edible maxima nests.
Despite extensive exploitation, the Niah population has not decreased—
as will be seen in what follows, it may well be near saturation (cf. Medway
1957 ; Gibb & Harrisson 1959 ; Harrisson 1964b).
II. Aerial flight and feeding observations
(i) Super-canopy : lateral scatter
First, where do Niah’s millions feed ? Although all Borneo observers
have agreed that the dark-nesting swiftlets only casually feed over
clearings and inhabited areas, never under tree-cover, little more was
known. This observer spent nearly 350 hours during 1962-72, mainly
in helicopters, establishing an absolute dominance of swifts (5 species)
and especially swiftlets (3) as regular super-canopy operators. No
other birds except a few Hemiprocnidae were normally feeding at this
level, though some eagles hunt downward into the forest. Nineteen others
were seen in local or migratory flight, only hombills regularly.
FOOD OF COLLOCALIA SWIFT LETS
370
Table 1
Birds seen above the Borneo forest canopy
(compiled from Harrisson 1963 ; 1966 ; and 1972 unpublished)
* C. salangana and maxima plus C. vestita in the Baram basin — not at Niah
(Smythies 1968).
f H. longipennis, which mainly feeds oyer secondary jungle and clearings.
Lateral spread of super-canopy swiftlets proved erratic. Probable
Niah birds were seen far inland, but there is no way of being certain of
source at any distance. Sustained helicopter sorties to clarify this aspect
in the vicinity of the caves and over the coastal plain during August-
December were not fully successful. Co-ordinated with ground watch
along the river and one road line (since 1965) on some days, especially
if fine, at any season, the great mass of birds is not visible within 10-25
miles of the limestone massif. On 20-21 December, as an extreme
example, 4 hours’ intensive flying mostly north and West of Niah produced
only one swiftlet ; simultaneous ground records showed the cave nearly
empty of birds at the same times (II, iv, below).
Medway (1962 : 229) had ‘ never seen maxima or salangana more than
15 miles from the cave ’. But there was then no good way to observe
beyond that distance and limited facilities for seeing over the canopy
anywhere. On that basis, his own figure (same sentence) of ‘ at least
four million resident adults ’ would mean a super-canopy all-day density
of 6,000 birds per square mile, even ignoring that the immediate radial
380 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. li (3)
land is heavily deforested or cultivated (rice, pepper) and thus only
suitable for C. esculenta foraging.
Both salangana and maxima have been timed flying at 25-30 m.p.h.
Most are usually away at least 11 hours a day. 50-75 miles inland will
take them over huge tracts of virgin jungle, still incompletely explored
on the ground (Harrisson 1959a ; Richards 1936), widely without other
limestone to support 4 competing ’ cave populations (cf. maps in Wilford
1964 ; list in Smythies 1968 : 71). Otherwise, surely, the vast Niah
insectivorous population — birds and bats — might be insupportable
through the year, including long wet periods which flood the forest floor
in the immediate vicinity ?
(ii) Vertical trends
About 2% of swiftlets were seen 1000 ft or more above the canopy
(Table 1) — birds crowding and spiralling immediately over the cave
gorge to come in the dusk inrush are not feeding (Medway 1962 : 231
agrees). The large majority move between 20 and 800 feet, without
recognizable stratification (Harrisson 1963). There may be a tendency
for maxima to feed higher at times, but no distinct or regular trends could
be found — certainly not to the extent postulated quite theoretically by
Medway (1962 : 243), who put salangana at 4 intermediate ’ levels and
maxima higher.* Except directly over limestone, any swiftlet (and per-
haps any insect ?) above 1500 feet super-canopy is quite a rarity (Harrisson
1966 : 419).
In March 1967, with maxima nesting strongly, a special effort was
made to search higher air levels in case birds had previously been missed.
None were located.
The evidence so far in this difficult aerial field indicates maxima only
erratically flying high but tending to go further afield and stay out longer*
when 4 necessary ’ (see below).
(iii) 4 Swarming ’
Collocalia concentrations of c. 50 to c. 500 were seen associated with
dense swarms of unidentified flying insects, again very erratically.
Swarming ants and termites may be periodically crucial in the food
supply (III below). Unfortunately, almost nothing is known on
controlling factors in the region (see Appendix).
* In the summary of his long paper, Medway (1962 : 245) restates his earlier hypo-
thesis as if it was proven (‘ C. maxima feeds higher than C. salangana ). Interes-
tingly, the larger C. gigas of Java ‘ tends to feed higher ' than other Collocalia, accord-
ing to Becking (1971). But elaborating, this experienced observer makes clear his
observation was largely over open country, and that gigas came low also ‘ in particular
when there are flying termites ’ (Becking 1972). All but one of the few gigas records
for Borneo are low-flying in the open (Smythies 1968). There is no present evidence
that ants or termites swarm tropically high, rather the contrary (Nutting 1969; Deligne
1972).
FOOD OF COLLOCALIA SWIFT LETS 381
(iv) Movements through the cave formation
The broad flow patterns into and inside the limestone have been
very adequately described by Medway (1962). Further study, incor-
porating mist-nets (since 1964), requires only three new emphases
(T.H.) :
(1) More swiftlets, especially maxima , stay out part of the night
than was earlier recognized, especially with clear moonlight.
(2) Both fly at all levels inside, according to internal topography,
though the proportion of salangana tends larger lower down
towards the floor*
(3) Although rain and storms visible from the caves immediately
inhibit Collocalia movements in the vicinity, on a wider view
they can, like other swifts, operate around considerable storm
patterns (cf. Lack 1958). This can be a factor delaying
evening return, too (and cf. Nutting 1969).
III. Laboratory analyses
(i) Stomach contents
Many swiftlets netted on the dusk inrush have the stomach so dis-
tended that it bulges conspicuously through the belly skin. But return-
ing-to-rest birds are equally often almost empty, including at peak nest-
ing (March- April).
Contents of a full salangana stomach weigh near 1| grams, maxima
1J to 2 grams, averaging near 11% body weight. 100 full stomachs
examined on the spot had 27 to 232 individual insects (cf. Table 7) most
of those over 100 in salangana. Numbers depend primarily on propor-
tions of tiny beetles and flies (2-4 mm; rather than larger types of termite
(13 mm) and ants (see Table 11).
We can estimate that the year round Niah Swiftlets eating well could
daily use c. 5000 kilos ; involving not less than 100,000,000 individual
insects each 24 hours ?
Nestling stomachs (65) show the same varying food types as adults
in other seasons (Tables 2-5). A 21 -day maxima was distended with
26 whole ants, 6 large termites and beetles (11+ species) ; at the other
extreme, a 3-day chick had only tiny hard beetle fragments. Fledgelings
under favourable conditions can survive without food for 15+ days,
an important ability under these conditions (see below).
382 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
(ii) The food spectrum
Id addition to on-the-spot stomach examinations (as above), 41 were
preserved for fuller laboratory study. This was undertaken with the
most generous help and expertise of Dr G. H. L. Rothschild (1965-8),
reseaich entomologist in the Department of Agriculture, Sarawak ; and
later extended at Cornell University, N.Y., with the generous and patient
help of Dr W. L. Brown Ji. (1968-71), Professor of Entomology there
and Hon. Curator of the important Harvard University collection of
ants, on specimens which could not be adequately identified earlier in
Borneo. The results incidentally give the first information on what,
other than birds, moves over the Borneo canopy.
The main material was 23 maxima and 18 salangana netted in dusk
samples, November and March (breeding peak) at Niah, with a separate
February check sample from the Kakus caves, 100 miles to the southwest
(10 maxima , 3 salangana). In view of the many lacunae in area ento-
mological knowledge, identifications were aimed at main groupings only.
Over half the food materials were Hymenopteran ; at times this
reached 99 % for maxima (Table 4).
Table 2
The Order Hymenoptera in Collocalia stomachs
Five other insect orders are present, with 34 species ; though in
actual frequency the alate of one large Macrotermitinae species domi-
nates this sector (Table 7, etc.).
* See Appendix.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (3)
Harrisson: Collocalia Swiftlets
Plate
Fig. 1. Field laboratory for cave studies, Niah Great Cave, Sarawak.
(Photo: Barbara Harrisson )
Fig. 2. Part of west mouth of Niah Great Cave, showing mist-netting area near
big central stalactite and two birds-nester’s climbing poles (up to 200 ft high).
(Photo : Christine Harrisson)
383
FOOD OF COLLOCALIA SWIFT LETS
Table 3
Other insects in Collocalia stomachs
Since we do not know anything about invertebrate life super-canopy*
it is not possible to assess how far these two lists, covering 65 species of
5 orders, reflect a cross-section of available flying food. The absence
of a single Orthopteran may be noteworthy, though these are mostly
large (over 15 mm) in Borneo. Light-winged Trichoptera and Odonata
(dragonflies) are also possible absentees. Softness or hardness alone
are not final selective factors, since both swiftlets tackle the hardest-
headed Carpenter Ants (e.g. Colobopsis) as well as tiny mosquitoes ;
these have been identified in nestlings, too.
3
384 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol. li (3)
(iii) Ants in particular
One occasionally finds adult salangana without ants (e.g. one with 21
termites and 51 other insects, Nov.) and maxima often without termites
and with only a few ants (min. 5). But ants remain constantly the com-
monest feed, though sometimes flooded out by larger, fatter termites.
Or Rothschild calculated the gross stomach contents for the two Niah
samples:
Table 4
Percentage of foods in Collocalia stomachs (& cf. Table 6)
Food Novmber March ‘ Average ’
Termites are of three unidentified ‘ types ’ (i.e. at least 3 species ?), all
Macrotermitinae. Type 1, fattest and largest (13 mm) comprises two-
thirds of such food ; type 2, fat but small (3*5 mm) forms about one-
third ; type 3, tiny (2 mm), only 1 %. Type 1 frequently occurs alone ;
2 and 3 usually mixed with 1.
By contrast, we have at least 25 species of ants identified to genus or
beyond. In Professor Brown’s view the forms represented are those
from the whole range of ants one might reasonably expect to find in
Borneo. His subsequent examination confirmed Dr Rothschild’s earlier
(1968) view that ‘ the two echo-locating swiftlets of Niah consume the
whole taxonomic spectrum of flying ants, without any entomologically
discernible specialization or exclusion ’.
From 19 stomachs the sex for 40 ants of 12 genera was determined.
A heavy female preponderance, 35 : 5, is consistent with their generally
much fatter swarming condition (see Appendix). Significantly, in no
case were both sexes of the same genus found*
Sexed ants Were : 5 males— Par at rechina (2), Rhopalomastix (2),
Amblypone (1) ; 35 females— Camponotus (11), Crematogaster (5),
Cladomyrma (5), Pseudolasius (4), Petramorium (3), Hyponera (3),
Brachyponera, Trachymesopus , Pheidologeton , and ‘ a small myrmicine ’.
* Every identified ant of all three subfamilies was found at least once, usually
several times, in both salangana and maxima .
385
FOOD OF COLLOCALIA SWIFTLETS
Other, unsexed, genera include Colobopsis, Polyrachis and Solenopsis
(all common), probably Emeryopone and several unnamed myrmicine
genera.
The following were identified down to species :
Trachymesopus darwini — the very common ‘ flying ant ’ at lights in
settlements in Borneo ; not common in cave food.
Tetramorium guineense — a world-wide 4 tramp ’, originating in
Africa ; mainly terrestrial ; twice in food.
Camponotus of cottesi and impressus groups — big-headed Carpenter
Ants ; very common in this food, including over a third of all the
March maxima samples (sparsely in salangana then).
Brachyponera jerdoni — occasionally, singly, in food.
38 stomachs provided satisfactory material to check the number of ant
genera present, a point relevant to the number of swarms foraged in any
one food-sequence.
Table 5
Nos. OF ANT GENERA IN 38 Collocalia STOMACHS
Out of the quarter taking simply one ant-form 4, all maxima , had
nothing else to eat. The rest had supplementary termites or other insects.
Moreover, no one adult had more than 16 of any one ant-form. Notable
in comparison was a well-grown maxima nestling (19 November) with
ants of at least 9 species, along with 5 large termites, a whole borer-
beetle and 2 fragmented flies.
(iv) The total meal
To see the food pattern more closely (cf. Table 4) let us next glance at
a single sample of 13 adults caught in one mist-net within dusk-rush
minutes, 29 March. Both species then had young in nest ; and maxima
nest-harvesting was over. (A minority, this day estimated under 5%,
had come in before inrush.)
386 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
Table 6
13 Collocalia stomachs in single inrush net (29 March)
On this flash-sample, there is a clear-cut distinction : salangana on
termites, smaller ants and other insects ; maxima on larger ants. But
individual variation is high. Indeed 1 $ salangana had zero termites
and accounts for 127 of the ‘ other insects ’, while and $ maxima
had only smaller ants. Species and sex differences are immediately
diluted by comparison with another sample. For instance, if we switch
a month earlier and 100 miles to the Kakus caves, further inland, with
smaller numbers of both species living together in the same way, the
apparent salangana dependence on termites vanishes. Neither swiftlet
has taken one. Or going back to November at Niah, some of both
maxima and salangana were then distended on termites, others had
none, though as in March the smaller bird had considerably more termites,
especially the largest (Type 1).
Table 7
AVERAGE of 3 insect groups per stomach, 3 PERIODS
Average no. of individuals per
FOOD OF COLLOCALIA SWIFTLETS
387
On each occasion salangana had more than twice as many items per
bird as maxima (cf. Ill, vi). The total termitelessness of March maxima
(Table 7) was repeated for both in February, but neither in November.
The process can be clarified another way :
Table 8
Nos. of Collocalia stomachs without a single example
FOR 3 GROUPS (3 PERIODS COMBINED)
This Well brings out the relative frequency of termitelessness, and the
correlated but lesser neglect of any insect other than ants. One of the
two termite-eating maxima above had only termites, 36, entire. Several
maxima nestlings and adults earlier examined at the caves had whole large
termites too.
(v) Swallowing and fragmentation
Swiftlets swallow whole insects of all sorts. There are, however,
notably often fewer termite wings than bodies in stomachs (see vi).
Some smaller items, especially Diptera, rather surprisingly remain intact —
even with wings after transfer from adult food ‘ pellet * to nestling
stomach. For others, especially beetles, both whole ones and separate
hard elytra occur, as with two March salangana.
Table 9
Beetle (only) remains in two salangana stomachs
This suggests long survival of some hard parts which may well serve
a secondary function, remaining in a slower digestive cycle than is pre-
sently understood and perhaps peculiar to Collocalia — which already has
nest salivation and echo-location as precedent specialisms for success in
this remarkable cave-niche.
388 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
(vi) Size factors
From complete or re-assembled specimens we were able to calculate
the original body size of nearly all the food insects. This further labour
seemed essential in view of the above somewhat negative conclusions on
species-differentiation by other criteria, as well as to test a second sug-
gestion (cf. II, ii) by Medway to explain the Niah Collocalia situation.
Following general western theory (cf. Lack 1947) he concluded (1962 :
240) that as ‘ the two species must have different ecology ’ so, where
feeding overlaps aerially, they each ‘ select different elements from the
airborne prey ’ according to bill size. This was re-examined at Niah
in 1965. Consistent with longer wing and higher body weight, maxima
gape there averages c. 1 mm more than salangana. Does this directly
affect size intake ?
In the case of the ‘ other ’ insect group, the problem hardly arises,
since over 95% of these are c. 5 mm or less.
Table 10
Approximate body length of various ‘ other * insects taken
REGULARLY BY Collocalia
At this size level, clearly no size differentiation by bird species can be
delected ; indeed the slightly larger wasps and bugs are, on these data,
less likely to be taken by the larger bird (cf. Tables 2 and 3). It is fairly
safe to suspect both swiftlets may take pretty well anything of this size
they come across, and that the absence here of a few small items for
maxima — only one of which occurs at all regularly with salangana (Table
2) — is partly chance on small series, though partly, also, a reflection of a
less positively ‘ omnivorous ’ approach and relatively less consumption
of beetles and flies perhaps.
The earlier noted absence of certain other possible super-canopy
forms, such as tiny dragonflies, need not be truly selective, but for the
FOOD OF COLLOCALIA SWIFTLETS
389
less obvious reason that with such insects in flight stiffness or angle of
wing, rather than actual span, may restrict the capacity to swallow.
Although larger winged termites and some large flying ants are taken at
more than twice the sizes of Table 10, the wings of many of these fall off
or fold inward on touch (Nutting 1969 : 258 ; T.H.)- It is extremely
difficult to differentiate all such wings in stomach analysis. Certainly,
of 255 measured termites taken, 67 % were over 12 mm long ; present in
both swiftlets but mainly salangana (Tables 6-8).#
The 25 ant species present a more complex problem. These range
from 2*5 to 12*5 mm, mostly 5-10 mm. Only a few, mostly Carpenter
Ants, run as large as Termite Type 1 (over 12 mm). Thus the 4 middle-
sized ’, 6-12 mm, niche in this material is exclusively filled by ants, and
only these fall within that category below :
Table 1 1 (cf . Table 7)
Size range of 1530 measurable insects from Collocalia food
Month Species No. of Percentage of this length-range
insects -5-5 mm 6-12 mm 12+ mm
(small ants, (larger (largest
termites, & ants) ants &
all * others ’) larger
termites)
Thus, although smaller salangana regularly has twice as many insects as
larger maxima (Table 7) and dominates the larger termite sector in pro-
portion to the latter bird’s smaller gross intake, twice in three times
maxima has well over half its food in the middle range ; and when
salangana dominates here (with the same ant species), maxima has stepped
up the food size. Therefore— as usual — there is no exclusivity for either
*A thoughtful new study of swifts feeding in Puerto Rico shows a big
March-August insect peak, with over 90% of available insects less than 5 mm long,
only T2% exceeding 10 mm, and severe food supply limitations on two swift popu-
lations (Kepler 1972).
390 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
species by size. But there is a significant tendency for maxima to eat
fewer and larger items, especially in the middle size range.
We have recalculated these and other figures in other ways, without
any fresh insights resulting. In the end it has to be concluded that size
alone is not a direct and dominating selective factor except in so far as
both species are equally restricted by the nature of their shared feeding
processes. Size can, within these limits, be varied according to the
overriding consideration of food availability — and chance encounter.
IV. How much do C. salangana and maxima differ in
FOOD HABITS ?
1. This limited study has been surprisingly unsuccessful in defining
any distinct or consistent differentiation or specialization of feeding
habits or food for two sympatric Collocalia breeding numerously together
in Sarawak caves and feeding together in the super-canopy.
2. There is an indistinct tendency for larger maxima to fly further,
stay out longer and go longer on less ; and even more erratically to fly
a little higher, though apparently both swiftlets intermix completely at
(crucial) ant/ termite swarms (cf. 7 below).
3. C. maxima , however, seems to ‘prefer’ more large fat female
ants, salangana more large termites, small ants and other small insects
(Tables 10-11). But there is much bird-to-bird and day-to-day variation
and overlap, especially when swarms are scarce. At times either bird
‘ might take anything manageable that’s flying ’ (Dr Rothschild agreeing
with writer).
4. Of 22 families and subfamilies of insect identified in salangana
stomachs, 8 were not recorded in maxima (Tables 2-3) ; but only 1 of
these was other than occasional (rare) in the former. Rothschild cal-
culated food common to both birds on three main samples :
Table 12
Taking all three lots and refining further from Dr Brown’s later ant-
analysis, 94% by insect item and about 98 % by bulk was of forms found
in both birds at least once. All the common foods (ants, termites and
(Wo beetle families) were at some stage shared.
FOOD OF COLLOCALIA SWIFT LETS
391
5. Looked at another way and momentarily forgetting western ideas
applied to the Indian sub-regional equatorial setting, it might even seem
stranger that two so-close bird species ate differently in identical context
than that both ate everything available (and exclusive to them) they
could equitably swallow, especially since there is significant supporting
evidence that insect food of all kinds may be in highly erratic supply
seasonally (Ward 1969 for Singapore ; Fogden 1972 for Sarawak ; cf.
Kepler 1972 for Puerto Rican Swifts).
6. Differences might be sought elsewhere. Collection and utiliza-
tion of nest materials, with associated tactile habits, are suggested as one
sector, and will be the subject of a following paper.
7. A residual (difficult) question remains : why does maxima often
seem to be taking less food, both by numbers and to a lesser extent
Weight ? The verb 6 seem’ is used purposefully. It is possible that this
result is methodological. In retrospect, netting more birds coming in
full darkness might have been illuminating, though it cannot have changed
the overall picture as regards food spectrum. But if, as is quite likely
(cf. Appendix), some ants and termites (especially) swarm best after sun-
set and into full dark, the writer may have too readily followed Medway
in accepting that echo-location would not be used for nocturnal swarm-
feeding. Alternatively, it could be that maxima , with its special nest-
salivation and single-egg rhythm may use relatively less energy consump-
tion than salangana, which also has a shorter wing ratio ? The question
remains open.
APPENDIX : Swarming Insects (cf. II, iii and Tables 5, 8)
The periodicity and distribution of flying ant and termite swarms are evidently
crucial for Niah Collocalia. The matter has lately been touched upon in another
and extensive Sarawak Museum study by Dr Michael Fogden (1972 : 315), apropos
general forest bird food, although he only considers termites. As with the wider
flying insect problems we are once more faced with very meagre entomological or
ecological information. It is agreed that for ants the males swarm first, fly less errati-
cally and are much thinner (by then) than the females which next fly up slowly , in prime
condition (cf. 7 : 1 sex ratio in III, iii), to copulate. With termites, the swarming is
constantly bisexual and copulation occurs after falling ; there is no big female prepon-
derance, but both sexes are almost equally fat.
Both Professor Brown (1969-71) at Cornell and Professor l’Abbe G. Van Boven
(1972) at Louvain University, Belgium (specializing in tropical Africa) consider that
in Borneo’s equatorial and climatic conditions, ants and termites of one species or
another might be swarming on almost any day of the year, subject to weather and other
variables. Dr Jean Deligne, University of Brussels, qualifies this view for termites and
suggests there may be considerable periods of little or no swarming in Borneo. He
has observed this specifically in West Africa (Deligne 1970, 1972), while marked
seasonal periodicities have been reported in arid Arizona and equatorially. Single,
392 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY , Fo/. 71 (3)
short-duration flights only once a year have been demonstrated as normal for at least
one species of Macrotermitinae (of the very few studied) in tropical Congo and India
(Nutting 1969; cf. Wynne-Edwards 1962 for ‘advantages’). In the Philippines
Macrotermus gilvus, common through Southeast Asia, swarms in great numbers at
dusk from May to September (Uichanco 1919). M. insperatus in Java swarms pro-
fusely for a bare 15 minutes at dusk from late October to mid-November (Roonwal
1970).
Bees are also differently involved. Both Niah Collocalia have been recorded with
tiny stingless Meliponidae, probably genus Trigona (Schwarz 1937). These ‘ swarm’
feeding on the suddenly, erratically, seasonal flowering crowns of great fruit-trees along
the Niah river. I have seen all three Great Cave swiftlets taking them thus. But
whereas C. esculenta (and Hemiprocne longipennis ; see Smythies 1968) will take many,
both salangana and maxima usually stay a minute or less, do not forage such bees
systematically. This appears to be definite negative selectivity ?
Suitable super-canopy insect swarms present concentrated rich food prizes for
swiftlets, uniquely. But these surely occur with much spatial and periodic erraticism,
and their absence poses almost equally severe problems of difficulty. Swarms cannot
be relied on !
Moreover, as individual termites and ants fly once in a life-time, it seems unlikely
that even ‘ in season ’ they can be continuously available in the required massive daily
densities. On the other hand, colonies have been censused to several millions, with the
termite alate (flying) proportion up to 43%. An annual al’ate production of 200,000
per acre estimated in Nigeria seems inadequate for Niah-type needs (Nutting 1969 ;
237) ; but density may be far higher in rain forest ? I hope in the near future to ela-
borate on this theme, with some fresh field observations— especially nocturnal.
Tom Harrisson 10/72
References
Ali, Salim (1964) : ‘ Oriental Region ’
in Thomson, 1964 : 556-9. Dictionary
of Birds.
(1969) : Birds of Kerala.
Bombay (O.U.P.).
& Ripley, S. Dillon (1970) :
Handbook of the birds of India and
Pakistan ; 4 ‘ Frogmouths to Pittas ’.
Bombay (O.U.P.).
Becking, J. H. (1971) : ‘ The breeding
of Collocalia gigasJ Ibis 113 : 330-4.
(1972) : Personal communi-
cation (see II, ii, in text).
Boven, G. Van (1972) : Personal com-
munication (see Appendix).
Brown, W. L. (1968-71) : Personal
communications (III, iii, in text).
Deligne, Jean (1970) : Unpublished
thesis on termites. Brussels Free Uni-
versity (Science Faculty). Doctoral
thesis, April, 1970.
(1972) : Personal com-
munication (see Appendix).
Fogden, M. P. L. (1972): ‘Popu-
lation Dynamics of Forest Birds in
Sarawak.’ Ibis 114 : 307-42.
Gibb, Hugh & Harrisson, Tom
(1959) : Birds' Nest Soup. BBC TV
colour film (Grand Prix, Cannes Film
Festival).
Griffin, D. R. (1958) : Listening in
the Dark. New Haven.
Harrisson, Tom (1957) : ‘ The Great
Cave of Niah.’ Man 57 : 161-6,
(1959a) : ‘ Innermost
Borneo : ten years of exploration and
research.’ Geographical Journal 125 :
299-311.
(1959b) : ‘ The Caves of
Niah : a history of pre-history.’ Sara-
wak Mus. J. 8 : 549-95.
— (1963) : ‘ Birds above the
Borneo jungle canopy.’ Ibis 105 :
403-6.
(1964a) : ‘ 50,000 years of
stone-age culture in Borneo.’ Smith-
sonian Institution, Annual Report : 521-
FOOD OF COLLOCALIA SWIFTLETS
393
Harrisson, Tom (1964b) : 4 Echo-
location ’ and ‘ Edible Nests ’ in
Dictionary of Birds, ed. Landsborough
Thomson, 1964 : 230-6.
(1966) : ‘ Further Notes on
super-canopy birds in Borneo.’ Ibis
108 : 419-20.
(1967) : ‘ Bats netted in and
around Niah Great Cave.’ Sarawak
Museum J. 14 : 229-33.
(1970) : ‘ The Prehistory
of Borneo.’ Asian Perspectives 13 :
17-45.
& Medway, Lord (1962) :
‘ A first classification of prehistoric
bone artefacts from Niah Great
Cave.’ Asian Perspectives 6 : 219-29.
Howells, William H. (1972): ‘20
millions d’annees pour faire un homme."
Le Courrier ^UNESCO), 25, Aug.-
Sept. 1972 : 4-13.
Kepler, Cameron B. (1972) : Notes
on the Ecology of Puerto Rican Swifts.
Ibis 114 : 541-3.
Lack, David (1947): Darwin’s Finches.
Cambridge.
— (1958) : * Weather move-
ments of Swifts.’ Bird Study 5 : 128-42.
Marshall, A. J. & Folley, S. J.
(1956) : ‘ The origin of the nest-cement
in edible-nest swiftlets ( Collocalia ).’
Proc. Zool. Soc. 126 : 383-9.
Medway, Lord (1957) : 6 Birds’ Nest
collecting.’ Sarawak Mus. J. 8 : 252-6.
(1958a) : ‘ Food bone in the
Niah Cave excavations.’ Sarawak Mus.
J. 8 : 627-36 (and following papers).
(1958b): ‘300,000 bats.’
Sarawak Mus. J. 8 : 667-79.
(1959) : ‘ Echo-location
among Collocalia. ’ Nature 184 : 1352-3.
(1961) : * The identity of
Collocalia fuciphaga (Thunberg).’ Ibis
103 : 625-6.
('1962) : ‘The swiftlets ( Col-
localia) of Niah Cave, Sarawak.’ Ibis
104 : 45-66 and 228-45.
Medway, Lord (1966) : ‘ Field charac-
ters as a guide to the specific relations of
Swiftlets,’ Proc. Linnean Soc,, London ,
177 : 151-72.
(1968) : ‘ Cave swiftlets ’ in
Birds of Borneo by Smythies, 1968 : 62-70.
Nutting, W. L. (1969) : ‘ Flight and
Colony Foundation’ in Biology of
Termites (ed. Krishna & Weesner), New
York, Vol. I: 233-82.
Richards, P. W. (1936) : ‘ Ecological
Observations on the rain forest of Mount
Dulit, Sarawak.’ Journal Ecology
24 : 1-37.
Ripley, S. Dillon (1967) : The Land
and Wildlife of Tropical Asia. New
York (Life Nature Library).
Roonwal, M. L. (1970) : * Termites
of the Oriental Region ’ in Biology of
Termites (ed. Krishna & Weesner). New
York, Vol. II: 315-91.
Rothschild, G. H. R. (1965-8) :
Personal communications (III, ii, in
text).
Schwarz, Herbert F. (1937) :
‘ Results of the Oxford University
Expedition to Sarawak : Bornean Sting-
less Bees.’ Bull. Am. Mus. NH. 73 :
281-329.
Smythies, B. E. (1968) : The Birds of
Borneo. Edinburgh (2nd edition),
Thomson, A. Landsborough (1964) :
A New Dictionary of Birds. London.
Uichanco, L. B. (1919) : ‘ General
Facts in the biology of Philippine mound-
building termites.’ Philippine Journ.
Sci. 15 : 59-65.
Ward, P. (1969) : ‘ The annual cycle
of the Yellow-vented Bulbul.’ J. Zool.,
London, 157 : 25-45.
Wilford, G. E. (1964) : Geology of
Sarawak and Sabah Caves. Kuching
(Geological Survey, Bulletin 6).
Wynne-Ed wards, V. C. (1962) :
Animal Dispersion in Relation to Social
Behaviour. New York.
Physiological adaptations in the
Rosy Pastor wintering in India1
J. C. George
Department of Zoology, University of Guelph ,
Guelph , Ontario, Canada
Introduction
The physiology of bird migration has been the subject of extensive
investigation for many years in my former laboratory at the Maharaja
Sayajirao University of Baroda (latitudes 20-24 and longitudes 72-76),
Gujarat, India. The Rosy Pastor or the Rosecoloured Starling [Sturnus
roseus (Linnaeus)] has been one of the most intensively studied species
of migrants wintering in the area. With the establishment of a centre
for the study of the physiological basis for animal migrations at the
University of Guelph in Canada, it has become possible to collaborate
With former colleagues at Baroda in continuing some of the studies and
also extending them to species of the northern hemisphere.
In any physiological investigation on a wild species, reliable field
information regarding its distribution and natural history is a prerequi-
site. In my own studies on the Rosy Pastor as well as on other species
of Indian birds, I have had to draw constantly from Sdlim Ali’s
experience. On occasions when he pulled me out into the field with him,
he generously shared with me his incredible enthusiasm and wealth of
knowledge. I consider this opportunity of associating myself in the feli-
citations on the occasion of his 75th birthday a unique privilege, since
another one of his kind may never be.
According to Salim Ali (1955), the Rosy Pastor is one of the earliest
winter visitors to India, abundant in the north-western parts. They
arrive in July- August and leave about the middle of April and return
to their breeding grounds in eastern Europe, western and central Asia,
where they nest in May and June. Their breeding is known to overlap
that of the migratory locust, thus ensuring sufficient supply of food for
themselves and their young.
On arrival in Baroda, they are greeted by the monsoon rains and
plentiful supplies of insects as food. Toward their departure in late
April, the ambient temperature in Baroda may go up as high as 110°F
or more, after an intervening period of the cool tropical winter. Toward
1 Migration Series 035, University of Guelph. Supported by the National
Research Council of Canada. Received October 1972.
PHYSIOLOGICAL ADAPTATIONS IN ROSY PASTOR
395
migration their diet becomes mostly, if not entirely, vegetarian consisting
of banyan and pipal figs and various types of berries. The fruits of
Pithecolobium dulce , locally called goraz amli, seems to be a major food
item during the fattening period prior to migration. The difference in
the day-length between the winter and spring (summer) months is rela-
tively insignificant compared to that in the Temperate Zone. Never-
theless, the changing environmental conditions do impose on the bird
the necessity of adaptational changes in the body.
Nature of adaptations
The adaptational changes in the body of a migratory bird may be
regarded as the result of a dialogue between the environment and the
biological organization within. These changes evidently occur at various
levels of organization, thereby affecting the physiology and behaviour of
the organism as a whole. The physiologist therefore seeks to investigate
the influence of environmental factors such as light, temperature,
humidity etc., structural and metabolic adaptations, the mechanism of
internal regulation which possibly determines the actual timing of migra-
tion and the processes involved in the generation and utilization of
energy for migratory flight. These aspects of the physiology of the
migratory bird embrace practically all basic life processes and the reve-
lation of these principles should lead ultimately to an understanding of
the very nature of life itself.
This review deals mainly with the work done, under the auspices
of the M. S. University of Baroda, on the Rosy Pastor from the time of
its arrival in Baroda to its departure for its breeding grounds
abroad. The exact time of their arrival in Baroda is not known but
small groups are quite common about September. This phase will be
referred to as the postmigratory phase. Towards March, they flock
together into larger groups and by April end, form large migratory
swarms [see photograph by Salim Ali (1955) ; Plate 72 facing p. 127].
This phase will be referred to as the premigratory phase. The adapta-
tional changes occurring in the various tissue and organ systems will be
considered under these two phases.
Internal regulation
The hypothalamus is well recognized as the seat in the brain that
controls numerous autonomic and endocrine functions. It contains
neurosecretory cells some of whose secretions are transported to the
hypophysis through portal circulation while others are stored and
released from the neurohypophysis. The hypothalamus has also been
396 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
shown to be controlling the regulation of food intake. A normal mature
animal maintains its body weight fairly constant, which is indicative of a
regulatory mechanism operating to balance energy intake with output.
It has been demonstrated in several laboratory mammals that two areas
in the hypothalamus are responsible for the regulation of food intake.
The studies of the Indian physiologist B. K. Anand and his associates
(1955) have provided experimental evidence to show that the lateral
hypothalamic area is involved in increased daily food intake and the
medial area in decreased food intake. It is well known that migratory
birds deposit considerable amounts of fat in the body prior to migration.
Rosy Pastors have been found to weigh 50-60 g in October and 80-125 g
in April (Naik 1963) the increase in body weight being, by and large, due
to the deposition of fat. Kuenzel & Helms (1967) have produced obesity
in the migratory Whitethroated Sparrow by experimentally creating
lesions in the ventro-medial area of the hypothalamus. In the light of
these observations, the hypothalamus may be considered as not only the
link between the brain and the endocrine complex but also as the site
Where the initial triggers, that control the sequence of events in effecting
migratory activity, reside. George & Naik (1965) have described the
hypothalamo-hypophysial neurosecretory system of the Rosy Pastor.
The hypothalamic neurosecretory centres consist of the supraoptic and
paraventricular nuclei, and the anterior and posterior divisions of the
infundibular nucleus as revealed by staining with paraldehyde fuchsin
as well as Gomori’s chrome alum haematoxylin phloxin for neuro-
secretory material. The granular neurosecretory material presenting a
beaded appearance was traced from the cell body along the axon to the
regions of distribution and storage depots. The intensity of staining in
the cells was considered an index of their secretory activity and that in the
storage areas, the extent of accumulation of the neurosecretory material.
On studying the intensity of staining of the neurosecretory material in
birds collected during the postmigratory and premigratory phases, they
observed certain definite cyclic changes. During the postmigratory phase
(October /November), the amount of the neurosecretory material in the
supraoptic and paraventricular nuclei, the median eminence and the
neurohypophysis was found to be relatively low compared to that in the
premigratory phase. Towards February, there was slight increase but
no perceptible change was noticed until the end of March. From the
last week of March, there was distinct increase, especially in the supraoptic
and paraventricular nuclei, the tractus tubero-hypophysis and the neuro-
hypophysis. The neurosecretory cells were found to be conspicuously
larger with the nuclei and nucleoli also increased in size and surrounded
by a larger amount of cytoplasm. The axons of the cells also were easy
to trace due to their high content of neurosecretory material. A few
days prior to migration, however, the neurosecretory material was found
Physiological adaptations in rosy pastor 397
to be considerably depleted in the neurohypophysis, presumably released
into the general circulation. The reduction in the neurosecretory material
was also noticed in the other parts possibly released and dispersed into
the anterior pituitary through the portal circulation. This release of the
neurosecretory material was considered a trigger in initiating the chain
of events that follow in the migratory process. In a study of the localiza-
tion and intensity of the activity of the enzymes, acid and alkaline phos-
phatases in the hypothalamo-hypophysial system, Naik & George (1966)
observed considerable increase in the enzyme activity towards migration
time. They correlated these changes with increased production and
release of the neurosecretory material. John & George (1970) studied
histo-chemically the localization and intensity of lipase activity in the
hypothalamo-hypophysial system in the post- and premigratory periods.
The enzyme activity was found to be increased in the premigratory
phase in the hypothalamic neurosecretory nuclei, median eminence, pars
nervosa and adenohypophysis. The increase in the enzyme activity
has been correlated with increased lipid metabolism in these regions.
If the release of the neurosecretory material were to influence the
regulatory mechanism in the body, evidently significant changes in the
master gland in the body, the anterior pituitary, should be expected.
Extensive studies on the mammalian pituitary have shown the relation-
ship between the various cell types and the hormones secreted by the
gland. In a cytological study of the pituitary gland of the Rosy Pastor
using histo-chemical staining techniques, Naik & George (1965a) distin-
guished six types of chromophil cells consisting of three types of acido-
phils : Small orange G cells (prolactin [LTHJ cells), Large orange G
cells and Acid fuchsin cells (ACTH cells) ; and three types of basophils :
Purple cells (TSH cells), Deep green cells (FSH cells), Light green cells
(LH cells). Functionally these cells are believed to be responsible for
the production of the hormones indicated in brackets against each cell
type. The cell type for the growth hormone could not be identified. A
general increase in the number and activity, as indicated by size and
staining intensity, was noticed in all cell types towards migration.
A few days prior to migration, the purple cells showed signs of degra-
nulation. This coincided with the release of the colloid in the thyroid
gland (George & Naik 1964a). A study of the serum tyrosine level which
is indicative of thyroidal activity, by Pilo & George (1970a), showed
that the peak level of 104 microgrammes per millilitre was reached
towards migration time (last week of April).
The increase in the number of the deep green cells was found to be
associated with the development of the testes in male (Naik & George
1964a). With the release of the colloid from the thyroid, the develop-
ment of the testicular elements ceased at the stage of primary and secon-
dary spermatocytes, to be resumed after migration at the breeding
398 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol li (3)
grounds. Parallel changes in the females were considerably slower,
which probably accounts for the fact that females leave later.
Prolactin has been implicated as a factor in fattening leading to
migratory activity. The increase in the small orange G cells is in accord-
ance with this contention.
The increase in the acid fuchsin cells prior to migration was reflected
in the increased production of corticoids in the adrenal towards migra-
tion (Naik & George 1963). Increased production of ACTH is also
of significance since this hormone is known to be a fat-mobilizing hor-
mone. The transport of fat from the adipose tissue to the muscles as a
hormone-mediated process is now Well established. Histological and
histochemical studies (Naik & George 1965b) on the adrenal have
demonstrated striking seasonal changes in the adrenal cortex. Towards
migration there was considerable increase in the amount of RNA and
fat and also in mitochondrial density, thus presenting a sort of hyper-
trophic condition in the cortex. These changes might have been in-
fluenced by increased ACTH production. The above changes in the
adrenal were also found to be accompanied by increased activity of
alkaline phosphatase in the cortex and of acid phosphatase in the medulla
(Naik & George 1964b).
The ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) content of the adrenal was found
to drop towards migration (John & George 1967b). They suggested that
this drop in ascorbic acid might be a factor in stimulating the produc-
tion of corticosteroids and adrenalin. Cholesterol is known to be a
precursor of steroid hormones. John & George (1967a) found a marked
increase in total cholesterol in the adrenal from February to April, the
increase in February being significantly more than that in April. They
suggested that cholesterol was being rapidly converted to corticosteroids
With the aid of ACTH which was also expected to be significantly in-
creased (Naik & George 1965a). The role of ACTH in the conversion
of cholesterol to corticosteroids has been discussed by Hayano et al.
(1956). In the production of adrenalin, tyrosine is known not be a pre-
cursor While phenylalanine is believed to have a role in the synthesis of
adrenalin. In a study of the seasonal changes in the concentration of
these two amino-acids in the adrenal, John & George (1967c) found that
the peak was reached in the month of February and the trough towards
migration time. This drop in the amino-acid level has been correlated
with the decrease in ascorbic acid and also with increased production of
adrenalin towards migration time.
The adipokinetic as Well as hyperglycaemic function of glucagon and
the hypoglycaemic function of insulin, the two hormones produced by
the alpha and beta cells respectively in the islets of Langerhans of the
pancreas, are Well known. George & Naik (1964b) observed an increase
in the number of islet cells mainly through the conversion of the acinar
PHYSIOLOGICAL ADAPTATIONS IN ROSY PASTOR
399
cells during the premigratory phase. With the increased activity of the
beta cells the high blood-sugar level in the month of February began to
decline, reaching a low in April, obviously with increased production of
insulin. Consequently, the high sugar intake was diverted towards fat
synthesis.
Premigratory fat deposition
That migratory birds deposit large amounts of fat prior to migration
is common knowledge. Fat mainly in the form of triglycerides is stored
in the adipose tissue present in the different regions of the body, the
abdominal fat pad being the most prominent. Unlike in mammals,
the adipose tissue in the avian body is not known to be an active site
for fat synthesis. Most of the synthesis of fat is believed to take place
in the liver in birds. George & Naik (1963) discovered certain haemato-
poietic nodules in the liver of the Rosy Pastor which were also found to
be sites of fat synthesis. These nodules were found to be most active in
the production of different types of blood cells— erythrocytes, granular
leucocytes, lymphocytes and monocytes, during the premigratory phase.
Fat was found to be synthesized by the lymphocytes, monocytes
and free moving reticulo-endothelial cells, the main synthesis being in
the reticulo-endothelial cells. Though fat is not actively synthesized in
the avian adipose tissue, the tissue as such has been shown to be a
metabolically active tissue, much more so in the Rosy Pastor than in
the domestic fowl (George & Eapen 1958, 1959). Naik (1963) studied
the water, fat, protein and glycogen content of the liver of the Rosy Pas-
tor in the post- and pre-migratory phases. He observed that the body
weight increased from 51-58 g in October to 80-125 g in April prior to
migration. While the water and protein contents of the liver decreased to-
wards migration time, fat and glycogen content increased. The increase
in body weight was by and large due to the deposition of fat in the adi-
pose tissue. Blood fat in transit was also high towards migration time.
An enzyme, lipase, known to be responsible for hydrolysing fat into fatty
acid and glycerol and esterifying fatty acids and glycerol to glycerides,
is also known to be a clearing agent for fat in the blood. George & Vall-
yathan (1961) studied the serum level of lipase activity in the domestic
fowl, pigeon and the Rosy Pastor. They found that the Rosy Pastor had
a serum lipase level about 10 times that of the domestic fowl and
about twice that of the pigeon. The pigeon which is a good flier has a
very much higher serum lipase level than a poor flier like the domestic
fowl; while the Rosy Pastor, which is a migratory bird, has a considerably
higher level than the pigeon.
Seasonal variation in the deposition of fat in birds in general, and the
deposition of migratory fat in migratory birds in particular, is well
4
400 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
documented (see George & Berger 1966). The role of fat as fuel for
muscular energy during migration has been discussed at length by George
& Berger (1966). The machinery necessary for metabolizing fat in the
muscles therefore becomes a topic for consideration.
Fuel of muscle
It is well established that the fat content of the chief avian flight
muscles, pectoralis and supracoracoideus, is generally higher than the
muscles of most other animals (George & Berger 1966). In the Rosy
Pastor the fat content of M. pectoralis is considerably increased towards
migration (Vallyathan 1963). It should be mentioned here that the
glycogen content of the muscle is also increased at the same time
(Vallyathan & George 1964 ; George & Chandra-Bose 1967). It is
possible that during the initial part of flight and also in short flights,
carbohydrate would be the preferred fuel, thus sparing fat, and as flight
is prolonged, fat would take over as the chief fuel. Even then, some
carbohydrate would be metabolized, because the utilization of fat through
fatty acid oxidation takes place in the ‘ flame 5 of carbohydrate. Studies
on pigeons subjected to electrical stimulation of the pectoralis muscle
have shown that fat is transported from the adipose tissue to the muscle
through the blood stream (George & Berger 1966 ; Vallyathan & George
1969 ; Vallyathan et al. 1970). If fat is to be utilized, it has first to be
broken down to fatty acids and glycerol. The fatty acids are then
oxidized in the mitochondria, generating free chemical energy in the form
of adenosine tri-phosphate (ATP) as the main product and carbon dioxide
and water as by-products. It is known that the flight muscles of birds
contain a high concentration of the enzyme, lipase, which splits fat into
fatty acids and glycerol (George & Berger 1966). It is also known that
the avian flight muscle contains numerous mitochondria and high con-
centrations of oxidative enzymes (George & Berger 1966).
The pectoralis muscle of the Rosy Pastor contains two types of fibre,
a red, narrow fibre containing numerous mitochondria and high concen-
trations of fat, lipase and oxidative enzymes and the other a light, broader
fibre considerably fewer in number and containing fewer mitochondria
and much less lipase and oxidative enzymes (George & Berger 1966).
Using histochemical techniques, George & Talesara (1962) showed that
the pectoralis muscle fibres of the Rosy Pastor contain considerably
higher levels of oxidative enzymes than those of the domestic goose and
the domestic fowl. In another study they (1961) observed that the
activity of one of the key enzymes in the Krebs cycle, succinic dehydro-
genase (SDH), in the Rosy Pastor Was higher than that of the several other
birds and a bat studied. They also found that towards migration the
PHYSIOLOGICAL ADAPTATIONS IN ROSY PASTOR 401
SDH activity in the muscle of the Rosy Pastor reached a peak level, twice
that of the level recorded during the postmigratory period. On the other
hand lipase activity in the muscle was found to be lower in the pre-
migratory phase (Vallyathan 1963). In a study of the particulate fractions
and whole homogenate of the pectoralis muscle in the premigratory and
postmigratory periods, George & Vallyathan (1964a) observed that lipase
activity was lower in the premigratory phase and SDH activity higher than
in the postmigratory phase. The experiments were conducted in the
early hours of the morning as well as in the evening so as to know if there
were diurnal differences. From the results obtained they suggested
that fat was synthesized during the night. George & Chandra-Bose
(1967) studied diurnal changes in the levels of glycogen and fat in the
pectoralis muscle of the Rosy Pastor during the premigratory and post-
migratory periods. Glycogen content of the muscle was found to be
higher in the evening than in the morning whereas fat content was higher
in the morning. The decrease of glycogen during the night and of fat
during the day was explained as due to the preferential utilization of the
two metabolites, namely glycogen during night and fat during day time.
Prior to migration, however they observed that the level of fat in the
morning and in the evening was more or less the same. This obser-
vation prompted them to suggest that during the premigratory phase
when the body fat reserve was being built up, the bird was utilizing carbo-
hydrate for muscular energy by oxidizing pyruvate instead of fatty acid
and thereby sparing fat. Phosphorylase activity in the pectoralis muscle
of the Rosy Pastor was found to be higher in the premigratory period
(Vallyathan & George 1963, 1964). This also supports the above
suggestion.
Experiments were conducted to assess the capacity of the muscle
for fatty acid oxidation. George & Vallyathan (1964b) showed that the
breast muscle homogenate of the Rosy Pastor in the postmigratory phase
had a greater capacity for fatty acid oxidation than that in the premigra-
tory phase and that there was greater oxidation of malate in the mano-
metric system in the latter case. In a comparative study of the capacity
for fatty acid oxidation by the breast muscle homogenate of the Rosy
Pastor in its premigratory phase, and that of a non-migratory starling,
Acridotheres tristis, George & Iype (1964) found that it was lower in the
Rosy Pastor at that time. They suggested that there exists a control
system in the Rosy Pastor which minimizes fat utilization during the
premigratory period so as to enhance fat storage. Such a control system
should obviously be a hormonal system. Experiments are presently
being carried out by George and his associates at Guelph with a view to
obtaining a clearer understanding of the regulatory mechanisms in-
volving the secretions of the hypothalamus and the endocrine glands
which control the various metabolic processes in the body.
402 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
The heart muscle is also known to utilize fat as the major fuel for its
energy. George & Iype (1961), correlating lipase activity of the cardiac
muscle with the rate of heart-beat, showed that the lipase activity in the
heart muscle of the Rosy Pastor was lower than that of the non-migratory
starling; Acridotheres tristis , indicating a slower heart rate in the former
as is known to be the case in human marathon runners.
Sustained flight during migration is possible only if there is a copious
and continuous supply of the fuel as well as oxygen. Since the transport
of oxygen is the function of the red blood cells, seasonal changes in the
blood should be expected. Pilo & George (1970b) studied erythro-
poiesis in the bone marrow and seasonal changes in the haemoglobin
content as well as red cell count in the blood of the Rosy Pastor. In-
creased erythropoiesis was noticed in the bone marrow in the pre-
migratory period. Consequently, a corresponding increase in haemo-
globin content as well as red cell count was seen in the blood. A
considerable degree of red cell destruction was found in the liver during
the postmigratory period.
Studies on the physiological adaptations in the Rosy Pastor have
provided interesting and significant leads towards a clearer understanding
of the mechanisms of internal regulation and energy metabolism and
have also stimulated further research. Research on these lines Would
undoubtedly lead to the solution of the riddle of bird migration. The
wealth of new information expected to emanate in the years ahead Would
also have far-reaching implications not only in biology but in medical
science as well. While we realize these goals, it is necessary and legiti-
mate to recognize the valuable contributions of field ornithologists that
formed the foundation for such studies. In bringing forth the present
volume, We pay our tribute to a great ornithologist for his monumental
contributions to ornithology in general and to ornithology of the Indian
subcontinent in particular.
R~e ferences
Ali, Salim (1955) : The Book of
Indian Birds. Fifth edition. Bombay
Natural History Society, Bombay.
Anand, B. K. & Dua, S. (1955):
Feeding responses induced by electrical
stimulation of hypothalamus in cat.
Indian J. Med. Res. 43: 113-122.
& Shoenberg, K. (1955) :
Hypothalamic control of food intake in
cats and monkeys. J. Physiol. 127 :
143-152.
George, J. C. & Berger, A. J. (1966) :
Avian Myology. Academic Press,
New York.
George, J. C. & Chandra-Bose, D. A.
(1967) : Diurnal changes in glycogen
and fat levels in the pectoralis of the
migratory starling, Sturnus roseus.
Pavo 5 : 1-8.
& Eapen, J. (1958) : Histo-
chemical demonstration of certain
enzymes in the adipose tissue of the fowl
( Gallus domesticus ) and Rosy Pastor
( Pastor roseus). J. Anim. Morphol.
Physiol. 5 : 101-103.
& (1959) : Lipase
activity in the adipose tissue of verte-
brates. ibid. 6: 119-122.
PHYSIOLOGICAL ADAPTATIONS IN ROSY PASTOR
403
George, J. C. & Iype, P. T. (1961) :
Lipase activity in the heart muscle of a
migratory and a non-migratory bird.
Auk 78 : 633-634.
& — (1964) : Fatty
acid oxidation by breast muscle homoge-
nates of a migratory and a non-migra-
tory starling. Pavo 2 : 84-87.
— — & Naik, D. V. (1963):
Haemopoietic nodules as centres of fat
synthesis in the liver of the migratory
starling. Pastor roseus . Quart . J. Micro.
Sci. 104 : 393-399.
— & (1964a) : Cyclic
changes in the thyroid of the migratory
starling Sturnus roseus (Linn.). Pavo
2 : 37-47.
& (1964b) : Cyclic
histological and histo-chemical
changes in the pancreas in relation to
blood glucose levels in the migratory
starling, Sturnus roseus (Linn.). Pavo 2 :
88-95.
& (1965) : The
hypothalamo-hypophysial neurosecretory
system of the migratory starling, Sturnus
roseus (Linnaeus). J. Anim. Morphol.
Physiol. 12 : 42-56.
& Talesara, C. L. (1961) :
The succinic dehydrogenase levels of the
pectoral muscles of a few representative
types of birds and a bat in relation to the
fibre diameter, muscle weight and body
weight. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 3 :
267-273.
& (1962) : Histo-
chemical demonstration of certain oxi-
dizing enzymes in the pectoralis major
muscle of the Rosy Pastor ( Pastor
roseus), goose ( Anser albifrons ) and fowl
{Gall us domesticus). J. Anim. Morphol.
Physiol. 9 : 59-62.
& Vallyathan, N. V.
(1961) : A comparative study of the
lipase activity in the blood sera of three
representative birds. J. Anim. Morphol.
Physiol. 8 : 48-53.
■ & (1964a) : Lipase
and succinic dehydrogenase activity of
the particulate fractions of the breast
muscle homogenate of the migratory
starling Sturnus roseus in the premigra-
tory and postmigratory periods. J.
Cell. Comp. Physiol. 63 : 381-391.
& (1964b) : Capa-
city for fatty acid oxidation by the breast
muscle of the starling {Sturnus roseus )
in the pre- and postmigratory periods.
Can. J. Physiol. & Pharmacol. 42 : 447-
452.
Hayano, M., Saba, N., Dorfman,
R. I. & Hecter, O. (1956) : Some aspects
of the biogenesis of adrenal steroid hor-
mones, In : Recent Progress in Hor-
mone Research (G. Pincus, Ed.) 12.
Academic Press, New York.
John, T. M. & George, J. C. (1967a) :
Seasonal variation in cholesterol level
in the migratory starling, Sturnus roseus.
Pavo 5 : 29-38.
& — (1967b) : Cyclic
changes in the ascorbic acid (Vitamin C)
content of the adrenal in the migratory
starling, Sturnus roseus. Pavo S : 39-
46.
& (1967c) : Seaso-
nal variations in the levels of tyrosine
and phenylalanine in the adrenal of the
migratory starling, Sturnus roseus.
Pavo 5:47-51.
& (1970) : Histo-
chemical observations on lipase activity
in the hypothalamo-hypophysial system
of a migratory starling. J. Anim.
Morphol. Physiol . 17 : 15-18.
Kuenzel, W. J. & Helms, C. W.
(1967) : Obesity produced in a migra-
tory bird by hypothalamic lesions. Bio-
Science 17 : 395-396.
Naik, D. V. (1963): Seasonal variation
in the metabolites of the liver of the
Rosy Pastor, Sturnus roseus (Linnaeus).
Pavo 1 : 44-47.
& George, J. C. (1963) :
Histochemical demonstration of increased
corticoid level in the adrenal of Sturnus
roseus (Linn.) towards the migratory
phase. Pavo 1 : 103-105.
& (1964a) : Cer-
tain cyclic histological changes in the
testis of the migratory starling, Sturms
roseus (Linn.). Pavo 2 : 48-54.
& (1964b) : Histo-
chemical demonstration of changes in
the activity of alkaline and acid phospha-
tases in the adrenal of a migratory
starling. J. Histochem: Cytochem. 12 :
772-776.
& (1965a) : Cyclic
changes in the pituitary of the migra-
tory starling, Sturnus roseus (Linn.).
J. Anim. Morphol. Physiol. 12 : 171-188.
& (1965b): Cer-
tain cyclic changes in the histology and
histochemistry of the adrenal in the
migratory starling, Sturnus roseus (Linn).
Pavo 3 : 121-130.
& (1966) :
Changes in acid and alkaline phosphatase
activity in the hypothalamo-hypophysial
system of the migratory starling, Sturnus
roseus, towards migration time. Pavo
4 : 15-21.
Pilo, B. & George, J. C. (1970a) :
Serum tyrosine level as an index of
thyroidal activity in migratory starling.
J. Anim. Morphol. Physiol. 17 : 26-36.
404 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Pilo, B. & George J. C. (1970b) : Ery-
thropoiesis in the migratory starling.
Sturnus roseus (Linn.). J. Anim. Mor-
phol. Physiol. 17 : 19-25.
Vallyathan, N. V. (1963) : On the
lipid content and lipase activity in the
breast muscle of Sturnus roseus (Linn.).
Pavo 1 : 106-109.
& George, J. C. (1963) :
Phosphorylase ‘ a ’ in bird and bat
breast muscles. J. Anim. Morphol.
Physiol. 10 : 15-23.
& (1964) : Gly-
cogen content and phosphorylase activity
in the breast muscle of the migratory
starling, Sturnus roseus (Linn.). Pavo
2 : 55-60.
& (1969) : Effect
of exercise on lipid levels in the pigeon.
Archiv. inter. Physiol. Biochim. 77 :
863-868.
, Grinyer, I., & George,
J. C. (1970) : Effect of fasting and
exercise on lipid levels in muscle. A
cytological and biochemical study. Can ,
J. Zool , 48: 377-383.
The voice of the Indian Hill Myna
( Gracula religiosa ) in the wild1
Brian Bertram
Sub-Department of Animal Behaviour, Madingley,
Cambridge University
The northern race ( intermedia ) of the Indian Hill Myna ( Gracula reli-
giosa) was studied in the field during 1966-7, and the major findings are
summarized in this paper. The distribution and general ecology of the
species are outlined. Vocalizations are dealt with in detail; all can be
classified into one of four categories, one of which (‘ Calls ’) forms the bulk
of this paper. Birds have repertoires of call types, some of which they share
with a few near neighbours of the same sex. The call type last made or heard
influences the call type next made. Playback experiments showed that birds
can distinguish strangers, neighbours, and their mates by their calls. There
is no mimicry of other species, but extensive and complicated vocal imitation
of conspecifics, which makes understandable their remarkable imitative
ability in captivity.
Introduction
Salim Ali (1927) unearthed the best brief description of the Indian
Hill Myna I have found, from the Writings of the Mogul Emperor Babur
in the 16th Century : ‘ there is another sort ; they bring it from Bengal.
It is all black. In its two ears are yellow leathers which hang down and
look very ugly. They call it the Maina. It learns to speak well and
fluently.’ Although known since so long ago, and kept as a talking pet,
it is only recently that the Hill Myna has attracted the attention of
ethologists, on account of its remarkable ability in captivity to imitate
extremely accurately the words of its captors. This ability has caused
great puzzlement, since it appeared (e.g. Thorpe 1964) to be an ability
which Was found only in captivity, partly through lack of knowledge of
its vocalizations in the wild. Stuart Baker (1926) referred to Hill Mynas
‘ copying the notes of other birds freely in the wild state ’ ; Smythies
(1953) appears to have copied freely the notes of Stuart Baker, using
identical words. Other authors (e.g. Ali 1941, 1953 ; Delacour 1947 ;
Glenister 1951 ; Henry 1955) have been more cautious, and more
accurate, referring to the great variety of different noises made by wild
Hill Mynas but not mentioning any imitations by them. Clearly a de-
tailed study of Hill Mynas in the wild was called for.
1 Received September 1972.
406 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
The author carried out such a study in India in 1966 and 1967, under
the sponsorship of the Bombay Natural History Society and the guidance
of Dr Salim Ali. Three months were spent in South India (in the Periyar
Sanctuary, Kerala) studying the southern race of Hill Myna; this race has
the reputation of being a much less good talker than the northern race.
The main cause of the difference is probably, as Salim Ali (1963) pointed
out, that southern-race birds are generally caught as adults, while
northern-race birds are taken from the nest when young ; but, as will be
reported elsewhere, the southern race produces fewer deep or human-
like sounds in the wild, and has much less variety in its calling, and
probably even when taken as a nestling makes a somewhat less satis-
factory talking pet.
The rest of the study period was spent in North India, mainly in
Assam at Kaziranga, but with short visits to other Hill Myna regions and
with study of captive birds at Gauhati. Detailed results of this work
have been published (Bertram 1970), where will be found data to support
the points made in this paper.
General
(a) Classification and distribution
In this section it is helpful to elaborate Babur’s summary. In Hill
Mynas the sexes are identical, both being iridescent black all over except
for white wing-patches, orange-yellow beak and legs, and yellow pendant
wattles ; these latter, and size, vary according to the subspecies. Ten
subspecies of Gracula religiosa have been recognized, distributed over
south-east Asia from India to Indonesia. In Ceylon, two forms occur,
and since they overlap but do not interbreed the form endemic to Ceylon
has been given specific rank as G. ptilogenys (Peters 1962 ; Ripley 1961).
In my view, G. r. indica from south-west India and Ceylon also merits
specific rank : in their vocalizations this race is completely distinct from
G. r. intermedia which stretches from Nepal to Indo-China ; in aviaries
they do not interbreed or interact with this latter race ; and G. r. indica
is considerably smaller and with more complex wattle arrangements than
the other races of G. religiosa .
(&) Ecology
Hill Mynas inhabit particularly the edges of forest, especially ever-
green and Semi-evergreen, and thus are found in regions of high rainfall
and humidity. They are rarely abundant, being found usually in pairs
or small flocks. They fly fast, with their white wing-patches conspi-
cuous. They are basically a resident species, but may move locally.
VOICE OF THE INDIAN HILL MYNA
407
They are mainly frugivorous, but they take nectar, insects and lizards
when available, the latter two especially when rearing young. They are
completely arboreal, virtually never coming down to the ground.
The onset of breeding coincides with, and is probably triggered by,
the start of the rainy season. At this time the small winter flocks split
up into their constituent (and probably permanent) pairs, which select
a nesting area. They appear to be semi-territorial. They nest in Small
holes in hollow trees, of many species but especially (in Assam) the
Velou tree, Tetrameles nudiflora , if available. They build a rough nest
of sticks and leaves, collected in a remarkably haphazard manner by
both sexes equally. There is almost no courtship before copulation. A
clutch consists of 2 to 3 eggs, which are incubated for 13 to 15 days by
both birds but more by the female. The young are fed by both parents,
largely on regurgitated food ; they leave the nest about 27 days after
hatching, and are independent of their parents very soon after this. It
is likely that they breed first when a year old. Although their nests
may be vulnerable to predation, Hill Mynas probably have few enemies
other than Man, who robs their nests for young birds for the sizeable
export market. In the Garo Hills, artificial nests are put up in the tree-
tops, and the young birds taken from them (Bertram 1968).
Vocalizations
(a) Methods of study
Most of the observations reported here were made on a number of
wild individual pairs of adult Mynas at Kaziranga in Assam. The term
‘ Myna ’ hereafter refers only to G. r. intermedia , the race of Hill Myna
found there. Separate nesting pairs were observed during their breed-
ing season, at the edges of the scattered tea estates and remains of hill
forest along the north edge of the Mikir Hills. Thus this was along an
east-west line at the edge of their habitat, the country immediately further
north being flood plain unsuitable for Mynas. Birds were observed
from the ground, when in the vicinity of their nests, the only place where
they could be recognized at first, although later this was possible by
means of their vocalizations .
Myna noises were recorded with a Nagra tape-recorder and parabolic
reflector. Also, a notation system was developed With which it was
possible to write down all the noises made by a given pair of birds. Fre-
quently they Were very silent, and were then sometimes stimulated to call
by playback calls, as described later. Sounds recorded were analyzed
later in the laboratory by means of a sonograph,
403 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
(b) Classification of vocalizations
All the noises regularly made by wild adult Mynas of either sex
can be classified into the four main categories below :
(i) Chip-call. This is a very loud, very piercing, short descending
squeak, and is made by all adults when excited or alarmed. The body
is jerked or swivelled as the chip-call is uttered with the beak open, a
movement which helps to make the caller visible. The structure, with
sudden onset, is such as to assist further in locating the caller (Marler
1955 discussed the cues needed for such location), and is also Well suited
to being heard through the irregular 6 white ’ noise of intermingled
forest noises. Their function appears to be partly in long-range contact
between individuals, and partly as an alarm call at closer range. The
structure of the chip-call made by different individuals differs slightly
but consistently. There are greater differences between the chip-calls
of birds from different regions, and playback experiments showed that
Mynas could detect these differences, responding more strongly to chip-
calls recorded in their own region.
(ii) Um-sounds. These are soft sharp nasal ‘ am ’ noises, made
almost all the time by all active birds, and apparently functioning mainly
in close-range contact and co-ordination between individuals. The
structure of an um-sound makes it easy to locate the caller. This sound
grades in structure according to context.
(iii) Whisper-whistles. These are soft high-pitched sounds of
repetitive structure. They are made in periods of inactivity and low
arousal. Any adult Myna has a repertoire of a few discrete patterns of
whisper- whistles, all of them unique to itself. Their function, if any,
is unknown.
(iv) Calls. These are loud noises of an enormous variety of
precise types : whistles, wails, shrieks, gurgles, groans, squeaks, etc.
They are often low-pitched and human-like. They are made especially
When Mynas see or hear others. Every adult bird possesses several
such calls, of different types ; they are the most characteristic and most
interesting of Myna vocalizations, and were studied in the greatest detail.
It is ‘ calls ’, as defined here, which are dealt with in the rest of this paper.
Call types
It was clear to the ear in the field that Myna calls were of discrete
types, without intermediates. It proved possible to demonstrate this
objectively by comparing sonograms of different calls ; the method deve-
loped was to determine the proportionate overlap of the two patterns of
monographed calls being compared, using a tracing of ope of these song-
VOICE OF THE INDIAN HILL MYNA
409
grams on transparent graph paper. Details of this 4 Difference Index ’
method have been described elsewhere (Bertram 1970). The great value
of the method lay in establishing that the differences and similarities
in call types as noted by ear in the field were genuine and not purely
subjective ones.
Any adult Myna was found to have a repertoire of different call
types, without intermediates ; i.e. the call types of each individual were
discrete. The size of the repertoire varied between individuals, ranging
from 3 to 13 with a median of 8*5. Using the concept of a 99% reper-
toire (Bertram 1970), it proved possible to compare repertoire sizes of
birds from which different numbers of calls had been observed. Males
were found to have generally larger repertoires than their mates ; but
males did not call significantly more or less often than did their mates.
Birds with large repertoires tended both to have mates with large reper-
toires, and to call more often.
Some of the call types in a bird’s repertoire were uttered much more
frequently than others, in many cases 10 and more times as often. Birds
which were heard in both years of the study were found to keep
their repertoires roughly constant over that time, in size, in call types in
the repertoire, and in commonness of those call types.
No bird shared any of its call types with its mate. No general
differences could be found in call types made by the two sexes ; each bird
certainly has the^potential capability of producing its mate’s call types,
and certainly it has frequently heard them, yet it does not possess them
in its repertoire. Its own call types are as different from one another
as from those of its mate.
Recordings were made of Mynas in different regions of north-east
India. No Myna shared a call type with any other from a region other
than its own.
On the other hand, each Myna shared some of its call types with one
of the birds in each of several near neighbouring pairs, and it was
eventually determined that in each case, it was with the bird of the same
sex as itself. Thus a male shared call types with several neighbouring
males, and females similarly. The great majority of call types in a
bird’s repertoire, especially the common ones, were found to be possessed
also by at least one other individual. On average, 40-50% of a bird’s
repertoire of call types Would also be in the repertoire of a neighbour
living within 2\ km of it; this proportion declined gradually with distance
with the result that birds more than about 14 km apart had no call types
in common with one another, yet both would share some with an inter-
mediate individual. This is clear evidence of vocal imitation of other
individuals in the wild.
Call types which were made commonly by one bird tended also to be
made commonly by other birds which possessed that call type. Each
410 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
call type had a limited geographical range, and tended to be scarce in the
repertoire of birds possessing it at the edge of its range.
In the detailed structure of a shared call type, fine but consistent
differences could be detected on sonograms and often by ear. Playback
experiments (the technique of which is described later) indicated that
birds could distinguish between a call made by their mate and a call of
the same type made by a neighbour.
Call types produced by myna pairs when alone
There were few external contexts other than auditory ones which could
be shown to determine or to influence the call type produced. The
exception was of call types uttered when in the air ; birds occasionally
called while flying (especially when chasing one another in flight), and
if they did, the call type used either was a call type heard on no other
occasions (i.e. purely a flight call) or was one particular other one of the
call types in their repertoire.
Auditory contexts appeared to be more important ; the call type
next uttered by a bird could be shown to depend both on the last call
type it had made, and on the last call type its mate had made. Mynas
were found to call at irregular intervals. Their calling, with calls very
short compared with the intervals between them, is highly discontinuous.
It was sliown that birds did not produce their call types at random, but
tended to order them. After a call, the next call uttered was likely either
to be a repeat of that same call type, or to be a call of one or two other
call types which significantly often followed the first. Some individuals
tended to utter two particular call types alternately. It was found that a
bird tended to produce its call types in the same order as its neighbour
produced its call types, provided such call types Were in the repertoires
of both individuals. This is evidence of more complicated vocal imi-
tation between individuals .
A bird also tended to standardize the call types made after each parti-
cular call type of the mate; this was especially so with ‘replies i.e. calls
made within 2J seconds of a call by the mate. ‘ Replies ’, as defined
thus, occurred frequently, and tended to be of standard types which
depended on the particular call type of the mate which was being replied
to. These standardized call-and-reply sets tended to be the same in
neighbouring pairs of birds, provided, obviously, that these neighbouring
pairs possessed these call types in their repertoires. This again is
evidence of vocal imitation in calling, of an even more complicated form.
Call types produced when in contact with other pairs
Pairs rarely met one another conveniently for me. Therefore most
of the information on calling between pairs came from playback experi-
VOICE OF THE INDIAN HILL MYNA
411
merits. These were carried out in the following way. A single Myna
call was played to a pair of Mynas from a tape-recorder on the ground
about 30 m from the tree in which they were nesting and were therefore
usually perched. The call was played once ; the next call Would be
played 1£ to 2 minutes later. The birds’ responses, both physical and vocal,
were noted down. Frequently the birds flew ; if they did, it was usually
at once, and in the direction of the loudspeaker ; they also usually called,
especially at once, and used call types dependent on the playback call
type. Thus they were clearly responding to the playback call.
In experiments where playback calls of neighbours were alternated
with calls of strangers from a distant region, Mynas responded more
strongly to their neighbours’ calls. (The measures of strength of res-
ponse used were : occurrence of flight within 30 seconds; total number of
calls and whisper-whistles within minutes ; time elapsing before
response ; and proportion of playback calls ignored.) Nonetheless,
they were definitely responding to the calls of these strangers, although
such calls were of call types completely unfamiliar to them — they must
have been able to recognize them as Myna calls, either by sound quality
or by elimination.
In the above experiments, the calls of neighbours were of call types
which were in the repertoire of the subject pair being tested. Further
playback experiments showed that the stronger response found (above)
to neighbours’ calls was because they were familiar, not because they were
in the subject pair’s repertoire. After hearing a playback call, birds tended
to match it, i.e. to produce at once that same call type if they possessed
it in their repertoire. (This matching was also extremely noticeable
when pairs of Mynas met.) That call type was then also made more
frequently during the subsequent 1J minutes, and so were those other
call types which were associated with that call type in the subject pair’s
calling when in isolation. There were indications that the commonness
of different call types in a pair’s repertoire was influenced by the call types
their adjacent neighbours used.
Thus the call type a bird has just heard (made by either itself, its
mate, or its neighbour) influences the call type it makes next ; and since
these other birds behave similarly, calls made also influence calls heard.
Summarizing this and the previous section, it may be said that the more,
and the more recently, a bird has made or heard a call type or sequence
of call types, the more likely it is itself to produce that same call type or
sequence of call types.
Discussion
It appears that Mynas are able to recognize conspecifics by the quality
of the calls they produce, if these calls are not of local types which are
familiar to them. What aspects of vocal quality can be possessed in
412 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
common by the enormous variety of different call types is not clear, and
it is possible that they also rely on a method of elimination in recognizing
as a Myna a stranger from an unknown region. Playback experiments
showed that Mynas can recognize birds from the same locality, responding
more strongly to these than to strangers ; the reason for this difference
in strength of response is not clear. The sex of a neighbour is at once
obvious from the call types it makes ; it is not known whether there are
any cues which enable identification by voice of the sex of a stranger.
Auditory recognition of individuals is clearly possible in several ways :
by which call types are in the repertoire ; by the fine structure of these
call types ; by whisper-whistles ; or by details of the structure of chip-
calls ; the relative importance of these is not known, and nor is the extent
of the need for auditory recognition of individuals.
There have been few satisfactory experimental studies demonstrating
auditory recognition of individuals in other species ; those in which it
has been shown to occur include Guillemots, Uria aalge (Tschanz 1968),
Laughing Gulls, Larus atricilla (Beer 1969), and Common Terns, Sterna
hirundo (Stevenson et al. 1970) where there was recognition of parents
by offspring ; in Gannets, Sula bassana (White 1971) in which recognition
of the voice of the mate was shown ; and in Whitethroated Sparrows,
Zonotrichia albicollis (Falls 1969) where there was recognition of indi-
vidual neighbours. There have been numerous studies showing audi-
tory recognition of conspecifics, and in some cases (e.g. Abs 1963 ;
Bremond 1967, 1968 ; and Falls 1963) it has been shown what para-
meters of the songs are used by the birds in such recognition.
No wild adult Myna was found to imitate another species; it is likely
that they rarely if ever do so. If such vocal mimicry does occur, it would
appear to be insignificant compared with the large amount of vocal
imitation which has been shown to take place within the species. Why
they do not mimic other species is a question which is asked only because
Mynas are known to imitate in captivity ; there is no reason why they
should, and their mimicry in captivity is probably equivalent to their
learning calls by selective imitation of conspecifics in the wild. Such imi-
tation of conspecifics is necessary in a bird with no innately patterned
calls and apparently little or no inventiveness. The evolution of this
situation will be discussed elsewhere. For the present, knowing the
use of the voice by Mynas in the wild, their imitative ability in captivity
is no longer inexplicable ; it is no less remarkable.
Acknowledgements
I owe very many thanks to Salim Ali : for his enthusiastic support
of my work in India ; for the many advantages of working under his
renowned wing ; and for his stimulation and kindness as host and friend
in Bombay. Also to the Bombay Natural History Society for their spon-
VOICE OF THE INDIAN HILL MYNA 413
sorship of my project, including the loan of their Nagra tape-recorder.
At Madingley, I owe thanks to many members of the Sub-Department
of Animal Behaviour for their help, advice, and discussions, especially
to my Supervisor Professor W. H. Thorpe, Professor R. A. Hinde, and
Dr R. G. W. Prescott.
Financial support was provided by a Leverhulme Scholarship from
the Royal Society, London, followed by a Research Studentship from the
Science Research Council, U.K. ; to both organizations I am much
indebted.
References
Abs, M. (1963) : Field tests on the
essential components of the European
Nightjar’s song. Proc. XIII int. orn.
Congr. 202-205.
Ali, S. (1927) : The Moghul emperors
of India as naturalists and sportsmen.
/. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 32 : 34-63.
(1941) : The book of Indian
birds. Bombay Natural History Society,
Bombay.
(1953) : The birds of Tra-
vancore and Cochin. Oxford Univ.
Press, Bombay.
— (1963) : On the alleged in-
feriority of the Southern Grackle
( Gracula religiosa indica ) as a talking bird.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 60 : 455-456.
Beer, C. G. (1969) : Laughing Gull
chicks : recognition of their parents’
voices. Science, N.Y. 166: 1030-1032.
Bertram, B. C. R. (1968) : Hill
Mynas breeding in artificial nests in the
Garo Hills District of Assam, India.
Agricult. Mag. 74 : 180-181.
(1970) : The vocal behaviour
of the Indian Hill Mynah, Gracula
religiosa. Anim. Behav. Monogr. 3 :
79-192.
Bremond, J.-C. (1967) : Reconnais-
sance de schemas reactogenes lies a
l’information contenue dans le chant
territorial du rouge-gorge ( Erithacus
rubecula). Proc. XIV int. orn. Congr.
217-229.
(1968) : Valeur specifique
de la syntaxe dans le signal de defense
territoriale du troglodyte ( Troglodytes
troglodytes). Behaviour 30 : 66-75.
Delacour, J. (1947) : Eirds of
Malaysia. Macmillan, New York.
Falls, J. B. (1963) : Properties of
bird song eliciting responses from terri-
torial males. Proc. XIII int. orn. Congr.
259-271.
- — — (1969) : Functions of terri-
torial song in the Whitethroated Sparrow.
In : Bird Vocalizations (ed. by R. A.
Hinde). Univ. Press, Cambridge.
Glenister, A. G. (1951) : The birds
of the Malay peninsula, Singapore and
Penang. Oxford Univ. Press, London.
Henry, G. M. (1955) : A guide to the
birds of Ceylon. Oxford Univ. Press,
London.
Marler, P. (1955) : Characteristics
of some animal calls. Nature, Lond.
176 : 6-8.
Peters, J. L. (1962) : Check-list of
birds of the world, 15 : (ed. by
E. Mayr and J. C. Green way). Museum
of Comparative Zoology, Cambridge
(Mass.).
Ripley, S. D. (1961) : A synopsis of the
birds of India and Pakistan. Bombay
Natural History Society, Bombay.
Smythies, B. E. (1953) : The birds of
Burma. Oliver & Boyd, Edinburgh
and London.
Stevenson, J. G., Hutchison, R. E.,
Hutchison, J. B., Bertram, B. C. R. &
Thorpe, W. H. (1970) : Individual re-
cognition by auditory cues in the Com-
mon Tern ( Sterna hirundo). Nature,
Lond. 226: 562-563.
Stuart Baker, E. C. (1926) : The
fauna of British India : Birds. Taylor &
Francis, London.
Thorpe, W. H. (1964) : Mimicry,
Vocal. In : A New Dictionary of Birds
(ed. by A. L. Thomson). Nelson &
McGraw-Hill, London and New York.
Tschanz, B. (1968) : Trottellummen :
die Entstehung der persbnlichen Bezieh-
ungen zwischen Jungvogel und Eltern.
Z. Tierpsychol ., Supplement 4 : 1-100.
White, S. J. (1971) : Selective res-
ponsiveness by the Gannet {Sula bassana)
to played-back calls. Anim. Behav. 19 :
125-3L
Bird vocalizations as systems of
communication1
W. H. Thorpe
Sub-Department of Animal Behaviour , Madingley,
Cambridge University
( With eleven text-figures)
I believe all naturalists will agree that birds are the most vocal ani-
mals apart from man. But what is all this noise for ? Obviously — for
communication ! (Thorpe 1961). This answer at once gives rise to a
second question, namely, what are the special circumstances of bird life
which render vocal communication pre-eminently valuable? After all
birds have outstandingly refined and perfected visual powers including
excellent colour vision ; they show a wide and often spectacular develop-
ment of plumage, obviously adapted for display and signalling purposes.
Linked with these they have evolved a complex series of elaborately
and precisely controlled display movements and postures, designed
to exhibit to the utmost advantage, as signalling devices, almost every
feather of these specific plumage patterns : so, with all this, where does the
voice come in ?
Sound production, coupled with the right degree of development
and specialization of the organs of hearing, has certain intrinsic advan-
tages over other communication methods. The methods of communi-
cation employed by animals are, of course, very various. Apart from
the visual signals, displays and gestures just mentioned, odour trails
and the marking of territory by excreta and the secretions of syeeial
glands are all common and widespread in the mammals and the social
insects. Such methods may indeed have iheir advantages for strictly
terrestrial animals. But for the mobile and active birds, so often nesting
in trees or bushes and little in contact with the ground, they have little
utility. Again much sex behaviour in mammals is initiated and controlled
by sensitivity to special secretions, as with the dog seeking the bitch on
heat. However, birds, being mostly aterrestrial, have had no reason
to develop the special secretions and high olfactory sensitivity found in
mainly ground-living animals. So it is understandable that the birds
should not have developed olfactory stimulation as a feature in their sex
life [Thorpe, W. H., see chaps. 2, 5 and 6 in Hinde, R. A. (Ed.) 1972].
1 Received January 1973.
BIRD VOCALIZATIONS
415
Quite apart from the special needs of creatures which ?re airborne,
active and largely arboreal, these above-mentioned methods of com-
munication all have considerable general limitations compared with
mechanical vibrations of a medium — especially the air— as signals.
Spiders of course can obtain certain information as a result of perceiving
the vibrations of the web, and rabbits signal by thumping the ground.
But the great advantage of using airborne or waterborne vibrations,
namely ‘ sound * as signals, is that sound carries far and fast and readily
bypasses obstacles. There is also a great spectrum of frequency and
intensity available for use. In terms of mechanical effort, sounds are
extremely economical to produce, and — since sounds vanish as quickly
as they are produced — the items of information do not accumulate so as
to prevent the sending of further messages. So it is obvious why a
language (and after all the communication systems of birds may legiti-
mately and in a general sense be termed a language) if it is to achieve its
full potentialities must be a language of sounds. But although the
language of sounds has been brought to a high degree of development
by the insects, the amphibia, the mammals and perhaps also by the
fish (which would be expected, because a sound Wave travels farther, for
a given loss of amplitude, in water than in air, and also approximately four
times as fast) the birds, again apart from man, have raised the language of
vocalizations to a level not otherwise attained in evolution.
Granting all this we may ask the question, ‘ What are the particular
circumstances of avian life which render vocal communication so
valuable ? * These can be briefly listed under two headings as follows:
A. On the nesting grounds during the breeding season. Here the
communication is primarily by song or its substitute call-notes in birds
which have no song. B. On winter or off-territory feeding grounds,
on migrations and in strange or hostile environments. For these pur-
poses it is usually the call-notes which are involved rather than the song,
but there is no doubt that there are many examples (e.g. Terns) where
call-notes, besides constituting a series of signals widely and perhaps
innately understood throughout the species as warning calls etc., can
also contain sufficient individual elaboration to render them serviceable
as individual recognition marks.
Included under group A above, we may list the advertisement, esta-
blishment and maintenance of territory. The establishment of the pair
bond. The recognition of the mate and the ability to distinguish him or
her from other individuals in neighbouring territories; and also, as often
seems to be the case, to distinguish between various neighbouring indi-
viduals. Then when the young are hatched and moving about, and while
parental care is still operative, it is clearly often important that the young
should be individually recognizable by the parents and the parents by the
young. It is doubtful how far this situation obtains in the nidicolous
5
416 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
and altricial species but there is clear evidence that in many of the nidi-
fugous and precocial birds such individual recognition may be extremely
important and may extend for a long time after the young are fully
winged and active. Even though they may not require feeding, it can
often be important for the young to be protected from the inclement
weather, shepherded away from danger and introduced to the best feeding
grounds and the most suitable types of food available in the general
environment (Thorpe 1968).
Under the heading of B the following circumstances must be men-
tioned. For life during the winter and in feeding flocks, as indeed
throughout the whole life-history, calls warning of predators or other
dangers are perpetually required. Above all perhaps on migration is it
undoubtedly valuable, on many occasions, that a flying group should
keep together.
Finally there are some situations common to A and B, namely com-
munications in darkness or bad visibility, communications in dense
vegetation and communications amongst colonial nesters, especially
dense colonies of sea birds, where nothing less than the great elaboration
and precision of which auditory communication methods are capable is
likely to provide the necessary refinement and individually recognizable
multiplicity of signals.
A very significant example of the way in which call-notes are often
adapted to the particular function that they serve is provided by the
call-notes used by various passerine families that give warning of danger
from predators. Marler (1955) has shown how such notes are
specialized in their acoustic structure for the particular type of predator
encountered. Thus in finches, chats, warblers, thrushes and wrens,
detection of an enemy on the ground or perched in a tree (e.g. a weasel,
a hawk or an owl) results in the birds giving repeated loud calls of ex-
tremely brief duration but covering a great frequency range. Call-
notes of this structure usually sound more or less click-like or tick-like
to our ears. They are often given in a situation in which it is presumably
advantageous for the bird concerned to draw attention to this particular
danger and to warn others of its exact location. Thus we get what is
known as the mobbing response of many small birds to a perched owl
in which they stand around at a fairly safe distance and chatter at the
enemy. The result is to attract neighbours to join in the mob. Now it
has been shown that this type of call has the characteristic of being very
easily located — not only by bird ears but by our own ; for loud click-
like sounds are quickly and readily referred to the right direction and
roughly to the right distance.
When however danger is from a flying predator in the air above,
e.g. hawk, or an owl, then the threat is immediate and the danger great.
So far from making itself conspicuous the threatened bird dives into the
BIRD VOCALIZATIONS
41 1
nearest shelter and gives a type of call which starts and stops gradually
and maintains a fairly constant pitch somewhere around 7 kHz. Other
birds hearing these calls likewise fly to shelter and repeat the same calls
from their hiding-places. The point that first strikes the human observer
on hearing these calls is that they are extremely difficult to locate. This
is due in the first place to the fact that they lack the characteristics pre-
viously mentioned which make localization easy. But besides this there
is another reason. A bird employs the same methods as we do to locate
the origin of a sound. These consist of comparisons between the sound
as received by the two ears involving three different types of data :
(1) phase difference, (2) intensity difference and (3) time of arrival.
Phase difference is most likely to be valuable at low frequencies : for
instance, the data become ambiguous when the wavelength is much less
than twice the distance apart of the ears. Intensity differences are most
valuable at fairly high frequencies and the differential effect on the two
ears is due to the ‘ sound shadow ’ cast by the head of the listening bird.
Sound shadows only become important when the wavelength approxi-
mates to the diameter of the obstruction. Differences between the time
of arrival of the sound at the two ears will, of course, be more obvious
the larger the distance apart of the ears. But calculations suggest that
sounds about the frequency of 7 kilohertz are likely to be maximally
difficult to locate for the ears of a bird of medium size— say a hawk or an
owl. This frequency is too high for effective binaural comparisons of
phase difference and too low for there to be enough sound shadow per-
ceptible by the ears. Thus the seet call of the male chaffinch probably
gives no clues as to its location either by phase or intensity difference.
This leaves only the third method, the appreciation of binaural time
differences ; and just because the sounds begin and end gradually or
imperceptibly, no clues for time difference are supplied. So it appears
that the alarm-calls of quite a number of passerine families, uttered when
a predator threatens, are both physically and physiologically far more
precisely adapted to their function than anyone would have supposed
previous to Marler’s work.
One of the most interesting results oTrecent studies of bird behaviour
' has been the discovery of the desirability, one may even say the necessity,
that parents should learn to recognize their young individually and the
young their parents. Even in nidifugous species, where the young move
about and may scatter soon after hatching, this individual recognition is
often crucial. This implies of course both individual distinctiveness
and the ability to learn and respond appropriately to individual
" differences. Indeed when we consider the problem of reproduction and
survival faced by birds such as many species of gulls, terns, gannets,
penguins and so on — birds which nest in very dense colonies and obtain
their food during the nesting period in rather restricted areas of sea or
418 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
coastline near their colony — we can at once see a number of ways in
which such abilities for individual recognition could be advantageous.
Without it the feeding of the young, at least as soon as they
become mobile, could be a very wasteful process. Hordes of young
would be competing for food from each individual adult as it returned to
the colony ; with the result that the strongest, the most fortunate, the
most mature or the quickest, would obtain ample food and many others
would starve. And those which did survive would be no better fitted
to take their place as adult members of a colony-nesting species. In
the circumstances of colony nesting the eugenic need is for selection to
operate so that adults which ensure that their own young are fed are at a
selective advantage without, thereby, decreasing the chances of other
young in the assemblage. This is the sine qua non of social life.
Tschanz, summarizing in 1968 nearly 10 years of work, was a pioneer
in his demonstration that young guillemots {Uria aalge) learn to react
selectively to the call of their parents and that, during the first few days of
life, the parents similarly recognize their own young. Indeed there is
some evidence that the young while still within the egg may learn to res-
pond to and recognize some aspects of the sounds produced by the adults.
There has long been considerable reason for suspecting that in some
terns and gulls also (Beer 1970) the adults can recognize their mates
and young and the young their parents, by call alone. Thorpe and his
co-workers (Thorpe 1968 ; Hutchison, Stevenson & Thorpe 1968 ; and
Stevenson et al. 1970) have studied two species of terns in this respect,
the Sandwich Tern {Sterna sandvicensis) and the Common Tern {Sterna
hirundo) and have found that the so-called ‘ fish call ’, uttered by the
parent when returning to its young with food, has just the kind of struc-
ture required to provide auditory data for individual recognition. In
the forty different individuals from which it was possible to obtain a
series of samples of the 4 fish call ’, each bird had a call measurably
distinct from all the others and the successive calls given by any one bird
were extraordinarily similar. Each call lasts only half a second or less
but within this half-second there are three phases and each of these phases
is different from the others and characteristic of the individual which
gives them, in a combination of qualities. Thus we can measure inde-
pendently the duration of the segment, the number of pulses in a seg-
ment, the lowest and highest frequencies displayed and the change with
time in the distribution of the principal frequencies. Yet with all these
individual characteristics present the 4 fish call * is still a good diagnostic
feature for the species. In the case of the Sandwich tern for instance it
seems probable that the duration and number of pulses in the third seg-
ment are used to identify the individual’s call and also that the frequency
changes during the passage of the second segment contribute to this.
On the other hand the first segment of the call does not show individual
BIRD VOCALIZATIONS
419
differences of the same degree and it is likely that the first segment is
primarily of importance for indicating the species and the last two more
specialized for determining the individual. And all this information is
conveyed in a call lasting as I have said half a second or less and the
individual segment perhaps enduring for no more than a fifth of a second.
Sensitivity to changes in auditory stimulation of such extremely brief
duration are of course quite beyond the capacity of the human ear. But
there is now a considerable amount of evidence showing that the temporal
sensitivity of the bird ear is better than ours by a factor of about ten.
And indeed if we slow down tape recordings of these 6 fish calls * of the
terns to about 1/4 speed we find that we can begin to distinguish these
important individual differences. That the terns themselves can indeed
do this has been shown by Thorpe and his co-workers (Stevenson et al.
1970) in the Common tern. He found that the chick at 4 days of age
while quite unresponsive to a playback of calls of other members of the
colony, responds immediately on being played the returning call of one
of its own parents. The response is a sudden alert, ‘ cheeping ’, turning
and walking towards the loudspeaker. So it seems that the call of the
returning parent, the Common tern, carrying food, is quickly learnt and
responded to by the individual young concerned. If we may put this in
blatantly anthropocentric terms it appears that this call is in effect
saying ‘ Here is Mum [or here is Dad] with food
There is also a great deal of information available regarding the
specialization of songs, as distinct from call-notes, for individual recogni-
tion. For my discussion of this I shall restrict myself to a particular case,
namely that of antiphonal song or duetting as a new topic and one parti-
cularly appropriate to this volume as mainly relevant to tropical species.
I first encountered the duetting of tropical bird species on my first
visit to a tropical forest environment, namely that at Barro Colorado,
Panama, in 1932. There I encountered the spectacular duetting of the
Marbled Guiana Quail ( Odontophorus guianensis panamensis). I also
then learnt of the duetting propensities of the tropical American wrens.
A lengthy visit to Tanganyika in 1939 reinforced my interest in duetting
but the time was still far too early for careful study since the tape-recorder
had yet to be invented. Not until 1962, during a study visit to Uganda,
did I have the opportunity to record African birds for myself, and I
at once became fascinated and astonished at the constancy and precision
of duetting in the genera Laniarius, Cisticola, Cossypha and Trachy -
phonus ; and realized the possibilities of study, now for the first time
opening out, as a result of the development of portable tape-recorders
linked with the use of the sound spectrograph. Thus commenced a
research project which was to last over 10 years (Thorpe 1972). As a
result of my own work and of a survey of the now extensive literature I
can state that there are 32 or more families of birds in which duetting—
420 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
that is either simultaneous or alternating song — is known to occur
between the mated males and females. Within these families there are
something of the order of 120 species which have been noted as duettists
in this sense and of these 120 nearly 100 are tropical. In fact precise
duetting or antiphonal singing as a means of maintaining contact between
male and female is extremely rare outside the tropics.
Of the 32 families mentioned there are some 9 in which antiphonal
song at its highest development has been produced. By this we mean
alternating or precise unison song between the paired male and female
given with high precision and used even when the birds cannot see each
other. The result of this is that distance, intervening vegetation etc.,
offer little or no obstacle to mutual recognition and the maintenance of
contact. These 9 families are: Megapodidae, Phasianidae, Rallidae,
Formicariidae, Troglodytidae, Turdidae, Sylviidae, Laniidae and Meli-
phagidae. It soon became clear that the most attractive African genus
with which to begin work was Laniarius and L. aethiopicus the most
promising species for our purpose. Accordingly the brief summary
which I shall give here concerns this species almost exclusively. Before
proceeding further however, one point should be made : that is that the
term duetting includes four varieties of dual song namely, ( a ) antiphonal,
( b ) polyphonic, (c) unison and (< d ) overlapping (polyphonic). These
four examples are illustrated by Fig. 1. Three separate populations
Fig. 1. Types of duet singing. [N.B.— The contributions of the
two birds are distinguished by the notes of one having the tails up and the
other down. Thus in (c) where all the notes are shared each note has two
tails, one up the other down.]
of the race major of this species were studied in East Africa, two of them
in Kenya separated by about 240 km and one in SW. Uganda separated
from the nearest Kenya population studied by about 700 km. Vocaliza-
tions consist of antiphonal singing between the members of the mated
pair, the male usually, but not necessarily, being the leader. On occasion
the birds may sing the whole of a given pattern in exact synchronicity.
We also found that either bird alone can sing the whole duet pattern by
itself. As Figs. 2-8 Will show, these song duets comprise attractive little
tunes, even striking the European listener as of considerable musical
quality with a clear harmonic relationship. The device of one bird
singing the whole duet pattern by itself when the other happens to be
BIRD VOCALIZATIONS
421
absent, seems to be used as a means of calling an absent mate back to
his or her territory. It was also shown that while there are many duet
patterns common to most, if not all, pairs in a given area, the repertoire
of each pair is likely to be distinct from that of its neighbours and the
Fig. 2. Laniarius aethiopicus sublacteus , Vipingo, Kilifi, Kenya,
Dec. 1954. N.B.— All the illustrations are given at approximately scientific
pitch (middle ‘C’=256 c/s). Unless otherwise stated, as here, all the figures
refer to race major (Thorpe & North 1965). N.B.—The figure 8 above the
treble clef symbol indicates that all that follows should be read as one octave
higher than would otherwise be the case, e.g. middle ‘C’ becomes 512 c/s.
‘ x 9 & ‘y’=t\\Q two birds.
Fig. 3. L. aethiopicus , Dundori, Nakuru, Kenya, 17 Mar. 1964
(Thorpe & North 1965).
Fig. 4. L. aethiopicus , Kabale, Uganda, 15 Feb. 1962 (Thorpe &
North 1965).
Fig. 5. L. aethiopicus , Meadow Point, Lake Nakuru, Kenya, 17 Mar.
1964 (Thorpe & North 1965).
Fig. 6. L. aethiopicus , Hippo Pool, Lake Nakuru, Kenya, 17 Mar.
1964. Note that this is a rather more elaborate duet than the previous ones.
The contribution of the two birds is not indicated in this case since it seemed
to vary a good deal (Thorpe & North 1965).
Fig. 7. L. aethiopicus mossambicus, San Martino, Mozambique Coast
(C. Haagner). The timing in this example is very precise but the bar length
might vary between 0‘75 and l*5s (Thorpe & North 1965).
Fig. 8. L. aethiopicus mossambicus, San Martino, Mozambique Coast
(C. Haagner). This is a duet with a more complex time pattern. Bar length
l-5s (Thorpe & North 1965).
individual repertoire and to some extent also the individual voice quality
can be used as a means of individual recognition by the birds. The vocal
repertoire is worked out and developed between the two members of a
mated pair and isolated birds seem unable to produce any complexity
of vocalization patterns. Studies of captive birds have shown that the
422 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
crowding of the birds, particularly if they cannot see one another, leads
to great temporary elaboration of duet patterns ; and there is some
evidence that in crowded areas where territories are small, duet patterns
are more complex than in regions where the population is sparser.
The functions of antiphonal song in this species seem to be (1) location
and maintenance of contact with mate ; (2) mutual stimulation between
the two birds of a pair, as a part of, or substitute for the ordinary methods
of visual display ; (3) aggressive maintenance of territory and (4) mutual
reassurance after disturbance. During the course of this study on the
Kenya research areas we not infrequently encountered cases of
trio, singing and occasionally of quartet singing. Both of these may, I
think, result from aggressive encounters between mated pairs at terri-
torial boundaries and it seems likely that trio singing commonly takes
place between a mated pair and a well-grown young one. Figs. 2-8 show
a variety of characteristic duets made by three different subspecies of
Laniarius aethiopicus and Figs. 9 and 10 show two remarkable examples
Fig 9 ( a , b ). L . aethiopicus. Lake Bunyoni, Kabale, Uganda, 14 Feb.
1962 a represents a duet pattern heard as a very long, precisely timed
series During one considerable stretch of this series a third bird ‘z’
ioiiied in It was far away from the others but nevertheless inserted its
single note remarkably accurately, b, it tended to intervene in every
second duet of V and (Thorpe & North 1965).
Fig. 10. L. aethiopicus, Dundori, Nakuru, Kenya, 3 Apr. 1964.
A remarkable trio. All three birds were in the same tree. Note that bird
V gave a D sharp every 2 s and bird Y a D sharp every other 2 s whilst
bird ‘z’ gave a G sharp and an A natural every other 2 s in alternation
(Thorpe & North 1965).
of trio singing in the field. Vocalizations of this species were of course
studied by the usual methods of physical analysis using a sound spectro-
graph but since the notes of which the duets are composed are so pure and
precisely pitched ordinary musical notation gives a much better and
equally accurate picture of the songs than does the sound spectrograph
and is accordingly used here.
In addition to studies in the field on this species and others also
studied during a period of four years in large tropical aviaiies at
Madingley, Cambridge, England, this work confirmed the field obser-
vations that the birds have exact control of the timing, pitch and overall rate
BIRD VOCALIZATIONS
423
at which they produce their duets . The pitch control is certainly accurate
to a semitone and often consistent to a quarter-tone ; although whether
the Shrikes ‘ deliberately 5 control their pitch to this degree of fineness
is not absolutely clear. Work in aviaries and in some simple separation
experiments confirm the view arrived at from field work that one of the
major functions of the imitative ability of the birds is to establish and
strengthen the social bonds. It also suggests that social antiphonal
singing is in the nature of a mutual display which serves to maintain
cohesion and ensure recognition. The possibility that a duet phrase
could be used as a personal ‘ name ’ by one bird for another prompted
us to carry out separation experiments with paired birds. These con-
firmed the view that it is the male who normally initiates the duets and
when a duet is started by a female her note is usually an unmusical snarl.
This may be because the male usually hesitates about answering female
notes other than the snarl. It seems that new duets are particularly likely
to be initiated by the female if the response of the male is for any cause
unpredictable or illtimed. The results of these experiments can be
briefly summarized as follows : (1) separation leads to an increase in the
total vocalization of the bird left in the territory. (2) The bird moved to
a new territory tends to decrease its vocalization. (3) The bird remaining
in the territory, if it is a male, employs all its usual vocalizations and may
employ some of those of the missing partner in addition. (4) An isolated
male will answer a playback of his mate’s voice with the appropriate item
of his repertoire but he is much less likely to respond to a playback of
his own voice ; and if he does so at all it will only be with the item played.
(5) The female left in the aviary will answer those notes of her own male
which she may be able to hear, but will not answer the notes of any
neighbouring pairs. (6) A male kept in association with a duetting pair
was never heard to vocalize until the resident male was removed ; when
it became clear that he had, at least in part, learned his rival’s repertoire,
although he had never been heard to produce it before. The remaining
female would respond to this though she would not respond to strangers.
Thus the overall picture shows that these duet patterns are worked
out between members of a mated pair as soon as their formation is
established and that the repertoire of any one pair, while it will certainly
include a number of vocal patterns which are common to other pairs
in the district or other districts, is nevertheless sufficiently individual
to the pair concerned to render its recognition by voice alone quite simple.
Thus antiphonal singing seems to be fully explicable as a highly effective
method for maintaining contact between known individuals in an
environment of dense vegetation.
In conclusion it is illuminating to consider the situation amongst
the 40 species and 153 subspecies of the genus Cisticola (Grass warblers).
Out of this great assemblage the superspecies Cisticola hunteri , comprising
424 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
four species, contains the only ones for which there is as yet evid-
ence for antiphonal singing. It seems likely that these four, hunteri ,
chubbi, nigriloris and discolor are duettists, although there is no firm
evidence concerning the last of them. They are all birds of dense grass
vegetation above an altitude of 1500 metres ; ascending in one case to
over 4300 metres. The songs are normally a duet, presumably started
by the male ; but trio singing, quartet singing and elaborate communal
singing among pairs are well established in one species and probable
in the others. There is evidence for both individual and geographical
differentiation between song patterns and the accuracy of timing is on
occasion phenomenal. In one instance with Cisticola chubbi , the mean
Vertical scale : kilohertz
Horizontal scale : Time in seconds
Fig. 11. Traced sonograms showing only the musical tones in the duets
of Cisticola nigriloris and their transposition. S.a, S.b, S.c, and S.d are four duets
recorded from a single pair by Stjernstedt. a, b, c & d. Consistent pitch
patterning with transposition in the Mbeya Mountain pair (Thorpe 1972).
reaction time of approximately 400 millisecs was consistently maintained
to a standard deviation of around 3 millisecs : that is about 1/8 of the error
which a human being would show under similar circumstances (Thorpe
1963). The speed and precision of the response timing is almost as
impressive as this in some of the Shrikes including Laniarius aethiopicus
and particularly the superspecies Laniarius barbarus. L. barbarus and
L. erythrogaster have been particularly carefully studied in this respect,
BIRD VOCALIZATIONS
425
the second species by ourselves in tropical aviaries as well as in the field
(Thorpe 1972). But to return to Cisticola , while the function of multiple
singing is not understood there is good evidence that individual recogni-
tion can be based on vocal characteristics. It is suggested that at the
high altitudes in which these birds are found, persistence of dense mist
and cloud may well be responsible for the survival value of well deve-
loped vocal communications. Fig. 11 (Thorpe 1972) shows another
intriguing characteristic of the songs of Cisticola nigriloris where the
pitch patterning is highly precise but has, an unusual feature of bird
songs, a precise transposition in the middle of the song.
In conclusion it may be said that although a great deal has been
learned about antiphonal song in recent years it is clear that a vast
number of further examples wait to be elucidated and that they are most
likely to be found in inhabitants of tropical vegetation.
References
Beer, C. G. (1970) : Individual
recognition of voice in the social beha-
viour of birds. Advances in Study
Behav. 3 : 27-74.
Hinde, R. A. (1969). (Ed.) : Bird
Vocalizations. London : Cambridge
Univ. Press.
— (1972). (Ed.) : Non-verbal
Communication. London : Cambridge
Univ. Press. (See chaps. 2 & 4-6.)
Hooker, T. & Hooker, B. I. (Lade).
(1969) : Duetting. In Hinde, R. A.
(1969). (Ed.).
Hutchison, R. E., Stevenson, J. &
Thorpe, W. H. (1968) : The basis for
individual recognition by voice in the
Sandwich Tern {Sterna sandvicensis) .
Behaviour 32 : 150-157.
Marler, P. (1955) : Characteristics of
some animal calls. Nature, Lond. 176: 6-7.
Stevenson, J., Hutchison, R. E.,
Hutchison, J., Bertram, B. C. R. &
Thorpe, W. H. (1970) : Individual
recognition by auditory cues in the
Common Tern ( Sterna hirundo). Nature,
Lond . 226 : 562-563.
Thorpe, W. H. (1961) : Bird Song :
The Biology of Vocal Communication
and Expression in Birds. London, Cam-
bridge University Press.
Thorpe, W. H. (1963) : Antiphona
singing in birds as evidence for avian
auditory reaction time. Nature, Lond.
197: 774-776.
— (1968) : Perceptual bases for
group organization in social vertebrates.
Nature, Lond. 220 : 124-128.
— — (1972) : Duetting and anti-
phonal song in birds fits extent and signi-
ficance. Behaviour : Monograph Supple-
ment ^Ao. 18 : 1-197.
— — — & North, M. E. W. (1965) :
Origin and significance of the power of
vocal imitation with special reference to
the antiphonal singing of birds. Nature,
Lond. 208 : 219-222.
& _ (1966) : Vocal
imitation in the Tropical Bou-Bou Shrike
(Laniarius aethiopicus major ) as a means
of establishing and maintaining social
bonds. Ibis : 432-435.
Tschanz, B. (1968) : Trottellummen.
Z. Tierpsychol. 4.
White, S. J. (1971) : Selective res-
ponsiveness of the Gannet to played-back
calls. Anim. Behav. 19.
, White, R. E. C. & Thorpe,
W. H. (1970) : Acoustic basis for indi-
vidual recognition in the Gannet.
Nature, Lond. 225 : 1156-1158,
The Asian Honeyguides1
Herbert Friedmann* *
Our overall knowledge of the honeyguides has grown considerably since
my 1955 monograph, as is evidenced by the fact that we now recognize
17 species as against 11 at the time that publication was issued, by the
fact that we know more about the nature of wax digestion by some of
the African species, and by our considerable accumulation of additional
data on the choice and relative frequency of brood host selection by a
number of African honeyguides. However, this does not necessarily
mean that our information ab^ut the ethology of all the members of this
fascinating group of birds has advanced accordingly. The two Asian
species of the family, as well as many of the African ones, unfortunately
have remained quite unstudied in the field, and are still known primarily
as ‘ museum species ’ rather than as living organisms. I fully realize the
great difficulties involved in studying them in life, but I would like to
emphasize the importance, even the critical importance, of furthering and
deepening our knowledge and understanding of the two geographically
‘ remote * members of this remarkable, and otherwise African, avian
family. One cannot help but want to know more about the two species
of honeyguides found in Asia, so far from the rest of their relatives ; to
know whether they present similar or divergent ethological patterns ;
whether either or both of them show anything comparable to the so-
called 4 guiding behaviour ’ of the African greater honeyguide (very
inconclusive evidence seems to suggest they do not, but this is uncertain) ;
whether they are brood parasites (it would be most unlikely if they are
not, but this remains to be learned) ; whether either or both have mandi-
bular as well as maxillary egg teeth when hatched. Questions like these
are far easier to ask than to answer, but they are worth making the
necessary effort to solve. This paper will have served its purpose if it
may help to induce local observers in Asia to make special and con-
certed efforts to fill in any of these gaps in our knowledge of these birds.
When we consider the almost complete absence of biological infor-
mation still available about the two Asian honeyguides, the Himalayan
Indicator xanthonotus, and the Malayan Indicator archipelagicus , it is
surprising, indeed, it is historically ironical, that of all the species in the
family, it was one of these, the Himalayan honeyguide, that was actually
i Received March 1972.
* Dedicated to S&lim Ali, the foremost ornithologist of India, on the occasion of
his seventy-fifth birthday.
THE ASIAN HONEYGUIDES
427.
the very first one of the whole group to be written about, even though
the authors involved had never seen it, had no idea what it really looked
like, and were led to mention it only because they had heard of its cero-
phagous, or wax-eating, habit. This was more than seventeen centuries
ago, at a time when none of the African species were even known to what
we like to term ‘ civilized ’ man. This extremely early awareness of this
bird, the only member of its family to occur in India, has probably been
overlooked by most current naturalists, as its recounting is buried in my
monograph, referred to above. For this reason it may be well to state
again the original ‘ source material * of this precocious knowledge.
While assembling data for my 1955 book, I mentioned to my late
friend, Austin H. Clark, my disappointment in the lack of published
field notes on this honeyguide. At his suggestion, as a most unpromising
‘ last resource ’ measure, we decided to search in the libraries to see if,
by some remote chance, there might be anything on record about the use
of bees-wax in Asia that might yield any adventitious crumbs of infor-
mation about the only birds in that continent that share with man an
interest in this substance. We already knew that bees-wax was a prized
article of commerce in ancient times ; it was used for the treatment of
dysentery, for wounds and fractures. During the all too frequent recur-
rences of famine, men ate bees-wax and thought it helped to assuage their
hunger, and they added to this dubiously nutritious programme the
thought that by eating bee- comb they would also slow up the advent of
senility.
In this search we were fortunate beyond our expectations, and we did
find an old account that could only be connected with the Himalayan
honeyguide. Our clue to this early mention of the bird was found in
Read’s 1941 book on old Chinese materia medica. In the section on
bees-wax, therein classed as one of the ‘ insect drugs ’, Read wrote that
in the Po-wu-chih , a compendium of information of all sorts originally
amassed by Chang Hua in the Chin Dynasty, in the latter part of the third
century (of the Christian era) it was stated that the bees-wax from wild
bees’ nests was very much in demand and was highly prized in China at
that time, and that it came from the remote glens and solitary ridges of
the high mountains to the south, obviously the Himalayas. Chang
Hua’s manuscript account appears to have been gathered from the
reports of traders and travellers who informed him that the places where
the wild bees’ nests are found are all on steep cliffs which cannot be
scaled, and that to reach them in order to gather the wax as well as the
honey, people have to go to the tops of the mountains and then are
lowered over the precipices in baskets on long ropes. The important
point for our present interest is that Chang Hua goes on to state that
When the bees go away and leave the wax comb on the rocks, flocks of
sparrow-like birds called ling cITueh or tits, also called mi mu , blackish
42$ JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
in colour, come and peck it nearly all away. These birds are said to be
found 4 ... in the south, where in the first lunar month they go to
mountain cliffs to find a quiet place,’ and where there are bees. It appears,
from this account, that the local Chinese workers who were involved
as wax gatherers had to compete with these unknown, undescribed birds,
which were undoubtedly Himalayan honeyguides.
According to Wylie (1922) the Po-wu-chih was apparently lost during
the Sung period, and the work as we now know it was painstakingly
reassembled from bits and pieces of it that had been preserved in a
number of other Chinese compendia. The resulting reassemblage was
completed in the mid years of the twelfth century by Le Shih, in ten
books under the title Suh-po-wuh-che.
An earlier, great 80-volume encyclopedic treatise on all sorts of
information, the T’ai-ping-yu-lan, compiled by imperial command by
Li Fang and his staff, was completed in the year 983. In this work there
is a fuller version of Chang Hua’s account of seven centuries earlier,
kindly translated for me by the late Archibald G. Wenley, as follows :
It also says in many distant countries there are secluded places in the
mountain districts which produce beeswax. These bees wax places are all
abrupt cliffs and rock walls which are unclimbable, and only by raising baskets
to the top of the mountain and lowering them to the bottom is it obtained.
When the bees leave not to return, the surplus hives and wax are unlimited.
There is a small bird in shape as a sparrow. It comes in flocks of thousands
to peck at it. By spring it is all used up and the place is as if it had been
scrubbed and washed. In spring the bees all return to the clean place just as
before. Year by year it is like this without any confusion. People also
note these smooth places. They call them [the birds] wax honey birds, ;
and call them spiritual sparrows (because) they are entirely unable to
catch them .... It was added that in the spring the bees return and store
up honey as before, either in the surviving combs of the previous season Or
in newly constructed ones. The people protect these places, which they call
‘honey preserves’.
The Himalayan honeyguide is the only bird in the area known to eat
bee-comb, and there can be no question but that it is the same as the ‘wax-
honey bird ’ or ‘ spiritual sparrow ’ of Li Fang’s encyclopedia. The
large size of the flocks reported is undoubtedly an exaggeration, and is
an item that need not really bother us ; it is the kind of error that easily
could creep into a compiled work written by scholars who had no
personal experience with the actual situation in a very remote region, and
who, quite understandably. Were tempted to embellish their account
With such dramatic statements.
As I wrote in my 1955 book, ‘ . . . it follows that 1,700 years ago
the Chinese scholars had heard of the wax-eating habit of a bird they had
never seen for themselves, a bird that remained unknown to the Western
World for nearly 16 centuries longer, and of whose wax-eating habits we
have only become aware in the last few years. There is even a curious
THE ASIAN HONE YGU IDES 429
parallel between the old Chinese appellation ‘ spiritual sparrow ’ and
Hume’s subgeneric one, Pseudofringilla, proposed for this bird some
30 years after Blyth first made it known . . . ’ to science.
The first corroboration by a modern collector naturalist of the habits
of the Himalayan honeyguide was made in Garhwal in the 1940’s by
Walter Koelz, who kindly sent his notes to me for inclusion in my 1955
book. He noted that swarms of bees built their exposed combs on the
vertical surfaces of high cliffs. ‘. . . The honeyguides would perch in
the trees and then fly to the cliffs where they often clung like wood-
peckers and pecked at the wax. Sometimes they would be within a few
feet of the bees, of which they seemed wary and afraid .... Gizzards
of a dozen or so specimens collected all contained bees-wax . . . .’
That the bird is subject to seasonal wandering altitudinally, if not to
extensive geographic migration, in Nepal, was suggested by Ripley
(1950, p. 376), thus corroborating the ancient inference of seasonality
in the birds’ presence and activity around the 4 bee cliffs ’.
Alerted to the problem of the Himalayan honeyguide by earlier cor-
respondence, Fleming (1964, p. 523) made special inquiries about it
from his local assistants in Nepal. He found that in the spring of the year
the bees left their usual wintering areas to go to their ‘ hidden ravines ’
in the remote mountain gorges. At Bigu (6,000 feet) his head mantold
him, ‘ . . . . that his men went once a year to get honey from cliffs about
three miles away and that he would send his man the next day to show
us the place. Sagar Rana, of our party, found the location. When he
scrambled down to the overhanging cliff above a stream, he saw a bird,
apparently standing on its head, pecking at the remains of a bees’ comb.
It proved to be a honeyguide whose stomach was crammed with Wax.
‘ We visited the place again and waited for ten minutes but saw no
movement. Then Sagar made out a bird, like a small bar bet, sitting on
a dead branch about a foot or two from the face of the rock near where
bees were flying in and out. It was another honeyguide . . . .’
Fleming’s observations bear out the old Chinese account surprisingly
closely. Even his noting the bird feeding upside down confirms the
ancient parallel to a titmouse, which often feeds in this position. Fleming
wrote me at the time that all the ancient Chinese authors had reported
was quite in keeping with what he had seen.
The Himalayan honeyguide is known only from the highlands, at
elevations of from 5,000 to over 9,000 feet, from near the Afghanistan
border, east along the Himalayas across Garhwal, Nepal, Bhutan and
Nagaland to the Myitkyina District of northern Burma. It is the only
honeyguide to have such an exclusively altitudinal range, especially
now that the African Indicator pumilio has been found to descend from
its originally thought similarly high habitat to much lower altitudes.
The other Asian species, Indicator archipelagicus , is a lowland bird of a
430 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HISI. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (3)
distant region — Malaya, Siam, Borneo and Sumatra, at altitudes from
sea level to 3,000 feet. Obviously, the two never come in contact, and,
indeed, they seem less related to each other than each does to some of the
African species. This fact, in itself, adds much interest to them as
extreme examples of geographic isolates, and increases our desire to
know more about them as living entities.
The presence of a honeyguide {Indicator archipelagicus) in south-
eastern Asia presents no surprisingly different, or unique, zoogeographic
fact as there are numerous instances of faunal elements common to the
wooded areas of southern Asia and of Africa. But the presence of
another species {Indicator xanthonotus) in the Himalayan highlands has
no such parallel. Its existence there poses a puzzling problem, unfor-
tunately a problem to the answer of which we have no suggestive clues as
yet.
Our understanding, or, more accurately, our attempted interpre-
tation, of the phylogeny of the two Asian species is, of course, only
hypothetical, but there is no reason to change the diagram of their
relationships to the rest of the family proposed in my 1955 book (p. 10) ;
the Himalayan species seems more nearly related to the subgenus Melig-
nothes , the Malayan one to the subgenus Indicator. We have no way of
estimating even approximately how long they have been in existence*
One thing is clear about them ; their respective stocks have not
been involved in parallel speciation as has been the case in some of the
African honeyguides. This suggests (but does not prove) that in the
habitats of each of the two Asian species there was not ecological ‘ room *
for more than a single kind of honeyguide. It is not at all obvious why
this should be so, as in Africa we find numerous instances of sympatric
existence of two or more Indicator species of similar habits.
In a family noted for very limited phenotypic potential, the Himala-
yan honeyguide is an outstandingly aberrant development. In the course
of its existence it has become geographically differentiated into three
subspecies, whose distinguishing differences are only slight. The Mala-
yan honeyguide has no currently recognized races. It might be more
accurate to say that until sufficient specimen material of the latter from
various parts of its discontinuous, and, hence, suspiciously expedient,
range becomes available for study, this honeyguide has not been found
to be divisible into races, although attempts have been made in the past
to distinguish an island race and a mainland one.
The Himalayan Indicator xanthonotus is unique in its coloration,
being the only member of the entire family with patches of bright colour—
orange to orange-yellow on the lower back and rump, less intense but
still bright, orange yellow on the forehead and cheeks. The large bright
area on the lower back is, it is true, largely concealed by the folded
wings when the bird is at rest, but it must show up as a brilliant 4 sign *
THE ASIAN HONEY G U IDES
431
or ‘ beacon * when the bird takes flight again. One cannot help but
wonder what, if any, adaptive purpose this surprising colouristic signal
may serve. Because the bird is so aberrant in its appearance, it is intri-
guing to speculate whether or not it has, along with its odd coloration,
any as yet unsuspected ethological specialization. This is a question
that only prolonged and careful field observation can answer. Nothing
in the known habits of any of the plain-coloured African species gives
even the slightest suggestion as to what purpose such adaptation might
be directed. It is, of course, possible that it serves no purpose other
than as a communicating visual ‘ flash * to others of its own kind, or as a
colouristic ‘ lure which by its sudden disappearance when the bird
comes to rest, may serve to bewilder possible pursuing predators. The
orange rump patch of the Himalayan honeyguide may thus be compar-
able in its function to the red or yellow rumps of some of the small barbets
of the genus Pogoniulus , or to the white rump patch of the semiterrestrial
woodpecker, the flicker of North America, Colaptes auratus. The fact
remains, however, that so far we simply do not know, and it would be
most interesting to learn more about it. It is true that two other Spe-
cies of the same genus, Indicator indicator of Africa, and Indicator archi -
pelagicus of southeastern Asia, have a little band of yellow on the 4 shoul-
ders ’, i.e. on the lesser upper wing coverts, but this colour is not very
bright in hue, and is usually wholly or at least partly concealed in the
folded wing when the bird is at rest, and is hardly visible when in flight.
In its bill structure, rather small and decidedly stubby, the Himalayan
bird agrees most closely with some of the African small-billed species of
Indicator , the group formerly called the subgenus Melignothes , includ-
ing such drab, plain-coloured birds as minor , conirostris , exilis, pumilio ,
meliphilus , and narokensis, none of which flaunt even a trace of the
bright colours of xanthonotus. The Malayan honeyguide, Indicator
archipelagicus , on the other hand, has a larger bill, and agrees in this
respect with the African greater honeyguide, Indicator indicator , to the
female plumage of which it bears much resemblance. In its call notes
it appears, from descriptions, to be similar to the scaly- throated honey-
guide, Indicator variegatus , another similarly large-billed species. While
the Himalayan honeyguide is strikingly different in appearance from all
its relatives, the Malayan is not ; it is obviously a distinct species, but fits
very well into the overall picture of its subgenus.
We know, from stomach contents of individuals collected as speci-
mens, that both the Malayan and the Himalayan honeyguides regularly
consume quantities of bee-comb. We also know that the wax-breaking
bacterium, Micrococcus cerolyticus , that enables the African Indicator
minor and Indicator indicator to break down bees-wax and render it at
least partly digestible, also occurs in Borneo in the range of Indicator
archipelagicus. It seems safe to assume that this same microbe is involved
6
432 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
in the metabolism of bees-wax in this honeyguide as well. The Micro _
coccus is a soil bacterium that is absorbed together with soil-derived
nourishment into the roots of the plants and thence into their flowers,
where it is inadvertently acquired by the bees, which, in turn, equally
inadvertently, transfer it to their hives where the honeyguides get it
when eating the bee-comb. To date no one has made a search for this
microbe in the Himalayan habitat of Indicator xanthonotus. Conse-
quently we cannot say if it or another bacterium, ingested along with
the wild bee-comb into the alimentary tract of that bird, is similarly
operative in its nutritional metabolism.
Information about all parts of the life-history of each of the two
Asian honeyguides would be most welcome, not only for our knowledge
of these species but to help to complete and to formulate more meaning-
fully our concepts of the whole family. In the case of the Malayan
species there is little reason to expect anything very different from what
we know of some of the African Indicators , but in the case of the Himala-
yan one the unknown seems more intriguing because we do not know
what we may anticipate. The recent (1970) summary of the little that
we know of this bird, by Ali and Ripley, is a useful starting point for
further investigation. I know of no bird in the entire Indian fauna that
offers a more alluring prospect to the field student.
References
Ali, Salim & Ripley, S. Dillon (1970): completion date): T’ai-ping-yii-lan.
Handbook of the birds of India and The 1892 edition of the 1807 copy of the
Pakistan, vol. 4. Oxford University Sung wood-block edition, in 80 volumes,
Press. Bombay, London, New York, was consulted in the present connection
265 pp. by the late Archibald G. Wenley.
Fleming, Robert L. & Melvin A. Read, Bernard E. (1941) : Chinese
Traylor (1964) : Further notes on materia medica. Insect drugs. Natural
Nepal birds. Fieldiana, Zoology 35 (9) : History Bull. Peking, 213 pp.
495-558. Ripley, S. Dillon (1950) : Birds
Friedmann, Herbert (1955) : The from Nepal, 1947-1949. J. Bombay
honeyguides. U.S. National Museum nat. Hist. Soc. 49 : 355-417.
Bull. 208 : 292 pp. Wylie, Alexander (1922) : Notes on
Li Fang (a.d. 925-996) et al. (983 : Chinese literature. 307 pp.
Present distribution and population
status of the Great Bustard, Otis tarda
Linnaeus1
Yu. A. Isakov
Institute of Geography of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow
( With three maps)
In 1969 Dr Salim Ali drew attention to the rapid reduction in numbers
of the population of the Great Indian Bustard ( Choriotis nigriceps).
In his report made at the Xlth Technical Meeting of the International
Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources held in Delhi
he expressed his anxiety about the future of this valuable species. Salim
Ali is quite right in considering direct persecution by hunters and the
disappearance of its main habitats to be the main causes of the disastrous
reduction in the Indian Bustard population.
The report was quite a timely one, as there are reasons to be anxious
not only about the future of the Great Indian Bustard, but about the
future of many other species of European, Asian and African bustards
as well. In this connexion I should like to present some information
concerning the present distribution and numbers of the Euroasiatic
Great Bustard ( Otis tarda), whose population tends to decrease.
The bustard is a bird of open landscapes, mostly inhabiting steppe
and forest-steppe. In semi-desert bustards are found rather seldom,
and are not numerous there. One may suppose that the northern limit
of distribution of the European Bustard Otis tarda tarda Linnaeus lay
on the southern boundary of the forest zone in the pre-agricultural
period. In forest-steppe, strips of Bustard range protruded far to the
north, while in some patches of insular forest-steppe (e.g. in the Middle
Volga and in the Ural Foreland2 areas) it formed separate patches. Due
to forest felling and the extension of the areas under pasture, hay mea-
dows, and the plough, the bustard moved to the north into the forest
zone. Unfortunately, one cannot find in any publication exact data
concerning the time and rate of extension of the bustard’s range.
In Western and Central Europe this process seems to have taken place
somewhat earlier than in the European part of the USSR. In western
and central Europe forests had been cut and replaced by vast areas of
heathland as early as in the Middle Ages. According to Gesner’s
evidence (1555), in England bustards appeared in the 16th century, pro-
1 Received April 1973.
9 The Ural Foreland is the low-lying land (not foothills) west of the Urals,
434 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
bably due to the development of sheep breeding and the rapid extension
of pasture. In the German-Polish lowlands bustards appeared not later
than at the beginning of the 18th century, since as early as in 1751 they
were found throughout the Potsdam area, though they had not been
found there before (Schalow 1919). Probably at the same period the bus-
tard appeared in the Vistula regions of Poland (Linnaeus 1758), and then
in the adjoining areas of Byelorussia, around Grodno and Brest. In
the 18th century bustards inhabited the eastern part of the Baltic Hills,
including the Kaliningrad region (Tischler 1941), and then passed to the
southern, most densely populated part of Latvia (Fischer 1778). Through-
out the territory bustards inhabited mainly dry watersheds which had
previously been under mixed pine-broadleaved forests and where heath-
lands, which are very favourable for bustards, had appeared after felling.
In France, bustards Were breeding in Champagne at that time, in the
regions that had formerly been under broadleaved forest, predominantly
oak.
The end of the 1.8th century is considered to be the period of maxi-
mum extension of the range of the bustard in Europe and probably the
period when its population Was the highest. At that time bustards
inhabited many areas of the Russian Plain which had been under forest
not so long before. They had their breeding sites on the territories of
Minsk, Gomel, Chernigov, Bryansk and Orel regions, as well as in some
areas of Ryazan and Gorki regions, in the Chuvash and the Tatar Autono-
mous Republics and even in the western part of the Sverdlovsk region
(Kirikov 1959, 1966). It is interesting to note that the bustard area did
not extend behind the Urals in that period. In West Siberia bustards
never bred north of the forest-steppe zone, because farming only pene-
trated along the river valleys, and did not change the landscape funda-
mentally. In Eastern Asia bustards began to inhabit the forest zone
much later. In Map 1, the borders of the breeding area of the species
in the period of its maximum extension are outlined. The borders
cannot be assigned to any definite period, as the extension of the species
area in the east coincided with its reduction in the west.
The way in which the landscape was changed by man, causing an
increase in numbers and affecting the distribution of bustards, may be
illustrated by data concerning several areas of the Russian Plain situated
in different natural zones. It is seen from Table 1 that as early as in the
first half of the 18th century open landscapes occupied more than 50%
of the whole forest-steppe area. In the area of broadleaved and coni-
ferous and broadleaved forest such conditions were established only in
the middle of the 19th century (Tsvetkov 1957). The decrease of forest
areas and their replacement by agricultural lands appeared to be favour-
able for bustards. They began breeding in the fields, especially in those
which alternated with fallow lands and pastures.
Map 1. Distribution of the Great Bustard at the time of its maximal expansion
1. Exact boundaries ; 2. Approximate boundaries.
.So
Map 2. Past and present distribution of Otis tarda tarda in the USSR.
Area at time of maximal expansion. 3. Specific breeding areas.
Present distribution. 4. Isolated breeding areas.
DISTRIBUTION AND STATUS OF THE GREAT BUSTARD 435
Table 1
Land cultivation in the European part of the USSR in the 18th and 19th
CENTURIES (INCREASE IN THE PERCENTAGE OF AREA UNDER OPEN LANDSCAPES : ARABLE
LANDS, HAY MEADOWS, AND PASTURES)
In the second half of the 18th century the way in which the landscape
was changed by man was somewhat different. The expansion of the
area under arable land was followed by the reduction of the area under
natural and semi-natural grass communities, i.e. steppes and dry mea-
dows. This process was extremely intensive at the end of the 19th cen-
tury (Table 2), its consequences being unfavourable for bustards, espe-
cially in the period of reproduction.
Table 2
Change in the area under natural and seminatural steppe lands in the 18th
AND 19th CENTURIES (REDUCTION OF THE PERCENTAGE OF AREA UNDER PASTURES AND
HAY MEADOWS ON ACCOUNT OF INCREASE OF ARABLE LAND)
436 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Table 3
Historical changes in distribution of the European Great Bustard
{Otis tarda tarda L.) in various zonal landscapes in the USSR
Regions, Territories, Republics
.A 8.
g.o
o<+-
U ^
T3 O
G S-
xxx Breeding in large numbers
xx Breeding in small numbers every year
x Rare breeding pairs, not every year
- Disappeared in the 20th century
— Disappeared by the end of the 19th century
* Formerly Stalingrad, t Formerly Akmolinsk. $ Formerly Staling,
1
DISTRIBUTION AND STATUS OF THE GREAT BUSTARD 437
In the 19th century the numbers of bustards began to decline markedly.
In many localities the birds stopped breeding, and a number of territo-
ries, one after another, were excluded from their vast area. This happened
first in the areas where bustards had appeared comparatively recently,
i.e. within the forest zone. After 1838 they were not found in England
(Niethammer 1942), and shortly later in France either. In the sixties
bustards disappeared from the Kaliningrad region, and by the end of the
century from some other regions of the European part of the USSR
(Menzbier 1893). At present the range of this subspecies has greatly
decreased everywhere. The succession of its reduction within the USSR
is shown in Table 3. First (as early as in the 19th century) bustards
ceased breeding in the areas situated in the subzone of mixed forest,
then (at the beginning of the 20th century) in the subzone of broadleaved
forest. In forest-steppe they remained longer, but in the first half of the
20th century they disappeared from most of the forest-steppe areas too.
In mountain steppes there are almost no bustard either. Only in some
plain steppe areas do considerable numbers of bustard continue breeding.
In order to ascertain the present distribution and the numbers of
bustard in the USSR, a special inquiry Was conducted in 1971 in which
Republican and Regional Game Management Administrations, Hun-
ters’ Associations and ornithologists took part. The information obtain-
ed by means of the inquiry is summarized in Table 4. The accuracy of
some data is not very high and the indications of numbers should be
considered as approximate. Nevertheless, these data give us a clear
indication of the numbers and distribution of bustards in the USSR.
At present, the total number of breeding pairs of the European subspecies
on the territory of the USSR is between 2200 and 2300, and that of the
Eastern subspecies (according to much less accurate data) about 500
or 600 pairs (Table 5).
The bustard range does not make a solid unit now. Areas where the
birds are still breeding alternate with localities where they are not found
at all (Map 2). Within the USSR several geographical populations of
the European Bustard occupying isolated areas may be singled out
(Table 6). (<z) The Black Sea population whose main part inhabits the
Crimea and Odessa regions. The birds breeding in the Poltava region,
though their habitat is separated from the main area, also belong to
this population, (b) The Volga-Don population which is made up of the
birds breeding on the Middle and Lower Volga (Saratov and Volgograd
regions) and in the middle part of the Don (Voronezh and Rostov re-
gions). (c) Formerly the Caucasus Foreland population occupied a
big area and was rather numerous. Now it is represented only by small
groups of birds inhabiting rather small areas on this vast plain : the
lower reaches of the Kuban, the area of the Manych-Gudilo Lake, North
Caspian Lowland from Kalmykija to Daghestan and the Ergeny Hills,
438 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST, SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Table 4
Present distribution and numbers of O. t. tarda in the USSR
* The number of breeding couples given in brackets is defined approximately, by
calculation.
DISTRIBUTION AND STATUS OF THE GREAT BUSTARD 439
Table 5
Present distribution and numbers of O. t. dybowskii in the USSR
Table 6
Approximate numbers of the main geographical bustard-populations
in THE USSR (1971)
(d) The West Kazakhstan population which inhabits the Urals region
and the adjoining areas of Orenburg and Aktyubinsk regions. ( e ) The
Central Kazakhstan population occupies a vast territory from the Turgay
valley to the eastern borders of Kazakh small-hills area (i.e. 65°-70°E.).
Recently the density, as well as the total number, of this population has
declined. Its number is somewhat higher only in Karaganda region.
(/) The East Kazakhstan population inhabits the steppes of Semipalatinsk
region and the foothills of Tarbagatay and Dzungarsky Alatau.
440 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
The range of Eastern Bustard subspecies ( O . tarda dybowskii Tacza-
nowski) extends mainly outside the Soviet Union, in Mongolia and China.
It extends from the depression of Great Lakes in the west of Mongolia to
North Manchuria in the east (Kozlova 1930 ; Tugarinov 1929, 1932 ;
Bannikov & Skalon 1948 ; Cheng 1947). The landscapes of true steppes
( Aneurolepidium , feather-grass, and shrub steppes) prevail on this vast
territory, considerable areas being also under meadow and mountain
steppes. Within the USSR there are only some strips of the range of this
subspecies (Map 3). Therefore the name East Siberian Bustard, which
is sometimes used, is not a proper one. It would be more correct to call
it the East Asian or Central Asian Bustard.
The extreme western area of its distribution in the USSR is Tuva,
where bustard is breeding in the steppes of Ubsa Nor and Tuva depres-
sions. Not so long ago it was found in Minusinsk forest-steppe as well.
Farther to the east, bustard inhabits the steppe areas of the Selenga river
basin. From there it moves to the Vitim uplands,1 where it is breeding
in very small numbers in lake depressions (Arakhley and Eravnin lakes)
and in the meadows among larch taiga. At one time bustard was found
even farther to the north (in the valley of the Barguzin river and in Olkhon2
district, on the western coast of Lake Baikal ; now they are not found
there. Another bustard area in the USSR is Dauria.3 Meadow steppes
(. Aneurolepidium , tansy, and feather-grass ones) are typical for this area,
as they are for the Selenga lowland. The number of populations men-
tioned is not big (Table 5) and tends to be reduced. However our data
concern only a small portion of the Eastern subspecies area, so we cannot
make any conclusion about the total number of its population.
Not so long ago bustards were breeding in the USSR in two more
areas of the Far East : in the middle part of the Amur river, in the plain
between the mouth of the Zeya river and the mountain range Malyj
Khingan, and somewhat further south in the lowlands near Khanka
Lake (100 km north of Vladivostok). Both these regions are situated
in the area of oak-forests and are separated from the main bustard area
by a wide belt of broadleaved forests. Bustard could inhabit these areas
only after they had been deforested and cultivated, so that the boundaries
of the main area moved to the north and to the east. It should be men-
tioned that L. Schrenk (1861), who was travelling in the middle part of
the Amur in 1854-56, wrote in his account that no bustards were found
there. So it is clear that they colonized the Amur territory only at the
end of the 19th century. In the first half of the 20th century bustards
bred regularly in four districts of the Amur region (Barancheev 1954),
1 The Vitim river rises north of Chita and joins the Lena at Vitim city.
2 An island in Lake Baikal,
3 SE. Chita, . A \ .
Map 3. Distribution of Otis tarda dybowskii.
Present distribution. 2. Known breeding areas. 3. Isolated breeding areas. 4. Breeding regions at the
end of the 19th and beginning of the 20th century. 5. Main breeding area m Mongolia and China ; 6. Area
colonized only at the end of the 19th century.
i :
DISTRIBUTION AND STATUS OF THE GREAT BUSTARD 441
but in the last ten years there has been no reliable evidence about them
in this area, and they have not been found near Khanka Lake either.
The contraction of bustard area within the territory of the USSR
is indicative of its considerable decrease in numbers. It is difficult to
describe the extent of this process, as bustard population surveys have
been performed rather seldom, and have been carried out in different
regions and on different dates, so that the data are hardly comparable.
Thus, in August 1941, 18 bustards were found per 1000 1cm in Turgay
region, the registering being done from a car. Fifteen years later (1955-
57), only 5*5 birds per 1000 km on the average were found on the car
routes covering most of North Kazakhstan. - In Tselinograd region the
number was much higher. In May 1936, 16*7 bustards per 100 km
were found here, and in 1947, even 58 birds (Gavrin 1962). At present,
the total number of bustards in Tselinograd region probably does not
exceed 200 birds, in Turgay region 150 birds, and in Kustanay region
some dozens of birds. In North Kazakhstan region breeding bustards
have been registered only 3 or 4 times during the last eight years.
The data concerning bustard numbers in Central and Eastern Europe
are more definite (Table 7). One may suppose that the whole stock of
Baltic population (the GDR, Poland) does not much exceed 1000 birds,
that of the middle Danube population (Austria, Hungary, Czechoslova-
kia) about 3000 birds, and that of the lower Danube population (Ru-
mania) probably about 1500 birds. The number of Iberian, North
African and Near East populations is not known, but they are hardly
numerous, as bustards are rather sporadic there.
Table 7
* The indices of bustard numbers in Poland and in the GDR (1936 and 1939)
are brought to conformity with the present boundaries of these countries ,
t In 1967,
442 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Quantitative estimates of bustards conducted in the countries of
Central Europe show that during the 20 years since the late thirties, their
number was almost halved. During the following 10 years it was halved
again. The most complete data available concerns the GDR territory.
If we assume that the bustard population on this territory was 100 in
1900 then by 1939 it had decreased to 27, by 1961 to 17, and by 1971
to 7. Over the period of 70 years the bustard stock declined by 93 per
cent (Schiemenz 1972). This happened under conditions of well-orga-
nized protection of the species and in spite of measures intended to ensure
its preservation (special devices on farm machines to frighten away the
birds, artificial egg incubation, rearing young birds from abandoned
nests, etc.).
The main cause of the continual decline in the number of bustards
is the changing environment. It is well known that bustards do not
avoid agricultural lands and readily breed in the fields, but their success-
ful breeding there depends on the kind and dates of agricultural work.
With every year farming becomes more intensive, mechanization and
chemicals being applied more widely. Some fields are cultivated about
five times a year, and almost every time with machines. The net-
work of roads is growing, and the number of human settlements is increas-
ing too. These are factors which greatly disturb birds and cause, for
example, in the GDR, the loss of 80 to 90 per cent of bustard egg clutches
(Schiemenz 1972). The wide application of pesticides is an important
factor in the general decline of bustard numbers. Birds may perish
because of chemical poisoning, but to our mind the indirect effect of
pesticides on bustard population is of much greater importance. In
the bustard’s dietary, animal food plays a great role. For young birds,
which cannot yet shift far away from the hatching place, this food is of
the greatest importance, and is probably the reason why bustards often
make their nests in the steppe very close to underground anthills (Span-
genberg 1946). Investigations conducted by V. F. Ryabov & Z. Y. Iva-
nova (1971) in Kustanay region showed that animal food accounts for
96 per cent by weight in a young bustard’s diet and 38 per cent on the
average in that of adult birds. However, even for adults the share of
animal food reaches 80 per cent in late summer. With the present system
of field crop cultivation, arable lands are fused into big areas thoroughly
cleared of insects and rodents. Meadows and pastures occupy very
small areas. As a result bustards, and especially their young, are absolu-
tely deprived of the animal food they need.
For a long time both these factors interfering with bustard repro-
duction had only local effects, the bustards on the vast steppe territories
continuing their breeding. But then the situation changed. In Hun-
gary, Czechoslovakia, Poland, in the GDR, and later in the south of the
European part of the USSR, the areas of virgin lands disappeared and
DISTRIBUTION AND STATUS OF THE GREAT BUSTARD 443
those of dry meadows were minimized due to the indoor maintenance of
cattle. Sowing spring cereals instead of winter cereals was highly
unfavourable for bustards. In the late forties and early fifties, vast
areas of virgin and fallow lands were ploughed up in the steppes of West
Siberia and Kazakhstan. The economic development of these terri-
tories Was accompanied by the increase of populated areas and by the
construction of roads. In this area living conditions have become much
more difficult for bustards. The number of birds has markedly declined
and continues to decline, in spite of the fact that hunting has stopped
completely.
What can be done to stop this process and to prevent the danger of
complete disappearance of this valuable species ? The first requirement
is a complete ban on shooting or trapping bustard. However, as has
been said before, protection alone, even the most complete and active
protection, cannot increase the stock. To achieve that, it is necessary to
make long-term plans for the preservation of biotopes in which bustard
can successfully reproduce. Both natural (areas of virgin steppe) and
semi-natural biotopes of economic value (pastures, hay meadows, areas
under perennial fodder grasses, etc.) belong to this group. These lands
should be conserved not only to save bustard, but also to preserve a
large complex of steppe animals which are also threatened. Among
birds these are the Little Bustard1, the Demoiselle Crane2, the Sociable
Plover3, the Blackwinged Pratincole4, the Steppe Eagle5 and the Pallid
Harrier6, the Black Lark7, the Whitewinged Lark8 and others.
A few remaining areas of virgin steppes should become nature reserves.
Semi-natural steppe complexes with their plants and animals should also
be protected by the State, and a rational utilization regime established
for their preservation. The problem of what is in store for the steppe
animals is no less disturbing than the fate awaiting the inhabitants of
wetlands and marshes which are being protected in accordance with such
international projects as MAR9, AQUA10: and TELMA11. That is
why the elaboration of an international project for the conservation of
natural and semi-natural steppe ecosystems and of the animal species
inhabiting them, is an extremely urgent one.
1 Otis tetrax.
2 Anthropoides virgo.
3 Vanellus gregarius .
4 Glareola prat incola,
6 Aquila nipalensis.
6 Circus macrourus.
7 Melanocorypha yeltoniensis .
8 Melanocorypha leucoptera.
9 IUCN and UNESCO project for the conservation and management of
temperate marshes, bogs and other wetlands.
10 IUCN and UNESCO project for the conservation of aquatic habitats (lakes
and rivers).
11 IUCN and UNESCO project for the conservation of all actually or potentially
peat-forming ecosystems.
444 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
References
Ali, Salim. The Great Indian Bus-
tard Choriotis nigriceps (Vigors). Intern.
Union for Conserv. of Nature and Natu-
ral Resources. 10th General Assembly,
11th Technical Meeting, New Delhi,
India. Technical Papers. Third Session,
Survival Service Commission, 1969.
Almasan , H . & Popescu , C . Raspindirea
speciilor de vinat din R.P.R. Institutul de
cercetari forestiere. Bucuresti, vol.
XXIII- A, 1963.
Bannikov, A. G.& Skalon, V. N. Orni-
thological sketches on Mongolia. Okh-
rana Prirody, 5, 1948 (In Russian).
Barancheev, L. M. Game Birds of
Amur Region. 1954, Blagoveshensk (In
Russian).
Cheng Tso-Hsin. A distributional
list of Chinese Birds. I. Non-Passerifor-
mes. Trans. Chin. Assoc. Adv. Sci., 1947 .
Ferianc, O. Rozsirenie dropa velkeho
(Otis tarda L.) na Slovensku. Biologia ,
XVIII, 12, 1963, Bratislava.
Festetics, A. Das unbekannte Ver-
halten der Grosstrappe und die Griinde
ihres Aussterbens. Natur uhd Land ,
54, N6, 1968.
Fischer, J. L. Versuch einer Naturges-
chichte von Livland. Leipzig, 1778.
Fotor,T.,Nagy, L., & Sterbetz, I. A
tuzok. Mezogazdasagi Kiado, Budapest,
1971.
Gavrin, V. F. Order Otides. Ptitsy
Kazakhstana, v. 2, 1962, Alma-Ata (In
Russian).
Gell, P. Hunting economy of the
Socialistic Republic of Slovakia. Hunt-
ing and Hunting Economy , N3, 1973
(In Russian).
Gentz, K. Geschiitzte, jagdbare und
ungeschutzte Vogel. 6. Fortsetzung.
Falke, 8, N12, 1961.
Gesner, C. Historiae Animalium,
Liber III qui est de avium natura etc.
Tiguri, 1555.
Gewalt, W. Die Grosstrappe (Otis
tarda L.). Neue Brehm-Bucherei, H.
223, 1959, Leipzig.
Gewalt, W. Schutz und Hege der
Grosstrappe. Arbeitsgemeinschaft fur
Jagd- und Wildforschung. Deutsche Acad.
Landwirtschaftswissenschaft zu Berlin.
Merkblatt N8 (2 AufL), 1969.
Kirikov, S. V. Changes of fauna in
natural zones of the USSR (XVIII-XIX
centuries). Steppe and Forest-steppe.
AN USSR, 1959 (In Russian).
Kirikov, S. V. Game Animals, Natu-
ral Environment and Man. AN USSR,
1966 (In Russian).
Kozlova, E. V. Birds of South-West
Transbaikalia, North Mongolia and
Central Gobi. AN USSR, 1930, Lenin-
grad (In Russian).
Linnaeus, C. Systema Naturae, edit,
decima, 1758.
Menzbier, M. A. Birds of Russia,
vol. I, 1893, Moscow (In Russian).
Necas, J., & Hanzl, R. Rozsirenie a
bionomia dropa velkeho eurosibirskeho
Otis tarda tarda Linn. Sbornik Krajs-
keho muzea v Trnave, sv. 2, 1956.
Niethammer, G. Handbuch der Deut-
schen Vogelkunde, Bd. 3, 1942, Leipzig.
Radkiewicz, J. Drop w Polsce wspol-
czesnej. Chronmy Przy rode Ojczysta, 26,
2, Mar.-Apr., 1970.
Ryabov, V. F., & Ivanova, Z. Y. On
Bustard ecology in the North Kazakhstan.
Transact, of Moscow University, Biology.
5, 1971 (In Russian).
Schalow, H. Beitrage zum Vogel-
fauna der Mark Brandenburg. Deutsche
Ornith. Gesellschaft, 1919, Berlin.
Schiemenz, H. Die Situation der von
Aussterben bedrohten Vogel in der
DDR. Falke, 19, H 2, 1972.
Schrenk, L. Reisen und Vorschun-
gen im Amur-lande, in den Jahren 1854-
56. Bd. II, Vogel des Amurlandes.
1861, Spb.
Sokolowski, J. Drop (Otis tarda L.)
w Polsce . Ochrona Przyrody , N5 1 , 1 939,
Krakow.
Sokolowski, J. Ptaki ziem Polskich
t. II, 1958, Warszawa.
Spangenberg, E. P. Some ecological
factors of Bustard (Otis tarda L.) breed-
ing. Bull. Soc. naturalists of Moscow,
Sect. Biology, v. 51, NIJ946 (In Russian).
Tischler, F. Die Vogel Ostpreussens
und seiner Nachbargebiete. Bd. 2, 1941 ,
Konigsberg-Berlin .
Tsvetkov, M. A. Changes of wood-
lands in European Russia since the end
of the 17th century up to .1914. AN
USSR, 1957 (In Russian).
Tugarinov, A. Y. North Mongolia
and its Birds. Preliminary account of
Zoological Expedition to North Mongolia
for 1926. AN USSR, 1929 (In Russian).
Tugarinov, A. Y. Birds of East Mon-
golia according to observations of the
Expedition of 1928. AN USSR, 1932,
Leningrad (In Russian).
Problems resulting from the
discontinuous distribution of
Muscicapa latirostris Raffles1
Erwin and Vesta Stresemann
What directed our interest to Muscicapa latirostris was initially the
fact of its being a winter visitor in tropical South-East Asia, arriving
there from its Palaearctic breeding range in September or October after a
long journey and leaving again in April or early May. In this regard
the migratory movements of the species agree fairly well with those of
some other Palaearctic passerines like Lanius tigrinus , Lanius cristatus,
Pericrocotus divaricatus and Locustella certhiola , which all have recently
been shown by the present authors to have two complete moults, a post*
nuptial one on breeding grounds and a prenuptial one in their distant
winter quarters. This similarity of migration patterns induced us to
study the moult of Muscicapa latirostris in the hope to discover an addi-
tional case of ‘ two complete moults each year ’. But our expectation
did not come true.
Witherby (1938), who believed Muscicapa latirostris to nest in the
Palaearctic region only, published his opinion about the plumage changes
of this flycatcher as follows : ‘ Winter — This plumage is acquired by a
moult of the body feathers in July-August, but wings, wing-coverts and
tail are not moulted in autumn. Summer — From February to May a
complete moult takes place.’ This picture proved on examination to
be entirely wrong. In fact the species undergoes a complete postnuptial
moult on its Palaearctic breeding grounds in July/ August/September/ and
in winter quarters does not moult at all ! Young birds retain the first
generation of flight-feathers for about one year. Their partial moult
from the spotted nestling plumage to the adult dress begins probably, as
in Muscicapa striata (Heinroth 1926, p. 53), at the bird’s age of nearly
27 days and lasts about one month. Freshly moulted first-year birds
are distinguished from fully adults by pale-cinnamon tips of the greater
secondary coverts, retained from the nestling plumage. Thus our results
conform to those of Whistler’s (in Ali 1938, p. 299).
The postnuptial moult lasts about 60 days. In the sequence of
feather replacement this species agrees with Passer domesticus (Zeidler
1966). For details see the Appendix.
1 Received August 1972.
446 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Besides the highly migratory Northern populations there are smaller,
scattered populations and single pairs that nest in the tropics. Indivi-
duals remaining in the tropics all through the Northern summer have been
recorded from various countries, chiefly from India, but also from Malaya,
Thailand and Burma (Deignan 1957). The first author to prove nesting in
India seems to have been B. Shelley (1894), who recorded it in the Vindhya
Range near Mhow in June. His note has been quoted in full by Stuart
Baker (1906), who added a second case. Hartert (1910, p. 478) however
considered both instances doubtful and suspected a confusion with
Muscicapa sibirica fuliginosa ( =cacabata ). Even in 1934 he had not
changed his point of view, disbelieving in the many additional records
since published by Stuart Baker (1924, p. 249 and 1933, p. 216). His
negative attitude was not fully shared by Whistler (in Ali 1933, p. 388)
though he admitted : ‘ More information is needed about the breeding
of this flycatcher in India.’
Such additional information will soon be given in Vol. 7 of Ali’s
and Ripley’s monumental Handbook. Dr Dillon Ripley kindly sent
us in advance a photocopy of the text on Muscicapa latirostris. From
this one learns that the species is :
(a) a fairly common summer visitor to the foothills of the Himalayas
(b) a common breeder in the Vindhya Range (hills round Sehore
and Mhow)
(c) a scarce breeder in the southern parts of the Western Ghats,
probably also in the Eastern Ghats and in the Biligirirangan
Hills (Mysore).
The breeding population of India is migratory in the Himalayas and the
Vindhya Range, where it appears on its breeding grounds in April and
departs in September, while in the Ghats there is a resident population.
Muscicapa latirostris is a winter visitor to the foothills of Dehra Dun
from October to February. It also winters in Ceylon, where it is most
common from October to March (loc. cit.).
Since the highly migratory Palaearctic and the Indian populations
cannot be distinguished by colour or measurements (Vaurie 1954) it
remains uncertain to what extent Palaearctic immigrants invade Indian
territory in autumn to stay there for the winter. Ali & Ripley apparently
consider this influx to be negligible. They regard the main winter quar-
ters of the palaearctic population to be ‘South-east Asia, the Philippines
and Indonesia ’. But the species is almost unknown in the Philippines
and to South-east Asia should be added Burma, where it is very com-
mon after 24 September (Oates 1883) and whence numerous specimens
are likely to extend their migration into India.
What stimulated our interest in this species and its most unusual
distribution Was the question whether the two widely separated popula-
DISTRIBUTION OF MUSCICAPA LATIROSTRIS RAFFLES 447
tions, the Palaearctic and the Indian, agreed with regard to season of
moult. Considering the differences of day length, climatic factors and
length of migration, a notable difference in the timing of this cyclic
process could be expected.
To our surprise the difference proved to be trifling or even non-existent.
Due to the absence of migration and the continuous presence of
flying insects, breeding may start in the resident population of South India
as early as in April, while in North India it does not begin before May
(Ali & Ripley). In Japan, where this species arrives about 15 April,
the second half of May has been recorded as the starting-point for nidi-
fication (Jahn 1942).
Consequently, the complete postnuptial moult may begin in South
India at a somewhat earlier date than in the foothills of the Himalayas
and in Hondo (see the Appendix).
Muscicapa latirostris , known to be a widespread and locally common
breeding bird in India, has also been recorded in summer from several
localities in South-East Asia (Deignan 1957), but convincing proof of
its breeding there remains very scarce. Such proof exists for :
Southern Burma : Oates collected at Kyeik-Padein (near Pegu) an
adult on 21 July and a 4 quite young bird ’ on 30 July (Oates 1883, p. 277).
The adult specimen was considered by Deignan (1957) to belong to his
* new species ’ Muscicapa williamsoni (about which see Vaurie in Mayr
1971).
Thailand : Occasional nesting is testified by a skin in the Field Museum
of Natural History (Reg. No, 81181), collected 15 Aug. 1921 at Ban Hia
(13°30'N, 100°35'E), south of Bangkok, in the vicinity of Paknam, accord-
ing to M. Traylor (in litt .), who added : 4 The specimen is about 95 % in
first winter plumage, with scattered juvenal (=nestling) feathers on crown
and back. Below, the brownish breast band is noticeably streaked.
It fits very closely Deignan’s description of williamsoni , although I find it
hard to believe that there are two resident species, M. latirostris and
M. williamsoni , in Southern Asia.’
Western China : Muscicapa latirostris had generally been supposed
to occur in China on migration only. We were therefore much surprised
to learn that Dr George Watson, while perusing the material of the U.S.
.National Museum, had found 4 skins of this Flycatcher in primary
moult collected in the mountains of Yunnan and Szechuan by S. F. Rock
and David C. Graham respectively (see the Appendix).
Proof is lacking, though nesting has been suspected in :
Malaya : 4 It is possible that a few pairs remain throughout the year
and breed in the mountains ’ (Robinson 1928, p. 130). A skin from the
state of Selangor, dated 17 August, has been attributed by Deignan to
his ‘ species ’ williamsoni.
7
448 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 7l (3)
Ann am : ‘ Possibly there may be a resident form in the mountains of
South Annam’ (Riley 1938, p. 446, basing this remark on a specimen
collected there on 10 May 1918).
The extension of the breeding range of this migratory bird from the
temperate region of Japan, Eastern Siberia and neighbouring countries
(see Vaurie 1959) to the hills of India without appreciable effect on mor-
phology or physiology of the settlers may have been initiated by single
pairs which, instead of returning in spring, remained in winter quarters
for reproduction. Owing to some physiological preadaptation of the
species this may have been frequently repeated by single birds up to the
present time, since in autumn there is (probably) a constant influx of
Palaearctic migrants belonging to Muscicapa latirostris , and the ‘swamp-
ing effect ’ (Mayr 1942, pp. 244-5) prevents differentiation of populations
which remain isolated during the summer months only.
What may be the result if isolation is complete and lasts for a long
period is shown by Muscicapa {latirostris) segregata Siebers. This
resident species (or rather semispeeies) is confined to Sumba, one of the
Lesser Sunda Islands. It differs constantly from M. latirostris by longer
bill and wing shape (Siebers 1928 and Rensch 1931). The length of
primaries 8 and 9 (from within) is reduced relatively to primary 7, a
frequent difference between migratory and resident populations of the
same species (see Mayr 1963, p. 324 : ‘ wing rule ’)• The colour, however,
remained unchanged. Not so the season of breeding and, consequently,
of moult. Specimens in the Zoological Museum of Berlin prove a great
difference relative to Palaearctic and Indian birds, No. 30.1691 is in coim
plete nestling plumage on 25 March 19251, while two other young birds
(Nos. 30.1692 and 30.1693), dated 28 and 30 March respectively, have
already undergone the post-nestling moult, as shown by the cinnamon-
coloured tips of the greater secondary coverts which signify first-year
birds. This suggests the breeding of segregata about January or February
—probably in adaptation to the local annual rhythm of ample food supply.
Obviously M. segregata is a relic from a quaternary period when
Palaearctic migrants used to penetrate farther into the Malay Archipelago
than nowadays, even reaching Australia, as Botaurus stellar is, Fulica
atra , Porzana pusilla and Podiceps cristatus. Some of these migrants
settled there and became the ancestors of Australian subspecies (Strese-
mann 1939, p. 417).
Muscicapa segregata fits in this group of colonists. Its ancestor
M. latirostris does no longer reach the Island of Sumba in the migratory
period. In present times it goes no farther east than Java, and there is
no record known from the intervening islands of Bali, Lombok, Sum-
i According to Siebers (1928) and Rensch (1931, p. 379), Dr Dammerman in
addition collected two other skins in nestling plumage, dated 22 and 28 March 1925.
DISTRIBUTION OF MUSC1CAPA LATIROSTRIS RAFFLES 449
bawa and Flores. Thus the isolation of the Sumba population has long
since become perfect.
Acknowledgements
Our thanks are due to S. Dillon Ripley and George E. Watson for
important informations, to G. Diesselhorst (Munchen), R. Piechocki
(Halle a. S.) and to the authorities of the Bombay Natural History Society
for the loan of specimens in moult ; and to Melvin A. Traylor (Chicago)
for his untiring efforts to promote our studies.
Summary
Muscicapa latirostris moults the entire plumage on breeding territory.
The innermost primaries are replaced by new ones soon after (or even
before ?) the end of parental care. The birds nesting in India do not
differ appreciably from the highly migratory Palaearctic birds, either in
morphology and breeding season or in timing of moult. It is suggested
that this lack of differentiation may be due to the swamping effect which
results from incomplete isolation of the Indian population.
What may be the effect if isolation is complete is shown by Muscicapa
( latirostris ) segregata, a descendant of M. latirostris latirostris , confined
to the island of Sumba. It agrees with the latter in colour, but differs
by having a blunter wing-tip and by the season of reproduction and
moulting*
Refer
Ali, S. (1933) : The Hyderabad State
ornithological survey. Part I. /. Bombay
nat. Hist. Soc. 36 (2) : 357.
(1938) : The Ornithology
of Travancore and Cochin, ibid. 38:
299.
— — & Ripley, S. D. (1972):
Handbook of the Birds of India and
Pakistan, Vol. 7. Bombay.
Baker, E. C. Stuart (1906) : Notes
on the Nidification of Indian Birds.
Part II. Ibis : 257-285.
(1924) : The Fauna of British
India. Birds. Vol. II. Taylor & Francis,
London.
(1933) : The Nidification of
the Birds of the Indian Empire, Vol. II.
Taylor & Francis, London.
Deignan, H. G. (1957) : A new Fly-
catcher from South-eastern Asia with
remarks on Muscicapa latirostris Raffles.
Ibis 99 : 340-344.
NCES
Gizenko, A. I. (1955) : The birds of
Saghalin. Moscow (in Russian).
Hartert, E. (1910) : Die Vogel der
palaearktischen Fauna, Bd. J. R*
Friedlander & Sohn, Berlin.
& Steinbacher, F. (1934) :
Die Vogel der palaearktischen Fauna.
Erganzungsband, Heft 3. R. Fried-
lander & Sohn, Berlin.
Heinroth, O. & M. (1926) : Die
Vogel Mitteleuropas, Bd. I. Hugo Ber-
muhler, Berlin-Lichterfelde.
Jahn, H. (1942) : Zur Oekologie und
Biologie der Vogel Japans. Jourti. /.
Orn. 90: 1-301.
Mayr, E. (1942) : Systematics and
the Origin of Species. Colombia Uni-
versity Press, New York.
— — — - (1963) : Animal Species and
Evolution. Harvard University Press,
Cambridge, Mass.
(1971) : New Species of
450 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. U (3)
Birds described from 1956 to 1965.
Journ.f. Orn. 112 : 302-316.
Oates, E. W. (1883) : A Handbook to
the Birds of British Burmah. Vol. I.
Rangoon.
Rensch, B. (1931) : Uber einige
Vogelsammlungen des Buitenzorger
Museums von den Kleinen Sundainseln.
Treubia 13 : 371-400.
Riley, J. H. (1938) : Birds from Siam
and the Malay Peninsula. U.S. Nat.
Mm. Bull. 172. Washington.
Robinson, H. C. (1928) : The Birds of
the Malay Peninsula. Vol. II. H. F. &
G. Wither by. London.
Shelley, B. (1894) : Nesting of the
Brown Flycatcher. J. Bombay nat. Hist.
Soc . 9 : 223.
Siebers, H. C. (1928) : Neue Vogel
von Sumba. Treubia 10 : 399-404.
Stresemann, E. (1939) : Die Vogel
von Celebes, Teil I. Journ. f. Orn. 87.
Vaurie, Ch. (1954) : Systematic
Notes on Palaearctic Birds. No. 12 :
Muscicapinae, Hirundinidae and Sturni-
dae. Amer. Mus. Novit., No. 1694.
(1959) : The Birds of the
Palaearctic Fauna. Order Passeri-
formes. H. F. & G. Witherby. London.
Witherby, H., et al. (1938) : The
Handbook of British Birds, Vol. I.
H. F. & G. Witherby. London.
Zeidler, K. (1966) : Untersuch ungen
uber Fiugelbeflederung und Mauser des
Haussperlings. Jour. f. Orn. 107: 113-
53.
APPENDIX
Postnuptial moult (complete)
A. palaearctic region
1. 10 July 1956, $, Manchuria: Little. Khingan — Piechocki No. 37
Pr. 1 in sheath gr. 1 cm, 2 in sheath gr. 2 cm, rest old. Sec. tail, body old,
no moult.
2. 14 July 1956, $, Manchuria : Little Khingan — Piechocki No. 56
Pr. 1 and 2 in sheath, rest old. Sec. tail, body old, no moult.
3. 15 August 1900, Hokkaido : Nemuro — Miinchen No. A 692
Pr. 1 and 2 in sheath, 3 lacking, rest old. Sec. 8 lacking, rest old. Tail
old. Body many germs on throat and pteryla gastraei.
4. 15 August 1900, Hokkaido : Nemuro — Munchen No. A 682
Pr. 1 to 4 new, 5 almost full grown, 6 gr. 3/4, 7 in sheath 1 cm, 8 to 10 old.
Sec. 1 gr. 4/5, 2 in sheath 2 mm, 3 to 6 old, 7 gr. l/2j 8 new, 9 lacking. Tail
four rectrices gr., 5 and 6 old. Body moult almost completed, gr. feathers
only on head and throat.
5. 27 August 1900, Kurilas : Iturup— MGnchen No. A 695
Pr. 1 to 4 new, 5 almost full grown, 6 gr. 3/4, 7 gr. 1/3, 8 out, 9 and 10 old.
Sec. 1 and 2 gr. 3 to 6 old, 7 gr. 1/2, 8 and 9 new. Tail all rectr. gr. 2/3 to 1/2.
6. 10 September 1900, Kurilas : Iturup— Munchen No. A 697.
Pr. 1 to 6 new, 7 with rest of sheath, 8 gr. lacking 1 cm, 9 gr. 3/4, 10 gr.
Sec. 1 and 3 new, 4 gr. lacking 1 cm, 5 gr. 1/2 cm shorter than 4, 6 gr. 3 mm
shorter than 4, 7 to 9 new (7 with rest of sheath). Tail new. Body every-
where some gr. feathers, otherwise new.
B. WESTERN CHINA
All information communicated by Dr G. E. Watson
7. 28 June 1929, £, Szechuan : Mupin— Washington No. 313582— All feathers
old.
DISTRIBUTION OF MUSCICAPA LATIROSTRIS RAFFLES 451
8. 31 July 1928, $, Szechuan: Ningyen Fu 6000 ft. — Washington No. 310735
Pr. 1 new, 2 almost full gr., 3 gr. 3/4, 4 gr. 1/4, 5 to 10 old. Tail all old.
9. 22 Aug. 1923, $, Yunnan: Lichiang Plain 8200 ft. — Washington No. 296396
Pr. 1 to 7 new, 8 gr. 3/4, 9 gr. 1/2, 10 out. Tail all new.
C. INDIA
10. 20 July 1934, <?, Mysore : Biligirirangan Hills — Coll. Ripley No. 1833— Has
started primary moult.
11. 23 Aug. 1938, $, Indore St. : Bijwar 1450 ft. — Bombay No. 4156
Pr. 1 to 3 new, 4 and 5 still gr., 6 gr. 2/3, 7 pin 1 mm, 8 to 10 old. Sec. 1 still
gr.,2 gr. 1/3, 3 to 6 old, 7 gr. 2/3, 8 and 9 new. Tail 1 new, 2 to 6 gr. in centri-
fugal sequence (2 almost full-gr., 6 gr. 1/2). Body all feathers new or gr., still
many in pin.
12. 24 Aug. 1938, <J, Indore St. : Bijwar 1450 ft.— B.M. 1949. Whi. 1.10703
Pr. 1 to 5 new, 6 still gr., 7 gr. 3/4. 8 gr.1/2, 9 pin, 10 out. Sec. 1 and 2
new, 3 still gr., 4 gr. 2/3, 5 pin 1 cm, 6 pin 3/4 cm, 7 to 9 new. Tail 1 to 5
new, 6 still gr. Body moult completed.
13. 24 Aug. 1924, Baghat St. (NW Himalaya) : Koti 3500 ft.— Bombay
No. 16916
Pr. 1 to 5 new. 6 and 7 still gr., 8 gr. 3/4, 9 gr. 1/3, 10 old. Sec. 1 new, 2 still
gr., 3 gr. 1/2, 4 pin 1 cm, 5 and 6 old, 7 still gr., 8 and 9 new. Tail 1 to 3 new,
4 still gr., 5 gr. lacking 1 cm, 6 gr. 2/3. Body some feathers still gr.
14. 6 Sept. 1938, <J, Dhar St. : Gujri 750-1000 ft. — Bombay No. 4155
Pr. 1 to 6 new, 7 still gr., 8 gr. 1/2, 9 gr. 1/3, 10 out. Sec. 1 and 2 new, 3 gr.
1/2, 4 pin 1 1/2 cm, 5 pin 3 mm, 6 out, 7 to 9 new. Tail 1 to 5 new, 6 still
gr. Body moult completed.
Similitudes and differences of the
Indian and Indochinese avifaunas1
J. Delacour
The two great tropical peninsulas of Asia form two faunal subregions
of the Oriental Region. Both are sharply separated from the temperate
areas to the north, for the greatest part, by the highest mountains in the
world and, as can be expected, theii floras and faunas are closely related.
But India is connected in the west with Asia Minor and Arabia, two arid
countries, while Indochina is gradually linked to China in the north-east,
and to Malaya (and in the recent past to Borneo and Sumatra) in the
south, respectively moist- temperate and equatorial in climate. Also
it has many more local microregions, due to broken-up chains and plat-
eaux, and to large rivers, with specialized and often endemic populations.
The western part of the Indochinese Peninsula of course resembles
India more nearly, and, as it extends farther north, towards the Hima-
layas, the faunal changes are quite gradual in a number of cases.
The lower and more open parts of the whole Oriental Region, and also
the cultivated lands, are often inhabited by the same species, represented
by local but usually fairly similar subspecies. It is in the higher, forested
districts that the avifauna becomes more distinct, with many striking
forms usually confined to relatively small territories which constitute
special habitats.
To illustrate more strikingly the differences between the two subre-
gions, it is preferable to consider, on the one hand, continental India,
without Ceylon or other islands, and on the other, the eastern parts of
Indochina, made up of Vietnam (Tonkin, Annam and Cochin-China),
Cambodia and Laos, which used to form French Indochina. Being
situated at the extreme south-east of Asia, they possess a much richer
and more specialized fauna than the western parts, Thailand and Burma.
As also I have spent some twenty years exploring that country and study-
ing its bird life, 1 am more familiar with it.
It is not my intention, in a short note, to make a general survey of
the similitudes and differences of these avifaunas as a whole ; it would
fill volumes ! But I shall venture to show those existing in three families
which are particularly well represented in the Oriental Region, better
perhaps than in any other one : Phasianidae, Picidae and Corvidae.
It will offer a good sample of the general picture.
Received December 1971,
SIMILITUDES AND DIFFERENCES OF AVIFAUNAS
453
One has above all to remember that India is a much larger area than
eastern Indochina, so that the actual numbers of species found in each
of the two do not represent its real comparative wealth. The truth is
that, for areas of comparable size, Indochina is actually the richer of the
two.
Phasianidae
North-west India and the Himalayas have a large population of game
birds akin to the palearctic ones, none of which occur in Indochina.
Among the Phasianidae popularly known as ‘ partridges ’ without long
tails or bright colours, the following genera are represented in India*
but not in Indochina : Lerwa , Ammoperdix , Tetraogallus, Tetraophasis%
Alectoris, Perdix, Ophrysia. All are of palearctic or Himalayan origin.
Two other genera, confined to the warmer parts of India, are not
represented in Indochina : Perdicula , Galloperdix. There are five spe-
cies of Francolinus in India : francolinus , pictus , pondicerianus , gularis,
pintadeanus. The last named is the only species to reach Indochina and
to extend to southern China. It can be noted here that the centre of
distribution of Francolinus is Africa. Of the three species of Indian
quails, Coturnix coromandelica is endemic, while the migrant C. coturnix
and the resident C. chinensis are also found in Indochina.
Bambusicola fytchii lives in the north of both subregions, and there
are only four species of the forest partridges ( Arborophila ) in India :
atrogularis, mandellii, torquata and rufogularis. The last two, as slightly
different subspecies, also inhabit Indochina, where four more species
are found : brunneopectus, cambodiana , davidi , chloropus.
Among the genera accepted as ‘ pheasants ’, Ithaginis, Lophophorus ,
Pucrasia , Crossoptilon, Catreus, Syrmaticus do not enter French Indochina
although some reach northern Burma. Tragopan has four species in
India : melanocephalus, satyr a, blythii and temminckii, the last of which
only is found also in north-west Tonkin, at high altitudes. The palearctic
Phasianus colchicus , however, is found in northern Indochina, close to
China.
India has but one polymorphic species of Lophura ( leucomelana )
while eastern Indochina is the home of four: nycthemera (with many
subspecies), imperialism edwardsi and diardi. It also possesses the Crested
Argus ( Rheinartia ) and two Peacock Pheasants : Polyplectron germaini
and P. bicalcaratum, the latter also found in northern India.
The Red Junglefowl ( Gallus gallus) is common to both subregions,
but G. sonneratii is peculiar to western and southern India.
The Indian Peafowl {Pavo cristatus) of India is replaced in Indochina
by the Green (P. muticus).
454 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
PlCIDAE
Woodpeckers are particularly numerous in the Oriental Region ;
there are no fewer than 32 species in India and 2 in Indochina, many of
them inhabiting the same territory, where they are common.
India has in the north-west representatives of one palearctic species,
Picoides tridactylus, while another one, Picoides major , is found in both
peninsulas. Another Picus ( squamatus ) and four Picoides ( himalayensis ,
assimilis , auriceps and nanus ; the last is merged by some authors into
P. canicapillus of northern Indochina) are proper to India, as are Dino-
pium benghalense , D. shorii and Chrysocolaptes festivus.
Indochina has of its own Picus vittatus, P. erythropygius , P. rabieri
and Meiglyptes jugularis.
The following are common to both subregions, with sometimes very
well characterized subspecies : Jynx torquilla, Picumnus innominatus ,
Sasia ochracea , Micropternus brachyurus, Picus cams , P. myrmecophoneus,
P. flavinucha , P. chlorolophus , Dinopium javanense , Chrysocolaptes
lucidus, Gecinulus grantia , Mulleripicus pulverulentus , Dryocopus javensis ,
Hypopicus hyperythrus , Picoides darjellensis , P. cathpharius , P. maceU
P. atratus , P. mahrattensis , P. canicapillus , Hemicircus canente , Blythipicus
pyrrhotis.
Corvidae
Crows, Magpies and Jays are represented by many species in the
Oriental Region, much more numerous there than in any other part of
the world : 22 in India and 15 in eastern Indochina. Only 10 are com-
mon to both.
A number of palearctic and Himalayan species are found only in
India : Corvus corax , C.frugilegus , C. monedula,Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax,
P. graculus , Podoces humilis , Nucifraga caryocatactes, while a few only
extend farther east : Corvus corone , Pica pica , Garrulus glandarius.
Indochina alone has Corvus torquatus (also found in China).
Of the tropical forms, India alone possesses three : Corvus splendens,
Dendrocitta leucogastra , Garrulus lanceolatus, while Indochina is inhabited
by four birds, two extending to China or Malaysia : Cissa whiteheadi
(also found in Hainan), C. thalassina, Crypsirina temia , C. temnura (also
in Hainan).
The following species are common to both subregions : Corvus macror
rhynchos , Cissa erythrorhyncha , C. flavirostris , C. chinensis , Dendrocitta
vagabunda , Z>. formosae , Z>. frontalis.
As is shown by the above examples, the repartition of species varies
somewhat in the Oriental Region, their distribution being affected by
the greater or lesser abilities to travel of the birds of different families
SIMILITUDES AND DIFFERENCES OF AVIFAUNAS
455
But the general pattern is fairly constant. It is clear that the birds of
both subregions are closely related.
When I started exploring Indochina in 1923, it was not always easy
to identify specimens in the field, as there was no practical handbook
at hand ; only publications on particular areas, such as Tirant’s Les
oiseaux de la Basse-Cochinchine, and various reports by Oustalet. We
often had to use books on Indian and Burmese birds such as those of
Oates and Blanford, and later of Stuart Baker. They proved very
useful. Much more is known at present on the birds of the Oriental
Region. Among the ornithologists most responsible for such progress
is Salim Ali. I am delighted to dedicate to him this small contribution.
As I write it, the memory of many happy days in India and in Indochina
come back to me, and I cannot but congratulate myself for the luck I
had in being able to explore and to study the incomparable fauna of
Indochina when conditions there allowed researches to be carried out
in safety and relative comfort. I only hope that such favourable condi-
tions will before too long prevail in that marvellous country.
Zoological results of the Daily Mail
Himalayan Expedition 1954: notes on
some birds of Eastern Nepal1
Biswamoy Biswas
Zoological Survey of India , Indian Museum, Calcutta
Introduction
During my stay in Nepal as a member of the Daily Mail Himalayan
Expedition 1954, mainly in search of the abominable snowman (=yeti),
I made a small collection of, and observations on, birds as and when
opportunities were available. The area covered extended from Kath-
mandu east to extreme eastern Nepal (Nepal-West Bengal frontier),
and the period, between the last week of January and first week of July
1954. From mid-February to the end of May, however, I worked in
Khumbu, in the vicinity of Mount Everest, within the altitudinal range
of approximately 3800 to 6000 metres, where most of the specimens
were collected. Except in Khumbu and in one or two other areas of
collection, observations were made on birds seen mainly along the tracks.
Ornithology of eastern Nepal is not well covered in scientific literature.
A few ornithological reports, such as those of Gray (1863) on Hodgson’s
collection, Stevens (1923-1925), Ripley (1950), Rand & Fleming (1957),
Biswas (1960-1964, 1969), Fleming & Traylor (1961, 1964, 1968), and
Fleming (1968) covered parts of eastern Nepal. The most comprehen-
sive account of birds of the high-altitude areas of Khumbu has, however,
been given by Diesselhorst (1968).
In the following pages, notes on the birds collected and/or observed
by the writer in Nepal east of Kathmandu are presented. The number
of species and subspecies involved is 133, of which 67 are represented
in the collection by 197 specimens.
In the list that follows, forms whose representatives were not collected
have been indicated by asterisks preceding their names which are mostly
binomial, except where I was reasonably sure of their subspecific identity.
Ecological notes covering many of the collecting localities have al-
ready been given in an earlier paper (Biswas & Khajuria 1957), but
those that have not been included there are given hereunder.
1 Received January 1973.
457
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
Bung (c. 27°31'N, 86°50;E): This is a large village situated in Okhal-
dhunga district on the right bank of Hongu Khola and one of its tribu-
taries . It has extensive cultivation on the lower slopes, but higher up
there is a good forest of rhododendrons, fir, magnolias, etc. Collec-
tions were made in the forest at about 2740 m altitude.
Chainpur (c. 1525 m ; 27°18'N, 87°20'E) : Situated on the ridge
between Hinwan and Pilua Kholas (both tributaries of the Arun river)
in the Arun watershed, Chainpur is a fairly large village of Dhankuta
district. The slopes are extensively cultivated and the terraced fields
are dotted with clumps of large trees ; patches of forest here and there
break the monotony of the sloping landscape.
Dingboche ( c . 4400 m ; 27°54'N, 86°57'E) : It is a small summer
village situated on a wide slope on the right bank of Imja Khola. It
has about a dozen or so stone huts and small patches of cultivation where
potatoes and kuru (a kind of barley) are grown. Alpine scrub and grass
form the main natural vegetation of the area.
Gnachu (c. 4800 m ; 27°50'N, 86°36'E): Another small summer
village used by graziers and situated off the left edge of the Thami glacier.
The vegetation of Gnachu consists mostly of dwarf rhododendrons and
junipers, grass and other alpine scrub.
[Below] Khumjung ( c . 3810 m ; 27°49'N, 86°44'E) : A small patch
of forest consisting chiefly of fir, birch and rhododendrons. A narrow
footpath from the Namche Bazar-Thyangboche trail passes through this
forest.
Longbonga Lake ( c . 4500 m ; 27°56'N, 86°43'E) : This is the lower-
most in the chain of lakes on the upper reaches of the Dudh Kosi river,
in the western ablation valley of the Ngojumba glacier. It looks as if the
narrow, trickling Dudh Kosi has expanded here into an irregularly trian-
gular lake, the basal side of which is bounded by a steep mountainous
wall that separates this valley from that of the Bhote Kosi. The eastern
shore of the lake is a small, narrow, flat land covered with dwarf rhodo-
dendrons and other alpine scrub.
Pankhoma ( c . 3050 m ; 27°35'N, 86°45'E) : Situated near the crest
of a ridge between the Dudh Kosi river and Inukhu Khola in Okhal-
dhunga district. The area is heavily forested.
Phurte ( c . 3900 m ; 27°49'N, 86°42'E) : A small village situated
on the left bank of the Bhote Kosi river, a little to the west of Namche
Bazar. There are a few small plots of cultivation and forests of junipers,
rhododendrons, birch, etc. around.
Tesinga ( c . 3610 m ; 27°50'N, 86°44'E) : A small village situated on
the right bank of the Dudh Kosi river, almost across from the Base
Camp. A little hill stream trickles through the wide cultivated area.
There are not many trees around, there being only a few fir, birch and
458 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
rhododendrons, and some scrub lining the Namche Bazar-Thyangboche
track which passes a little below the village.
Thammu ( c . 4150 m ; 27°49'N, 86°41'E) : A small village located
on the left bank of the Bhote Kosi river, further to the west of Phurte,
to which it is very similar ecologically.
Thonak Lake (c. 5000 m ; 28°59'N, 86°41'E) : A glacier lake situated
about 2 km north of Gokyo (Dudh Pokhari) in the western ablation
valley of the Ngojumba glacier. It is bounded on the west, north and
north-east by mountainous walls, and on the east and south there are
moraines. Except for a little dwarf alpine scrub and grass on the moraines
there is no prominent vegetation around.
Thyangbo ( c . 4680 m) : A few stone huts with small plots of cultiva-
tion here and there, and some alpine scrub and grass, adorn this small
summer village located in the Thami Valley a little to the east of
Gnachu.
Toujung Lake (c. 4800 m ; 27°57'N, 86°43' E) : It is a small, irregu-
larly triangular lake on the Dudh Kosi river, lying between Dudh
Pokhari and the Longbonga Lake. There is very little vegetation in
this area except some scrub and grass on the lateral moraine of the
Ngojumba glacier.
The altitudes given for some of the collecting localities by Biswas &
Khajuria (1957) are wrong. Their correct altitudinal figures and their
geographical locations are given below :
Base Camp : c. 3800 m ; 27°49'N, 86°45'E.
Chugima : c. 4850 m ; 27°56'N, 86°44'E.
Ghat : c. 2750 m ; 27°43'N, 86°43'E.
Gokyo (Dudh Pokhari) : c. 4900 m ; 28°1/N, 86°43'E.
Hunko : c. 4050 m ; 27°50'N, 86°40'E.
Marlung : c. 4700 m ; 27°53'N, 86°39'E. (Across Bhote Kosi river from Mar-
lung : c. 4800 m).
Nah ( = Nang) : c. 4400 m ; 27°55'N, 86°43'E.
Namche Bazar : c. 3800 m ; 27°49'N, 86®43'E.
Pangboche : c. 4600 m ; 27°51'N, 86°47'E.
Pare : c. 3900-4000 m ; 27°49'N, 86°40'E.
Phakding : c. 3000 m ; 27°44'N, 86°43'E.
Phalong Karpo : c. 4570 m ; 27°55,N, 86°49'E.
Pheriche : c. 4300 m ; 27°54'N, 86°49'E.
Phorcha : c. 3960 m ; 27°51'N, 86°45'E.
Tarangan : c. 4200 m ; 27052'N, 86°38'E.
Thami : c. 4400 m ; 27°49,N, 86°39/E.
Thugla : c. 4700 m ; 27°56'N, 86°49'E.
Yaral : c. 3900 m ; 27°51'N, 86°48'E.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
459
In the following pages the measurements of the birds are given in
millimetres, and the unsexed specimens indicated by a dash ‘ — \
Sex determined from plumage and not from examination of gonad is
indicated in parentheses, (c?) or (£).
Order Falconiformes
v
Family Accipitridae
#Elanus caeruleus (Desfontaines) : Blackwinged Kite
A single example of the Blackwinged Kite was observed near Kiranti-
chhap, at about 1500 m (c. 27°38'N, 86°4'E), Charnawati Valley,
Ramechhap district, in the afternoon of 31 January. It was quietly
perching on a tree overlooking a cultivated field.
Milvus migrans govinda Sykes : Pariah Kite
Dhankuta district : Chainpur : 1 — (16 June).
Measurements : 1— : Wing 465, tail 203, bill 40.
Colours of bare parts: Iris dark brown, bill black, cere and gape pale wax
yellow, legs and feet wax yellow, claws black.
The Pariah Kite was found up to about 1525 m in eastern Nepal
occurring in and about villages.
Milvus (migrans) lineatus (J. E. Gray) : Large Indian Kite
Khumbu : Imja Valley : Yaral : 1 $ (29 April).
Measurements : : Wing 509, tail 305, bill 4P5.
Colours of bare parts: Iris dark brown, cere dull greenish white, bill black*
legs and feet pale greenish yellow, daws black.
The Large Indian Kite did not appear to be uncommon in eastern
Nepal between c. 2100 and 3500 m. Below and above this altitudinal
range, it appeared scarce. The highest place where it was observed was
Dudh Pokhari (c. 4900 m), where a single example flew up along the
Dudh Kosi river on 14 May at about midday. It soared over the area,
alighted on a boulder on the shore of the lake, stopped there for a few
minutes, and then flew down along the valley. Besides, stray specimens
were observed occasionally at c. 3800-4000 m during the spring.
#Haliastur indus (Boddaert) : Brahminy Kite
A few examples of the Brahminy Kite were seen in the Pilua Khola
valley, about 10 km east of Chainpur at about 1370 m in late June.
460 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. li (3)
Accipiter nisus melaschistos Hume : Indian Sparrow-Hawk
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Hunko : 1 $ (17 March) ; Lobujya Valley;
Phalong Karpo : \$ (23 April).
Colours of bare parts : Iris golden yellow, cere lemon yellow, bill bluish slaty with
black on tip (black more extensive in male), legs and feet chrome yellow, claws black.
The Sparrow-Hawk did not appear to be particularly common in
eastern Nepal. Examples were sporadically seen at altitudes ranging
between c. 3000 and 4570 m in spring.
My male specimen from Phalong Karpo is doubtfully placed under
this subspecies. It is not in full adult plumage and is somewhat Worn.
It is a shade paler than the other examples of melaschistos I have examin-
ed, but not quite as pale as nisosimilis. Dr Charles Vaurie, Who examin-
ed the specimen, writes (in litt.) ‘ that nisosimilis is not a very good race ’
as out of the hundreds that he has seen 4 about 40 per cent . . . are not
Separable from nominate nisus ’. He concludes that my specimen * is
either A. nisus melaschistos or A. n. nisosimilis ’.
*Aquila chrysaetos (Linnaeus): Golden Eagle
The Golden Eagle was sighted only on a few occasions in eastern
Nepal between c. 1830 and 3050 m in January-February.
*Ictinaetus malayensis (Temminck) : Black Eagle
The Black Eagle was seen by me twice between Dolalghat and Risingo,
central Nepal, at c. 850-1520 m late in January, and once in the Pilua
Khola valley, about 12 km east of Chainpur, at c. 1400 m on 26 June.
*Icthyophaga nana (Blyth): Greyheaded Fishing Eagle
The Greyheaded Fishing Eagle was seen by me once at Dolalghat
(c. 850 m) on the Sun Kosi river, central Nepal, on 27 January ; and
thrice in Khumbu, eastern Nepal, twice below the Base Camp on the
Dudh Kosi river, at about 3500 m between 4 and 8 May, and once a
single bird flying down along the Dudh Kosi river between Karnassa
and Nah at about 4250 m on 10 May.
The species does not seem to have so far been reported from as high
an altitude as 3500 m.
#Torgos calvus (Scopoli): Black Vulture
In eastern Nepal, the Black Vulture was observed by me once between
Those and Chyangma at about 2130 m in the Khimti Khola valley,
Ramechhap district, on 4 February, and a few times between Khote and
Chainpur (c. 610-1600 m), Dhankuta district, between 13 and 25 June
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
461
*Gyps himalayensis Hume : Himalayan Griffon
The Himalayan Griffon appeared rather scarce in Khumbu. I
saw it only on a few occasions around Namche Bazar, Base Camp and
Thyangboche between 3800 and 4000 m in mid-February.
[ Gypaetus barbatus aureus (Hablizl) : Himalayan Lammergeier
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Pare : 1— (2 April).
Measurements : 1 — : Wing 827, tail 512, bill 87.
The Lammergeier or the Bearded Vulture was occasionally met with
by us from c. 1830 to 5480 m and above in eastern Nepal. In Khumbu
it was regularly seen almost every day, but there appeared to be only a
few individuals there. It used to soar up and down along the various
rivers, frequently crossing high ridges to get into the adjacent valleys.
It was seen soaring above the Khumbu glacier, Gokyo and Thonak,
Ngojumba glacier, as well as passing down along the Dudh Kosi river
below Namche Bazar.
On 4 February a nest of this bird was found in a small cave on the
cliff-face overlooking Those-Chyangma path at about 2135 m. The
incubating parent bird was chased away and the single egg which formed
the clutch was collected by a member of the expedition. Later, on 18
April, an aerie of the Lammergeier was found a little to the northwest
of Pangboche in a cave high up on a sheer cliff-face at about 4700 metres
on Taweche ridge. The cliff-face below the mouth of the aerie was marked
with long white streaks of droppings. During mid- April and early May,
the Lammergeier was occasionally seen to enter into and leave the aerie.
*Falco tinnunculus Linnaeus : Kestrel
The Kestrel was occasionally seen by us in and around the cultivated
fields near Chainpur in June.
Order Ciconiiformes
Family Ciconiidae
*Leptoptilos dubius (Gmelin) : Adjutant
A pair Was seen flying near Chainpur in the morning of 16 Junes
Order Anseriformes
Family Anatidae
#Anser indicus (Latham): Barheaded Goose
On 5 April at about 12.15 hours We noticed from the Ease Camp a
flock of the Barheaded Goose flying from south to north over the Dudh
Kosi river. The passage appeared smooth till the flock reached the
462 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
confluence of the Imja Khola with the Dudh Kosi, where the birds seem-
ed hesitant for a short while. Circling over the confluence for a few
minutes the flock flew upwards above the Phorcha and Thyangboche
buttresses, and changing course northwestward, disappeared into the
mist along the Dudh Kosi valley which it apparently took.
Tadorna ferruginea (Pallas) : Ruddy Sheld-duck or Brahminy Duck
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Toujung Lake : 1 $ (15 May); Longbonga
Lake : 1 (<£) (15 May).
Measurements : 2 : Wing 378, 385 ; tail 135, 138 ; culmen 43’5, 46.
The Brahminy Duck was found in small numbers on the three lower-
most lakes on the upper reaches of the Dudh Kosi, namely, Longbonga,
Toujung and Dudh Pokhari ( c . 4700-4900 m) between late February and
mid-May.
The Toujung specimen had much enlarged testes. Obviously, the
birds were getting ready to breed and preparing to leave for their breed-
ing grounds, unless they bred locally.
Anas penelope Linnaeus: Wigeon
Khumbu: Dudh Kosi Valley: Longbonga Lake: 2 <2 (11 May).
Measurements : 2&\ Wing 240+, 255 + + ; tail 95, 102 ; bill 40, 42 ; culmen
33(2).
The Wigeon was observed in small numbers on the Longbonga Lake
and Dudh Pokhari only in May. Furthermore, on 5 April at about 11
hours, a single male specimen of what appeared to be a Wigeon was seen
from the Base Camp flying back and forth along the Dudh Kosi river
between its confluence with the Imja Khola and a kilometre or so to the
south. It looked as if the bird had lost its way and was trying to get its
bearings. After two or three sorties north and south, it finally made off
towards the south and Was not seen to come back.
Both my specimens had enlarged gonads.
The primaries are worn in both the specimens, more so in one of
them. In that specimen the tail is in moult — the two central pairs of
rectrices are fresh, while the other tail-feathers are very worn.
The two Khumbu specimens differ somewhat in the details of colora-
tion. Thus, one of them has the head, neck, chin and throat slightly
paler than those of the other specimen. Also, it has very few black
spots on the lores and the sides of the head, and it lacks the blackish
vermiculations on the upper breast, which are conspicuous in the other
specimen. This latter bird has the buff on the forehead and crown very
much paler than in the other bird— almost of cream colour.
Aythya fuligula (Linnaeus): Tufted Duck
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Longbonga Lake : 1 <J (11 May).
Measurements : 1 $ : Wing 198+, tail 55, bill 48, culmen 41.
463
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
Colours of bare parts : Iris bright yellow, bill slaty with black on tip and lower
mandible, legs and feet slaty olive, claws black.
The Tufted Duck was seen by us in very small numbers on the Long-
bonga Lake and Dudh Pokhari in May.
The two outermost pairs of primaries in my specimen are somewhat
worn, and the rectrices are fresh, except the central pair which is only
half-grown and has sheath on base.
Order Galliformes
Family Phasianidae
#Lerwa lerwa (Hodgson) : Snow Partridge
The Snow Partridge was observed by me only twice in Khumbu,
once on the lateral moraine of the Khumbu glacier at about 5000 m on
20 February, and again above the track near Koner (a kilometre or so to
the northwest of Phorcha), Dudh Kosi valley, on 10 May. It was, how-
ever, heard more frequently in March and May than seen. The highest
elevation at which it was encountered was about 5200 m on 31 March,
when it was heard near the crest of the ridge separating the Langmoche
and Thami valleys between Langmoche and Gnachu.
Tetraogallus tibetanus aquilonifer R. & A. Meinertzhagen : Sikkim
Snowcock.
Khumbu: Bhote Kosi Valley: Marlung : (10 March); Thami Valley:
Gnachu : 1 A (24 March) ; Thyangbo : 1 1 $ (24 March).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
4 $ : 267, 268, 270, 271 161, 162, 163, 164 37-5, 38-5, 39 (2)
1?: 265 158 36
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, edges of upper eyelid orange, edge of
lower eyelid, postorbital skin, cere and nasal membrane reddish orange, bill dusky
orange-yellow, legs and feet reddish orange, claws black.
The Snowcock was not uncommon in Khumbu in groups of two to
six or so on moraines, sparsely scrubby or grass-covered rocky areas, etc.
between c. 4700 and 5335 metres during February-May. Strangely
enough, it appeared to be fairly common and quite at home on the snow*
covered moraines of the Khumbu glacier at c. 5180-5335 metres in
February !
The gonads of the Thami Valley (Gnachu and Thyangbo) specimens
were moderately enlarged, the male from Gnachu having 16x10 (right)
and 15x8 (left) testes, and that from Thyangbo having them 10x6
(right) and 14 X 7 (left) ; and the female from Thyangbo having a coarsely
granular ovary, the largest ovum being about 3 mm in diameter.
8
464 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 1i (3)
The extent of dark grey on the base of the throat in the males is some-
what variable in my specimens. Thus, it is in two small irregular patches
in the Gnachu male, while it is in the form of an almost complete band
with a little gap in the three other males, much like the Sikkim birds
described by Rand & Fleming (1957, p. 59). The female has the chin
and anterior throat white, while the malar region, posterior throat and
anterior breast are brownish black mottled with light buff and white.
*Francolinus francolinus (Linnaeus) : Black Partridge
The Black Partridge was heard only once in eastern Nepal, below
Kirantichhap, at about 1000 m, in Ramechhap district, on 31 January.
Ithaginis cruentus cruentus (Hardwicke) : Nepal Blood Pheasant
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Base Camp : 1 <J, 1 $ (7 April) ; Imja Valley;
Yaral : 1 $ (3 May).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
1 d : 207 157 27*5
2$: 190,205 130,159 24»5, 25
Colours of bare parts : Male : Iris brown ; orbital skin, cere arid nasal
iriembrane orange-vermilion ; bill black with coral red on base and gape ; legs, feet and
pads coral red ; claws dark horny on top but pale orange on underside. Female :
Similar to male but orbital skin dull orange, cere black anteriorly but orange
posteriorly, nasal membrane black, bill black all over, legs arid feet coral red
with a dusky tinge specially on feet.
We found the Blood Pheasant to be fairly common in Khumbu
between c. 3800 and 4100 m during February-May. It occurred in
small parties in forests consisting of rhododendrons, birch and fir, and
did not appear to be particularly shy.
Tragopan satyra (Linnaeus): Crimson Horned Pheasant
Solu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Ghat : 1 d> 1 £ (29 April, 16 May).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
1<|; 272 253 31
1 $ : 235 184 30'5
Colours of bare parts : Female : Iris brown, bill horny brown, legs and feet
reddish brown, claws homy.
The Crimson Horned Pheasant was seen between c. 2750 and 3050
metres in the Dudh Kosi valley above Ghat and Phakding in April and
May, and above Bung (c. 2740 m) in the Hongu Valley, early in June.
The specimens listed above were caught alive in Ghat area by some
local people and brought to the Base Camp for the Expedition’s mena-
gerie. The female bird, after it was caught, remained with the catcher
for some days when it was said to have laid three egg s. It was then
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
465
brought to our camp where it lived only for a few days and died on the
morning of 29 April. The male bird lived in the menagerie for a week
and died on 16 May morning.
The male specimen had well-developed testes, but the female had
an exhausted ovary.
Lophophorus impejanus (Latham): Monal Pheasant
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley: Hunko : 2<J, 1? (17, 19 March); Thami
Valley : Thami : 1 ^ (19 March).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
3<$: 292,294,301 203 + ,222+,— 52(2),—
1 $ : 270 — 47
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, orbital skin bright blue (paler in the
female), bill dark horny, legs and feet olive horny, claws horny.
The Monal Pheasant was found to be common in small parties in
Khumbu between c. 3800 and 4270 m in forests during February-May.
The tips of rectrices are somewhat worn in the Thami male (19
March), and very much so in the female from Hunko (17 March).
The Thami male has still retained some juvenile characters. It has
rufous barrings on the outer two secondaries, partial barrings on the
inner four secondaries, and dark brown and white mottling on the bases
of rectrices, the two outermost pairs of which are extensively marked
with black bars and spots.
Compared with the winter-taken female specimens from northern
Sikkim, the only female from Khumbu has somewhat reduced white on
the chin and throat, and has slightly paler, less rufous bars on the secon-
daries .
The gonads of the Khumbu specimens had already started swelling.
*Lophura leucomelana (Latham): Kalij Pheasant
The Kalij Pheasant was seen late in the afternoon of the 7th February
near Taksindhu at about 3050 m ( c . 27°37'N, 86°38'E, Okhaldhunga
district), that is, on the ridge separating the Solu Khola from the Dudh
Kosi. Later, on 25 May, it was seen in a pair early in the afternoon
feeding in a harvested field on a ledge about 50 m below Namche Bazar,
that is at about 3750 m. I was informed by some local people that this
pair of birds regularly came there late in the day. Next day (26 May),
I saw the pair again there feeding at about II a.m.
466 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Order Charadriiformes
Family Charadriidae
Subfamily Charadriinae
*Vanellus duvaucelii (Lesson) : Spurwinged Plover
A few individuals of the Spurwinged Plover were observed on the
bank of the Arun river between Sati Ghat and Tumlingtar at c. 450 m
altitude on 11 and 12 June.
Subfamily Scolopacinae
*Numenius arquata (Linnaeus): Curlew
Dr William Edgar, Medical Officer of the Expedition, who has a
good knowledge of the British birds, reported to me that he had heard
the Curlew on the Khumbu glacier at about 5300 m early in May. He
was not, however, lucky enough to view the bird.
#Tringa hypoleucos Linnaeus : Common Sandpiper
A few specimens of the Common Sandpiper were sighted singly on
the edges of both the Indrawati and Sun Kosi rivers near their confluence
at Dolalghat (alt. c. 850 m ; 27°38'In, 85°43'E) on 27 January.
*Scolopax rusticola Linnaeus : Woodcock
On 2 April, at dusk, two specimens of the Woodcock were seen
separately, flying slowly and somewhat irregularly over the forest to the
east of the Base Camp, uttering feeble squeaks at the same time. They
Were observed to proceed as far . as the head of a small hill stream and
- could not be traced any further owing to bad visibility. The same per*
formance was repeated at the same time on 3 and 4 April. I am not
Sure if they were 4 roding 5 .
Subfamily Ibidorhynchinae
*Ibidorhyncha struthersii Vigors : Ibisbill
A party of five Ibisbills was observed on 27 January at Dolalghat
on the shingle banks at the confluence of the Indrawati and Sun Kosi
rivers. The birds did not appear to be shy and permitted prolonged
observation by most members of the Expedition from fairly close range.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
467
Family Laridae
*Sterna aura alia J. E. Gray: Indian River Tern
The Indian River Tern was seen only once by me at Sati Ghat on
Arun river (alt. c. 460 m ; 27°21/N, 87312'E) on 11 June, when a few
birds were scanning the river at about midday.
#Sterna acuticauda J. E. Gray : Blackbellied Tern
Small numbers of the Blackbellied Tern were observed on the Arun
river from Sati Ghat to Tumlingtar (alt. c. 305-460 m) on 11 and 12 June,
Order Columbiformes
Family Columbidae
#Treron sphenura (Vigors): Wedgetailed Green Pigeon
A party of four examples, and another of six, of the Wedgetailed
Green Pigeon were noticed on Ficus trees near Khote (alt. c. 915 m ;
27°16'N, 87°14'E), Sabhaya Valley, Dhankuta district, eastern Nepal,
on 11 June.
Columba leuconota leuconota Vigors : Snow Pigeon
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Thammu : 1 $ (7 March) ; Thami Valley :
Thami : 1 A (8 March).
Measurements :
Colours of bare parts : Iris golden yellow, bill black, legs and feet cherry red9
claws black.
The Snow Pigeon was first seen during this Expedition on 7 February
in a large flock above Junbesi ( c . 27°34'N, 86°33'E) in the Beni Valley,
Solu, at about 3000 m. It Was later observed at different places in Solu
in large flocks between c. 2895 and 3050 m up to 10 February. In
Khumbu it was seen from mid-February to April between c. 3655 and
4400 m in and about all the villages, but never in large flocks: it
occurred there in small flocks of about a dozen birds at the most, and in
late April, even in pairs.
Compared with the northern Sikkim examples taken in January,
these Khumbu specimens have much duller head and wing-coverts, and
browner mantles. I have not, however, been able to compare these
specimens with examples from the western Himalaya.
468 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
Streptopelia orientalis agricola (Tickell) : Eastern Turtle Dove
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Below Khumjung : 1 $ (9 April).
Measurements : 1 <£ : Wing 190, tail 139, bill 21.
Colours of bare parts : Iris orange-red ; orbital skin, edges of eyelids, cere and
base of bill purplish crimson ; bill pale horny ; legs and feet crimson ; claws homy.
The Eastern Turtle Dove was rather scarce in Khumbu. None was
seen there until April 9, presumably because none had returned from
the winter quarters. Subsequently, it was seen in one or two pairs at a
time only at a few localities, such as near Thyangboche ( c . 3960 m)
on 17 April and 4 May, below Phorcha ( c . 3950 m)on 9 May, and Phakding
on 28-30 May. Later and further southeastward in the Arun watershed
about Chainpur, it appeared commoner. There many pairs were found
between 13 and 25 June on the edges of forests.
Order Psittaciformes
Family Psittacidae
*Psittacula himalayana (Lesson): Himalayan Slatyheaded Parakeet
The Himalayan Slatyheaded Parakeet was seen only once in a small
flock at an altitude of about 1100 metres in a forest between Manga
Deorali and Kirantichhap, Ramechhap district, on 31 January.
Order Cuculiformes
Family Cuculidae
*Cuculus sparverioides Vigors: Large Hawk-Cuckoo
The Large Hawk-Cuckoo was heard only in the Arun watershed at
about 1525 m altitude between Pokhara and Dingla, Bhojpur district,
on 8-10 June.
*Cuculus micropterus Gould : Indian Cuckoo
The Indian Cuckoo was heard and seen several times between 13 and
25 June about Chainpur, Dhankuta district.
*Cuculus canorus Linnaeus: Cuckoo
The Cuckoo was first heard in Khumbu by me on 10 May near Phorcha.
It was subsequently observed or heard between c. 3650 and 4260 m up to
the last week of May when I left Khumbu. It was not particularly com-
mon there. Elsewhere in eastern Nepal, it appeared to be common
between c. 1220 and 2745 m from the Hongu Valley east to the Tamur
Valley in June,
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
469
*Cuculus saturatus Blyth : Himalayan Cuckoo
This cuckoo seemed common in the Solu region, Dudh Kosi Valley
(Puiyan, Phakding, etc,) eastward to the Tamur Valley, between c. 1525
and 3050 m from end May to end June.
#Eudynamys scolopacea (Linnaeus) : Koel
The Koel was observed and heard only about Dingla ( c . 1525 m) in
the Arun Valley, Khote ( c . 915 m) in the Sabhaya Valley, and in the
Hinwan Valley at c. 1370 m, below Chainpur, between 9 and 25 June.
Order Caprimulgiformes
Family Caprimulgidae
Caprimulgus indicus hazarae Whistler & Kinnear: Himalayan Jungle
Nightjar
Okhaldhunga district : Inukhu Valley : c. 9 km E of Pankhoma : 1 — [in
alcohol] (2 June).
Measurements : 1 — : Wing 207, tail 140, bill from posterior edge of nostril 9.
This specimen was found lying dead on the edge of a forest path at
about 10 in the morning. Rigor mortis had not set in when it was found,
and it had no visible mark of injury on its body.
Some nightjars, probably the Jungle Nightjars, were heard at Chiya
Kharka ( c . 3050 m), Inukhu Valley, and at Bung ( c . 2700 m), Hongu
Valley, early in June.
Order Coraciiformes
Family Coraciidae
*Coraeias benghalensis (Linnaeus): Roller
The Roller was met with in very small numbers only around Tum-
lingtar (c. 305 m), Arun Valley, and near Khote (c. 915 m), Sabhaya
Valley, both in Dhankuta district, on 11 and 12 June.
Family Upupidae
Upupa epops saturata Lonnberg : Tibetan Hoopoe
Khumbu : Pumori glacier (c. 5700 m ; 28°N, 86°50,E) : 1 — [in alcohol] (7 May).
Measurements : 1 — : Wing 153-5, tail 102, bill 65.
The only specimen of the Tibetan Hoopoe encountered by us was
shot by Mr T. Stobart of the Expedition in an ablation valley of the
Pumori glacier.
470 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
The Tibetan Hoopoe has earlier been reported from the adjacent
areas of Tibet and Sikkim as high as c. 4572-6400 metres by Wollaston
and Blanford (in Kinnear, 1922, p. 204). Diesselhorst (1968, p. 174)
and Martens (1971a, p. 122) have reported it from Khumbu between
3800 and 5000 metres.
Order Apodiformes
Family Apodidae
*Apus pacificus (Latham): Whiterumped Swift
The Whiterumped Swift was observed on several occasions flying
about in small flocks over the Dudh Kosi river near the Base Camp at
c. 3600-3800 m in April-May. It was also seen in Chainpur area
(c. 1525 m) in mid- June.
Apus affinis (J. E. Gray) : House Swift
The House Swift was common in Chainpur in mid-June.
Order Piciformes
Family Capitonidae
#Megalaima virens (Boddaert) : Great Himalayan Barbet
The Great Himalayan Barbet was found practically all over eastern
Nepal between c. 1500 and 1830 m in June and early July. It was,
however, more often heard than seen.
#Megalaima franklinii (Blyth) : Goldenthroated Barbet
This barbet did not appear to be common in eastern Nepal. It Was
observed on a few occasions between Pokhara and Dingla, Bhojpur
district, on 8 June, and about Chainpur between 13 and 25 June.
Family Picidae
*Picoides auriceps (Vigors) : Brownfronted Pied Woodpecker
Many pairs of the Brownfronted Pied Woodpecker were observed
in a pine forest a little below Manga Deorali ( c . 1830 m; 27°40'N, 85°57'E),
Ramechhap district, on 31 January. Diesselhorst (1968, p. 186) has
recorded it further eastward, at 86°4'E, in the same district.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
471
Order Passeriformes
Family Alaudidae
Calandrella acutirostris tibetana Brooks : Brooks’s Short-toed Lark
Khumbu : Lobujya Valley : Phalong Karpo : 1 $ (6 May) ; Imja Valley :
above Pangboche (c. 4700 m) : 1 — [in alcohol] (16 May).
Measurements :
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, bill orange-horny with blackish on
culmen and tip, legs horny brown, feet and claws horny.
This short-toed lark was found in small numbers in the scrub about
Phalong Karpo and above Pangboche in May.
The Phalong Karpo specimen is in a somewhat worn plumage, but
the other one is fairly fresh.
Family Hirundinidae
*Hirundo daurica Linnaeus : Striated Swallow
The Striated Swallow was common in June in most of the larger
villages of eastern Nepal situated between c. 1525 and 2440 m.
*Delichon nipalensis Moore : House Martin
Small numbers of the House Martin were observed in Chainpur area
in mid-June.
Family Motacillidae
Anthus roseatus Hodgson : Hodgson’s Pipit
Khumbu: Lobujya Valley : Pheriche-Phalong Karpo (c. 4300-4570 m) : 3 <$<$,
2$, 1 — [in alcohol] (22-26 April); Dudh Kosi Valley: Longbonga Lake:
1?(11 May).
Measurements :
Wing
Tail Bill
3 c?: 89,90*5,94 66,69,73
3 $ : 81*5, 83-5, 84 59, 62 (2)
1— : 89 65
16, 16*5, —
16 (2), -
16-5
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, bill horny black but fleshy horny on lower
mandible, legs and feet fleshy brown, claws horny.
In mid- February when I camped in the Pheriche-Phalong Karpo
area, not a single example of the Hodgson’s Pipit was seen there, but
when I revisited the area between 22 and 29 April, it was quite com-
472 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Yol 71 (3)
mon there. It occurred in small parties which were breaking up into
pairs. It was usually feeding on the damp ground near the large numbers
of Streamlets that criss-cross the area, and when alarmed was hiding in
the dwarf alpine vegetation. Its behaviour and the somewhat swollen
condition of the gonads suggested that it was getting ready to breed.
It was also found equally common in small parties or pairs in a western
ablation valley of the Ngojumba glacier, especially on the shores of the
Longbonga and Gokyo lakes (c. 4700-4900 m) between 11 and 15 May.
Motacilla alba alboides Hodgson : Hodgson’s Pied Wagtail
Khumbu : Lobujya Valley : between Phalong Karpo and Thugla (c. 4600 m) :
1 <J, 1 $ (24 April) ; Thami Valley : Thami : 1 — (18 March).
Measurements :
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
Hodgson’s Pied Wagtail was found from time to time during my
march eastward from Kathmandu, especially about Banepa, Lamadihi,
Dolalghat, Chyaubas and the Khimti Valley between 850 and 2150 m.
In Khumbu, it appeared rather rare from mid-February to early April.
From mid-April onwards, it was quite common in pairs, one chasing
the other, with characteristic undulating flight, and uttering a rather
musical note. In the Pheriche-Phalong Karpo area, it occurred generally
on the larger streams up to a little below Thugla (c. 4700 m).
Family Campephagidae
*Pericrocotus flammeus (Forster): Scarlet Minivet
A flock of the Scarlet Minivet (males) was seen between Lamadihi
and Dolalghat ( c . 850-1050 m), Chautara district, on 27 January.
Pericrocotus ethologus favillaceus Bangs & Phillips : Longtailed
Minivet
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Par6 (c. 4000 m) : 1 d fin alcohol] (1 April).
Measurements :1c?-' Wing 93, tail 110, bill 16.
Colours of soft parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
The Longtailed Minivet was first observed by us on 8 February below
Taksindhu (c. 1980 m), Dudh Kosi Valley. It occurred in a mixed
flock of males and females. The only other occasion when we found it
was above Pare in Khumbu, and only two pairs were seen there,
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
473
Family Pycnonotidae
Pycnonotus leucogenys leucogenys (J. E. Gray) : Whitecheeked
Bulbul
Dhankuta district : Chainpur : 1 $, 1 — [in alcohol] (19 June).
Measurements ;
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
The Whitecheeked Bulbul was found from time to time during our
eastward march, especially in the Khimti Valley ( c . 1800 m) in early
February, and in the Arun, Sabhaya and Tamur Valleys ( c . 600-1800 m)
in June.
*Pycnonotus cafer (Linnaeus) : Redvented Bulbul
The Redvented Bulbul was seen by us between Banepa and Risingo
( c . 1370-1520 m), Chautara district, during late January, and again in the
Tamur Valley, Dhankuta district, up to c. 1500 m in June.
*Hypsipetes madagascariensis (P. L. S. Muller) : Black Bulbul
The Black Bulbul was found in flocks near Manga Deorali ( c . 2400
m), Chautara district, on 30 January, and between Tamba Kosi and
Khimti valleys, Ramechhap district, at c. 1500-2000 m in early February.
Family Laniidae
Lanius tephronotus tephronotus (Vigors) : Tibetan Shrike
Khumbu : Imja Valley : Dingboche : 1 ^ (20 April). Solu : Dudh Kosi
Valley : Phakding : 1 1 — [in alcohol] (27, 28 May).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
2 S : 98-5+, 103 120,— 21,22*5
1— : 101 — 22
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill black (slaty on base in a male) ;
legs, feet and claws black.
We did not find the Tibetan Shrike to be common in eastern Nepal.
It was encountered only once in Khumbu, on 20 April, when the specimen
was taken. During late May, however, it appeared somewhat commoner
in the Ghat-Phakding area of Solu.
The gonads of the Khumbu specimen (20 April) were but slightly
developed, while they were fully developed in the male collected at
Phakding on 27 May.
The Phakding specimens are in somewhat worn plumage.
474 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
Family Cinclidae
Cinclus pallasii tenuirostris Bonaparte : Brown Dipper
Khumbu: Confluence of Dudh Kosi river and Imja Khola (c. 3650 m ; 27°50/N,
86°45'E): 1 (3 April).
Measurements : Wing 103, tail 62*5, bill 23-5.
Colours of bare parts : Iris brown, bill black, legs and feet pale bluish slaty, pads
yellowish grey.
The Brown Dipper was first sighted by us on Khimti Khola at Those
( c . 1830 m), Ramechhap district on 4 February. Later, it was seen in
Khumbu on several occasions, sometimes in pairs, on Imja Khola,
specially about its confluences with the Dudh Kosi and Lobujya Khola,
during February-May between c. 3650 and 4570 m.
The testes of the specimen were slightly enlarged.
Family Troglodytidae
Troglodytes troglodytes kinneari Biswas: Kinnear’s Wren
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Thammu : 1 [Holotype] (7 March).
Measurements : 1 <J : Wing 54, tail 34, bill 9.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws dark horny.
The Kinnear’s Wren was observed in Khumbu during February-May
between c. 2740 and 3660 m. It occurred singly among boulders forming
boundaries of agricultural fields.
Vaurie (1959, p. 205), Ripley (1961, p. 538) and Ali & Ripley
(1973, p. 137) have treated T. t. kinneari Biswas as a synonym of T. t,
nipalensis Blyth.
Family Prunellidae
Prunella collaris nipalensis (Blyth) : Eastern Alpine Accentor
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Thonak : 1 $ (8 April), Base Camp : 1 ?
(1 March) ; Bhote Kosi Valley : Thammu : 1 — [in alcohol] (7 March) ;
feet fleshy brown (March) or brownish orange (April-May), claws black, pads greyish
yellow.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL 475
In eastern Nepal, the Alpine Accentor was found only in Khumbu.
It did not appear to be particularly common there, occurring generally
singly in scrub. During late February to early April, it appeared rather
scarce and shy, but later it was bolder and was seen in larger numbers.
The April male specimen from Thonak had its gonads somewhat
enlarged, but those from Chugima taken on 14 May had well-developed
testes.
The white fringing of the flank feathers is rather variable in the
Khumbu birds. Thus, the male from Thonak and one of the males
from Chugima have mere traces of white on the flank feathers, but the
female taken at the Base Camp area has somewhat more extensive white
fringes on the flank feathers, and its central abdominal feathers are also
fringed with white. The other male from Chugima has, however, no
white on the flanks. The chestnut in the Khumbu birds is much deeper
than in my only Sikkim bird (tf, Lachung, 3050 m, 22 January 1953).
The Sikkim bird has, however, as much white on its underside as in the
Khumbu female.
Prunella strophiata strophiata (Blyth) : Rufousbreasted Accentor
Khumbu : Lobujya Valley : Phalong Karpo : 1 <$ (23 April) ; Thugla, 1 A
(24 April); between Phalong Karpo and Thugla (c. 4650 m) : l <J (26 April) ;
Imja Valley : Yaral : 1 <£, 1 — (30 April).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
4<£: 62,66,68,70 53, 57, 58, 6T5 —(4)
1—: 66 56-5 —
Colours of bare parts : Iris reddish brown, bill black (once with brownish on
base), legs and feet brownish fleshy, claws horny.
A confiding bird, the Rufousbreasted Accentor was not uncommon
in Khumbu between c. 3650 and 4930 m during February-May.
The gonads of the Phalong Karpo and Thugla specimens were some-
what enlarged.
Prunella rubeculoides rubeculoides (Moore): Robin Accentor
Khumbu : Thami Valley : Thami : 1 A (17 March) ; Imja Valley : Dingboche :
2 $ (19 April).
Measurements :
_ Wing Tail Bill
1<J: 73 62 —
2$: 77,78 65,66 14,—
Colours of bare parts : Iris reddish brown, bill black, legs and feet light (March)
to orange (April) brown, claws dark horny to black.
The Robin Accentor was found in Khumbu in small numbers between
c. 3960 and 4930 m during February-May, frequenting scrub and feeding
generally on the ground.
476 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. fi (3)
The male specimen (mid-March) had undeveloped testes, but the
females (mid-April) had granular ova.
The rufous brown streaks on the dorsal side of the March specimen
are more rufous than those of the other specimens, and the ferruginous
on its breast is also deeper. The differences in coloration may possibly
be due to the state of wear, the Thami male (17 March) being in very
fresh plumage, while the other two (19 April) are slightly worn.
Family Muscicapidae
Subfamily Turdinae
Erithacus pectoralis confusus (Hartert) : Eastern Ruby throat
Khumbu : Lobujya Valley : Phalong Karpo : 3 £ (22, 23, 29 April) ; Ngo-
jumba Valley : Chugima : 1 $ (14 May).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
3 3 : 76,77,79 64,64-5,— 17, — (2)
1?: 67 55 —
Colours of bare parts ; Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black (legs in $
dark horny).
The Eastern Ruby throat was sighted and collected in the Lobujya
and Ngojumba Valleys of Khumbu between c. 4570 and 4850 m in April-
May. It occurred among boulders of moraines and in scrub on the
ground, but appeared to be rather uncommon.
Two of the male specimens taken on 22 and 23 April had enlarged
testes, but in the one collected on 29 April they had just commenced
swelling, and the female (14 May) had an ovary that appeared to be
spent.
Erithacus cyanurus rufilatus (Hodgson) : Redflanked Bush Robin
Khumbu: Bhote Kosi Valley : Pare (c. 3900-4000 m) : 2$ (25 March,
1 April) ; Imja Valley : Yaral : 3 <J, 1 $ (30 April, 1 May); Pangboche : 1 ($)
[in alcohol] (29 April).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
4 <*: 82,83 (3) 65,66,67,— —(4)
2?: 78,79 60,62 15,—
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
The Redflanked Bush Robin occurred in Khumbu in scrub and bushes
in small numbers during late March and early April, but about a
month later, that is during late April and May, it was commoner there.
Three of my male specimens (1 April, 30 April) and a female (1 May)
had fully developed gonads.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
477
Erithacus chrysaeus chrysaeus (Hodgson): Golden Bush Robin
Khumbu: Imja Valley : Yaral : 1 (30 April), 1 $ (3 May).
Measurements :
dolours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill black with golden yellow on lower
mandible and sides of upper mandible (0) or golden yellow on base of lower mandible
and dusky on its anterior half ($) ; legs and feet brown but golden yellow showing
through ; claws horny ; pads yellow.
The Golden Bush Robin appeared rather rare in Khumbu : we did
not see any there till late in April, and then also rarely and under thick
bushes.
The gonads of both my specimens were somewhat enlarged.
Erithacus indicus indicus (Vieillot) : Whitebrowed Bush Robin
Khumbu : Imja Valley : Yaral : 1 <$ (1 May).
Measurements : 1 0 : Wing 80, tail 66, bill 16.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill black ; legs, feet and claws very
dark horny.
The Whitebrowed Bush Robin appeared very scarce in Khumbu. It
was spotted there only once in scrub, when it was collected.
Copsychus saularis sauiaris (Linnaeus) : Indian Magpie-Robin
Dhankuta district : Chainpur : 1 0 (19 June).
Measurements : 1 0 : Wing 97, tail — , bill 20.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
The Indian Magpie-Robin was common during January-July from
the Nepal Valley east to the Singalila ridge on the Indian frontier up to
about 1550 m altitude in and about towns and villages, in orchards, and
in light forests.
Phoenicurus frontalis (Vigors): Bluefronted Redstart
Khumbu : Thami Valley : Thami : 1 0 [in alcohol] (18 March) ; Bhote Kosi
Valley : Hunko : 1 0 (25 March) ; Imja Valley : Dingboche : 1 0 (20 April),
1 $ (18 April), Yaral : 2 (1, 2 May).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
5 0 : 84, 85, 86 (2), 91 65, 68 (2), 73, — 15 5 (2), 16 (3)
1 $ : 79 61 15
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
The Bluefronted Redstart was quite a common bird during winter
and spring from the Nepal Valley east to Okhaldhunga district up to
about 4950 m altitude.
478 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 11 (3)
Two of the male specimens, taken on 25 March and 20 April, had
their testes somewhat enlarged, but two other males (1 and 2 May) and
the female (18 April) had fully developed gonads.
Phoenicurus schisticeps (G. R. Gray) : Whitethroated Redstart
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Tesinga : 1 $ (6 March) ; Bhote Kosi Valley :
Phurte : 1 <3 (7 March).
Measurements : 2 c? : Wing 85, 87 ; tail 70, 72 ; bill 16, 16-5.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
The Whitethroated Redstart was found in Khumbu during March
only, occurring in small numbers in scrub and bushes between c. 3600
and 4000 m.
Rhyacornis fuliginosus fuliginosus (Vigors): Plumbeous Redstart
Solu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Phakding : 1 <? (29 May).
Measurements : 1 $ : Wing — , tail — , bill 14.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown; bill black; legs and feet brownish horny;
claws black; pads white.
The Plumbeous Redstart was frequently found singly on boulders
and shingle in the beds of streams of eastern Nepal during January-May
between c. 900 and 4250 m altitude. In Khumbu, however, it did not
appear to be particularly common.
The testes of the present specimen were fully enlarged.
Its plumage is very Worn, specially the wing and tail.
*Grandala coelicolor Hodgson : Hodgson’s Grandala
A flock of the Hodgson’s Grandala was seen twice in Khumbu, off
Namche Bazar near the bend of the Dudh Kosi river, on 11 and 14 Feb*
ruary. There were perhaps 50 birds in the flock which circled above the
valley and from time to time alighted somewhere in the gorge below.
*Enicurus scouleri Vigors : Little Forktail
The Little Forktail was seen by us only once in eastern Nepal, on
Khimti Khola near Those, Ramechhap district, on 4 February at c. 1830 m.
*Enicurus maculatus Vigors : Spotted Forktail
We found the Spotted Forktail only once on a little stream (a
tributary of the Chaunri Khola) below Manga Deorali, Chautara district,
at c. 1525 m on 30 January.
*Saxicola torquata (Linnaeus) : Collared Bush Chat
The Collared Bush Chat was sporadically seen singly in bushes about
cultivated fields between 26 January and 5 February in Chautara and
Ramechhap districts.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
479
#Saxico!a ferrea G. R. Gray : Dark Grey Bush Chat
The Dark Grey Bush Chat was sighted once in the Bhota Kosi valley,
Ramechhap district, on 1 February at about 1220 m — a single bird
perched on the top of a shrub.
Chaimarromis leucocephalus (Vigors) : Whitecapped Redstart
Khumbu : Lobujya Valley : between Thugla and Phalong Karpo (c. 4650 m) :
1 <$ (24 April), Pheriche : 1 3 (24 April) ; confluence of Lobujya and Imja
Kholas (c. 4200 m ; 27°53/N, 86°49'E) ; 1 3 (25 April).
Measurements : 3 3 : Wing 100, 101, 102 ; tail 77, 81, — ; bill 17-5, 18 (2).
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
A few individuals of the Whitecapped Redstart were seen on Khimti
Khola at about 1830 metres altitude near Those, Ramechhap district, on
4 February. In Khumbu, it appeared common in pairs in the larger
streams, such as Lobujya, Imja, Jambur and Chola Kholas, during
April-May. A single example was also seen between Gokyo and Thonak
Lake at c. 4950 m on 13 May.
The gonads of the specimens listed above were somewhat enlarged.
Myiophoneus caeruleus temminckii (Vigors) : Himalayan Whistling
Thrush
Khumbu : Thami Valley : Thami : 1 3 (25 March) ; Dudh Kosi Valley :
Nah : 1 3 (10 May) ; Bhote Kosi Valley : Pare : 1 $ (29 March). Solu :
Dudh Kosi Valley : Phakding : 1 £ (28 May).
Measurements :
Wing Tail
23: 173,180 + 131,135 +
2$: 172,173 126 +, 128
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill yellow
base of upper mandible ; legs, feet and claws black.
The Himalayan Whistling Thrush was heard in Solu between Tak-
- sindhu and Kharilchola, Dudh Kosi Valley, at c. 1830 m on 8 February.
In Khumbu it was found singly from time to time during March-May
on Thami, Dudh Kosi and Bhote Kosi rivers between c. 3800 and 4400
metres; and was once seen on a boulder in the bed of the Dudh Kosi a
little to the north of Toujung Lake at c. 4800 m for a few minutes on 15
May. It appeared rather silent in Khumbu. Later, it was found breed-
ing in Solu at c. 3000 m late in May, and in June and early July further
eastward up to the Singalila Ridge fairly commonly and frequently giving
out its characteristic musical call.
The March specimens had somewhat enlarged gonads ; the male
taken on 10 May had fully developed testes, while the female of 28 May
had already laid and had incubation patches present.
9
Bill
34, 34-5
33, 34’5
with black on culmen and
480 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
#Zoothera mollissima mollissima (Blyth) : Eastern^ Plainbacked Moun-
tain Thrush
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Base Camp : 1 <J, 1 ? (5 April).
Measurements :
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, bill dark horny, legs and feet wax yellow,
claws pale horny.
This mountain thrush appeared scarce in Khumbu. It was seen
singly only on a few occasions during April-May between c. 3650 and
3960 m.
The gonads of these two specimens were somewhat enlarged.
Turdus boulhoul (Latham) : Greywinged Blackbird
Okhaldhunga District : Hongu Valley : above Bung (c. 2740 m) : 1—
[in alcohol! (4 June).
The Grey winged Blackbird was occasionally heard and/or seen in
eastern Nepal in forests during February and June between c. 1060 and
2740 m.
The example under report was a fledgling that could fly only short
distances. It was abandoned by its mother on our approach.
Turdus ruficollis atrogularis Jarocki : Blackthroated Thrush
Khumbu : Thami Valley : Thami : 1 (18 March).
Measurements : 1 : Wing 133, tail 92, bill 33.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, bill black with yellow on base, legs and
feet dark horny, claws black.
The Blackthroated Thrush was seen in Khumbu in flocks of about a
dozen birds chiefly on juniper trees in Thami, Bhote Kosi and Dudh
Kosi valleys from c. 3960 to 4400 m altitude in March and early April.
The testes of my specimen were only slightly enlarged.
Subfamily Timaliinae
^Garrulax alhogularis (Gould) : Whitethroated Laughing Thrush
This Laughing Thrush was observed only once in eastern Nepal in a
small flock in the forest below Serete, Likhu Valley, Okhaldhunga dis-
trict, at about 2440 m on 5 February.
Garrulax lineatus setafer (Hodgson): Nepal Streaked Laughing
Thrush
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : below Khumjung : 1 <?> 1 ? (9 April). Solu :
Dudh Kosi Valley : Phakding : 1 $ (29 May).
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
48 i
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
1 cJ : 78 93+ 19
2?: 75, 75-5 86 + , 92 18-5,19
Colours of bare parts : Iris brown to reddish brown, bill pale horny to horny
with dusky on base or on culmen, legs and feet horny brown, claws horny to brownish
horny, pads fleshy.
Only a few pairs of the Streaked Laughing Thrush were seen in Solu
and Khumbu during April-May at altitudes ranging from about 2800
to 3810 m. It did not appear to be a shy bird at all, and on 29 May at
Phakding a pair was seen feeding hardly two metres away from a man
who was noisily repairing his bamboo shutters.
The gonads of the April specimens were fairly well developed, and
that of the May one was fully developed.
*Garrulax? subunicolor (Blyth): Plaincoloured Laughing Thrush
On Sangasoti Danda (= Ridge), Chautara district, below Chyaubas
at about 2130 m, a small flock of about six birds that appeared to be this
laughing thrush was seen on 29 January late in the afternoon.
Garrulax affinis bethelae Rand & Fleming : Eastern Blackfaced
Laughing Thrush
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Base Camp : 1 A, 1 $ (3 March) ; Bhote Kosi
Valley : Tarangan : 2 $ (16 March) ; Thami Valley : Thami : 1 $ (17 March) .
Solu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Phakding : 1 d (29 May).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
2 3 : 108,109 125 +, 128 24, —
4 $ : 103, 104, 107, 113 125, 126, — (2) — (4)
Colours of bare parts : Iris brown, bill black, legs and feet fleshy or light brown,
claws horny.
The Blackfaced Laughing Thrush was commonly found in Solu and
Khumbu in flocks of 4-8 birds or in pairs between c. 3000 and 4500 m
during February-May. It was very confiding and noisy, and occurred
in bushes.
The ovaries of the birds collected on 16 and 17 March had just
commenced development, but the testes of the one taken on 29 May
were fully developed.
The male taken on 29 May was worn. One of the females taken on
16 March had all its rectrices except the pair next to the central in moult.
The moulting feathers were all in about equal stage of development.
They were probably growing after their accidental loss.
These eastern Nepal birds are somewhat intermediate between
those of the Nepal Valley and Sikkim, but are closer to the latter.
Five of my specimens (2<J, 3$), show, as reported by Rand & Fleming
482 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
(1957, p. 133) for their eastern Nepal birds, 4 a tendency toward paler
edgings of the breast feathers, though otherwise most like hethelae \
While none of my specimens is close to nominate affinis , one (£) cannot
be separated from bethelae of Sikkim.
Garrulax erythroeephalus (Vigors): Redheaded Laughing Thrush
Okhaldhunga District : Pankhoma : 1 — [in alcohol] (2 June).
In eastern Nepal, the Redheaded Laughing Thrush was seen first on
the crest of the ridge separating Solu Khola from Dudh Kosi at Taksindhu
(c. 3050 m) on 7 February. Later, in the early hours of the cloudy
morning of 2 June it was found, just east of Pankhoma, that a Redheaded
Laughing Thrush, obviously one of the parents, was tending two fledglings.
On my approach, the parent bird and one of the fledglings flew down the
slope, leaving the other fledgling for me. The parent bird was undoubt-
edly of this species, and from the point of view of distribution, should
belong to group D of Rand & Fleming (1957, p. 134).
#Minla ignotincta Hodgson : Redtailed Minla
The Redtailed Minla was sighted only once on Sangasoti Danda,
below Chyaubas, Chautara district, at about 1800 m in a flock of about a
dozen birds on 29 January.
Yuhina occipitalis occipitalis Hodgson: Rufousvented Yuhina
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Pare (c. 4000 m) : 1 1 $ (1 April).
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, bill reddish brown, legs and feet dull
brownish orange, claws horny.
Only a pair of the Rufousvented Yuhina was encountered by us,
that is, the pair collected from a mixed feeding party above Pare.
The gonads of both the specimens were enlarged.
This bird was inadvertently reported under Yuhina bakeri by me
earlier (Biswas 1962, p. 222). I am thankful to Mr Michel Desfayes
for pointing out this error to me.
Alcippe vinipectus diumbiensis (Kinnear): Eastern Whitebrowed
Tit-Babbler
Khumbu : Imja Valley : Yaral : 1 $ (3 May).
Measurements : 1 $ : Wing 55, tail 48, bill 1 1 .
Colours of bare parts : Iris creamy white ; upper mandible dark horny, lower
mandible pinkish fleshy with horny tip ; legs, feet and claws horny ; pads white.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
483
The Eastern Whitebrowed Tit-Babbler was common at certain locali-
ties in Khumbu between c. 3800 and 4000m during February-May, such
as the Base Camp in the Dudh Kosi Valley, and Thyangboche and
Yaral in the Imja Valley. It Was confiding in nature, occurring in loose
parties of 4-6 birds in scrub, and occasionally on the ground, spe*
cially at the edges of melting snow.
The gonad of the specimen had finely granular ova.
#Heterophasia capistrata (Vigors) : Blackheaded Sibia
The Blackheaded Sibia Was frequently observed and heard near
Chyaubas on Sangasoti Danda at c. 2150 m in Chautara district on 29
January, in the Likhu Valley, Ramechhap district, at c. 1740 m on 5
February, and later in the western slope of the Singalila Ridge, Dhan-
kuta district, on 1 and 2 July.
Subfamily Sylviinae
Phylloscopus affinis (Tickell): Tickell’s Leaf Warbler
Khumbu: Imja Valley: Dingboche : 4$ (18, 19, 21 April), Pangboche:
1 ? (29 April).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
4<J: 56,58,61,62 42,46,47,48 11-5,12, — (2)
1$: ■ 62 47 12
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, upper mandible dark horny, lower
mandible yellow, legs horny, feet and claws dark horny.
The Ticked’ s Leaf Warbler was first observed in Khumbu near Pare
during 26-30 March in very small numbers. Later, during mid-April-
May it was not so uncommon in the Base Camp area and in the Imja
Valley between c. 4300 and 4600 m. It usually occurred singly in scrub.
One of my male specimens (19 April) had but slightly enlarged gonads,
but all the other specimens, males and females, had them fairly Well
developed.
Phylloscopus ptildier pulcher Blyth: Eastern Orangebarred Leaf
Warbler
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Pare ( c . 4000 m) : 2 <? (1 April) ; Imja Valley :
Yaral : 1 $ (2 May). Dhankuta district : Chainpur : 1 — [in alcohol] (19
June).
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; upper mandible dark horny or black,
lower mandible horny or brown with yellow on base and black anterior half ; legs,
feet and claws brown or horny ; pads white, pale yellow or chrome yellow.
484 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (3)
This leaf warbler was not uncommon in Khumbu during April-
May, and in Chainpur area in mid- June. It occurred in pairs in bushes
and trees.
While the testes of one of the males taken on 1 April Was somewhat
enlarged, those of another male collected on the same day were fully
developed. The female (2 May) appeared to have already laid.
Phylloscopus proregulus chloronotus (G. R. Gray) : Nepal Leaf
Warbler
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : below Khumjung : 1 — (9 April) ; Imja Valley :
Yaral : 1 <J (3 May).
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; upper mandible black, lower mandible
yellow on basal half but horny anteriorly ; legs, feet and claws horny ; pads pale yellow.
The Nepal Leaf Warbler was seen only rarely in Khumbu. It occur-
red in pairs on trees during April-May.
The male specimen had fully developed testes.
Phylloscopus trochiloides trochiloides (Sundevall): Dull Green Leaf
Warbler
Khumbu : Imja Valley : Yaral : 2 ^ (2, 3 May).
Measurements : 2 $ : Wing 62*5, 63 ; tail 52, 52'5 ; bill 12, — .
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; upper mandible black, lower mandible
yellowish fleshy with horny tip ; legs, feet and claws horny ; pads pale yellow.
This leaf warbler did not appear to be common in Khumbu. Dur-
ing May it was found in pairs on trees.
The gonads of both the specimens were fully developed.
Phylloscopus reguloides reguloides (Blyth) : Blyth’s Leaf Warbler
Solu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Phakding : 1 (29 May).
Measurements : 1 : Wing 59, tail 45, bill — .
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, bill horny with yellow on edges and gape,
legs and feet greenish grey, claws pale horny.
This leaf warbler was noted only once in eastern Nepal, when the
specimen was collected. It occurred in a mixed feeding party on a tree.
The testes of the bird were fully enlarged.
Subfamily Muscicapinae
Ficedula strophiata strophiata (Hodgson) : Orangegorgetted Fly-
catcher
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Base Camp : 1 <2 (11 April).
Measurements : 1 <5 : Wing 76-5, tail 60, bill 13.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown , bill black, legs and feet horny, claws
dark horny.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
485
The Orangegorgetted Flycatcher was seen during the first half of April
in the vicinity of the Base Camp. It was found singly on scrub, and in
all only a few birds were sighted.
The testes of the specimen were fairly well developed.
#Niltava sundara Hodgson : Rufousbellied Niltava
This niltava was found only once in the Likhu Valley, Ramechhap
district, on 5 February at about 1830 m.
Culicicapa ceylonensis pallidior Ticehurst : Himalayan Greyheaded
Flycatcher
Okhaldhunga district : Hongu Valley : Bung : 1 — [in alcohol] (4 June).
Measurements : 1 — Wing 57, tail 48*5, bill 12.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; upper mandible dark horny, lower
mandible fleshy with horny tip ; legs, feet and claws fleshy brown.
Only a few individuals of the Greyheaded Flycatcher were seen in
eastern Nepal. In the forest above Bung a single example was found in a
mixed feeding party in the morning, and it Was collected. Later in the
day in the same area, two birds were seen carrying food presumably
into nests placed high up (about 5 m, and not visible, from the ground)
on tree-trunks thickly covered with epiphytes.
#Rhipidura hypoxantha Blyth : Yellowbellied Fantail Flycatcher
This flycatcher was first seen in mixed feeding parties on trees near
Those, Khimti Valley, Ramechhap district, in early February. During
March-April it was quite common in Khumbu between c. 3610 and 3960
m in the Dudh Kosi Valley, especially so in the Base Camp area late in
the mornings when sunlight flooded the area.
Family Paridae
Parus ater aemodius Hodgson : Himalayan Coal Tit
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Base Camp : 1 $ (3 March) ; Thami Valley :
Thami : 1 — [in alcohol] (18 March) ; Bhote Kosi Valley : Pare : 1 — (2 April).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
1 $ : 59 42 10-5
2 — : 56,60 41,44 11,—
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill black ; legs, feet and claws dark
slate grey.
The Himalayan Coal Tit was quite common in the Base Camp area
from February to May. It Was also found in the Bhote Kosi and Thami
Valleys at about 3800-4400 m during March and April.
The ovary of the female specimen (3 March) was not enlarged,
486 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
#Paras major Linnaeus : Grey Tit
We saw the Grey Tit only once, on the bank of the Charnawati
Khola, Ramechhap district, on 31 January at about 1000 m altitude.
*Parus monticola Vigors : Greenbacked Tit
This tit was observed only once in Khumbu, below Thyangboche at
about 3960 m in the Imja Valley on 25 February.
Parus nifoituchalis beavani (Jerdon): Sikkim Black Tit
Khumbu: Bhote Kosi Valley: Pare: 1 — [in alcohol] (27 March); Imja
Valley : Yaral : 1 <$, 1 $ (30 April, 1 May).
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, bill black, legs and feet bluish slaty,
claws black with bluish slaty on base.
In Khumbu the Sikkim Black Tit was found in the Dudh Kosi, Bhote
Kosi and Imja Valleys between c. 3655 and 4200 m during March-May.
The Yaral examples (30 April, 1 May) had fully developed gonads.
These Khumbu specimens are similar to Sikkim birds both in colora-
tion and in size.
Martens (1971b) has shown that the blackbellied P. rufonuchalis
and the rufousbellied P. rubidiventris are sympatric in west-central Nepal
during the summer when they do not occur in mixed pairs, and that they
have different call notes. They should, therefore, be treated as two dis-
tinct species ( contra Vaurie 1950, pp. 41-44 ; 1957, pp. 18-19).
Parus dichrous dichrous Hodgson : Brown Crested Tit
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Thammu : 1 <$ (2 April).
Measurements : 1 $ : Wing 74, tail 51, bill — .
Colours of bare parts : Iris reddish orange, bill black, legs and feet bluish slaty,
claws horny.
This tit was found in small numbers between c. 3650 and 4150 m in
Khumbu during February-May. It occurred in pairs in mixed feeding
parties .
The testes of the specimen were only slightly enlarged.
This specimen formed the basis of Biswas’s (1955) description of
Parus dichrous izzardi. However, Snow (in Vaurie 1957, pp. 39-40)
has shown that izzardi is a synonym of the nominate dichrous.
*Aeg it halos concinnus (Gould): Redheaded Tit
Several examples of the Redheaded Tit were spotted once in a mixed
feeding party near Serete (c. 2530 m), Likhu Valley, Ramechhap district?
on_5j; February.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
487
#Aegithalos iouschistos (Hodgson): Rufous fronted Tit
A small flock of about six examples of the Rufousfronted Tit was
sighted only once for a few minutes on the scrub below Lamjura Bhan-
jang at about 2745 m in the Likhu Valley, Ramechhap district, on 6
February.
Family Certhiidae
Certhia familiaris mandeliii Brooks : Mandelli’s Tree Creeper
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley: Base Camp: 1$, 1 — (3 March, 11 April);
Bhote Kosi Valley : Pare : 1 — [in alcohol] (1 April).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
1 $ : 63 48 15
2—: 61,63 —(2) 14*5,15
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; upper mandible very dark horny, lower
mandible pinkish white (once with dusky tip) ; legs, feet and claws horny to dark
horny ; pads white.
This tree creeper was observed only on a few occasions in Khumbu —
once below Thyangboche, Imja Valley, on 25 February, three or four
times in the Base Camp area between March and May, and once above
Pare on 1 April, all between the altitudes of c. 3800 and 4000 m.
The ovary of the female specimen (11 April) was enlarged.
Family Nectariniidae
#Aethopyga gonldiae (Vigors): Mrs Gould’s Sunbird
Mrs Gould’s Sunbird appeared uncommon in eastern Nepal, where
it was seen in Khumbu four times in the Bhote Kosi Valley at about 3655
m during February-May, once in Solu in the Dudh Kosi Valley at c. 3050
m in June, and twice in the Hongu Valley at about 3350 and 3655 m in
June.
*Aethopyga ignicauda (Hodgson): Fire tailed Sunbird
The Firetailed Sunbird was occasionally seen in Khumbu at c. 3050-
3655 m between February and May in Bhote Kosi and Dudh Kosi
Valleys.
Family Emberizidae
#Melophus lathami (J. E. Gray): Crested Bunting
The Crested Bunting was seen only once in eastern Nepal, in the
Bhota Kosi Valley, Ramechhap district, at c. 1370 m on 1 February,
488 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Family Fringillidae
Leucosticte nemoricola nemoricola (Hodgson): Hodgson’s Mountain
Finch
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Marlung : 1 $ (10 March) ; Thami Valley :
Gnachu : 1 A, 3 ? (23 March) ; Lobujya Valley : Phalong Karpo, between
Phalong Karpo and Thugla : 2 A (23, 24 April) ; Imja Valley : Yaral ; 1 $
(1 May).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
3 c?: 97,98,100 66,68,69 13,14(2)
5$: 93, 95 (2), 97, 97-5 64, 66 (3), 67 13-5, 14 (3), 14*5
Colours of bare parts : Iris brown, bill brown with yellow on base and gape,
legs and feet horny, claws dark horny, pads yellow.
This mountain finch was first seen near Lamjura Bhanjang at about
3650 m in Likhu Valley, Okhaldhunga district, on 6 February in a flock
of about 20 birds. Later, it was occasionally seen in Khumbu in flocks
of various sizes, e.g. about 10 at Marlung, 50 or more at Gnachu, 12-20
in Phalong Karpo-Thugla area, 10-12 at Yaral.
The gonads of the March birds were rudimentary, but those of April
and May were somewhat enlarged.
The Gnachu female specimens (23 March) are very worn on the head.
Thus, one of them is so Worn that the streaks on the head are obliterated,
presenting a uniform brown coloration from forehead to crown, with
traces of new feathers on the lores ; the second specimen is similar to the
last one, but its lores consist of all new feathers ; while in the third speci-
men moult has further advanced, so that it has all new feathers on the
lores and forehead. The Yaral female (1 May) is slightly worn, but the
rest of the specimens are in fresh plumage.
The male from Phalong Karpo has abnormal claws on its hind toes :
they are much longer than the normal ones.
Leucosticte brandti audreyana Stresemann : Sikkim Mountain Finch
Khumbu : Lobujya Valley : Thugla, Phalong Karpo : 1 $, 1 — [in alcohol]
(24 February, 26 April).
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill dark horny with yellow on base ;
legs, feet and claws black.
The Sikkim Mountain Finch was found only in the swampy area
between Pheriche and Thugla ( c . 4300-4700 m) during February and
May, occurring in flocks of about 20-50 birds.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
489
The ovary of the female specimen (26 April) had just commenced
swelling.
Carpodacus rhodochrous (Vigors): Pinkbrowed Rosefinch
Khumbu : Imja Valley : Yaral : 1 $ (4 May).
Measurements : 1 $ : Wing 72, tail 58, bill 1 15.
Colours of bare parts : Iris reddish brown, bill pale horny with paler lower
mandible, legs and feet brownish fleshy, claws horny.
The Pinkbrowed Rosefinch was found in Khumbu early in May in
the Imja Valley at about 3900 m. It occurred in small parties of about
four birds.
The testes of the specimen were not enlarged.
Carpodacus pulcherrimus pulcherrimus (Moore): Beautiful Rosefinch
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Thangmoche ( c . 4100 m ; 27°50/N, 86°39'E) :
1<J, 1? (8 March); Thami Valley: Thami : 2 c?, 2$ (18 March); Dudh
Kosi Valley : below Khumjung : 1 (9 April) ; Imja Valley : Pangboche :
2 ? (18 April), Dingboche : 3 <?, 1 — [in alcohol] (18-21 April) Yaral :
2 c? [1 in alcohol] (1 May).
Measurements :
Colours of bare parts: Iris brown to dark brown ; bill, legs and feet horny, some,
times lower mandible or legs paler ; claws black.
In Khumbu the Beautiful Rosefinch was a common bird between
c. 3800 and 4600 m during March-May. It occurred in juniper bushes,
sometimes several pairs sharing the same bush.
Four male and two female birds (18, 19 April, 1 May) had slightly
swollen gonads.
Rand & Fleming (1957, p. 206) cast doubt on the validity of waltoni
Sharpe from south-eastern Tibet on the basis of the wing measurements
of their Nepal birds. The chief difference between pulcherrimus and
waltoni is not in size, but, as Kinnear (1944, p. 352) has already stated,
in their coloration. From that point of view, waltoni should be reckoned
as a valid subspecies (see also Vaurie, 1959, p. 633).
One of the male specimens (Dingboche, 18 April) is in female plumage.
It had minute testes, while the others taken on the same day had them
slightly enlarged. In size, however, it is no smaller than the other males.
Carpodacus thura thura Bonaparte & Schlegel: Sikkim Whitebrowed
Rosefinch
Wing
76(3), 77(2), 78(3), 79
72-5, 74-5, 75(2), 77
75
Tail
60,61,62(3), 62-5, 63-5, 64
60,61,62, 63,64
62
Bill
12(3), 12*5(4), 13(2)
12(3), 12-5(2)
12
Khumbu : Imja Valley : Yaral : 1 <?, 1 ? (3, 4 May),
490 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Measurements :
Colours of bare parts: Iris dark brown, bill horny, legs and feet brownish horny,
claws black.
A few small loose parties of the Sikkim Whitebrowed Rosefinch were
observed in the Yaral area of the Imja Valley early in May.
The gonads of both the specimens were slightly enlarged.
Both the specimens have slightly worn rectrices.
Carpodacus puniceus puniceus (Blyth): Nepal Redbreasted Rosefinch
Khumbu : Ngojumba Valley : Chugima : 1 $ (14 May).
Measurements : 1 $ : Wing 108, tail 77, bill from skull 18, from anterior
edge of nostril 12*5.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill horny but lower mandible paler ;
legs, feet and claws black.
S'
Three pairs of this rosefinch forming a feeding party were found in
the Chugima area on 14 May.
The ovary of my specimen was somewhat enlarged.
The plumage is worn to some extent, and there is no yellow on the
breast.
Pyrrhula erythrocephala Vigors : Redheaded Bullfinch
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Hunko : 1 <J (17 March), Pare : 1 <J, 1 $ (1
April) ; Dudh Kosi Valley : Base Camp : 1 <J, 1 $ (5 April) ; Imja Valley ;
Yaral : 1 1 $ (1 May).
Measurements :
Wing Tail Bill
4 <? : 79-5, 80(2), 81 64(2), 67, 68 9*5, 10 (2), —
3$: 78-5,79,— 63,64,— 9-5, 10(2)
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown; bill black; legs pale horny; feet horny,
claws dark horny.
In Khumbu the Redheaded Bullfinch was not uncommon between
c. 3800 and 4100 m during March-May. It occurred in small parties of
two or three pairs, generally in clumps of ringal bamboo, and some-
times on rhododendrons also.
The gonads of the Hunko specimen (17 March) were not enlarged,
unlike in all the others (1 April- 1 May) in which they were somewhat
enlarged.
Mycerobas carnipes carnipes (Hodgson): Whitewinged Grosbeak
Khumbu : Dudh Kosi Valley : Tesinga : 1 tf, 1 $ (6 March); Base Camp :
1 9 (8 April) ; Imja Valley: Pangboche : 1 $ (18 April).
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
491
Measurements :
Colours of bare parts : Iris brown ; bill horny, paler on base and gape ; legs, feet
and claws horny.
This grosbeak appeared to be common only in certain areas of
Khumbu, specially where there are juniper trees. It is a noisy bird
occurring in small parties of four to six individuals.
The gonads of my two April birds were somewhat enlarged.
The male specimen from Pangboche (18 April), with somewhat en-
larged testes, is in female plumage except for a few black feathers on
the chin, throat and upper breast. It is finishing a complete moult :
the right lore is still in moult, the wing and body feathers are very fresh,
but the rectrices are slightly worn, indicating that they moulted first.
Like the Sikkim birds (Meinertzhagen 1927, pp. 376-77 ; Rand &
Fleming 1957, p. 208), my Nepal females also vary a great deal in wing
size.
Family Ploceidae
#Passer domesticus (Linnaeus): House Sparrow (altitude up to
c. 1520 m).
*Passer montanus (Linnaeus): Tree Sparrow (altitude c. 610-2140 m).
Family Sturnidae
*
#Acridotheres tristis (Linnaeus). Common Myna (altitude up to
c. 1830 m).
The above three birds were very common from Kathmandu to
extreme eastern Nepal in and about human settlements in the altitudinal
zones given against each.
* Acridotheres fuscus (Wagler): Jungle Myna
The Jungle Myna was observed once, outside the village Lamadihi
( c . 1050 m), Chautara district, on 26 January.
Family Dicruridae
#Dicrurus adsimilis (Bechstein) : Black Drongo
The Black Drongo was found from Kathmandu to far eastern Nepal
up to about 1830 m.
492 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Dicrurus leucophaeus longicaudatus A. Hay : Indian Grey Drongo
Dhankuta district : Chainpur : 1 $ (19 June).
Measurements: 1 $ : Wing 127 ; tail, length 131 -f-, depth of fork 39+ ; bill
28.
Colours of bare parts : Iris brick red ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
The Grey Drongo was a common bird of eastern Nepal between
c. 915 and 1830 m.
The plumage of the specimen is fairly Worn.
Family Corvidae
*Garrulus glandarius (Linnaeus) : Jay
A small party of the Jay, consisting of about six birds, was seen in a
pine forest below Manga Deorali, Ramechhap district, at about 1830 m
on 31 January.
*Cissa erythrorhyncha (Boddaert) : Redbilled Blue Magpie
Two parties of the Redbilled Blue Magpie, each of four to six birds,
were seen in the forest below Milke Bhanjang, Dhankuta district, in the
Tamur watershed, at about 1525 m on 28 June.
#Dendrocitta formosae Swinhoe : Himalayan Tree Pie
The Himalayan Tree Pie was observed once in the Irkhua Valley,
Bhojpur district, at about 1220 m on 7 June ; and later (13-28 Jane),
in Dhankuta district, several times in Chainpur area ( c . 1525 m), and in
the forests on both banks of the Tamur river (c. 1525 m) between Sango
and Taplejung.
*Nucifraga caryocatactes (Linnaeus) : N utcracker
The Nutcracker was heard in the forest between Khari an4 Puyian,
Dudh Kosi Valley, Solu, at about 2430 m on 9 February.
Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax himalayamis (Gould) : Himalayan Redbilled
Chough
Khumbu : Imja Valley : Dingboche : 1 S (20 April).
Measurements : 1 ^ : Wing 290+, tail 150+ +, bill, from base 62, from nostril
55, tarsus 54.
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown ; bill, legs and feet blood red, claws black.
The Redbilled Chough appeared to be common in Khumbu only at a
few places, such as Namche Bazar (in February), Dingboche (in April)
and below Phorcha (in May), where it was feeding in the fields in flocks
of 10-20 birds. A pair was also seen at Thyangbo on 23-24 March.
The testes of the specimen collected were somewhat enlarged.
The specimen has fairly worn rectrices.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
493
Pyrrhocorax graculus digitatus Hemprich & Ehrenberg : Himalayan
Yellowbilled Chough
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : opposite Marlung across river : 1 $ (14 March),
Colours of bare parts : Iris dark brown, bill yellow, legs and feet dusky coral red,
claws dark horny.
The Yellowbilled Chough was seen in pairs, loose parties or large
flocks in various parts of Khumbu. Thus, a pair was sighted on 22
February on the edge of the Khumbu glacier near its head (c. 5330 m) ;
large flocks in Bhote Kosi and Thami Valleys in March ; and pairs or
loose parties in May at Gokyo, Dudh Kosi Valley, where it was very
common.
During my stay at Marlung (10-16 March), it was observed that every
day at about midday a large flock of this chough flew from north south-
ward high up along the opposite bank of the Bhote Kosi. The same
flock was found on 28, 30 March and 1 April during visits to Hunko area
to split up into three smaller flocks high above Hunko, one heading west-
ward along the Thami Valley, another across the Bhote Kosi towards
the north of Samde, and the third continuing its flight south-south-
Westward over Pare.
The testes of my male specimens were somewhat enlarged.
The rectrices of the Pare birds (29 March) were fairly worn, and the
remiges and rectrices of the other specimen (14 March) slightly* worn.
Vaurie’s (1954, p. 7) measurements of eastern Himalayan birds are
much larger than mine from Khumbu. Other specimens present at the
Zoological Survey of India (only from Kashmir — Ladakh, Chitral, etc.)
are larger birds, and their measurements fit in with those given by
Vaurie. Dr Charles Vaurie, who examined my Khumbu material,
informed me (in litt.) that only the larger male from Pare ‘ is fully adult
. . . the wing and bill [of this specimen] are ... a little shorter than
in the specimens I had seen from eastern Himalayas \
#Corvus splendens Vieillot : House Crow
The House Crow was found from Kathmandu east to the eastern
border of Nepal wherever there were human habitations up to an altitude
of about 1525 m.
Corvus macrorhynchos intermedins Adams : Himalayan Jungle Crow
Khumbu : Bhote Kosi Valley : Namche Bazar : 1 d (9 April) ; Imja Valley :
Dingboche : 2d, 1 ? (19, 20 April) ; Lobujya Valley : Phalong Karpo : 1 d
(28 April).
494 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Colours of bare parts : Iris blackish brown ; bill, legs, feet and claws black.
The Himalayan Jungle Crow was found from Chautara district east to
extreme eastern Nepal above c. 610 m during January- July. In Khumbu, it
was found in almost all the valleys and occurred singly or in small parties.
All my specimens had enlarged gonads.
Dr Charles Vaurie, who has examined these specimens, informs me
(in lift.) that they 4 are much more similar to intermedins than they are to
tibetosinensis , even though a couple (especially 28119) [ = cT, Namche
Bazar] have the bill slightly larger than normal in intermedins. One
would expect this sort of thing in eastern Nepal. At any rate, your birds
are not glossy enough and are too white at the base of the nape feathers
to be tibetosinensis \
Acknowledgements
I am thankful to Dr Charles Vaurie of the American Museum of
Natural History, New York, for kindly comparing some of my material
with his, and to my colleague Dr K. K. Tiwari for his helpful suggestions
in the preparation of this manuscript.
References
Ali, S. & Ripley, S. D. (1973) : Hand-
book of the Birds of India and Pakistan,
9 : 137. Oxford Univ. Press, Bombay.
Biswas, B. (1955) : Zoological results
of the ‘ Daily Mail ’ Himalayan Expedi-
tion 1954. Two new birds from Khumbu,
eastern Nepal. Bull. Br. orn. Cl. 75 :
87-8.
(1960-1964) : The birds of
Nepal (parts 1-11). J. Bombay nat.
Hist. Soc. (1960) 57 ; 278-308 ; (1961)
57: 516-46; 58: 100-134, 441-74;
(1962) 58 : 653-77; 59 : 200-227, 405-29 ;
(1963) 59 : 807-21; 60 : 173-200, 388-99 ;
(1964) 60 : 638-54.
(1969) : Some new bird
records for Nepal. /. Bombay nat.
Hist. Soc. 65 : 782-4.
& Khajuria, H. (1957) :
Zoological results of the ‘ Daily Mail ’
Himalayan Expedition 1954. Notes on
some mammals of Khumbu, eastern
Nepal. Proc. zool. Soc., Calcutta,
Mookerjee memor. vol. : 229-53.
Diesselhorst, G. (1968) : Beitrage
zur Okologie der Vogel Zentral- und Ost-
Nepals. In Hellmich, W. (ed.) : Khumbu
Himal 2 : 1-417. Univ. Verl. Wagner,
Miinchen.
Fleming, R. L. (1968) : Nepal birds :
Supplement to Biswas’ list. J. Bombay
nat. Hist. Soc. 65 : 326-34.
& Traylor, M. A. (1961) :
Notes on Nepal birds. Fieldiana (Zool.)
35 : 443-87.
— & (1964) : Further
notes on Nepal birds. Fieldiana (Zool.)
35 : 491-558.
— — & (1968) : Distri-
butional notes on Nepal birds. Fieldiana
(Zool.) 53 : 147-203.
BIRDS OF EASTERN NEPAL
Gray, J. E. (1863) : Catalogue of the
specimens and drawings of mammals,
birds,, reptiles and fishes of Nepal and
Tibet, presented by B. H. Hodgson,
Esq., to the British Museum. Br. Mus.,
London.
KinNear, N. B. (1922) : On the birds
collected by Mr. A. F. R. Wollaston
during the First Mt. Everest Expedition.
Ibis, (11) 4: 495-526.
(1944) : In Ludlow, F. The
birds of south-eastern Tibet. Ibis 86 :
348-89.
Martens, J. (1971a) : Zur Kenntnis
des Vogelzuges im nepalischen Himalaya.
Vogelwarte 26: 113-28.
(1971b) : Artstatus von
Parus rufonuchalis Blyth. J . Orn. 112 :
451-8.
Meinertzhagen, R. (1927) : Syste-
matic results of birds collected at high
altitudes in Ladak and Sikkim. 1. Ibis
(12)3 : 363-421.
Rand, A. L. & Fleming, R. L. (1957) :
Birds from Nepal. Fieldiana (Zool.)
41 : 1-218.
495
Ripley, S. D. (1950) : Birds from
Nepal 1947-1949. J. Bombay nat. Hist .
Soc. 49 : 355-417.
(1961) : A synopsis of the
birds of India and Pakistan. Bombay
Natural History Society, Bombay.
Stevens, H. (1923-1925) : Notes on
the birds of the Sikkim Himalaya (parts
1-7). /. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. (1923)
29: 503-18, 723-40; (1924) 29: 1007-
30, 30 : 54-71 ; (1925) 30 : 352-79, 664-
85, 872-93.
Vaurie, C. (1950) : Notes on some
Asiatic titmice. Am. Mus. Novit.
(1459) : 1-66.
(1954) : Systematic notes on
Palearctic birds. 5. Corvidae. Am.
Mus. Novit. (1668) : 1-23.
(1957) : Systematic notes on
Palearctic birds. 27. Paridae : the genera
Parus and Sylviparus. Am. Mus. Novit.
(1852) : 1-43.
(1959) : The birds of the
Palearctic fauna. Passeriformes.
Wither by, London.
10
The Fauna of Narcondam Island1
Part 1. Birds
Humayun Abdulali
In the Journal for August 1971, I had a note on a fleeting visit
to Narcondam Island in the Bay of Bengal, when I could only stay for a
few hours . It was evident that a regular collecting trip Was necessary
over a longer period and with the assistance of the Charles McCann
Vertebrate Zoology Field Work Fund (see J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc.
70 : 244) I arranged for Messrs S. A. Hussain, Research Assistant,
Bombay Natural History Society, and N. J. George, Assistant, Natural
History Section, Prince of Wales Museum, Bombay, to visit the island.
They reached Port Blair on 12 March 1972 and on the 14th left by
a police launch via Maya Bunder in North Andamans arriving at
Narcondam on 16 March. They stayed till the 14th April and during
this time collected 48 birds, some mammals, reptiles, and other zoo-
logical material. The present paper deals with the birds. The field
notes, unless otherwise specified, are from the notes kept by Messrs
Hussain and George. The number of birds noted and/or collected is
very small, and hardly half a dozen species, including the hornbill dis-
covered just a hundred years ago, are resident. For the sake of complete-
ness the earlier notes and specimens in the Bombay collection are incor-
porated. Mr Hussain also assisted me at the Society’s rooms while I
was working out the collection.
The collection though smaller than anticipated includes the following
new records:
Dicrurus leucophaeus leucogenys
Muscicapa parva albicilla
Phylloscopus inornatus inornatus
Phylloscopus tenellipes tenellipes
Zoothera sibirica davisoni
Thirty-three birds collected in the Andaman Islands on the journey to and
from Narcondam are not dealt with in this note.
The serial numbers relate to S. Dillon Ripley’s a synopsis of the
birds of India and Pakistan (1961) with additions made in subsequent
literature. The measurements are in millimetres. I am grateful to
Dr Ripley and his Research Assistant Mr Gorman M. Bond at the
Smithsonian Institution for the identification of some of the specimens,
particularly the Phylloscopi.
1 Received September 1973.
THE FAUNA OF NARCONDAM ISLAND. PART 1. BIRDS 497
43 Ardeola bacchus (Bonaparte). Chinese Pond Heron
1 ? 3 April 1970
Not seen on this trip.
51 Egretta sacra (Gmelin). Eastern Reef Heron
1<J 12 April 1972
Frequently seen on rocks, all dark grey.
The tails are slightly smaller than recorded in fauna and repeated in
INDIAN HANDBOOK (1 : 77).
7 84-91 av. 87*7 ; 2 84, 88 ; (ih 93-98)
Accipiter sp.
I had noted a small dark hawk (chasing a kingfisher) which remains
unidentified. Osmaston (1905) saw two small hawks resembling Astur
in flight circling round the top of the mountain.
173 Haliaeetus leucogaster (Gmelin). Whitebellied Sea Eagle
Quite frequently seen on island — four at one time.
As on the last occasion this bird was seen being mobbed by hornbills.
345 Amaurornis plioemcurus insularis Sharpe. Andaman White-
breasted Waterhen
1 $ 23 April 1970
Only seen in one area.
386 Numenius phaeopus variegatus (Scopoli). Whimbrel
1 $ 8 April 1972
Frequently seen. Settled in trees along shore. When cataloguing
the birds in the Bombay Collection, I said that I was unable to decide if
any of the material was variegatus and listed all, including birds from the
Andaman and Nicobar Islands, under the nominate race. We have since
received by exchange a pair of variegatus from Japan, and it does appear
that some of the specimens, particularly those from the Andaman and
Nicobar islands, are of this race, being distinguished by :
(a) the streaking/marking on the lower back and the rump contra
pure white,
(b) the heavier and duskier markings on the upperparts,
(c) the heavier streaking on the breast, extending further on to
the belly and the flanks,
(i d ) the barring on the axillaries being more pronounced and heavier,
all the bars meeting at the shaft in the centre.
Two specimens, Nos. 21910 (Andamans) and 23260 (Camorta, Nicobars),
agree completely with the Japanese birds. Seven others (1 Pulicat,
Madras, 1 Narcondam, 2 Andamans, 2 Car Nicobar, 1 Great Nicobar)
498 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. li (3)
do not show all the characters listed above, but appear to be different from
specimens from western India. Though I can find no references to
seasonal changes of plumage, it may be mentioned that all the western
specimens were obtained in August-November while the eastern birds are
between March and May. Curiously, the 9 western birds include only
one female, while 8 of the 1 1 eastern are females.
The specimen obtained on Narcondam has a white rump, but shows
the other characters of variegatus. Provision would perhaps have to be
made for an intermediate population showing characters of both races.
The two groups show no differences in size but the wing measurements
are smaller than those indicated for European birds in handbook of
BRITISH BIRDS (4 : 176) I
Wing Bill Tail
11 <?c? Indian & Japanese 224-238 av. 232 62-84 av. 76-5 91-97 av. 93*5
(BR. HAND. 232-250 76-86 87-99)
9?$ Indian & Japanese 229-247 av. 238 77-90 av. 84*5 89-102 av. 97
(br. hand. 243-265 80-90 — )
401 Tringa hypoleucos Linnaeus (Sweden). Common Sandpiper
1 $ 8 April 1972
Frequent.
402 Arenaria interpres interpres (Linnaeus). Turnstone
Noted by Osmaston (1905).
471 Sterna anaethetus anaethetus Scopoli. Brownwinged Tern
On 23 April 1969, a male settled on the boat off Narcondam.
508a Ducula aenea andamanica Abdulali. Andaman Green Imperial
Pigeon
3 :1c?* 1 $ lo?
Wing 235*, 229, 232 ; bill 24, 25, 27* ; tail 145(3)
No evidence of nesting, but frequently seen in ones and twos.
All three are shiny green above and have shorter tails than the
Andaman birds (cfcT 155-161,$? 154-162), but a cT collected on an earlier
trip is darker above and measures wing 239, tail 157. One wonders if
the extent of the sheen on the upperparts is just an individual variation,
as apparently accepted.
509 Ducula bicolor (Scopoli). Pied Imperial Pigeon
2:1c? 1$
None were visible near the camp, but a nesting colony was found on
a rocky islet, about 70 feet high, off the north coast, which could be waded
to at low tide. Small trees grew out of the cracks in the rocks, and one
about 12 feet high held 8 nests, all of the usual sketchy type distinctive
THE FAUNA OF NARCONDAM ISLAND . PART 1. BIRDS 499
of the family. When examined, most of the nests held a single chick,
of various ages, while others still contained an egg. Some of the nests
could be reached by hand by climbing up the hillside. The number of
nests was estimated at about a hundred. When disturbed the birds
flew directly to the main island and settled on trees. Occasionally, three
or four would soar high up and drop downwards together for some dis-
tance on closed wings, and then glide away to a perch.
Streptopelia orientalis subsp. Rufous Turtle-Dove
George twice noted a pigeon which he thought was this species but
no specimen was obtained.
544 Chalcophaps indica maxima Hartert. Emerald Dove
1 $ Wing 143 ; bill 18 ; tail 89
A few seen.
The single specimen appears nearest to another female from Camorta,
Central Nicobar (Abdulali 1967 : 168).
548 Psittacula eupatria magnirostris (Ball). Large Andaman Parakeet
2 $$ Wing 194, 204; bill 37, 38 ; tarsus 19, 19; tail 300, 304.
Common. Three pairs Were nesting at varying heights on one
Salmalia insigne on the shore line near the camp. All the nests
contained young and their chiri .... chrr was often heard outside.
A female collected had her mouth full of caterpillars !
[555 Psittacula longicaudata tytleri (Hume). Redcheeked Parakeet
Hume (1874, Stray Feathers 2 : 184) refers to this species being found
on Barren and Narcondam islands, but Osmaston has already suggested
that the latter record was in mistake.]
592 Eudynamys scolopacea dolosa Ripley. Andaman Koel
5 : 3 $$ 2 $$ 22nd to 28th March 1972.
Wing Bill Tarsus Tail
AS 195, 196, 209 30, 31, 1-1 32, 32, 33 190, 190, 203
£$ 190,200 32,32 35,35 184,185
Upon arrival they were very common but they appeared to have
diminished in number by mid April. The several calls were prominent
early in the morning and in the evening, and sometimes at night. Some
of the specimens were very fat on the belly, and there was no evidence
of their breeding here. Osmaston (1905) had noted them as common in
early October and thought they were cold-weather visitors.
618a Otus scops modestus (Walden). Andaman Scops Owl
One caught in a net on 8th April was pulled out and completely
destroyed by one of the dogs in the camp. The few breast-feathers and
500 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
portions of a wing which were recovered agree closely with the single $
from South Andamans available for comparison.
The call whoo-uk , whoo-uk heard at night, high up on the hill, was
attributed to this species.
679 Caprimulgus macrurus subsp. Jungle Nightjar
A chaunk chaunk heard at night high up on the hill suggests this spe-
cies Which has a resident race in the Andamans.
Apus sp.
I had noted (1971) large black swifts soaring out of range. Hussain
and George report some large swifts circling round a pair of soaring Sea
Eagles much too high to attempt an identification.
Ccllocalia sp.
Numbers were seen (‘ thousands at the summit ’) but in the absence
of specimens it is not possible to add anything to my querying of Osmas-
ton’s record of C. brevirostris innominata from Narcondam.
739 Halcyon pileata (Boddaert). Blackcapped Kingfisher
1 $ 30 April 1970 ; 1 ? 27 March 1972
Single birds were noted at three places along the shore.
These two females together with a third from Trinkut, Central
Nicobars, appear to be brighter in colour than the others available from
India.
748 Merops philippinus philippinus Linnaeus. Blue tailed Bee-eater
Noted by Osmaston, on passage (?), in early October.
1 9
762a Eurystomus orientalis subsp. Broadbilled Roller
l $
In my last report (1971), I had referred to a single specimen with a
very small bill obtained on Narcondam Island on 29 April 1970 which did
not agree with any of the described races. Curiously, this large and
conspicuous bird was not seen on the present trip.
773 Rhyticeros (undulatus) narcondami (Hume). Narcondam Hornbill
This was easily the most abundant species on the island and breeding
was in full swing in March/April, some 73 nests of the standard hornbill
type being noted at varying heights above about 6 ft. Hussain kept a
daily list of male and female sightings and over the stay of 24 days, 728
male and 149 female sightings were recorded. The disparity in numbers
is probably due to the females being mostly imprisoned in their nests,
and the males being seen following regular lines of flight to'and from the
nests.
THE FAUNA OF NARCONDAM ISLAND. PART 1. BIRDS 501
/ Two nests examined contained 2 eggs/young each.
Seeds of fruit eaten by both (?) the female and the young were piled
up at the bottom of the nest. At least eight different species were pro-
minent but even with the assistance of the Botanical Survey of India, it
has only been possible to identify tvfo—Anamirta cocculus (L.) W. & A.
(Menispermaceae) and Bassia longifolia (L.) Macbride (Sapotaceae).
One egg, dirty brownish white in colour, measured 45 X 33.
A hornbill was seen chasing a male Koel and reference has already
been made to several together mobbing a fishing eagle.
Two young, a male and a female, taken from the same nest have
been brought to Bombay and now live noisily at the Society’s premises
in Hornbill House.
The species is protected and appears to be thriving on the island.
Unless commercialized in some manner, I do not think that it is in
danger and it need not have been put on to the I.U.C.N. Red List.
917 Hirundo rustica gutturalis Scopoli. Eastern Swallow
\s 1? 9 April 1972. Wing 112, 113
Considerable numbers appeared to be present on the island through-
out the period and large numbers (‘ several hundreds ’) flew low over the
bay during a drizzle on the day after a storm. On my last visit I had
noted a large swallow with whitish underparts and a forked tail, which
I could not identify.
950 Lanius cristatus lucionensis Linnaeus. Philippine Brown Shrike
1 o? 29 March 1972
A few seen.
This and another cT obtained on South Andaman on 20 April
1972 have grey heads and no bars on underparts.
966b Dicrurus leucophaeus leucogenys (Walden). Whitecheeked Grey
Drongo
1 3 24 March 1972
Others were seen in the same area. When picked up, hair-like
feathers were noticed at the nape which are now seen with difficulty.
Similar hair can be seen in dark specimens of the same species from
Bhutan and the Eastern Ghats.
The subspecific identity has been determined by Mr Bond. This is
an interesting record of this race from Indian limits, as one sent from the
Andamans by Capt. Wimberley and identified by Hume as leucogenys
has appeared under D. 1. salangensis Reichenow in Indian handbook
(5 : 122). Mr Bond has drawn attention to the fact that the tail is in
moult with the feather sheaths present, the dark tail-feathers being shed
during the first winter and being replaced by grey ones, which in the
present specimen project beyond the fork in the tail.
502 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (3)
1018 Gracula religiosa andamanensls (Beavan). Andaman Hill Myna
1 $ 23 April 1969 ; 1 $ 20 March 1972, ovaries enlarged
Small parties seen from time to time.
The two females (1 collected on an earlier trip) from Narcondam
resemble andamanensis but are larger (wing 169, 170 contra 160-166 av.
162*7 ; tail 80, 89 contra 71-82 av. 77*75) and tend towards the Central
Nicobar birds.
1407 Muscicapa latirostris Raffles. Brown Flycatcher
lo? 12 April 1972
This is a well-known winter visitor to the Andamans, Car Nicobar,
and to Camorta, Central Nicobars.
1412 Muscicapa parva albicilla Pallas. Eastern Redbreasted Flycatcher
1 <? 22 March 1972
This was identified by Mr Bond and is a new record, not only from
Narcondam, but also from the Andaman group. Incidentally While
attempting its identification it was noticed that three males of Af.
subrubra in the Bombay Natural History Society collection from Kashmir
(2) and Point Calimere, in distinctive plumage, have the second primary
shorter than the sixth as required in the Key in the Indian handbook
(7 : 139) and not shorter than seventh as stated on page 159 (loc. cit.).
1549 Phragamaticola aedon aedon (Pallas). Thickbilled Warbler
1 29 March 1972
In Indian literature the nominate race is accepted in the Andamans
and Nicobars but Dementiev and others in birds of the soviet union
(1968) refer to rufescens Stegmann as the subspecies found in this area.
With the material available it is not possible to confirm or deny this.
1586 Phylloscopus fuscatus fuscatus (Blyth). Siberian Dusky Leaf
Warbler
1 <? 1 o ? 26 and 31 Mareh 1972
1592 Phylloscopus inornatus inomatus (Blyth). Siberian Yellow-
browed Leaf Warbler
1£ lo? 26 and 31 March 1972
This species has not been recorded previously from the Andaman
and Nicobar islands.
1612a Phylloscopus tenellipes tenellipes Swinhoe. Palelegged Leaf
Warbler
3 <?<? on 22, 23 and 29 March 1972
Except for a single specimen captured on a boat 10 miles east of Great
Nicobar, there is no record of this species either from these islands or
anywhere in Indian limits.
THE FAUNA OF NARCONDAM ISLAND . PART 1. BIRDS 503
1732a Zoothera slbirica davisoni (Hume). Siberian Thrush
1 (J 6 April 1972
One was collected out of a party of four high up the hill where other
birds Were conspicuous by their absence. This was identified by
Mr Bond. The only traceable record from the Andamans is a female (?)
collected by Capt. Hodge at Port Blair and described as a new species
Oreocincla inframarginata by Blyth Jour. Asiat. Soc. Bengal 29 : 106 ;
1860. If further evidence shows that the Siberian Thrushes visiting this
area are not of the nominate race, the name inframarginata would have
priority over davisoni.
1762 Turdus obscurus Gmelin. Dark Thrush
2 23 April 1969 and 20 April 1970
I had commented (op. cit.) on the last two trips each yielding a speci-
men of this thrush. It was not seen on this occasion.
1864 Anthus cervinus (Pallas). Redthroated Pipit
1 <? 5 April 1972. Wing 85 ; bill 12 ; tail 59
Only one seen on the edge of the forest.
In length, the bill can be matched with that of another from Prome,
Burma, but it is much heavier than any of the seven redthroated adults
available for comparison.
1874 Motacilla indica Gmelin. Forest Wagtail
1 $ 29 March 1972. Wing 77 (77-81) ; tail 68 (65-68)
Osmaston had seen it in the first week of October ; the present
specimen was one of several seen.
1875/6 Motacilla flava subsp.
1<J
These birds were common on the rocks on the shore and would visit
the drip from the freshwater pipe.
1884 Motacilla caspica subsp. Grey Wagtail
4 : 3 1 $ 18, 20(2) and 28 March 1972. Wing 80(2), 82, 83 ; tail 87, 88,
89, 90
Two males are in almost full breeding plumage.
Vaurie (1959, birds of pal. fauna : 87) accepts C. L. Brehm’s robusta
with tail 80-96 mm contra 92-103 in nominate caspica (cine re a). In an
earlier paper, he has noted the nominate race from Andamans. The
present specimens suggested the eastern form, but an examination of
26 males from Iraq, Chitral, Garhwal, Simla, Bombay and Kerala, in
the Bombay collection, shows a tail range of 76-92 av. 87. Are they all
robusta ?
504 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
1913 Nectarinia jugularis andamanica (Hume). Yellowbreasted or
Olivebacked Sunbird
5 : 3 cJc? 2 $$
The Narcondam birds have slightly larger wings than those from the
Andamans, but the series available does not show any noticeable difference
in colour.
5 Andaman $$
4 Narcondam $$
3 Andaman $$
2 Narcondam $$
(fauna
Wing
52, 53, 54(3)
56, 56-5, 58, 59
50, 53, 53
52*5, 55
52-58
Bill
19, —
19, 20, 20, 21
17-5, 19,—
18, 19-5
18-19
Tail
33.34
34, 36, 36, 37
29-5,31,31
29.34
32-38)
The measurements include those of 3 males from Andamans borrowed
from the Zoological Survey of India.
Osmaston (1905) said it was the commonest bird on the island
and chiefly frequented the shore. An old typically sunbird nest was
found about 3 feet from the ground.
As this paper is being published in the Salim Ali Festschrift
I take the opportunity of adding a few words. Salim Ali was
perhaps the first man I saw going round the countryside with a
pair of Zeiss 8 x 40 slung round his neck. Having been permitted
to peep through them, the acquirement of a similar pair became one of
my life’s ambitions, which I was fortunately able to realize with the help
of a Sunday paper puzzle ! In the early thirties I spent three long
college holidays with him in Hyderabad and Travancore where he was
carrying out ornithological surveys. During these expeditions, I got my
first real introduction to collecting and field Work and, a few years later,
we jointly produced the birds of Bombay and salsette, the precursor
of the several popular books which he has since written.
Most ornithological work in India has been carried out by people
in the Imperial Services, keenly enthusiastic, but hindered by the fact
firstly that they could only undertake the work as a hobby and, secondly,
that they had no control over their transfers and movements and so no
continuity of work was possible. Workers like E. C. Stuart Baker, Hugh
Whistler, and C. B. Ticehurst carried on after retirement, but this work
was necessarily of a taxonomic nature.
Over the last 50 years and even perhaps today, there is no living for a
wholetime ornithologist in India. Salim Ali however carried on and
succeeded in making his hobby a successful profession enabling him to
assist further research in the ornithological field. His position in Indian
ornithology is unique, and will no doubt be sustained as such by his
many books.
THE FAUNA OF NARCONDAM ISLAND. PART 1. BIRDS 505
References
Abdulali, Humayun (1964): The
birds of the Andaman and Nicobar
islands. J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc.
61(3): 483-571.
(1967) : The birds of
Nicobar Islands with notes on some
Andaman birds, ibid. 64(2) : 139-190.
Abdulali, Humayun (1971) : Nar-
condam Island and notes on some
birds from the Andaman Islands, ibid.
68(2) : 385-411.
Osmaston, B. B. (1905) : A visit to
Narcondam. ibid. 16 : 620-2,
Adaptations of Andean and Tibetan
birds: a brief comparison1
Jean Dorst
National Museum of Natural History , Paris
The Andes and Tibet — the Roof of the World — are the most formidable
and extensive mountain assemblages of the world. Both constitute tem-
perate or cold plateaux over which rise very high mountains surrounded
by tropical or semi-tropical warm habitats at least for a part. Animals
which succeeded the colonization of these regions had to adapt not only
to altitude, but to its ecological consequences, particularly a harsh climate
and a scarce vegetal cover.
Of course conditions differ to a great extent in both areas, above all
in consequence of the different latitudes under which they lie. The
high Andes from Colombia to Peru are located within the intertropical
zone, whereas Tibet has a more northern situation and its northern
border is contiguous to cold regions. Nevertheless, as many ecological
features are similar, it is worthwhile to compare the evolution and
convergent ecological adaptations of the Andean and of the Tibetan
avifaunas.
Comparisons can also be made with the high mountains of Africa,
though the African montane habitats merely constitute small ‘islands’
isolated amidst warm tropical lowlands. In spite of their very special-
ized fauna, they are not similar to the other high mountains in regard to
speciation and faunal differentiation. Ethiopia is the only part of
Africa where corresponding geographical conditions occur, as there
is an extensive highland area, but average altitude is lower and birds
have to face less sevefe ecological factors.
This paper mostly refers to the Northern plateau of Tibet (Chang
Tang) and to the high Andes of Ecuador and Peru (the Chilean sector
differs widely by its climate and ecological conditions), and mentions only
briefly the African mountains. It considers only a few of the adaptations
of birds established in the upper zone, above about 4000 m, where open
habitats are largely dominant.
In both areas, climate is very harsh. In the Andes, mean tempera-
tures are relatively low, the annual mean temperature averaging 1-2°C
in the region of lake Titicaca. There is a wide daily range, sometimes
1 Received August 1972.
ADAPTATIONS OF ANDEAN AND TIBETAN BIRDS 507
from — 15°C at night to + 15°C and more during the day. The nor-
thern sector is humid, due to high rainfall, well distributed through a
good part of the year. The southern sector is much drier, as rainfall
is concentrated during the austral summer and as the dry season is long
and very severe ; dryness and cold are exaggerated by strong winds.
There is no snow under 4000 m, except during brief storms, after which
it rapidly melts.
In the part of Tibet considered here, climate is still more severe.
Temperatures are very low, and may fall well below freezing during
any part of the year (temperatures of — 44°C have been recorded).
Rains are restricted to a short period during the summer. Thus dryness
is an important feature, accentuated by strong and almost permanent
winds. Snow may cover the soil for long periods, even in summer.
Climatic conditions are definitely more severe than in the Andes, parti-
cularly in winter, due to cold and snow.
It is not surprising that such conditions strongly influenced the
vegetal cover. Arboreal vegetation is absent from the upper level,
except in a very few places. Grassy alpine steppes predominate across
flat expanses, valley beds or plateaux, formed of coarse tufts of Gramineae
between which grow a small variety of herbaceous plants and sparse
bushes. Shrubs and other ligneous plants only grow in sheltered places,
close to cliffs or on well exposed slopes. Beyond a certain altitude,
around 5000 m, but varying according to local conditions, the landscape
is barren and rocky habitats maintain the last vestige of vegetation.
Birdlife reaches the limits of permanent snow. In the Andes, various
birds such as Thinocorus orbignyianus, Cinclodes fuscus , Geositta cuni-
cularia and even hummingbirds such as Patagona gigas are observed
up to 5000 m. In Tibet Pyrrhocorax graculus , Grandala coelicolor
Prunella collaris and Carpodacus puniceus commonly live at elevations of
5700 m. Practically birdlife ends at the upper limit of vegetation. But
birds were recorded at much higher altitudes, particularly in Tibet, Where
Anthus novaeseelandiae , Phoenicurus ochruros , Columba rupestris , Corvus
corax , C. macrorhynchos, Upupa epops and Prunella collaris were ob-
served at well over 6000 m, and Pyrrhocorax graculus at 8229 m ; geese
have been reported as flying at a height above that of Mt Everest (8847 m)
during migrations (quoted by Vaurie 1972). Apparently they live with
perfect ease in spite of the incredible effort needed just to fly.
Evolution and speciation
It is needless to say that the avifaunas of these two regions differ
fundamentally by their origin and that they have no relationship, except
a few ubiquitous birds represented in each area by allied species. The
508 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Andean avifauna derives from stocks which emigrated from the surround-
ing lowlands or from Patagonia from where a series of birds spread north-
wards. The avifauna of Tibet, and particularly of the part concerned,
is chiefly of Palearctic origin, though a few Sino-Himalayan elements
penetrated even the Chang Tang (7 species according to Vaurie 1972).
In spite of different origin, birdlife shows some astonishing convergences
and parallelisms in evolution due to identical factors of the environment
to which they had to adapt.
Both avifaunas are greatly impoverished when compared to those of
nearby lowlands. Climate acted as an efficient filter and eliminated a
large number of potential colonizers, particularly those which are partial
to closed habitats. The upper Andes are inhabited by 153 species,
aquatic birds excluded (Vuilleumier), and the northern plateau of Tibet
by 175, among which only 67 are found on the Chang Tang. Both
avifaunas are more diversified than their African counterpart. In Africa
only 74 species are met in the montane non-forest zones, which due to
its limited surface, have never been active centres of differentiation in
contrast to the forests which surround them (Moreau 1966).
In the Andes and in Central Asia, very active adaptative radiation
occurred in relation to isolation. Andean ‘ islands 5 conform to archi-
pelagos in many ways, in spite of some differences (Vuilleumier 1970).
Though adaptative radiation interferes with geographic speciation, which
also reaches a very high degree in mountains as a consequence of dis-
continuity of ranges and variety of habitats, lack of competition due to
the limited number of original stocks favoured differentiation of sym-
patric species occupying various niches. In the Andes this phenomenon
affects particularly Furnariidae ( Geositta , Upucerthia , Cinclodes,
Asthenes ), Tyrannidae ( Muscisaxicola ) and Fringillidae ( Spinus , Sicalis,
Phrygilus).
In Tibet, adaptative radiation occurs among Turdidae ( Phoenicurus
is represented by 9 of its 11 species), Fringillidae ( Carpodacus , With 14 of
the 17 species of the Old World; Rhodopechys , with 3 of the 4 species uf
the genus) and Ploceidae ( Montifringilla , with 6 of the 7 species of the
genus, 4 being endemic ; ecological differentiation is particularly visible
among Snow Finches, each species being adapted to a well defined habitat).
It is worthwhile to note that granivorous birds radiated intensively*
probably in relation to the diversity and the large amount of seeds
available in these habitats. The Andes and Tibet have been very impor-
tant evolutionary centres, a fact also attested by the number of
characteristic species, endemic or having secondarily spread over larger
areas .
In contrast adaptative radiation did not occur in the montane non-
forest zones of Africa, even in Ethiopia, probably as a consequence of
the limited areas involved.
Adaptations of andean and tibetan birds 509
Parallel evolution
In spite of their completely different origin, the Andean and the
Tibetan faunas show striking parallelisms. Homologous species differen-
tiated in the same type of habitat, due to similarities of available eco-
logical niches. In a very few cases, they belong to the same genus. Thus
pipits of the genus Anthus nest on the high Andean plateaux (A. corren-
dera , A. furcatus , A. bogotensis) and in Tibet (A. roseatus ), apparently
in the same type of habitat. Many raptors, such as representatives of
the genera Buteo and Bubo and grebes (. Podiceps ) are found in both areas,
where they occupy the same niches. But in most cases, birds originate
from very different stocks and show remarkable convergences. In Tibet,
Snowcock Tetraogallus tibetanus peculiar to stony habitats, Partridges
Perdix hodgsoniae, and Sandgrouse Syrrhaptes tibetanus peculiar to
grassland, occupy somewhat the niche filled in the Andes by various
tinamous, and maybe also by Seedsnipes Thinocorus orbignyianus. Several
Tibetan larks ( Calandrella cinerea , C. acutirostris , Eremophila alpestris ,
Melanocorypha maxima) and wheatears ( Oenanthe deserti) are the eco-
logical equivalents of various Andean Furnariidae, particularly represen-
tatives of the genera Geositta and Upucerthia , many of which show similar
morphology, pattern and even behaviour. Many similitudes also exist
among seedeaters, well represented in both areas. In the Andes, birds
belonging to the genera Phrygilus, Sicalis , Spinus and Zonotrichia are
well diversified and their populations abundant through most of the
habitats, particularly in grasslands which cover extensive surfaces on the
altiplano. In Tibet, birds of the genera Montifringilla, Acanthis, Leuco *
sticte and Carpodacus occupy the same niches and are just as numerous.
Among insectivores, Phoenicurus can in some way be considered as
the equivalent of various Tyrannidae, such as Muscisaxicola and
Oehtoeca.
It can be admitted that at least at some levels, the Andean and the
Tibetan ecosystems have the same structure and that birds of different
origins play the same role in the ecology of these two regions. In con*
trast there are differences, due to geographical and ecological features.
Aquatic avifauna is Well diversified on the Andean high plateaux in
relation to the wealth of lakes and Wetlands. A series of ducks (Anas
flavirostris , A. puna , A. spinicauda, A. specularioides, Oxyuraferruginea),
grebes (Podiceps rolland, P. occipitalis ), coots (Fulica americana , F,
gigantea ), Ardeiformes (Plegadis ridgwayi, Nycticorax nycticorax) and
some waders colonized various aquatic habitats where their populations
are often numerous. They have no equivalent on the Tibetan plateaux
where the breeding Anseriformes are mostly Aythya nyroca, a scarce bird,
and Mergus merganser , a characteristic bird of the highlands from 4000 tp
510 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
4700 m, avoiding the lower elevations during the breeding season.
Except Anser indicus , Tadorna ferruginea and a few ducks, the other
Anseriformes met on the northern plateau of Tibet are mostly migrants
or stragglers.
Among other aquatic birds, grebes and gulls nest in both regions,
Larus serranus in the Andes and L. bmnnicephalus in Tibet, where com-
mon terns Sterna hirundo also nest up to 4800 m, without equivalent in
the Andes. Waders, present in both regions, at least as migrants, are
more diversified in Tibet where several nest, among which Charadrius
mongolus , up to 5100 m, the Redshank Tringa totanus , Gallinago soli -
taria, up to 4500 m (its Andean counterpart is G . paraguaiae ), and the
Ibisbill Ibidorhyncha struthersi , a bird strictly adapted to streams.
Broadly speaking, though the Tibetan avifauna comprises a few
birds with no Andean equivalent, aquatic communities seem much less
flourishing in Tibet than in the Andes, maybe in relation to lower pro-
ductivity of the adequate biota and to severe winter conditions, though
the latter might be overcome by seasonal movements.
In each area other birds are found with no equivalent in the other
for both faunistic and ecological reasons. Thus the Andean humming-
birds ( Oreotrochilus , Chaleo stigma, Patagona) have no counterparts, no
sunbird being adapted to high elevations. In contrast, some Tibetan
birds such as the crane Grus nigricollis and corvids have no Andean
equivalents.
Nevertheless, the avian communities of the two regions show re-
markable convergences. When the same niche is available in both
areas it is occupied by birds from different origin, but which evolved with
some parallelism. Birds exploit the same type of resources, and con-
centrate at the same trophic levels. Vegetarians are numerous and in-
sectivores are present, though not the dominant group. Most of them
are specialized feeders and many are polyphagous. Raptors also are
numerous and well diversified, particularly in Tibet, many of them preying
on rodents. These mammals play a very important role in the high
mountain ecosystems, as converters of vegetal to animal matter, being
abundant and much diversified. Many of them are active in daytime,
probably as a response to nocturnal coldness. Therefore they can be
preyed on by many raptors, such as buzzards, the diet of which is largely
made up of these mammals.
It should be stressed that vultures are numerous in Tibet, just as they
are in the high mountains of Africa, particularly in Ethiopia, whereas
their Andean counterparts are scarcer and less diversified. This could
be related to the fact that larger mammals are much more diversified in
the Old World than in the Neogea. Therefore large scavengers could
not find a suitable niche in the Andean habitats where the only indi-
genous ungulates are Auchenidae and a few deer.
ADAPTATIONS OF ANDEAN AND TIBETAN BIRDS 5ll
Ecological adaptations
In both regions, birds had to overcome many difficulties to colonize
the upper zones. The few which succeeded had to adapt to very hostile
environments, not only to altitude in itself, but also to its climatic con-
sequences. As a response to low oxygen pressure they developed ana-
tomical and physiological mechanisms, probably the same in all areas
of high elevation over the world. Other adaptations are of ecological
nature, and probably these are even more important to the birds. Re-
markable convergences are found when birds from the Andes and from
Tibet are compared.
Birds are not evenly distributed over these bleak regions, but con-
centrate in the most favourable places. Therefore their distribution is
largely discontinuous and their populations split into small units, some-
times separated over great distances by unsuitable habitats (this had a
consequence on speciation, definitely favoured by such distribution).
As birds had to concentrate within small areas, many became gregarious.
In the Andes, many birds show a strong tendency to gregariousness, at
least during the non-breeding season. Many passerines, such as Fringil-
lidae, gather during the night in sheltered places, under rocks or in
crevices, which provide roosts and better refuges against cold and bad
Weather. During the breeding season, many concentrate in small areas,
where territories are reduced in size, and feeding grounds often shared by
several pairs with no agonistic behaviour. Favourable nest-sites are
occupied by many birds which gather and build their nests at
short distances from one another. This occurs in the few arborescent
plants of the altiplano, such as puyas (Puya raimondii, Bromeliaceae),
and along cliffs as well.
In Tibet, birds show the same tendencies. Barheaded Geese nest in
large colonies and even lay their eggs in a very promiscuous manner.
Hume’s Ground Jay Pseudopodoces humilis lives in small parties of 5-15
birds looking collectively for their food on the ground. Rednecked
Snow Finches (Montifringilla ruficollis ) do the same and Adams’ Snow
Finches (M. adamsi) even live in bands numbering up to 100 birds which
display well defined social behaviour patterns. A tendency to gre-
gariousness is found in Grandala coelicolor , Acanthis flavirostris and
various representatives of the genus Carpodacus. Several of these birds
have collective displays, which are also known in Robin Accentors,
Prunella rubiculoides. As in the Andes, birds concentrate in the most
favourable nest-sites where their density can be very high. In a small
part of a cliff, nests of Answer indicus, Tadorna ferruginea, Bubo bubo ,
Corvus corax , Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax , Columba rupestris, Gypaetus
barbatus, Buteo hemilasius and Falco cherrug were found together, the
11
512 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
various birds living quietly side by side, though an active competition
exists between birds of very distinct groups.
Rocky habitats are particularly favourable to birds. Open plateaux
offer very harsh conditions to animal life, being cold and open to winds.1
In contrast cliffs and piled boulders provide shelters against wind and
snow, and the microclimate is more favourable in their vicinity. Tem-
peratures are higher due to absence of wind and better exposure. Rock
warms up quicker and better than earth when exposed to sun, and thus
plays the role of a thermal regulator. As food is more abundant and as
many nest-sites are available, it is no Wonder that birds frequent preferably
these habitats, where they nest in large numbers. In the Andes many
raptors nest on small cornices along cliffs, such as caracaras ( Phalcobaenus
albogularis) and hawks (Buteo poecilochrous), side by side with ibises
( Theristicus branickii), doves ( Metriopelia melanoptera), parakeets
(Bolborhynchus aurifrons), hummingbirds ( Oreotrochilus ) and numerous
passerines, such as swallows (Oreochelidon, Petrochelidon), and finches
( Sicalis , Spinus). They build their nests in crevices, sometimes under
shelters and even in caves. Adaptation to rock probably opened high
mountain habitats to hummingbirds. It has already been mentioned
that numerous birds, mostly Fringillidae and Furnariidae, take refuge
under rocks and in crevices during the night.
In Tibet too many birds became rupicoline for the same ecological
reasons. Among raptors, the Tibetan Saker Falcon Falco cherrug
nests exclusively in crags2, in contrast to other races which nest in trees.
Similar nest-sites are chosen by Buteo hemilasius , Bubo bubo , and of
course Falco tinnunculus and Gypaetus barbatus. Barheaded Geese
Anser indicus nest for a part on crags Where they compete with birds of
prey, often very successfully. Corvidae, such as Corvus corax, Pyrrho -
corax pyrrhocorax and P. graculus, place their nest on crags or in a hole
or fissure. Of course Wall Creepers Tichodroma muraria find here their
optimal habitat up to 5000 m, and other passerines. Rock Sparrows
Petronia petronia among others, nest in crevices.
Other passerines nest near the ground in hollows, or under stones and
boulders. This mode of nidification is particularly adopted by represen-
tatives of the genera Carpodacus and Leucosticte, Roborovsky’s Rose
Finch Kozlowia roborovskii, some Snow Finches such as Montifringilla
adamsi , accentors and redstarts. Their feeding grounds are located
in the same habitat, where vegetal and animal food is more abundant
than anywhere else.
1 Nevertheless open plains are not void of birds. In Peru steppes are inhabited
by some passerines such as Phrygilus alaudinus, Geositta cunicularia and Anthus corren-
dera in addition to various tinamous and seedsnipes ( Thinocorus orbignyianus) . In
Tibet, Horned Larks Eremophila alpestris breed in the barest and most desolate habitats,
usually in the most exposed places (Ali 1946).
2 Since it uses old nests of ravens etc. and no tree nests are available ! — SA.
ADAPTATIONS OF ANDEAN AND TIBETAN BIRDS
51.3
The vicinity of cliffs also offers a much more favourable microclimate
than the nearby areas, allowing the growth of a denser and higher vegeta-
tion of shrubs, and occasionally some small trees. Well exposed slopes
are covered by dwarf scrub and stunted*vegetation, which contrasts with
the grassy steppe characteristic of plains and plateaux. This habitat
similar to those of the temperate zone attracts a number of birds with
strict ecological requirements. In the Andes such places are inhabited
by hummingbirds, doves, various passerines such as Leptasthenura
andicola, Asthenes d’orbignyi , Troglodytes musculus , Turdus chiguanco
and Phrygilus gayi. In Tibet, their equivalents are Turdus kessleri ,
Saxicola torquata , Phoenicurus frontalis , Phylloscopus affinis , P. fuscatus ,
Lanius sphenocercus, Parus superciliosus , Leptopoecile sophiae , Acanthis
flavirostris, Emberiza cia and Urocynchramus pylzowi.
Another way to escape cold and severe weather conditions is to nest
in burrows. In habitats with wide daily range of temperature and a great
frequency of winds with a great cooling power, detrimental to birds and
particularly to their brood, this mode of nidification is highly beneficial.
In the Andes, in habitats in which temperatures fluctuate daily from
below 0° to 25°C, temperature within a burrow is constantly around
10°C and does not fluctuate more than 2 — 3°C during the whole nesting
season. Birds benefit from a considerable economy of energy, highly
advantageous to the young. Besides, the brood is well protected against
predators. Certainly a hypogean mode of nidification is known among
other birds than those of the upper zones. But it is so widespread in the
high Andes and in Tibet (but not in Africa) that it can be considered as a
response to the hostile conditions of this habitat.
In the Andes birds nesting underground belong to many groups,
ranging from ducks ( Anas flavirostris ), doves ( Metriopelia melanoptera ),
and raptors ( Falco sparverius ) to many passerines. Though some use
natural cavities or holes excavated by other animals, most dig their own
burrows. Andean flicker ( Colaptes rupicola ) dig long tunnels, some
T50 m deep, in smooth earth or sand of river banks, leading to an incu-
bation chamber, where eggs are laid on bare earth. Others, such
as Furnariidae, excavate long tunnels ending in an incubation room where
they accumulate vegetal matter, feathers and wool on which the eggs are
laid ; some, like the ground tyrants ( Muscisaxicola ) even build a com-
plete nest inside, the brood being thus protected at the same time by the
burrow and by a cup-shaped construction.
The same mode of nesting is found among Tibetan birds, a fair pro-
portion of which nest underground. The habit of using burrows of
various rodents is a characteristic feature. Several of them live in close
association and in good harmony with marmots {Marmot a bobak) and
pikas or mouse-hares ( Ochotona daurica and allies). Little Owls Athene
noctua nest in old marmot burrows, thus resembling the Peruvian Burrow-
514 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
ing Owl Speotyto cunicularia though the latter is able to excavate its own
burrow. Ruddy Shelducks always nest in cavities, sometimes among
rocks, but often in marmot burrows, the nest being located up to 2 m
from the entrance. With its strong incurved bill, Hume’s Ground Jay
( Pseudopodoces humilis) is able to excavate a tunnel from 30 to 180 cm
deep, ending in an incubation chamber where moss, grass and wool are
stored to form a very snug nest. But often it uses a pika burrow as nest
site or shelter. This becomes the normal, if not the exclusive, habit of
several Snow Finches ( Montifringilla taczanowskii, M. blanfordi, and to
some extent, M. ruficollis ), which nest in pika burrows, sometimes at
3 m from the entrance, building a big nest of roots, grass and wool.
It should be remembered that underground nidification is unknown
in the high mountains of Africa, in spite of the advantages it offers against
the aggressive factors of the environment.
Altitudinal migrations
Though well adapted, all birds nesting in high mountains cannot
survive the year round in the same habitat. When climatic conditions
become too severe, many respond by altitudinal migrations. This
phenomenon is known in every mountain range over the world including
the temperate regions (Alps, California) where it has been studied more
extensively than elsewhere. In the northern Andes, humidity is sufficient
at any season to make food available to most categories of consumers
which can stay permanently within the same area. In southern Peru,
a very severe dry season is unfavourable to many birds, especially in-
sectivores. It is likely that some evacuate the upper zones and descend
to lower elevations where food remains available, but these movements
should be limited as favourable habitats are not distant and conditions
not particularly bad even in the heart of the dry season. It should also
not be forgotten that permanent snow is unknown in southern Peru
under 5000 m. In contrast, in the Chilean Andes, where winter is much
more severe and snow may stay for long periods, altitudinal migrations
are well spread among many birds, such as flamingoes, Andean
Sheldgeese Chloephaga melanoptera, Seedsnipes Attagis gayi and Gay’s
Greyheaded Finches Phrygilus gayi . When winter snows set in, most
descend to the valleys (Johnson 1965).
Migration is prevalent among Tibetan birds, only a few being seden-
tary (Vaurie 1972). Over half of the birds are true migrants and most
of the others change their habitat or wander over appreciable distances
to warm valleys or plains. Some, particularly seed-eaters, are only
nomadic and wander on a limited scale to more favourable habitats.
ADAPTATIONS OF ANDEAN AND TIBETAN BIRDS
515
Others, mostly insectivores, are true migrants. Thus Chaimarrornis
leucocephala descend to the Indian plains. Barheaded geese evacuate
their nesting grounds and winter in tropical India, reaching the south-
centre of the subcontinent. Even raptors, such as Bubo bubo , follow the
same movements, because prey is scarce in winter, as many rodents
hibernate or display little activity, having stored large amounts of food
(pikas, voles of the genus Alticola).
Thus Tibetan birds are largely migrants, in contrast to Andean birds,
except those from the Chilean sector. The difference is related to the
very hostile conditions Which prevail in winter, much worse than in the
Andes. Some even wander during summer, when weather conditions
become too bad. Thus Grandala coelicolor gather in bands of up to
300 birds when snow-storms make the land unsuitable to them, and
descend to the valleys until the weather improves. Some warblers,
such as Phylloscopus pulcher, perform the same movements. In view
of this behaviour, the breeding success of many seems very low, due to
interruption of reproduction.
However some Tibetan birds do not evacuate high altitude in winter.
Alpine Accentors Prunella collaris , tits Pams super ciliosus, tit-warblers
Leptopoecile sophiae and Redbreasted Rose Finches Carpodacus puniceus
can Stay all the year round in the upper zone where they have
been observed in winter at an altitude of 5400 m. This represents an
incredible resistance to the aggressive factors of the environment.
References
Ali, S. (1946) : An ornithological
pilgrimage to Lake Manasarowar and
Mount Kailas. J. Bombay nat. Hist.
Soc. 46 : 284-308.
(1962) : The Birds of Sikkim.
Madras (Oxford Univ. Press).
Dementiev, G. P., et al. (1966-68) :
Birds of the Soviet Union. Vols. 1-6.
Jerusalem (Israel Program for Scientific
Translations).
Dorst, J. (1956) : Recherches ecolo-
giques sur les oiseaux des hauts plateaux
peruviens. Trav. Inst. Fr. Et. Andinest 5 :
83-140.
(1957) : The Puya stands
of the Peruvian high plateaux as a bird
habitat. Ibis 99 : 594-9.
(1962) : A propos de la
nidification hypogee de quelques oiseaux
des hautes Andes peruviennes. Oiseau
Rev. Fr. Orn. 32 : 5-14.
(1964) : Quelques adapta-
tions 6cologiques des oiseaux des hautes
Andes peruviennes. Proc. XIII Int. Orn.
Congr. (Ithaca, 1962) : 658-65.
Johnson, A. W. (1965, 1967) : The
birds of Chile. 2 vols. Buenos Aires
(Platt Est. Graf.).
Koepcke, M. (1954) : Corte ecologico
transversal en los Andes del Peru central
con especial consideration de las aves.
Parte I : Costa, Vertientes occidentales y
Region altoandina. Mem. Mus. Hist.
Nat. * Javier Prado ’ 3 : 1-119.
Kozlova, E. V. (1952) : [Avifauna of
the Tibetan highland, its relationship
and history]. Trudy Zool. Inst. Akad.
Nauk. USSR, 9 : 964-1028 (in Russian).
Ludlow, F. (1950) : The birds of
Lhasa. Ibis 92 : 34-45.
(1951) : The birds of
Kongbo and Pome, South-East Tibet.
Ibis 93 : 547-78.
(1964) : The birds of South-
eastern Tibet. Ibis 86:43-86, 176-208,
348-89.
516 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
Moreau, R. E. (1966) : The Bird
Faunas of Africa and its Islands. New
York and London (Academic Press).
Schafer, E. (1938) : Ornithologische
Ergebnisse zweier Forschungsreisen
nach Tibet. /. Orn. 86 : Suppl.
Troll, C. (1959) : Die tropischen
Gebirge. Bonner Geogr. Abhandl. 25 :
1-93.
Vaurie, C. (1972) : Tibet and its
Birds. London (Witherby).
V uilleumier , F. (1970) i Insular bio-
geography in continental regions. I.
The Northern Andes of South America.
Amer. Nat. 104 (938) : 373-88.
Walton, H. J. (1906) : On the birds
of Southern Tibet. Ibis 8(6) : 57-84,
225-56.
Weigold, H. (1949) : Tibet einst ein
Entwicklungs-zentrum . Ornithologie
a Is Biologische Wissenschaft, Festschr.
E. Stresemann. Heidelberg (C. Winter
Universitatsverlag) : 92-107.
Wright, H. E., & Osburn, W. H.
(Ed.) (1967) : Arctic and alpine en-
vironments. 1th Congress INOUA,
Boulder. Indiana Univ. Press.
Two tropical forests and their birds'
H. Elliott McClure
SEATO Medical Research Laboratory , Bangkok1 2
Avifaunal studies were made in two moist dipterocarp tropical rain
forests ; Gombak Valley, Selangor, Malaysia (3°18'Nx 101°43'E), and Khao
Yai National Park, Thailand (14*20'N X 101°30'E), for periods of 90 and
32 days 1958-60 and 1970 respectively. 261 species were recorded, 59 in com-
mon, 115 additional in the Gombak Valley and 87 at the National
Park. Population density in Khao Yai appeared to be three times that of
Gombak. Niche occupancy in the two forests is compared. Feeding flocks
of insectivores were formed at both latitudes and their compositions are com-
pared. It is suggested that these flocks lack the complex organization
described for similar groups of neotropical species.
Karr (1971) recently compared tropical environments of Panama with
forest environments in Illinois. McClure (1965) compared the
residencies of birds contemporary to environments in Japan and in
Malaysia. These are meaningful studies, but somewhat like comparing
day and night ; the differences are greater and more numerous than the
similarities. The present study is a comparison of the avifauna of two
tropical forests separated by only 11 degrees but in different climates,
tropical rain and monsoon ; the Gombak forest at Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia, and the forest of Khao Yai National Park, Thailand.
Description of areas
The Gombak watershed drained by the Gombak river lies at the
eastern edge of the state of Selangor, Malaysia, at 3°18'N, 101°43'E
and has an altitude of from 600 to 2000 feet. Although thinned of many
of the large merchantable trees by lumbering it still presents a closed
canopy with a depth of one hundred to two hundred feet. The forest is
dominated by Dipterocarpaceae of many genera and species. Trees
with a DBH of over 4 inches may be as numerous as two hundred species
per acre. Large trees with buttressed boles may include only four or
five trees per species per acre. The forest is diverse with a lack of uni-
formity in species distribution from acre to acre. Fruiting is indi-
vidualistic by trees (McClure 1966) and so abundant that the bird popu-
lation moves about the forest following available and preferred foods.
1 Received May 1972.
a These studies supported by the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research,
Washington, D.C. 20012, the U.S. Army Medical Research Unit, Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia and the U.S. Army Medical Component, South East Asia Treaty Organiza-
tion, Bangkok.
518 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Wyatt-Smith (1952) classifies this formation as Lowland Dipterocarp
forest which extends up to 1000 feet and Hill Dipterocarp forest 1000 to
2500 feet. These two belong to the world formation commonly referred
to as tropical lowland evergreen rain forest. The study area at the
Gombak entered both levels of forest. Dipterocarpaceae included 50%
of the emergent trees of the canopy, from 100 to 150 feet tall. The 70 to
100 feet canopy included not only young dipterocarps but genera of at
least ten other families.
This study refers mainly to the valley between 600 and 1000 feet. A
logging road extended for two and a half (2J) miles into the forest follow-
ing contours above the stream. Once each week observations were
made along this road from 0700 to 1200 spending two and a half hours
going into and similar time coming out of the forest. These tallies
covered 90 days and 450 hours over a two-year period. Birds were
recorded and counted by both sight and call. This required a training
period so that call counts became more accurate as the study progressed.
The Khao Yai study area was in the National Park at 14°20'N, 101°
30' E with an altitude of between 1500 and 2000 feet. This forest was
also a dipterocarp rain forest but at the northern edge of the biome and
was much less diverse than that further south. It would fall in the
second category of Wyatt-Smith, but still be considered as a tropical
evergreen lowland forest. The Dipterocarpaceae are the dominant
canopy trees but with fewer species than in the Gombak (Smitinand
1968). Where the canopy was closed the forest presented the same
open condition at ground level as further south, but with fewer of the
shrub-like palms such as bertam palm ( Eugeissona sp.). The study area
had been cut over once and had more forest edge and less closed canopy
than the Gombak forest.
The observation route was along a narrow macadam road through
the forest, more open and with less overhead canopy than the trail at
Gombak. Studies were made here three days each month for a year,
totalling 32 days and 128 hours of observations. Each observation began
at dawn and lasted until 0900 requiring about three hours to traverse
a mile and return. Birds were tallied by sight and by call. As with the
Gombak area figs and fruit trees were very important to the distribution
and movements of the birds. The forest offered diverse habitats with an
abundance of food. The fruiting patterns of the trees has not yet been
reported but seemed to be as individualistic as that in the Gombak
valley.
In the Gombak valley the rainfall was distributed throughout the
year averaging about 50 mm per week with heavier rains in November
and December of 100 mm per week. The dry season of January-
February brought the rainfall down to 25 mm per week. Temperature
averaged 21 °C for the year.
TWO TROPICAL FORESTS AND THEIR BIRDS
519
In Khao Yai the annual rainfall was 4000 mm, peak rains occurring
during the South-West Monsoon from July into October. During other
months rainfall was occasional, sometimes lacking for a whole month.
Lack of cloud covering during April-May brought the temperature up to
30°C or above, while in December-January it was as low as 18°C.
There were 174 species recorded along Gombak route totalling 14,631
individuals, and 146 species in the Khao Yai study area totalling 12,596
birds. Some of the bionomics of these data were as follows :
1. The population ratios :
The number of species represented by :
Apparently there were more species at Gombak in slightly larger
flocks than those at Khao Yai.
2. Six hundred miles separated the two forests but there were only 58
species, 20*6% of the total involved in the two areas, that were common
to both. These made up 33*6% of the species at Gombak and 40*0% of
those at Khao Yai. There were 115 species limited to Gombak as com-
pared with 87 limited to Khao Yai. Either the diversity of niches was
greater at Gombak, the birds fitted them more closely than in Khao Yai,
or many niches at Khao Yai were vacant.
3. Population density : At Gombak there were 450 hours of field
observations over a period of three years and at Khao Yai 128 hours
over one year. The number of birds tallied per hour was 31*6 and 98*2
respectively. By this method the population appears to have been more
than three times as dense at Khao Yai than at Gombak. This may have
been an actual difference or it may have resulted from a higher visibility
in Khao Yai where the canopy was more open than that along the
Gombak route. The number of birds tallied per mile of route through
the forest was 66 in Gombak and 321 in Khao Yai, five times as great.
To carry this comparison one step further, the average number of birds
recorded per day in the field was 164 at Gombak and 321 at Khao Yai.
This brings the density down to about double that of the Gombak, but
is not valid since the Gombak route is 2J times that of Khao Yai.
There were T2 times as many species recorded in the Gombak
valley than at Khao Yai suggesting a more heavily saturated environ-
Birds tallied in the two areas
Gombak Khao Yai
Only 1 individual
2-10 individuals
11-100 individuals
101-1000 individuals
15 (8*6%) 13 (8*9%)
49 (28*3%) 50 (34-4%)
73 (42*1%) 48 (33*1%)
36 (20*8%) 34 (23*4%)
520 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
men t, but when the number of birds per species per observation is con-
sidered the figures indicate 0*93 birds at Gombak and 2*7 at Khao
Yai, again nearly three times as dense a population at Khao Yai.
Over 500 birds of 70 species were weighed with an average weight of
53 grams. Since the same average figures of birds tallied must be used,
a calculation of avian bio-mass in the two areas is fruitless ; 8*6 and
20*8 kilograms per observation ; or 3*4 kg and 17*0 kg per mile.
It is estimated that birds can be seen up to about 100 feet in the forest
on either side of the trail. Since an acre is a little more than 209 feet on
a side, then for each 200 feet (65 m) traversed one acre has been covered.
A total of approximately 25 acres is covered for each mile tallied. By
this method the counts determined 2*6 and 13*0 birds per acre respectively.
The ratio would not change if reduced to hectares. When reducing the
averages to the number of birds per species per observation the figures
are 1*76 for Gombak and 6’3 for Khao Yai, still a ratio of 3 : 6. By the
data and means at hand the population density at Khao Yai appeared to
be between three and five times as great as that at Gombak. See Table 1.
4. Seasonality : Peak volumes of precipitation were experienced
at the Gombak during November and December followed by two months
of reduced rain. Peak population density fell in January during this
brief dry spell. At Khao Yai there were two definite seasons, wet from
May into October and dry from October into April. Peak population
density fell in December when the environment was dry. The peaks in
both areas were during the period when migrants from the north were
present, 15 species in the Gombak and 25 at Khao Yai. At neither
locale were these migrants abundant enough to cause this population
peak.
Niche occupation
Udvardy (1969) summarizes the niche concept as follows : ‘ By
“ niche ” — which we understand in a figurative rather than a concrete
or spatial sense, we mean the role of a particular animal or plant in the
community which it fills by virtue of its tolerances and requirements
(Hutchinson 1957) and its special combination of structural, functional,
and population biological adaptations. Each animal species has its own
niche, which is not exactly duplicated by any other related or unrelated
form. By and large, however, functional counterparts in related ecosys-
tems are said to fill the same niche ; where such a counterpart is missing,
the niche is considered to be empty.’
The niche occupancy in the two forests was different both as to
species and their abundance. In Table 2 those species tallied in numbers
of approximately one hundred individuals or greater are compared by
forest and month. These are arranged as couplets and where related
A COMPARISON OF POPULATIONS AT MlLE 13 GOMBAK, SELANGOR, MALAYSIA, 2*5 LINEAR MILES, AUG. 1958— NOV. 1960.
the Elephant Walk Route, one linear mile, at Khao Yai National Park, Thailand, Jan.-Dec. 1970
521
TWO TROPICAL FORESTS AND THEIR BIRDS
>%
d
d
o
u
£
3
£
d
©
•s
o
o
8
c«
.©
O
0) d
ft a
r-J
O.S?
X) <43
is
d
©
a ,
a
o
d
©
o
©
04
<Z)
Ui
©
a
(43
d
il
IS
3 M
e «
c &
© ^
GO O
522 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
CM
3
a
O OS
as
H hJ
5 w
^ Xfl
g|<
§a.
m °
O
6 H
O pH
V,0
§2
« w
zli
IS
S p
0 g
u 3
W «
a e
H g
8|
z *
§H
§
Oh
1
u
o
<u
CP
m
9 <o
• to
99
>b 9
«n O
4 6
t" CM
Gv rn o o
O VO
CN Ah
99
’— 1 A"
in 9
VO
0^ 0^ 0^ OW
-2
VO
VO
<2
vj
05
-2
e
2
§ a
.« Vo
§£
§ o
9^
-o
.2
3 2
§•■5
&•§
?5
•2 .2
§o Si
ft
Vo Vj
<3 <3
» a> *-•
'3 &
Jy a>
2^S
62
a> u
H o
a x>
(/} d
a
o
.2 fl
«J "S 4J
D d 60
a cp d
3S»
^ --S
PQ Sh "*■*
-d 2
^ o
*3} «a
d (u u
X rj Ph
ill
C5 ^
CP <U rt
6"r
8^S
S'S*
=aa
8 26
x> m §
H3^§.
ID'S A
w). y cp
el d cvs
d
§ a
S o
w o
cvS
o £ d-d
*0 'o 5 cvj
«,rt o >
as « h
o^.aa^
S-v>
£ &p d
a
« g o
d d a
TWO TROPICAL FORESTS AND THEIR BIRDS 523
CM
> — -
(N
W
H
Recorded about 1000 ft. higher on the mountain. Occurs here but has gone to roost before observations started.
MONTH
524 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
<L>
■g
a
m
3 .s
R V.
•is
to '3
I?
SI
c a
s-§
§1
S?Sj
Subang, a nearby secondary forest lower than Mile 13. Listed here for comparison. Not common at Gombak,
TWO TROPICAL FORESTS AND THEIR BIRDS
Table 2-(5)
526 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Table 2-(6)
TWO TROPICAL FORESTS AND THEIR BIRDS 527,
H
£
O
S
o
>
<
-5
o
H
a
s
g 5
gi jN
2
12
No equivalent
Table 2-(7)
S28 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HJ&T. SOCIETY, Vol. l\ (3)
Subang^a nearby secondary forest lower than Mile 13. Listed here for comparison. Not common at Gombak.
TWO TROPICAL FORESTS AND THElR BIRDS 529
species apparently fill the same niche in each habitat they are compared.
This table indicates seasonality as well. The figures given are the average
birds tallied per observation without consideration of time involved
or distance covered. Some species occurred in both forests. Some
niches appeared to be occupied by more than one species in one forest
and only one in the other. Some niches appeared to be occupied by one
or several species in one forest and to be vacant in the other.
In any concept of niche the observer is at a handicap because of his
inability to discern the parameters which delineate the niche from the
standpoint of the organism occupying it. Inhibiting factors obvious to
the organism may escape the observer. In these two forests the presence
or absence of related species may be a function of the inability of the
forest to provide what is needed to the birds even though the situation
appears similar to the observer.
In both forests there were several conditions related to niche. These
appeared to be : 1. Niche present in both and occupied by a species
capable of increasing to an abundance (abundance is here interpreted to
be in numbers so that 100 or more could be tallied). 2. Niche present
and occupied only sparsely by a low level population. 3. Niche present
but species capable of occupying it were absent. 4. Niche absent. We
are still in the position of setting up such categories arbitrarily without
reference to the organisms present or knowledge of their critical needs.
The less abundant species and their counterparts are listed in Table 3.
Many of the differences evident here appear to be related to thermal
conditions, for some species found at Khao Yai at 1000 to 2000 ft.
(c. 500 m) are found in Malaya at 4000 to 6000 ft. (c. 1500 m).
Bird waves
4 Wave ’ action of the birds was evident in both forests, however it
appeared to be much more prevalent among the birds at Gombak than at
Khao Yai. The birds of Khao Yai were more independent in their food
gathering. Both forests had an abundance of insects, but at Khao Yai
there was a year-round supply of fruit in greater quantities than was noted
at Gombak. Frugivorous birds go to the feeding trees in flocks and
mingle with other species present, but there is not the flock organization
evident among the species as in a feeding flock of insectivores. A com-
parison of the flock dynamics is given in Table 4. Size of flock, number
of species involved, etc. was similar for the two areas.
Aanlyses of feeding flocks have been reported by many observers
including Moynihan (1962, Panama), McClure (1967, Malaya),
Diamond & Terborgh (1967, Peru ; 1970, New Guinea), Cody (1971,
California) and in each paper the factors reported differ. The flocks
discussed have varied from single species granivorous feeders through
A COMPARATIVE LIST OF THOSE SPECIES WHICH DID NOT DEVELOP NUMERICAL ABUNDANCE, FILLED THE NICHES SPARSELY,
OR CONVERSELY, THE HABITATS DID NOT PERMIT GREATER POPULATIONS ; OR THE NICHE WAS UNOCCUPIED
530 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol 71 (3)
.52
a y
5
co
8
a
c
s!
ft
Qi .Co
" i 5$
bo'-.
,ft a
‘§ § .1
lllii
s^gg
52 ^ »
a a .52
•S ft £ §
£§ I «
■SJ-g | §
~S % -5 > •§
1-a 8 1'g
'Jo a
IS
C .52
2 C
ft, o
a
-a
ft
I
3 1
to .ft
;S^a Si
SS ft g
^ a c,
§ a ft
ft ^ ^
S ft
co a
».ft Co
a 5- „a
a ft*a
§!§•
^ ft ^
a a *“
If a
ft b a
a 5 .ft
2 ^ a
ft
| 8s
^ N* ^ ^ CO
ft a
<a*ft
ft Co
a g
1114‘S
ft ft -g a .3
as ft,.& ^ 5
.a .ft ft
co a
ft as
ft s
Kg; bo
Cv &o
a1 a
^ C3
8- a
Go;
a
ft
a
ft
a
.2 ^
a £
■§1
k|I
p,ft
Oq o
co
-2
ft
H,
ft"
ft 52 K,
*a ft
Bp
ft ft a
Hjiri ^
wwkq
a as
SB
ft |
-a -Si
"ft ft
ft o
ft 5k.
a >5
s a
ft sr
ft
a
-a
1
2 -S
£"ft
-si § w
9 g §!
as a,.? -a
g.a
^ i4o
Cl S
s ^
ft ~a
ft~?
ifli
~3 "a ft "ft
a a ft
ft ~a >g; .
ft,
M
a ^ a
co ft ft
S .ft £
‘I I l|.§
H*l§
a ::
B 8
s? a
S §
§-ft
ft^S
v3 52
ft Si
13
l|
ft >S
09 ig
■§£31
•3r§i§-2
|VS|
jft a ft ft
•Si £
a §
ft Kg;
§ ft
i.i
S-5
ft
ft /
a to O
§.§3S
SB?
§ S 3
qj ^ **
•a &§,
ft 00
1*uf si'pt
l
Co ft
§1
a c
co £*«:
I § S
a a ft
l||
■SjfS,
TWO TROPICAL FORESTS AND THEIR BIRDS
531
Table 4
A COMPARISON OF THE FLOCK DYNAMICS OF BIRD WAVES AT GOMBAK AND KHAO YAI
many species of insectivores to many species of frugivorous forms using one
tree. Each author has given his own interpretation to his observations.
The primary difference between the flocks of insectivores and those
assembling in a fruiting tree is that the insectivore ‘ waves * move through
the forest (generally in a predictable pattern or territory) and the fruit
eaters go to a specific tree. Many of the travelling waves contain fruit
eaters which have joined them for varying periods or distances, such
as the bulbuls or the barbets. If every species that is seen with such
flocks is listed there will be many that occur only once in a series of
observations. These may or may not be accidentally with the group. If
they are seen on two occasions then the relationship may be more than
casual. There were 68 species at Gombak and 43 at Khao Yai that were
noted in association with feeding flocks two or more times.
McClure (1967) gives tables attempting to relate the species within
these feeding flocks, based upon the numbers of times the birds were
seen together. Table 5 duplicates this for the eleven species commonly
found in waves at Mile 13 Gombak. In this table the figures are given as
percentages of the total birds tallied. For example 75% of the 252
Yellowheaded Green Leafbirds ( Chloropsis cochinchinensis) were
seen in company with 83% of the 242 Minivets ( Pericrocotus flammeus
and P. igneus). With a less numerous form, 34% of the leafbirds were
associated with 85% of the 27 Chestnutbreasted Malkoha (P. curviros -
tris). These data can be interpreted to indicate interspecific affinities,
or simply the physical impossibility for 75 or 85 % of the leafbirds to be
in the flocks with the malkoha when there was only one tenth as many
malkohas present.
Table 5. The numerical relationships among the birds commonly found in feeding flocks at Gombak
532 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol 71 (3)
,*00(0— (<^\^£>Orninco£S
fo^oOiomoj^i'r^TrfoON
fOfOrt-fO<N'^-fr)r-iT^-fnir)
\o o\ as — ' r£ ^ o r^* o© <o
’*tv©'onoefOfN«or>.0ooo
^ 't h in t "t t vO tJ- M
m co 00 oo — ; O oo ON (M IO
'TrOTfV) ,nTt^<N<Nio(0
^D— iiO^or^oj — m'Or^oo
•^-(OTH'^-^o'ovominro^
Jof^ioONnOr^'OO^Oio'T
r^^r^vo r^'t^- t^'ooioooi^'
jnoooot^t^'ooooc^-r^oo'O
§
s;
•Sp
•&
$
a
»3
s
<3
§■
.O
£
<3
5
1 1 . Aegithina viridissima
Table 6. — The numerical relationships among the birds commonly found in feeding flocks at Khao Yai
TWO TROPICAL FORESTS AND THEIR BIRDS 533
csj — ' ^ w
csrsio©Tf~H'Ooooo©\*-<r-
cQmnm nn ^ ri <n b©
r^co'^irfm-^Ooo^O'^o
io'Of^csvov>or^TfvO’-^fn
irj-H— ioi^ir-r-Tr^'ocior^
m*nt^vom'nv)vo^otN,^‘’-H
dO*ou^fMiHr-r^r^’-^o«n
«n©Ooo^fOor-o^^co
ir>«n<N
(Movooo«o— 1 cs o e'-
en 'O rj '"t cn m v© «o vo
«r> — 1 noovo©rj-(SOOVOOO
in^ovJ 'o^ooinio'oe^aNm
in^,n^n^l-'>Oooo©‘nv^v-»oo
3
•nvoONin^oOf^-HOOino
«^)Tt<Nv>o‘n<Nr-,^>'^)'>0'o
•a
o
<U
o.
o n
.5.
l
•2
-2
a
550
a
a
o
■s 5
-a
5J
8
05
I
-2
8
§
i
l
*
8.
03
I'
I
I
— <N m
Read Tables 5 and 6 horizontally : i.e. 84% ofthe A.poioicephala (Line 3, Column 1) were seen in association with 46% of the C. cochin-
chinensis (Line 1, Column 3). Bold faced numbers are the total birds tallied and the remainder are percentages of these figures.
534 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY , Vol 71 (3)
Arranging the twelve common participants found in waves in Khao
Yai in the same way (Table 6), the same relationships appear to be
present.
Four species were common to bird waves in both forests, Yellow-
headed Green Leaf bird Chloropsis cochinchinensis , Barwinged Flycatcher-
Shrike Hemipus picatus, Fairy Bluebird Irena puella and Scarlet Minivet
Pericrocotus flammeus. In the Gombak 75 % of the leaf birds were With
83% of the minivets. In Khao Yai 61 % of the leaf birds were with 67%
of the minivets, the same relationship. The temptation is to ascribe
interspecific affinities or relationships to these observations. A review of
both tables simply makes it evident that birds get together to find food.
At Khao Yai the numerical abundance of species was in the same order,
i.e. 60 Hemipus picatus and 51 C. cochinchinensis with 51% of the leaf-
birds in association with 52% of the flycatcher-shrikes. In the Gombak
they were 252 leaf birds to 34 flycatcher-shrikes and a ratio of 23 % of the
leaf birds to 73% of the flycatcher-shrikes. A purely spatial and popu-
lation density relationship in both cases. Species with similar food habits
get together to hunt. To go further in interpretation is treading on
shaky ground.
Summary
A comparison of the avifauna of the moist dipterocarp tropical rain
forest at its northern edge in Thailand and in the centre of its range in
Malaya reveals that there is a large species overlap between the two
areas, that the population density in the northern edge of the forest was
greater than in that under study in Malaysia, that both of these populations
may be the result of edaphic conditions brought on by man disturbance.
Niche occupancy in both forests was not the same, there being vacancies
in both which were occupied in the other. The insectivores in both
environments gathered into feeding flocks that moved through the forest
each day. The species composition of these flocks depended upon those
species available and lacked the complex flock organization reported
from the neotropical forest.
References
Cody, M. L. (1971) : Finch flocks in
the Mohave Desert. Theoretical Popu-
lation Biology 2 : 142-58.
Diamond, J. M. & Terborgh, J. W.
(1967) : Observations on bird distribu-
tion and feeding assemblages along the
Rio Callaria, Department of Loreto,
Peru. Wilson Bull. 79: 273-82.
Hutchinson, G. E. (1957) : Conclud-
ing remarks. Cold Spring Harbor
Symp. Quant. Biol. 22 : 415-27.
Karr, James R. (1971) : Structure of
Avian communities in selected Panama
and Illinois Habitats. Ecol. Mong. 41 :
207-33, No. 3.
McClure, H. Elliott (1965) : Com-
TWO TROPICAL FORESTS AND THEIR BIRDS
535
parison of the periods of residency of
some migrant birds common to Japan
and Malaya. Misc. Reprints , Yamashina
Institute of Ornithology and Zool. 4 :
149-62.
(1966) : Flowering, fruiting
and animals in the canopy of a tropical
rain forest. Malayan Forester XXIX :
182-203, No. 3.
(1967) : The composition of
mixed species flocks in lowland and sub-
montane forests of Malaya. Wilson
Bull. 79: 131-54.
Moynihan, M. (1962) : The organi-
zation and probable evolution of some
mixed species flocks of neotropical birds.
Smithsonian Misc. Collections 143, No. 7,
140 pp.
Smitinand, Tem. (1968) : Vegetation
of Khao Yai National Park. Nat' l
Hist. Bull. Siam Soc. 22 : 289-305.
Terborgh, J. & Diamond, J. M.
(1970) : Niche overlap in feeding assem-
blages of New Guinea birds. Wilson
Bull. 82 : 29-52.
Udvardy, Miklos D. F. (1969) :
Dynamic Zoogeography. Van Nostrand
Reinhold Co., New York, p. 149.
Wyatt-Smith, J. (1952) : Malayan
Forest Types. Malayan Nat. Jr. 7 :
45-55,
Geographical distribution of the
avian lice (Phthiraptera) :
a review 1
Theresa Clay
British Museum {Natural History)
The avian lice are obligate parasites, spending their whole life-history
from egg to adult on the body of their host without a free-living stage as
in the fleas or intermediate hosts as in some of the endoparasites. It
might therefore be thought that they would be independent of external
conditions such as climate and other ecological aspects of the host’s
environment. However, the great diversity of structure found amongst
the eggs of the lice laid in comparable situations on the body of the bird,
some of the differences apparently being related to the host’s environ-
ment (Balter, in preparation), suggests that the external environment may
affect the louse and its distribution. The kangaroo louse Heterodoxus
spiniger Which has become established on the domestic dog in many
parts of the world is found almost entirely between lat. 40°N and 40°S
(Thompson 1940) and is perhaps limited by some climatic circumstances.
Thus, the louse population may be subject to both a micro- and macro-
environment, the latter perhaps sometimes influencing distribution
(Table III).
The distribution of the lice of birds is mainly a host one and. in many
cases a genus ot louse will be restricted to an order or family of birds with
each species restricted to a host species or a group of related host species.
It is interesting however, that some orders of birds are parasitized by
species with a wide host and geographical distribution (Table I). Pub-
lished work on the Phthiraptera has concentrated on the host distribution
and since Jardine, 1841 first suggested that ornithologists might use the
distribution of the Mallophaga to trace relationships between their hosts
(see Hopkins 1951), this aspect of the distribution of the Phthiraptera
has been developed by Kellogg, Harrison, Hopkins, Clay, Eichler,
Timmermann, Keler and others. Deductions of host relationships from
those of their parasites have been made with enthusiasm not always
tempered by judgement. In Clay (1957) an assessment was made of the
value of this source of evidence for host relationships and the factors
which might influence and modify the original relationships. It was
1 Received August 1972.
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF AVIAN LICE
537
shown that, in general, the relationships of the lice do reflect those of
their hosts and that anomalous distributions are the exception. In
some examples of anomalous distribution a species appears to exhibit a
geographical not a host distribution, but until recently discussion on
this subject hardly appeared in the literature. Hopkins (1949) and Clay
(1949) gave some instances and since then it has been mentioned in
various papers ; these together with unpublished examples are reviewed
here. Apologies are made to those authors who have written on this
subject but whose papers have been overlooked.
Table I
Phthirapteran species with wide host and geographical distributions
S. species, and G. genera of the host parasitized. N = New World (Nearctic &
Neotropical); P. Palearctic ; E. Ethiopian; O. Oriental; A. Australasian (including
New Zealand). ? None recorded, possible hosts present.
Authors and dates of all Phthirapteran species up to 1951 as in Hopkins &
Clay 1952.
The Amblyceran examples are taken from the revisionary work of Price et al. and
the Columbicola from Tendeiro, 1952.
Geographical distribution in the Phthiraptera may be due to various
causes which for convenience can be considered under the following
headings : Absence, Primary and Secondary ; Secondary Infestations ;
Geographical Isolation of Host ; Unexplained Distributions. These
divisions are not entirely satisfactory as some of the examples could be
considered under more than one of the headings and there is always the
dual role of host distribution and geographical distribution making
much of the evidence difficult to evaluate.
Absence
a. Primary. The most obvious example of this is the absence of
lice from certain geographical areas owing to the absence of the host, the
distribution of the lice being fundamentally a host one. Thus, none of
538 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
the 20 or so genera specific to the Tinamidae are found in Africa because
there are no tinamous in Africa.
Another reason foi the primary absence of a louse genus in a geo-
graphical area could be the absence of the genus on the ancestral stock
which gave rise to the avian group in that area. Ward (1958) has made
an interesting analysis of the louse fauna of the Galliformes and shows
that two Ischnoceran genera : Cuclotogaster and Lipeurus, now represen-
ted by many species on the Old World Galliformes, are not found in the
Mew World and suggests that they were not present on the Avian stock
which crossed the Behring land bridge. The absence of one of the
starling lice in Noith America could be a modern example of this : Boyd
(1951) examined 300 starlings ( Sturnus vulgaris) from six states in the
U.S.A. and found only three of the four species which parasitize this
bird in Europe ; Sturnidoecus sturni common on the European starling
being absent on the introduced bird. The Coloceras- complex on the
Columbidae may show another case of primary absence, Campanulotes
being absent in the Ethiopian region and Coloceras perhaps absent in the
New World ; although both are possibly replaced by related genera.
In the Palearctic, Oriental and Australasian regions species of both
genera are present, sometimes on the same host individual, showing
that the absence in certain regions is not due to competition between the
species of the two genera.
The absence of Quadraceps ridgwayi in part of the range of its host,
Haematopus ostralegus (Table III, 3) is probably primary, the parasite
having perhaps been acquired from another member of the Charadrii-
formes by the host stock which gave rise to the southern populations of
Haematopus.
b. Secondary Absence. A species of louse may be found in part
only of the range of its host or a genus found only on members of an
avian order in certain areas, having become extinct elsewhere. Clay
(1949) gave examples of the absence of a host-specific species even with-
in quite small areas, local populations apparently lacking certain species ;
presumably in such cases the missing species will be acquired again from
neighbouring inter-breeding host populations. However, where the
population is isolated then that species may be completely lost from the
population. The example given above under Primary Absence of the
missing species on North American starlings could equally well be ex-
plained as a case of secondary absence by extinction. Another example
which could be primary or secondary is shown in the distribution of
Piagetiella (Amblycera) : the species of this genus are confined to the
Pelecaniformes, living in the throat pouches ; they are represented by
five species on pelicans and three species parasitic on six species of cor-
morants (Price 1970). These three species belong to a distinctive species
group easily separable from those on the pelicans, indicating that they
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF AVIAN LICE
539
have not recently been acquired by the cormorants . There is no evidence
suggesting that the hosts form a group of closely related species. Table II
shows that with the exception of Phalacrocorax auritus and penicillatus ,
all the records are found within an area bounded by latitude 0° and 70°S
and longitude 80° W and 20°E. It is possible that Piagetiella was once
found throughout the genus Phalacrocorax but has become extinct in
other parts of the world. Alternatively, this genus was parasitic on the
stock Which gave rise to some of the southern cormorants, being secon-
darily acquired by other unrelated cormorants and carried further north
in the New World by Phalacrocorax olivaceus and auritus. The fact
that Phalacrocorax neglectus from South Africa is parasitized by the
same species of Piagetiella (P. incomposita) as the two American cor-
morants ( auritus and penicillatus ) suggests, if not a relationship between
the hosts, at least a common distribution at one time. It is probable
that Piagetiella will be found on other cormorants but it can be predicted
that these will be cormorants from the subantarctic and adjacent regions ;
it is unlikely that it occurs on the European Phalacrocorax carbo and
aristotelis, many of these birds having been examined without result.
This distribution may therefore be an example partly of host isolation
(see below) and partly of secondary infestation (see below).
Table II
Distribution of Piagetiella on Phalacrocorax
Secondary absence may occur where a host species is parasitized by
sympatric species belonging to the same genus or by species of a number
of related sympatric genera. Such genera are presumably the result of
divergence of an ancestral stock on a host group so that the resulting
genera aie more closely related to each other than to genera found on
other host groups. Examples are the Philo ceanus-complQX on the
Procellariiform.es (comprising about 10 genera), the Coloceras- complex
of the Columbidae ; the Goniodes- complex of the Galliformes and the
Ischnocera of the Psittaciformes and of the Bucerotidae. Thus, if one
540 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 7i (3)
of a pair of sympatric species becomes extinct in part of the host’s range
and the other in another part (Clay 1949, fig. 4), the two species will show
a geographical distribution ; the Falcolipeurus species on Gyps ruppellii
(Table III, 6) may be an example. The same would apply if some of the
genera belonging to a generic complex became extinct in part of the host’s
range ; the North American game-bird fauna and the African and New
World pigeon fauna, if not explicable by primary absence, may be
examples of this.
Table III
Phthirapteran taxa found in part of the host’s range
Secondary infestations
The establishment of a louse population on a new host may have taken
place at any time during the evolution of louse species and host species.
It seems probable that establishment is more likely to take place on a new
host of the same family or order than on one belonging to a totally un-
related group. That this is so is supported by the cases of geographical
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF AVIAN LICE 541
distribution discussed below and which may be explained by such intra-
group transfers. Little is known about what prevents a louse establishing
itself on a new host, but it seems possible that much of the isolation of the
Phthiraptera is due more to birds of different species not normally com-
ing into close enough contact for the transfer of lice, than to the louse
being unable to establish itself on the new host. Possible methods of
inter-specific transfer were given in Clay, 1957.
There are a number of examples of two or more hosts in one geo-
graphical area having the same or similar species of parasite whereas this
would not be expected from their relationships. An example is the
occurrence of a species of Rhynonirmus on Bartramia (subfamily
Tringinae) related to one on Philohela (subfamily Scolopacinae) ; the
genus Rhynonirmus elsewhere being known only from the latter sub-
family. If the placing of Bartramia in the Tringinae is correct then this
may be a straightforward case of secondary infestation (Clay 1961).
Another distribution, perhaps explicable by secondary infestation, is that
of the species of Anatoecus on the flamingoes : Phoenicopterus antiquo-
rum and Phoeniconaias minor , sympatric in Africa, have the same species
of Anatoecus , while Phoenicopterus ruber and P. chilensis in the New
World each have a distinct species. It would be expected that P. minor ,
considered genetically distinct, would have the different parasite. Alter-
natively, this distribution could be explained by divergent evolution of
the New World lice or a mistaken assessment of flamingo relationships.
However, that secondary in testation may have taken place bet ween the
two African species of flamingoes is supported by the distribution of the
species of another genus parasitic on this* host family. Tandan &
Brelih (1971) have shown that the three species of Phoenicopterus (anti-
quorum, ruber and chilensis) are parasitized by one species [ (Anaticola
phoenicopteri (Coinde) ], whereas Phoeniconaias minor has this species
and also a distinct species of the same genus (Anaticola dissonus ), the
two never having been found together on the same host individual. It is
suggested that phoenicopteri evolved on Phoenicopterus and dissonus
on Phoeniconaias and that subsequently the former species became
secondarily established on P. minor. The wide distribution of Saemunds -
sonia africana (Table III, 2) on the southern populations of the Vanellinae
may be due to secondary infestations on some of the hosts.
Tendeiro (1962) has analysed the distribution of the louse genus
Columbicola parasitic on the Columbidae and shown that the distri-
bution of some species is more a geographical one than a host one and
that these can be attributed to secondary infestations.
There are other examples, probably due to secondary infestation,
but in which the transfer of lice must have taken place at a time when
the distribution of the host was different. Thus, Corvus kubaryi
(Corvidae) on Guam Island (Marianas) has an established population
542 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
of a louse species belonging to a genus normally parasitic on the Rallidae,
the species Rallicola insulana (Carriker) also being found on a Porphyrio
(Rallidae); at the present time there is no overlap in distribution of the
possible hosts (Clay 1953). Another example is the unexpected occur-
rence of Actornithophilus hoplopteri, a parasite characteristic of the
Vanellinae, on Charadrius vociferus (see Clay 1962). The absence of
members of the Vanellinae in North America at the present time suggests
extinction or changes in distribution of hosts from which this louse might
have been acquired by Charadrius vociferus. The same may apply to the
Coliiformes in Africa which are parasitized by a genus Colilipeurus
apparently most nearly related to Falcolius on Microhierax (Falconi-
formes) found in the Oriental region (Clay 1955). Relationship between
the hosts is unlikely but if the distribution is due to secondary infestation
then it must be postulated that the two host groups have at some time
been sympatric. As both parasite genera now comprise a number of
host-specific species, it must be presumed that the transfer preceded the
divergence of the hosts.
Geographical isolation of host
The present distribution of Chelopistes can be explained by the iso-
lation of the host group on which it evolved. Ward (1958) suggests
that this genus, now widely distributed on the Cracidae, Odontophorinae
and the Meleagrididae, evolved from a Goniodes stock in N. America
during the Tertiary and after the re-union of North and South America
in the Pliocene, moved southwards to Central and South America on such
genera as Odontophorus. However, a study of the morphology of
Chelopistes suggests that it (as well as Labicotes) is a derivative of Oxyli-
peurus , although it occupies the Goniodes-mchz. Therefore, it seems
possible that only the ancestral Oxylipeurus (among the Ischnocera)
reached S. America, perhaps on an early Cracidae stock, which either
crossed before the severance of connections between North and South
America in the Paleocene or as one of Simpson’s 4 Old Island Hoppers *
(Simpson 1950). During this isolation Chelopistes evolved from an
Oxylipeurus stock to occupy the niche used by Goniodes in many of the
Nearctic and Palaearctic birds. With the re-uniting of the Americas
during the late Pliocene and the movement south of other families of
birds, Chelopistes became established on the Odontophorinae and
Meleagrididae. This would explain its absence on members of the
Odontophorinae north of Mexico and the absence of Goniodes on the
Cracidae. Thus, the present distribution may be the result of divergence
on an isolated host group, with some subsequent secondary establishment
in other host groups, all taking place during the early evolution of the
hosts. This shows the difficulty of using host-parasite relationships to
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF AVIAN LICE 543
elucidate the phylogeny of the higher categories of birds. However,
such cases if correctly interpreted may throw some light on the origins
and migrations of avian groups.
Another unusual type of distribution perhaps explicable by host
isolation is that of Aquanirmus on the grebes (Podicipitiformes).
Edwards (1965) has shown that two of the grebe species common to
Europe and North America are parasitized by species of Aquanirmus
belonging to different species groups on the two sides of the Atlantic
(Table IV). In addition, Podiceps cristatus is parasitized in Europe
by A. podicipis (Denny) belonging to the colymbinus species group and
Table IV
The species of Aquanirmus on Podiceps
Podiceps griseigena on both sides of the Atlantic has the same species of
Aquanirmus , belonging to a species group otherwise found on North
American grebes. If, as has been suggested, the grebes originated in
North America, it is possible as Edwards says that only one of the grebes
arriving in Europe had the colymbinus stock and that the others acquired
it by secondary infestation. However, another perhaps more likely
explanation is that the colymbinus stock was the original stock on all
the grebes and on the European grebes it diverged little, perhaps now
representing only a polytypic species, whereas on the North American
stock greater divergence took place ; it should be noted that the
differences between the species groups of Aquanirmus are small. If
this is a correct hypothesis, the following deductions can be made:
a. Podiceps griseigena became established in Europe at a later date than
the other Species of Podiceps . b. The possibility of a New World rufi-
collis stock, now extinct, which gave rise first to the Northern European
13
544 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
ruficollis parasitized by the colymbinus species group and at a later date
to the African and Oriental ruficollis populations after it had acquired
bahli from a New World grebe. Specimens from ruficollis in other parts
of its range might throw further light on its distribution routes. Iso-
lation of host may be responsible for the two species of Strigiphilus
parasitic on the widely distributed Tyto alba (Example 5, Table III) and
may indicate the distribution routes from the centre of origin of this
bird.
Some apparent cases of geographical distribution of lice are probably
host distributions due to the hosts in one region being closely related to
each other, having evolved from a common stock in that area. Trinoton
aculeatum, for instance, is parasitic on Dendrocygna viduata in South
America and South Africa and on D. bicolor and D. autumnalis in the
New World, while each of the species D. javanica (Oriental), D. arcuata
(Australia, Papua) and D. eytoni (Australia) are parasitized by a separate
species (Clay 1963). This is probably a host distribution, the divergence
of the lice being dependent on the time and divergence of the hosts.
Other cases which may be either host or geographical distribution are
those in which two subspecies of host are each parasitized by a species of
louse, as for example, the occurrence of Heleonomus semiluctus on
Balearica p. pavonina in west Africa and H. cornutus on Balearica pavo -
nina gibbericeps in east Africa (Price 1970). The specific differences
may have arisen during the geographical isolation of the louse popula-
tions or as an adaptation to some difference in the host’s external
characters, arising during the isolation of the hosts themselves. The
distribution of Myrsidea on the subspecies of Corvus macrorhynchos
may be partly a geographical and partly a host one (Klockenhoff 1969).
In the case of Corvus orru cecilae in Australia (Table III), the same
subspecies is parasitized by one species of Myrsidea in the Townsville
area, Queensland and by another species (or a distinct subspecies) at
Port Essington, Northern Territory (Klockenhoff 1972).
Unexplained distributions
The explanation of the distributions discussed above are highly
conjectural ; in the following examples any conjecture at all may be
unwise : a. Example 4 in Table III in which Sula sula and Sula leuco-
gaster (Pelecaniformes) share the same parasite in the Atlantic and share
a different one in the rest of their range. Some possible explanations
for this were given in Clay, 1964. b. The distribution of Degeeriella
regalis sens. lat. on the Milvinae ; Buteo jamaicensis , B. swainsoni and
B. galapagoensis ; Haliaeetus vocifer, H. leucoryphus and Gypohierax
angolensis (see Table I for geographical range). This may be an example
geographical distribution OF AVIAN LICE 545
of secondary absence by extinction of one of a sympatric pair, the fulva
group taxa having become extinct on these hosts, and the regalis group
taxa on others of the Falconiformes. c. Two similar species of Struthio-
lipeurus , one oa the ostrich ( Struthio ) in Africa, the other on the Rhea
in South America, the genus Struthiolipeurus being found only on these
two host genera. This could be explained either by relationship between
the hosts or by overlap of distribution at some time. d. The occurrence
of Chelopistes on Lerwa lerwa. As shown above Chelopistes is found
on the New World families Cracidae, Odontophorinae and the Meleagri-
didae and this distribution suggests that its origin and divergence took
place in the New World. Why therefore does a typical member of the
genus turn up on Lerwa (subfamily Phasianinae) now restricted to
Afghanistan and the Himalaya east to the mountains of Szechuan?
Chelopistes is a distinctive genus and the species on Lerwa resembles the
other species too closely to suggest that it could have arisen by parallel
evolution. It must be presumed that Chelopistes was found on hosts
With a continuous distribution from the New World to the Oriental
region, of which only that on Lerwa in a small part of Asia remains.
It may be relevant that also parasitic on Lerwa is a species of Lagopoecus
which does not resemble the species-group typical of the Tetraonidae and
found on some members of the Phasianinae, but is more similar to the
species found on the Odontophorinae, especially to Lagopoecus numi -
dianus (Denny) from Colinus virginianus. This group of species of
Lagopoecus parasitic on the Odontophorinae shows rather diverse charac-
ters especially in the form of the male genitalia, so that the fact that those
of the Lerwa-infesting species are distinct would not rule out a relation-
ship.
Conclusions
The present distribution of the avian Phthiraptera is the result of a
complex of circumstances and factors operating at all stages of the
evolution of the host and parasite and involving host specificity, geo-
graphical isolation, extinction, secondary infestations and the various
changing ecological factors in the environment of the louse provided
by the body of the bird. The ornithologist may benefit from a knowl-
edge of the distribution of the Phthirapteran parasites, not only from
the light this may throw on bird phylogeny, the phylogenetic relation-
ship being the basic one, but the evidence provided of early migrations,
dispersal routes (Table V) and of former distributions. More extensive
collecting and closer study of the genera, based on detailed revisions, are
revealing and will reveal further examples of geographical distribution
and perhaps help to elucidate some of the present inexplicable cases.
546 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Table V
Species and genera of phthiraptera showing
DISCONTINUOUS GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION
? No records, possible host present.
References
Boyd, E. M. (1951) : A survey of
parasitism of the starling Sturms vul-
garis in North America. /. Parasit.
37 : 56-84.
Clay, T. (1949) : Some problems in
the evolution of a group of ectoparasites.
Evolution 3 : 279-299.
(1953) : Revisions of the
genera of Mallophaga. 1. The Rallicola-
complex. Proc. Zool. Soc. Lond. 123 :
563-587.
— (1955) : Revisions of the
Genera of Mallophaga. Colilipeurus and
a new genus. Trans. R. ent . Soc. Lond.
107 : 169-186.
Clay, T. (1957): The Mallophaga
of Birds in Premier Symposium sur la
specificite parasitaire des parasites de
Vertebres. Neuchatel.
— (1961) : Three new species of
Mallophaga (Insecta). Bull. Brit. Mus.
(Nat. Hist.).
(1962) : A key to the species
of Actornithophilus with notes and des-
criptions of new species. Bull. Br.
Mus. Nat. Hist. (Ent.) 11 : 189-244.
— . (1963) : New species of
Trinoton (Mallophaga, Insecta). Mem.
Queensland Mus. 14 : 87-93.
— — — (1964) : Geographical distri-
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF AVIAN LICE
541
bution of the Mallophaga (Insecta).
Bull. B.O.C. 84 : 14-16.
Clay, T. (1966) : The species of Strigi-
philus (Mallophaga) parasitic on the barn
owls ( Tyto ). /. Ent. Soc. 5 : 10-17.
Edwards, R. L. (1965) : Revision
of the genus Aquanirmus (Mallophaga)
parasitic on Grebes (Podicipidae). Can.
Ent. 97 : 920-935.
Hopkins, G. H. E. (1949) : The host-
associations of the lice of mammals.
Proc. Zool. See. Lond. 119 : 387-604.
(1951) : Stray notes on
Mallophaga, XI. Ann. Mag. nat. Hist.
4 : 371-377.
Hopkins, G. H. E. & Clay, T. (1952) :
A check list of the genera and species of
Mallophaga. British Museum (N.H.)
London.
Klockenhoff, H. (1969) : Zur Ver-
breitung der Mallophagen der Gattung
Myrsidea auf der Dschungelkrahe Corvus
macrorhynchos. Z. Zool. Syst. Evol.
Forsch.l: 53-58.
(1972) : Zur Taxonomie der
auf der Salvador i Krahe Corvus orru
lebenden Mallophaga-Gattung Myrsidea
Waterston. Bonn. zool. Beitr. 23 : in
press.
Price, R. D. (1970) : The Piagetiella
(Mallophaga : Menoponidae) of the
Pelecaniformes. Can. Ent. 102 : 389-404.
— — (1970) : A review of the
genus Heleonomus (Mallophaga : Meno-
ponidae) from the Cranes. Ann. ent.
Soc. Am. 63: 1162-1174.
Simpson, G. G. (1950) : History of
the fauna of Latin America. Am.
Scient. 38 : 361-389.
Tandan, B. K. & Brelih, S. (1971) :
A new species of Anaticola (Phthiraptera :
Ischnocera). Entomologist 104 : 268-276.
Tendeiro, J. (1962) : Revisao mono-
grafica do genero Columbicola (Ischno-
cera, Philipteridae). Mems. Jta. lav.
Ultramar. 32 : 1-460.
Thompson, G. B. (1940) : The distri-
bution of Heterodoxus spiniger. Pap.
Proc. R. Soc. Tasm. (1939) : 27-31.
Timmermann, G. (1971) : 4 Regel-
widrigkeiten ’ im Ausbreitungsbild bei
Vogelmallophagen. Mitt. Hamb. Zool.
Mus. Inst. 67 : 135-174.
Ward, R. A. (1958) : Preliminary
observations on the origin of some
Nearctic Bird Lice (Mallophaga). Proc.
10 th Intern. Congress Entom ., Montreal
1956, 1 : 745-749.
The Migration of the Gannet
into the Mediterranean1
A. Landsborough Thomson
This paper develops a particular aspect of a more general study of
the migration of the Gannet Sula bassana based on the recovery records
of birds ringed at breeding stations round the coasts of Great Britain
and Ireland (Thomson 1974). That study is itself a reassessment of a
situation earlier analysed by use of records representing only about
one-eighth of the number latterly available (Thomson 1939). It
is assumed that the ringing data, with due allowance for probable
fluctuations in death-rate, are reasonably representative of the geo-
graphical incidence of the birds at different ages and seasons. On this
assumption, the ringing data provide numerical indications such as
cannot be derived from general statements of distribution based on unco-
ordinated observational evidence. The records have been placed at
the Writer’s disposal by the British Trust for Ornithology.
Source of the data
Gannets native to, or breeding at, stations round the British and
Irish coasts represent a large proportion of the eastern North Atlantic
population of the species. Relatively little ringing of these birds has
been done at the large breeding stations off Iceland and in the Faeroe
Islands ; and others are of negligible size. The largest British station,
that on St Kilda, has also contributed nothing, owing to its inaccessi-
bility. Most of the birds here considered were ringed at one or other
of three offshore islands : — the Bass Rock in the Firth of Forth, on the
east coast of Scotland (56°0'4N, 2°38'W) ; Ailsa Craig in the Firth
of Clyde, on the west coast of Scotland (55°23'N, 5°07'W) ; and
Grassholm in the Irish Sea, off Pembrokeshire, SW Wales (51°44'N,
5°29'W.). Other stations off the coasts of Scotland and Ireland have
yielded a few records. No differences in migratory behaviour between
birds from the several localities have been detected, except that those
from Grassholm tend — as might be expected — to appear in Biscay waters
somewhat earlier in the autumn than those from the Scottish stations.
The records used in the main study numbered 1761, after discarding
those considered to be non-viable owing to uncertainty in the parti-
1 Received September 1972.
MIGRATION OF THE GANNET
549
culars or because the birds had never flown. The records had resulted
from the ringing of 32,681 birds, mostly as nestlings ( pulli ),
up to and including 1968, and recoveries therefrom up to the end of
1971 — a yield of almost 5*4 per cent. Of these records, 46 were from
the Mediterranean ; and to these are here added 5 others of more
recent date which there is no special reason for excluding in the present
context.
Conclusions of the general study
The main study shows a dispersal of the birds in northern waters,
and a partial migration southwards along the Atlantic seaboards of
western Europe and of northern and tropical Africa ; the extreme
records are from Portuguese Guinea (just south of 12° N). From
this movement there is the branch into the Mediterranean Sea, obviously
through the Straits of Gibraltar, which is here of more detailed concern.
The other principal finding is that birds in their first year of life are
migratory in markedly higher degree than those in their second year,
taken alone, or than all older birds taken together. That there is
any further decrease in the migratory urge after the second year is doubt-
ful, despite some slight appearance of this in the figures. The picture
is obscured by the fact that some of the immature birds — in a
species which does not breed until four or five years old — do not
return to northern waters in summer. A close examination of the
Mediterranean records seems to throw some light on this point.
Observed distribution in the Mediterranean
Gannets are seen in the western Mediterranean in winter, and less
frequently at other seasons ; Jenkins (1944) recorded about 150
fishing off Algeria in November, but such numbers are considered to
be exceptional. Referring generally to North Africa, Etchecopar & Hue
(1967) state that ‘In the Mediterranean the usual easterly limit is in the
region of Tripoli, but it has been seen exceptionally in Egypt’ — this last
not improbably refers to the bird recorded by Cornish (1934). On the
other hand, Hardy (1946) has published a circumstantial statement
that the Gannct is a ‘ fairly common winter visitor to the Palestine coast’,
appearing under certain weather conditions in numbers up to 50 ; this
statement, and later supporting evidence, seems to have been overlooked
by subsequent writers. The Bannermans (1971) rate it as a rare visitor
to Cyprus, where it had not been recorded before 1965.
Spano (1965, 1966) has listed and analysed the 100 then known
instances of Gannets being taken in Italy, and a further 25 sight records.
550 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (3)
Although these occurrences are spread throughout the year, most of
them fall in the months from November to March inclusively, with a
secondary peak in June (when, in contrast with ringing recoveries, there
are about equal numbers of adulti , semi-adulti and giovani). The
largest concentrations of records are in the Gulf of Genoa and off the
north coast of Sicily ; but there are occurrences up to the head of the
Adriatic and several inland (Po valley, etc.).
Mediterranean recoveries of ringed birds
Numbers : As already stated, there are 51 records of Gannets ringed
at breeding stations in the British Isles and recovered in the Mediter-
ranean— 46 included in the main study to which reference has been made,
and 5 of more recent date. The 46 recoveries may be compared with
the inclusive total of 747, in the main study, south of Ushant (Ouessant ;
48°28' N) ; Mediterranean recoveries thus comprise just under 6*2
per cent of all those showing migration southwards from home waters.
Age incidence : All but one of the recovered birds were ringed as
nestlings ( pulli ), and these Were recorded in the Mediterranean in the
following years of life :
1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th
24 15 6 2 2 1
Years of life are reckoned from 1 May, as in the main and earlier studies,
although during May and June of the first year the birds are at most
in the egg or in the nest and recoveries are nil.
The figures show the usual pattern of diminishing returns as the
total ‘at risk’ decreases with annual mortality. The ratio of second-
year to first-year birds (15/24=62*5 p.c.) is, however, about double
that found in the generality of recoveries south of Ushant.
(133/458=29*0 p.c.). This may well be a result of first-year birds
remaining in the Mediterranean through the next summer ; the alter-
native that second-year birds have a special proclivity for migrating
into the Mediterranean seems to be highly improbable in the light of
all the evidence.
Geographical incidence : The Mediterranean may be conveniently
divided into eight longitudinal sectors, each covering five degrees—
rather more at the two extremes ; a distinction can also be made between
the north and south sides of the Sea within these sectors. The recoveries
can then be tabulated as follows :
MIGRATION OF THE GANNET
551
It can be seen at a glance that the movement from the Atlantic into the
Mediterranean is of the nature of a dispersal, numbers falling off rapidly
With distance, rather than a migration with ? definite eastward urge.
Rather more than half of the total number of records fall in the first
(slightly enlarged) sector, weot of 0°, and are about equally divided bet-
ween northern and southern sides of the Mediterranean. On the north
side 13 records are spread from Gibraltar along the south-eastern coast
of Spain as far as Valencia ; on the south side 14 records range from
just south of Ceuta along the northern coast of Morocco and the coast
of Western Algeria (Oran, etc.).
Approximately another quarter of the total fall in the second sector
(0-5°E), equally divided between the north and south sides. On the
north, all 6 records relate to that part of the coast of France lying west
of the Rhone delta ; 6 records are from the south side, which comprises
the middle part of the coast of Algeria (Algiers, etc.)
In the third sector (5-10°E), there are no records from the north
side of the Mediterranean, while on the south there are single records
from eastern Algeria (Bone) and western Tunisia (Bizerta,) respectively.
In the fourth sector (lO-^E) there are, on the north, 4 records
from the western side of Italy (Elba ; Naples) and of Sicily (Palermo ;
Agrigento) ; and on the south one record from eastern Tunisia (Sfax)
and one from western Libya (Tripoli). In the fifth sector (15-20°E)
there are two records on the north, from eastern Sicily (Gulf of Catania)
and south-eastern Italy (Gulf of Taranto).
Beyond that there are just two records, one on the north and one on
the south, from the extremity of the (slightly enlarged) eighth sector (east
of 30°E) :
101.0734 Bass Rock (pull.) 1964 : ca. 5.iii.65, Gulf of Iskanderun
S.E. Turkey (Asia Minor), 36°40'N,
36°00'E.
104.7812 Ailsa Craig (pull.) 1966 : 3.iii.71, Ashdod, Israel (near
Gaza), 31°48'N, 34°38'E.
552 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
Seasonal Incidence : The month by month distribution of the Medi-
terranean recoveries, showing those in the first two years of life separately,
is as follows :
All the recoveries east of 5°E were in the period November-March
inclusively.
A peculiar point emerges from a more detailed examination of the
recoveries of first and second year birds in the first two sectors ; beyond
that, as regards both age and distance, the figures become rather small.
No first-year birds have been recovered on the north side in the second
sector, whereas there have been 5 recoveries of second-year birds, 3 of
them in July and 1 in August. It seems unlikely that these birds had
migrated in that year from northern waters, and more probable that they
had remained in the Mediterranean from the year before (other evidence
of which has already been mentioned). An apparent tendenc> to move
northwards into the Gulf of Lions in summer is of interest, especially as
that area is not otherwise productive of records (a second-year bird in
November, and a third-year bird in June).
Comparison with the Baltic
The Baltic Sea (Os t see) appears to offer a comparable opportunity
for a lateral movement eastwards at right angles to the general southward
migration. In fact, however, the species is uncommon in the Baltic
and the number of ringing records from there is almost negligible.
There are numerous records of British-ringed Gannets from the eastern
and south-eastern coasts of the North Sea, and into the Skagerrak and
Kattegat. But with one exception there are no records showing pene-
tration beyond what one may call the Baltic approaches ; the extreme
case, perhaps slightly overstepping that definition, is of a Grassholm
bird recovered in March of its second year in the Gulf of Lfibeck, off
MIGRATION OF THE GANNET
553
i
the coast of Mecklenburg. The definite exception is a Bass Rock bird
(507 318) recovered in summer, in June of its fifth year, in the Sovetsk
region of Lithuania, 55°05'N, 21°52/E.
There are obvious reasons for regarding the Baltic Sea as a relatively
inhospitable area. Parts of it are frozen over in winter ; and elsewhere
floating ice may be a hazard to birds plunging from a height. According
to A. Wheeler of the British Museum (Natural History), in a personal
communication, lack of food fishes is not likely to be a factor ; most of
the species which the Gannet is known to take in British waters are found
in the Baltic. He suggests that turbidity of the Water, in a shallow sea
fed by numerous silt-bearing rivers, may often make it difficult for flying
birds to see fish swimming beneath the surface layers.
Summary
The now abundant recovery records of Sula bassana ringed at British
breeding colonies give a numerical indication of the geographical incidence
of the birds according to age and season.
From the partial southward migration along the Atlantic seaboards
of Europe and Africa, notably in the first year of life, there is a lateral
branch into the Mediterranean Sea. This is a relatively small move-
ment, represented by little more than six per cent of the total number of
records south of Ushant (taken as the southern limit of home waters).
It is more of the nature of a dispersal, numbers decreasing rapidly with
distance, than a definite migration with an eastward urge ; the spread
takes place along both the north and the south sides of the Mediterranean,
and there are exceptional records from the far corners of the Levant.
There is a suggestion that first-year migrants remain in the Mediter-
ranean through the following summer in higher proportion than in the
Atlantic ; and that there is then a movement northward into the Gulf of
Lions.
There is, comparable with that into the Mediterranean, virtually no
lateral movement eastward into the Baltic Sea.
References
Bannerman, D. A. & W. M. (1971) :
Handbook of the Birds of Cyprus
and Migrants of the Middle East.
Edinburgh.
Cornish, (Mrs) H. (1934) : Cited
editorially, Brit. Birds 27 : 266.
Etchecopar, R. B. & Hue, F. (1967) :
The Birds of North Africa. Eng. trans.
P. A.D. Hollom. Edinburgh and London.
Hardy, E. (1946): Letter on the
winter distribution of the Gannet in the
eastern Mediterranean. Brit. Birds 39 :
256.
Jenkins, A. R. (1944) : Cited edi-
torially, Brit. Birds 38 : 58.
Spano, S. (1965) : La Sula [Sula
bassana bassana (L.)] in Italia. Riv. ital.
Orn. 35 : 1-33 ; and supplement 1966.
ibid. 35 : 89-90.
Thomson, A. L. (1939) : The migra-
tion of the Gannet : results of marking
in the British Isles. Brit. Birds 32 :
282-289.
(1974): The migration of the
Gannet : reassessment of British and
Irish ringing data. Brit. Birds 67 : 89-103.
The role of birds in the natural foci
of tick-borne arboviruses in
Western Siberia 1
G. I. Netsky, G. B. Malkov and I. I. Bogdanov
Omsk Research Institute of Natural Foci Infections , Omsk , USSR
In Western Siberia the existence of two arbovirus infections communi-
cated by ixodid ticks has been determined : the Russian spring-summer
tick-borne encephalitis (RSSE) and the Omsk hemorrhagic fever (OHF)
closely related to it, discovered in 1946-48.
The two viruses belong to the antigenic tick-borne encephalitis
complex whose representatives are found in many localities at great
distances from one another in Eurasia and North America.
The discovery in India (Work, Trapido and others) of the Kyasanur
forest disease, which is etiologically and clinically close to RSSE, showed
the possibility of virus exchange between India and Western Siberia,
occurring most likely on account of the migration of birds between India
and Siberia. Thus, the region of Siberia-India (and more widely South-
East Asia) has been selected as a typical area for studying the role
of migrating birds in spreading arboviruses on the virus models of tick-
borne encephalitis complex. Theoretically, within this region, besides
the exchange of arboviruses of the spring-summer tick-borne encephalitis
complex, there is the assumption of possible arbovirus transfer of other
antigenic groups northward of the Himalayas from South-East Asia
and Africa.
Very important in solving these problems can be named the studies
on migrating birds in India that have been carried out under the guidance
of Dr Salim Ali.
As we are concerned with viruses communicated by ixodid ticks,
the ascertaining of biocoenotic relations of birds with ticks in the foci
of corresponding infections will be of foremost interest. This article
brings out the basic results of our comparative studies of biocoenotic
relations of birds with ticks and viruses in the foci of tick-borne encepha-
litis and Omsk hemorrhagic fever in Western Siberia.
1 Received December 1972.
BIRDS IN THE NATURAL FOCI OF ARBOVIRUSES 555
The principal transporters of the said viruses are two basic West-
Sibsrian species of ixodid ticks : Ixodes persulcatus P. Sch. (taiga foci
of tick-borne encephalitis) and Dermacentor pictus Herm (forest-
steppe foci of OHF). In Western Siberia spontaneous infectivity
with both viruses has been repeatedly determined in the said two species
of ticks.
The importance of birds in the host range of ticks
Ixodes persulcatus and Dermacentor pictus
Our observations of many years, together with the available data
of other authors, have shown that the role of birds in harbouring ticks
is quite different for each of the two basic West-Siberian species
(see Table 1).
Table 1
Host-range of I. persulcatus and D. pictus in Western Siberia
The said species of ticks differ basically in that the I. persulcatus
feeds broadly on birds and mammalia, while D. pictus feeds mostly on
mammalia (rodents and insectivorae) and where birds, amphibia and
reptilia serve only as accidental hosts. In the present instance the
question concerns the feeding of larvae and nymphs of ticks, as the
imagines of both species feed on large mammalia, principally on cattle.
An idea of the role of different species of birds in harbouring
L persulcatus is given in Table 2.
It can therefore be said that the number of bird species acting as
tick-carriers, will be the greater the greater the area of forested terri-
tory, that is, from 23 species in large taiga areas to two species on the
terraces on the flood-lands of taiga rivers, where the vegetation is represen-
ted by shrubs and thinned groves. The leading role belongs to Anthus
trivialis , Turdus pilaris and Emberiza citrinella which become regularly
556 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (3)
Table 2
Birds acting as carriers of I. persulcatus ticks in different areas of
TERRITORY WHERE TICK-BORNE ENCEPHALITIS IS ENDEMIC (FOREST-STEPPE ON
FOOTHILLS AND HIGHLAND TAIGA OF WESTERN SIBERIA)
* Uncommon species of birds regularly infested by ticks.
** Common species of birds regularly infested by ticks.
infested, and are the most numerous on all the mentioned areas, or at
least on three of the four observed. A substantial role also belongs
to Emberiza aureola which, though less numerous, is nevertheless
regularly infested in all of the areas. The extent to which various bird
species are infested depends on the peculiarity of their food, as Well
as the average time spent daily on the ground.
BIRDS IN THE NATURAL FOCI OF ARBOVIRUSES 557
The number of bird species taking part in the feeding of ticks /. persul ~
catus varies in different areas, and depends on the general reserve of
immature stages on the given territory (Table 3).
Table 3
Percentage of birds infested by ticks ; the reserve of immature
stages of I. persulcatus, and the number of bird species acting as
TICK-CARRIERS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF FOCI
Birds become particularly infested in the years when the number
of small mammals is low, and when they serve to fill up the deficiency
in hosts (Shilova 1966). This shows the substantial role birds play
in keeping up the number of ticks /. persulcatus.
Absolutely different relations obtain in areas where D. pictus predomi-
nates. Birds are infested With ticks of this species at an average of only
OT-O’9% (forest-steppe of West Siberian lowland). Unitary nymphs
of D. pictus have been collected from Tringa ochropus , Anthus trivial is,
Motacilla flava, Emberiza citrinella , Emberiza schoeniclus and Turdus
philomelos. It follows from this that birds may serve only as accidental
hosts of D. pictus , which nevertheless does not signify their exclusion
from the virus circulation (see below).
The fact that D. pictus does not parasitize on birds has been
repeatedly noted by a number of authors who have worked in Western
Siberia, but has not so far received satisfactory explanation.
Birds, as the factor of formation of mixed ixodid
TICK FAUNA AND THE FACTOR OF COMBINING NATURAL
FOCI OF VARIOUS INFECTIONS
The retention of virus population on a given territory is ensured by
its reproduction during the circulation process within the range of con-
forming biocoenosis, as well as by viruses brought in with arthropods
558 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
and vertebrates. Here a certain role must belong to birds, capable of
promoting virus exchange between foci not only within limited areas,
but over large distances as Well (migrating birds). Birds may act as
the factor of formation of mixed tick fauna, and of combining natural
foci of various tick-borne infections.
In Western Siberia some Altai regions are of special interest, where
the tick-borne encephalitis fauna is represented by five species of ticks :
/. persulcatus , I. apronophorus, Haemaphysalis concinna, D. pictus
and D. silvarum. Ixodes persulcatus and Haemaphysalis concinna
can be named as the most numerous tick species in the biotopes investi-
gated. These species, in the present case, are epidemiologically sig-
nificant as being the carriers of tick-borne encephalitis and tick-borne
typhus fever (Serdyukova 1956 ; Shaiman et al. 1966), and they
regularly parasitize on birds (see Table 4).
Table 4
Species of birds infested by ticks in the investigated areas of Altai
Species and stages of ticks
I. persulcatus | H. concinna
Ixodes persulcatus has been found on 17 bird species in the imma-
ture stage and as imago. Haemaphysalis concinna has been found only
BIRDS IN THE NATURAL FOCI OF ARBOVIRUSES 559
on eight bird species and exclusively as larvae and nymphs. Hence,
I. persulcatus attacks birds more readily than H. concinna. Table 5 shows
the. state of infestation of birds and small mammalia by these two tick
species in different biotopes.
Table 5
Comparative data on the infestation of small
MAMMALIA AND BIRDS BY TICKS
(Observations made in Altai)
Nymphs of H. concinna in secondary forests have been found only
on birds ; small mammalia were left practically uninfested. The
birds, obviously, become parasitized with this tick beyond the bounds
of secondary forests, and, in the present case, in the foothill forest-
steppes, where H. concinna are much more numerous than under the
cover of the forest. The foothill forest-steppes, due to their mixed
character of biotopes, concentrate birds that act as hosts for H. concinna
( Turdus pilaris , Anthus trivialis, Emberiza leucocephalos, E. citrinella).
The constant daily shifting of certain bird species (search of food for
young, daytime location, etc.) from foothill forest-steppes to the secon*
dary forests serves to transfer H. concinna into the forest biotopes*
At the same time there occurs the transport of ticks from the secon-
dary forests to the foothill forest-steppes. In this respect it is especially
interesting that birds of the sparrow family are parasitized not only by
14
560 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
larvae and nymphs of I. persulcatus, but by the imago of the latter as
well. In connexion with the discovery in Altai of the tick Ixodes
pavlovskyi, similar to Ixodes persulcatus and co-existing with it in the same
biotopes, and owing also to the inclination of I. pavlovskyi to feed on birds,
Filippova & Ushakova (1967) suggested that the imagines of ticks in our
collections from birds belong mostly to I. pavlovskyi. The leading role
of Ixodes sp. as carriers in secondary forests belongs to T. pilaris
(infestation up to 69%), as well as to E. citrinella and E. leucocephalos
(infestation up to 50%).
These observations allow us to consider birds as one of the factors
providing the formation of mixed ixodid fauna in the said locality on the
boundary between the forest-steppe and the taiga. I. persulcatus and
H. concinna aie the vectors of tick-borne encephalitis and Asian tick-
borne rickettsiosis, and birds, as it can be seen, play a definite role in
forming combined foci of these infections in Western Siberia (Netsky,
Shaiman).
According to observations made by H. Hoogstraal et al. (1963)
the exchange of ixodid ticks by migrating birds is also possible at
great distances. In this case the repeated bringing in of even single ticks
may be of significance. While its possibility is predetermined by the regular
mass migration of birds along evolutionally established routes.
Our observations show that ticks of the local ixodid fauna may take
part in irradiating pathogens brought in from a definite spot to adjacent
territories. This is, apparently, most probable where the biotope changes
and in the presence of ticks that actively attack birds.
j ' - $
The role of birds in the circulation of
TICK-BORNE ARBOVIRUSES WITHOUT THE PARTICIPATION
OF IXODID TICKS
Participation of birds in the circulation of West Siberian tick-borne
arboviruses (tick-borne encephalitis and Omsk hemorrhagic fever) is
effected not only by the attacks of ixodid ticks, but by other ways in
which birds get infected. Thus, in the forest foci of RSSE, I. persulcatus
regularly feed on birds (21 to 40% of the birds are parasitized by ticks),
on the other hand, in forest-steppe foci of OHF D. pictus , which is the
dominant species there, leaves the birds practically untouched (only 0T
to 0*9% of the birds are parasitized).
At the same time Maty ukhin and Fedorova et al. (1966) have shown
that in the forest foci of RSSE, as well as the forest-steppe foci of OHF,
there occurs wide contact of birds with viruses. The immune layer
against viruses of the RSSE complex in forest-steppe foci makes up
22*9%, and in the forest-steppe areas from 13*4 to 22*3 %. As a whole,
in the forest-steppe foci of OHF out of 606 specimens of birds (77 spe*
BIRDS IN THE NATURAL FOCI OF ARBOVIRUSES S6l
cies) antibodies to viruses of the RSSE complex were found on 87 birds
(32 species) (see Table 6). In the latter case the rare instances of ticks
attacking birds are, apparently, insufficient to maintain the immune
layer on said level.
Table 6
Birds in fqrest-steppe foci of OHF with antibodies to viruses of the
RSSE complex (matyukhin, fedorova et al. 1966)
1 . Anthus novaeseelandiae Gmelin
2. Anthus trivialis (L.)
3. Acrocephalus agricola (Jerdon)
4 . Motaci l la alba L .
5. Motacilla flava L.
6. Motacilla citreola Pallas
7. Emberiza citrinella L.
8. Emberiza schoeniclus (L.)
9. Emberiza patlasi Cabanis
10. Emberiza leucocephalos S. G. Gmelin
11. Emberiza aureola Pallas
12. Alauda arvensis L.
13. Oenanthe isabellina (Temnrnck
14. Panurus biarmicus (L.)
15. Sylvia borin Boddaert
16. Saxicola torquata (L.)
h 17. Erithacus svecicus (L.)
18. Corvus cor one L.
19. Anas crecca L.
20 . Anas querquedula L .
21. Anas platyrhynchos L„
22. Anas strepera L.
23. Anas acuta L.
24. Anas penelope L.
25. Ay thy a fuligula (L.)
26. Ay thy a ferina (L.)
27. Anser anser (L.)
28. Tringa glareola L,
29. Phalaropus lobatus (L.)
30. Podiceps auritus L.
„ „ 31. Sterna hirundo L.
32. Larus cams L.
In the present case, mosquitoes are the most probable vectors for
immunizing birds with virus. Positive results have been achieved in the
Virologic studies of mosquitoes carried out on a territory endemic with
OHF and characterized by an abundance of lakes, as well as a wide zone
of reed growth and marshes serving for the mass propagation of mos-
quitoes and the concentration of migrant waterfowl : eight strains of
virus, identified as the virus of OHF, have been isolated from the mos-
quitoes Mansonia richardii Fie*, Aedes flavescens and A. excruciahs
56>2 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
(Netsky e/ ah 1966). Subsequently the virus of OHF has been repeatedly
isolated from mosquitoes during two or three seasons in two different
localities separated by a distance of 300-400 kilometres, but with
similar landscape. It was also shown experimentally that mosquitoes
(M. richardii) are capable of being infected with the virus of OHF on
an infected white mouse, and of communicating the virus by stinging a
healthy mouse (Volynets & Bogdanov 1971).
Mosquitoes in the forest-steppe foci of OHF can, therefore, be consi-
dered as the probable vector of virus to birds, since the role of ixodid
ticks in the present case is excluded.
Conclusion
In West-Siberian foci of tick-borne encephalitis and Omsk hemorrhagic
fever wide participation of birds has been established in the circulation of
definite viruses. Involvement of birds in the circulation of viruses in the
taiga and adjacent areas is connected with the regular feeding of ticks
Ixodes persulcatus and Haemaphy salis concinna (latter in Altai) on birds.
In the forest-steppes of Western Siberia birds are drawn into the circula-
tion of these viruses without the ixodid ticks taking part, as the tick
Dermacentor pictus practically does not attack birds. Mosquitoes are
considered as the most probable carriers of viruses among birds.
The movement of birds assists in the formation of mixed ixodid fauna
and of combined foci of infections connected with different species of
ticks, which occurs owing to the carriage of ticks from biotopes where
certain species of ticks predominate to adjacent territories where they are
not otherwise found.
References
Filippova, N. A., Ushakova, G. V.
(1967). On the species of the group
Ixodes persulcatus ([xodidae, Parasiti-
formes). 1. Ixodes pavlovsky. Pom. in
Eastern Kazakhstan ; redescription of
female and description of male. (In
Russian, English summary.) Parazito-
logiya, 1(4) : 269-276.
Hoogstraal, H . ( 1 963) : ‘ Migrating
birds as tick, transporters in Asia, Europe
and Africa.’ Abstr. Pap. 7 Int. Congr.
Trop. Med. Malar. (Rio de Janeiro),
p/279,:
Hoogstraal, H., Kaiser, M. N.,
Taylor, M. A., Gober, S., Guindy, E.
(1963) ‘ Ticks (Ixodoidea) on birds
migrating from Africa to Europe and
Asia.’ Bull. World Hlth Org., pp. 147-
212.
Hoogstraal, H., Taylor M. A.»
Gober, S., Malacatis, G., Guindy, E.,
Helmi, J. (1963) ‘Ticks (Ixodidae) on
migrating birds in Egypt, spring and fall
1962.’ Bull. World Hlth Org., pp.
355-67.
Matyukhin, V. N., Fedorova, T. N.,
Malkov, G. B., Danilov, O. N., Bog-
danov, 1. 1., Dargol’ts, V. G., Ravkin,
Yu. S. ‘Results of serologic investigations
of birds in foci of tick-borne encephalitis
and Omsk hemorrhagic fever in Wes-
tern Siberia.’
Rol’ pereletmkh ptits v rasprostra-
nenii arbovirusiv, edited by Netsky
G.I., Maksimov A. A., Yurlov K. T.
(in Russian), Mater. 2. Mezhinst. Simp.,
Novosibirsk, April 26-27, 1965, pp.
33-39.
BIRDS IN THE NATURAL FOCI OF ARBOVIRUSES
56 3
Netsky, G. I., Fedorova, T. N.,
Alifanov, V. I., Volynets, L. V. (1966) :
‘ Virus research on blood-sucking
mosquitoes in the forest-steppe foci of
Omsk hemorrhagic fever ’ (Virusolo-
ghicheskye izsledovanya krovososoos-
chykh Komarov v lyeso-styepnykh
ochagakh Omskoi ghemorraghicheskoi
likhoradki). In book : ‘ Migrating
birds and their role in the spreading of
arboviruses * (Peryelyotnye ptytsi i ikh
rol v rasprostranyenii arbovirusov),
Novosibirsk, pp. 294-300.
Serdyukova, G. V. (1956) : Ixodid
ticks of the fauna of the USSR. (Ixo-
dovye klyeshi fauny SSSR.), Moscow-
Leningrad.
Shaiman, M. S., Netsky, G. I., Chu-
lovsky, r. K., Fedorova, T. N., Mal-
kov, G. B., Dargolts, V. G. (1966) :
Results of the work of an epidemiologi-
cal group for control of tick-borne
encephalitis, tick-borne exanthematous
fever and leptospirosis in Altai (in
Russian). Materialy nautshno-prakti-
cheskoi konferencii. Barnaul, pp. 5-6.
Shilova, S. A., (1966): Influence of
vertebrate animals on spatial distribu-
tion of Ixodes persulcatus ticks (in
Russian). Tezisy Dokl. 1 Akarol.
Soveshch.pp. 230-231.
Volynets, L. V. , Bogdanov, I. I.
(1971) : A study of the susceptibility of
mosquitoes Mansonia richardii Fic. to
the virus of Omsk hemorrhagic fever.
(Izuchenye vospriimchivosty komarov
Mansonia richardii Fic. k virusu Omskoi
ghemorraghicheskoi likhoradki). In
book : The problems of infectious patho-
logy. (Voprosi infektsionnoi patologii),
Omsk, pp. 82-4.
Work, T. H., Trapido, H. (1957):
Summary of preliminary report of
investigation of the Virus Research Cen-
tre on an epidemic disease affecting
forest villagers and wild monkeys of
Shimoga District, Mysore. Indian J,
Med. Sci. 11 : 340-341,
. j ~:c
:x
• i w
XT' _• io
■■J d mcxiz
- C ,
L XT
it!;:,.
Visual learning capacity and retention
in the Tree Shrew ( Tupaia ) : an
extension1
Rudolf Altevogt and Sigrid Zeller
(with technical assistance by Miss Anne-Katrin Hapel )
Physiology and Ecology Department , Faculty of Biology,
Munster University , Germany
(With three figures — 1 in text, 2 inset)
, ■ " j: '} ■ : qi : ; H.i
This paper is dedicated to India’s foremost ornithologist, Dr S&lim
Ali. Even if it does not dwell on birds we venture to offer it to him as a
token on the occasion of his 75th birthday as he is also an eminent ecolo-
gist, general biologist and conservationist with a deep interest and love
of animals : hence Tupaia may enter.
Since tree shrews (Tupaiidae) have been placed fairly high on the
ascending evolutionary scale, and since some authors regard them as the
link between Insectivora and Lemurioidea, or even as essentially lemuri-
form (e.g. Le Gros Clark 1934, 1959 ; Simpson 1945), every bit of infor-
mation concerning their functional, sensory and behavioural performance
is welcome as it might shed further light on the human whence and where
of his own capacities. The problem of the systematic position of tree
shrews is by no means settled as can be seen from the more recent papers
by Van Valen (1965 : tree shrews and primates not closely related, fossil
evidence), Spatz (1967 : contrary view, anatomical, histological, beha-
vioural facts) and Martin (1968 : behavioural evidence in favour of no
close relationship).
To assess the visual learning capacity of an animal one has to rely
on a method yielding quantitative results for comparison. Various para-
meters have been used for comparing animal performance and thus plac-
ing various animals on certain systematic and phyletic levels, e.g. learning
speed, amount of errors in the learning process, duration of retaining the
tasks learned, learning set, etc. The literature on animal learning and
retention is vast, and we shall not go into details here.
One method which we used rather early and, as we hope, successfully
is the serial rotation test of visual discrimination learning (Altevogt
1 Received August 1972,
VISUAL LEARNING IN TREE SHREWS
565
1951). In this method, the animal is required to learn a visual discrimi-
nation of two-dimensional patterns in a two-choice set-up, e.g. black
cross versus black circle each on white background, and offered as a
cardboard to be pushed aside to get the food reward. After the first two-
pattern-discrimination has been learned to criterion, the animal learns
the next task, say fine stripes versus broad stripes, again offered as black-
white patterns on plaques. In this way a number of discrimination tasks
can be learned one after the other, the data indicating learning speed,
criterion reached, etc.
Serial rotation is introduced after two or more such tasks have been
learned to criterion, i.e. then task 1, 2 and 3 are offered one after the
other in this sequence or in any other predetermined order, say 3, 1,2, 2,
3, 1, etc. Obviously, with increasing number of tasks learned, the num-
ber of Stimulus pairs in each of such sequences increases, and the experi-
menter Will find out just how many of the stimuli will be mastered quasi
simultaneously by the animal as it is required to have the correct choices
ready, e.g. to know the right (and wrong?) stimulus of pairs 1 to 5 if
given the 5 pair serial rotation test. In this manner, especially Rensch
and his collaborators have tested a number of animals of various levels
from fish to elephants (survey given in Rensch 1962).
The range of visual learning capacity thus determined reaches from a
meagre 1 in the opossum (Neumann, 1957) to 20 visually discriminated pairs
of patterns in the Indian elephant (Rensch & Altevogt, 1955). Unfortu-
nately, the monkey and ape level has not been touched yet as far as We
know, and man himself has not been tested by this method either.
Tigges (1964) applied the method on tree shrews ( Tupaia glis Diard
1820) ‘since they belong to the most primitive level of primates ’
(232). He used 3 pairs of black-white and 3 pairs of colour stimuli as
discriminanda and found that ‘ none of the 6 animals was able to retain
simultaneously more than 3 different tasks ’ (240).
This rather poor performance does not compare favourably with the'
fact that a reasonably ‘bright’ mouse or rat masters at least 5-6 pairs of
visual discriminanda in the serial rotation test (Boxberger 1953 ;
Reetz 1958).
While working on the behavioural physiology and ontogeny of
Tupaia glis (Zeller 1971) we carried out a series of experiments on the
visual learning capacity using the 6 pairs of black-white patterns shown
in Figure 1. Thus We eliminated possible experimental errors most
often inherent in studies using (pigment) colour stimuli (i.e. proper
control of brightness and hue). The discriminanda Were 6 x 9 cm in
size and could comfortably be duplicated photographically. As they
soiled rather often due to the animals’ tendency to impregnate paths and
objects of their home range olfactorily (for review see Zeller 1971) they
were covered by plastic film so that they could easily be cleaned to control
566 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Val. 71 (3)
for possible olfactory clues in the discrimination trials. The discrimi”
panda were offered on 2 - 4 small white doors of 10*5 x 10*5 cm which
swung open if the animal touched them— which they did with their
Fig. 1. The six pairs of discriminanda used in choice
experiments with Tupaia glis.
spout or hands. The experimental animals were given access to the
discriminanda from a starting platform (bottom, Fig. 2) at a maximum
distance of 50 cm from where they could view the discrimination pairs as
shown in Fig. 3. Illumination by hidden bulbs resulted in a brightness
level of 285 lux measured 18 cm in front of the discriminanda. After
choosing the positive pattern, i.e. opening the respective door, the animal
found the food reward (biscuit, lettuce, meat).
To control for spontaneous preferences, the animals were first pre-
sented with both stimuli of each pair food-baited, and the pattern sponta-
neously preferred was given negative meaning, i.e. would not be rewarded
subsequently.
For the daily trials the animal’s living cage was connected to the choice
apparatus by an alley, thus giving free access to the starting platform
and keeping the animals’ disturbance due to handling etc. at a minimum.
VISUAL LEARNING IN TREE SHREWS
567
Experiments were run between 9 and 11 a.m. (sometimes to 1 p.m.),
with food and water given ad lib. from afternoon to night. Normally
there were 25 trials per day and animal.
The learning criterion was 5 consecutive days with at least 25 trials
each and more than 75% correct runs per day (this is a higher criterion
than that used by Tigges, who chose 12' 1 % on 5 successive series follow-
ing Roller’s [1953] statistics).
All animals were housed individually in cages of 100 x 60 x 75 cm
with a smaller sleeping and eating box of 20 x 20 x 17 cm. Room tempe-
ratures Were 27 - 30° C and relative humidity was kept at 30 -50%.
Apparently this regime suited the tree shrews fine, as within 2 years the
7 animals we started with produced 19 young (for details see Zeller
1971).
From our animals we chose one $ and one <}, both 1 year old at the
beginning of the experiments, for the study of visual learning capacity.
This small number would do as we only wanted to find out whether
Tigges’s findings could be extended or if indeed Tupaia must be credited
with such a limited visual learning capacity as indicated in his paper.
Single tasks
Spontaneously the two animals showed the following preferences
(Table 1) :
Table 1. Figures indicate number of choices of respective pattern in 20 trials with
both stimuli rewarded.
Correspondingly, if there was a strong preference of a particular
pattern it was given negative meaning and vice versa.
Learning the discriminanda, offered as pairs indicated and in the
order of Table 1, was mastered by both animals without difficulty except
pair no. 3 (‘ snake ’ versus bar) which was learned by the male with a
good record (80, 80, 88, 92, 88 %: average 85*6 % over 5 days with 25
trials each), but which could not be mastered by the female, who failed to
reach criterion in 21 days. She was therefore offered another (i.e. 7th)
pair of discriminanda : j<>] versus Q yielding 76, 80, 76, 84 and 76 %
correct choices, hence reaching criterion.
568 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
The respective correct choices by our test animals shown at the
various visual tasks 1-6 are tabulated in Table 2.
Table 2. Correct choices (%) by Tupaia , in 5 series of 25 trials each leading to
learning criterion.
Number of tasks
Table 3. Serial rotation test in Tupaia. Correct choices (%) in 2-, 3-, 4-, and
5-task test.
As can be seen from Table 3, both animals not only mastered the 3-
and 4-task test in serial rotation with good results, but showed even
better percentages of correct choices than in the single task tests. Thus,
task 1 had yielded 82*4 and 84% in the single (see Table 2), but in the
serial rotation of tasks 1 and 2 both the animals reached 9 1*6%. This
finding is in accordance with data by Altevogt (1951) in chickens, by
Rensch & Altevogt (1955) in the Indian elephant, and by various authors
applying the same method on various animals (see Rensch 1962, for
review). Possibly, the animal’s attention and ^willingness to discriminate
is aroused to a larger degree by the continuously changing order of discri-
minanda which may be less 4 boring ’ than having to work on the same
pair of patterns for a longer time.
Due to the fact that the female had not reached criterion in tasks
3 and 5, her 3-task test comprised pairs 1, 2, and 4, while in the male it
was 1, 2, and 3. Both animals, however, scored excellently (<j> 92 ‘5% ;
# 94-4%).
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (3) Plate I
Altevogt & Zeller: Tree Shrew
Fig. 2. Visual discrimination apparatus. Starting platform at bottom.
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (3)
Altevogt & Zeller: Tree Shrew
Fig. 3. A pair of discriminanda on swinging doors, animal’s view.
VISUAL LEARNING IN TREE SHREWS
569
Correspondingly, in the 4-task rotation the female was confronted
with tasks 1, 2, 4 and 6, because she had not performed too Well at task 5
(fine and coarse stripes). The male was given tasks 1, 2, 3, and 4, and
reached an average of 90*9 %, while the female scored 96T %. Hence,
both animals had already bettered the old Tupaia-YQcord, and there seem-
ed good hope of an even further improvement.
In the 5-task rotation the male mastered pairs 1-5 to a remarkable
degree scoring an average of 92‘5 %. The female (with tasks 1, 2, 4, 6
and 7) reached only 75, 72*5, and 67*5% on three consecutive days with
40 trials each, hence failing success. Repeated re-training at the appa-
rently more difficult discriminanda did not improve the situation in the
rotation presentation, hence indicating that apparently the visual capacity
of this female was limited to keeping in mind 4 pairs of patterns at a given
time simultaneously.
In the male this range could be extended to 5 pairs as shown by the
5-task test where he scored a surprising 92’5%.
Though the male learned task no. 6 (white versus black plaque) rather
easily after this 5-task test, he was unable to perform the 6-task test,
successfully scoring only 65’9, 53*7, and 48*8 % on 3 successive days.
Indeed, the behaviour of the male was now definitely changed as erratic
bursts of locomotion, escape reactions and unwillingness to enter the
discrimination situation etc. would impede proper and correct choosing,
A similar behaviour was seen in the female leading to a failure already in
the 5-task test.
Possibly, we might have succeeded in training our animals to an even
higher level of Simultaneously mastered pairs of discriminanda had we
offered colour stimuli, as Tigges (1964) noted that ‘black-and-white
patterns are obviously difficult for tree shrews to learn 5 (242), and ‘ that
tasks involving coloured stimuli were learned rapidly and were well
retained’ (235). For reasons of comparison, however, we did not try
to do so, and We may state that in the ascending scale, Tupaia with at
least 5 visual tasks mastered simultaneously fits in nicely as a reasonably
good learner Which possibly can do even better.
Summary : Two tree shrews, Tupaia glis, 1 $ and 1 <}, were trained in
rewarded 2-choice tests requiring the visual discrimination of pairs of
two-dimensional black- white patterns. After the first two pairs of dis-
criminanda had been learned the animals Were offered these pairs alter-
nately in a serial rotation test which required the simultaneous mastering
of the positive (and negative ?) stimuli of these two pairs. Similarly,
after learning the 3rd, 4th, 5th, etc. pairs the 2-, 3-, 4-, 5-, rotation tests
were offered.
The female mastered 4, and the male 5 tasks in the serial rotation test,
and with this kind of multiple presentation both animals scored more
correct choices than in most single-task learning.
570 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
References
Altevogt, R. (1951) : Vergleichend-
psychologische Untersuchungen an
Hiihnerrassen stark unterschiedlicher
Kdrpergrosse. Z. Tierpsychol. 8, 75-
109.
Boxberger, F. von (1953) : Verglei-
chende Untersuchungen liber das visuelle
Lernvermogen bei weissen Ratten und
weissen Mausen. Z. Tierpsychol. 9,
433-51.
Koller, S. (1953) : Graphische Tafeln
zur Beurteilung statistischer Zahlen
(Steinkopff, Darmstadt).
Le Gros Clark, W. E. (1934) : The
early forerunners of man (Bailliere,
Tindall & Cox, London.)
Le Gros Clark, W. E. (1959) : The
antecedents of man (University Press,
Edinburgh).
Martin, R. D. (1968) : Reproduction
and ontogeny in tree shrews ( Tupaia
belangeri ) with reference to their general
behaviour and taxonomic relationship.
Z. Tierpsychol , 25 : 409-532.
Neumann, G. H. (1957) : Die visuelle
Lernfdhigkeit primitiver Saugetiere und
Vogel. Diss. Munster.
Reetz, W. (1958) : Visuelles Lernver-
mbgen von Ratten und Mausen. Z.
Tierpsychol. 20, 80-109.
Rensch, B. (1962) : Gedachtnis,
Abstraktion und Generalisation bei
Tieren. Arbeit sgem. f. Forschung Nord-
rhein-Westfalen, Heft 114.
Rensch, B. & Altevogt, R. (1955) :
Das Ausmass visueller Lernfahigkeit
eines Indischen Elefanten. Z. Tier-
psychol. 12, 68-76.
Simpson, G. G. (1945) : The principles
of classification and a classification of
mammals. Bull. Amer. Mus. nat. Hist
85, 350 pp. (New York).
Spatz, W. N. (1967) : Die Ontogenese
der Cartilago Meckeli und der Symphysis
mandibularis bei Tupaia glis. Folia
primat. 6 : 180-203.
Tigges, J. (1964) : On visual learning
capacity, retention and memory in Tupaia
glis Diard 1820. Folia primat. 2, 232-45.
Valen, L. van (1965) : Tree shrews,
primates, and fossils. Evolution 19:
137-51.
Zeller, S. (1971) : Lernpsychologische
und verhaltensphysiologische Studien
an Tupaia. Staatsarbeit Munster.
What leads to increases in the
range of certain birds?1
Horace Alexander
Ornithologists have good reason to deplore the decrease and even the
total disappearance of bird species in many parts of the world. The
reasons for such decreases are no doubt various, but in all the conti-
nents and on many of the islands where birds are disappearing, the en-
croachment of that ever-increasing mammalian species, Man, is almost
certainly the most important single cause. It may well be that Man’s
transformation of the environment is also the predominant cause in
some, if not all, of the cases in which a species has noticeably increased.
Certain birds have become closely dependent on human artifice,
whether using buildings for their nesting purposes, as with several species
of swallow and martin (Hirundinidae) and swifts (Apodidae), or a more
general use of human developments, as with the House Sparrow {Passer
domesticus) or Starling {Sturnus vulgaris). In both sides of the North
Atlantic, the Herring Gull {Larus argentatus) seems to have increased
greatly in the course of this century, largely because the growth of modern
cities has provided them with a new kind of reliable food in the form of
large rubbish dumps. But in other cases, adaptation to man is not so
recent, and one can only speculate as to the extent, if any, of increase
of the species resulting from the (presumed) change in breeding habits.
How many House Swifts {Micropus affinis) were there in India before
man began to build solid houses ? How many (or hoW few) Cliff Swallows
{Hirundo fluvicola) before men began to build bridges of brick and stone
across streams and rivers ? Was the Common Swallow {Hirundo r us tied)
the common and very widespread species that it is today in the days
when man was himself a scarce animal, living chiefly in caves ? Today,
all across its vast range, it seems to build its nest almost exclusively on
man-made buildings.
Such questions are difficult to answer. It is better, perhaps, to
concentrate on species whose increase is recent and certain, and for which
it ought to be possible to assign some clear explanation.
Two species, both of them common and familiar birds in India, have
greatly increased their range and so, presumably, their abundance in the
world, during the past few decades. These are the Cattle Egret {Bubulcus
1 Received March 1972.
572 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
ibis) and the Collared Dove (Indian Ring-Dove of modern Indian bird-
books, Streptopelia decaocto). It is my personal impression that increase
or decrease of the range of a widely distributed bird normally reflects
some change in its status in the centre of its range. So it may be worth
while to examine these two spectacular increases with a view to enquire
what, if any, circumstance in the environment in India (in the case of the
Cattle Egret possibly the African environment is even more relevant)
has led to the explosion.
The two cases are not really, I think, closely parallel, except at the
‘ receiving ’ end. But each is worth examining.
It appears that the Cattle Egret found its Way across the Atlantic
to northern South America (Surinam about 1880 seems to be the earliest
definite record) rather less than a hundred years ago. But it is only
since it appeared in Florida in the 1940s that its increase has been specta-
cular. Now it breeds as far north as Ontario (Canada), and it has been
recorded right across North America to the west coast. Moreover, the
species has established a regular migratory habit in eastern North America,
so that birds breeding in the mid-Atlantic States go south before the
onset of winter. In February, 1971, I found it an astonishingly plentiful
bird in Jamaica, though it was not recorded in the West Indies at all until
1952. Probably some of these were winter migrants from North America.
In the February 1972 issue of the magazine Natural History (Journal
of the American Museum of Natural History, New York), William J.
Weber discusses its breeding biology, which he has studied in order to
see if there are special reasons why this species has increased so rapidly.
He finds several such reasons. His summary is in these Words : ‘ The
nesting stability [i.e. he found that the adults returned to the nest very
quickly after being disturbed, and quickly Tolerated his presence], the
incubating, brooding and feeding of the young by both parents, the domi-
nant survival order of the chicks based on available food, and the long
breeding season add up to an evolutionary balance favoring survival.’
All this is of great interest, and shows reasons why the Cattle Egret should
prosper ; but as none of these habits is known to be recent, it does not
really answer the question: Why such a rapid increase in recent years?
Cattle Egrets are obviously among the species that depend on the presence
of Man ; but it is Man the Herdsman, who is not a very modern inven-
tion, not Man the city-dweller or the industrial developer, whose activity
is useful to them. Has there in fact been any noticeable change in the
habits of Man the Herdsman in either Africa or Asia? And has the
Cattle Egret extenied its range or increased in numbers in either India or
tropical Africa? The recent arrival of the species in Australia is, I
believe, the result of introduction. Is there evidence of its increase in
Southern Asia? Or can it be that the spectacular increase in America
is due first of all to a more or less fortuitous crossing of the Atlantic
INCREASES IN THE RANGE OF BIRDS 573
followed by the discovery of a 4 niche ’ in at least Central and North
America which was open to it, and which it has rapidly filled? As far
as I can see there has been no noticeable spread of its range in south
Europe,
The spread of Streptopelia decaocto is quite another matter, though
here too we may end by asking questions for which, as far as I can judge,
there are no very clear answers.
First, let us try to see what the story is : A century ago, when H. E.
Dresser was writing his great birds of Europe, the 4 Collared Turtle-Dove
as he called it, was only found in the extreme south-east of Europe, in
the Baikan peninsula. It is interesting to note that, even in those days,
in that part of its range, it preferred to live in or around towns and villages.
Thus, Dresser quotes Messrs Elwes and Buckley as writing (in The Ibis
for 1870) that 4 it inhabits most of the towns and villages in the south of
Turkey In Constantinople it is especially numerous, and also in
some of the Macedonian villages which are interspersed with trees and
gardens. It appears to love the neighbourhood of dwellings, and may be
seen sitting, like a Sparrow, on the roofs of the houses, where it is never
molested by the Turks ’. So its behaviour in Turkey a hundred years ago
was the same as its behaviour in western Europe in the 1960s.
In India, which I am treating as its original home, this close identifi-
cation With the haunts of man is not so obvious. Here let me quote the
latest and fullest account in the handbook of the birds of india and
Pakistan, by Salim Ali and Dillon Ripley, vol. 3, p. 148, published in 1969 :
4 One of our commonest doves ; very plentiful in some areas, inexpli-
cably scarce in others outwardly just as suitable. Keeps in pairs or small
Parties — often in company with other doves — gleaning in paddy stubbles,
newly sown millet fields, or fallow land often in the environs of towns
and villages. The birds perch freely on the buildings, and boldly enter
cattle sheds and verandas and courtyards of rustic dwellings to feed with-
in an arm’s length of the occupants.’ Local migrations are noted.
Let me add a paragraph about the habits of this bird as I have noted
them in Britain since it arrived there and bred in Norfolk in 1955. Then
we can see whether the available information gives any clue to its quite
extraordinary ‘explosion’ during the past forty years.
The Norfolk colony, which I watched more than once, fed in the
grounds of a good-sized house, near the sea, and the birds nested in
cypress trees, which are, of course, not native to England. For some
years this addiction to cypress trees was noted as a characteristic feature
of most of the early colonies in the south of England. I doubt if that
could still hold today, when the species has become so widespread that
it is nesting in deciduous trees quite commonly. Indeed, the first pair
that Were known to breed in Kent (SE. England) were nesting in a deci-
duous tree at a farm quite a long Way from the sea. But, like the Norfolk
$74 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
birds, these Kentish doves were able to feed on the food provided for
fowls ; and this would be true for many of their early colonies, indeed it is
probably true over most of the British range. Before leaving south-east
England, I may recall that in October, 1959, only four years after the
first Norfolk birds had nested, and only two years after the first Kent
birds had been shown me (very secretly), we spent a few days at the small
town of Lydd, a few miles from the English Channel. It is a town I
have known all my life, and I have known just what birds to expect there.
But this was different. The one large grove of trees Was constantly alive
With the 4 coo-coo-cuk ’ of Collared Doves. Already the local inhabitants
Were beginning to get tired of their perpetual cooing. We saw a dozen
or more together. They Were Well established.
That is only thirteen years ago. The latest British Ornithologists’
Union British bird list ( The Status of Birds in Britain and Ireland), publish-
ed in 1971, summarizes the present status of the species in Britain thus :
‘It now breeds locally in all except a very few counties in England, Wales
and Scotland, and in at least half those in Ireland.’ The emphasis,
perhaps, is on that word ‘ locally ’. One of the peculiarities of its spread,
both on the continent of Europe, and in the British Islands, is that it has
advanced, not along a steady, broad front, but by a series of leaps.
Often it has jumped across some seemingly suitable areas, but in course
of time it may fill them up. Thus, the city and county of Oxford, which
is singularly well supplied with bird-watchers, was missed out for several
years, while the doves were colonizing all around. Dr Radford, when
she published her book on the birds of Berkshire and Oxfordshire in
1966, gave no records for Oxford city. On the other hand, those who were
with the famous International Congress voyage all round Scotland in
July 1966 will recall that we found Collared Doves cooing on the roofs
of the houses in Lerwick, Shetland, the most northerly town in the
British Islands— just north of latitude 60°. This seems a strange place of
permanent residence for a species whose headquarters are in the tropics.
The same might, no doubt, be said of the House Sparrow, only that its
wide distribution is something we are accustomed to. Yet it does seem
to underline the fact that Collared Doves, like Sparrows, evidently de-
pend for their success on Man, not on a limited natural environment,
Do these facts give us any clue to the spectacular increase of the
Collared Dove in recent years ? I am not sure that they do. When did
the north-westward spread begin ? Have they lived in the Balkan penin-
sula for centuries? Or was their presence in 1870 due to quite recent
colonization? The spread of the species across Europe in the second
quarter of this century has been very fully described by James Fisher in a
characteristic article in British Birds (Yol. 46, Number 5, May, 1953).
With regard to the early history, Fisher Writes : ‘The researches of
Adametz and Stresemann (1948) and Stresemann (1950) have shown that
INCREASES IN THE RANGE OF BIRDS 575
it is unlikely that the Collared Turtle Dove had spread west to the Levant
before the sixteenth century,’ though there is some evidence that it
inhabited Persia at that time. ‘ Stresemann is satisfied that Streptopelia
decaocto was, by 1547, already one of the birds of the town of Constanti-
nople.’
Curiously, in spite of the immense bibliography appended to Fisher’s
article, it seems that he did not consult the various mid-nineteenth century
authors quoted by Dresser. But the position at the beginning of the
twentieth century seems to have been about the same as it was in 1870.
It looks as if there had been a spread from India several centuries ago ;
then a long pause, covering centuries, and finally a thousand miles and
more of northwestward spread in the past forty years. This spread is
given in great detail by Fisher, who wrote just before the first definite
colonization of Britain. In 1954, when the well-known field-guide to the
birds of Britain and Europe Was first published, the Collared Dove is
shown as resident throughout Denmark and even in south Sweden, but it
had not yet crossed the North Sea.
What one would like to know, but it may be impossible to discover,
is what change, if any, in the environment in the basic habitat of the
species, that is to say in India or possibly West Asia, took place in the
period just before 1930, to which the Collared Dove (Indian Ring Dove)
responded ; or, alternatively, what significant change in the habits of
the species took place about that time ? — such as a change in feeding
habits or in adaptation to a changing environment. In India it was
certainly a time when the human population was increasing rapidly.
Was it also a time When the human inhabitants of India, especially the
villagers, adopted new methods of storing grain or of growing crops that
might be of advantage to such a bird ?
Fisher quotes Dr Ernst Mayr as saying (1951) ‘ in all cases of explosive
range expansion such as have occurred in the Serin ( Serinus ccmarius)
. . . and in the Ring Dove (. Streptopelia decaocto ), there is reason to believe
that this expansion was initiated by a genetic alteration of the peripheral
populations’. 1 hesitate to question such an authority as Mayr; but
Fisher himself doe$ not believe that this applies to the Fulmar (. Fulmarus
glacialis), a species whose spectacular increase in the twentieth century
Fisher himself investigated very thoroughly, demonstrating that it seemed
to be closely related to a change in the habits of fishermen ; so, it would
seem to me at least possible that there is another explanation in the case
of a species as closely dependent on Man, who is constantly changing the
environment in drastic fashion, as the Collared Dove appears to be.
There are other questions that arise in one’s mind. Has there been
any visible increase in the population of Streptopelia decaocto in India
itself? or in Persia, where a hundred years ago, according to authorities
quoted by Dresser, it was scarce ? Is there any sign of an extension of
15
576 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (3)
range in other directions? Fisher was not able to show any when he
wrote in 1953, but perhaps that is not quite conclusive. There may be
other questions we should be asking. I wonder if any of them are
answerable.
Let me summarize : It is clear that decaocto has some of the charac-
teristics of a 6 successful ’ bird of this era in the World’s history. It has
adapted itself to Man and some of the changes he has made in the environ-
ment. It has a broad range of food. In some parts of its range, it
breeds at all times of the year. But these things do not explain why it
has suddenly colonized more than a thousand miles of fresh territory
in the past forty years. If these are old characters, one would have
expected the species to have spread over a large area much longer ago.
So, one looks for some dramatic change either in the environment or in
the adaptability of the species. Neither of these is obvious ; so one is
tempted to accept Mayr’s proposition of a 4 genetic alteration ’ ; but how
can that be proved?
It will be seen that the purpose of this essay is to ask questions, rather
than to explore or expose Work already done. I have little doubt that
there may be very diverse explanations for the expansion of the range of
different species. Let me conclude with an example taken from India,
which looks to be quite unlike the examples I have been examining—
a case where it is difficult to see that the expansion of range can be due to
Man’s influence on the environment.
When I spent a few weeks in India, chiefly in and near Delhi, in the
late part of 1971, I was amazed to see Pied Mynas ( Sturnopastor contra )
at many places. Twenty years ago we thought them uncommon round
Delhi. From what I have seen of it, I do not think the species has adapt-
ed to human modifications of the environment. Of course, many
species have their rises and falls, over, perhaps, a fifty-year period. If
in fact the Pied Myna has increased in recent years, it may be a case of
this sort.
Perhaps there are other cases of birds that have made notable in-
creases in range or in numbers in India. The purpose of this essay is
to invite closer attention to such phenomena, so that, if at all possible,
we can learn something of their hidden causes. From my long and happy
association with Salim Ali, in field and home, I suspect that it is the
sort of enquiry he would welcome and encourage.
References
Aoametz, E. & StREsemann E. (1948):
Rasche Ausbreitung der Tiirkentaube
in Mitteleuropa. Biol. Zbl. Leipzig
67 : 361-6.
Mayr, E. (1951) : Speciation in birds,
Proc. X. hit. Orn. Congr. Uppsala.
1950 : 91-131 (p. 118).
Stresemann, E. (1950) : Erste Bruten
der Tiirkentaube in Deutschland. Orn ,
Ber. 2 : 98-103.
Dr Salim Ali and I1
Yoshimaro Yamashina
Yamashina Institute for Ornithology , Tokyo , Japan
I first heard the name of Dr Salim Ali in 1933. In those days, I
had a great interest in the birds of Formosa and had dispatched a collector
and research worker there, who stayed continuously for five years on the
Island. I myself also made several trips to Formosa to make personal
field studies on classification, distribution and habitat of the birds of
Formosa (Taiwan). I noticed that the birds of lowland Formosa were
exactly similar to those of mainland China, but that the birds of the
mountains bore a striking resemblance to the birds of the Himalayan
Range and Northern India.
As a result I began to study the literature of the birds of Northern
India and was amazed to find the name of only one Asian ornithologist,
Dr Salim Ali, among many notable names of the western world. The
name of that sole Indian bird expert. Dr Salim Ali, has been carved deep
in my heart ever since.
My first meeting with Dr Salim Ali in person occurred in 1958 at Helsinki,
Finland, where the quadrennial Conferences of IOC and ICBP were
held. It was my first experience of visiting Europe, and as it was right
after the termination of World War II, I was bewildered by the confused
state of post-war Europe and, naturally, I could not enjoy the trip on
that occasion. However, I was able to accomplish my object somehow
or other, mainly because I fortunately had the delightful privilege of
being warmly greeted by noted ornithologists such as Dr Delacour and
several others with whom I had been exchanging communications for
more than twenty years in the past.
At the Helsinki Conference Dr Salim Ali seemed quite familiar with
European affairs and accustomed to the proceedings of international
meetings from past experience. This made me most happy and 1 felt at
ease under the able guidance of Dr Salim Ali in many ways during the
conference. His warm cordialness is one of the sweet memories
which will remain with me to the end of my life.
Two years after the Helsinki gathering, Dr Salim Ali came to Tokyo
to take part in the ICBP conference in 1960. His amiable personality
and charming good humour were chiefly responsible in bringing success
to this international assembly, the first held in Asia.
1 Received February 1972.
578 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 7i (3j
After the conference was adjourned, a field trip was made to Hokkaido
which has been considered as the most remote region in Japan. Having
few facilities to receive foreigners, I and my associates had been feeling
somewhat uneasy for our guests in case of any inconvenience or breach
of etiquette. Wherever Dr Salim Ali appeared however he always pro-
voked cheerful laughter, making that side trip to the northland a most
delightful and fruitful event.
At this 1960 Tokyo meeting, the Asian Continental Section of ICBP
Was initiated and Dr Salim Ali, as its Vice-Chairman, has done a great
deal to enable this newly established Section to grow as it has today.
He has been highly admired by all the members of the Asian Section.
He is not only the respected elder scientist of all Asia, but has been an
active adviser as Well as a dependable counsellor from the beginning.
It is Worth mentioning that the successful outcome of the Hong Kong
meeting of the Asian Section and the subsequent conference in Bharatpur,
India, were chiefly due to the tireless efforts of Dr Salim Ali.
On this memorable occasion, celebrating the 75th anniversary of the
birthday of our dear friend, Salim Ali, I sincerely wish to extend heartfelt
congratulations, as one of his fellow bird-lovers of the Asian Section,
and respectfully hope that Dr Salim Ali will keep up his usual vigorous
spirit for a long future and continue to guide our deliberations with his
agreeable presence.
A portrait of Salim Ali
Zafar Futehally
My first real contact with Salim Ali the ornithologist, as opposed to
Salim Ali the uncle by marriage, was when my wife and I visited his bird
camp in Palanpur State, Saurashtra, in 1944. He had invited my wife to
come to Palanpur, and she had taken the precaution of misunderstanding
the invitation to include me.
We arrived at Palanpur expecting a holiday atmosphere in the beauti-
ful lodge at Balaram overlooking a broad nullah with thick jungle beyond.
I found that all the members of the camp, which included two skinners
and an unlimited number of ‘ orderlies ’ of the Raj, were driven much
harder by Salim than any slave-driver would have dared to drive them.
The team left the bungalow in the small hours with their collecting guns.
The middle of the day Was taken up in weighing, measuring, and skinning
the morning 4 bag \ Another round in the jungle in the evening with
notes being Written up late into the night. As I got to know Salim better,
I discovered that an untiring thoroughness was part of his nature and
What he expected from others Was only what he demanded of himself.
He can also Work longer hours than anyone else I know. Whenever we
stayed with my wife’s parents, I got used to hearing his typewriter tapping
at 5 o’clock in the morning. This usually continued late into the night,
with short intervals for meals, and a Walk in the evening. The sight of
the slight but muscular figure in shorts, carrying a stick, must have become
familiar in the neighbourhood.
Except partly for the handbook, the material for all his books has
been collected, researched, written and typed by himself. Two volumes
of the handbook had already been completed in this same solo fashion
before it was decided that the Bombay Natural History Society would
offer him the services of an editorial assistant.
The perfectionism which he had developed in his ornithological work
extended to everything connected with his life. Each field trip was
planned, mounted, and carried through with exactness. He personally
worked out the logistics of every expedition ; personally supervised
the packing and loading of all the gear ; and personally checked the
condition of every part of the car. His own physical fitness and the
fact that, all his life, he has been hardier than any young man half- his
age, has great advantages of course. When he was well o\er 60, I have
seen him pulling himself on to the back of a standing camel while the
rest of us were looking round for ladders.
580 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
The camp at Palanpur was the tail end of the Gujarat Bird Survey.
These bird surveys were, in a sense, invented by Salim himself in the
early thirties, when he had no other employment. With the help of
S. H. Prater, the then Curator of the Bombay Natural History Society,
it was arranged that he should make a survey of the birds of the Nizam’s
State of Hyderabad. The Bombay Natural History Society would pro-
vide the skinners and assistants. The Nizam’s Government was per-
suaded to contribute Rs. 3,000 towards the cost of keeping the expedi-
tion in the field for four months. The skins would be sent to Hugh
Whistler in England for taxonomic study, and the final report would be
published j ointly in the Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society. Al-
though it was obvious that such a survey Would not make Salim a rich
man, he found that the undertaking was extraordinarily rewarding.
He was simultaneously pursuing a hobby, gaining invaluable knowledge,
and living among surroundings, and in a manner, which he most enjoyed.
Even more important, perhaps, in a manner which his wife also immensely
enjoyed. Indeed, it would have been difficult to undertake these surveys
Without her enthusiasm and help.
Between 1934 and 1948, Salim did bird surveys of any area where the
administration was willing to bear a part of the cost. He ‘ did ’ the
Indian States of Travancore, Cochin, Bhopal, Indore, Gwalior and Dhar,
Mysore, Bahawalpur, Gujarat and Bastar. With these surveys, plus
several years’ residence in Burma and innumerable other trips, it is now
difficult to put one’s finger on any part of the map of the Indian subregion
which Salim has not penetrated on an ornithological quest at some time
or other. It used to be said that there was no part of India where Nehru
had not been. I am sure that this remark Would be even truer of Salim.
Since my first visit to the bird camp at Palanpur, I have invited myself
to as many camps as possible, although it has had to be for short periods
for I have to earn my living at a 9 to 5 job. An especially interesting
period began in 1959 when Salim was asked by the World Health Organi-
zation to undertake migration studies, in order to discover whether ticks
carried by migratory birds could be the carriers of viruses, with special
reference to a ‘ new ’ one that had erupted in Mysore. I attached myself
to one of the first sorties which was going to Kutch, whose sandy, salty
wetlands were known to be visited by countless migrants on their spring
and autumn routes. Consequently, camp was pitched in a place called
Kuar Bet— -well known, it so happened, as an area abundant in the Saw-
scaled Viper. Our first evening in camp was devoted to trying to under-
stand how to use the anti -venom snake kit which Salim had, with his
usual foresight, brought along. After struggling with the instructions
contained in the kit, it was generally agreed that, in case of a bite, the
victim should quietly be allowed to die. This was also the first time we
were using mist nets and the greater part of the day seemed to be spent
A PORTRAIT OF SALIM ALl
581
in straggling with the strange and unmanageable nets. Incidentally Loke
Wan Tho was present at this camp for a few days and his unfailing cheep*
fulness and enthusiasm enlivened everyone.
As the Bird Migration Scheme got under way, there were camps at
Bharatpur, Edanad, Point Calimere, Rajkot, Daulatabad, Mahableshwar,
etc., etc. These camps became meeting-places for all kinds of natura-
lists, ornithologists, scientists, professionals and amateurs, locals and
foreigners. Anyone who could manage it would take a few days off to
join the camp, and lend a hand with the netting and banding. Here
one met new people with shared interests, and renewed friendships With
old cronies. Young people, the children of friends and relations, also
appeared whenever their school or college holidays allowed them to.
Salim has always had a special rapport with children, from babies on-
wards. His humour seems to be at its liveliest in their company. And
if any child showed the slightest interest in natural history, he would
lavish on it an enormous amount of time and trouble, teaching him or her
and helping to build up their interest. Considering that he has a naturally
impatient temper, it always amazed one that he was so patient with child-
ren. In the old days it was nephews and nieces who trailed around with
him ; later on it was grand-nephews and grand-nieces ; while today he
still has a large following of great-grand-nephews and great-grand-nieces.
It is to be seen whether any of these turn out to be a worthy successor.
At the same time, Salim’s influence has been pervasive in our family and I
think that there is greater interest in nature generally and birdlife in
particular among the members of our family than there is in most compa-
rable groups.
If Salim took so much trouble in encouraging amateur interest, he
exerted himself even more to help Serious students and young profess-
ionals. Sometimes, indeed, the time and trouble he expended on helping
young naturalists with their Work seemed almost disproportionate.
Anyone who wished to make a career in Salim’s favourite subject could
count on every possible kind of help and support from him. My own
interest in birdlife and in conservation stems largely from his encourage-
ment, although he has never, even by accident, allowed me to realize that
he knows this. The kind of hidden jealousies and envies which some-
times attack even the most eminent scientists in their dealings with their
juniors seem never to have touched him. My amateur entry into the
world of birds has a curious history. The Times of India in the early
fifties once carried an article on the Magpie. The author had obviously
never seen our Magpie-Robin nor the European Magpie in the field and
from such sources as he could lay his hands on in the library, produced a
concoction which implied that the Indian bird ( Copsychus saularis)
had many of the characteristics of its semi-namesake in Europe. Salim
Wrote an irate letter to the Editor which immediately fetched the expected
582 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vvl 71 (3)
response of asking him to produce an article. Not having the time to do
so, Salim passed on this assignment to me and this led me to take a greater
interest in avians than I Would otherwise have done.
On many occasions while accompanying Salim on bird-Watching trips
I have felt that he has been over-conservative in coming to conclusions
and never being content with circumstantial evidence, however convincing
it seemed to be. Not being of a particularly scientific bent of mind
myself, and more prone to generalizations than to detailed inquiries, I
often found his comments frustrating. But at an outing in Bhutan, I
recognized that one can never be too cautious in dealing with birds and
their identification in the field. We came across a group of Longtailed
Sibias (Heter aphasia picoides) with white foreheads. Salim expressed his
surprise at this because he said that this species was not supposed to
have any white anywhere except on the wing. I had expected him to be
more enthusiastic about having discovered a new species or at least a
new race, but he said dryly that one could never be too sure until one had
a bird in hand. The White on the forehead was so obvious, and the
reference books which we consulted on returning to camp so explicit
about the lack of any white on the head of these birds, that 1 thought this
was truly a case of disregarding the time-honoured principle that seeing
is believing. However, the next day when Salim was out with his collect-
ing gun he came across these sibias and shot one of them. It turned out
that the white colouring of the forehead was caused by the pollen of
flowers on which the birds had been feeding. Since then 1 have acquired a
new respect for the adage that a bird in hand is worth several in the
bush.
I have referred to Loke earlier, and it was in the camp at Kutch that
I got to know him really Well. Wan Tho Loke was soon to make a name
as one of the best bird photographers in the world. Loke, a Malayan,
was an evacuee in Bombay during the war years. Being interested in
bird photography, he fell into the habit of becoming part of any expedi-
tion which Salim planned. Loke had a remarkable capacity for taking
immense pains, for making light of hardships and irritations. His ^easy
amusingness blended Well with Salim’s more cynical wit, and he was al-
ways a Wonderful companion as well as a dependable helper. Once in
Madhya Pradesh during World War II while he was pushing the broken-
down old charcoal-driven bus uphill, he suddenly said, ‘ You really
ought to have a station wagon, Salim.’ And when he got back to Singa-
pore after the war, and found himself once more a millionaire, he sent
Salim a station wagon.
Indeed, once Loke was back in Singapore it seemed that Salim’s finan-
cial problems were solved for always. Whether it was a question of
mounting an expedition, buying technical equipment or attending a
meeting on the other side of the World, Loke always insisted on having
Futehaiiy: Fortran or sanm
J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 71 (3)
Futehally: Portrait of Salim Ali
Plate 11
Salim Ali and Loke Wan Tho on the houseboat Pandora, Kashmir. 1951
A PORTRAIT OF SALIM ALI
583
the honour of providing the means. It may be added here, as an aside,
that after his tragic death in 1964, his family have kept up the tradition.
I once asked Salim which single event in his life had given him the
greatest pleasure. I thought it might be the completion of the great
10-volume handbook of Indian Birds, to which he was then in the pro-
cess of putting the finishing touches ; or some of the many distinctions
and honours which had been showered on him by various institutions
or possibly the Padma Bhushan which his own Government had bestowed
on him. The occasion in 1969 when he was given the John C. Phillips
medal for Conservation, and the whole vast assembly of the I.U.C.N.
rose to give him a standing ovation, could easily have been the most
satisfying event in anyone’s life, however great. But his answer was
unexpected. It Was his Work on the breeding habits of the weaver birds,
he said.
His paper on the weaver bird is, of course, a classic field study, enough
to ensure immortality for any ornithologist. It was written at one of the
most anxious periods of his life. When he returned to the Bombay
Natural History Society after a study leave of eight months, he was told
that his post had been abolished. No one in India those days — not
that things are very different today— employed a naturalist; certainly
not one without a university degree. All efforts to find employment
having failed, he and his wife removed to a family house near the sea
coast simply because it Was the cheapest place to live. And it was there,
half a mile from the house, that Salim found the bayas building their
colony and studied them to such good effect. Perhaps, on second
thoughts, it is not really strange that he should consider the baya study
so rewarding. Ornithology often involves long processes of recording,
checking, collecting and comparing material. It is seldom that one has
the chance of original Work, the discovering and registering of such un-
likely processes as the nesting habits of the bayas, which can be truly
classed as a piece of creative work. For a naturalist like Salim, always
much more interested in field Work, in the living bird rather than the dead
skin, such observations represented the most deeply satisfying facet of
his vocation. He was really an ecologist even at a time When the hard
core of ornithology was still considered to be systematics.
The baya study then, was the silver lining to the cloud of his self-
imposed exile. 1 might add here that he often admits that his inability
to find a job, ‘ in spite of his best efforts ’, was one of the luckiest things
that ever happened to him. Imprisoned behind a bureaucrat’s desk,
his life would have been much less productive. And, of course, much
less fun.
Throughout his life, I have heard Salim make grateful reference to
Dr E. Stresemann, whom he refers to as 6 my guru ’. The face-to-face
contact with the guru lasted exactly seven months, when Salim studied
/
584 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
sysfematics with him in 1929 in Berlin. For the next almost half-century,
contact was kept up by a copious correspondence. Dr Stresemann
apparently wrote a very difficult hand, as opposed to Salim’s exquisite
writing (of which he is very proud). Nevertheless the contact with Dr
Stresemann was like a lifeline, to be used when in doubt. He wrote
careful advice, suggestions, instructions, encouragement about every-
thing—from the correct way to pack skins to ideas for new ecological
studies. For, very soon, Salim was writing to say that he was finding
field studies far more exciting than laboratory work among specimens.
A theme which was often discussed was the idea of research into the
interrelation of birds and plants. Nobody had attempted to analyse the
part played by birds in propagating or in destroying the vegetation around
them. Surely this was odd in a primarily agricultural country where so
much depended on conditions which govern the success or otherwise of
crops ? Stresemann suggested making germinating experiments with
fruit-stones taken from faeces of birds and stones of some fruits which
had not been swallowed by birds. ‘Nothing seems to be known from
India regarding biological and field questions of the transfer of worm
parasites to birds ’ Some of the ideas churned up in this corres-
pondence form the basis of Salim’s repeated attempts to persuade the
Government of India to finance a major research project on the role of
birds in agriculture. There seems hardly any need to emphasize that, in
our country, such a project would indeed be money well spent.
As could be expected from their common interest, one of the close
associates of Salim Ali from about 1933 until his death in 1948 was
Hugh Whistler. Whistler was very excited when Salim started his terri-
torial surveys commencing with Hyderabad in 1933 for he felt that it
would be a great thing to get the huge blanks on the map of distributions
filled in for Hyderabad and other places. Obviously Salim’s comments
and guidance were of great help to Whistler and he acknowledges this
generously in a letter dated 24 October 1938. ‘ It has been a very great
benefit to me that we drifted into collaboration largely in its beginning
as an accident— when you pointed out my mistake over the webs of
Drongo’s tail feather— and the mistake has proved to me well worth
while. And here and now I must thank you very warmly for making
my collaboration a condition of your undertaking the Mysore and
Sunderbans surveys.’
It was Whistler who put Salim in touch with Col. R. Meinertzhagen,
whom he joined in a collecting expedition to Afghanistan. Col. Meinert-
zhagen was a colourful and controversial figure from Whose very original
methods of field work Salim gratefully acknowledges that he learnt a
great deal. The relationship began stormily enough ; neither of them
had any extra stock of forbearance. But they soon began to trust each
other, and to plan and undertake other joint expeditions, and long before
A PORTRAIT OF SALIM All
585
the end of his life, Meinertzhagen had become one of Salim’s most reliable
friends. There are, indeed, hardly any professional colleagues with
whom Salim has not managed to make lasting friendships. Friendships
have a very important place in his life.
There was something particularly tragic in the death of Salim’s wife
in 1939 . She had encouraged him to pursue his hobby rather than attempt
to enter some uncongenial profession. She had preferred to live on her
own small income rather than press him to find a job ; she had created
conditions in Which he could Work uninhibitedly at his own special
interests. And she died a few months before his first taste of real success,
the publication of the book of Indian birds. After his wife’s
death Salim moved away from Dehra Dun and made his home with his
sister and brother-in-law in Bombay, the parents of my wife. I think he
would agree with me that, to the extent they could, they have created for
him conditions in which he could continue to work effectively. This
sort of tacit support has always been provided by all his numerous bro-
thers and sisters at various crises of his life.
the book of Indian birds had been a long-planned Bombay Natural
History Society’s project, to be based on the sale of wall charts of bird
pictures. The same blocks were to be used in the book. From the
moment it appeared, it was clear that the book 4 filled a strongly-felt need ’,
although a great part of its success was certainly due to the attractive
style of writing. Now in its 9th edition, much enlarged and continuously
brought up to date, the book remains the standard guide-reference book
for the Indian subcontinent, and is perhaps the only book which is bought
by novices as Well as experienced ornithologists. One of my friends
possessed a copy which he had found abandoned in a prisoner-of-war
camp in Indonesia. It had helped him to become an ornithologist
during the War, and he managed to get it autographed when he came to
India 30 years later ; another copy was given by Nehru to his daughter
as a birthday present at the time he was prisoner in Dehra Dun jail.
In 1942 the Oxford University Press agreed to publish Indian hill
birds, and seven years later it appeared, superlatively well illustrated by
G. M. Henry, the birds of kutch had already been issued, and
the birds of travancore and cochin followed in 1953 and the birds
of SIKKIM in 1962. And finally the magnum opus which is, of course,
the handbook of the birds of india and Pakistan, whose tenth and
final volume was delivered to the Press some months ago.
As far back as 1947 Stuart Baker’s volumes on Birds in the fauna of
British india series were already out of date, and it was obvious that,
instead of reprinting, the Government of India would be better advised
to commission a new work altogether. In fact, in 1947, Salim, once
more in touch with his mentor Stresemann after the war, told him that
he had submitted a memorandum to the Government, detailing the
586 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol, 71 (3)
lines on which the new book should be produced. He would like to
have it more or less on the lines of Witherby’s handbook of British
birds with suitable modifications. It should have as many species as
possible — not subspecies— illustrated in colour — their distribution being
shown on maps. At the time Salim was in the Mishmi Hills with Dillon
Ripley, and they talked of the possibility of collaborating on the
project. Their ideas agreed on many points. Both thought that splitting
the genera, species and subspecies had been carried to meaningless
lengths, and a halt must be called. Mayr and Delacour’s recent review
of the Anatidae was the line systematics should be modelled on. It
seemed a suitable arrangement that Ripley should be responsible for the
systematic arrangement of the work, while Salim looked after the field
notes and habits. With support from the Government of India, the
Smithsonian Institution and the Bombay Natural History Society, the
Oxford University Press was able to undertake publication of this major
work.
At 75 Salim Ali is far from being a spent force. He is working hard
on a new book, and only the King’s death prevented him from visiting
the ornithologically unexplored parts of northern Bhutan this year.
Even as the final pages of the handbook are leaving for the press he is
well on his way to completing a field guide to the birds of the
eastern Himalayas. He also plans to survey the former Portuguese
territory of Goa. It is certain that his passionate dedication to Indian
ornithology will make it impossible for him to retire or to cease to
study birds.
Reviews
1. SEVENTY YEARS OF BIRDWATCHING. By H. G.
Alexander, pp. 264 (21-5x14 cm). With drawings by Robert
Gillmor. 15 photographs and six maps. Berkhamsted, 1974. T. &
A. D. Poyser. Price £ 3-80.
T have always enjoyed keeping records of what I see; And what
records! Until his ears began to give way, in his late sixties, Horace
Alexander recorded every bird song he heard every day in the year,
at any rate when he was in Europe. In this book there is a table
giving dates of the arrival in England of 31 summer migrants during
the years 18974968 and for these 72 years the author himself, or
one of his brothers (Wilfrid — W.B. — or Christopher), has 68 annual
records for five species (Swallow, Cuckoo, Whitethroat, Sedge
Warbler and Swift) and never less than 28. Wilfrid was ‘off birds’
or out of England for some fifteen years, and Christopher was killed
in 1917, so Horace must have been responsible for most of these
observations. Or again, here is a section of a 6-inch-to-the-mile map
of the area round Grantchester on which are recorded nesting sites
found between 1910 and 1918, showing for instance that Willow Wrens
occupied the same site in five of those years. On his eighth birthday
Horace was presented with a book called the naturalist’s diary :
A DAY BOOK OF METEOROLOGY, PHENOLOGY AND RURAL BIOLOGY, and
this he used till he lost it in Bombay in 1946 ("conditions of travel
were still abnormal after the war’, he charitably adds). In this book
one page was given to each day, the left half divided into sections
dovering Weather, Plants flowering. Birds nesting, singing or migrating,
Insects appearing ‘and so forth’ while the other half was left blank
for the owner to record his own observations. This set a pattern
which the author followed ever after. His eyes, ears and memory
Were abnormally reliable, as his records in British Birds , Witherby’s
handbook and elsewhere testify.
Horace Alexander was on the Council of the Royal Society for
the Protection of Birds for more than twenty years and from his boy-
hood he has been associated with the work of the British Ornitho-
logists’ Union and the British Ornithologists’ Club. He has partici-
pated enthusiastically in group migration studies, New Year’s Day
lists, county lists, etc. He was a member of the British Birds Rarities
588 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. li (lj
Committee and has met and corresponded with a host of ornithologists.
Yet he sums up: ‘a day or even an hour spent in total relaxation
just watching the birds has meant more than any scientific enquiry’.
What he calls the strangest happening of his seventy years of
birdwatching occurred in New Jersy, U.S.A. It was the explosion
of a small bird from the bonnet of a motor-car which had stopped
for petrol. A few miles back the car had, to his horror, run over a
sparrow-like bird which was feeding in the middle of the snowy road,
and somehow it must have flown up into the engine and perched
there until the bonnet was raised. Alexander’s companion said it
was a Whitewinged Crossbill (Loxia lencoptera ), a rather occasional
visitor to New Jersey in mid winter, so they drove back to the scene of
the incident and were rewarded with the sight of three more, two
females and a male.
The records of particular species at particular places, mostly in
southern England, are of limited interest to ornithologists resident
elsewhere, though they will learn much from this book as to the ways
in which emphases have changed and keenness on bird study spread
since the beginning of the century. Some more general questions
too are asked. ‘Do Birds Migrate over the Himalayas?’ is the title
of one chapter, in the course of which the author makes the dogmatic
statement: ‘No one is going to spend a couple of months sitting on
a Himalayan glacier counting how many Stints, Hoopoes and trinomial
pipits fly over.’ Usually he is much more tentative. ‘How birds do
love to upset the things you confidently write about them’ he reflects,
after seeing a flock of 50 of a species he had labelled uncommon. The
purposes, if any, of song, migration, tail -wagging and flocking in
various species are discussed, leading to the conclusion that ‘survival
value’ is a very partial answer. ‘We struggle to survive; we aid one
another in the struggle; and for much of our lives, even if we are
birds or insects, we cease from struggling and enjoy life.’ This book
is solid evidence in support of the author’s claim that birdwatching is
‘not only an intense aesthetic experience, but also a stimulus to the
mind and to the imagination, as one tries to understand the nature
of a bird’s world.’
R. E. H.
2. PLANT GALLS OF INDIA. By M. S. Mani. pp. 354
(22x14 cm). With 56 text-figures. Madras, 1973. Macmillan India.
Price Rs. 80 00.
REVIEWS 589
The science of the study of plant galls or cecidology has in recent
years developed into a distinct biological discipline not only emphasis-
ing the close interrelationship between the gall former and the con-
cerned plants, but also paving the way for a better understanding
of tumorous growths of plant and animal tissues. The present volume
by the eminent entomologist Prof. M. S. Mani, is yet another valuable
contribution towards our understanding of plant galls besides his famous
treatise on the ‘Ecology of plant galls’ and attempts to bring together
the results of forty-five years of intensive study of galls from all over
this country and parts of Afghanistan.
The introductory portion very briefly discusses all the significant
aspects of galls such as the types of galls, the nature of their causal
organisms, the intensities of galling on varied hosts, effects of infection
and probable modes of differentiation in the affected tissues along
with some interesting information on the histological and functional
aspects of mature galls. Mention has been made of ‘neoplastic growth5
and of limited and unlimited neoplasms and their relative significance
on gall structure which appear to offer fresh avenues in the explora-
tion of biological intricacies with galls as the experimental material.
A further highlight of this chapter concerns the distributional patterns
of gall bearing plants in the Indian subcontinent, laying stress not only
on the endemic types but also on those exhibiting affinities to Ethiopian
and Mediterranean, European and middle Asiatic as well as to Indo-
Chinese and Malayan regions. Laboratory procedures for the analysis
and study of galls and methods of rearing of insects are also briefly
discussed.
The major part of this compendium is devoted to the concise and
systematic enumeration of galls classified in their respective natural
orders. Nearly 750 identified galls belonging to 85 natural orders,
with fourteen unidentified hosts and caused mostly by gall midges,
mites, aphids, thrips, cynipids, nematodes, bacteria and fungi. The
addendum provided, further describes thirty more recent records.
Analysis of the general preference of gall makers to particular natural
orders in so far as has been noted in the survey, shows that the
families Leguminoseae, Moraceae, Lauraceae, Combretaceae, Anacar-
diaceae, Cucurbitaceae and Compositae are highly susceptible for gall
infections. The synoptic, dichotomous keys provide easy provisional
identification of the galls which have been briefly described.
The 103 references to literature on plant galls, the gall index giving
the plant species, gall organisms and parts of the plants bearing galls
as well as a detailed host plant index of cecidogenous organisms,
590 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
inquilines, parasites, successori, etc. and a well compiled index to the
host plants and gall makers make this neatly executed volume written
by one of the foremost authorities on the subject, an invaluable source
book to everyone — naturalists, students, researchers and teachers —
interested in the fascinating study of the galls.
T. N. A.
3. GENERAL ENTOMOLOGY. By M. S. Mani. Second and
Enlarged Edition, pp. xiii + 597 (24x16 cm). With 185 text-figures.
New Delhi, 1973. Oxford and IBH Publishing Co. Price Rs. 18-75.
This enlarged edition covers almost all aspects for ‘fundamentals
of entomology’; and it is written in entirely new form. The book is
divided into two main parts. General part and Systematic part.
General part covers anatomy, physiology, reproduction, development
and growth, insect ecology, zoogeography and fossil insects. Chapters
on anatomy, physiology, reproduction, development and growth are
comprehensively but very briefly described which may be a little
difficult to follow for new students. ‘Insect and its environment’,
‘Geographical Distribution of Insects’, and ‘Fossil insects’ are the
chapters to which Prof. Mani has paid particular attention and seem
to be the central point of this book.
The systematic part covers classification of insects, special
characters, habits and relations between different orders. A key to the
orders and keys to the families have been provided which should enable
students to identify the family of a particular insect.
The book has a number of original, simple but clear text-figures.
The price, although not nominal, is certainly not high for the
average Indian pocket, and the book is good value for the money.
M. D.
4. MAIN TRENDS IN PSYCHOLOGY. By Jean Piaget,
pp. 72 (21*5 X 13-5 cm). London, 1973. George Allen & Unwin Ltd.
Price £ 0-85.
MAIN TRENDS IN INTERDISCIPLINARY RESEARCH.
By Jean Piaget, pp. 73 (21*5 X 13*5 cm). London, 1973. George
Allen & Unwin Ltd. Price £ 0-95.
REVIEWS 591
These are nos. 2 and 5 in the series Main trends in the Social
Sciences produced by IJnesco and published by George Allen and
Unwin, London. Other works in the series are sociology by
P. Lazarsfeid; economics edited by I. Sachs, and demography by
Jean Bourgeouis-Pichat.
Unesco carried out a study in collaboration with national and
international research centres as well as individual scholars in the
social sciences, and these small volumes indicate the present state and
the future perspectives in the various disciplines covered. They are
intended for the educated reader, the research worker as well as for
institutions who organize and plan research studies.
Jean Piaget is an eminent psychologist and educationist whose
work has influenced educationists all over the world. In these two
volumes he has examined the conceptual framework, methods of study,
and the influence these concepts and methods, in turn, have on our
thinking and understanding of the subject. For instance, discussing
the intelligence tests, when Binet was asked ‘What is intelligence ?\
his answer was ‘It is what my tests measure’. This was a wise answer
since strictly, no other answer is possible. However, to measure
intelligence in terms of such tests is itself ‘limitative, and consists in
measuring only the resultants or performances and not the actual
processes which have produced them’. Unlike in Physics, where a
certain result presupposes the underlying process or processes, we have
no such exact knowledge about thought processes.
The applications of psychology in the social sciences, in medicine,
in education and vocational guidance have been discussed together
with the problems which arise in such applications.
In the volume on interdisciplinary research, the relationships between
different branches of science, the epistemological background, the
edifice of knowledge which is raised or its structure, and the inter-
actions of these, one on another, are lucidly discussed.
These volumes are small, about 70 pages each, but the material
and thought compressed in them is vast. No abstract or short review
can do more than suggest the scope covered. For the worker in the
social sciences, and, to an extent, in other fields also, the volume on
interdisciplinary research offers a re-examination and analysis of current
ideas, which, whether he agrees with them in their entirety or not, may
well serve to reorient his thinking in his own field of work.
A. N. D. N.
16
502 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
5. FUNDAMENTALS OF HIGH ALTITUDE BIOLOGY. By
M. S. Mani. pp. 196 (21*5x13-5 cm). New Delhi, 1974. Oxfofd
and IBH Publishing Co, Price Rs. 42*00.
Studies on high altitude ecosystems have in recent years become an
integral part of eco -physiological studies not only from the view point
of the adaptations exhibited by animals and plants inhabiting these
areas, but also from the view point of human endurance or acclamatiza-
tion to high altitude conditions. This book by the ‘Dean of Pligh
Altitude Entomologists’, in all comprises seven chapters providing an
astounding array of facts. Commencing with a brief introduction to
the various factors of the high altitude environment which are ‘closely
and inseparably interlinked and intricately intertwined’ into a complex
constituting ‘a self-regulating dynamic system’, this book deals essentially
with the two major aspects (1) high altitude plants and animals, (2) impact
of high altitude factors on man. Numerous examples of high altitude
plants particularly of the Himalayas, as well as those of insects along
with their adaptive features provide interesting reading. Mention has
also been made of the summit seeking species and their ecological
significance.
A good portion of this volume devoted to the impact of the high
altitude on man provides interesting information on the various
physiological changes—respiratory, circulatory, neurohormonal and
other changes— -besides the action of ionizing radiations on man, more
particularly on the human skin, as also of the high prevalence of
cataract of the eyes in the permanent residents. The use of the term
‘high altitude neurosis’ is particularly interesting referring to the
emotional sickness at high altitudes due to the cumulative effects of
the complex factors.
The multiplicity of factors leading to the acclimatization of man
to altitudes provides stimulating reading and the author with his long
experience of Himalayan explorations concludes that ‘the ability of man
to tolerate high altitude conditions differs significantly even at com-
parable altitudes in different parts of the world’ and ‘that man lacks
distinctive high altitude specialization’ and that he is ‘not an integral
product of the high altitude ecosystem, but merely an intruder in it’.
An extensive bibliography comprising 449 references, a glossary
to high altitude ecology and an index add to the usefulness of this
volume. Written in an inimitably lucid style and incorporating a vast
Reviews 59$
amount of data, both new and known, based mostly on the author’s
own experience over the past many years, this also provides available
information on human acclimatization to high altitudes from Russian
work. Besides opening up a new field to students of ecology, this
book also provides stimulating information on applied aspects of
ecology.
T. N. A.
Miscellaneous Notes
1. R. H. WALLER'S OBSERVATIONS ON WILDLIFE
SANCTUARIES IN INDIA: A PARTIAL REJOINDER
It is unfortunate that excerpts from Mr Waller’s account of wildlife
sanctuaries in India (presented to the 1UCN and WWF in 1970)
should have been published in Vol. 69 — No. 3 (December 1972) of
J.B.N.H.S. , for to most readers unfamiliar with the sanctuaries
mentioned and the ways of Indian wild animals, the very fact that
these excerpts were published in the Journal will invest them with the
semblance of scientific truth and credibility, qualities they do not
always possess. It is always an unpleasant and thankless task re-
butting errors in a note of this nature, for outside courts of law the
burden of proof is most wrongly shifted from the person making the
incorrect statements to the person questioning them — further, it is a
simple matter to make an incorrect statement briefly and with the
assumption of authority but takes a laborious and lengthy argument
to rebut it, and the very length and tediousness of the rebuttal
suggests to readers that where no much denial is needed, there must
be some truth in the original allegation! Mainly for these reasons,
this rejoinder is confined to Mr Waller’s comments on the Sigur R.F.,
(Segur) and the Mudumalai and Bandipur sanctuaries, areas which
I have known long and intimately: this does not mean that 1 agree
entirely with him in his observations on other sanctuaries and his
conclusions from such observations.
Had Mr Waller offered his comments as the casual ihipressions
of a visitor to these sanctuaries, based mainly on hearsay (as I feel
they are, in fact) there might have been no occasion for this rejoinder.
But he says that he spent about 5 months in 1970 in 15 sanctuaries
and faunal areas, mainly ‘in the jungle’, and that his report ‘attempts
to combine personal observation with certain scientific facts about
ecological conditions and animal populations’. Such a report, when
it is so manifestly mistaken in so many particulars, cannot be allowed
to pass unquestioned. Mr Waller’s comments on elephants in the
Segur area are based on arbitrary presumptions and hearsay (possibly
volunteered by those with a vested interest in the area), and completely
ignore the recent past wildlife history of Segur and the surrounding
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
595,
forests ; There is not an iota of truth in the frequently and loudly
voiced claim of landholders in and around Segur to the effect that
elephant populations in the Wynaad have increased enormously in
recent years. The truth is that sustained and intensive human
invasions of a vast elephant forest, not even peripherally but in
ramified penetrations deep into the heart of these jungles, have so
profoundly disturbed the wild animals that those of them given to
ranging far (like elephants'! are now to be found restlessly traversing
their old trek-routes more frequently than before, and that naturally,
with the reduction of their territory by human occupation, they are
much more in evidence. It is a simple and inevitable consequence
of deep, diverse and sustained human penetrations of their immemorial
homes that elephants in the Wynaad, frequently disturbed and often
injured by men, should be seen much oftener than before in transient
local concentrations and that they are, naturally, aggressive towards
humanity.
Mr Waller mentions the death of a German photographer here as
proof of his statement: as one who has photographed wild elephants
in India more often than any other, I can assure him that from
detailed inquiries made on the spot soon after the event I am
satisfied that the elephant was not responsible for its being provoked
into killing that photographer.
Mr Waller’s statement, ‘They raid the neighbouring crops, having
destroyed much of their own environment’, is egregiously incorrect
and provably so. In the entire Segur-Mudumalai Sa.-Bandipur Sa.
area, there is not a single acre of forest that has been destroyed by
Wild elephants, and anyone knowing the feeding habits of Elephas
maximus under normal conditions will know how patently incorrect
such a statement is. It is humanity, and only humanity, that has
destroyed the habitat of wild elephants in the Wynaad — by setting up
hydel projects with all their concomitant clearings and pylons and
high-voltage lines, by intensive exploitation of the forests departmentally
and by individuals, by the sudden springing up of human settlements,
agriculture, and herds of cattle in and around forests, by highways
and by-ways criss-crossing the entire tract, and in many other ways,
some of them insidious but potent. No wonder the elephants raid
the crops growing in their old homes.
The remedy, surely, is not to shoot down the already much-shot-at
elephants of the Wynaad, but to provide them with an adequate area
freed from human disturbance. This is what is being attempted in
the Wynaad under Project Tiger, and perhaps in the Kerala-Tamil
596 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Nadu-Kamataka interstate sanctuary proposed. Even so, used to a
much larger range only 30 years ago, elephants will roam out of
the protected areas, especially if crops are grown on their outskirts,
but if it is then necessary to shoot them, not for any fault of theirs
but because of established human rights on these outskirts, it may be
ordained that they should be shot — in fact, this is the only prediction
I have made in my recent ecological survey of the larger mammals
of the peninsula.
Seldom has anything so anthropomorphic and self-defeatist been
suggested in recent years in wildlife circles as Mr Waller’s suggestion
that dhole should be shot down, because they will hunt sambar to
extinction in Segur. Firstly, he is wrong in saying that sambar con-
stitute the main prey of dhole in the area, and that chital escape more
readily from the predator. Ground birds such as junglefowl and
peafowl, monitors and other reptiles, field rats, hares and even
porcupines, deer of all kinds, pig, and occasionally the young of gaur
and even more rarely domesticated calves are the main prey of dhole
in and around Segur, and in my experience, chital are the most
frequent prey of dhole here. With the tiger and panther on the
decline, dhole are of special importance in maintaining the balance
of nature here: but for them, the herbivores would overrun the
jungles. The role of predators like the dhole in maintaining the
balance of nature is, in fact, almost patently evident in the Segur
area, and the observations of Schaller and others on the wild dog in
Africa (published within the past 2 or 3 years) will further add to
my point. Being so much smaller than many of the animals they
hunt, dhole sometimes (infrequently, in a pack they kill quickly
enough) literally eat their victims alive, and sometimes wait for them
to weaken after maiming them, before killing them; Tinbergen and others
have pointed out how the most deadly of avian predators, the peregrine,
will not stoop at a flock of close-flying birds when there is the risk of
violent collision with a bird next to jts chosen victim; for all its
superb muscular co-ordination and agility, a leopard will not jump
down from a three-foot high rock (as a man will) but will glide down
to the earth. Predators cannot afford injury, and avoid it instinctively.
Dhole do not expose themselves to injury, even in the deadi -throes
of their victims, being predators. Nervous shock, loss of blood and
fright seem to combine to virtually anaesthetise the victim in such
circumstances, and it suffers itself to be eaten piecemeal. Not a
pretty sight, but that is the only way dhole can get their meat at
\
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
59 7
times. It is not for us to try and be wiser than nature, and anyway,
who are we to comment on the cruel ways of lesser killers!
Except when breeding, dhole range far and are seldom confined
to a locality. In the course of thousands of years, dhole and deer
have coexisted in the Wynaad, without any noticeable decline in the
populations of the latter. Surely Mr Waller should know that
even with artificially imposed factors conditioning wildlife in a
locality, there is never the risk that the predators will kill out the
prey, because invariably the predator dies out in advance of the
prey? Moreover, apart from theoretical arguments, prior to 1968
there was no noticeable diminution in the numbers of sambar in the
Segur-Mudumalai Sa.-Bandipur Sa. area. If subsequently there has
been a slight decline, surely that is to be attributed to the disastrous
rinderpest epidemic of 1968, and not to dhole.
Regarding the effects of rinderpest on gaur (gaur were easily the
worst affected by the epidemic) in the Mudumalai Sa.-Bandipur Sa.
area in 1968, from where did Mr Waller get the figures he provides
so confidently? I was in Bandipur on the heels of the epidemic, and
naturally tried hard to get all the statistics and observation records
I could, especially as there were some interesting aspects of the
disaster, suggesting an instinctive defensive (or rather prophylactic)
behaviour in the animals afflicted. Moreover, I am specially inter-
ested in gaur, and had, only 2 years earlier, warned the Madras
Government (as it was then) of the impending epidemic and suggested
remedial measures, at the completion of a survey of the Mudumalai
Sa. spread over 6 years that I had taken on. I wandered all over the
most favoured haunts of gaur in both sanctuaries in 1968 (only
Bandipur), 1969, and 1970 (only Mudumalai), and also hired tribals
to bring in counts of carcasses and skeletal remains, and still I was
able to get only figures from which a broad approximation could be
made. Mr Waller says that in these 2 sanctuaries ‘90% of the gaur
died—probably 1000 animals ’ as the result of the epidemic. He
adds, ‘skulls now litter the two sanctuaries as a reminder of what can
happen when there is no control of cattle infiltration — the undoubted
spreader of the disease ’, and goes on to provide percentages of deaths
caused by the disease among sambar and chital.
Such statements are, I submit, unworthy of a scientific report.
With a much longer time spent in both sanctuaries, with a much
more intimate knowledge of the gaur tracts in both and with a
greater incentive for getting reliable figures for my own report,
T was unable to count more than 20 skeletal remains in both areas
598 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (3)
(except for a negligible number, the gaur that died of the epidemic
in Bandipur were buried deep or burnt). I can assure the reader
that skulls do not litter the 2 sanctuaries now, and did not in 1969-70.
I looked for them.
Granted that about 1000 gaur died in the two sanctuaries of the
epidemic disease (many outside the sanctuaries — they wandered away
outside to die), on what basis does Mr Waller get his 90 %? The
gaur population of this tract is not resident, but a shifting population,
and during July- August 1968, when rinderpest took heavy toll of the
victims, many of the gaur would have moved out of the Mudumalai
sanctuary, where the tall grass is rank and coarse by then. I think
the 90% Mr Waller provides is an exaggeration. Guesswork should
not take the place of counts in statistical work.
2/14, Edward Elliot Road, M. KRISHNAN
Madras-4,
October 9, 1973.
2. RECORD OF A PIEBALD FULVOUS FRUIT BAT,
ROUSETTUS LESCHENAULTI DESMAREST
(With a text-figure)
Instances of albinism and aberrant colorations of the fur have
been recorded in bats. Setzer (1950) in his review of albinism in
bats mentioned the occurrence of albinism in the genera Rhinolophus ,
Glossophaga, Myotis, Pipistrellus, Eptesicus, Lasiurus , Antrozous,
Chaerephon and Molossus. Glass (1954) and Metzger (1957) recorded
aberrant coloration and partial albinism in Tadarida mexicana and
Myotis sodalis respectively. Mitchell (1963) reviewed the records of
occurrence of albinism and aberrant coloration in Tadarida brasiliensis
mexicana and reported an instance of aberrant coloration in Tadarida
femorosacca. The present report records a case of piebaldism in the
Indian fruit bat Rousettus leschenauhi Desmarest, 1820
The specimen, a juvenile male, was obtained from a colony in a
subterranean laterite cave at Muroor, North Kanara District, Karnataka
State, India, on 20th August, 1972. The colony had an estimated
population of 10,000 individuals of normal coloration. The coloration
of this piebald specimen made it very prominent and it was easily
picked up with a sweep net.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
599
Dorsally the specimen has a white patch on the back. Ventrally
a white bar runs diagonally across the middle of the body and extends
Fig. 1. Dorsal (A) and Ventral (B) aspects of the piebald specimen of
Rousettus leschenaulti along with a specimen of normal coloration,
600 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
to the right forearm. Both wing membranes have large irregular
patches of unpigmented areas (Fig. 1).
Apparently this is the first record of piebaldism in the genus
Rousettus.
Acknowledgements
We thank Dr N. P. Gupta, Director, Virus Research Centre,
Poona, for the constant encouragement, and Dr J. E. Hill of the
mammal section, British Museum (Natural History), London for
valuable suggestions.
Virus Research Centre, M. A. SREENIVASAN
Poona, H. R. BHAT
June 18, 1973.
References
Glass, B. P. (1954) : Aberrant colora- Mitchell, H. A. (1963): Aberrant white
tion in Tadarida mexicana. Amer. Midi, fur in the pocketed free-tailed bat. ibid.
Nat. 52 : 400-402 . 44 : 422.
Metzger, B. (1957): Partial albinism Setzer,H. W. (1950) : Albinism in bats,
in Myotis sodalis. J. Mamm. 37 : 549. ibid. 31 : 350.
3. NEW METHODS OF COLLECTION OF BATS
Methods of collection of species of bats living in small colonies in
obscure and inaccessible places for a thorough survey do not appear
to be satisfactory because they depend largely on chance. During a
bat survey of Jabalpur city and environs, a method for collection of
such species was developed and applied and resulted in the collection
of twenty species which, except three rare and rather poorly known
forms, included practically all the species so far recorded from
Central India. The method is described below: —
The method consists in moving about at dusk and dawn when
the bats leave or enter their roosts respectively. If a specimen is
seen during these hours, it is certain that it cannot be far away from
the roost. It is necessary to note the direction from which it comes
out at dusk or in which it disappears at dawn. The next step is to
wait at a place a bit farther up the direction from which it has been
seen coming out or in which it has disappeared. This is because
there is a general tendency among the species studied to follow a
restricted path while leaving and entering the roost. After a few
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
601
attempts, generally from 1 to 3, the haunt of the specimen can be
easily located. The location is facilitated by the fact that in most
cases the forms under consideration live in colonies of varying number
and they generally enter or leave their haunts one or two at a time
so that the process of departure from and return to the haunt of the
whole colony is spread over a considerable period depending upon the
size of the colony. After the location of the haunt the specimens can
be collected by various common methods depending upon the nature
of the haunt. Two of these, however, need special mention.
(a) If the specimens are hidden in deep holes, they can be collected
by tying a butterfly net around the haunt. Most of the specimens
easily enter the net when they come out in the evening.
(b) If the haunt consists of crevice having one or a few
openings, the openings except one are blocked with cotton or other
material and cigarette smoke is blown into the hole for a few minutes
till the bats come out. This method can be used for collection
during any time of the day.
Only a few individuals should be collected and the rest left for
observation in their natural habitat which they do not generally leave
for sometime if the collection does not involve considerable
disturbance.
The method has been found suitable especially for the following
species : Taphozous l. longimcinus Hardwicke, T. k. kochhensis Dobson,
Rhinolophus l. lepidus Blyth, Hipposideros f. fulvus Gray, H. galeritus
brachyotus Dobson, Pipistrellus c. coromandra Gray, P. m rnimus
Wroughton, P. ceylonicus indicus Dobson, Scotozous d. dormeri
Dobson and Scotophilus h. heathi Horsfield.
Central Regional Station, H KHAJURIA
Zoological Survey of India,
Jabalpur, M.P., India,
December 9, 1971.
4. A NOTE ON BODY COLOUR AND BREEDING HABITS
IN CAPTIVITY OF COMMON PALM CIVET (PARADOXURUS
HERMAPHRODITUS) OF ORTSSA
Prater (1971), has described the normal body colour of the
common Palm Civet as ‘black or blackish-brown civet with long
goarse hair .... the new coat, before it is fully grown, generally
602 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
shows a pattern of longitudinal stripes on the back and spots on
the flanks, shoulders and thighs. The limbs are always black or dark
brown. Facial markings variable, . . .
Four young common Palm Civets ( Paradoxurus hermciphroditus )
were procured from Simlipal National Park in Mayurbhanj district
of Orissa on 8-V-70 at an estimated age of 20 days. Their body
colours were: —
(a) in two females and one male creamish-white throughout
the body coat except the face* head, upper parts of the neck and
shoulders from the elbow joints or the middle of the external side
of the fore-arms upwards and are large or two small patches at the
base of the tail, which were black in colour. The hind limbs and
fore -limbs below the elbow joints or middle of the fore-arms were
creamish-white. White patches or spots below and above the eyes
were present;
(b) in the other male the body colour was black except at the
tip of the tail of 5 cm length which was creamish-white and white
spots below and above the eyes were present.
Breeding One of the females described above under (3) was
allowed to remain with the male, (b) at the Nandankanan Biological
Park (Orissa) from 6-X-70, Copulation was observed from 30-i-71
to l-ii-71. On 3-iv-71 the female gave birth to three young (males)
(gestation period of 60 days). The colour pattern of the body cnat
of the young was almost the same as described above under (a).
The birth weight of the young was from 69 to 102 gm (average
of 83 gm) the length from tip to tip was from 28 cm to 30 cm with
an average of 29 cm and the tail length was from 11 cm to 13 cm
with an average of 12-2 cm. The eyes were closed at birth and the
young were fully furred. Two of the three young were eaten bv
the mother within 24 hours of birth. The eves of living voung onened
on the 10th day. The young was seen taking banana along with the
mother at the age of 6 weeks onwards. The mother carried the young
by holding the middle of the body. The young one which weighed
102 gm at birth, weighed 995 gm on 3-vii-71 (3 months).
There is no mention of birth weight and size; gestation period,
and age of opening of the eyes of the new born young in the available
literature (Prater, loc. cit.; Walker et ah 1964; Asdell 1964; Crandall
1965). The litter sizes are given as 3 to 4 (Prater loc. cit.), 3 to 4,
sometimes as many as 6 (Asdell loc. cit.) and 2 to 4 (Walker et al„
loc. cit.). ’
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
603
Acknowledgement
We are grateful to Dr M. M. Patnaik of State Veterinary
Laboratory, Bhubaneswar-3 for going through the manuscript critically.
Nandankanan Zoo, L. N. ACHARJYO
Barang, (Cuttack).
National Park, A. P. TRIPATHY
JOSHIPUR, (MAYURBHANJ),
September 15, 1971.
R~E FERENCES
Asdell, S. A. (1964) : Patterns of
Mammalian Reproduction 2nd Edition,
Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New
York, p. 474.
Crandall, Lee S. (1965) : The Mana-
gement of Wild Mammals in Captivity.
The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
and London, pp. 348-350.
Prater, S. H. (1971) : The Book of
Indian Animals. Bombay Natural History
Society, pp. 92-93.
Walker, Ernest P. et dl. (1964) :
Mammals of the World, Vol. 11 — The
John Hopkins Press, Baltimore, p. 1234.
5, - AN OBSERVATION ON THE BEHAVIOUR OF
NILGIRT TAPIR {HEM IT R AGO S HYLOCRIUS ) WHEN
THREATENED BY WILD DOG OR DHOLE ( CUON ALPINES)
About five o’clock one evening while returning from the Erivikulam
camp I saw a large herd of Tahr on a ridge above the path. As
the wind was favourable I decided to stalk them and try to take some
photographs.
On reaching the ridge top I found that they had moved about
100 yds over the crest and were standing in a tightly bunched group
above a fairly steep cliff face. The fact that they had moved while
I was stalking them surprised me at the time, as they could neither
have seen nor scented me during my approach: The herd numbered
approximately 80 animals and consisted of all age groups from kids
of about four months to yearlings and immature and mature bucks
and does. I approached under cover to within about 30 yds and
from there began to photograph them. In order to do this I stood
up and was greeted by alarm sneezes when they saw7 me. They did
not, however, exhibit their usual behaviour in these circumstances.
Normally they wheel round and bolt a few yards, before finally
making off altogether when they have established that the cause of
b04 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
their disturbance is human, or else they take to the cliffs. Instead
of this they gradually approached me en masse until the nearest
were about 20 yds away. A strong breeze from the North was
blowing from them to me.
Suddenly I saw two magnificent Wild Dog approaching the herd
at a fast lope down wind from the North. When they were about
100 yds away the dogs circled to the West and very quickly arrived
on the ridge over which 1 had stalked. At this point the dogs
evidently scented me, for they turned about and raced back the way
they had come, moving at an incredible speed and seeming to glide
across the face of the hill, their rich red coats and black tails standing
out against the newly-sprouted grass. When about 400 yds away
both dogs stopped and emitted a series of high-pitched yaps of
penetrating loudness. At this the whole Tahr herd wheeled round
and faced the direction of the dogs, but made no attempt to move
either on to the cliff or away. The two dogs then raced on and were
joined by four other adult dogs and five small pups of about 4-5
months, all of which had evidently been lying in the grass from where
the two dogs had originally come. The whole pack then made off
out of sight.
It was most unfortunate that the dogs detected my presence when
they circled the herd, otherwise I should have been able to witness
their method of attack on the Tahr. One can only speculate that they
intended to approach the herd up-wind and then would have attempted
to stampede the Tahr— or at least some of its less staunch members—
in the direction of the pack. Had this failed would the rest of
the pack have been called up and an atiempt have been made to
grab a Tahr out of the herd? It is likely that the herd on being
closely approached would have moved onto the cliff face where, still
tightly packed together and presenting their heads to the dogs* they
would probably have been a match for them if they had tried to
approach within seizing distance across the steep rock face.
Cases have been cited of Sambar and Chital seeking the protectioh
of humans when hard-pressed by Wild Dog. They also show no
apparent fear of humans when, after the Wild Dog have been
dispersed, their human saviour has escorted them out of the water in
which they have sought safety. This would probably account for the
unusual attitude of the Tahr when they first detected me, for theif
reason for bunching together above the cliff was presumably due to
the fact that they had seen or winded the Wild Dog before my
approach.
Miscellaneous notes 605
I can only assume that the yapping was emitted either out of
frustration, or that it was a signal to the rest of the pack that their
attack on the Tahr had been foiled.
Shortly afterwards, when I withdrew in full view the Tahr
remained in the same position, and an hour later when viewed from a
distance they were still there, though some were lying down and others
were grazing nearby.
It is probable that the Wild Dog had little difficulty in finding a
meal elsewhere that evening. At this time of the year after the grass
has been burnt off and is sending up new shoots, both large mixed
herds of Tahr and small parties of bucks of the same species may be
found grazing all over the plateau and Wild Dog are easily able to
course and pull down some of them before they can reach the safety
of the cliffs.
Lower Vagavurrai Estate, J. C GOULDSBURY
Talliar P.O.,
Kerala State,
May 10, 1974.
6. FOOD REQUIREMENT OF ‘BLACK RAT9,
RATTUS RATTUS L.
There have been several investigations on the food consumption of
‘black rat* Rattus rattus L,, (Harrison & Woodville 1950; Majumdar
et al. 1966; Parrack 1966). But realising the regional variation in size
and weight of this species (Harrison & Woodville 1949; Deoras &
Gakhale 1958), it seemed desirable to estimate the food requirement
of the rat, Rattus rattus rufescens , caught from various localities of
Aligarh city. The results are reported here, together with an attempt
to calculate the figure for translating food takeon into number of rats
for census work.
Rats caught in ‘ wonder traps ’ were weighed and sexed by standard
procedures (Evans et al. 1968). Pregnant females were excluded, and
others were housed individually in wire-mesh cages of 1T7 X 088X
0-35 m. The rats received a weighed surplus of unextracted wheatflour
(wholemeal) in 15 cm diameter glass dishes. The residue was weighed
on the succeeding day and the difference recorded. Replicates were
run in all cases; and the observations continued for a minimum period
of ten days. There was an unlimited supply of drinking water. The
606 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
data was statistically analysed by recommended methods (Bailey 1958;
Chakravarti et al. 1967).
Table 1 makes clear the relationship between the amount of
wholemeal eaten and body -weight of the rats. Juveniles weighing
45 gms or 50 days in age (Spillett 1966), consumed daily an amount
Table 1
Estimated intake of wholemeal per day by the rats.
of food equalling 21-35% of their body-weight. The figure decreased
to 15.57% for sub-adults of 85 gm and 80 days in age; and varied
from 8 to 11% for adults above 130 gm in weight. Evidently, consump-
tion was high in fast-growing juveniles and sub-adults, and tended
to level-off in older age groups (Harrison & Woodville 1950; Leslie &
Ranson 1954; Majumdar et al. 1966).
The same exponential relation was demonstrated when logarithm
of food consumption (y) was plotted against logarithm of
body-weight (w). The calculated line of best fit log y=log a + b
log w, was given by:
log y = log 0.34644-0.3853 log w or y = 0.3464 w0'3 8 5 3
It was compared to similar data reported for brown rats Leslie &
Ranson 1954). The hypothesis H: a = T. 5396, b = 0-3853 was tested
by the F-test for assigned linear regression (Chakravarti et al. 1967).
The test statistics was found to have the value 2T856; which when
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES 607
compared with the tabulated value at (2-23) degrees of freedom, was
significant at 5% level. This establishes the acceptance of the present
results.
The weight-structure of a representative population of black rats
in Aligarh, may be taken from the records of 600 rats examined
from July, 1971 to May, 1972. The data is summarized in Table 2,
with observed weight distribution expressed per 1000 rats. The
relationship demonstrated between food intake and body weight of rats
(Table 1), gives a working basis for calculating the average consumption
of wholemeal per member in this population.
Table 2
Weight-structure and food requirements of the * black rat 9 populations
Weight Group Number of rats
up to— 20 10
20-29 30
30-39 35
40-49 45
50-59 30
60-69 25
70-79 50
80-89 50
90-99 60
100-109 90
110-119 55
120-129 80
130-139 80
140-149 95
150-159 80
160-169 65
170-179 60
180-189 20
190-199 10
200-209 25
210-220 5
Total . . . . 1000
Mean Body Weight (gm) .. 1 10*4
Estimated average consump-
tion per member per
day . . . . 13-5
According to Leslie & Ranson (1954), consumption per member per
day can be calculated for a given population ‘by applying the daily
consumption of wheat calculated for the pivotal weights to the observed
frequencies in each weight class and summing*. Presently this comes
to 13-5 gm wholemeal consumed /member /day. The range of this
17
608 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
average calculated from range of error of the regression line (O' 38 53 zb
0-08085) is negligible. The take of wholemeal in gm divided by the
factor of 14 would give the approximate number of rats in a population
of this weight-structure (Table 2). Apparently the same factor can
generally be used for census work; if the populations are not known
to differ basically from that considered presently.
Acknowledgements
We are thankful to Professor S. M. Alam, Head, Zoology
Department, AMU, for facilities and encouragement. Special thanks
are due to Dr S. N. U. A. Kirmani, Department of Statistics, AMU,
for helping with statistical calculations.
Zoology Department, DEVENDRA BHARDWAJ
AMU, Aligarh, (U.P.), JAMIL AHMAD KHAN
May 30, 1973.
References
Bailey. N. T. J. (1959) : Statistical
methods in Biology. English University
Press, London.
Chakravarti, I. M., Laha, R. G. &
Roy, J. (1967) : Handbook of methods in
applied statistics. Vol. I. John Wiley &
Sons, New York.
Deoras, P. J. & Gokhale, M. S. (1958) :
Some biometrical observations on the
common rats of Bombay. /. Bombay
nat. Hist. Soc. 55 (3) : 450- 459.
Evans, C. S., Smart, J. L. & Stoddart,
R. C. (1968). Handling methods for wild
house mice and wild rats. Lab. Animals
2 : 29-34.
Harrison, J. L. & Woodville, H. C.
(1949) : Variation in size and weights in
five species of house rats (Rodentia,
Muridae), in Rangoon, Burma. Rec.
Indian Mus. 47 (1) : 65-71.
(1950) : Notes on the feeding
habits ofhouse-rats in Rangoon, Burma.
Ann. Appl. Biol., 37 (2) : 296-304.
Leslie, P. H. & Ranson, R. M. (1954;:
In ‘ Control of rats and mice ’, Vol. II.
pp. 335-349, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Majumdar, S. K., Krishnakumari, K.
& Urs, Y. S. (1966) : Some observations
on food preferences and intake of rats
under different ecological conditions.
Proc. Indian Rodent Symp., pp. 124-136.
Parrack, D. W. (1966) : Food con-
sumption in three common Indian
rodents, ibid., p. 137. Proc. Indian
Rodent Symp., p. 137.
Spillett, J. J. (1966) : Growth of
three species of Calcutta rats, ibid., pp.
177-196. Proc. Indian Rodent Symp., pp.
177-196.
7. GOLIATH HERON IN THE SUNDER BANS,
WEST BENGAL
While on a visit to the Sunderbans I observed It Goliath Heron ( Ardea
goliath) at the mouth of one of the creeks on 22 March 1974. Although
I had not seen the bird before I am quite familiar with this impressive
heron from photographs and had, indeed, hoped to see it when in Africa.
The Goliath heron was not in my mind when soon after dawn we
approached the mouth of the creek in the Forest Department’s launch
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
609
Banashree. I spotted a heron feeding and it took off as I raised my
glasses and flew slowly in front of me. I had no hesitation in exclaiming
‘Goliath heron’, but checked myself at the thought that I had never
heard of it in the Sunderbans area.
On my return to Calcutta I consulted Finn (cannot remember title)
and found that Goliath herons had appeared in Calcutta market in
1845-46. I was later able to consult the handbook and found that the
Goliath heron had last been recorded in 1925 in the Khulna Sunderbans
(now in Bangladesh), only a few miles from where I found it.
The handbook describes the Goliath heron as essentially an African
species, and a rare vagrant to India. Apart from the records in the
Calcutta market and the Khulna Sunderbans already mentioned, Hume
saw six gigantic herons near Multan in 1873 which were probably
Goliaths, Blanford saw one near Nagpur and one in Baluchistan, and
Stuart Baker saw five on the Meghna near Dacca in 1910. Ceylon
has records in 1878 and 1879 but not since.
It seems probable that the Goliath heron is regularly to be found
in the Sunderbans area, and the lack of reports is solely due to the
absence of knowledgeable bird watchers. The great size and fine
plumage resembling a brighter coloured Purple heron are distinctive.
1100, Morges, PETER F. R, JACKSON
Switzerland,
May 30, 1974.
8. ? THE LITTLE GULL, LARUS M1NUTUS PALLAS,
IN KUTCH
On visits to the Great Rann of Kutch in April 1956, April 1957*
March 1960, and again as recently as January 1974, I observed rather
distant flocks of a puzzling gull which it struck me at the time could,
by all the rules of the game, be no other than the Little Gull, Lams
minutus Pallas. I did not publish this earlier in view of the extreme
paucity of records of this species in the Indian subcontinent (a single
specimen from Ladakh, and a possible sighting in Bombay Harbour- -
Indian handbook 3: 37), and lack of positive conviction on my own
part. However, on the latest visit to the Rann (23/24 January 1974)
I was able to watch a fairly large flock sufficiently closely to support
my earlier conjecture, though confirmation must still await a specimen.
At first the birds, which were in winter plumage, looked like winter
610 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Blackheaded Gulls (L. ridibundus), but their comparatively diminutive
size was immediately distinctive, as also the absence of any black
in the primaries. The blackish bill suggested Gullbilled Tern
(Gelochelidon nilotica ), but the white tail was not forked as in the
latter. The blackish underwing, tern-like flight (with rapid wing-
flapping) and habit of flicking food off the water surface — and of
course the small size for a gull — are the points on which my tentative
identification rests. What other species it can be is difficult to guess!
46, Pali Hill, Bandra, SALIM ALl
Bombay 400 050,
May 27, 1974.
9. WHITECHEEKED TERN STERNA REPRESSA
HARTERT IN BOMBAY
On 26th June 1973 a tern with one leg almost completely missing
below the tarsal joint was brought to me by a local boy who had
picked it up on the beach. Though the wound appeared to have healed
the bird died within a few hours, no doubt due to other causes, and I
sent it to the Bombay Natural History Society where Mr Humayun
Abdulali has identified it as Sterna repressa Hartert.
This species is known to nest on the Vengurla Rocks off Ratnagiri,
southern Maharashtra, but this is the first record from the Bombay
neighbourhood. I referred to the Regional Meteorological Centre,
Colaba, Bombay to know the prevailing weather conditions and was
informed that from 24th to 26th June there was no stormy weather
but a northwesterly wind with a speed of 5 to 10 knots prevailed.
The primaries and tail are both in moult but the black cap on
the head precludes its being an immature.
Sir Mohamud Yusuf Trust, PRABHAKARA MENON
C. I. Campus,
Nhava via Panvel, Kolaba District,
Maharashtra,
July 26, 1973.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
61 i
10. NOTE ON THE COLLAR APPEARANCE IN THE MALE
ROSE-RINGED PARAKEET, PSITTACULA KRAMERl
(SCOPOLI)
The adult male of rose-ringed parakeet, Psittacula krameri
(Scopoli) bears a rose-and-black collar which is lacking in the female.
The fledglings as they leave the nest do not show any such external
secondary sexual character. Fourteen nestlings (about 30-40 days old) of
rose-ringed parakeet were, therefore, collected and reared in the labora-
tory in May, 1971 to determine the age at which the collar appears in the
male fledglings. The black collar started appearing in the beginning
of September, 1971 at the age of 4 months of the fledglings in the
form of a faint thin line just on the sides of the neck and then extended
underneath the lower mandible, which subsequently deepened in
colour. It was complete in form and colour in three months. The
rosy collar first appeared in the form of a spot on the dorsal surface
of the neck at the end of April 1973 at the age of 23 months, which,
then descended on the sides of neck along the black collar. It took
4 months for its completion. The rose-and-black collar in the male
parakeet thus appears fully at the age of 27 months.
Punjab Agricultural University, G. S. SIMWAT
Ludhiana, A. S. SIDHU
March 4, 1974.
11. EXTENSION OF THE RANGE OF CETCTS WARBLER
CETT1A CETTl ALB1VENTRIS SEVERTZOV
The Society’s Bird migration study party at Bharatpur, Rajastan
(27° 13' N.; 77° 32' E.) netted a warbler which was not readily
identifiable in the field. The bird, collected and preserved on 30th
October 1971, was later identified by me at the Society’s bird room
as Cetti’s Warbler Cettia cetti albiventris Severtzov, and confirmed
by Dr Salim All. The bird breeds in the area ranging from Iran
to Russian Turkestan and winters south to southern Iran and
Afghanistan. According to the available literature its wintering range
within the Indian subregion is confined to the Indus Valley west of
River Indus, from Peshawar in the north and Sind in the South.
612 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Bharatpur lies approximately 800 km east of the Indus river and
possibly its occurrence in similar biotope east of Sind might have
been overlooked all these years. A species which affects inundated
reed-beds and tamarisk bushes along the freshwater reservoirs and
saline backwaters it is an inveterate skulker, more often heard than
seen.
Hume, who says \ . . . personally I (A.O.H.) consider the
individuals of this species the most unmitigated little beasts that ever
bothered an ornithologist’, gives the following amusing account of
his attempts to obtain this bird in Sind:
‘ On several occasions when boating about in gloomy rush and tamarisk
swamp I caught glimpses for a second of a small dusky long-tailed bird fluttering
about the stems of the centre of the tamarisk bushes ; each time I mentally
resolved, “next time I see that fellow, I’ll shoot him”. This went on for several
days; but I never once did see him; a momentary glance in the centre of a thicket
was all that was ever vouchsafed, and so I made up my mind that I must get a
specimen, coute que coute. At last having seen, or fancied I saw, one in a small
island of rush, about 40 feet square, in which some dozen dense tamarisk bushes
were growing, I set to work systematically, and made six men beat through it in
the expectation that the bird would, at any rate when thus pressed, fly out into
one of the many neighbouring similar little islets; no such result however followed;
one of the men saw it flit by him and that was all. This process was repeated
five or six times, but with no better success ; then I made up my mind to go
and beat through bushes myself, which as the water was cold, and with mud fully
three feet deep, was unpleasant. I drew the charges of my gun, put in only about
i drachm of powder and | oz. of dust shot in each barrel, and went in for mud-
larking operations in earnest. Three times I beat the clumps backwards and
forwards without catching a glimpse of the wretched little creature; getting my
hands and face scratched and cut, with the reeds and tamarisk branches, besides
getting up to my waist in a hole at the root of one of the bushes, yet as each
time one of the party saw it, I felt bound to persevere; the fourth time the bird
suddenly appeared at the muzzle of my gun, darted, I believe, between my legs,
where there couldn’t have been much room, considering the depth of water, and
disappeared. I duly let the gun off, but I had reason to suppose, in exactly the
opposite direction to that in which the bird at the moment was; then I altered my
tactics and stood quite still in the middle of the clump, whilst I made the men
beat from the other side. This was obviously the right plan, for the very first
time I got a shot, at least seven feet off the muzzle of the gun, and blew the bird
entirely to pieces; besides, unfortunately, peppering one of the boatmen so soundly,
that though it was only dust shot, they positively refused to beat any more upon
that system. This was by many degrees too bad; I had no special grudge against
the species to begin with; but then and there registered a vow that an ample series
should give me my revenge; accordingly for many hours of two days I devoted
myself entirely to Cstti’s Warbler. Every little dark dense patch of rush, reed, and
tamarisk, standing out in the water contained one or two of these atrocious little
skulks, the thing was to bag them. I never but once succeeded in flushing any
one of them, and then I missed him, at least so the boatmen said. I did not
admit the fact at the time, and I don’t see why I should now, but anyhow the
corpus delicti was not produceable. I never got a shot more than three yards
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
613
distance from the muzzle of my gun, and I absolutely blew to pieces more than
half of the specimens I did succeed in shooting, and all I can say further is, that
having established the occurrence of the species in India, any one else may go and
shoot them who pleases, no one will ever catch me at it again.’
(A. O. Hume, 1873 Stray Feathers 1 : 192.)
Bombay Natural History Society, S. A. HUSSAIN
Hornbill House,
Shahid Bhagat Singh Road,
Bombay 400 023,
October 30, 1974.
12. NEST CONSTRUCTION TECHNIQUE OF THE SPOTTED
MUNIA, LONCHURA PUNCTULATA
Spotted Munia is known to breed, wherever it occurs, throughout
the year, intermittently but mainly during the rains. (Hume 1890;
Ferguson 1904; Baker 1926, 1934; Whistler 1928; Ali 1953, 1961).
At Poona too for the past 9 years or so I have come across the nests
of this species during the rainy season i.e. from June to September.
I have noticed most nests with eggs in July and most nests with
young, in August.
This species is known to construct a rather clumsily put together
globular nest of grass, bamboo leaves, leaves of jowar and bajra and
in Bengal even jute fibre (Baker 1934:27). The normal diameter of
the nest globule varies from 20 to 24 cm but extremes of 7*5 cm and
45 cm have been on record (Baker 1934:27). There is a lateral
entrance hole usually between the middle and top of the globule. The
nests are generally placed in thorny bushes or small trees at any height
from 1 to 6 metres from the ground. Whereas the foregoing information
regarding the breeding season, shape, size and location of nests and
the nesting materials used is already well known, the nest construction
technique, i.e. mode of shaping the nest preferred time of the day
for construction, number of trips made by the birds in search of
nesting materials, the selection of nesting materials at various stages
of nest construction and time taken for construction, have not been
recorded so far.
Last August I had an opportunity to observe closely the nest
construction technique of this species while a pair constructed their
nest in a small Thuja oriental^ tree in the compound of a residential
614 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
bungalow in a Poona suburb. On 21st August at about 2 p.m. I
noticed a spotted Munia emerging from the grass patch in a vacant
lot in front of my house, with a large blade of grass held in the
beak. After a minute or so another one was sighted carrying a blade
in the same direction. Still another blade was whisked away after
another minute or two. The birds carried the long blades held firmly
in the beak and the folded legs, stretched across the breast and
abdomen, fluttering free under and behind the tail. While carrying
these large grass blades the birds flew rather low, about 1-2 metres
above the ground.
Obviously a nest was being constructed nearby. I came out of
the house and followed the birds to the small thuja tree, approx.
5 metres high, growing inside the compound of my neighbour. The
birds with grass blades kept on arriving, perching for a while and
then disappearing in the thuja tree for another two hours at the rate
of 3 to 4 times every ten minutes. At 4 p.m. two Spotted Munias
emerged from the tree, sat for a few minutes on a telephone wire
nearby before flying away together in a direction away from the!
grass patch. When they did not return for about ten minutes or so
I ventured near the Thuja tree and parted the branches to have a
look at the nest. The construction had been started in a vertical
fork about 2 metres from the ground. The long blades of grass had
been loosely woven across the thin leaflets in a circular fashion to
shape the sphere. The blades were not placed very close together.
Light could be seen through the gaps, especially the large one in front.
I kept a look-out for the birds next morning, i.e. on 22nd August.
It was a bright sunny morning. The birds appeared at 8-20 a.m.
and started the construction work. They made 228 trips bringing in
the nesting material, in five hours, averaging 45-6 trips an hour. The
average decreased to 35 trips an hour during two hours of slight
drizzle and rose to 52-6 in three hours of bright sunshine.
It started raining shortly after 1*30 p.m. I abandoned the observation
post and later discovered that the birds too had called it a day.
In the evening I checked the nest. The globule had taken shape.
The walls were still thin, hardly 2 blades thick and the entrance hole
had taken shape.
On the morning of 23rd there was a light rain. It stopped at
about 10.30 a.m. The birds appeared shortly afterwards and took up
the construction. They made on an average 44-2 trips an hour
during the 5-hour observation period from 11.00 a.m. to 4.00 p.m.
Number of trips in the forenoon being more than in the afternoon,
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
615
In the evening when I checked the nest the walls of the globule
were found thicker. The fresh material was found incorporated on
the inside.
On 24th August I could not make any observations. On 25th
when I reached the scene at 9 a.m. the work was already in full swing.
I clocked 48 trips on an average for the next three hours and took some
photographs. The birds were still bringing the long and broad
leaves of Urochloa panicoides . I parted the branches to have
a clear view of the entrance. The birds (both of them) were now
flying in with the material. One of them stayed inside obviously doing
the construction, while the other made the material hunting trips. The
work continued throughout the afternoon but I got tired of counting
the trips. It kept on raining intermittently. The number of trips
decreased when it drizzled lightly and stopped during heavy shower.
The birds stopped work at 5.40 p.m.
On 25th morning I was earlier than the birds. They appeared at
8.45 a.m. each with a long leaf blade and kept on the tempo til! I left
at 11.00 a.m. In the afternoon I returned at 3.30 p.m. They were
still at work. But they were no longer bringing the long and broad
leaves of Urochloa panicoides , but were bringing the thin stems and
long narrow blades of lawn grass. The number of trips had also
gone down to 25 an hour (average for 2 hours). Obviously the egg
chamber was being lined now. At night at 9 p.m. I checked the
nest. One bird flew out. There were no eggs.
On 26th morning when I left for laboratory at 9.45 a.m. the birds
were already bringing in the thin stem of lawn grass to which long
narrow leaves were attached, but the material being brought was no
longer green. It was rather yellow looking and dried up. One of the
birds was sitting occasionally in the entrance hole adjusting the
nesting material in the egg chamber. On 26th night at 9 a.m. one
of the birds was flushed out of the nest. There was also one egg
in the nest.
On 27th morning there was hardly any construction work. Between
9 a.m. and 10 a.m. only two trips with nesting material were noticed.
By the afternoon the building activity had totally stopped. At night,
at 9 p.m. two eggs were noticed in the nest.
Western Regional Station, B. S. LAMBA
Zoological Survey of India,
1182/2, F.C. Road,
Poona-5, (Maharashtra),
September 6, 1973.
616 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vo /. 71 (3)
References
Ali, S. (1961) : The Book of Indian
Birds, 6th Ed., Bombay Natural History
Society, Bombay.
(1953) : Birds of Travancore
and Cochin. Oxford University Press.
Baker, E. C. S. (1926) : The Fauna
of British India including Ceylon and
Burma. III. Taylor and Francis, London.
— (1934) : Nidification of the
birds of Indian Empire. III. Taylor and
Francis, London.
Ferguson, H. S. (1904) : The birds of
Travancore with notes on their nidifica-
tion by Bourdillon, T. F. J. Bombay nat.
Hist. Soc. 15 : 468.
Hume A. O. (1889-90) : Nests and Eggs
of Indian Birds, 2. R. H. Porter, London.
Whistler, H. (1928) : Popular hand-
book of Indian Birds. Gurney and
Jackson, London.
13. A NOTE ON EN HYDRIN A SCHIST OS A (DAUDIN)
(HYDROPHI1DAE : SERPENTES)
On 26-ix-1972 afternoon at about 14 hrs a sea snake, Enhydrina
schistosa (Daudin), commonly known as ‘Valakadyen’, was caught at
about 5 km off Madras by a fishing nylex net locally known as
‘Kavala Valai’. The snake was brought to the laboratory, kept in an
aquarium and observations were made.
The snake was restless and kept protruding its head out of water
often. Now and then it bit at the sides of the aquarium. It ignored
the small fish push into the aquarium as food. This behaviour continued
till late in the evening.
On the same night at about 9 p.m. the restlessness and movements
of the snake increased and it began biting at the sides of the aquarium
ferociously. Then it came to the surface, vomitted two puffer fish
one after the other and died a few minutes later. The fishes were
identified as Arothron hypselogenion (Bleeker), each measuring 90 mm
in total length. The fish were partly digested and pale in colour.
The snake measured 750 mm and has been preserved in the Museum
of this Regional Station.
Sherman (1966) observed three genera of fishes namely, Tetrodon ,
Coilia and Harpodon in the stomachs of Enhydrina schistosa (Daud.)
The fishes belonging to Tetrodontidae are poisonous in general.
They are ichthyocrinotoxic, producing their poisons by glandular
secretion. Halstead (1970) has compiled an excellent account of the
poisons of this group of fishes. He states that the slime of the fish
is toxic. Fukuda (1951) found that in a series of 129 cases of puffer
poisoning, ten were due to eating the skin of the fish. Day (1878) also
has given some account of the effect of the poison of these fishes.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
617
Two probable reasons can be attributed for the death of the snake.
The snake may have died due to the effect of toxins produced by the
fishes or there might have been some difficulty in swallowing the two
fishes and death may have been caused by asphyxiation.
Acknowledgement
I am thankful to Dr. A. Daniel, O/C, Z.S.I., Madras for provid-
ing facilities and giving constant encouragement.
Marine Biological Station, T. VENKATESWARLU
Zoological Survey of India,
Madras-28,
June 28, 1973.
References
Day, F. (1878) : The Fishes of India,
London.
Fukuda, T. (1951) : Violent increase of
cases of puffer poisoning. Clinics and
Studies, 29 (2).
Halstead, W. Bruce (1970) : Poiso-
nous and venomous marine animals of
the world. Vol. 3. United States Govt.
Printing Office, Washington, D.C.
Sherman, A. Minton Jr. (1966) :
A contribution to the herpetology of
West Pakistan. Bull. Amer. Mus. Nat.
Hist., 134 : 31-184.
Smith, M. A. (1943) : Fauna of British
India. Reptilia and Amphibia. Vol. III.
Serpentes. Taylor and Francis, London.
14. ECHIS COLLECTION IN RATNAGIRI DISTRICT
In July 1969 Mr R. Joshi of Deogad (Ratnagiri District) and
myself supervised and participated in the collection of over 2,000 live
specimens of Echis carinatus (Russel) for the venom production
laboratory of Haffkine Institute of Bombay.
The Catchers :
A group of tribal people called Mahrs traditionally catch the
‘phoorsi’ (as they call the saw-scaled viper) in Ratnagiri District but
catch no other snakes. They believe that the phoorsi can strike
several feet so their catching apparatus consists of long-headed pincers
about one metre in length made from bamboo, or may be a black-
smith fashioned forceps. They also carry a stout bamboo staff with
an 8 inch spike through one end to serve as a rock turner. The
collection basket is plastered with cow dung and has a weighted
coconut shell for 4 secure lid,
618 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
The Biotope:
Coastal Ratnagiri District is comprised of rocky (laterite) tableland
interspersed with small hillocks of boulders and patches of small
forest growth. Most of the year hot and barren, the area literally
sprouts life with the arrival of the monsoon (June-September). The
tableland becomes slippery from algae and under rocks myriads of
amphibians, reptiles and arthropods can be found, urgently feeding and
breeding. All of the construction in the area is done with quarried
lateriate and in the vicinity of villages most of the loose rocks and
boulders are gathered up to form boundary walls. Where the Echis
go in the hot season is unknown and a subject of much speculation.
Dr Vad of Haffkine and myself spent the better part of a day looking
for Echis in May with no success. Echis is the most common reptile
besides Calotes, its ecology is based on the rock strewn tableland which
shelters them as well as their prey.
Echis carinatus ssp.:
This species is found in dry areas from Kenya in Africa to the
Jaffna area in Ceylon with wide variation in size, coloration and
pattern giving rise to several subspecies the classification of which is
being worked upon by investigators such as Stemmier of Switzerland.
The Ratnagiri form is a small snake averaging 250-300 mm in length
with occasional individuals over 500 mm. It is mainly nocturnal in
its habits as very few were collected in the open and of these only one
was on the move. Its feeding and breeding habits have been noted by
M. A. Smith and other authors, 3 large specimens (over 450) disgorged
specimens of the black scorpion Heterometrus which measured over
100 mm. Also field mice ( Mus sp.) were found disgorged in the
collection boxes. Juvenile Echis were not collected but the ratio of
young compared to 200 mm ‘ adults ’ was about 1 : 4. Echis exhibit
variable temperaments like most snakes, some preferring escape when
disturbed and others being very defensive, inflating their bodies and
rubbing their body coils to produce the surprisingly loud hissing sound
and striking repeatedly at the tormentor.
The Collection:
About 30 Mahrs were engaged for a total of 5 days during which
over 2000 Echis were collected. 1200 were of the acceptable 200-
300 mm length, 600 were over 300 mm and the remainder were under
200 mm. The /average price paid to the collectors was 50 paise per
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
619
snake. The general method was for the Mahrs to scatter in the early
morning to their various favoured collection areas and proceed to
walk around turning over likely rocks and covering about 15 km
during the day. On the first day, collecting alone I found 6 Echis
under rocks. During the next days, using the experience of the Mahrs,
in particular a man named Jamsandekar, my average daily catch was
15 Echis , not including babies. The Mahrs have been regularly
catching Echis for Haffkine’s antivenom production for the last 20
years and say that the species is getting noticeably scarcer around
Deogad. After some experience one learns which rocks are more
likely to be hiding an Echis (i.e. those that are not embedded or
surrounded by soil and grass). The rock is quickly turned over
by hand or stick and the phoorsi, if there, is quickly picked up with
the tongs and deposited in the basket (or in some cases an ordinary
tin). Some of the snakes are injured by the rough use of these forceps
but the risk of bite is reduced to almost zero by this method. Other
snakes encountered are either killed or left alone except for Boiga
trigonata which is also caught and feared as being an extra long Echis !
General Notes :
Heavy concentrations of Echis carinatus are common in several
parts of its range. In Kenya during 2\ months in 1962 and 1963
A. Duff -Mackey and J. Leakey captured 6,933 Echis. Wall reports
a large population of Echis in N.W. India and in ‘Ratnagiri District
alone rewards were paid on an average of 225,721 Phoorsas per annum ’,
during the late 1800’s. Bites from Echis in Ratnagiri District and in
areas of N.W. India like Punjab and in some parts of the South
(around Madras and Trichy) are frequent but fortunately the relatively
small size- of the central and southern form makes fatal bites
extremely rare. However it appears that the larger face in N.W.
India and Pakistan is potentially much more dangerous to man.
Other fauna found in conjunction with Echis under the thousands
of stones we overturned are listed as follows:
Snakes :
Amphiesma stolatus
Boiga trigonata
Vipera russellii
Naja naja naja
Lizards :
Calotes versicolor — many Garden lizard
Riopa guentheri — 7 skink
Ophisops beddomei — 5 skink
— 2 Striped Keelback
— 4 Catsnake
— 1 Russell’s Viper
— 1 Cobra
620 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Conclusion :
The biotope of Rainagiri District in the State of Maharashtra
is especially interesting for its very high population of Echis
carinatus. Though an inhospitable area in monsoon it is an extremely
valuable study area and worth more attention by herpetologists and
entomologists in particular.
Madras Snake Park Trust, R. WHITAKER
Madras-22,
August , 1973.
15. OCCURRENCE OF THE BAT-FISH, PEGASUS VOL1TANS
LINNAEUS (PEGASIFORMES : PEGASIDAE) FROM
THE COASTAL WATERS OF INDIA
Day (1889) recorded Pegasus draconis Linnaeus from the Andamans;
Johnstone (1904) and Munro (1955) recorded Pegasus (Parapegasus)
natans (Linnaeus) from the Pearl Banks of Ceylon; and Munro (1955)
recorded Pegasus ( Parapegasus ) volans (Linnaeus) and Pegasus draconis
Linnaeus from Ceylon. According to Herre (1953) Pegasus (Para-
pegasus) natans (Linnaeus) and Pegasus ( Parapegasus ) volans (Linnaeus)
are synonymous with Pegasus volitans Linnaeus. The family Pegasidae
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
621
with one genus, Pegasus Linnaeus, with probably two degenerate
species, P. volitans and P. draconis , is Indo-Pacific in its distribution,
extending from East Africa to Japan and Australia.
Jones & Pantulu (1958) reported a few post-larval stages of Pegasus
( Parapegasus ) volitans ( natans ) from the Orissa Coast and Krishnamurthy
(1961) reported a single larval stage of the same species from the
plankton collections off Porto Novo, considered to be the earliest known
stage for this species. Since Munro’s record from the Gulf of Mannar,
there is only one record of an adult specimen of Pegasus volitans Linnaeus
from coastal waters of India. Jayadev Babu (1966) reported a single
specimen of Pegasus volitans Linnaeus, off Kovalam^30 miles south of
Madras, the total length of which is only 57 mm.
While going through the fish collections of this Regional Station
(Madras), a single specimen of Pegasus volitans Linnaeus was found.
The specimen was caught off Appa Island, Tamilnadu on 21 -i- 1969.
The present specimen measures 90 mm in total length which shows
that it is the first record of a fully grown specimen from coastal waters
of India. The upper surface is dark brown in colour and the lower
surface is paler. There are brown spots on the pectoral fins.
The specimen was deposited in the collections of this Regional
Station with Reg, No. V. 452.
Acknowledgements
My thanks are due to Dr A. Daniel, O/C, S.R.S., Z.S.I., Madras
for giving facilities and encouragement, and to Dr A. G. K. Menon,
Z.S.I., Calcutta for going through the manuscript critically and for
valuable suggestions.
Marine Biological Station,
Zoological Survey of India,
Madras,
July 24, 1973.
Refe
Day. F. (1889) : Fishes : Fauna of
British India, 2 Vols. London.
Herre, A. W. (1953) : Checklist of
Philippine Fishes. Washington (U.S.
Govt. Printing Office).
Jayadev Babu, S. (1966) : Occurrence
of the Bat-fish. Pegasus volitans Linnaeus
(Pegasiformes : Pegasidae), from the
coastal waters of India. J. Bombay
nat. Hist. Soc. 63 (1) : 210-211.
Johnstone, J. (1904) : Ceylon Pearl
Oyster Fisheries nd Marine Biology,
2: 201-203.
T. VENKATESWARLU
ENCES
Jones, S. & Pantulu, V. R. (1958) :
On some larval and juvenile fishes from
the Bengal and Orissa coasts. Indian J.
Fish. 5 : 118-143.
Krishnamurthy, K. (1961) : Occur-
rence of a very early stage of Parapegasus
natans (Linnaeus), from the near-shore
waters of Porto Novo, South India.
J. Mar. Biol. Ass. India., 3 : 271-272.
Munro, Ian S. R. (1955): The Marine
and Fresh water Fishes of Ceylon.
Canberra.
622 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
16. NOTE ON THE RECORD OF GENUS AM NICOLA
FROM AHMEDABAD
This genus Amnicola has two species namely Amnicola cincta
(Gould) and Amnicola parvula (Hutton). Amnicola cincta has been
recorded from Burma by Gould and Amnicola parvula is recorded
from northern Afghanistan by Hutton.
The shell is ovately conical and thin. The spire is composed of
4 rounded whorls. The aperture is small, ovately rounded oblique
with continuous lips. The colour of the shell is glossy with pearly lustre.
As the shell which was collected from Sabarmati river was a very
young shell, it was not possible to decide the species and hence a
description of genus Amnicola is given above.
Habitat : Shell was collected from the sandy bottom of the river
bed just near Raj Bhavan.
Specimen in collection :
Measurements: Height: 5 mm, Maximum diameter: 3-5 mm,
aperture height: 2 mm, aperture diameter: 1*5 mm.
Acknowledgement
We are grateful to Mr A. S. Rajagopal, Zoologist, Zoological
Survey of India, for help in identification.
Biology Department, Y. M. DALAL
Gujarat College, G. T. P ANDY A
Ahmedabad-6,
May 15, 1972.
17. ADDITION TO THE RECORD OF HOST PLANTS OF
CHILO ZONELLUS (SWINHOE) (I.EPIDOPTERA : PYRALIDAE)
The Jowar stem borer, Chilo zonellus (Swinhoe), has been reported
as a major pest of Jowar and Maize. It has also been recorded on
Sugarcane, Bajra, Rice, Johnson grass. Job’s tears ( Coix lachryma-jobi
L.), Kawdia or Burgur (Polytoca barbata Stapf) (Trehan & Butani
1949), teosinte {Euchlaena mexicand) (Pant et al. 1962), Sawa ( Panicum
jrumentaceum), Sarkada ( Saccharum sera), other grasses like
Andropogon spp., Eragrostis spp., Eleusine verticillata and Triant hema
monogyna (Anonymous 1964).
During the year 1971-72, the insect has been found as a minor
pest of Wheat at Nelamangala, Chintamani, Hoskote, Kanakapura and
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
623
Hebbal in Mysore State. The caterpillar while boring causes dead
heart in young plants and chaffy earheads in mature plants.
Division of Entomology, M. VISHAKANTAIAH
University of Agricultural B. L. VISWESWARA GOWDA
Sciences, Hebbal,
Bangalore-24,
June 22, 1972.
References
Anonymous (1964) : Entomology in (Swin.) in different host plants. Indian
India. The Entomological Society of J. Ent. 23 : 128-136.
India, pp. 529. Trehan, K. N. & Butani, D. K.
(1949) : Notes on Life-history, Biono-
Pant, N. C., Pathak, M. D. & Pant, mics and control of Chilo zonellus
J. C. (1962) : Resistance to Chilo zonellus Swinhoe in Bombay Province. Indian
J . Ent . 11 : 47-59.
18. OCCURRENCE OF PESTS ON KODO MILLET
(PASPALUM SCROBICU LATUM)
The kodo millet is one of the minor crops, cultivated over an area
of about 2-42 lakh hectares in Tamil Nadu. The crop is raised during
rainy season on poor soils. Generally, the crop is free from any
pest or disease.
The crop raised during 1970 at the Millet Breeding Station of the
Tamil Nadu Agricultural University was unusually infested with the
following new pests.
(a) Semi-looper ( Azazici rubricans) — (Family Noctuideae).
The pest was noticed during the flowering phase of the crop and
the caterpillars were feeding on the flowers. The damage to the crop
was not however severe since the flowering phase was near completion.
(. b ) Leaf roller ( Cnaphalocrocis medinalis).
The incidence of this pest was observed in the flowering stage of
the crop. The extent of attack on a few varieties of the crop was
assessed and the data are presented below
18
624 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
The percentage of attack among the varieties ranged from 6-8
to 13-3.
Based on these preliminary observations, the extent of damage in
yield of grains has to be investigated in future.
Tamil Nadu Agricultural V. D. GURUSWAMY RAJA
University, U. S. NATARAJAN
Coimbatore-3,
January 6, 1972.
19. SYSTEMATICS OF INDIAN RHOPALIDAE (HEM1PTERA)
Earlier workers disagreed upon the rank and the name- of this group
of insects. It had been considered a subfamily of the family Coreidae
under the name Corizinae for several years. Recently, Harris (1942),
Schaefer (1965) and Chopra (1967) have pointed out that this group deser-
ves the status of a family and the correct name should be Rhopalidae,
Amyot & Serville rather than Corizidae, Douglas & Scott. The Indian
representatives of this family have been described and listed by Distant
(1902 & 1918) in the subfamily Corizinae. Distant (1902) followed the
earlier classification of the group and has indicated that the Indian species
belong to two divisions : Corizaria, Stal and Serinetharia, Stal. In
1902 he included four species of a genus Corizus in the division Corizaria
and six species of the genus Serinetha in the division Serinetharia. In
1918 he added six new species to his genus Corizus and two additional
genera : Agraphopus Stal, and Therapha Amyot & Serville each contain-
ing two species. According to the most recent classification (Chopra
1967) the family is divided into two subfamilies : Rhopalinae, Amyot &
Serville and Serinethinae, Stal. The former is considered to be com-
posed of six tribes : Niesthrini, Chopra, Rhopalini, Amyot & Serville,
Chorosomini, Douglas & Scott, Harmostini Stal, Maccevithini, Chopra
and Corizomorphini, Chopra while the latter included only one group.
The Indian species of this family belong to the subfamily Serinethinae
and the tribes Niesthrini, Rhopalini and Chorosomini of the subfamily
Rhopalinae.
Among Serinethinae, Leptocoris Hahn has priority over Serinetha
Spmola. The species listed by Distant under Serinetha , therefore, pertain
to Leptocoris. Gross (1960) synonymized dallasi Dohrn with augur F.,
while Chopra (1971) has described a new species L. arorai from south
India. The genus Leptocoris as recognized now contains nine species
and three subspecies from India.
Among the subfamily Rhopalinae, Corizus Fallen belongs to the
tribe Rhopalini and has priority over Therapha Amyot & Serville. The
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
625
species listed under Thsrapha , therefore, belong to Corizus. Kerzhner
(1962) synonymized diluta Distant with limbatus Reuter. The genus
Corizus is now represented by only one species. The genus Agraphopus
Stal belongs to the tribe Chorosomini and is represented by one species
while the sec end species oriental is (Distant) belongs to the genus Lepto -
czrasa Jakovlev. The genus Corizus Fallen as considered by Distant,
has been divided into several genera. The Indian species listed under
Corizus actually belong to the genus Liorhyssus Stal which is* now included
in the tribe Niesthrini. Chopra (1967) for the first time recorded the
occurrence of Peliochrous Stal also of the tribe Niesthrini from south
India. Specimens have also been collected from Chandigarh, India.
Checklist of Indian Rhopalidae
The descriptions of the species recorded by Distant are mainly based
on colour differences which are quite unreliable as the colouf of most of
the Rhopalid species studied by me vary in a bewildering manner. Until
the type specimens are studied further the Indian Rhopalidae are consi-
dered to be represented by the following taxa. Some of the species listed
below, as indicated, have not actually been reported from India but most
probably these will be discovered sooner or later.
Family Rhopalidae Amyot & Serville
Subfamily rhopalinae Amyot & Serville
Tribe Niesthrini Chopra
Genus Peliochrous Stal
Peliochrous Stal, 1873
Type species : Corizus nigromaculatus Stal, 1855 ; monobasic.
P. nigromiculatus Stal, 1855, Locality : Chandigarh & South India.
Tribe Rhopalini Amyot & Serville
Genus Corizus Fallen
Corizus Fallen, 1814, Therapha Amyot & Serville, 1843, RhopaJus Spinola, 1837.
Consivius Distant, 1909.
Type species : — Corizus : Cimex hyoscyami L., 1758 ; fixed by Brulle, 1835.
Therapha : Cimex hyoscyami L., 1758 ; fixed by Oshanin, 1912, Consivius : Consivius
collinus Distant, 1909 = Cimex hyoscyami L., 1758 ; monobasic.
C. hyoscyami (L.), 1758. Locality : Simla Hills, Kumaon and Shamkhet.
Therapha diluta Distant, 1918. (Syn. by Kerzhner, 1962).
Genus Liorhyssus Stal
Liorhyssus Stal, 1870, Colohatus Mulsant & Rey, 1870.
Type species : Liorhyssus : Lygaeus hyalinus F., 1794 ; fixed by Reuter, 1888. Colobatus:
Corizus gracilis Herrich- Schaeffer, 1835 = Lygaeus hyalinus F., 1794 ; monobasic.
62 6 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
L. bengalemis (Dallas) 1852, Locality: North Bengal, Bombay, Bor Ghat&Pusa.
L. brevicollis (Motsch) 1863. Locality: Ceylon.
L. imperialis (Distant) 1918. Locality : Bombay & Dehra Dun.
L. macropictus (Distant) 1918. Locality : Chikkaballapura, Nilgiri Hills & Madras.
L. multimaculatus (Distant) 1918. Locality : Chikkaballapura, South India.
L. parvipictus (Distant) 1918. Locality : Chikkaballapura, South India.
L. pronotalis (Distant) 1918. Locality : Dehra Dun.
L. rubicundus (Signoret) 1859. Locality-: Ceylon & Dehra Dun.
L. semicruciatus (Motsch) 1863. Locality : Ceylon.
L. subfasciatus (Distant) 1918. Locality : Ceylon.
Tribe Chorosomini Douglas & Scott
Genus Agraphopus Stal
Agraphopus Stal, 1872
Type species : Agraphopus lethierryi Stal, 1872 ; monobasic.
A. lethierryi Stal, 1872. Locality : Chikkaballapura, South India.
Genus Leptoceraea Jakovlev
Leptoceraea Jakovlev, 1874
Type species : Leptoceraea viridis Jakovlev, monobasic.
L. orientalis Distant 1918. Locality : North Bengal & Pusa.
Subfamily serinethinae Stal
Genus Leptocoris Hahn
Leptocoris Hahn, 1831. Serinetha Spinola, 1837. Lygaemorphus Blanchard, 1840.
Pyrrhotes Westwood, 1842. Tynotoma Amyot & Serville 1843. Boisea Kirkaldy,
1910.
Type species: Leptocoris: Leptocoris rufus Hahn, 1831 —Lygaeus abdominalis F.,
1803 ; monobasic. Tynotoma : Tynotoma vittata Amyot & Serville, 1843 ; monobasic
(nomen dubium). Boisea : Boisea vittata Kirkaldy, 19 10= Leptocoris trivittatus Say,
1825 ; monobasic.
L abdominalis (F.) 1803. Locality : Calcutta & Assam.
L. abdominalis abdominalis (F.) 1803.
L. abdominalis blotei Gross 1960.
L. abdominalis taprobanensis (Dallas) 1852.
L. arorai Chopra 1971. Locality: Nilgiri and south Malabar Hills.
L. augur (F.) 1781. Locality: Bombay, Calcutta & Madras.
L. dallasi (Dohorn) 1860. (Syn. by Gross, 1960).
L. coimbatorensis Gross 1960. Locality : Coimbatore.
L. corniculata (Stal) 1866. Locality : Western India.
L. coxalis (Kirby) 1891. Locality: Ceylon.
L. rufomarginata (F.) 1794. Locality : Calcutta & Nicobar Islands.
L. subrufescens (Kirby) 1888. Locality : Ceylon and Christmas Island.
L. vicina (Dallas) 1852. Locality : Ceylon.
Department of Entomology, N. P. CHOPRA
Haryana Agricultural University,
Hissar,
August 18, 1972.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
627
References
(Note : All references prior to 1967 are
listed by Chopra, 1967 and Distant, 1902
& 1918.).
Chopra, N. P. (1967) : The higher
classification of the family Rhopalidae
(Hemiptera). Tram. R. ent. Soc. Lond.
119 : 363-399.
(1971): A new species of
Leptocoris Hahn from India (Rhopalidae :
Hemiptera). Oriental Insects . 5 : 507-
509.
Distant, W. L. (1902) : The Fauna of
British India including Ceylon & Burma .
Rhynchota (Heteroptera) 1 : 416-420.
London.
(1918) : The Fauna of British
India including Ceylon & Burma. Rhyn-
chota (Homoptera : Appendix ; Hete-
roptera : Addenda). 7: 168-173. London.
20. DISTRIBUTIONAL RECORDS OF MUSCIDAE (DIPTERA)
Muscidae (Diptera) contains probably the world’s commonest
and most ubiquitous inseqts, the adults of which transmit
several dangerous and widespread diseases including typhoid fever,
several kinds of dysentery, cholera and trachoma while a few
members of the family have been listed as parasitic in nature. The
following muscids were collected at Damoh, Madhya Pradesh and
Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh.
I am thankful to Dr S. C. Sen Gupta, Director and Dr
A. Bhattacharya, Entomologist of the Institute, for providing
facilities to work. Thanks are also due to Mr B. P. Mehra,
Scientific Officer of the Institute, for going through the manuscript
628 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, VoL 71 (3)
and to Mr A. C. Pont and Mr R. W. Crcsskey, Commonwealth
Institute of Entomology, Lond:n, for identifying the muscids.
Indian Lac Research Institute, R. S. GOKULPURE
Namkum, Ranchi,
October 15, 1971.
21. SHEPHERD'S PURSE— AN EDIBLE PLANT OF KASHMIR
Shepherd’s purse — Capsella bur sa-past oris Mcench is a widely
distributed plant growing throughout temperate regions cf India. It
is reported to have a wide medicinal application which includes its
use as a diuretic and as a deterrent for haemorrhage (wealth of indta,
II, 68, 1950). There is however no record cf its use for edble
purposes. In the course of cur search for little known edible plants
of the North-Western Himalayas we found people in district Doda
of Jammu and many parts of Kashmir valley using this plant as a
favourite vegetable. At Sanasar in Dcda District the plant is known
as ‘Drati’ and in Kashmir province it is called as ‘Krai mund \
The leaves and tender flowering shoots of the plant are cooked into a
slightly sour dish.
Rosettes of Capsella bursa-pcstoris appear immediately aTer the
snow melts. At this time of the year, very few plants are availaWe
for human c"nsvmotion in the mountamcus areas. The locals largely
depend upon sun-dried vegetables cf the previous season. Shepherd’s
purse, therefore, provides a good change. The children also eat the
raw fruits.
Capsella bursa-pastoris Moe~ch b~Ungs to the mustard family
(Cruciferae) and is an erect annual wifh a rosette of deeply clefted
leaves oppressed to the ground. Flwering shoots are about 40 cm
long and bear small white flowers and conspicuous heart-shaped
fruits (to which the plant owes its common English name). The
fruits dehisce longitudinally along the central septum exposing two
rows of minute seeds on each side.
Acknowledgement
The junior author thanks Indian National Science Academy, New
Delhi, for financial assistance.
Department of Bio -Sciences,
University of Jammu,
Jammu,
August 11, 1973.
A. K. KOUL
J. L. KARIHALOO
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
629
22. TAXONOMICAL NOTES ON CLEOME ASPERA
KOEN. EX DC., C. RURMANNI WT. & ARN. AND
C. RUTIDOSPERMA DC. (CLEOMACEAE)
litis (Brittonia 12: 290, 1960) included C. aspera Koen. ex DC.,
C. burmcmni Wt. & Arn. and C. rutidosperma DC., together with C.
micrantha (Boj.) Baker of Madagascar, under the section Rutidosperma
litis because of their close affinity. The close alliance of C. burmanni
Wt. & Arn. with C. rutidosperma DC. (= C. ciliata Schum. &
Thonn.) is also evident from the remark of Hooker f. 8c Thomson
(FI. Brit. Ind. 1: 170, 1872) who commented that the former
resembles the latter which is a native of tropical Africa, now
introduced elsewhere. Dixit & Siddiqui (Ind. For. Ined.) had gone
to the extent of reducing C. burmanni Wt. & Arn.— a peninsular Indian
and Ceylonese species, to the synonymy of C. rutidosperma DC.— *
an African alien.
C. aspera Koen. ex DC— another Peninsular Indian and Ceylonese
species, is also dosely allied to C. burmanni Wt. & Am. It is this
species that is often mixed and confused with C. burmanni Wt. 8c Arn.
As is evident from the description as well as from the annotated
specimens by Jacob, the Malaysian plants which were hitherto referred
to as C. aspera actually belong to C. burmanni (vide Jacob, FI. Males, :
Ser. 1, 6: 105, 1960; Backer & Bakh. f., FI. Java 1: 183, 1963).
However, it is true that C. burmanni is very much similar to C.
rutidosperma in its vegetative features, but is remarkably distinct
from C. aspera in certain vegetative and floral characters. These three
related taxa can be distinguished in the following manner:
1. Pod sessile. Leaflets oblong-lanceolate, clothed with tubercle-based setose
hairs ; petioles shorter than leaflets, 0'5-l*5 cm long
C. aspera
1. Pod distinctly stalked (on gynophore). Leaflets ovate, elliptic, rhomboid or
obovate, glabrous except softly setose nerves ; petioles as long as or longer
than leaflets.
2
2. Pod terete, torulose, 0‘ 15-0*2 cm across. Petals (V5-0-7 cm long. Stems
thinly clothed with persistent short, compressed, hooked or recurved prickly
appendages, 0 03-005 cm long ; seeds with a closed cleft, without elaioscmes
C. burmanni
2. Pod compressed, 0*4 cm across. Petals Q’8-1 (-1*2) cm long. Stems clothed
with deciduous or subpersi stent, linear, recurved, soft appendages, O-QS-O^ cm
long. Seeds with a closed cleft, with white elaiosomes
.......... C, rutidosperma
630 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Cleome aspera Koen. ex DC. Prodr. 1: 241, 1824; Wt. & Arn.
Prodr. 22, 1834; Wt. Icon. t. 287, 1840. Hook. f. & Thoms,
in FI. Brit. Ind. 1 : 169, 1872; Gamble, FI. Presid. Madras 40-41,
1915. Trimen, Handb. FI. Ceyl. 1: 56, 1893; Pax & Hoffm. in
Pflanzenfam. ed. 2. 176: 214, 1936.— C. diffusa Roxb. FI. Ind.
3: 129, 1832.
Prostrate or decumbent-ascending, multicauline, annual herbs.
Stems simple or sparsely branched at base, ribbed, clothed with short
compressed, hooked prickly appendages. Leaves 3-foliolate, rarely,
higher ones 1-foliolate, lower ones long-petioled, upper ones short-
petioled or subsessile, becoming smaller upwards: petioles 0-2-1-5 cm
long; leaflets subsessile, oblong-lanceolate, subobtuse, tipped with a
bristle, with ciliate, recurved margins, scabridly hairy with tubercle-
based hairs, 0-5-2-5 X0-2-0-5 cm. Flowers solitary, in axils of higher
leaves often forming leafy racemes; pedicels 0- 3-0-5 cm long, glabrate
or short hairy; sepals linear-lanceolate, 0-05 cm long; petals white,
oblanceolate, 0-25-0-3 cm long; stamens 6, 0-25 cm long; ovary sessile,
style linear, 0-02 cm long Fruit sessile, terete, torulose, narrowed
at both ends, 1-5-3 cm long (inch beak), glabrous, 0-15-0-2 cm across;
seeds reddish brown, with prominent cross-ribs and concentric ribs,
0-15-0-17 cm across.
Type : Koenig (K)
Flowers and fruits : July-Oct,
Specimens examined : India : Coimbatore, Bolampatti valley, alt.
500 m, Fischer 2038 (CAL). Nellore, Velikonda Hills, Ramaswamy
1352 (CAL) ; without definite locality, Cleghorn , s. n. (CAL)
Distribution : Peninsular India and Ceylon.
Cleome hurmanni Wt. & Arn. Prodr. 22, 1834 ; Hook. f. & Thoms,
in FL Brit. Ind. 1 : 170, 1872; Gamble, FI. Presid. Madras
40-41, 1915 ; Pax & Hofifm. in Pflanzenfam. ed. 2. 176 : 214, 1936.
C. aspera sensu Jacobs in FI. Males. Ser. L6 : 105, 1960 ; Backer
& Bakh. f. FI. Java 1 : 183. 1963 (non Koen. ex DC.).
Erect, widely branched annual herbs. Stems ribbed, thinly clothed
with short compressed, prickly appendages, 0*03 cm long. Leaves 3-
foliolate, lower ones on longer petioles, higher ones short-petioled or
subsessile, upwards reduced; petioles 0*15-2*5 (-3) cm long; leaflets
subsessile or short petioled, elliptic-lanceolate or oval-lanceolate, narrowed
at both ends, acute or subobtuse at apex, slightly oblique, cuneate or acute
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
631
at base, membranous, laxly, faintly crenulate-serrate, ciliate, glabrous
except setosely hairy nerves, l-3x0"4-l cm. Flowers solitary, in axils
of higher reduced leaves ; pedicels slender, short-gland-hairy, O' 5-1 *5
(-2) cm long; sepals lanceolate, acuminate, 0*1-0-15 (2) cm long;
petals 0*4-0- 5 cm long ; stamens 6, 0*5 cm long ; ovary on a 0*2 cm long
gynophore. Fruit terete, torulose, glabrous, attenuate at both ends, on
0-4-0- 6 cm long gynophore, 3-5 cm long (inch 0*02-0-03 cm long beak),
0*15-0-2 cm across; valves parallel-nerved; seeds reddish-brown, 0*1
cm across with concentric and cross ribs, with a closed cleft and without a
elaiosome.
Type : Wight 75 (K-holotype ; CAL-isotype)
Specimens examined : India : Without definite locality, Wight
15 (CAL-isotype). ceylon : Without definite locality, Thwaites
1068 (CAL). Indonesia. : Java Madioen Zeehooghe 65 H, Backer
6911 (CAL).
Distribution : Western Peninsular India, Ceylon and Java.
Cleome rutidosperma DC. Prodr. 1 : 241, 1824 ; litis in Brittonia
12 : 290, 1960 ; Jacobs in FI. Males. Ser. 1. 6 : 105, 1960 ;
Backer & Bakh. f. FI. Java 1 : 183, 1963.
C. ciliata Schum. & Thonn. Dansk. Vid. Selsk. Afgh. 4 : 67, 1827 ;
Pax & Hoffm. in Pflanzenfam. ed. 2. 17b : 213, 1936 ; Johnson & Tan.
in Gard. Bull. Sing. 17 : 325-330, 1959.
Erect or decumbent-ascending, usually widely branched, annual
herbs, 15-100 cm tall. Stems ribbed, clothed with soft, linear, recurved,
deciduous, 0*05-0*2 cm long, prickly appendages. Leaves 3-foliolate,
lower ones long-petioled, higher ones short-petioled or sessile, upwards
reduced ; petiole 0’3-0°5 cm long ; leaflets subsessile or short-petioled,
elliptic-rhomboid or elliptic-lanceolate-oblong, with a cuneate or acute,
narrowed base, subacute, often narrowed to the top, ciliate ; serrulate,
often purple margined, glabrous except softly setose hairy nerves, 0*5-3 x
0* 3-1*5 cm. Flowers solitary, in highest leaf axils ; pedicels 1-1*4 cm
long during anthesis, 2-2*5 (-3) cm long in fruiting, short-gland-hairy ;
sepals lanceolate, acuminate, 0-25-0*4 cm long ; petals obovate-elliptic,
0*9-1 (-1*2) cm long ; stamens 0-8-1 cm long ; ovary on 0-15-0-2 cm long
gynophore, stigma sessile. Fruit compressed on 0*5-1 cm long gyno-
phore, attenuate at both ends, glabrous, 4-7 (inch 0* 1-0-2 cm long beak)
cm long, 0-3-Q-4 cm across ; seeds suborbicular reniform, dark-brown,
with an open cleft and a white elaiosome (aril), with prominent concen-
tric and cross ribs.
632 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
Type : Without Collector's name ( Smeathman ) ( G-DEL )
Flowers and fruits : Greater part of the year.
Specimens examined : india : West Bengal. Calcutta, Lady Bra-
bourne College Compound, Chandra , (CAL). Singapore : Chury
Road, Tangli, Furtado 2117 (CAL).
Distribution : A native of tropical Africa, adventive in New World,
introduced in the Caribbean region, found in Malaysia, collected in
Burma and is now recorded here from India.
In his extensive diseussion on the typification and identification of C.
rutidosperma DC., litis (loc. cit.) showed that C. ciliata Schum. & Thonn-.
is.conspecific with C. rutidosperma DC., which was hitherto considered
as an enigmatic species, and is the correct name for this widely spreading
tropical African alien, as it has got priority over C. ciliata Schum. &
Thonn.
Acknowledgement
Grateful thanks are due to Dr M. P. Nayar, Keeper, Central National
Herbarium, Calcutta, for his encouragement and suggestions.
Central National Herbarium, C. R. BABU1
Howrah,
September 8, 1973. N. C. MAJUMDAR2
23. A NEW SPECIES OF SONERILA (MELASTOMATACEAE)
FROM KERALA, S. INDIA
( With a plate)
Sonerila devicolamensis sp. nov.
Affinis S. sadasivanii Nayar, sed caulibus infra subangularibus, supra
teretibus, crassibus, rubicund ibus, conspicue cicatribus, carnosis, folio-
rum marginibus conspicue serratis, inflorescentias robustis carnosisque,
floribus majoribus differt.
Herba suberecta, caulibus infra subangularibus, radicantibus, supra
teretibus, rubicundibus, cicatribus, crassibus carnosisque. Folia opposita,
ovata vel ovato-elliptica, 3-6 x 1*5-3 cm, basi obtusa vel anguste cuneata,
apice acuta, margine e basi ad apicem conspicue serrata, supra subterque
glabra, 5-nervia, nervis ex apice petioli ortis, venulis transversis absenti-
1 Present address : Department of Botany, University of Delhi, Delhi-7.
a Present address : Botanical Survey of India, Shillong-3.
- 0
s
- 10|
mm
Sonerila devicolamensis sp. nov.
A, Habit — natural size.
B. Petal.
C. Stamen
*
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
633
bus. Petioli 1-2*5 cm longi, crassi, rubicundi. Inflorescentia terminalis
vel axillaris, 4-8 cm longa, glabra 5-12 flora ; pedunculus 3-4 cm longus,
glaber, rubicundus ; pedicelli 4-8 mm longi. Calycistibus campanulatus,
7-10 mm longus, glaber, rubicundus ; limbus 3-lobatus, lobibus triangu-
laribus 2*5-3 mm longis. Petala 3, ovato-elliptica, 1*3-15 X 1-1*2 cm,
apice apiculata, rosea. Stamina 3, filament is 6-7 mm longis, antheris
5*5-6 mm longis, basi cordatis, connectivo, inappendiculato. Stylus
filiformis, 1*2-1 *3 cm longus, glaber, stigmate punctiformi. Capsula
obconica, 1-1*5 cm longa, glabra ; pedicellus 1-1*3 cm longus. Semina
cuneata, 1 mm longa, numerosa.
Typus : A. Meebold 13771 (CAL).
Sonerila devicolamensis sp. nov.
Allied to Sonerila sadasivanii Nayar, but differs in having the lower
portion of the stem subangular, and upper portion of stem terete, thick,
fleshy, reddish and conspicuously marked with leaf scars, leaf margin
conspicuously serrate, inflorescence robust fleshy, and flowers larger.
Suberect herb ; stem in the lower portions subangular rooting at the
nodes, upper portion terete, reddish conspicuous with leaf scars thick
and fleshy. Leaves opposite, ovate or ovate-elliptic, 3-6 x 1*5-3 cm, base
obtuse or narrowly cuneate, apex acute, leaf margin from base to apex
conspicuously serrate, upper and lower surfaces glabrous, 5-nerved, nerves
arising from the apex of the petiole, transverse venules absent ; petiole
1-2*5 cm long, thick and reddish. Inflorescence terminal or axillary, 4-8
cm long, glabrous, reddish, pedicel 4-8 mm long. Calyx tube campanu-
late, 7-10 mm long, glabrous, reddish ; limb 3-lobed, lobes triangular,
2*5-3 mm long. Petals 3, ovate-elliptic, 1*3-1*5 x 1-1*2 cm, apex apiculate,
pink. Stamens 3, filament 6-7 mm long, anther 5*5-6 mm long, base cor-
date, connective, inappendiculate. Style filiform, 1*2-1 *3 cm long, gla-
brous, stigma punctiform. Capsule obconical 1-1*5 cm long, glabrous ;
pedicel 1-1*3 cm long. Seeds cuneate, 1 mm long, numerous.
Distribution : India : Kerala, Devicolam, A. Meebold 13771 (Holo-
type CAL) ; ibid. ; alt : 2000m., Dec. 1910, A. Meebold 13893, (CAL).
Acknowledgement
I am thankful to Dr K. Subramanyam, Director, Botanical Survey of
India for encouragement.
Keeper, M. P. NAYAR
Central National Herbarium,
Botanic Garden P. O.,
Howrah-3,
May 5, 1973.
634 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
24. HEMIGR APHIS H1RTA (VAHL) T. ANDERS.— A NEW
RECORD FOR BOMBAY
( With a text-figure)
The author in his rambles in the ravines of Por (Dist. Baroda) has
come across Hemigraphis hirta which is not listed in Th. Cooke’s (1904)
Flora of the Presidency of Bombay. H. Santapau (1952) did not record
it in his monographic work — The Acanthaceae of Bombay ’ and in
Journ. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc. 51 : 349-68, 1953.
Hemigraphis hirta (Vahl) T. Anders, in Journ. Linn. Soc. 9 : 462, 1867 ;
Clarke in Hooker’s FI. Brit. Ind. 4 : 422, 1884.
Rusllia hirta Vahl, Symb. Bot. 3 : 84, t. 67, 1794 ; Roxb. FI. Ind.
3 : 46, 1832 ; Nees in DC. Prodr. II : 145, 1847, excl. var. 0.
A. Part of the plant.
B. Flower.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES
635
R. latebrosa Roxb. FI. Ind. 3 : 46?, 1832 ; Wall, Cat. 2382, not
of Roth nor of Dalz. nor of Wight.
R. sarmentosa Nees in Wall. PI. As. Rar. 3 : 83, 1832.
Soft, pubescent herbs ; villous with white hairs. Stems creeping,
flexuose. Leaves small, ovate, crenate. Flowers in small, close termi-
nal heads ; pale blue in colour ; corolla long-cylindric below, upper part
funnel-shaped ventricose ; bracts elliptic, bracteoles O ; calyx-lobes
linear, obtuse, green. Capsule linear-obovoid, glabrous except at tip,
about 12-seeded.
Flowering and Fruiting : April.
Index Kewensis gives India as the home of this plant. The species is
confined to India and occupies a rather isolated position in the genus
Elemigr aphis Nees.
The species has not been recorded from Bombay.
Acknowledgements
The identification was checked in Netherlands by Professor Dr C.
E. B. Bremekamp, to whom I tender sincere thanks.
General Education Centre, G. M. OZA
Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda,
Baroda 2,
September 2, 1973.
25. HERMAPHRODITISM IN CASSAVA ( MANIHOT
ESCULENTA CRANTZ.)
( With two photographs & nine text-figures)
Cassava (Man i hot esculenta) is an important food crop, extensively
cultivated in the tropics for its tuberous roots which contain starch.
Kerala is the chief cassava-growing State in India.
A large collection of germplasm consisting of about 400 varieties of
this monoecious species is maintained in the Department of Botany,
University of Kerala, Trivandrum. During the course of extensive stu-
dies on cassava germplasm, hermaphrodite flowers have been observed
in one strain of cassava namely H. 450 (Accession No. M. 67-48). The
present paper deals with detailed observations on hermaphroditism in
this species, which is being recorded for the first time.
636 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 7l (3)
Observations
As has been described by earlier workers (Rendle 1925 ; Panicker
1957), flowers in Manihot esculenta are hypogynous, actinomorphic and
are borne in terminal compound cymose panicles. The female flowers
are fewer in number compared to male flowers, usually occur at the basal
part of the panicles and open first. After a week or so, the male flowers,
produced in large numbers in terminal clusters, begin to open one by one
in acropeta! succession. This difference in maturity of the male and
female flowers ensures cross pollination in nature and consequently the
plants are highly heterozygous.
Unisexual Flowers
The majority of the flowers produced in H. 450 are unisexual. Pistil-
late flowers are larger than the staminate flowers and have five free perianth
segments and a tricarpellary, syncarpous superior ovary on an annual
slightly lobed prominent disc. In the staminate flower, the perianth is
cup-shaped, five lobed above, with ten stamens in two whorls of five each.
Hermaphrodite Flowers
Hermaphrodite flowers having five free perianth lobes (Photo 1 and
Text-fig. A) and those with fused cup-shaped perianth (Photo 2 and Text-
fig. G) have been found in this variety. The hermaphrodite flowers with
free perianth lobes resemble the female flowers in external appearance,
the only difference being the presence of stamens in them. They are seen
below the male flowers in the cymose panicle. Each flower has five free
triangular perianth segments with obtuse apex (Text-figs. A & B).
The perianth segments are imbricate in bud (Text-fig. F) and white in
colour with greenish tint on the outside. The majority of the flowers
have 10 stamens, but the number has been found to vary from 1-10 in
many cases. When there are 10 stamens, they are arranged in two whorls
of five each. The outer stamens have long filaments and are seen oppo-
site the perianth lobes (Text-figs. C & D). The inner five have short
filaments and alternate with the first whorl. Anthers dehisce longitudi-
nally, those of the outer whorl introse and inner, extrose (Text-figs.
D & F). About 93 % of the pollen are fertile. The pistil is tricarpellary,
syncarpous with superior ovary on an annular, slightly ten lobed, promi-
nent disc (Text-fig. E). The ovary is broadly oblong, distinctly six ridged
and three chambered with a solitary, pendulous, anatropous ovule in
each chamber (Text-figs. B & F). The stigma is almost sessile, trifid,
sticky and white in colour and each stigmatic branch divides repeatedly
into many fine closely packed lobes.
A second type of hermaphrodite flower with cup- shaped perianth
like the normal staminate flowers also occurs in these plants. They open
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES 637
along with the pistillate flowers, earlier than the staminate flowers. The
perianth is cup-shaped with five distinct lobes at the top and the cleavages
Fig. 1. A portion of an inflorescence showing a hermaphrodite flower
with free perianth lobes.
Fig. 2. Hermaphrodite flower having cup-shaped perianth.
extend almost to the middle of the cup (Text-fig, G). The fused basal
part of the perianth is slightly ribbed outside. The perianth lobes are
white with a slightly reddish tint and imbricate in bud (Text-fig. 1),
638 JOURNAL , BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
The number and arrangement of the stamens are similar to those of the
normal male flowers (Text-figs. H & I). The pistil is usually well deve-
loped, but rarely poorly developed. About 94% of the pollen are fertile.
Figures A-F — Details of hermaphrodite flowers having free perianth lobes and
G-I— flowers having fused perianth. A : whole flower. B : L.S. of flower. C : flowed
after removal of perianth lobes. D : stamens having long and short filaments. E :
Gynoecium. F : floral diagram. G : whole flower. H : L.S. of flower. I : floral
diagram.
Discussion
Hermaphrodite flowers do not appear to have been recorded so far
in Manihot esculenta. There are reports of the occurrence of herma-
phrodite flowers in coconut, cucurbits and papaya, which like M. esculenta
usually produce unisexual flowers. Gopala Rao (1948) observed a stray
instance of hermaphrodite flowers in coconut and Davis, Anandan &
Menon (1954) have reported the occurrence of hermaphrodite trees in
coconut. In cultivated cucurbits where hermaphrodite female and male
plants occur, genetic studies have indicated that the development of
stamens and pistil is suppressed by two dominant genes ‘ A ’ and ‘ G ’
respectively, the recessive alleles of which in the homozygous conditions
promotes development of plants with perfect flowers (Whitaker &
Davis 1962). Papaya plants with hermaphrodite flowers are also known
to be homozygous recessive (mm), the two dominant alleles Mx and M2
in heterozygous condition (Mxm and M2m) resulting in male and female
MISCELLANEOUS NOTES 639
plants respectively (Storey 1953- ; Hofmeyer 1953). Plants having ex-
clusively hermaphrodite flowers have not so far been encountered in
Manihot esculenta. However, the regular occurrence of hermaphrodite
flowers in all the ten plants in the variety H. 450 indicates that this pheno-
menon is possibly genetically controlled.
Acknowledgements c
This study has been made possible through the efforts of ProT
A. Abraham, University of Kerala (now in the F.A.O.) who had
assembled a large collection of germplasm of root and tuber crops in
this Department. The material studied by us is a hybrid evolved by him*
We are grateful to him for access to this material. We are also thankful
to the United States Department of Agriculture for a generous grant which
enabled us to maintain and make further studies on this collection.
Department of Botany, PHILOMENA MADHAVADIAN
University of Kerala, SUSAN ABRAHAM
Trivandrum, C. A. NINAN
September 29, 1973.
References
Davis, T. A., Anandan, A. P. &
Menon, K. P. V. (1954) : Hermaphrodi-
tism in Cocos nucifera. Indian Coco. Jour.
7 : 133-142.
Gopala Rao, T. (1948) : A note on
the occurrence of a hermaphrodite flower
in coconut ( Cocos nucifera). J. Indian
Bot. Soc. 27 : 208-211.
Hofmeyer, J. D. J. (1953) : Sex rever-
sal as a means of solving breeding pro-
blems of Carica papaya L. S. African J .
Sci. 49 : 228-232.
Rendle, A. B. (1925) : The classifica-
tion of flowering plants. Vol. II. Dico-
tyledons. Cambridge University Press.
Panicker, P. K. S. (1957) : Investiga-
tions on tapioca (. Manihot utilissima).
Thesis submitted for the Degree of Master
of Science of the University of Kerala.
Storey, W. B. (1953) : Genetics of
Papaya. J. Heredity 44 ; 70-78.
Whitaker, T. W. and Davis, G. NL
(1962) ; Cucurbits — Botany, Cultivation
and utilization. Inter Science Publishers,
New York.
ANNUAL REPORT OF THE BOMBAY NATURAL
HISTORY SOCIETY FOR THE YEAR 1973-74
Executive Committee
President \
Dr Salim Ali, d.sc., f.n.a.
Vice-Presidents
Mr R. E. Hawkins
Mr G. V. Redekar, i.c.s. (Retd.), j.p.
Hon. Secretary ) ex-o fficio
Mr Zafar Futehally
Hon. Treasurer
Mr J. D. Kapadia, i.c.s. (Retd.)
Member
Secretary, Ministry of Education, Govt, of India ,
Elected Members
Dr S. R. Amladi m.d.
Prof. P. V. Bole
Dr E. B. Fanibunda, f.d.s.r.c.s. (Eng.)* f.r.p.s.
Dr A. N. D. Nanavati, m.d.
Mr D. J. Panday
Mr B. B. Paymaster, i.c.s. (Retd.)
Mr G. S. Ranganathan
Mr D. E. Reuben, i.c.s. (Retd.)
Mr Sandip Thakore
Dr C. V. Kulkarni m.sc., ph.d. {Jt. Hon. Secretary)
Advisory Committee
64i
A G.M . 1973 1974-PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS
HONORARY SECRETARY’S REPORT FOR THE YEAR 1973
Membership
The membership position continues to be unsatisfactory. The
main source of income for the Society should be the Ordinary Members.
The number of 4 paid up ’ members on the Society’s register as on the
1st January of the years 1971 to 1974 is given below :
1971 1972 1973 1974
Ordinary Members 703 780 801 770
The Society’s activities during the year under report have resulted
in a deficit of Rs. 30,090 which is equivalent to the subscription of an
additional 858 ordinary members at the current rate of subscription.
We would request members to assist the Society by recruiting more mem-
bers. The current income from membership subscription hardly covers
the cost of printing three issues of the Journal.
The number of other classes of members are given below :
1971
Life Members 174
Student Members 5
Honorary ,, 3
Forest Department
Nominees 78
1972 1973 1974
181 187 198
5 9 16
3 3 3
80 89 90
ACTIVITIES
Publications
Journal : Only two issues of the Journal were published during
the year Vol.69 No.3 & Vol. 70 No.l. We continue to be plagued by
the inability of the press to keep to publication dates and in 1973 there
was unfortunately a very severe power cut upsetting all production
schedules. We hope to give a better account in 1974.
The articles continued to cover a wide range of subjects with empha-
sis on the ecology, behaviour, and taxonomy of Indian fauna and the
taxonomy and regional lists of Indian flora.
We are making progress in the preparation and publication of the
Journal indexes. 8 indexes have been published so far (including a
General Index of subjects and authors for Vols. 43 to 53) at a total cost
of Rs. 19,341.45 (1968-73). Six indexes are still pending publication.
642 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Books : During the year the following sales were made :
We are continuing our efforts to obtain financial assistance for
reprinting our out-of-print books on Natural History, particularly
SOME BEAUTIFUL INDIAN TREES, SOME BEAUTIFUL INDIAN CLIMBERS AND
SHRUBS, BUTTERFLIES OF THE INDIAN REGION, CIRCUMVENTING THE
MAHSEER AND OTHER SPORTING FISH, and INDIAN MOLLUSCS.
We are glad to report that 9 volumes of the handbook of the birds
of India and Pakistan by Salim Ali & Dillon Ripley* sponsored by the
Society and published by Oxford University Press, are now available.
The 10th volume of this definitive treatise on birds of the Indian sub-
continent is expected to be published in 1974.
The publication costs of the checklist of the birds of
Maharashtra were borne by the author, Mr Humayun Abdulali
and the sale proceeds after adjusting publication costs will be credited
to the Charles McCann Field Work Fund. We are grateful to Mr
Abdulali for this generous arrangement. The checklist is an in-
valuable aid to birdwatchers in Maharashtra.
Mr Krishnan’s excellent photographs and supporting text on the
mammals of peninsular India, India’s wildlife 1959-70 will be
available in book form in 1974. We are grateful to the Seth Purushot-
tamdas Thakordas & Diwaliba Charitable Trust for the financial assis-
tance which made this publication possible.
The Society’s Nature Calendar continues to be popular and a source
of income.
Conservation
The Society continued to take a leading part in the Conservation
Movement in the country through its representatives on the State and
Central Wild Life Boards, and through its members on the International
Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources, the World
Wildlife Fund, and the International Council for Bird Preservation.
Conservation oriented field studies were made by the Society’s staff in
various parts of the country on specific projects.
A.G.M. 1973-1974— PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS
643
Research and Field Studies
Bhutan Bird Survey. A party from the Society led by Dr Salim
Ali spent seven weeks in Bhutan, collecting specimens and observing
birds at various elevations. Interesting collections include the rare
Indian Honeyguide, a bird not so far represented in the Society’s collec-
tion. Dr Salim Ali is at the moment engaged in the preparation of a
field guide to the birds of the Eastern Himalayas.
Saltwater Crocodile Survey. The Curator led a party to the Bhitar-
kanika Island in Orissa to study the status of the crocodiles living in the
area. The report on the survey was sent to the crocodile Specialist
Group of the IUCN. The survey was financed by the World Wildlife
Fund — Indian National Appeal.
Gir Forest. Mr R. B. Grubh, Senior Research Assistant, visited
the Gir to report on the effect of drought on the Wildlife, particularly
the lions. The trips was financed from the Dorabji Tata Trust Field-
work Fund.
Salim Ali/Loke Wan Tho Ornithological Research Fund. The Fund
continued to support with a fellowship, the research of Mr V. S. Vijayan
who is investigating the ecological isloation of two sympatric species of
bulbuls in the Point Calimere Sanctuary in Tamil Nadu.
Nilgiri Tahr Survey. Mr E. R. C. Davidar, a member at Coonoor,
Nilgiris, was given a grant from the Fauna Preservation Society’s Indian
Membership Funds for surveying the status of the Tahr in the hills of
South India. A report has been received.
Leopard Study. Efforts were continued by a small group of Bombay
members to obtain information about, and to draw to baits, leopards
living in the Borivli National Park near Bombay. Leopards were seen
on several occasions in drives along the Park road but no baits were
taken. It is planned to continue the work in a slightly different
manner in 1974. The study group was supported by a grant received
from the Fauna Preservation Society’s Indian Membership Funds.
Nature Walks. Nature Walks were organised in Borivli National
Park for birdwatching and for study of the vegetation during almost all
the months of the year. The field activities were financed from the Col.
Burton Fieldwork Fund.
Bird Migration. The activities during the year were supported by
grants from the Ministry of Agriculture, Government of India. The
emphasis of the studies was more on bird populations than purely on
644 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
migratory phenomena. Camps were held at Bharatpur (Rajasthan)
Borivli (Bombay), and Daulatabad (Maharashtra).
During the year we received information of the recovery in Russia
of 176 of our ringed birds. Other interesting recoveries were of flamingos
ringed in Iran and recovered near Delhi, Rajasthan, Gujarat, Hydera-
bad, and Chilka Lake, Orissa. A bluewinged teal ringed by us at Pt.
Calimere in South India was recovered in Kano, Nigeria.
ICAR Seminar on Economic Ornithology . The Seminar-cum-Work-
shop was organised between 21st and 25th May at the Society with finan-
cial support from the Indian Council of Agricultural Research. The
participants were from Agricultural Universities in India. There were
two visiting lecturers from the U.K. The theme of the seminar was
‘ Birds and Agriculture The Workshop dealt with methods of bird
study.
Primate Research Centre , Japan. A research team from the Centre
accompanied by one of the field staff of the Society surveyed the present
status of the Rhesus Macaque in Central India and the distributional
limits of the Rhesus and the Bonnet Macaques in the Peninsula.
Study of the Lion-tailed Macaque {Macaca silenus ). The Society
sponsored the application of Dr. Steven Green of the Rockefeller Univer-
sity, New York for studying the ecology and behaviour of the lion-tailed
Macaque, an endangered species. An Indian graduate student was
associated with him.
Reference Collections
During the year 497 specimens were received at the Society.
Important additions to the collections are :
Birds : Brownwinged, Kingfisher ( Pelargopsis amauroptera)
Coll : J. C. Daniel & S. A. Hussain.
Loc : Bhitarkanika Island, Orissa.
Honey guide ( Indicator xanthonotus)
Coll : Salim Ali.
Loc : Bhutan.
> A-GM. 1973-1974— PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS
645
Goldheaded Blackfinch ( Pyrrhoplectes epauletta)
Reptiles : Skinks : Leiolopisma latrimaculatum , L. beddomei ,
L. palnicum , Ristella guentheri
Snake : Dendrelaphis grandioculis
Coll : Romulus Whitaker
Loc : Western Ghats.
Nature Education Scheme
The activities of the Scheme were continued on a more modest
scale than usual as the Nature Education Organiser Mr M. R. Raut went
on leave preparatory to retirement. Mr Raut was responsible for the
activities of the Scheme from its inception in 1948. Under his guidance
the Scheme drew the attention of the school children of Bombay to the
world of nature, through lectures, field trips, and a series of booklets on
nature authored by Mr Raut.
Library
During the year 175 books were added to the Library, of which 17
were purchased, 130 donated, and 28 received as review copies for the
Journal. The total number of books and bound periodicals in the lib-
rary is 8532 and includes many rare and out-of-print volumes on Indian
natural history.
Grants & Donations
The Society acknowledges with gratitude the following grants re-
ceived for specific purposes :
Rs. 3000 — from the Dorabji Tata Trust for field work.
Rs. 4500 — from Dr Salim Ali as a donation to the Salim Ali/Loke
Wan Tho Ornithological Research Fund.
Rs. 1000 — from the Fauna Preservation Society (London)
for Leopard study.
Rs. 2500 — from the Gaekwad of Baroda for the Charles McCann
Field Work Fund.
Rs. 600— from Mr S. Chaudhuri for the Charles McCann Field
Work Fund.
The equipment purchased from grants from the Smithsonian Re-
search Foundation and the Yale School of Forestry including vehicles
has been donated to the Society by these institutions.
646 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Awards & Honours
Dr Salim Ali was presented with the 6 Ivanowsky Jubilee Medal *
on behalf of the Scientific Committee of the Ivanowsky Institute of
Virology, Moscow.
Dr Salim Ali was made an Officer of the Golden Ark by H.R.H.
The Prince of the Netherlands and a Member of Honour by the World
Wildlife Fund in recognition of outstanding service to the conservation of
wildlife and the natural environment. He was also awarded an honorary
degree of Doctor of Science by Delhi University.
Meetings/Exhibitions
January : Dr Volmar spoke on ‘ Round the world in 60 slides \
Dr Karan Singh spoke on ‘ Wildlife Tourism \
March : Cactus club show
Dr Madhav Gadgil spoke on 4 Sacred Groves and ancient
practices of Nature Conservation \
April : Mr P. Merwanji spoke on 4 Birds of Bharatpur
June : Mr J. C. Daniel spoke on 4 Crocodiles of Bhitarkanika \
July : Dr Salim Ali spoke on 4 Wildlife Tourism in Africa \
Mrs Malati Tambay-Vaidya spoke on 4 Tourism in
Maharashtra V
September : Exhibition of 4 Bird Paintings’ by D. W. Sharma.
Dr Juan Spillett spoke on 4 Latest Techniques of Wild-
life Management’,
December : Mr Orlando K. Cellucci spoke on 4 The Asian Lion Pro-
ject’. Mr David Fletcher spoke on 4 East African
Birds & Animals ’. Mr Pat Louis showed slides on
4 Natural History of India ’. Mr E. Hanumantha Rao
showed slides on 4 Wildlife of India ’.
Revenue and Accounts
The financial situation of the Society continued to be very difficult.
The year’s operation showed a deficit of Rs. 30,090.09 in spite of
stringent economies.
\
AGM: 1973-1974— PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS 647
Staff
The Committee wishes to record its appreciation of the willing co-
operation of the staff in the entire activities of the Society. Mr Madhav
Raut, the Nature Education Organiser retired during the year (since
deceased).
Acknowledgements
The Committee’s thanks are due to Mr M. J. Dickins who looked
after the Society’s affairs in the U.K., and to the members and others
who gave help in its field projects and other activities.
Registered No. F. 244 (BOM)
648 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
SQ
rn co
d" oo
d" vo
m d*
X3 <U 3 c
o> oo 3 3
c/} S-i o 3
03 d P O
r rt O o
o-s « a
Ui . 03
3^3 c
<D £2
~ g -3 g
>. <U G O
O >> 03 X
Oi
<D
Q
fl
s? to
<3 ^
2» ~
is a>
« a
•S3 *>
k( 03
£ 8
1 §
£ m
>2
o3
<U
>o
<U
X
0X)
G
3 G
T3 3
t-H
&0 OX)
G
O
G
1)
a
T3 g
< s
>
•• O
Bg'gO ;
a g£.a
1*3^
*3 *■« & S
^ j- 2 5
*s^J
g o g
3:52*
.ts ,d o
g oD^a ® <«
£.5^ .a
3 O G §
g O
O 3 O y
<>Tluys
II S-o
>-go |J2
D< G 00-3
G
>>
V
X
+■»
00
,3
3
*3
G
o
a
n>
Q
Q
%
<
xn
Q
Z
5
X/l
8
I
G
•i"
* • S »5
s S.s
^
^ 03
CO ȣS
£8
G
.=* - rt
s
.. 0)
1 04
t§ 3
•2 »
^ 2
Co G
Co c3
-X3 «
cv>
£
*3 2 T3
u h G
S3 2 §2
■6^". 2 if
Ui 5h tj +-> 5-i
3.2 u j= |3
Q.<— < •;r> OX) «
^ Ui o 3 o
oj v- of o
« a 2 u
X o
UJ
(/>
8 3 -I
* -H 3 >
D
- - £ &
^ C B ««
G J3 C
-rj G oS
4> ^ > 3
^ !— a (11
« gS £
<u_
o
* ~ ~ « =
oo 2
v +-; O
^■3 § o
2 2 5 g
2 "S -g 8<~
-* £ (J O
>3^1^
•• »- *3 o3 2
3 c s- O
^§"3 G 00-0
d<
G
3
O
o
o
03
S- 1
G 3
O O
O (U
2 3-3
1§£
^<§
las
a 3 o
..^ o.
. a »
a>
<u
J3
CO
<0
CJ
G
'3
. m
S* o3
Si
Cu
t g
Cv
5 O
§
©
A.GM' 1973-1974— PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS
649
a
.R
-G
©
m
o\
8
§
co
1
k 2
<N
O
SO
83 Tf
Oh ^
a m-c
— ' a o
ws s
g c u
c3 '£? in
>> O <yj
.£
■aU o
>,o
*£
a £
-5 a
*- >
O C
o
o w
<N
5
<
£P
~°^J
uU1
os _
X-S3 x)T3^r Ck
aSgl^S
S» O. M «3
1 2 a g l~I a
^ <D cc3 .
isi<as
rxJ c
c o
, 3 g*
I C o
; a a
» 3 o
*8‘S
aj
!g*
\E X3
o c
3 O
a
o s <n
m 5«n
ft .5 «n
> MO
CuN
s° .
C .3 •
o ’-5
^ o
t? i-i
O c_
O o
’dc.
Sc
d c3
•CP?
O, -
o.S
fe a)
a!
< 2_
..•S2
^ B
5 OJ5
k
°rT^P
GO C 1
u S
a> 2
> Oh
c 3 2
o O O
O O ft
^ 3
c
o
5 °
O o
g e
03 O
^ o
>>2
c.2
3 q,
“ «
uQ
O ft
-8-2
tj 2 a>
-•-§3
•-g'£
o.° S
o© >
g^o S
5 1’g
*■* co 3
O 2 c
s e
121
g<J
3*5
83 «£5*3
&
m’gs
..XJcg
JH 03
£> T3 _I
2 i-j
l<d
8'sr'
o
Vo£
oX r?
00 ..g
C/3 C
o
>n
" O
;U
M
C
SO 00 •
2?. 2 '
. a
CO *C
«M O
o j2
co o3
©««
W • *rt
oc£?-3
— t=j ^3
■SSo
>3
O -O 3
-a os'*-
<L) " .
8*0
00 < •
^C_ O
NOU
o
<N
E9
&
0
|3
1
Co
1
X
K)
3
oq
60
3
2
m
.
4: a
co
r3 «
k, o
If 2
.s: ks
iS’iS
^3 da
3
eg
&
I 8
si
>3 03
fi
S3 »
"S’3
lu
t§ 8.
V. CO
&
§§
§3
kffl
? *
*5 1
I £
&
Q
8
c
-2
"c3
ffl
83 «
<U
a
83
. 3
«o <u
.S3 «
> „5
g W
k
« « a
.2 S
S* *“■ rri
CX
T3
B
.2
'u
2 a
aji
a £
^1
•• >
650
JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
s
•S
K
£>
m
OS
8
tq
Q
m
§
§
*
s
Ea
6
o
s
8
^4
3
w >>
3
C 'c
•• -S I
§ c«
"CJ
<3 ST
T3
O
o
00
V, to
2 „ es
A) co +i
-S.a “
’S3 S 2
C £ w
o *5 </>
°'S c
» O C3
-o-g o
•• 3g£
S
g CJO
3 P.
S o -
Saw
2 g£
H WO
H s -
«n
* 5
in'
43
GO
3
o
Ui
to
w
CO
a
* • &
i*
l£
O <D
cO o
*£> G
3 aJ
V3 >
T3
<
8
SJ§
8 o
U
>>
A.GM. 1973-1974— PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS
651
^3
•S
R
C>
<o
T
cn
on
59
8
Q
t— H
co
§
I
§
B
o
gjjj
to
8
M
eq
• ^
Ph o
£tf r-T
<N
2 8
H CQ
C/2
00
<
<*>
IS
<5
%
co
• a
*.2
o
3
3
a
• Cm
• O
CO
G co
.2 8
g s
•- <L>
3 8
eueu
.s*
1
J3
, a .
<L>
B
c/5
C/5
8
c/5
•C
=2
3
G
T3
G
d) 3^,
S sP
. 43
• CO
c3
u,
G .
5«-G
3 i
02 l
S
*, g S
G v o
v+J H
u
u
’> ^ K
»-i , ON
<u p
C/3 O
.. TO *3 o
cj G £ CC
5 81 a*.
Q M C c
l^Ss
V. Q< G
6 3 O w
•S wO
S
CD
-a
03
O
<
<d
G d
<u
U CO
c/2 r-
_ ON
G
ll
G ^
£ G
G 2
.20
TO • T)
3 ij
44
G
• • G
-Gffl
.d CO
.
2 §■§
& o -r
s: o „r
-S 20
1= 8 g
§ u. G
5 c>-B
* G^
Q w4
«s* p-
3*
o
c
1^1
Hi
PQ
<%
60
>2 G
_ G‘>
03
C £ co
.2 o c
£
BALANCE SHEET FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER, 1973— {continued)
652 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
00
W
xn
<
too
13
O
u
pq
2
it
<§£
<§ g
il
3
oja-g-s
c3 ^ I
on --j « 5
'55 <04 W
a —a
i sSq 6
55^.« Q X5
3 b Cl . ,.ts
« sJfl
o a o 3
o.SgUft
•$ “
3^
* X)
0,3 ©
1<2§
^hOO'5
s IQ-8 >
O O 3 d tH
Q
I— > M-, £ ^ ©
°«2 §
5 3 ^ 5-1 e
8=e >,«o £
g> o
|ogl|
5g2 » §£
« a
3
- "3 3
^ ■•§■8
s j,
SMti
R- ^vo
w-i „
*5 m 5 3
= -g3
a
vu
a S "2 9 ^
|dS
«-. it-. £ Zji ^
^ o c
a r°5 X C 3
© ftfiU M B o
t: c£ o= 5b
J-=S^£go
u
. -T3 ■
* C '
3
- ! §
3 O O
8 c £
2 « a8
a ^ ©
5 ^ 52<
"« 3 <3
«
*> u ^ ©
§• 8/5 3
"as 3n o
g gHS
I J:S(S
3
o
H
on «
Cg »as
VO
52 a
§ °
•s
i
8
x>
3
00
a
x
CO
jg C on
© "*
s
©
"3 3
gX
X
© 52
ti 3
3 ©
©
z
1*
a, cq
ES
£
° o
© *d
a p«
w <;
#©
©
„ o
< fe"
Q >>
3 3 *h
< g O
PM ■«
4 § «
Q
* 2 3
^>3 3
$2,^ 3
g
ffi
. O
rs W
3
1|
T3 *3 >s
00 3
"" g
ffl
§T £
3 ©
CO
.s >,
3 ts •
e 03
g a, ©
SsiS
$.?§
3? ^ 3
X> 3 tl
M (fl O
3® Q
O 32 ©
3
4-» 3 Q
on X ^
© Z5 (h
X ©
s§Q
5 on 52
2 g-s
-mvH 3
o ^ u
© © +■>
XX ©
00 ^X
M-, -t->
PS's
3 0 (/>
§8 -
w © 52
P 3 3
o 2«
x 3 3
3iJ 3
© 3
X
A.G.M. 1973-1974— PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS 653
654
JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
§1
is
59 ^
1 1
l-5
§ |S
§ -V-
Ifll
° IT
in rt
<N
*
I
Pi
a .
•S-g
a .fa w
B v o’
•g js *h
s'-s
2
*.2 c
■w 3.2
li 2
o
os'
.lift *
§3*3 c
•^0*3
S5|
a^s
S fl »)-
<§!•'§<
I« s
s«- =
t*- <4_ -{$
£ o OC fl
o
i§*S :
|§i
.2 u
x>3 &
•G 3 c
It?
si!
2j5-2
o
o
*d
o §m
gfe cs
O
W3 „
a> 3
s£ O •*-»
aSg
|
si”
<§31
« G<
II!
O
m* _H QJJ 77
O B
sg
"B c
.o,_
p'nj
«
>
!"f|
qu£ §
’gOHfc
m
^ *
sl |*2
^ <3
1 • s
0-02 2
x w G
rrj s-t Q>
O w o
fe
S3
/~s
<)
ll O
A.G.M. 1973-1974— PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS 65$
o S
g* <
2 X
&9
l
t"
20
656 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
H
W
(— I
o
o
co
><
o
H
oo
c
04
5
H
I
$
CQ
§
o
PQ
ao
g
Sh EU
5 ^
« g
o w
S g
pQ co
33
H
m
r-
Os
|
I
8
§
1
*
s
a
£
C<
§
I
0
u
SJ
1
I
I
I
o
t3 "G
• • « G
** G.S2
s; t-i — ■
G O C3
OQ
*
cd 3
V o
co 0) co
.2 G ~
•g o «*
is G T3
3£"
G
oo -O
g
>-N» G ^
r*fc H ft i
X *>
Okj
•35 * a
OS3
O- A o
q St:
M o d
”d o -rj
£ a
e S
Ok)
*5
X 1/5
O u<
■>C/3 G
£>
e
=s
g
g
^ c
:o _
66 O S
P 3 o
«5 jS
3 a
G
• G
• n
o
•2
■S
<3
O
Q
*1
32
a a
*8
OB
ja w W
o 15 £ O
2 ^
£H
ZZZ Z
VO VO
t-i rn
,1
T-^ »0
O Tj*
<n m
«— 1 Tf-
oo vo
OO^ (N
t"-* vo"
cn o
*
G
!
§
&
G
5
5
I
sS
. O •
a
o
*33
*>
o
p
. a .
• <— •
0
1
:5»
P c
.2 §
§e
. i
. c
. «
G
G
co g
g§
G G
os
CO -—
G 12
s§
..ss'gi
c5 57*3 « 03
cd 0^(73 Q
Sr5
%
S
I
g
G
«
g
G
.g ..
,3—s
§2
Sfo
G
0) —
§ £
g o
g O
o d
0
2^
2 rn
-GS:
*5 ov
CO I-!
gK'rtrt
tG^^ o
cvsr> gcG
^ 43 ^
th- ij -6? as
o O O i-
2^ wo
Ills
G 66 G £
s s
I
C
1
c
.<o>
O G
O 2
£0
o ■
<£ g
w+3
<i w
• cd
Q eS
60 -G
G cvJ
1S-
.1°
co +f
G G
*r g
« a
CJ
CO
<
Q
60
_G
•3
o co G
G g >
Vh *2 2
a
INCOME AND EXPENDITURE ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER, 1973— {continued)
A.G.M. 1973-1974— PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS
657
oi
X
60
8 8
6 6
O '—I
o
ro
8
&
a
£
£
. o .
’ a
^ >,
a
a
*o
I-
o
S-4
s
.2*5
Uh CO
,S .2 t
■S-dofl
^ C ® CO
3>Ph V
^ ** « s
x £ g a,
o _oo0
TJ
2 3
SO
C ,2Z u
o o
o o
a- ©
vo O
t";
in vcT
m
p24>.2 S o 5
O >-»C*i rj G
•5b g> § o J
O co < *3 .2^ ^3
oJi S ^ £ ow c
2 j_, o c o ui ^
5 jiN aja . <2
.a a Jh
U Q
a a
■h «
*«: £ to
s x! a
g «5 .aa
a — • —
C X •—
.<3 3
W
«
>.«*-! tf-l
»5 p
’a . 2 ^
s&P
..el:
£<* a
S2 a
•• I Sa»-I
£
•2
(U
S u,
*- 3
V§
^ to
c *C
5 60
s<
5
Sx
O
O-J
" e
s
Ui >.
O *■•
<*= o
a
as
^ a
.2 a
c_ 5P c
o<£
S °
£
a
2
£ •
>£ ‘
’S£
<oS
~ X!
3 co
ca- £
.2*7 a
"tji m
Ss«
= 2S
T3
w
p 8
<n ©
5 §
8 -
60
3
O
Ul
PQ
°§
“fc
.3 §
o *o
o
CO
60.S
« St^-g
CO .2
o G
0*CU
co Cj
£X S?
Iu§
I c J
'S|u
sl^°
c«H
£-3
co
a 5
a> a
fs
co
P
60
3-i
a
x
o
p
a
CO
a
• CO
p
CO
a
p
a,
x
W
I P
s-<
.a
60 !? G
H >1 P
G P Cu
> ><
ic ^ CD _j
8 s o o
w 03
>&S^te§
hn'H y
•ti 2 x afe
:|§W32^1
^ Jco
p
•3
a
<
VS
C
I
tl
«o
a
8
Jl
|
s
£.2
.5 c
£ a
60
, a
■‘3
60
o
13
•4— •
a
V
ft o
O p *- g
a
Z, O 2^3
ep-|§
s s §(|~
p 22 p p x
OSaC Z
P
a co
p p
co «-i c«
p 2 c
co CX P
u a « a
^ p a x
aaS
H
INCOME AND EXPENDITURE ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER, 1973— (continued)
m JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST . SOCIETY, Vol 71 (3)
INCOME AND EXPENDITURE ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER, 1973 — (continued)
A.G.M. 1973-1974 — PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS 659
20-a
INCOME AND EXPENDITURE ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER. 1973— (. continued )
660 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY , Vol. 71 (3)
x
(30
3
O
u
P3
-O T3
C O
« &
©<8
2- c/3
x a
— w
« is
^ CZ3
te
° S
• U -P
T3 CccPh
c ® *o x
8 ! &|
^2 “I
O 1)
'fe.g.oS
§W
ft
<u
^ <Z3
d>
s
o
o
= «
q
5- X
ooo
§8
c
OS
.§3
a o
o
O.X
X a>
(U U
s
ox
c/3
</3 e
c/3 ”
8S
w
'ti'OO
m'poo
n^tnoo
X!
00
3
O
S-j
«
5^6 £
2 >
a 3^0
• . a
ft&jgj '
^ i-4 >
'to s-
tt ° o
•Si, G a>
Q)
~ » *p
■*' a> ^ «
2 U o
<D CT3
3 5
-o* 9
afe iJ
:§«&o
'6 «.2 -
C 3 C C
^sSs
o >s
<u
;g |^o»
om£Q
X w
OT)^
C/3 ^ O ^
5 3
3^
fa
• x "5 x o
z " o£
o»
C/3 XX _
o x o c
* ® S3£
• »
••Pf ^
23 °© o
£ X O J
2 5 "So~
a
2. CD
sa.o
.^2 x
*sw
— o o a o
°&I3SS2£S •
'8i°51^Ili-
ss,§«-c 11° =
|sE‘s4?(fl§'o£
. GO
Ih D
I l|
0-SI&
-2835
g* c/3 X 60 ?*i
I.JNJ
*&8fa
fcg-g-^ &
Q^hO-P
V. 3 3 O j->
■^00 ft- P3 O
As per our report annexed.
(Sd.) Habib & Co.,
Bombay, 17rA August 1974. Chartered Accountants .
BOMBAY NATURAL HISTORY SOCIETY
A.G.M. 1973-1974—, PROCEEDINGS AND ACCOUNTS
661
l
fe;
0
&
1
§
1
co
r-~
ON
s
8
3
1
§
I
§>
§
§
§
I
^3
ft5
As per our report annexed.
(Sd.) Habib & Co.,
Bombay, 17 th August , 1974. Chartered Accountants.
MINUTES OF THE ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING OF
THE BOMBAY NATURAL HISTORY SOCIETY HELD AT
HORNBILL HOUSE, SHAHID BHAGAT SINGH ROAD,
BOMBAY 400023, ON FRIDAY, 20TH SEPTEMBER 1974,
AT 6-30 P.M., WITH MR. G. V. BEDEKAR, I.C.S.
(RETIRED), A VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE SOCIETY, IN
THE CHAIR. THIRTY-ONE MEMBERS WERE PRESENT
1. At the suggestion of the President, Dr. Salim Ali, Dr. A. N. D.
Nanavati proposed and Dr. C. V. Kulkarni seconded that Mr. G. V.
Bedekar, a Vice-President of the Society be elected the Chairman of the
meeting. The proposal was accepted.
2. The Chairman advised the meeting that Mr. M. R. Raut, the
former Nature Education Organiser of the Society who had retired in
1973 and Mr. S. Venugopal Rao, a member of the administrative staff
had died during the year. The Chairman recorded the Society’s deep
appreciation of the work done by Mr. Raut and Mr. Rao. As a mark
of respect to their memory the meeting observed a minute’s silence, all
members standing.
3. Agenda Item (1). With the consent of the members present,
the reading of the Annual Report of the Executive Committee (copies
of which had already been supplied to the members present) was dispensed
with and the report was presented to the meeting. The Honorary Sec-
retary said that he would be glad to answer any queries on the report.
The Honorary Secretary clarified that he represented the Society on the
Indian Board for Wildlife.
Mr. A. A. Dikshit raised the point that the total membership for
1973 as given in the Annual Report did not tally with the figures given
in the Paymaster Sub-Committee Report. The Honorary Secretary
explained that the figure given in the Annual Report was the actual figure
of members, who had paid their subscription for the year as on 1st
January 1974 and did not include those who had not paid but were still
carried on the register in accordance with Rule 14 of the Society’s Rules &
regulations. The discrepancy was due to this factor. Dr. P. J. Deoras
requested information on the conservation oriented research and field
studies of the staff particularly with reference to Salt Water Crocodile
Survey and the Leopard study. Information on these points was given
by the Curator.
Mr. D. S. Manchekar desired details on the I.C.A.R. Seminar on
Economic Ornithology and felt that information on the Seminar should
MINUTES OF THE A.G.M. OF THE B.N.H.S.
663
have been sent to members, who wished to attend. He also stated that
he wished to see papers that had been presented at the Seminar. The
nature of the Seminar for which invitations were issued by the I.C.A.R.
was explained and he was advised that he would be welcome to see manus-
cripts of such lectures as were available. The Annual Report was then
adopted.
4. Agenda Item (2). The Chairman requested the Honorary
Treasurer to present the Balance Sheet and Statement of Accounts for
the calendar year 1973. Cyclostyled copies of these had been kept for
member’s perusal. Dr. R. N. Vasa wished to know whether the Commit-
tee had been aware of the receipt of funds from MAPS (Migratory Ani-
mal Pathological Survey) and drew attention to certain comments that
had appeared. The Honorary Treasurer stated that the funds were re-
ceived with the full knowledge of the Executive Committee and that the
approval of the Government of India for the project proposal had also
been received before the funds were made available to the Society.
Mr. H. Abdulali and Dr. P. J. Deoras objected to accommodation
provided to the World Wildlife Fund — India at Hornbill House. The
Honorary Secretary stated that their presence was on sufference and their
association with the Society was to the Society’s advantage. He cited
two instances of co-operation benefiting both organisations (sale of 7,500
calendars by the World Wildlife, and sharing of proceeds from the sale
of World Wildlife cards). Mention was made by Dr. A. K. Joshee and
Mr. D. S. Manchekar that a verbatim report of the proceedings of the
meeting was not being recorded since no stenographer was present. The
Chairman observed that in accordance with usual practice the Honorary
Secretary kept notes and drafted the minutes of the Annual General
Meeting which were then seen by the Chairman of the meeting and placed
before the Executive Committee for comments and thereafter published
in the December issue of the Society’s Journal. The Balance sheet and
the accounts were adopted.
5. Agenda Item (3)-(A). The Chairman stated that the following
nominations to the Executive Committee and the Advisory Committee
were deemed to be approved :
President :
Dr. Salim Ali, D.sc., f.n.a.
Vice-Presidents :
Mr. R. E. Hawkins
Mr. G. V. Bedekar, i.c.s. (Retd.)
Ex-Officio members of the
Executive Committee
664 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 (3)
Advisory Committee :
Mr. H. G. Acharya
Mr. F. C. Badhwar, o.b.e.
Dr. B. Biswas
Mr. S. Chaudhuri
Dr. Chintaman Deshmukh, i.c.s. (Retd.)
Mr. Zafar Futehally
Mr. Shivrajkumar Khachar . .
Mr. M. Krishnan
Mr. Duleep Matthai
Mr. Ranjit Sinh, i.a.s.
New Delhi
New Delhi
Ahmedabad
New Delhi
Calcutta
Hyderabad
Bangalore
Jasdan
Madras
Calcutta
Executive Committee {Ex-Officio members) :
(1) Dr. A. N. D. Nanavati, m.d. (Honorary Secretary)
(2) Mr. J. D. Kapadia, i.c.s. (Retd.) (Hon. Treasurer)
(3) Secretary, Ministry of Education, Government of India
(B) As regards ten members of the Executive Committee, the Chair-
man stated that apart from the nominees of the outgoing Executive Com-
mittee, whose names have been shown in the agenda papers (and are re-
produced, here) three nominations have been received as shown below :
(i) Nominees of the Executive Committee :
(1) Mr. Humayun Abdulali
(2) Dr. S. R. Amladi, m.d.
(3) Prof. P. V. Bole
(4) Dr. E. B. Fanibunda, f.d.s.r.c.s. (Eng.), f.r.p.s.
(5) Mr. Bansi Metha
(6) Mr. D. J. Panday
(7) Mr. B. B. Paymaster, i.c.s. (Retd.)
(8) Mr. G. S. Ranganathan
(9) Mr. D. E. Reuben, i.c.s. (Retd.)
(10) Dr. C. V. Kulkarni, m.sc., pIi.d. (Jt. Hon. Secretary)
(ii) Three other nominations :
(1) Dr. P. J. Deoras — Proposed by Mr. A. A. Dikshit and
seconded by Mr. B. F. Patuck.
(2) Mr. A. A. Dikshit — proposed by Mr. A. K. Joshee and
seconded by Miss Kamala Srinivasan.
(3) Dr. R. N. Vasa — proposed by Mr. Sidney D’Souza and
seconded by Mr. Boby Kovoor.
It would therefore be necessary to hold a postal ballot, as provided
in Rules 32 and 33.
MINUTES OF THE A.G.M. OF THE B.N.H.S.
665
6. Other business : (a) The following resolution, of which notice
had been given by Mr. S. R. Nayak was next considered by the meeting :
‘ Considering the fact that the Society has an All India and
International membership and is largely recognised in India and Inter-
nationally as the premier organisation on Indian Natural History
Society, it is resolved that the name of the Society be amended to
Indian Natural History Society and the name of the Society’s Journal
be amended to Journal of Indian Natural History Society.’
The resolution was seconded by Dr. S. R. Amladi. It was stated
that in view of the All India and International nature of the Society, the
present name with its parochial implications prevented the Society from
establishing branches in other parts of the country, and also that if an
‘ Indian Natural History Society ’ were to be started, such a society would
receive all the previleges and standing of that name, which rightly belongs
to the Bombay Natural History Society.
Mr. J. P. Irani and Mr. H. Abdulali opposed the proposal. Several
members drew attention to the fact that a proposal of such significance
should not be considered unless it had been previously circulated, and
members given sufficient time to think and decide on the proposal. The
Chairman drew attention to the fact such a proposal if carried would
necessitate action in accordance with the provisions of the Society’s Regis-
tration Act. After discussion, Mr. Nayak withdrew the resolution.
7. The second resolution, of which notice had been given by Mr.
A. A. Dikshit was next moved as under :
‘ Resolved that the findings of the Enquiry Committee headed
by Mr. B. B. Paymaster be duly published in the ensuing issue of the
Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society.’
Dr. Deoras seconded the resolution. Mr. Dikshit stated that he
felt that the Paymaster Report was very important and that all members
of the Society should be aware of it and this would be best served by
publishing the report in the Society’s Journal which went to all members
of the Society. Dr. P. J. Deoras, Dr. R. N. Vasa, Mr. D. S. Manchekarj
Dr. A. K. Joshee and Miss K. Sreenivasan spoke in support of Mr. Dik-
shit’s resolution.
The Honorary Secretary felt this was not practicable and offered to
provide typed or cyclostyled copies to those who requested it. Mr
Paymaster felt that the report not being a scientific document would
be out of place in the journal, but he would agree if the proposal was for
separate circulation. Mr. Abdulali suggested that it was not necessary
to circulate the report to all the members of the Society, but only to those
who wished to have a copy and offered to pay the cost of preparing
666 JOURNAL, BOMBAY NATURAL HIST. SOCIETY, Vol. 71 0)
cyclostyled copies for this purpose. Dr. S. R. Amladi and Dr. C. V.
Kulkarni felt that the report was submitted to the Executive Committee
at its request by its Sub-Committee and was essentially of an administra-
tive character, and its publication in the scientific journal of the Society
would not be appropriate.
The Honorary Secretary mentioned that the report apparently was
not so important as some speakers made out, since only one member
had taken the trouble to come and read it. A slip had been sent to all
members with the notice of the Annual General Meeting that the report
was available for perusal. After some further discussion the resolution
was put to vote and was lost with 11 members voting for and 18 voting
against.
The meeting terminated with a vote of thanks to the Chair.
In the postal ballot held in October 1974 the following were elected
to the Executive Committee :
Executive Committee
Mr. Humayun Abdulali
Dr. S. R. Amladi
Prof. P. V. Bole
Dr. P. J. Deoras
Dr. A. A. Dikshit
Dr. C. V. Kulkarni
Mr. D. J. Panday
Mr. B. B. Paymaster
Mr. G. S. Ranganathan
Mr. D. E. Reuben
PRINTED AND PUBLISHED BY T. DURAI AT THE DIOCESAN PRESS,
10 CHURCH ROAD, VEPERY, MADRAS — 10-3-1976. C6629.
editors: J. C. DANIEL, p. V. BOLE & A- n. d. NANAVATI
THE SOCIETY’S PUBLICATIONS
Mammals
The Book of Indian Animals, by S. H. Prater. 3rd (revised) edition. 28 plates in
colour by Paul Barruel and many other monochrome illustrations. Rs. 40
( Price to members Rs. 33)
The Ecology of the Lesser Bandicoot Rat in Calcutta, by James Juan Spillett. Rs. 10
Birds
The Book of Indian Birds, by S£lim Alt, 9th (revised) edition. 66 coloured and
many monochrome plates. Rs. 35
{Price to members Rs. 30)
Checklist of the Birds of Maharashtra, by Humayun Abdulali. Rs. 2*50
{Price to members Rs. 2)
Snakes
Identification of Poisonous Snakes. Wall chart in English, Gujarati, and Marathi,
Rs. 5
Miscellaneous
Glimpses of Nature Series Booklets :
1. Our Birds I (with 8 coloured plates) in Hindi, Marathi, and Rs. 0*80
Kannada. Rs. 0*62
2. Our Birds II (with 8 coloured plates) in Hindi. Rs. 0*62
3. Our Beautiful Tries (with 8 coloured plates) in Hindi and Marathi. Rs. 0*62
4. Our Monsoon Plants (with 8 coloured plates) in English,
Gujarati, Hindi, and Marathi. Rs. ©’80
5. Our Animals (with 8 coloured plates) in English, Gujarati,
Hindi, and Marathi. Rs. 1*25
Glimpses of Nature in India (with 40 coloured plates) in English. Rs. 7.50
{Price to members Rs. 5)
Back numbers of the Society’s Journal. Rates on application.
The Society will gratefully accept back numbers of the Journal , from
members who may not wish to preserve them.
TERMS OF MEMBERSHIP
Entrance Fees :
Members residing outside India should pay their subscription by means of orders
on their Bankers to pay the amount of the subscription to the Society in
Bombay on the 1st January in each year. If this cannot be done, then the sum of
,£3*50 should be paid annually to the Society’s London Bankers — Grindlays Bank
Ltd., 23 Fenchurch Street, London EC 3P 3 ED Account No. 1 101091 .
The subscription of members elected in October, November, and December
covers the period from the date of their election to the end of the following year.
CONTENTS
Prefatory Note
Introduction
Life History and Field Biology
Selection of nesting trees and the frequency of nest visits by Baya Weaver-
bird. By T. Antony Davis
On the Biology of the Olivaceous Leaf Warbler of the Tian-Shan Moun-
tain. By A. F. Kovshar and E. I. Gavrilov
The food of Collocalia swift lets (Aves, Apodidae) at Niah Great Cave
in Borneo. By Tom Harrisson
Physiological adaptations in the Rosy Pastor wintering in India. By J. C.
George
The voice of the Indian Hill Myna ( Gracula religiosa) in the wild. By Brian
Bertram
Bird vocalizations as systems of communication. By. W. H. Thorpe
The Asian Honeyguides. By Herbert Friedmann
Present distribution and population status of the Great Bustard, Otis
tarda Linnaeus. By Yu. A. Isakov
Zoogeography and Systematics
Problems resultlng from the discontinuous distribution of Muscicapa lati -
rostris Raffles. By Erwin and Vesta Stresemann
Similitudes and differences of the Indian and Indochinese Avifaunas. By
J. Delacour
Zoological results of the Daily Mail Himalayan Expedition 1954 : notes
on some birds of Eastern Nepal. By Biswamoy Biswas
The Fauna of Narcondam Island Part 1 — Birds. By Humayun Abdulali . .
Adaptations of Andean and Tibetan birds : a brief comparison. By Jean
Dorst
Two tropical forests and their birds. By H. Elliott McClure
Geographical distribution of the avian lice {Phthiraptera)—\ review.
By Theresa Clay
Migration, Biomedicine and Learning
The migration of the Gannet into the Mediterranean. By A. Landsborough
Thomson
The role of birds in the natural foci of tick-borne arboviruses in Western
Siberia. By G. I. Netsky, G. B. Maikov and 1. 1. Bogdanov
Visual learning capacity and retention in Tree Shrew ( Tupaia ) : an exten-
sion. By Rudolf Altevogt and Sigrid Zeller
What leads to increases in the range of certain birqs? By Horace
Alexander . . . . . . . .
Reminiscences and Biographical
Dr. Salim Ali and I. By Yoshimaro Yamashina
A portrait of Salim Ali. By Zafar Futehally
Reviews
Miscellaneous Notes
Annual Report of the Bombay Natural History Society for the year
1973-1974
Statement of Accounts of the Bombay Natural History Society
Minutes of the Annual General Meeting
page
351
353
356
367
376
394
405
414
426
433
445
452
456
496
506
517
536
548
554
564
571
577
579
587
594
640
648
662
| 5 W 1 5 I
„ , ™ _ o
2 -J 2 _J 2!
LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOlinillSNI NVINOSH1IWS S3 I BVU
2: r~ z r- ^
D3
30
>
m m
NOIinillSNl"~NVINOSHlll/MS S3 I JJVHQ H LI BRAR I ES ^SMITHSONIAN ^TNSTITUT
Z CO Z . CO 2;- I
2 , < ^ < a^y . .
e. \®szr<*y ± -4-jsw s
CO Z ,-CO - Z — (f)
LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION. NOlinillSNI NVINOSHlllAJS SBlUVd
co r; co — co
to
q n^yuv/ __ -*i y/~ O pcZ __ X^ius^X o
2 Nounxirsm^NViNOSHiiws^sa 1 ava a nJu brar i es^ Smithsonian^ institut
r” Z r~ 2 r~
CO
— rn .W X m Xi'yosv^X !£ m
5 CO ' — (/) 5 co
LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOlinillSNI NVIN0SH1IWS S3IUVH
2 '* 2 Z •* CO
2 ‘ 2 ^)gr > v 2 >
f 'NOUfUSISNI_NVINOSHlllA!SC- S3 I d Vd 8 11 L I B R AR I ES^ SMITHSON IAN ^INSTITUT
m z 00 z
O xtvosv^i
LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOIifUliSNI~NVINOSHillAIS S3 1 a VH
z C z r- . z
2 .. m ° Z- o o
4 oo a$
^ /?
>
30
rn x^v, gc^x ^ ~y/%P'/ m r' xw* u&vs m
co = co £ — co „
NOlinillSNI NVIN0SH1IINS SaldVdail LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITU
CO 2 to Z v. co 2
2 < X<yaSO X 2 . < . 2
■?/
>V *- 'ZMZWZ ^ \^ijyi/ Cl
> 'W'' 5 5 ^
LI BRAR I ES^SMITHSONIAN^ INSTITUTION NOlinillSNI NVINOSHlIWS^Sa I UVE
n; co zz co — co
r
CO
n
MU
O ~ O
2 _i 2
ARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOlifUllSNI NVINOSHXIWS S3iaVaSIT_LI
2: r* 2 r* z
o x<\v<soty>v o x<aAvXr^v - ... o >
CO
H-
(.dcJ^ <2 ' rn N^uv/ X^UiiS^X m
CO — if) \ ± if)
11I1SNI NVIN0SH11WS S3iavaail LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION N(
Z _ CO Z ,. <0 z <£
/ z =! „jsf A Z ^fx-> =! marts*, Z
ii
00 2 co * 2 co * 2
ARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOlifUllSNI NVIN0SH11WS S3iavaail LI
CO CO — CO
m v \w ^ \»vasvv^ m
</> " ~ CO —
ARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOIXfUIXSN! NVINOSHXHVS S3 1 avaa IT Ll
2 \ co z w Z
S s ^ /^^qX — —
I xS| § § «,
t sx%|^ Z , */ /S' t 5..
Vfr > 'C25S>' 5 -S\^ >’ S \SK/ >
A' 2 ^ ■••-' § M 2
uixsni nvinoshiiws ssiavaan libraries Smithsonian institution nc
2 \ 5 </> 2 M
CO V ^ w jMe,,
IARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOIXfUIXSNI NVIN0SHXIWS S3 lavas 11 U
o\
m m
CO £ CO \ f; CO
niUSNI NVINOSHimS S3 lava Oil LIBRARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION N
Z CO Z v *• . CO 2 ... CO
< 2: , 2
2 > *W" 2 > XJOiliS^X X ^ >
CO 2 CO * . 2 CO 41 2
VARIES SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION NOlifUllSNI NVINOSHlilAJS S3 lavaa 11 L
co ~ co — co r;
UJ ,n 2^50 LxJ ~ ^X\'\
^ U ec d av\>